Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(This post could have been titled "Sorry folks, I've got another book or two for you to buy.")

Today I want to write about new TTRPG Doomsong and the accompanying sandbox campaign Lord Have Mercy Upon Us. You might have seen that this game is nominated for a bunch of Ennies this year. I'm here to add to the hype.

Also, I want to explain how - quite unfortunately - this game has fallen between the cracks of Quinns Quest a little bit.

So, in the words of Teeth designer Jim Rossignol who was excitedly messaging me about Doomsong this week, "these books are berserk."

I might start by describing Doomsong as a fantasy TTRPG that takes the exact elements of history that fantasy RPGs generally discard like so many unpalatable chicken bones - namely filth, misery, and Christianity - and then turns them up to the max like the designers were cranking up a guitar amplifier.

Now, this might sound a bit like I'm describing indie smash hit MÖRK BORG. And sure, both are games that take place mid-way through the apocalypse, and both books can be heard giggling while presenting you the most hopeless locations, monsters and NPCs you've ever read.

But the two games are quite different.

MÖRK BORG presents grit and darkness as a kind of... stylistic pastiche of the fantasy RPG. Reading MÖRK BORG gives you a whiff of the Scandinavian role-playing scene, with its leather jackets, piercings and curse-words. The world is ending, and there's nothing you can do about it. Except rock some monsters!!!!

Doomsong has a far more nausea-inducing proposition. The world is ending, but there is hope... and it lies in the hands of the fanatical, witch-burning, achingly formal institution of the church.

Doomsong is a game that reads like the authors grew up Christian and are trying to exorcise (or at least parley with) some of those demons.

In other words, where MÖRK BORG is Death Metal, Doomsong is a hymn.

Let me talk about the core book first, which presents the world, the rules, and the bestiary. After that, I want to talk about the campaign book, Lord Have Mercy Upon Us, which is what really captured my heart.

So, Doomsong!

With exquisite black and white presentation, and then thin licks and splats of colour whenever it talks about the pantheon of Traitor Gods that are ruining the world (see above), Doomsong presents just the worst world ever.

At least MÖRK BORG is zoomed out a little bit, letting you consume the setting like so many song lyrics. Doomsong presents a society in lurid detail and you're going to wish it didn't.

Characters are created through a sprawling and surprising lifepath system, which feels like falling out of a tree and hitting every miserable branch on the way down. See below.

The Doomsong core book also has a calendar (which is expanded greatly in the charming official calendar supplement), bringing your campaign to life with a relentless barrage of holy days and wildlife breeding schedules and heretical traditions. The book has eight beautifully-illustrated pages on plants, trees and mushrooms help the GM "other" any scene the players are in (e.g. "Purging Buckthorn - This tree reacts to excessive moisture by expelling surplus water from its bark, staining anything it touches a deep black.")

Then we have monsters, which are presented not just as sets of frightening abilities, but as part of a disgusting ecology.

This book has fractionally-more-intelligent bears called "Bautenlobbes" that hunt bears for sport. Because we've all become used to the tired imagery of a giant squid, this game's signature sea monster is a ship-sized prawn. And in the four pages on the game's signature giant spiders - "Laceworkers" - you can practically hear the authors rolling their eyes at the idea that they should accommodate the common fear of arachnophobia, and instead they double and triple down on making spiders as real as possible.

To successfully survive (let alone eliminate) laceworkers, players should try and understand their life cycles (nests, hatchlings, males and females) and unique heresies. Famously, the gaps in the web of a full-grown laceworker act as fragile portals to their other webs. Get stuck in a laceworker web and half of your body could be a mile away, poking out of another web. And if either web is ripped, your body will be instantaneously, permanently sliced in two.

One of the special abilities of laceworkers is simply that they're "lucky", forcing players to re-flip the Doom Coin if they get a good result, which makes me laugh and laugh.

I should talk about the Doom Coin! You can see the official one below, though other coins will work just fine.

I've not played Doomsong, so take all the following with like eight pinches of salt, but the rules in Doomsong seem - in a word - grave. (There's also a novel and thought-provoking combat system, but I don't want to talk about it until I've tried it.)

