Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

883 - History Doesn’t Repeat Itself…But It Slimes (11/7/24) (Patreon)

Published:
2024-11-08 05:34:04
Edited:
2024-11-08 18:51:17
Imported:
2026-06

Downloads

Content

We have always lived in The Zone. We take in the stunning re-election of Donald Trump, the manifest failure of Kamala Harris, Joe Biden and the entire Democratic party, and all of the myriad obungles that have brought us to this moment. This has happened before, it will happen again…Reasons to be scared, reasons for hope, and assurance that we’re still ready to ride with you all every day.

Files

Comments

Raoul Duke

The Zone reminds me I should reread Gravity’s Rainbow🌈

Kainien Morel

"And in Taipei, a D.P.P. lawmaker got their wings."

Travis

slime me boys

CJ

This is super embarrassing to say but here it goes: I needed this.

JD Nonce

*Kamala voice* ‘We did it Joeeee we live in The Zone again!!’

Charlie

never need matt more than now 😢

Steph

Finally!

tanmantincan

I’ve never been more ready to listen to a chapo episode before now

Travis

Felix begins speaking at 0:02 seconds btw

Yutawq

Joe Biden is still my President

Goonba

I love chapo and gooning

Mac daddy

Let's gooo, Trump Chapo at the very least is never lacking in great material. We did it Joe!

AesopSPV

Good looking out

Semine

I didn't plan on cumming all over myself in public twice today but here we are

Travis

👍

Schwartz666

You stuck with that name forever now, huh? 😉

Jonathan Nathan

I hoped against hope that Felix would do a new version of I May Not Be, and he did!

Equality State Of Mind

Are you doing Vincent Price on Horror Movie Mindset this year or not?

Michael

We’re gonna have a DANG CHEETO in the White House! Again!

Ben H

I need Matt's takes!

Alexander Patterson

Felix starting the ep off in the funniest way possible, real heads know

Joe

In a glaze-haze

Ben H

Where does Biden fit in the hell of presidents tier list?? The people deserve to know!

Žiga Iglič

Great callback to the 2016 post-election cold open!

Uso Dayo

If you don’t define morality as a comparison between the two parties then it was impossible to vote

Evan

Ready to ride into the darkness once more.

Chris Wade

Yes! Our dual election shows screwed up recording schedule but Vincent Price 2 with I believe Theda returning will be out next Wednesday

JD Nonce

Noncing for the next 4-12 years

James

Cold open ❤️

ploob

The slop is hot

Uso Dayo

They should have just let Trump win in 2000. At least that way it would be all over now

Jack

Is this one going out to the public? Pitched the show to a few friends who finally lost faith after Tuesday, they’re awaiting the post election ep

MoldyTolge

Ouroboros Ouroboros Ouroboros

ss027503

God damn it I wish Matt was here.

K H

I don't care enough to look it up. Chat, is it true Trump had fewer votes than last time and KKKamala Holocaust Harrison had 14 MILLION fewer votes than Joe? If so, yea I think they definitely fucked themselves by refusing to back up on Israel. For sure they lost Michigan for that. I actually heard a guy(Owen something, sorry dude) interview Trumpers in Michigan and it made me think Harris would win because the Trumpers were so totally incoherent. Like they themselves couldn't tell if they were being ironic. Some did seem like Russian bots, except they were also pro NATO....which was baffling. Truly the stupidest people on the planet and perhaps soon the only ones dumb enough to actually vote for president. I still voted, but once again the presidential bubble could have just been a drawing of a penis for all its weight. Local elections still have some impact, but I did appreciate the gerrymandering I observed that crammed a massive section of the city population into one district, and split the suburbs into like 5. 0 wait time vs 4 hour wait times. I honestly hope local elections allow some amelioration otherwise we just need to burn this shit down, and that is way harder on my back.

K H

Soothing.

Waffle Poet

Mr. Piker has spent the entire day providing some of the best material analysis of the liberal cascade failure one could ask for, all while firing on all six dirtbag cylinders. He does this every day, but his stream today was an incredible autopsy of the entire liberal establishment from the DNC to the media and beyond. He put on one hell of a stream today.

tapwaterskeptic

Year eight of "I may not be dale earnheardt" ringing through my brain like a gong.

