Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this Patreon video, I set myself up to give you a tour of the TTRPGs of my youth. What fun that would be! Chatting about Deadlands...

In this Patreon video, I set myself up to give you a tour of the TTRPGs of my youth. What fun that would be! Chatting about Deadlands, Legend of the Five Rings, Traveller... if you watch the Mythic Bastionland review where I tease this video, you can see me describing it in terms.

...That was before I sat down to write the script.

What happened instead is sort of a long, oddly-guilty reflection of how hard it is to start a TTRPG campaign, let alone keep one going. The idea of this video becoming a mini-essay about perfectionism, but here we are. So if your TTRPG-playing life isn't where you hoped it would be, take heart! These things take time.

-- Hugs and kisses, Quinns

Files

Fan Club Content: The RPGs that "Made" Quinns

In this Patreon video, Quinns set himself up to give you a tour of the TTRPGs of his youth. What happened instead was sort of a long, oddly-guilty reflection of how hard it is to start a TTRPG campaign, let alone keep one going. If your TTRPG-playing life isn't where you hoped it would be, take heart! These things take time. Quinns' 2017 review of Blades in the Dark: https://www.shutupandsitdown.com/rpg-review-blades-in-the-dark/ Quinns' Patreon post on Blades in the Dark - Deep Cuts: https://www.patreon.com/posts/116057631/

Comments

Steffen Fitz

here is a shadow to the shining idea of this video. Ttrpgs that broke me;).

Dave

Deadlands is amazing. The new savage worlds version isn't quite as good. But still sweet. Terrible accents aplenty.

AnotherOne

I totally relate to the concept of "I read this book, I imagine this scene, I play this scene and am so disappointedby how it went because I don't (yet) know how to actually pull it off..." <3

elcaptainchef

First time running World of Darkness and it was a single player. A murder happened in the graveyard on his way back from the movies and the vehicle indicated it was most likely his friend. He left an NPC at the back fences and right when we he was close to a cop The NPC texted him drawing the cop to him. My friend still talks about it today. Its been like 10 or more years ago now.

Monsaemon

Luckily one of the first games I played was City of Mist, a PbtA game, alongside being a player of D&D campaign. Having that experience taught me the sort of range of GMing games can have which allowed me to be a lot more flexible when I run games.

Jack Graham

Would love to share my brief history of roleplaying games! I began in college, after watching a lot of Critical Role and a single session of my younger brother trying to GM—I decided that I should try and run a campaign. I put together a group of (7!) people and embarked to tell a grand campaign starting from level 1 with their level 20 foe already picked out. It was remarkably successful (equalizing with 5 players), lasting about 3 years and getting through about 10 levels. It was built on top of Storm King's Thunder and only ended when I was exhausted with D&D and stopped DMing for several years. I relate to your story of grand ambitions and scripted scenes, and while I want to come back to this story (maybe with Daggerheart?) I struggle against how rigid I built the bones of that campaign. I ran a couple D&D one-shots and loved being able to tell a complete story in one go of it so during COVID I started a "West Marches" style D&D campaign with 10 players each controlling 2 characters and small groups went on missions each lasting a session or two. The players were the head of a mercenary group that was decimated at the same time the world was (heavy influences from Colville's Chain of Akeron) and the campaign was built on COVID amounts of free time. It was demanding as a GM, had far too many subsystems, and had an active asynchronous discord channel where players roleplayed in character and told the stories of their adventures to each other (by far my players' favorite part). I ran this alongside my previous campaign and it also collapsed when I was exhausted with D&D. I have dreams of reviving this campaign, revamped to strip away the subsystems and be less demanding to run & play. My most recent game was last year where I ran a few sessions of Spire. It was so refreshing after being shackled to D&D for so long and so free-form! I loved the tone, and how sleekly it runs. It reignited my passion for roleplaying games. It fell apart because of commutes and busy schedules, but I'd loooove to return to Spire once more. These days, I'll be moving soon to closer to friends of mine and I'm plotting a Slugblaster Campaign. When I was younger, I thought the only way to roleplay was with the same group for a hundred sessions. I spent so much time planning out story beats that were years (years!) away, and now I want to return to the hobby and bring my best ideas to the table when I have them.

Eddie Terrell

I found my way to ttrpgs by complete accident - I went to my LGS to check out the chess club, which had been cancelled, and to save me from awkwardly sitting by myself, the D&D group invited me back to play. That first session was so unique and special in a way only a ttrpg can be, and I knew I needed to recapture that lightning in a bottle for my close friends. I probably spent a year and a half afterwards just consuming online DM content until the scheduling gods finally allowed me to get my ideal group to the table...we played Lost Mines of Phandelver and transitioned it into Curse of Strahd and...it was absolutely everything I had hoped it would be. That campaign lasted for 100 sessions, and even though we finished in 2019, we still all talk about how much fun we had. As a side note, the CoS community was incredible for bringing out the best of the campaign - I spent maaaaany hours at my desk job just blasting thru discord to modify and add new awesome encounters, and they were all amazing. The scheduling monster has torn us apart since then, but this channel has sparked the light again, and I'm slowly sending out the bat signals and working on what we can do next to recreate that experience that we've only ever gotten at the table.

zach

About a year ago I finished an urban fantasy DnD game with some of my college buddies and it was maybe the most fun campaign I've ever played. I think my favorite session of it was I had my players fight a beloved NPC who was mind controlled and the emotional fallout they suffered is something they've never forgiven me for. I remember during the combat they all were cursing at me. Beautiful stuff, really.

Ashley Turner

All of my best TTRPG experiences have been Star Wars RPG. But I’ve been spoiled. Every day of summer, my siblings and I would go down into the basement and play roleplaying games for hours. 4th edition, Dogs in the Vineyard, Mutants and Masterminds…. And a frankly unlikely amount of lightsaber swinging. And you know what? Every single one we have fond things to say about. Our childhood memories are punctuated by “that time Shiloh fell off a glass castle in Numenera,” or “when our Star Wars RPG campaign inexplicably turned into hunting for carpentry schematics in Indiana Jones-style catacombs.” Roleplaying is just special.

cheevocabra

As someone who read a lot of the novels and played a lot in the world I'd like to make an ill-advised attempt to defend Rokugan. I'm personally half Mexican and half Scandinavian and I've played a lot of Old West themed games that include Mexicans as little more than their cinematic counterpoints ie uncultured honorless banditos or cowardly peasants and I've also played a lot of games with "Northmen" or Vikings who are brutal savages that wear furs and want little more than to rape and pillage and plunder. I personally love those games. It's fun playing into stereotypes in fantasy worlds and I have very little interest in playing a culturally accurate game about being a Scandinavian farmer. Playing in a mythological world is fun, and mythologies are intrinsically stereotypical. If Lo5R were rereleased to be very historically accurate to the Asian cultures it pulls from then, as a non-Asian person, I don't think I'd be comfortable trying to pull off creating a character and roleplaying them accurately enough to do the game justice, as opposed to the fictional, mythological non-earth setting of Rokugan. (I should add that if another attempt at Rokugan were made I'd want there to be lots of people of Asian descent involved in it's creation as opposed to a room full of white dudes.) If Scandinavians were a marginalized people then I'm sure there would be a push to remove northmen and vikings from our fantasy games and literature and I think that would be a shame and our hobby would be worse for it.

Alone

Finally, lemon/soda water appreciation! The most refreshing of summer drinks. Now I've finished the video. I just ran my first RPG night with some work mates. It was awkward, full of bad accents, misunderstandings and it was wonderful fun. I highly recommend Night of the Hogmen (a stripped back version of Teeth/FitD) as a great one shot for newbies. I've got the bug, we did it all in one evening, I bought Percy Pigs and rubber pig noses. I'm already messaging other friends to see if we can do something soon.

August_A

Coming out of Covid I was really struggling with my creative chops. The game and the campaign that really broke me out of my slump was an urban fantasy hack of the film noir game "Hard City" by Nathan Russell! It had 2 players, was really focused and It couldn't have been more than 10 or so sessions but the system (Action Tales!) was so quick and easy to hack and design for that it fully re-lite my fire, and taught me that I really don't have much of a stomach for 2+ years old mega campaigns as a player or GM anymore. That 10-15 session "tv season" style of play is my new sweet spot and I will forever be in debt to the games of Nathan Russell!

Michael Heilemann

Been playing since 1988-ish. Favorite session ever is a toss-up between two completely on-the-fly Dark Conspiracy in my teens and Heavy Gear in my 20s. No notes, not ideas coming in, just "alright, let's see... it's night, you find yourselves in..." If only I could get into my thick skull that the best games are the ones where I let my creativity off the chain rather than bog it down in pre-conceived ideas; like you said.

Saucy

I couldn't help but laugh when you were talking about Lo5r. When I had my first proper long-ish term RPG group, there were 2 Vietnamese brothers and they were always pitching a Lo5r campaign. I guess at the time (about a million years ago now) it was the only game around that even tried to speak to them? But yeah times sure have changed.

eveningdreamer

my first experience as a GM was for my little nieces a couple years ago, they were 6 & 8, and my little brother (22) joined. none of them even knew what a ttrpg was. I ran them through a small One Page Adventure (by the Sodalitas people) and it was a lot of fun. now it's 3-4 years later and they ask to play again & again whenever we see each other. (I've had to scramble and prep another page last minute, which went... ok). It's been very rewarding and I hope they'll catch the ttrpg bug at some point I've now been running games for friends here and there, it's still pretty new to me but very fun to discover all of this world that until recently I only observed from afar. thanks for the deep dive into the past Quinns!

sperzdechly

3 games and 1 campaign that made me a GM 1. Warhammer FRP - D&D was not a thing behind the Iron Curtain in Poland. Once AD&D 2nd edition was published in early 90s, publishers either didn't have money or didn't believe they will find an audience, so it had a tiny reach. But Games Workshop had all the money necessary to go big, so WHFRP and was an "entry RPG" for the whole generation of Polish players. 2. Earthdawn - after few years in the Old World, my group wanted something with a little bit more hope. Barsaive was an ideal mix of heroism, horror, politics, and adventure. Running games for obsidiman, windling, and t'skrang was one the most fun roleplaying experience we've had. And one could use the whole set of dice from D4 to D20, woohoo! 3. Middle-earth RP - MERP had probably the most demanding and uninspired system, but we all loved Tolkien's books. As a GM I wanted to recreate the magic of Middle-earth and build an unforgettable experience for my group. After 2 one-shots, we started Palantir Quest and I added a lot of extra stuff to make the world rich and exciting. However, few sessions in I felt like our adventure is not at all like Tolkien's writing - pacing was off, nothing felt epic, story dragged because I bloated it with too many side quests. I thought I was disappointing my players and wasting their time, I wanted to quit GMing completely. Then I made one of the best decisions of my gaming life - I openly talked about my thoughts and feelings with the whole group. Something I've never done before. Their eyes grew big and mouths opened wide before they found words and shouted "What do you mean? We've had the best time! It is awesome!". I've never been so surprised in my life. The parts they enjoyed the most were mostly the parts I added in and felt they didn't work as well as they should. This completely changed the way i looked at my GMing, we started to openly talk about our experience after each session, and it helped me build next stories not for but together with my players. Over 20 years later I'm back to Middle-earth! I GM The One Ring for my kids and relive my early passion and enthusiasm as I watch them discovering the joy of roleplaying. I'm so glad I didn't gave up on this hobby.