Players don't have many advantages and checks aren't generous. It's a game where you can expect to die - more on that later - and your journey there will see you writing words on your character sheet like "Starving," "Uneasy," "Bleeding," or "Missing [limb]".

(Above you can see the official skill check reference cards, which - like everything in Doomsong - manage to be seductive, even if you're reading about botched surgeries.)

When reckoning with skill checks, players do have one advantage. They get a choice. A nasty little choice.

After rolling any skill check and getting a result which will be one of three levels - "Fail with cost", "Succeed with cost" or "Succeed", they OR ANY OF THE OTHER PLAYERS can always additionally flip the Doom Coin, which will step their result either up one level or down one level. Did you fail when you really, really needed to succeed? No problem. Would you like a 50% change of succeeding with a cost? Oh, and a 50% chance of truly devastating failure? I'm sure you'll get lucky. G'wan.

Flipping the coin is is the only way you get critical successes, which are one level higher than "Succeed", or critical failures, which are one level lower than "Fail with cost". And as you'd imagine in a game as bleak as this, Critical Successes are desperately desirable and Critical Failures are monstrous.

And here's the twist. Anyone who decides to flip the Doom Coin has to leave the coin in front of them until someone else flips it, and so long as the coin is in front of you, after a skill check the GM can force you to flip the Doom Coin. They can force you to pick up this literally and metaphorically heavy totem when you least want to push your luck. This is called being "Doomed", and lots of monsters and traps have... let's say a professional interest in whichever player around the table who might be Doomed.

As I say, I haven't played Doomsong, but that sounds like a lot of fun. I can imagine my players giggling and screaming through this whole charade.

I want to move on to talking about Doomsong's enormous published campaign, so the last thing to mention about Doomsong's core book is its cool campaign structure.

In the words of the book...

"Doomsong is not the story of any single character, nor even a single party. This is the story of a guild."

Now, while the Doomcoin is cute, I think this is just... uncomplicatedly intelligent. I'd be tempted to structure a campaign of Mothership like this, or any game that wants to threaten (and make good on) player death and party wipes without ending the story.

Whether your campaign is about a guild of Witchfinders or Woodcutters, Signmakers or Ratcatchers, your guild is the main character. This club is what accumulates resources, facilities, opportunities, enemies and character(s) as you play. This at once lets players permanently bank achievements in their administration, but also means the GM can pump the players full of dread like so much botox. Because the GM doesn't need to think twice about killing your character - the guild will always live on - every decision and dice roll can be freighted with risk.

And speaking of guilds... let's talk about the story of the Gravedigger's Guild.

Let's talk about the epic campaign book, Lord Have Mercy Among Us (henceforth L.H.M.). This is the reason I wanted to write this post.

LHM is a good fifty pages longer than the Doomsong core book, and look- I fucking love a giant adventure module. Y'all have seen my Delta Green: Impossible Landscapes review. I read Traveller's Pirates of Drinax like it was a novel despite knowing I'll probably never run it. I had the best time ever playing Mothership's Gradient Descent.

I'm here to tell you that LHM seems to be up there with the best of these mammoth endeavours (although again, I can't state this enough times: I haven't played a single minute of it).

Where do I start?

Oh gosh. Oh yikes. This book is a marvellous thing.

I should start by saying that these books - the core book and the campaign book - are like two halves that make a whole. The Doomsong core book by itself is... just a vision of a world with the authors' pupils fully dilated and maybe some spit at the corner of their mouths. It's all KINGDOMS, TONE, HISTORY, MUCK, MIRE, TRAITOR GODS, CALENDAR HOLIDAYS, FLORA, THE WORST MONSTERS YOU'VE EVER SEEN, COMBAT RULES THAT SEEM QUITE INNOVATIVE HONESTLY I'D BE EXCITED TO TRY THEM.

And so you read it and you're like "Wow!" ...but you'd be disinclined to actually run it because it's not quite a game, it's more like a reference book to an imaginary place. This is in stark contrast with the games I've been choosing to review on the Quinns Quest YouTube channel, because in the year of our lord 2025 many designers have realised that what is traditionally called a "Rulebook" in TTRPGs? That's a backwards descriptor, because what you should be writing is really more like a guidebook. The purpose of your game's core book should be that the GM can read it and know roughly what their job is, what session 0 looks like, what session 1 looks like and so on.