Uso Dayo

Trump called Bolton an idiot and it was awesome. Nobody Democrat could to that and it’s objective fact

Equality State Of Mind

There's a lot more votes left to count I think. It's usually a week to 100% reporting. Kamala still ate it, but...

interzoa

I appreciate episodes where Chris is on the mic. Also, when I think what would Matt say I think about his last few vlogs where he talks about how the liberal subjectivity is desperate to destroy itself. The two parties complement each other toward this road

Tim

Kamala is definitely going to underperform Biden. Cali only has 59% reporting. I don’t think it will be 14 million, but it could very well be around 10 million. Trump will likely break just about even with his 2020 totals.

Matt

One of the best Felix openings ever. Takes me back to the heady days of 2016 chapo

K H

Thanks.

Rusty

Once more into the fray, folks.

Cormac

Pointing the finger at Harris, when so many millions voluntarily voted for a corrupt fascist, is quite the angle.

Garth Hillsborough

Maybe it's because Harris lost millions of votes from last time, dumbfuck

Naked Shitter

Ah, now I remember why I started listening to this show.

Claire Meyer

did the country swing to the right or did more of the left leaning people not vote? I think probably the second

Schwartz666

Slop is BCE, Slime is CE... a new era hath begun.

Jacobi Jefferson

Chapo renaissance starts now, we are so back

Alex C

I may not be Hilary clinton, bit I both love and don't understand this joke format

Will

That seems to be what happened

Jesse Svetlich

You’re right, it’s beyond the pale to expect a candidate to blink or have a pulse

Elliot Matheny

Oh shit, Felix name dropping Richard Virguerie again. I live in Virginia and have met the guy, absolutely fascinating right winger. He calls himself “003” alla James Bond, as by his calculations he is the 3rd longest active Republican operative in the country.

Elliot Matheny

Hit me up if you want some Dick Vig anecdotes 😎

plainwrap

I'm sure it's maybe 0.01% responsible for this result but I must remind everyone that Biden's first act as president-elect back in 2020 was to rip us all off for $600 of the $2000 stimulus money he campaigned on. Just treating us all like suckers from the jump was the first nail in this coffin.

Mr Butterfield

“We resolve our differences at the battle box.” - Joe Cool

Well aged meme

if one of you fucking losers doesn't at least try to run in 4 years I'm never voting again.

Schwartz666

3rd mic Wade rocks! 🤘🏻

Mayor McCheese

CRINGE POST INCOMING but I think it's an important one to make: There is absolutely going to be another election in four years in spite of what panicking shitlibs are saying. The Democratic Party has one goal now: "How can we come back from this without making ANY changes to what we do and who we are." They need to be abandoned by as many voters as possible, but more importantly, a new party needs to be adopted by those voters. I suggest that everyone should join The Green Party ansd start pressuring them to remove Stein and elect a leader that alligns with your values...or you can stay with the Democrats and put all of your hopes on AOC. This will likely end the same way as it did with Jeremy Corbyn in the UK: The Democratic leaders and heavy hitters will work with CNN, MSNBC, The Atlantic, The NYT and Fox News and will organise a sabotage of her two campaign runs and throw the contests. You probably need to decide what you're going to do sooner rather than later.

Isaac Suárez

I think Gaza accentuated the weaknesses of Biden’s policies and Harris’s candidacy. Biden has been humiliated for months by Netanyahu- and he’s looked weak and incompetent while doing it. It alienated younger and minority voters, already weak points of the Biden admin- and undercut Biden’s claim to being a “stabilizing” leader, Harris’s refusal to distance herself from this policy made it very hard for her to distance herself from Biden. As one of the most publicized of Biden’s wars, her embrace of this policy made her look like a continuity candidate. She also looked like a fool leaning on the “I feel your pain” platitudes (much like a manager who’s about to fire you.) So, even if Gaza wasn’t decisive, it made Harris and Biden’s weaknesses very hard to ignore. The Republicans could just point to these weaknesses and attack them as “Palestinians”- allowing them to have their cake and eat it to.