Wilson__

As much as people hate the system, Shadowrun 5e is the game that set my soul on fire. The setting, the promise of it, the ocean of d6 spilling across the table. Yeah, it's hell to prep. Yeah, the game was formatted by a crazy person. Yeah, it sucks. But I love it and it opened the door to all the other RPGs that I enjoy today.

Grant Oberle

Quinns, this one was an absolute banger. I got started with D&D 5e in 2021 with all the Stranger Things hype as a player in a 9 person clusterf*ck. I quickly got the itch to do it myself, but every one-shot I ran, I was paralyzed by the same perfectionism you described, and I never felt *good* afterward because it could never reach my expectations. Blades in the Dark and Masks went a LONG way to fixing that for me, and though they both fizzled out to an extent, I think the best sessions came out of just rolling with whatever the players were leaning toward.

Steffan DelPiano

I was introduced to Dungeons and Dragons on the sidewalk outside my house in the late 80s. A neighbor, who soon after moved away, had a plastic play mat and plastic figures. One of the monsters was a Rust Monster! I couldn’t play the game that day because my mom made me go with her somewhere (I was only ten). But just getting a glimpse into that plasticine world was enough to hook me.

Nick Hurzeler

One of the most memorable sessions for me was a finale in a Forbidden Lands game where we were in a showdown with the BBEG, and the dwarf player got hit by an attack that broke his arm and he could no longer wield his two-handed axe. The fight seemed to be turning against the players, then the dwarf grabbed a one-handed weapon off another player and dealt the killing blow to the BBEG. It was pretty cool. Also want to add that I agree quite a bit with your assessment of Traveler, and it's sad because it has led to a shortage of good Sci-fi games in the TTRPG space IMO.

Aneagleslament

In terms of what got me into RPGs, it was the standard progression of PF1E at a con to D&D to shamelessly looking at new games going "I WANT TO PLAY YOU SO BAD". However, there's one game I remember particularly and fondly. It was a prize game of Call of Cthulu at a con (I think it was the year after I first played Pathfinder at) where we're playing through an "At the Mountains of Madness" and "The Thing" inspired game set in the Artic. We fly in and I'm trying to play him as a generic pulp detective, except I am rolling like SHIT. I first got a fear of the cold which was awkward, what with the Artic and all, and then I got a fear of all words, including speaking! But god damn it, I committed to the bit (including running straight into the arms of a giant penguin), after a certain point I only talked like 5 times at all, all OOC. It got to the end where we saw a certain King in Yellow chained up in a basement with this massive lock thing. I should mention at this point 2 things: 1) my sanity was very low and I had convinced myself that the King in Yellow would be able to save us all 2) I had been given an icepick So all of the other players are talking amongst themselves about what to do (I couldn't really contribute as much despite my exuberant miming) and as I was sat beside the GM, I OOC said that realistically I'd probably try to free him with the icepick. At which point the GM turned to me, low so the rest of the players couldn't hear "What's stopping you?" and I, big shit-eating grin on my face, mimed handing the GM the icepick under the table, no one else noticing at all. Soon after, the GM interrupted and told the rest of the players that they caught me try to and eventually free the King in Yellow, at which point my sanity was turned reduced down fully, where I lost all phobias and became a servant of the King in Yellow, which then lead to me fighting everyone else. AND I STILL ROLLED LIKE SHIT. I ended up getting crushed by a statue and dying under the debris of it all. It was fucking amazing

daniel schmitt

Hunter the Reckoning was so good. That was also one of my first RPGs, along with Shadowrun. It's why i was so disappointed when the new Hunter the Reckoning came out, I bought it, only to discover afterwards the authors said they really hated the original and so they designed the new one to be nothing like the original. It was such a miststep. They said they disliked the supernatural elements of it, which is odd because there's already a WoD for mundane monster hunters called Hunter the Vigil. Vigil was the mundane one, Reckoning was the supernatural one. And now for some silly reason they have two mundane hunter games instead. Really was one of the dumbest design decisions I've seen in the TTRPG space.

daniel schmitt

Shadowrun is such a wonderful game. It was my first TTRPG (2nd edition) and I still have so much love for it. I actually like every edition, except 6th.

daniel schmitt

I feel bad for people who's introduction into TTRPGs is D&D. They have no idea what they're missing out on and they believe "roleplaying" is choosing a toolbox of attack actions they like called a class, then creating a "build" and using those attacks on xp/gold piñatas to unlock new attack actions to hit more monsters with. I'm sure I'll get called a gatekeeper for this, but D&D is not an RPG, it's a tactical skirmish wargame. Ask a D&D player to describe their character and instead of telling you their personality traits, hopes, dreams, dislikes, they'll tell you their class, race, and what weapon they're carrying.

Miles Dudman

I was so late to RPG's I rode in on a combo of the actual play gold rush of like Critical Role and High Rollers and I would run these elaborate games of Werewolf at sixth form back in 2013 and from that I started D&D and one of the first adventures I ran was like Werewolf in D&D it was terrible. It's actually this channel and my increasing burnout and disillusionment with D&D that has me running my first campaign outside D&D in Heart right now. Like I've run a couple one shots in WoD games and ran Eat the Reich but I'm excited for a campaign with an end in sight which Heart provides

Johnathan Holstad

I started playing with B/X D&D (my uncle had a box set in his attic). It was fast, loose, and I made it all up as I went. It was great. When I got into high school, I migrated to Pathfinder 1e and eventually D&D 5e, and they basically killed my love of the hobby. The trad (and later neotrad) playstyle wrecked my love of the game. I got too focused on telling an "epic story," and it ruined the game for me. It wasn't until I discovered Dungeon Crawl Classics and the OSR movement in university that I rediscovered my love for game. I ran a bimonthly game of episodic DCC at my local game store, and it was like magic. My players were wandering into these intensely gonzo places and if they lived - it was intense. If they died - it was funny. Players often had 3 or 4 characters (and could very quickly make more) so the game was full of wacky, interesting, creative problem solving without worrying too much about character development. These days I play OSR games for the creative experimentation, story games for the characterful plots, and modern "trad" systems like 5e only if I have a gun to my head.

Sunbear Games

In my junior year of undergrad I ran a 2-year, 42 session campaign of dnd 5e. Probably one of the greatest artistic accomplishments of my life? It had an actual ending and everything, we met up and had an epilogue session at the end it was great (and it was then I told them I'd never run D&D again lol). (Also part of the reason that campaign worked so well was because I spent my sophomore year running several small games and cultivating a group of awesome players. Highly recommend.) Among all the great moments of that campaign (the ending was one of the only times I've cried in my adult life about fictional events) one of my favorites was the way it began. At our session 0, I told my players that my only requirement for their characters was that they had all been sentenced to death. It was up to them what they'd been charged with and whether they were actually guilty, but they were all on death row. They all started speculating about what kinds of spells they might need for a jailbreak, and what kinds of strategies they might need while they were on the run from the law. So they were very surprised when we began the first session with them crawling out of their graves, 300 years after being executed. So began an awesome campaign against a necromancy cult trying to reanimate the corpse of god that was the universe! Great times. It also turned into a really amazing story about second chances. All their characters genuinely confronted the things that had cut their lives short the first time, and I'm super proud of them all. R.I.P. Kata Ashseeker.

Echo Tango

A nice benefit DnD has, is that it can be a way to entice people who mostly play combat-focused board-games or video-games to play some non-combat stuff. Like, hook them in with the things that are what they already know, and then the character sheet has slots for things like personality, friendships/bonds/organizations, and the DM gives them some magic items whose use is outside of combat, stealth, or mental domination. :) I would however, love if DnD had as much mechanical depth and in its non-combat as it did for combat. (As well as as much love put into spells, items, or abilities.) It's very lop-sided right now. ^^;

daniel schmitt

I dont even mind combat, I love it being a shadowrun junkie, but I feel like D&D doesnt even have the spirit of an RPG, that you can do anything. I cant even count the number of times myself, or someone ive talked to has been at a table where players or a GM say "thats not on the action list, you cant do that" and it always turns out theyre D&D players. D&D is more like a board game than a ttrpg for that reason. In an RPG you can attempt anything that makes sense within the physics of the world, but DnD says you cant throw dirt at someone without taking a specific feat at a specific level and then you can do it x times a day. Thats how most people play it and thats why I dont consider it an rpg and think it teaches players and GMs bad habits.

Travis Ray

Top of mind best memory from roleplaying is a pretty recent one - I was running Tales from the Loop last year and I had one player character who had a crush on someone, who, incidentally, bullied several of the other characters. In the early part of a session the characters had to hash out how they felt about their friend making plans to go on a middle-school type date with their bully. It was organic, messy, tense, and had some great payoffs later in the session and at the end of the campaign. That scene was only possible because of TftL's gameplay pillars and insistence that you play a (fairly) naturalistic human kid. High fantasy adventurers can definitely have their moments of drama and tension, but the small scale interpersonal feelings of betrayal and navigating what it means to be a friend come so much easier in TftL. I've played quite a few systems, starting with DnD 3.5, but TftL has a special place in my heart because of how it really helps the players find their character's voice. I've never had a bad time playing it.