This is not Doomsong. Despite being so breathtakingly modern in its layout, in this one respect it's a bit of a throwback.

So how do you play this game?

I'll tell you! You're simply gonna run LHM (or at least read it to get a bunch of ideas you can pilfer). Because where Doomsong sprawls, LHM tightens.

I mentioned above that Doomsong is about a world at the brink of a holy apocalypse, right? Well, LHM tells the story of an epic - and contained - battle in this war.

Here's the pitch: 50 years ago, one of Doomsong's traitor gods, Pestilence, succeeded at capturing one of the kingdoms of the world for him to treat as his own private fiefdom. In an instant, the kingdom of Lethe vanished from the world, and unknown to all but the cursed people stuck living there, it became... The Plaguescape. It is now an inconceivably miserable mockery of what it once was, and the only reason that the humans and animals are still able to eke out a desperate existence is that Pestilence needs playthings, and subjects, and company.

Nobody can escape the Plaguescape. However, sometimes woe-begotten souls wander into the fog and find themselves there.

And this is how a campaign of LHM starts. Your players are all members of a Gravedigger's Guild in the wider world of Doomsong, only one day they get turned around in a fog and become the newest inhabitants/prisoners in the Lost Kingdom of Lethe.

Confused, alone, and utterly ignorant of what the shit is happening, the players will find themselves at a literal crossroads next to (and I love this for the first scene in a campaign) a broken signpost that says the local branch of the Gravedigger's Guilt is in one of four directions.

Perhaps allies can be found there, or employment, or at least answers?

And so a story begins where the players will eventually realise that the only way out of this hellscape will be for someone to slay the regent of this realm, the god himself, Father Plague. And with all the knights and heroes of the Plaguescape long-dead, it seems hope now lies with the only people willing to take a crack at this... our humble clan of gravediggers.

Important thing here: What I love about LHM is that while the world of Doomsong is laughably dismal, where every single NPC is illustrated as just the most fucked up, wonky-faced freak, and the monsters are so much worse? LHM is a story of heroism.

It's about a society of those wonky-faced fellows choosing to hope, knowing that many or all of them will die horrible deaths on this quest, but if you play this campaign right to the end it can be a story of your pathetic guild of gravediggers in their tumbledown guildhall eventually digging a grave for a god.

Now, your mileage may vary, because I know there are lots of fans out there of the grimdark worlds of MÖRK BORG or Warhammer 40,000, but to me these comedically dreary settings are fun as an aesthetic? They're cool! But they're not fulfilling meals by themselves. I need a little more light and shade than that. A little more texture, a little more nuance. (I also need a little more women lol come on guys it's the year 2025)

So I love that LHM is a game where you'll play in defiance of the setting. And speaking of texture and nuance (and women), LHM is a book that just contains so much texture, and so much nuance, and so many different sorts of people. It reminds me of TEETH in that respect. You get a whopping 350 fabulous pages of just the most colourful, funny, creative locations, objects, monsters, traps and - yes - wonky-faced freaks - you've read in a long time.

Your players can look forward to visiting the little wicker encampments of the child-sized Birdcatcher people. They will contract Toothworms. They will seek the death of Granny Redwork, and find an ally in the Licemother. They may bump into anyone from the book's two pages of feral orphans. They will explore towns and barrows and treehouses and orphanages and sanctuaries and convents and two different floating towns and, like, look-

Since I started Quinns Quest, a lot of people have asked me if I've taken a look at kickstarter success story Dolmenwood. The truth is, I have looked at it, and there's lots that I love about it? But the moment that I felt content closing those books and looking at the next TTRPG on my list was when I browsed the Dolmenwood books that describe the world itself, the various towns and dungeons, and what I discovered was that some of those places were interesting but lots of them weren't. And I don't care if your world is big if all sorts of places that the players might visit aren't super worth visiting.

That's not the case with LHM. The crowning achievement of this book is that I can crack open any of its 350 pages and find myself merrily captivated by the entire double-page spread, whether I'm reading about a bridge or a snake or a moth or a bakery. It's all fucking great!

