Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Another Quinns Quest review, another instance of me dropping an interview just beforehand that reveals what the game is. 🤫

Quinns Quest Season 2, Episode 2, is a SPRAWLING review of Chris McDowell's svelte TTRPG Mythic Bastionland. Having now spent a month writing, filming and editing my video, I have a dozen other questions I wished I'd asked Chris in this phone call. He's the design equivalent of a Greek philosopher king, and I want to get blasted on wine with him at the agora and just see what he can teach me.

Ah well! In this interview Chris teases that one of his next projects will be Intergalactic Bastionland, riffing on venerable RPG Traveller, and that'll be a great reason to have him back on the show.

Happy publish day, folks!

-- Quinns

Files

Comments

Lojaan

Oooh! Ooooh! Oooh! Mythic Bastionland! Amazing! I've been fascinated with it for ages but it's always seemed so impenetrable. Can't wait for this!

Elliott V

I've been watching the Mythic Bastionland deep dives Chris has been doing on YouTube after picking up the book at UKGE, can't wait to listen to this and see the full review!!

Ads

Impenetrable? The rules seem straightforward to me, but perhaps you're talking about the best ways to make use of the spark tables and other generative gubbins. Chris goes over a lot of that stuff in his vids. On the question of the rules, there's a bunch of helpful people in the Discord if you're having trouble figuring them out. I had a few questions and they cleared them up tout de suite.

Ads

Miiiiind you... If I were to level a complaint it would be that the Chris's minimalist style/approach is very definitely an aesthetic choice. There's also, imo, an assumed familiarity with running ttrpgs, which is sort of okay given the kind of people likely to come across his products but niggles my brain nonetheless. I know GM's who I suspect would find them an annoying read, so could bounce off/deem them impenetrable on that basis.

BassPope

Glad that QQ has decided to review a game I don’t need to immediately buy upon watching…because I already bought this damn game. Like with Heart last season I instead get to look forward to seeing if Quinn’s impressions of MB line up with mine and leave my wallet sealed in it’s concrete bunker…

Daniel Atkinson

AHHHHHHHHH I backed this. I also spent exam season of JHS in Japan (as an assistant teacher who had nothing to do) making a map to run a cheeky one shot just to see if it worked back when their was like 12 knights.

Patrick Joannisse

I'm only 2 minutes into this and the amount of English-ness is so high I need to make myself a cup of tea

Joe

An awesome pick for the next QQ review. I've been on a binge recently of Chris's YouTube channel and podcast getting hyped for Mythic Bastionland

Sascha

I love Chris.

Kevin

What an inspiring interview--thanks to both of you! I have and love Electric Bastionland, but I opted for only the pdf of Mythic Bastionland. Do I really need another fantasy-themed RPG? Curse you, Quinn's--I just caved and ordered the print version of MB!

Kevin

I actually know the answer re the "why doesn't Games Workshop promote WFRP" question asked. The short answer is "it doesn't sell models." The slightly longer answer is that Games Workshop (The company that makes the rules for Warhammer) doesn't own Citadel Miniatures (The company that sculpts the miniatures), it's the other way around. The miniature sculpting company is at the top of the corporate pyramid, and basically all business decisions are made based on this fact. Warhammer Fantasy roleplay is not a fun thing that a Warhammer player should be doing, it's a gateway drug for D&D players to be introduced to Warhammer. Buy a few heroes! Buying some skeletons or skaven? Why it's actually a much better deal to buy a starter set! Look at how many figures you get! You'll need some paints of course, conveniently located over here. It's the same way that minis are sculpted first, and then games designers need to figure out what they actually do or even are

Christopher derhodes

I heard you mention you read Dolmenwood, what’s your opinion of it? I understand what you say about a hex crawl game being very demanding for a GM but the setting has most of the work done for you.

TJ Kotzé

Thanks for spotlighting these! And these interesting interviews!

Nick Wakim-Takaki

I'm glad I got to listen to this interview of the last good British RPG designer!

Ads

Checks notes... Graham Walmsley Luke Gearing Gavin Norman (in some important ways, less so in others) Grant Howitt Christopher Taylor Emmy Allen Just off the top of my head. We've got a pretty cool homegrown scene!

Quinns Quest

I think this is a joke about Chris McDowell "pulling up the ladder", Ads! Good list though

Quinns Quest

There's a lot about Dolmenwood that I find extremely exciting, but it fell off my radar a bit when I looked at the world atlas and found so many locations/dungeons to be unexciting. Super duper hard to make a world that big and fill it with an equal amount of exciting stuff.

Nick Wakim-Takaki

Yes, exactly. And, like you were in the bit with Chris "pulling up the ladder", also kind of being amazed at how many great designers are in the UK

Christopher derhodes

It definitely leaves a lot to the DM to flesh out the scenarios. I’m running Dolmenwood now and half the stuff feels great, the other half feels half-baked. And there are some regions and large thematic NPCs like the nag-lord where I really wish the author did more with it. (Instead of…. Almost nothing). The modules are very good though, but in a way they serve to kind of highlight how some of the regular hex content is a lot like butter scraped over a little too much bread. I like how it goes beyond its OSE core in ways that are very good, but I find myself feeling like it would have been even better going further in that regard.

Bismuth Bronze Hume Device

Great to see a GLOG callout. It's my favourite nebulous, distributed RPG system/scene/style/quasi-community.

Oleksandr

What an awesome interview. I so appreciate that you are doing it and then embed bits and peaces of them into the final review. This adds so mach heart and character!

FishInBlack

I'd ordered a couple of ttrpgs after discovering Quinn's Quest (Heart and Slugblasters) while looking for Triangle Agency content, but hearing the stripped back and lean rules of mythic bastionland was the first to make me go "Ok I _need_ this". Having nearly finished reading the book I did find the rules confusingly laid out at times as a ttrpg novice (my experience is a handful of d&d and Cthulhu that were fun but didn't really inspire me and felt clunky), but the example play at the back of the book is really when they started gelling for me. Highly recommend people read that section when learning, it really drew the genius simplicity of the rules into sharp focus

con-f-use

I might be wrong, but didn't the video mention, that in the patreon interview (this interview), you asked Chris about encounter balancing? Did I hallucinate that from the video or did I miss it this interview?