Echo Tango

I've only been in one DnD campaign (for 3.5) (and several one-shots), and my character was a comedian-bard, who had a Bag Of Weasels, a skeleton-puppet inside his hat who he did ventriloquism with, who was useless in combat because daggers are underpowered in later levels. ^^; My most memorable world, was a sci-fi desert planet I invented, with constant sandstorms that kept most of the inhabitants at the equator, with spaceships continuing to crash-land on this planet because of Reasons. The non-native species (humans, lizards, and flies) were eking out an existence in the cobbled-together shelter of their crashed ships, learning to survive from the beetles who had a more nomadic lifestyle either hunting or with plant/insect livestock. :)

Mackbar's Discount Droid Brothel

I think one of my best campaigns I ever ran was an L5R game for two other people. It remains unfinished, but it was a lot of fun. I do agree that L5R is pretty goddamn Orientalist, but after having owned a copy of Kindred of the East as a kid it somehow seemed more mild by comparison. I think the 5E edition they released recently is closer to a non-offensive L5R, but maybe is still not quite there yet.

Colin Sarsfield

I've been fortunate enough to have run a lot of great campaigns and played in quite a few too as my high school group played solidly for a long time and was rich in DMs. I once started a WEG Star Wars campaign for 2 friends that ran off the rails in session 1 and saw them both, unexpectedly, exiled to a maximum security, Imperial prison planet for some dumb shit that they pulled for no reason (as is so typical). But that's when the campaign really found it's feet. They navigated prison politics, organized a riot, and captured a supply ship to escape the planet. They then became space pirates and eventually built up a huge fleet and gathered up a large cast of NPC crew. Other players joined the campaign and played more minor characters, but the 2 original were the heads of the pirate fleet. But how many pirate fleets have you heard of headed by 2 people? Eventually, politics took it's toll and an epic and deadly PC confrontation happened. It would've been the perfect place to end it, but I ran it for a bit after that as the fleet fell into ruin, mostly a victim of its own internal conflict. That was a very satisfying game for me to run and full of surprises at every corner.

Eric Wilkerson

A game that really stood out to me was a session I ran for Vampire: The Masquerade 5th with three players that were all new to role-playing. This was the second session and one of the players had a backstory NPC lover who they had turned into a vampire before the campaign began and landed them both in hot water. As a reward for completing tasks set out for her and the group, she was allowed to visit her lover at an undisclosed location. I remember the scene of them meeting again having this wonderful combination of beauty at the two characters being reunited and how much the player cared for them, and tragedy knowing this could be the last time they see each other. It really tugged at my players and I's feelings and getting to see them be almost in tears as these two had to be separated again on only the second session truly made me appreciate the joy of stories that we can tell being at the table. I still talk to that player and they bring this up two years later and it just makes my GM heart so happy that they were able to get an experience like that in this hobby :)

Nicholas Bielik

I have spent most of my gaming career playing games that weren't D&D (though I still love D&D too). These include: Top Secret, Call of Cthulhu, Cyberpunk 2020, Paranoia, Marvel Super Heroes, Mekton, Amber Diceless, Vampire: the Masquerade, Pendragon, and many more! One memorable moment was when I was playing Marvel Superheroes in around 1991. We were all playing characters that had been kidnapped by a godlike child who was making us fight some of the most powerful beings in the Marvel Universe in a sort of Secret War/ Contest of Champiosn style arena that was made to look downtown New York. The GM had told us we could play any hero we wanted. No restrictions on power levels or anything. Anyone. Taking up that challenge, I chose Gladiator of the Shi'ar Imperial Guard (because he's basically superman if he was blue and had an awesome mohawk). At some point during the game, I was fighting Thanos (yes, that Thanos) in a heated hand to hand battle, and I got an insanely high roll when Gladiator punched Thanos halfway across the city. And thus I killed the Mad Titan with one punch! It was an exhilarating moment that I still remember. One of those perfect collisions of dice and situation. Gladiator was troubled by this death, but Thanos was a being who threatened the entire cosmos (including the life of his beloved Majestrix), so he wasn't too broken up about it.

Jacob Marks

As a kid my dad gave me all his old D&D books and a few other things. This was in the early 2000s. Mostly Basic Expert rules and various AD&D books. I had a wonderful time flipping through them, looking at the art, and dreaming, but I didn't have enough friends or the space to really place any. Until highschool when I got what sounds like a perfect opportunity. There was a local pizza place and arcade that felt pretty retro, and I got a few friends together to play. The problem was I had absolutely no idea how to play. I figured it'd be like a board game and we could just figure out the rules as we went. I brought B/X rules with an AD&D module and somehow we muddled through maybe 2 rooms in a dungeon before calling it quits. It was still vaguely fun, but not a great way to start the hobby XD

Harry Bell

Some of my earliest trpg memories were of custom systems we made in high school to emulate the old Yogscast "Yogsquest" series on Youtube (certain cast members of which have not remained favourable in the public eye). We high schoolers were in no way games designers, so reams and reams of paper were wasted on custom character sheets and rules for every stupid possibility we could think might happen during play. The system was named DICESWAP. Did that have relevance to any game mechanics? No idea. Was DICESWAP an acronym for all EIGHT stats of the game?! Yes absolutely.

Caden Ashby

Running my first Pbta game (Avatar Legends) reset the way I think about prepping games. I’ve never felt more unprepared and then just had an absolute banger of session!

Dragonback Lancer

One of my favorite characters so far in my relatively limited ttrpg experience was a ghoul I played in Age of Sigmar: Soulbound. In AoS, ghouls are all horrible freaks who love to eat people, as you'd expect, except that they all suffer from a collective delusion that makes them believe they're actually noble knights and lords fighting for order and justice and whatnot. All of the species and factions in AoS are divided into four big superfactions, called Grand Alliances. Ghouls are part of Grand Alliance Death, which consists of all different sorts of undead, like skeletons, vampires, ghosts, etc. However, we were playing a Grand Alliance Order campaign, which is all the standard "good guy" fantasy races, like dwarves, elves, humans, also tree people. So the backstory I came up with for my guy was like a standard exiled prince story, his throne got usurped by a jealous relative and now he's going around trying to reclaim it. He sees all the humans and elves he's working with as various tribes of desert barbarians who he looks down upon, but eventually comes to appreciate their simple, down-to-earth life style and brutal sense of nobility (all of which he just fully made up and has nothing to do with how their society actually works). Everyone else sees him as a half-naked freak of nature running around casting spells and trying to eat people's bone marrow, but since he randomly decided they've got a common cause, nobody really wants to tell him he's wrong about anything

Jack Pressley

The first time I did GM prep as a reaction to my players characters rather then have my grand idea first was eye opening fun. It was a Savage Worlds game- an espionage story set on the moon in an alternate wierd science 1940s where War of the Worlds happened in 1899. Players got the revenge they sought, found redemption in a baby Martian and explored themes that meant something to the players ideologies. Was a blast and we did it all in 4 sessions.

Brian Bautista

Quinns, you asked for this. It's actually been a minute since I have ran a game, life kinda does that and I have been working on my games for a bit. My favorite session is from my very first campaign. I did EVERYTHING wrong you could ever imagine as a first time DM. Inspired by the Matts (Mercer and Coleville) I ,knowing nothing, texted every single person in my phone saying I wanted to run a game... I had 15 people respond back. I not knowing any better, went "that feels like a lot, I better break them up into 3 games." Yeah... suboptimal for brand new to the hobby dm. I was absolutely threadbare running all three, but the players were having a blast, we were all new to ttrpgs, so our mistakes went blissfully unnoticed. Then, I heard tale of a different campaign idea. West Marches. I had already been running them in the same world. They even shared several prominent NPCs as contacts. So rather than rationally and logically explaining the complexities of running 3 campaigns to my friends like an adult. I slowly worked them to the same place on the map. A pirate ship. Then I managed the impossible, I got all 15 of them to meet at the same time, they knew it was for something big, but my wife didn't even know my plan. I made them the crew of a pirate ship and they had to elect a captain. It was amazing, all three parties cleared the island of pirates before getting to the ship, the players were all different circles of friends, so they genuinely didn't know what each others characters were. It was a terrible idea in hindsight, but it worked. Crazy 3 part boss fight and a pirate election and character drafting later. I had all of them in a crew. We ran over 100 sessions over the course of two years after that session. It shouldn't have worked. It was a terrible idea in reality, but the actual momentum of the game itself made it work. We ran another campaign after that one with around 90ish sessions and while we are on a break, they make up my main testing group on my stuff today. Once live calms down a bit, I look forward to running more actual campaigns with them that aren't test sessions.

Raspberry Milkshake

I'm 21, just turned. I got into rpgs when I was 11, when my friends dad ran us through "the new D&D starter set". In the next few years I tried to run a few games that fizzled out, played in one classic 3 year long mess of a highschool campaign, ect. When I went to uni around 18 I ran my new friends through Curse of Strahd, and while that campaign was a blast I look back on fondly, 30 something sessions, great players, all wrapped up with a neat bow, it was also when I realized 5e was just not.... super great. I've recently-ish got together a new group; we play online, bc we're all broke art students with messy schedules and can't stick to a regular in person meetup. I've ran one full Lancer campaign of 14 sessions, now playing in two started by my players which are reaching their ends. Wrapping up a short magical girls themed Fate Accelerated campaign, and a Cloud Empress campaign I started to introduce friends to the hobby but I think is my GMing magnum opus. Three nights a week! I realize I'm sort of insane spending so many hours a week not only playing games but just making so much art and extra content for those campaigns, with three groups who all do the exact same. Recently I saw a player in that Strahd game who's moved off overseas, dropped a joke about a random moment I barely even remembered and brought up how much he'd loved that campaign and how he hadn't played anything like it since. Life affirming stuff.

The Scarllette

The first things my partner played that was not D&D was Liminal Horror. When I ran it for them it broke open their world on what role playing could be. It didn't have to be so numerical, or tedious, or slow. Actions could be immediately felt in the world, and consequences were brutal and harsh but truly felt. This super lightweight game made them persist with the roleplaying hobby to the point where they miss it when it's not part of our lives consistently, and has shown them that horror can be a thing they enjoy.