Chapo Bath House

He was the first president with two black best friends :(

Greg Stelmach

agreed - quite a few people i would like to send this to

Cormac

Incredible that you're not able to ask yourself why that happened

Shane-A112

you know shit is wild when there's a cold open

Cormac

Ah, so it's Trump's throbbing pulse you're into?

Tim

Democrats were determined to test the limitation of negative partisanship and boy did they.

Andrew Carmichael

I saw 14 million fewer votes and I thought, hmmm, maybe the Dems DID steal the last election. Good on em. Except they then squandered their opportunity while they had it. Fuck em.

triplevalaska

If that's what you want to think. I'm sure 20 million America's just cared so much about gaza

Claire Meyer

it's not just Gaza. it's salaries not increasing, every public space being privatized, less protections at work, decaying infrastructure. no real national action to protect abortion, a horrible healthcare system, etc

Stephen

Sometimes you gotta square the circle and triangulate in order to bring the two halves of the whole together forever so that they can be greater than the sum of their parts 🤣🤣🤣

Claire Meyer

how do you explain the lower voter turnout for both parties? some of the republican voters i imagine went over to the democrats since they are basically the republican party of like 10 years ago.

simon

Netanyahu is saying there were extremely violent actions against a Tel Aviv soccer club in Amsterdam yesterday and he's sending airplanes to evacuate Israelis (lol). I don't doubt there was violence with multiple groups of hooligans but the only footage I've seen is a bunch of Israelis absolutely beating and kicking the shit out of an Amsterdam cab driver.

K H

I guess it will be another month or so before they tally everything and get some better demographic data state by state. Depending on how bad youth turn out was I think will be telling as to what exactly did her in. Because presumably she should have outperformed Joe just from population increase. I really hope the narrative is that the anti holocaust left made them lose. Because we will have supposedly done it twice now. Mfers better get their minds right and get in line next time they vote...because we'll do it again old man.

Schwartz666

Wish I could get my Dad to listen to this ep.. He is so focused on hating Trump, he can't see the forest for the trees when it comes to the Dems. 😒

K H

Huvuhbuhvudaaaaaa!

K H

Tell your boy joey get ma fuckin money.

K H

Absolutely.

Dick Must Bust

Love that Chris is still bringing up AUKUS when ever he can lmao

m@tt

Mom…I wanna vape

K H

This was pretty good. Felix dropping obscure names of what I assume are sickos like they're common knowledge, referencing Matt's rambling. good shit. Good slop. Hungee

NYCM&AHole

AOCIA is as reliable as Liz Warren.

K H

Steaming. Sorry. Slimy.

Dick Must Bust

Lol yeah I can’t believe spitting in the face of Muslim-Americans, pandering to Liz Cheney (who celebrated the overturning of Roe v Wade), and aping Republican immigration policy turned out to be a losing strategy.

K H

Huvubuduva 🫡

Cormac

Pretty great false equivalency brah

Cole

Good shit you guys should probably unlock this one

K H

Vote GOAT. God damn. I wish I voted so I could use that.

Ardy Rezv

Chapo was better during the Trump era. You guys have been lost since Bernie cucked out. The show might have a direction again! Maybe we can rehabilitate Virgil?

Ardy Rezv

Even the Chapos admit she sucks now. Listen to the episode where Ryan is trying to hawk his crappy book. Their audience is still slightly to shitlib to see through it. Maybe give them more time

Ardy Rezv

They are shitlibs too cool for pod save. Need to watch msnbc and get it over with. They can gentle parent them through this

Ardy Rezv

Is this what the kids call cope?

Uso Dayo

I keep getting this wrong. I definitely meant 2020

Ardy Rezv

Watching him and Josh dumbfounded by the results will never not be funny. Guess the champagne socialist was wrong. Glad he’s providing the young dumb libs with anti Zionist info though. Same way Jimmy Dore debunks it for right wingers so credit where it’s due

Ardy Rezv

You meant 2020. All good

Uso Dayo

Will, what do you mean ONLY three people?!!!

plainwrap

Shout out to the ten million Democratic voters who did exactly what they've been threatening to do and no-showed on Election Day. A political middle finger so big it can be seen from space.