"Alright then Quinns," you say, exhausted from this week's battery of Quinns' hyperbole. "Why aren't you running a campaign of Lord Have Mercy, then? Why are we hearing about this in a blog post, as opposed to a full-fledged Quinns Quest video review? I've got your number, you overblown salesman."

Good question! Let me try and unpick it.

Let me start by saying that I might well go on to do a video review! It could happen!! Depending on which games capture my interest in 2026, I'm not ruling it out.

But the fact is that Doomsong's been in my possession for about a year, and I've never seriously found myself tapping my index finger against my front teeth while wondering which of my players I might plug into a campaign of this. So this blog post, in a way, is me admitting defeat. I can't see myself running this in the near future.

And if I had to give one reason why that is, it's that I have a nervous feeling in my gut that I'm not sure my players would adore the unique way that LHM is structured.

I'll explain: One of the cool things about Lord Have Mercy is that it actually seems to take a lot of inspiration from open-world videogames, like The Witcher or Elden Ring.

The players are given an open world that hates them and an objective that seems tremendously distant - kill a God who wanders around the world like an itinerant Ganon - and then (as I say, I haven't played it so I could be wrong) the campaign is about them picking their way towards this objective one step at a time (risking their lives time and again for an item, an ally, a fragment of the puzzle) in a way that I imagine could be tremendously satisfying? But would certainly be very different from what I've reviewed on Quinns Quest so far.

In video game design terms this is sometimes referred to as "Telescoping", after the way that a segments of a portable telescope fold up to be contained within one another.

I don't want to spoil too much, but basically the players need to:

Defeat Father Plague. To do this, they must...

Destroy some fraction of seven macguffins scattered around the world. To do this, they must...

Collect these seven macguffins. To do this, they must...

Know they need to look for the macguffins. To do this, they must...

Find out the truth of Father Plague. To do this, they must...

Hear rumours about the resistance against Father Plague. To do this, they must...

Make allies with the right local people. To do this, they must...

Learn about the Plaguescape and start solving problems. To do this, they must...

Explore.

I'm paraphrasing here. This is a TTRPG after all, and the campaign is full of clever ways for players to short-circuit this rough structure. But the campaign is also drastically more complex than I'm making it sound, and the PCs aren't heroes, they are gravediggers, and like, almost everything in this world is either hateful or selfish or deserves to die or wants them to die but most commonly ALL FOUR

And that's cool! The Lord Have Mercy book is an awe-inspiring achievement of interconnected threads. The world has about 100 problems for players to solve, about 100 NPCs with their own agendas, and about 100 locations which contain little clue fragments that encourage you to visit other problems, NPCs and locations. I'd love to see a visualisation of the plotthreads of this book. I suspect they'd look like the roots of a tree.

Again, I'm aware that I'm making this book sound great. And it is great! In writing this blog post I'm hoping that hundreds of members of the Quinns Quest community will realise that "Oh my god, this game was made for me!" And that I'll be able to hear you talking about your campaigns in the comments or the Discord.

But if I had to summarise why I'm not excited about running a campaign of it, it's that while I feel that other TTRPGs place a focus on the story you're enjoying or the individual scene you're in, Lord Have Mercy is all about the struggle.

You see, the nature of an open world that telescopes as much as this is that for the first god-knows-how-many-sessions of LHM it seems like your players are going to be taking on NPC quests that they don't know how to solve (yet), meeting NPCs that talk obliquely about things you won't understand (until - oh my god! - you do), encountering monsters that just fuckin' merc you (until you learn to avoid them, or manipulate them, because LHM loves a monster that has boutique desires who wants to talk to you first) and so on.

And here's the thing- I suspect some of my players would enjoy this struggle, and running their characters across the Plaguescape like they're running their fingers over a Rubik's Cube, working it over and over until it begins to yield to them. I also suspect (with slightly more hesitancy) that those same players would enjoy engaging with Doomsong's ruleset that, while interesting, does seem very excited to give players a black eye as often as it does a success.

But I can't be sure. And I become especially uncertain when you consider that they wouldn't be playing Lord Have Mercy in a vacuum, they'd be comparing it to all of the more immediately-entertaining TTRPGs that we play. And the other thing is that in order to find out if I'm wrong, in order to give this campaign a fair shake, we're talking about me reading a good chunk of the 650 pages represented by the campaign and the core book.