Mtksnd

I would actually love a video or discussion sharing our best prologues. I nailed it once and then that campaign fizzled and now I'm like can I just use it again? It was so good!!

Faust

My "awakening" moment with ttrpg: I have been playing "The Dark Eye" for a couple of year with my LARP friends; while larping TDE was great fun playing it as ttrpg was for me mediocre at best. It felt mostly "meh". But then - one day - through sheer coincidence I have gotten my hands on the "Mage: The Ascension" rulebook. This did change the way I am looking at ttrpg forever: I was no longer bound by the rules of the "game world" because there were no hard rules - take whatever you want or nothing at all. This felt liberating; especially coming from "The Dark Eye" (which is very strict and prescriptive imho) - I was thinking to myself utterly amazed: "Wait, you are allowed to do that?!" This experience changed my way of looking at an ttrpg evening forever - from "wasn't that nice?" to "There are so many amazing stories to tell, I can't wait!"

T.K.Valentine

Hearing you talk about your perspective of getting really into your own ideas for what the story behind your TTRPG story should look like and being disappointed when it didn’t go that way is very similar to my early experience as a GM, and I think it’s sad that it’s a consistent barrier to learning how to GM correctly. From my perspective, it comes down to the fact that buying a TTRPG is kind of a lonely experience if you don’t already have people you’re wanting to run the game for, and in that loneliness you imagine what the game’s imagery and themes could deliver for your own tastes first because the idea of player feels so hypothetical then. More and more I see DMing as stewardship, and that’s not to say it can’t be uniquely fun to be a DM (you’ve clearly shown that it can be) but the primary focus is a facilitation of play for the players so that the TTRPG can live up to the RP and G of its name. For folks who don’t have players to imagine crafting a story with, it can be such a huge push away from the hobby and a scary wall to breach, and I find it comforting to know it’s a shared experience. It means it’s not insurmountable and these games aren’t too high of a luxury to remain a shelf full of dreams.

Anthony Pearce

I have a very similar origin story. ADnD started as an after school club with a teacher, then when I ran games of our own on weekends (without the books just straight adlib from memory) at 14, Shadow run, DnD3, Dark Heresy, Black Crusade, Starwars... I always ended up running what I could find players for. Lots of great memories, lots of life time friends, lots of returns to old worlds with mixes of old and new players (highly recommend). Most of all, RPGs put me onto my career path as a leader. Many of the lessons that have made me successful were earned at the table top. Starting my kids now at 9 and 5, they're building worlds I never would have dreamed of and its so magical. Keep reporting and spreading this message Quinns!

Kevin

Perfectionism is definitely something I struggle with professionally and in my "leisure" activities. Although I do think it is a kind of "playing" to read through rulebooks and source books and imagine the worlds and stories you might create, as the Quinn's Quest Guarantee™ implies, you never really know a system until you play it. One thing that helped me was GMing for my daughter. We played Magical Kitties Save the Day (truly an excellent system), Mausritter, and Mothership. Each time has been rough and overprepared (you should see my notebook for Mausritter), but I am getting better at it thanks to just diving in! I suppose I would also get more games to the table if it were my job, so I am jealous of Quinn's having carved out a niche for himself (hooray!) doing just that!

Kevin

I think that part of the reason for (at least part of) the OSR is that people see fun aspects of the system, but feel weighed down by later bloat. Brennan Lee Mulligan makes the point (whether you buy it or not) that D&D 5e is perfect for people who want to roleplay and improvise. He said that he doesn't understand or want to devote much thought to combat, so the system takes care of it. Mothership takes a similar stance in that it doesn't offer any mechanics for stealth--something clearly most players would want to use!

Kevin

Have you tried the DCC spinoff "Weird Frontiers"?

Dave

No I have played a tiny bit if dcc and enjoyed it. So will have a look ta.

oldpapapopnlock

"A parade of small disappointments". Ouch, thats relatable!

Eric K

Unilaterally shutting down one's own campaign due to not living up to your own expectations for what it "should be" is something I've struggled with but never fully understood until you put it to words! I think I've naturally grown out of it through better understanding of the hobby over the years, but this was still a pretty cathartic revelation.

PaperSpace

Something I learnt from a game many years ago: A couple of friends committed to playing some D&D online and I, being newish, got overly excited. I wrote a whole setting, its history and this grand adventure. Session 1: the players interpreted the opening scenes completely differently from what I had written. To my horror, they didn't get on the very important boat. The whole written adventure just sailed away into the distance without the players.... Almost textbook example of how to screw up GMing. We still laugh about it.

Druidspell

My first game was DnD 5th Edition around 2019/2020 when Critical Role was surging in popularity. I played at a local game store at first and then got a group of my friends together to play. The best campaign I've run actually started in 2020 when I was starting out, where I successfully ran a multi-year level 3 to 16 homebrew campaign which ended last year. While I never want to DM for 5E ever again, being able to pull that off was an incredibly rewarding experience for both me and my players. Since I started, I've been a part of many campaigns/oneshots for a bunch of systems, and now I'm getting started with GMing a full-blown Lancer campaign, taking everything I've learned from my big DnD game and applying it to a TTRPG I truly love. I actually also played the most recent version of Legend of the Five Rings as a part of my foray into other RPGs. I'm someone from a half-Japanese household who has grown up with some Japanese culture throughout my childhood, so it was an interesting experience for me. It was a fairly short campaign, but I had fun with the game, the setting is neat, and it actually made me reflect a bit on where to draw the lines between cultural appreciation/appropriation. I am nowhere near equipped to tackle such conversations but it’s always interesting to think about!

Dakota Walsh

My first game was 3rd edition d&d at a friends house in middleschool. We didn't really know how half the rules worked and just made up lots of our own strange rules, but the idea of being able to do anything you could imagine was intoxicating. I quickly wound up dming mostly but mostly was running oneshots and d&d was very clumsy. I stumbled into fate core and only really played it a few times and poorly at that, but it made me realize there was a bit more than just d&d. Years later I got 5e and ran a little homebrew campaign ... but I think I suffered from a lot of the same perfectionist tendencies. I moved to a different country, years went by, and some new friends asked about dnd so I said I'd run it for them. We certainly had a blast and the years of growing up helped, but I still felt like we were just ignoring a lot of the rules. So a friend and I started designing our own stripped down d6 system and learned about a lot of new interesting games while researching ideas. Our system never really went anywhere other than a dozen or so playtests, but I learned about knave and then mothership's 0th edition. At some point I searched youtube for reviews about the "new" mothership release and came across your channel and have learned lots and run a bunch of new games since!

Patrick O'Duffy

My first RPG, and the first I ever ran was Basic D&D, in 1983. I was 12 then, I'm 54 now. And I haven't stopped running games in all that time. ...the thought of actually trying to remember all those games, pick out the good ones and talk about them... okay, I'm already exhausted, my knees my back etc.

Sascha

I will never forget one of my first ttrpg experiences, I was lucky in the way to get introduced to the hobby by real great systems. So my first gming experience was an adventure in Beyond the Wall, where at the end the players had to fight against a troll, which was a way too strong obstacle for a beginner group. The group still wanted to fight, which did cost one of the player characters his arm...A moment I will never forget. xD

George Poles

Loved this video. I got into the game in the early 80s, and my favourite early memories are GMing Tracy& Laura Hickman's I6 Ravenloft and playing through the Hickmans' I3-5 Desert of Desolation series. They felt unlike anything else out there - truly epic stories on a grand scale, filled with cool moments. After 20-odd years in the deep freeze, I came back via D&D5E which was... fine? Three spotlight sessions since the return have been playing through Gar Hanrahan's "A Cigarette, A Blindfold & You", for Yellow King RPG, which begins with one of those dilemmas that leaves all the players almost feeling ill as they wrestle with their and their characters' morality. Plus three different one shots of Paul Mitchener's wonderful Liminal RPG, all of them combining moments that were funny, scary and truly weird, and all grounded in the relationships between the members of the crew and the secrets they were keeping and sharing with each other.

Jonathan Dodd

Most memorable campaign I had was from about 20+ years ago, Vampire the masquerade (I think it was 3rd ed). There was a source book which allowed us set us to set the campaign in the medieval period and each player was an Elder forming the council of a small town. There were so many political machinations going on with players and other players and the GM, with notes and secret meetings, plots and attempted assassinations, an absolute blast. So much of this was going on that the emerging threat was completely ignored before it was too late. A great end to the campaign

Brett Rolfe

While I never got things to the table as much as I spent time planning and designing (GM prep is still my all time favourite solo game!) I have such fond memories of Middle Earth Role Playing (MERP), Paranoia, and Maelstrom…

Antonio Ruiz

Quinns, this was so much more raw and vulnerable than your other videos, and I absolutely loved it for that. Sharing your learning to GM journey and taking ownership of your missteps and how you turned those into lessons can be extremely valuable for the person watching Quinns Quest and thinking, “It sounds fun abut you’ve run so many games and are an expert—I could never do that!” It’s a powerful reminder that GMing is always a learning process. I’m still constantly experimenting with new approaches myself, and I make a point to ask for player feedback both midway through my campaigns and at the end. Highlighting the message that even experienced GMs are still evolving, too can be extremely powerful for those who are on the fence about GMing for the first time.

Redd Hibberd

The costume design for this episode is really good. Alongside the set it gave the episode this relaxed, holiday at home feel that made me feel cosy :)

Arseni Kritchever

I'll share a few games that made me fall in love with TTRPGs and one campaign that changed my life. The games that made me the player and GM I am today were: to no surprise D&D (I started with 2nd edition AD&D - that was my first true RPG, not counting the Choose Your Own Adventure books); Vampire: the Masquerade which showed me that RPGs could be more than hacking and slashing and what the R in RPGs could stand for; a heavily modified GURPS lite that I used to run Fallout because that was the first game I hacked myself and extensively wrote my own adventures and materials for and got me writing creatively too; and Ironsworn because it first introduced me to PbtA style games and also made me finally give up exhausting myself prepping for games and made me a better improvisational GM. Now one campaign that literally changed my life happened just over ten years ago when 5th edition D&D had just come out. I moved to another country to pursue a career, leaving my family and friends behind for over two years; I was in a very dark place both due to the move and my mental health and alcoholism. I did not know anyone in that country, but I put up a post on the now-defunct Wizards of the Coast LFG forum asking if anyone wanted to play some D&D and quickly several other people replied. In fact like 8 people replied so I ran my first 5e game for this massive group. And it was an absolute blast. Some people moved away, some people dropped out for one reason or another, more people joined in. And something magical happened both for me and for my players. We became a family and a support group; we celebrated Christmases, Thanksgivings, each other's birthdays, we were there for each other when some of us went through tough times or missed our families back home so much. I don't know if I would've literally survived the years I was overseas (mentally or even literally) if I didn't have that group. To this day, even though I've returned back home (as did most of my players) and got much better in every sense, we keep in touch and are there for each other. Honestly, that campaign saved my life and I know someone else's too (but that's not my story to tell).