Uso Dayo

I finally got it right. I need a nap

Dan J Johnston

Nice democracy you have there, where oligarchs have all the tools to win whenever they like, but if they're too embarrassed they might let the Democrats play pretend for 4 years until they need a tax cut revalidated. At this point, it's probably time to just lube up your assholes at 4 yearly intervals..

Ardy Rezv

Muller she wrote is going to be fire whenever they drop the ep!

Mayor McCheese

Well, then you know what to do alternatively.

Uso Dayo

It will be even funnier if Trump dies sometime in the next two weeks

Ranni

Grow up

Ranni

It will probably get unlocked if enough people ask nicely

Uso Dayo

I think they mean Amber

ancrapistan

Poppy actually got almost 54% in ‘88

Ardy Rezv

Naw my sweet boy Virgil. Amber is still working on a book whose title is from 2015 apparently

HamDrawn

We got a classic episode on our hands here

David Beare

I'm of this mind as well. I found his decision to linger in the race while everyone knew he could not possibly run to have been communicated in an extremely condescending manner. I don't give a fuck that a corpse is eating ice cream, fucking forgive student debt like you promised. They might as well have started jiggling some car keys around maybe that would have driven engagement more.

spencer toth

I was saying latinx the whole Bernie 2020 campaign, we still won that vote somehow...

Matt James Rich

Not smart to call bluffs, if so much is at stake.

THEKILLERWHALE

Yeah, if there is one great let down of the Biden presidency, it is how damn unfunny it was. He had his moments, but they largely shied away from the press and the supporting cast was too disciplined to be really comedic.

Ashley Naftule

Real talk: I never forgot that shit. Felt emblematic of the DNC’s whole deal—break a promise that will alienate your base for no discernible good reason beyond making conservatives like you (they will never like you). Drove me insane seeing libs trying to justify Biden backtracking that money rather than acknowledging it was incredibly bad politics.

Khemith

Free my boy.

Redmos78

Democratic party ran in 2020 Georgia Senate run off promise $2,000 stimulus and gave $1,400, while Trump gave them $1,800. Explaining this is why you lost. Leave the Trans Kids alone. Free Palestine.

Ardy Rezv

We’re going to find Bigfoot before Virgil

Redmos78

I changed to Non-Affliated voter in Pa and had listened to "Try Again". This was the most Right wing conservative campagin so do not care what they will say.

Robert Connor

I think he means Virgil Abloh the DJ who worked with Kanye - R.I.P

Redmos78

I can see all the Joy and Fun in Trump.-True Fuck Trump- True

Oh yea

Unlock!❤️

THEKILLERWHALE

Gaza does not rate highly in the eyes of voters. Probably true. But I think it does rate highly in the eyes of non-voters and they are the real difference in this election.

Special Adeline

29:21 "I did everything right, and they dethroned me!"

Joe Quigley

You mean Alexsis Texas' son?

THEKILLERWHALE

And the blame game against sexist minorities kills me. You know they just elected a woman in Mexico right? I know that these are not the same people but there is a degree of cultural continuity between Mexico and recent Mexican immigrants so this has to fall flat for a big portion of what the democrats refer to, dubiously, as the latin bloc.

George Mitri

If you guys could unlock this ep, it’d be great to share around. 👍🏻

IronNosy

Very cathartic episode here gents. Thankyou.

Frank

Adding my voice to the ones saying unlock this-- let the free piggies have their slop boys!

Matthew

Chris always raises the bar when he contributes to analysis episodes 👏👏👏

William

This was as big of a blowout as 2022 was

William

No it won’t- president Vance would be terrible. Vibes wise, Biden dying and Kamala being sworn in for a month is way better because it would also cause the republicans to have to reprint all the “#47” shit they’ve been making

William

Yeah, but, AOC has some big titties, so, you know, let’s hear her out

William

Harris is also a corrupt fascist? Like, do you know what she did as prosecutor

William

Dems want an electorate that only works with gerrymandering

Kinetics Video

If there's one story where Israelis did something vile and violent and another version where they didn't and were attacked for no reason you know which one to believe.