So for now, I'm writing this blog post instead. All 3,262 words of it. Rest assured though, if I'd actually played this game I could have written three times as much. It's really something special.

If I can't get it to the table to find out how special, I sincerely hope that some of you folks can do it for me.

In the words of Lord Have Mercy: Go with grace, beneath His foetid glory.

Tell me what you find.

-- Quinns

Files

Comments

Lisa H

DOOMSONG YAY I'm so glad to see more people talking about it

Marshall Rich

The Lords Have Mercy Campaign seems to be like the dnd adventure Curse of Strahd that someone added all of the reddit fan-made content for, but with plague god instead of a dracula. Probably very neat.

Alex

I've started running this as a Guildmarches (Westmarches), and so far the players have had a great time. I've been running LHM, and despite the long term goals of this book. I think even the single session being contained as they were ended up being super engaging. It's impressive how well this book can sort of run itself as players explore and follow leads. The players definitely feel as if they're stepping into a living world as opposed to having the world move around them. Its also been very fun to run, as it's so difficult to plan ahead (in a good way) as it's not clear where the players will go so keeps it exciting for me to see where it goes next and luckily the book is formatted perfectly for this.

moss_x

Dammit Quinns, not again with this. I haven't even managed to run the Impossible Landscapes adventure yet (although I've got plans to this fall after wrapping a long running Blades campaign), plus Mythic Bastionland which I've frankly become a bit obsessed with but have no idea when I'll find the time to run it. and now you give me yet another adventure book to add to the queue, seems right up my alley but come on! I'm tempted to start a 2nd play group so I can run campaigns twice a week but I've got no idea where I'd find the time, plus I'd love to play in more campaigns that other friends are planning on running. The burdens of a TTRPG player, I suppose - learning the system and coming up with a plotline is only half the battle, the other half is wrangling 3-5 adults with busy schedules haha

Timothy Story

AHA ! For once a game I already bought (at UKGE) ! I have a first session of LHM planned this Friday and I really can't wait !

Ennis Jackson

Damn three "like so much/many"s in one post -- the record holder? (affectionate)

George Poles

Okay, okay - I already owned Impossible Landscapes before the QQ review and I backed Mythic Bastionland’s crowdfunder, so that means I *have* to buy this, even if my wallet is lying flat on its face in the dirt, exhausted and begging to be left alone to die?

Echo Tango

This game has some pretty cool vibes - sort of like a TTRPG version of the videogame Blasphemous. :)

Steffen Fitz

I get the vibes that the next rpgs will be short campaign focused books, after the preference i see from quince. . i love one shot games those are my cup of tea.

Lojaan

I have thought for a while that high mortality games like Shadowdark and Mothership could be better if the PCs characters were the heads of an organisation, rather than the grunts that go out and do the work. Kinda like Band of Blades. This looks good but probably too bleak for me. Still I'll check it out if it ever comes to Oz

Matt Elder

There’s a lot of relevant Curse of Strahd comparisons that can be made here I think. And crucially, to add to the list of challenges for something both sprawling and hateful towards the PCs, the biggest lesson I took from running Strahd, particularly with relatively new players, was that role playing is often much more fun when the characters know things about the world, when they can think oh maybe in my home town I could talk to X person, or I’ve been here before I remember Y. When they’ve got no handholds and they have to solve the problem of the whole place it becomes even more daunting. And yes probably some level of alienation or estrangement is part of the point of the campaign, but as you point out Quinns, when there are other games one could play, it’s a serious question of whether that feeling and experience is more desirable than other options. Especially for such a sustained period of time. We couldn’t maybe play once a month (all got kids etc) and so we played Strahd for 3 years. For your socialising event that is only so often, to choose to sit in the alienation and brutality for that long is hard.