William Lynch

The campaign that sticks in my memory the most was a campaign that started with tomb of annihilation and once that adventure was over evolved into two other adventures. The thing that sticks with me the most was the characters all the players created and their evolution. It all felt very organic in a way that I have not been able to capture sense. Shout out to the Lichbane Brigade

J Aaron Farr

My RPG Journey: - Shadowrun 1st edition was my first RPG. I was in 5th grade. We had no idea what we were doing. - Robotech + RIFTS - 2E AD&D - 3.5, Pathfinder, D20 - Burning Wheel <-- This game changed my idea of what RPGs could be - PbtA, Blades in the Dark - OSR Highlights: - The RIFTS campaign I ran in late 90s with my brother and his friends. - The Ptolus campaign I ran using 3.5 and then Pathfinder Unique story: During the years I worked at Riot Games, I ran an informal working group exploring TTRPG systems set in Runeterra (League of Legends). I co-hosted TTRPG design projects as part of the company's semi-annual hackathon/gamejam called Thunderdome. Over the years, we explored League of Legends versions of Mutants & Masterminds, PbtA rules, 5th edition, and several homebrew systems. It gave me an excuse to explore dozens and dozens of RPG systems.

Ash

I'm definitely hoping that Wandering Blades will fill the space that L5R wants to occupy.

Trevor Mahoney

Pathfinder, 2014, 9 players, twice a week, for six plus hours every game. It was the best fucking year of my life, and then the worst as the rest of my life fell apart and all I had was this game to hold onto knowing that I was graduating college and I'd lose it come summer. Still....all my stories come from that year. Man I loved those players.

Édomaur odéon

My turn ! I discovered role-playing in the 1980s with a special edition of the French magazine Jeux&Stratégies, which featured a science fiction role-playing game called MEGA (short for Galactic Messengers). Many adventures followed, and I quickly learned to do anything as a game master, but above all to improvise like crazy. Then I got hold of ‘Rêve de Dragon’ (the second edition of which is available in English under the name ‘Rêve: the Dream Ouroboros’) and that's when we really had a blast. This game has quite complex rules, but its greatest strength is the incredible quality of the scenarios. I mean, something like ‘The Empire of the Gambling King’, a mix of fantasy with Kafka and Lewis Caroll, I've never seen anything like it since. Then ‘Amber Diceless RPG’ kept me busy for a while, but the thing that totally transformed my view of role-playing was ‘Over the Edge’. Holy. Shit. I ran that during my engineering studies and beyond. It was the role-playing game that taught me to think outside the box and showed me that rules could be simple and functional. It's crazy, I really recommend checking it out. I stayed with it for a long time and helped create several French-language games (including ‘Lyonesse,’ but not the latest one). And then one day, the Little Pink Book appeared: ‘Nobilis’ by Jenna K Moran. This game, and really everything Jenna writes, is totally and completely meta. You play soldiers of Creation, avatars of ‘concepts’ (like ‘freedom’ or “electronics” or ‘garden furniture’) at war against the Void... High-level brainfuck. But I love it! ‘The Far Roofs’ and ‘Glitch’, by the same author, raaah I have to play them, really, but it's hard to find compatible players :-D Right now, I'm playing a lot of ‘Itras By’, “Mothership”, and my own creations such as ‘La Noire Essence’ and ‘Freaks' Squeele’ (based on a French comic book of the same name), and I'd like to try ‘The Triangle Agency’ and ‘Vaesen’. But I have to finish writing ‘La Noire Essence’ and publish my friends' projects, games with crazy rule systems, like ‘Erdorin’ (Pulp Fiction in space with pansexual elves) or ‘La collection Maxbrown’ (horror investigations that lead the characters through the veils of reality, which reminds me a bit of Delta Green, but with a different ‘pantheon,’ The Lost Room as an RPG).

Édomaur odéon

Also, I'm a bit of a snob, but I've __NEVER__ played at D&D or any of it's derivatives, I was full "Rêve de Dragon" and never looked back.

Heorhi Yunakou

I will always remember my first experience as a game master. It was a Halloween game that stretched over two days. At the time, I didn't know about any systems other than D&D, Cthulhu, or Masquerade. So I had to run a story about 90s teenagers in the spirit of „It”, using a homebrew system. In advance, I asked all the players to prepare a scary story that their characters would tell at the Halloween party. After the party ended, all those horrors (along with the main story told by an NPC) started coming to life. There was a festival in the town and we even held a karaoke in characters. I also really enjoyed our games of Shinobigami. But to be honest, I worry whether I’ll ever be able to run a game better than that very first one...

Kira S

The game that got me first dreaming about TTRPGs and eventually DMing was the original Shadowrun (A friend's father was one of the writers, so we had access to all the original books) and then Dark Heresy. The Dark Heresy campaign had some of my greatest early memories -- we were two players and a DM who added in two DM-controlled PCs to the party so that we wouldn't die. That group had such tight character bonds and so many Hard Choices that really shaped us. Those characters still live as shorthand with my friends, long beyond the end of those games.

Ben McKenzie

Too many campaigns to mention! But I tried several times to get into RPGs as a teenager in country Australia, with whatever games I could get my hands on, and initially that was only Advanced Fighting Fantasy. That didn’t work out. A few years later a high school friend had somehow got hold of copies of Champions and Paranoia but didn’t know what to do with them, so passed them on to me. I ran a session of Paranoia and it is still some of the stupidest fun I ever remember having. One player piffed a d20 at another so hard it left “81” briefly imprinted on his forehead (and I still have the blurry pre-digital photo we took to try and document it). But my first formative campaigns were mostly shorter ones, and mostly in the World of Darkness, which I was introduced to when I moved to Melbourne for university. I played Vampire (as Malkavians, Ravnos and Tremere characters), but also Werewolf, Mage, Wraith and Changeling, both in tabletop and live action games. I went to conventions and played (and designed and ran) freeforms and weird hacks and homebrew systems, all as one-shots. I played a great Deadlands campaign where I played an entirely inappropriate character (my heart was in the right place, and also the Marshal wouldn’t let me play a mad scientist), and fell in love with that world too. (Though I lent my big stack of books to someone from that game and never got them back.) I tried L5R but was more into 7th Sea, and played a bit of that as well. I never got into Cyberpunk but I did play SLA Industries as a Frother Media guy with a vibro-claymore. And yes, I played and ran D&D, at the time mostly the third edition. The defining campaign of that time, though, was a Call of Cthulhu game which we decided to make slightly more realistic. We ran it as a series of one-shots in round robin style, taking turns to GM and try and scare each other a bit. But each session had to take place at least a few years after the previous one, so our characters weren’t dealing with the mythos every week. One of the characters got married to another; my character tried to play the hero too much and was killed, to be replaced by another. It was glorious even though it only lasted at most about eight games. Lots more has happened since, but that’s the origin story I suppose! Though weirdly I’ve never been super keen to go back to Call of Cthulhu…

Magical Herring

My friend has run a DND campaign based on the Klondike gold rush of 1896. Low magic, any magic you do has to be hidden with the further north you go the more magic nature gets. It made me fall in love with campaigns based on a semi magical earth. Also very interesting to see how affects your memory. I've now seen documentarys of the gold rush and read books of the klondike and at certain points it feels like I've been there. But I've only been there in story.

Mikkel Østergaard

I was introduced to TTRPGs in my after-school centre, playing DnD 3.5. The adult running it probably hid or streamlined a lot of the rules, because I do not recall the complexity the system is known for. One of my friends owned a ton of DnD minis, so a group of my friends had the idea of running a campaign, which I GMed. Of course, we were too young to be able to read the actual, written-in-English rules (I am Danish), so we/I made them up, creating abilities for the player characters between sessions, inspired mostly by World of Warcraft. I cannot recall exactly how this worked or for how long we played, but at some point it fizzled out. Some years later, now old enough to read the dang rules, I proposed trying again. However, when I went to buy the DnD books I was familiar with from the after-school centre, I was informed that 4E was all you could buy now. So I bought a bunch of 4E books, read the player's handbook over a summer, we made characters and started playing, using a classic amnesia start, and... after one session, it fizzled out. I think my friends were confused and found the combats too long and boring. So that left me with a bunch of 4E books, and kind of traumatized me from trying to run DnD again. Years later, I started playing board games. In 2015, with different friends from gymnasium (high school equivalent), we played some Imperial Assault, and I mentioned off-handedly that it was probably the closest to DnD we would play, and one of my friends asked "why?" in a tone, which made me start looking into DnD afterwards. I had heard in passing about DnD Next and the play-testing they had done, and after my short but bitter experience with 4E, it seemed promising. So I bought the books, bought some one-shot adventures and played an one-shot with some of my gymnasium friends, and with some of my middle-school friends. The gymnasium friends were kind of hot on the idea of running a campaign as a way to stay in touch after gymnasium was over, which we did. I ran that DnD campaign from 2016 to 2023, for 110 sessions in total. We went from playing monthly, to biweekly, to weekly(-ish), moving it online for covid, etc. I also ran a 15 sessions campaign of Lost Mines of Phandelver and some one shots at uni. Now, inspired by Quinns, I am playing shorter campaigns of different systems with two different groups.

Rylee Spaulding

the greatest session i ever ran and that made everything click was a single dnd session that the entire premise was how to climb a 200ft tower.