AMS700 Repo Squad

Dems treat voting for them like a plenary indulgence. The only way to save your soul is to vote for them. Stopped working for another group of rich molesters a while ago too

Kinetics Video

One thing that makes me think a third Party emerging might finally be a real possibility is how high Stein was able to rack up Dearborn. Granted that is just the one city, but if you think about it more and more people are (regrettably) going to be having direct encounters with imperialist violence. If Dearborn could blow out for the Greens in response to that, maybe other places can to.

Mountain Dew Or Crab Juice

Never been more convinced the Democrats are just controlled opposition. Promise something, promise anything, and the people flock to vote for them. We saw it with Obama, with Bernie, even to a smaller extent when they did give it to Biden and the campaign was promising to build at least somewhat of a bulwark against the Republicans. They didn't even have to be honest, politicians lie so much it's a trope, it's an accepted fact of the system and is part of why everyone hates this fucking country. Just lie about it. We'll never know how much it would have changed anything, but she could have said the words Arms Embargo, and then immediately called Netenyahu and wired him 50 Billion; but the party couldn't even make the effort of lying to people. If this was an earnest effort to win an election these people are hopeless, and should be running on giant hamster wheels to power the AI image generators that are going to be providing all our news coverage for the next decade.

Kinetics Video

Oh my God, the libs have been fucking rabid with making excuses this whole time. Just every fucking step piling in with the most transparent horseshit, my God

J Morse

nah you were cooking cogent trump handling 911 would have been a work of art

William

I agree with Tom sexton on David shore - it’s time to get out the ceremonial white robes and the tanto blade buddy. Your have brought great shame and disgrace upon your line

Kinetics Video

Hey, if this guy wants to help pay for content that obviously we understand and get anything from and he doesn't I say let him

Kinetics Video

It's the Cheeto House, he just let them have it for a while

fran

Unlock the episode!!

Kinetics Video

The only time you could feel anything was when Gaza started happening and uh, chuckles were not the vibe

Kinetics Video

Still time to stop the steal, Joe! You didn't concede

Kinetics Video

Sometimes you have a hole that only slop can fill

Seph

Episodes like these make me really miss Matt. His analysis and dissection of shit like this is always so spot on and accurate. I’m glad Chris is here to hold the torch for him.

Karl Childers

so biden is the most pro-labor president of our lifetimes but also bernie sanders says that he abandoned the working class -- which fucking one is it? why would anyone ever listen to sanders again? fuck this whole fake loser party

Kyle

Please make this one free

Tim O'

[Bernie voice] I am calling on the hosts of the Chapo Trap House podcast to release this episode for free, to give slop to all of the hardworking Americans who deserve it, not just the Patreon-percenters!

William

Chris is Matt’s Süssmayr; real heads know

Yairo Martis

Felix's epitaph for Kamala is a thing of beauty.

Laura

Felix opening with a callback to the Dale Earnhardt joke was perfection

Robert Aitken

last I checked he’s on track to end up with less votes than he got in 2020. so yes, the blame is absolutely on the dems for fucking it

Spence Lee

Trump is Netanyahu’s preferred candidate, and a rapist. Bibi is happier today because Trump won than he was yesterday. Just remember that.

Blank

“Key to Matt’s theory of history is this thing called contingency.” Ngl, that’s like saying “key to my theory of biology is this thing called evolution.”

Robert Aitken

seems like a lot of people got it

Tate Adams

Damn Matt's voice was sorely missed during this campaign season

Mountain Dew Or Crab Juice

Biden is the most pro-labor president of our lifetime, it's just that every other president drinks the blood of the working man to survive so the bar is underground

revolverbunny

I mean, they expected you to vote for a dessicated, barely animated corpse and then folded and replaced him with a giggly cop who agreed with slapping college kids around. Surely many people just didn't like their intelligence insulted by the so called good guys?

Kirk Lazarus

Flow My Slop, The Christman Said

B

It is both. Its just too little, too late. Plus the working class has been co-opted into virtue signaling for the rich because any sense of class consciousness has been beaten out of them by Democrats’ apathy towards them.

J Lit

Hate to be a pedant but turnout is going to be about on par with 2020

Doug Cartel

Not only did both the voting rights act and roe v wade get gutted under the watch of the democrats, but the dems didnt even use them for campaign talking points. They still expected ROEVEMBER though.