Mark Mitchell

I'm about 10 sessions into running a campaign of this for friends, and it's some of the most fun we've had at the table. We're coming mostly from story games, for what that's worth, and have bounced off some OSR stuff, which my group has found a bit narratively aimless. I'd just say that if this is of any interest, I'd encourage you to try it. Quinns' idea of how it might actually play is very far from our experience of it . We're playing in a sort of Guild Marches style, where my players give me a heads up of where they'd like to travel next session, and that gives me some time to prepare the location, add in some flavour, clarify threads and make connections to what they've already discovered, think about pacing. And importantly, consider how to make that one session exciting and immediate. It doesn't feel like a struggle at all. It feels like lots of great mini stories/adventures in an interconnected world. Every session is fun, but the idea of a great mystery happening in the world that they're gradually solving, as they move closer to the climax, has kept my players invested in a way I haven't seen before. They speculate on the Discord server, they debate about which leads to follow. YMMV of course, but to us the game's been magic. Also a shoutout to the calendar system mentioned by Quinns. There's info for every day of the year, and you can use it to paint a picture of a dynamic world. What's the weather? Is the river that runs through the Plaguescape frozen at this time of year? What does the moon look like? Is it one of the characters' birthdays? Every session I look at the upcoming week and integrate this info into their journeys. There's a bit to prep if you run the game in this way, but it's so much fun.

flyaturtle

A mini 2-3 session playthrough could be interesting from a review perspective. Would love one of this or Teeth!

Argonautica

It seemed that everything he described makes this campaign need a decent number of sessions to explore, understand, and then interact with the worlds terms

Quinns Quest

Yeah. I do think flyaturtle is right too, though, that a little 3 session taster would answer a lot of my questions

Quinns Quest

Amazing! Thank you for posting, that's given me a strong nudge off the fence

finlay robertson

I think maybe there is a "to" missing from the text on laceworkers Quinns

finlay robertson

Awesome post Quinns, you both simultaneously give me the desire to own it (and hold it covetously in my sweaty mits while eyeing up all my friends like the snide goblin of a GM I know I sometimes become) and also be weary of it as one of those games I may never find a group that fits for it's style and stamina of play requires.

Jesse Larson

There’s a decently sized free demo on the Itch.io page that includes lifepath character generation and a full adventure pulled (maybe we should say “excised”?) from the campaign book. Anyone wanting to run 2-3 sessions could do so for free using that. I definitely want to try it.

Jesse Larson

I backed Dolmenwood at the physical tier, got the PDFs, and ended up feeling similar to Quinns. Despite its beauty and the amount of loving detail, it doesn’t jump off the page for me. I’m not an experienced OSR GM, and I know many people will have fantastic adventures with it, but it didn’t click for me or my players in our four sessions. For me, it isn’t immediately gameable. I’m going to sell the books as soon as I get them. I don’t love inflicting horrible wounds and diseases on my group’s PCs, but my players like it, so I’m coming around. Also, the guild concept is perfect and should be used for lots of high lethality games; and if character creation is fun, it takes some of the sting out of losing a character. I’m going to show Doomsong to my group and see if they’re interested. Plus I’m a big fan of Gary Chalk’s art - his work on the Lone Wolf adventure books is a formative part of my imagination - and this is art is giving similar legit classic grotty English line work vibes. I want to read Doomsong, regardless of whether I run it.

Nicholas Caldwell

But Uncle Quinns, I was going into Tosche Station to pick up Mythic Bastionland!

Paul Pickering

I've never been quite able to put my finger on why Morkborg never quite appealed to me but Quinns really hits the nail on the head, there is something just a little bit one-note about it for me. This may be a great read the PDF and nick some ideas book for me, thank you for highlighting - hadn't heard of it at all!

Edward Gurney

I picked this up at UKGE on vibes alone because it is my exact jam. I read it cover to cover and had exactly the described experience "This seems really cool but what do I /do/ with it?" The cosmology is a fun riff on gnostic Christianity/kabbalah, with some strong cultist simulator/Magnus Archives vibes, and I really like the way the magic classes work, and the combat looks interesting, but what does a game actually look like? I didn't want to spend another £50 on the campaign on the day, but maybe I'll pick it up in future.

Zhed

I bought this after reading this post and something that I think didn't get enough attention is how *gorgeous* these products are! Each book has an embossed cover, spine, and back cover. They both have two bookmark ribbons. On the inside back cover, there's a little pocket built into the book that's just big enough to hold one of the game's character sheets (which fold up in a cute way to show you only what you need to know during different times of the game). They arrived bound in wrapping paper that has the music for the Doomsong printed on it, and sealed with a wax seal into which the Doom Coin was pressed. The paper is satisfyingly matte to the touch. Everything about the product design makes them just satisfying artifacts to hold and appreciate. I wish all books were made with this much love!