Édomaur odéon

at least one, Maelstrom Storytelling, from Hubris Games. It's also the parent game of the Story Bones rule system

Name

My favorite session I ever was a part of, I was a player and a friend of mine was running Settlers of a Dead God. Essentially the world IS A ROTTING CORPSE and you play as an insect or worm thing that resides within. This was before it was properly released and all that existed was a gorgeous 15ish page teaser with very basic character creation and art/atmosphere. Honestly, it was a bit of a clusterfuck for all of us, the rules were not for 5e dnd, which was the only system any of us knew at that point. We were low level and he had underestimated how lethal it was so there were health potions every 10 ft or so just so we could scrape by. Tldr; very fleshy and tense hunt for an artifact (a gold tooth filling) underground, with motives for betreyal being cast aside after we saved each others lives over and over again until it ended with a heroic sacrifice of my character and a mission success. That session, scuffed as it was, is the template for every one shot in any system I will ever run forever.

Jon Zachrisson

God it is hard to summarize. It was Eleventh Hour, the free starter adventure for Only War when I was like 21. I had been trying to start RPGs, I had tried to join RPGs but nothing stuck for more then like one-two sessions. But this adventure I had finally found people wiling to Roleplay and stick with me through the like 4-5 Sessions it took to bring the adventure to a finalé, where everyone but the Squad ogryn died. Was the moment I realised that YES, RPGs were as fun as I had always imagined they could be, they just required the right group.

Patrick O'Duffy

...okay, I know I said I was too old and tired to remember what games I've run, but the question got stuck in my head. So I trawled Wikipedia's timeline of RPG publishing - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_tabletop_role-playing_games - and did my best to remember what games I'd run, and whether any of them were the ones that 'made' me. Strap in, this is long. 1980s – Basic D&D, Call of Cthulhu, Champions, Marvel Super Heroes, Paranoia, Toon, Dragon Warriors, Hunter Planet, Warhammer FRP None of these were very *good* campaigns, but when you're a teenager the things you experience don't need to be good to consume you. 1990s – GURPS, more Champions, more Call of Cthulhu, even more Champions, Torg, Cyberpunk 2013, Dark Conspiracy, Dream Park, Whispering Vault, Street Fighter, Psychosis, Cybergeneration, Castle Falkenstein, Mage the Ascension, Kult, Theatrix, Deadlands, Feng Shui, Earthdawn, In Nomine, Fudge Wow, I ran a lot of Champions. Most of these were fairly short campaigns, going 3-5 sessions before I/the players lost interest and moved on to the next game. 2000s – 3E D&D (Freeport), Adventure!, Unknown Armies, Brave New World, Big Eyes Small Mouth, d20 Deadlands, Vampire the Requiem, 3E D&D (Eberron) Much less gaming in that decade, partially due to me doing much more freelance RPG writing than RPG playing, partially due to spending a couple of years focusing on drugs and raves, partially due to moving to a different city and struggling to find new player-friends. But then I met a group of very nice blokes in a pub, on a night we'd all come to play 4E Dark Sun in the game shop next door, and that was my future sorted. (Hi Ben! Love you buddy!) 2010s – 4E D&D (generic), 4E D&D (Eberron), Lady Blackbird, Atomic Robo, Smallville (weird west), Marvel Heroic (Annihilation), Monster of the Week, The One Ring, Urban Shadows, Fate (Freeport), Don’t Rest Your Head, World Wide Wrestling, Inspectres, Fiasco, The Sprawl, Cthulhu Dark, Blades in the Dark, One Last Job (Freeport), Fate (urban fantasy), tremulus (Armitage Files), 13th Age Another busy decade! Most of these were 3-4 session games, because I was inspired by an old Grant Howitt blog post that I don't think is online any more. I should run more of those - they're a fun way to experience new systems, and they're easier to schedule than long-running games. 2020s – Scum & Villainy, Bubblegumshoe, Masks, Monster of the Week (1970s), Spire, Heart, 5E D&D, Wanderhome, Lancer, Great Soul Train Robbery ...honestly, this decade's going kind of slow, now that we're past the everyone's-stuck-at-home-and-playing-games-on-Zoom paradise of.... um, a worldwide pandemic. I gotta lift my game. Looking back over all this: a) In hindsight, it's that 1999 Fudge campaign (about amnesiac Norse gods in the modern world regaining their power/memories) that made me - it's the first long game that really *popped*, where I brought all my growing improv skills to bear, where the players were engaged start to finish, where I started with an idea and found a system for it rather than vice versa, where the campaign had a proper ending. Before that game, I was a minimally competent GM; after it, I was a pretty good GM. b) I should maybe get a second hobby. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.

Auburnt Amaranth

I havent played too many as I am still relative new (once more) and only started to try more stuff than VtM. Currently DSA/TDE 5, where 4th edition was my entry. The Delta Green Campaign. One-Shots of Queerz and Punk Is Dead. That's it, but I want to change that. I started as player shortly with 23, but only came back with 28 I think, now as GM. For the video: - Still would love to hear more about your wonky HTR game from what you can remember. - I like Tarot, but I think many games and most GMs use them wrong. They should be an exciting addition or core mechanic, not a burden and a slog like you mentioned. In best case there are precise rules for them, and/or their own brand cards with names/instructions on the cards. But even without I recommend to just interprete them. It can be fun to learn any system there, but in the end everyone just freestyles it and that can be fun if the user is a creative spontanous person. The Cards are read for people, so you can read them for the characters and their situations. evocative beautiful decks work well, best thematic ones. e.g. for my Delta Green Campaign I started picking 3 cards each session after I introduced a soothsayer ingame. I interpreted them to what I think might happen this session. I used the KiY official deck and only added the emperor after they found the card ingame. Gladly, they never drew it or I would have come up with something terrible... heh Only after the soothsayer showed one the way out and the finale, I showed them what deck it was and that it had the Yellow Sign on the back. Of course a very specific case, but just to show it can be fun and good. - if u like Weird West, I wonder if you (would) like Call of Cthulhu Weird West? - thanks for the valuable lessons. I had a tough moment in my current campaign last session as I perceived them not having fun, because of how my supposedly plan to smooth out the problems I saw coming ahead of time, backfired spectacularly. i talked it out with them and they still had it. its easy to put yourself as a GM in an echo chamber of your own making I guess. - and yeah I also decided against a game once that was well meant but had issues. but such would be cool to reimagined by the right people. which I hope happens to Kindred of the East, as gladly Paradox decided against remaking it with western people behind it. btw mold in a house... why do I think of JKR... - and good points about that it could be to just look at newer already more appropiate material. and yeah that job is too often still just a vanity sticker for companies like "look, we do something, now shut up". I once talked to a diversity consultant for Chaosium for a book that is after years still not out (which is not untypical for them), but havent heard back and hope it still worked out and they deliver there. (and they have done a good job in other books, so I stand with hope). - I almost backed the last Blades in the Dark CF for the sick maps. But also see the source of this system as my gf recently got Girl by Moonlight that is based on it. I got another niece of the pbtA system: City of Mist, and its cousins, which I adore. I bet you know of it. Another I would love to hear ur take if u got anything to say about that is heh. (and of course KULT. and for the opposite feel, Thirsty Sword Lesbians - which would be amazing to see a Qinns Quest Review about. It deserves it. :D) - I got the VtM Core Set summer 2019, just before the pandemic. I just moved to England myself and also wanted something new and thought back to what I liked but never did more sadly and I just love vampires, so I remembered hearing about it and checked that there was a new edition released a year ago, not translated yet. it was quite fateful. and i took the pandemic to try it out further. in my case i slowed down again, more for not so nice fateful things and depression, but i picked steam up last year once more and I think it helped me see a routine and perspective honestly. TTRPGS are something special and cannot be underrated. as i write here, I am working on my own indie rpg that i hope to publish one day (as i am in the rules part still, just realistic not perfectionistic for once) once more wrote a wall of text, but hoping u see and enjoy my ramblings as i do yours. thanks for the insight and time travel!

Auburnt Amaranth

hit sent and hear about short comment. well.... oop. technically the part about for what u asked for is short... p.s. greetings from Lancaster, i meant to add

Sarah Grenham

My favourite session would be when I finally got over my fear of being the Storyteller/GM and got a bunch of friends together for a VTM One/Twoshot. I was so anxious for it the entire time, but I just loved the setting and got to really lean deeply into the NPCs for the scenario. The entire thing was essentially a Vampire Weekend at Bernies situation where they had to simultaneously work out who assassinated their mentor while pretending he's still alive and keeping up appearances at this huge party he was holding. The most nervous and the most "I'm not sure I can make a good character" player at my table ended up creating a concept of a Doomsday Prepper who's now accidentally been embraced into a completely different doomsday than he was expecting. I still love that character and I hope he can come back in future Chronicles.

Phenomena Film Society

Great video. Bring me memories of going to Rio to meet lots of friends and trying Tallislanta, Hollow World and Boothill.

Blank

i wish i liked torchbearer, we have a bad time each time because player education is really hard

Inverse Alien

Played several games in the 90's, but the one that really grabbed me was Rifts. Spent sooo much time reading it.. but only played it twice... once as a one on one with my cousin where we just staged one battle with him being a glitterboy mech fighting some giant tick monsters. and then another time where I had like 8 people all playing as different classes again just in a single battle... I recreated a scene from one of the pieces of art in the book where a huge dragon emerged from one of the Rifts (the "Rifts" from the title were rips in space-time to other dimensions with who knows what on the other side)... so here is where I need to explain that the movie "Seven" had just came out.... and one of the players decided that he would have a vibro-blade strap-on... as in a strap-on penis... like in the movie Seven... so of course I had the dragon swallow him whole, forcing the PC to fuck himself out of its throat before the dragon could muster up his breath weapon... He barely succeeded, but I don't remember anything else from that session. Edit: New Dice? I hope you are about to try out DCC, MCC, Weird Frontiers, or..... XCC :D

Blake Smith

(This was as short as I could make it) Although the only real campaign I was able to run in high-school was mines of Phandelver (dnd 5e), I became hooked on the idea of dnd in middleschool after watching way too many videos on how to dm and how to be a good player. Now, after meeting more people and getting a real group together in college. I'd say my favorite rpg is Goblinville, a game where my players can act like goblins and still be in character! Lo and behold, my favorite session was a few into the campaign when I made a trash-island one shot where my players saved goblinville from a stupid tinker goblin who reanimated an ogre ala frankstein with electricity. I'll never forget narrating the island blowing up when the most fire-obsessed goblin pc threw a bottle of nitroglycerin straight at the monstrosity.

Blake Smith

Shorter version that stuck in my head, Goblinville! Great ttrpg where you get a new "title" after every session that's like leveling up! You can invoke the title once per session to get an extra d6 on a roll!

Doc Webb

Deadlands was actually the game that got me over the hump of feeling like I had to plan everything out in advance and made me both a better GM and enjoy GMing waaaay more. I had a very convoluted adventure plotted out, involving a carriage chase and a standoff on a cliff after a cult leader escaped a compound, and one of my players (who had a stick of dynamite from the last adventure) said, “hey… can we just blow a hole in the compound wall?” I hadn’t even considered that, but it sounded great, and so I said “let’s find out!” And let them roll for it. It worked, they raided the cult compound, I had to basically scrap and rewrite the cult leader’s weakness on the spot (because of COURSE they were actually a Monster), and my friends still talk about that game now, 25+ years later. None of it planned, all of it improv, and I learned that, for me, the best games are the ones where I just figure out what happens if the PCs do nothing and let them go make a mess, rather than trying to predict what they’ll do. Deadlands will always have a place in my heart for teaching me that lesson.

Christopher derhodes

One of the games that made me was Robotech. We were in maybe the 7th grade and didn’t understand the rules but still played it and lots of fun. It turns out the rules were pretty terrible and borderline unplayable anyway.

Anders Kernel

Yep. We played Deadlands for years. Still have the wall of orange source books in my bookshelf ❤️ What kept our campaign alive was running the Heart of Darkness campaign for deadlands...

James Doig

Patreon feature request: non-YT options for video content please?

MrStickey

Battletech, Ravenloft and Dark Suns campaign settings for AD&D 2nd ed., Vampire: The Masquerade. Never got a campaign going, but the big blue hardback Champions rulebook was amazing and I created so many characters for that world.

Garrison Gondek

Ooh, i was one of the people who brought something like this up in Discord when you were looking for Patreon video ideas and it did not disappoint! This was really interesting and extremely relatable as I looked back over my own history of playing TTRPGs. I still think a lot about the development I've had as a GM (part of which being me learning that "forever GM," for me, is not a negative thing and is the role I genuinely prefer most of the time), how I went from trying to create the perfect fantasy novel or bespoke video game-style RPG for my players, to learning how to be flexible and improvise, to where I am now where the main things I seek to do is surprise and delight my players and be surprised and delighted in return. A lot of games helped me along that way--Savage Worlds, Dungeon World, Blades in the Dark, and Mothership are some of the most formative games for me in getting me to the style of play and the style of GMing I'm so excited about now. It was really cool getting to hear about your own journey!

Will S

Ntlothing can compare to my first love MERP. 12 yrs old is magical time and those Crit tables (later used Rolemaster tables) made us laugh.

Rose Knight

I don't know if you'll be delighted or horrified to hear this but I can report that there is STILL, TODAY, in 2025, a persistent online MUSH that uses Shadowrun 3rd Edition (Shadowrun: Denver) and - as you might expect - they have literally tens of thousands of words of house rules in order to make Shadowrun 3rd Edition into something that works. Anyway uh, I just had to share that. Great video :)

David Stephanoff

I only started getting into role playing games in 2020 (unfortunately the first campaign I ever played in got cut short by Covid), but I didn't get into running games until 2024. I have been pretty exclusively running Call of Cthulhu and Delta Green. My love for Delta Green is so great that I don't think I can really even bring myself to run Call of Cthulhu again. I have some interest in running Kult: Divinity Lost and maybe one of the Cypher system settings, but I have found my home in Delta Green for now and I'm happy about it!

JustAMia

Just got to this video and on the point of using 52 card decks in play more: just yesterday i played Despair Dilemma, a ttrpg about danganronpa/hunger games/squid game esque killing games, and not only was it absolutely FANTASTIC but I also adore how it uses cards. Its essentially an action point mechanic where having odds, evens, face cards, aces etc etc lets you do different stuff. What it turned into was essentially this roleplaying game (which is vaugley pvp) that we played almost like a strategy game, and then afterwards interpreting what happens. I feel like it did the main thing i appreciate DnD5E for doing, using gamesy rules to create a level of separation that made it more comfortable for new players to be vulnerable roleplaying (including a player for whom this was their first ever game!), but in contrast to DnD5E still telling a story through those rules instead of in spite of them. Really ace stuff, great use of playing cards, amazing PvP game. It instantly shot high up on my list among my favorites.

Scott C Bourgeois

After DnD, I got deep into the D6 "Star Wars RPG" by West End Games. That was the game my friends and I probably went deepest into beyond AD&D 2nd Edition during the nineties. Very fond memories of the zany, half-baked nonsense we got up to in the Star Wars universe.

Aaron

Posted this in chat, but thought I might get some good feedback here: Looking for recommendations on fun TTRPGs to run with my 9-yr old son, specifically ones that encourage and develop his writing skills and style. Solo or low player count preferred, but not a must, as he has opportunity to play Atma etc with the crew.

James Kew

One of my key memories from running DnD was giving the paladin in the group the legendary sword holy avenger. The player after reading the card said "is that all it does"

ZAN

Ran a session in the woods. Players went small enemy faction camp to strike a deal. The battle map had a campfire in the centre, with a ring of wax leaf bushes and trees around it. There was space around here for players to sneak around and approach with stealth. Party split, half going directly to the camp to talk things out, the other half doing stealth takedowns of guards posted to keep watch. PCs in the centre were drawing attention from the posted guards who were aiming guns on them. Stealth team cleaned them up good. But when PCs in the centre succeeded at convicing the faction leader to join forces, the leader whistled for her hidden men to step out as an act of 'good faith.' When only one stepped out, she immediatly knew what had happened and combat broke out. Still sticks with me

Jeremy Herrera

I have two big moments from running games that still really stick with me because they were both powerful examples of the players being invested in the characters and setting. Near the end of one long campaign, my players had to kill a powerful mage under a corrupting influence. As the fight drew to a close, the mage's un-corrupted mind resurfaced, and they begged for mercy. Even though they knew going in that they could not save this person, the players paused to consider, and the one who dealt the final blow later told me it was a very difficult and moving moment for him. At the end of a different campaign, which was the prologue to a different campaign we'd played some time before, may players faced down what was intended to be their final enemy. However, in a moment that deeply surprised me, the players all stopped, discussed everything they'd been through, and decided to trust this person they'd been pushed into opposing. After a good deal of talk, we spun out how this choice would lay the seeds for the state of the world many years later.

tompuce84

Campaign that made me a GM was actually a setting, PLANESCAPE BABY. I run a home conversion of the planescape setting using the Patrhfinder rule book. Best dnd setting, nothing comes close for me ;)

SandyMan

I'd look for anything with little to no rules. In my opinion, most ttrpgs are made for boring adults, who need boring rules to have (boring) fun. Kids are a well of imagination, but their play doesn't work like adult play. If you can't sit your kid down, and play a game of chess to completion without forcing him to play, don't expect him to play any game with a greater than or equal amount of rules. Also, kids like calling the shots, so let him actually get to make up rules, and break rules sometimes. Look into "Axe Cop" a cool comic written by a kid, and illustrated by his father for an idea of how this kind of collaborative storytelling can look like. I forget the name, but there's a simple rpg about being a bear trying to steal honey, that might suit you. Other suggestions include the one about being a little goose, and something like everyone is John. Idk a lot about 9 year olds, and you know your kid best. If he likes star wars then maybe find a book in that setting, and drop the rules that seem complicated & boring. If you want to encourage him reading, you need to incorporate it into the story. My mom used to do a thing like this. When I had math homework, and I didn't want to do it, she'd tell me something like "but you're a detective. You need to do these calculations to figure out... Who murdered the queen!" And I would go and do it right away. After having finished it she'd give me clues and stuff (she made it up on the spot, obviously) but it turned into a whole story about a gumshoe detective and an elusive killer. My math homework was a tool, in my detective toolbox.

SandyMan

For writing, I'm sure it could be something similar

Björn Andersson

I tried playing Dragonbane with my 8-yo this spring. Did not really work. Not so much the rule system i suppose, as a problem with how I ran investigative style one shot story arc. The build up was a bit too slow and the mystery too complex too captivate him. It fizzled. A few months later i saw the 1-bit Grotten videos on mystery quest, and tried that out with him, with an even looser interpretation of the rules. He had a blast, and displayed an amazing creativity that really told great stories from those just a few simple random tables. Not every kid has the same ADHD brain as my son, but i imagine keeping it simple and loose and taking it down one more notch than you might think would useful generic advice!

Patrick Mahon

As far as actual TTRPGs (before was imagination games with no rulz) my journey was really similar! I started with DnD 3.5 and Dead lands, and similarly did not know what I was doing while running those. Deadlands in particular felt like the priest addicted to peyote, rolling (literally) up to bandits to point blank shotgun them seemed like an unbeatable strategy. After I got into 5th ed (sorry 4th) and started collecting and reading (I guess also playing)more games.

moe

very late comment, but I subscribed here because I ran a mythic bastionland oneshot based on your review, which spiraled out of control into the first campaign I am GMing since high school some 20 years ago. To address both your feelings of perfectionism, which I share to this day, and to spin it back to mythic, I've been experiencing the most uncanny third man factor playing it. I've never before really used pre-made settings or adventures outside holiday oneshots for the group, and with mythic nearly demanding I do no prep and improvise 90% on the spot, I feel an unbelievable lightness on my shoulders before the game, but then an incredible feeling of perfectionism simply not applying to the situation. Neither does the sesh have to go like I imagined (I didn't imagine it at all!) nor do I have to maintain the author's vision of the premade (there isn't one!!), I simply go with the flow, the shared space ends up being exactly what it was supposed to become. It really is an incredible game. I really might get the book.