Todd Christiansen

oh it all sounds delightfully dreadful. The "guild is the main character" thing is brilliant. very Darkest Dungeon. Character sheets are a resource that can be replenished! sounds like a never-ending DCC funnel.

Chips

Doomsong looks really interesting, but i'm not sure I would enjoy reading 350 pages of bleakness right now, as delightfully crafted it seems to be. i actually got the "Oh this looks like the right thing for me" moment while watching the Mythic Bastionland review, and I'm considering buying a physical copy of the book. There's little chance I'll ever run it unless I can manage to do it solitary, but everything from its sharp ruleset to its gorgeous art style call to me like no other RPG you've talked about.

Samuel Fradette

You had me at the Doomcoin, but kept on reading. Great review, and this product looks too good not to support! Thank you!

The Dork Lord

When you'd first mentioned Doomsong in one of your posts I thought it sounded interesting and looked into it. The premise, art and especially the character creation sold me enough to pick up the PDF even though I knew I likely wouldn't be able to run it with my players. I feel almost exactly the way you do -although I haven't picked up Lord Have Mercy. I am so curious to how the combat system actually plays out, I love the idea of the doomcoin and the creatures and setting feel so we'll grounded in a way I love. However similarly I don't know how my players would mesh with the system. As much I love character deaths and the idea of running the guild as opposed to just a party I doubt my players would feel the same. My players like to have an interesting party dynamic through characters who's personalities arise somewhat emergently, and even partial TPKs can make continuing a campaign difficult. Now maybe Doomsong's framing would help address that issue... Maybe. Anyway, loved reading your thoughts as always!

Mitch Schiwal

I am just starting out running this as a Play by Post on discord. Caesar Ink were great enough to post content warnings for the main game and lord have mercy so I was able to just, show those to the players and go what here needs adjusting, what needs veiled. Love to have specific lists for this. The thing I did to get my players in the headspace for changing characters was to have them roll up 2 characters and choose either to start (Let's call those A and B). This gives them the opportunity to have some choice when they start, but if they chose A, they still keep B in their backup pile. Meaning they have the opportunity to think about the character or even RP as them a bit back at Guild to introduce them early. Then when character A dies, they get to make a new character, C, and choose between B & C to play as, but we always are keeping a similar level of supporting cast waiting in the wings. I don't know how well it will work out in play, but I think it has been a useful tool for keeping my players' minds elastic to the idea they may have to hot-swap their PC at any time.

Brian Stoffer

Okay. I'm ready to buy. $180 US dollars...? Urrrk. Okay okay... sorry, credit card...

Brian Stoffer

Okay... for what it's worth, I bought these (expensive) books... and they are absolutely the most beautiful books I've owned. The ideas in them are—how to say—ambitious, yet eloquently described and illustrated. And... I can see why Quinns says he'll probably never run it. I hope he does... or someone does, and writes it up. The material here is truly one of a kind. They've definitely made me curious for the third book, which I am inevitably going to acquire. I own dozens of very fine TTRPG books. These are at the top of the pile. I, too, will likely never run this game, but by the gods, I cherish every page. For what it's worth, the third book was kickstarted to only about 45k Euros, which is insane given the quality and depth here. I just bid into a TTRPG about witches running a cafe that scored 1.3mil Euros. What is happening here? The Lord Have Mercy Upon Us earned 25k Euros, for crying out loud! 235 backers! People... buy these books... play it. For me!

Auburnt Amaranth

rereading this for deciding if i get it on an offer. you know what, maybe u can collab with someone else that can play and review stuff too in between episodes/season could be nifty. (creating another payload is difficult, so just someone too interesting to not take the chance highlighting stuff i guess :D )

Aaron White

This text review is enough for me, and I thank you for it, but the broader world needs to learn of this gem beyond your Patreon- its' woefully undercovered I understand the significant published campaign is more of a sandbox experience, but two thoughts: - you do run RPGs that you don't use published modules for - Stonetop seems.... even less structured? Anyway, appreciated the write up enough that I bought this a while ago and have been so so happy. Looking forward to S3