Adam K Bunnell

Love this video! So good. The only part I felt a little weird about was the bit about L5R. While I understand the cringe inherent in a group of white teenagers roleplaying "honorable samurai" (because, well, I've done it) I don't think that it means games like L5R shouldn't exist. As an American of European descent, am I only qualified to design and play games set in those cultures? Should a Japanese game designer be told she cannot touch the Wild West as a setting idea without consulting a cattle farmer from Texas first? While cultural sensitivity is a net positive, I think an overemphasis on it only serves to stifle creative expression and restrict the worldviews and experiences of all. I know very little about what it was like to be an honorable samurai, it's true, or if historically that was even a real thing? But my clumsy roleplay of L5R did lead me to watch Kurosawa movies and broaden my cultural understanding much more than I ever would have done without that game. Trying my best to inhabit the mind of a samurai was an exercise in attempting to empathize with someone's interpretation of another culture and, while not perfect, I struggle to see more empathy of this kind in the world as a bad thing? I get that when it strays into exploitation, there is a big problem, though. Like most things, there is nuance. Would love to see Quinns dive deeper into topics like these in the future!

Chris Stark

I was spoiled at an early age: though I'd dabbled with Basic/Expert D&D in the earliest of days, a friends older brother run a multi-year campaign of his own system. It let me appreciate great storytelling. I haven't yet been able to replicate the experience, though I looked through so many systems and what it might run like. Games incd: MERP/ICE (oh those tables!), TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles, Heroes Unlimited, TopSecret, PsiWorld (i was big into psionics back then), Cyberpunk (1st gen), Paranoia (1st gen), James Bond RPG, Star Frontiers, Gamma World, VTM... Then nothing til SUSD/QQ dragged me kicking and screaming back into my fave hobby. Quinns et al -- I'd like to learn how to cultivate a good gaming group from nothing. I really fail at this now; though my kids are guinea pigs, I find it hard to find players. I've used Blood on the Clocktower as a potential 'filter' for people who might try. But a good group feels so critical to a great game....

Peter Robinson

My first campaign was DND 5e, and the fascinating thing about it is that I can barely remember it. It wasn't some childhood thing either: I was 20. I think the reason I only remember fragments is because one decade on, I can see how intensely my (at the time) unmedicated brain chemistry affected my behavior. I was such an anxious perfectionist that in certain social situations, I must have done something close to dissociation in order to cope. The reason I wanted to share this story is because my journey of dealing with my mental illness is one where I've employed RPG's as a therapeutic tool, to practice building routines, scheduled socializing, and defusing the impulse to value only perfectionist visions. I've since run a handful of short campaigns in 5e, and now Quinns Quest has compelled me to put different games in front of my friends. Mythic Bastionland is great. Hopefully, I can look back in decades to come on the games that made me healthy again.

Collin Hancock

My first DND campaign, the GM had an NPC named Yugdab. As a party, we immediately referred to him as Young Dab. We all knew Young Dab was solid beyond a doubt. Until the GM revealed the anagram (bad guy), spelling it out for us Tom Riddle style and, we had our big bad boss fight. TPK. Perfect. No notes.

Inclusive Investor

My first campaigns were D&D 3.5e dungeon crawls with almost no roleplaying - like, a very brief few lines of in-character dialogue per session at most, often in the form of establishing the impossibility of reasoning with malicious goblins, or liches who had totally lost their minds and just wanted to kill us/everything. These games were run by my friend's dad, and all us players were aged around 9-12 with zero prior understanding of the hobby. My entire concept of TTRPGs was therefore "me and my friends having magic powers and solving puzzles and getting caught in traps and fighting bad guys is pretty fun". (We all wanted magic and/or animal companions, so there wasn't much in the way of party balance!) Cut to university: I get invited to a game of Pathfinder, it has in-character moments and a non-dungeon area to explore (huh, neat!), but similar prewritten-adventure vibes and a heavy combat focus. But then, due to being in that campaign, I get invited to a Runequest game that a friend of a friend wants to run. And it was a REVELATION. My mind was completely blown in an early session when the GM reacted with surprise (followed by pretty solid roleplay of agonised terror) after my character harpooned a bandit in the leg and dragged him back to my teammates in order to stop him escaping and interrogate him. Which, to me at the time, had seemed like the only 'correct' course of action based on my experience of TTRPGs. I was so shocked that, despite all those years of conditioning to think otherwise, NPCs could be, like, people? Actual people who felt pain and emotions and had understandable motivations related to systems of oppression and lack of opportunities to survive/thrive? Not just disposable cartoonishly-evil enemies to feel smug about defeating?!? ...Wait, did that mean I'd just done something that had ethical weight and meaningful narrative consequences? If I had realised that was a choice, rather than an inevitable 'correct' gameplay move, would I have chosen differently? What did it mean for my character that I'd made him be the kind of person who would feel no reluctance to harpoon a retreating peasant bandit in the leg, just for convenience and strategic advantage? Was I going to play him like that forever, or would this experience be a turning point for him? It probably won't surprise anyone reading this that I did indeed make it a turning point, as he realised his time on a pirate crew had desensitised him to violence in a way that did not mesh with civilian life or reflect who he wanted to be now that he was relatively free for the first time in his young life. It was a narrative beat that had a huge impact on the rest of both our lives. That was the point I fell in love with TTRPGs - that Runequest campaign completely changed how I thought about what they could achieve as an art form, and how I could engage with them, and I never looked back. Over a decade later, now with experience of a wide variety of game systems and GM styles, that GM remains the best I have ever played with and the one I model my own GMing style after the most.

Frankie Frank

The rpg that made me fall in love was actually a game that falls into the cupboard LARP category you recently blogged about. I'd been playing DnD and CoC since college, but it was a meetup group in Edinburgh in 2019 where I played Rider's Last Rights (can be found on itch.io). The story sees 5 people sitting vigil for a mech operator with different ideas about how the situation should be handled. Think Alice is Missing, but it's more like Shinji is Dead. Imagine 5 strangers, sitting in a pub reminiscing, sitting vigil, arguing, making cases, two of us cried for our loss and in anger... I legit think about it once a week.

Frank Levi

I've been running games since I got my first D&D set when I was in grade school (the Basic set that came out in 1981). So far my favorite campaign is Impossible Landscapes (which I'm currently running for my 21 year old daughter and her college friends). We're about half way through. I found that thanks to you! :)

Duran

Fantastic to see another fan of 2300AD!

Chip Ridler

Games that made me? WEG Star Wars. Smart, funny, easy to pick up and play and built upon the limited knowledge we had for SW in 1987. A creative tour de force for the era and whose influence is still felt today.

Nick Daniel

The Shut Up and Sit Down review of Blades in the Dark is why I became a GM.

Dee

In the D&D third edition book Oriental Adventures based on the L5R setting, there is table that is so comically racist, but so clearly unaware of it, that it still makes me chuckle. It's table 5-1: Common Syllables on page 69 and it's a list of common recurring syllables in Asian names to help you "generate" your own. It's so naive and spectacularly tone deaf that my brain simply has no other response to it than laughing at it. Anyway, the one thing that has always stayed with me was this character I ran in someone else's campaign which was this awfully minmaxed monk/rogue multiclass that used shuriken and byt carefully combining the right feats and class abilities I could basically one shot anything beefy the DM put in front of us. I was terrible at crowd control, but if I decided something was going down, it was going down. That turn, usually. It was great and frustrated my DM to no end because he could basically not introduce any memorable villains

Erik

Fantastic video! The bit about having strong feelings when the players offroad the story you had planned (and often into areas you aren't prepared for or into material you don't enjoy) really resonated with me. And for the record, I think you're right about older Traveller but the modern incarnation of Traveller with Mongoose 2e does have a lot of the more fun stuff (including food!).

Stephen Place

I started with D&D 3.5. I fell in love mostly with the mechanics. The character building, min-maxing, selecting spells and magic items. The first summer I had the core books I made 100 characters before ever playing a game. I played for a few years with a group of friends then put it down for 15 years. It was only after discovering Mothership and other Rule-light and OSR style games did I fall back in love. Now I can't get enough. I am running multiple parties in different systems and loving every second of it. There are parts of me that want to play Lancer just for that crunchy mech building, but I know I never will because that's not kind of game I want to *play*

GoodOl'CSB

I came to role playing relatively late, but I have to say I love it and lament all the hours of fun, awkwardness, stress, joy, and anxiety that I feel certain I missed out on. That said, my group and I just session zero’d our second campaign of Heart last night drawing from a bunch of source books (we’re going to be stewarding a haven where the buildings all become sentient when they’re construction is completed) and I can already tell it’s going to be SO good. We sort of speed ran Heart the first time because it was a planned, 5 session mini-campaign and now we’re going to luxuriate in the world (though likely not the specific CHARACTERS) for quite a bit longer.

Wartide Card Game

I joined the Patreon specifically to watch this video, and was not disappointed. My favorite RPG memory was a L5R 4th edition campaign at my local game store. It was a multi table game, with at its peak about 45 players and about 150 player characters existing simultaneously in the world, populating different clans, moving between tables for different adventures, running campaigns and even full court larps. Honestly an amazing time and I still love Rokugan, and thing L5R 4t6h ed is one of the best design RPG systems I've ever played, though not so balanced at the higher level characters.

Lionel Herrbach

I was offered “Yggdrasil” (published by Le 7ème Cercle) by my group of friends when I was 16, and I played it for the first time 10 years later, lol. I had no prior experience with TTRPGs and the rules seemed pretty complex to me. There are also practically no online resources about it... It's a great book that teaches you a lot about Norse mythology, BUT it turns out the combat mechanics are broken... No wonder I couldn't wrap my head around it ! (Feel free to reach out if you have any experience with it). The setting/plot it comes with was also very politically focused, when I just wanted to slay epic monsters. So I got into DnD (the Phandelver starter set) and took the elements I liked from the game to spice up the slow-moving intrigue of Yggdrasil: I built an entire dungeon around an NPC which was just mentioned in the sourcebook and it was the best part of our game! I still gave a huge expo-dump at the beginning of the session to my players and way too many details throughout the game, as I thought that was what the game's designers expected of me and the way to best honour the source material. Today, I would have no hesitation just picking the elements I like the most to create my own a homebrew campaign — or I'd try to emulate the tone and structure of Mythic Bastionland... that could be fun.