Thomas Stevens

This election was a blowout for sure but if you look at the popular vote margin dems lost swing states by about a point compared to 3-4 points elsewhere. Their one path to victory was winning the electoral college while losing the popular vote.

Jake Creighton

I miss this chapo, there’s emotion, there’s a spark, they care.

Arno Noack

peng dehuai the or some of the other early party targets during the cultural revolution probably take the title over Trump for the most yelled at man in history just due to the size of the Chinese population, but your point still stands

Yacobum

Should Bernie have forgone any influence in order to maintain a credible record for us on the left? That seems like a pie in the sky, futile strategy. He has attempted to mitigate harm where able and call out the Democratic Party for being terrible when the opportunity to mitigate harm runs out.

Natalie

i knew trump was going to win because since Matt had his stroke, the series of world events that has followed has been so wild it's like God/"God" knows he isn't on the show, and trump winning is like the capstone to the year without Matt just becoming progressively more insane

Karl Childers

look i understand what you're saying but this (from sanders) is exactly the kind of technically-correct well-actually smug duplicity which just cost the democratic party an eight-figure number of voters. it's the rhetorical equivalent of a sibling saying "i'm not touching you" with their finger an inch from your face. no one wants to fucking hear this shit from these people anymore.

Greasy_Jones

i'm sure the people of palestine would prefer the bombs be dropped on them by a cackling xanax addict

Doug Cartel

If you listen to conservatives and libertarians, democrats stole 2020 and activated the shooters that tried to kill trump, and yet, they're not so evil as to, idk, overturn a loss this big. Dumbest people alive

Franklin Shepard Inc.

Dr. Jill's Money: Or how I learned to draw a salary after the loss

Uso Dayo

Damn the electorate for letting the Democrats down every time

HawkandQuail

It’s wild how cooked and awful this podcast has been this year. Hessa and Adam have been the only bright spots.

Thomas Stevens

At some point you have to stand for your principles or you never had any. Debasing yourself for zero gain is something that should lose people’s respect. He accomplished nothing.

Daniel

they need a third so bad. Hesse and Adam episodes show how much smoother everything goes with an extra voice in the room.

Cormac

Wonderful false equivalency

th

??? kamala is down 12 million votes from where biden was and trump sitting around 100k fewer, was there some secret third party that grabbed 10 percent of turnout

Cormac

Oh rest assured, I finally canceled today. Guy.

th

1million, not 100k, oopies !

Karl Childers

bernie's strategy was bad both in moral terms and in its result, he threw away all claim to be better than these genocidal monsters by defending them and they lost by an extroardinary margin anyway. he sold his soul for NOTHING

Yacobum

Souls are made up, he sold nothing.

Dylan

We’re back in the zone now

JoJo Sliwa

Chris should jump in these convos more. He always adds valuetainment™️

Podcast subscriber 78

Chris is the first person to pronounce the name Kamala correctly on this podcast. “No, please don’t.” 😆 After the loss, that’s some real drumpf-level commitment.

WizLizGiz

Stunning huh? Just the description lets you know Chapo been slipping a bit. Is this election the shot they need to reactivate or will they be drowned in the slime of the new emperor king? Stay tuned folks! The Zone 2: Enter the Zonening

PitMommy

When it’s all said and done Trump will probably have as many or more votes than he did in 2020. Will and Chris are going off the number from election night. No doubt still a turnout collapse for dems.

Ardy Rezv

Welcome my brother. We’ve been waiting for you

Sam Bondurant

Adam’s terrible. If we can’t get Matt back soon-ish take Virgil off the IR.

Ardy Rezv

Bernie and aoc should be dead to any real leftist

Ardy Rezv

Yeah Biden and Harris did genocide but Trump is going to do super genocide lmfao

Matt T

Liked hearing Felix say “Lah-tine x” five times.

William Hubel

I have a friend in Arizona who voted for Trump and for abortion access on the ballot initiative. He got everything he wanted, when the democrats were offering him nothing

Ardy Rezv

Yup he has no principles. If he did, he would’ve run independent in 2016, but his only goal was not to be remembered like Ralph Nader. He’s beyond a pussy. Told his voters not to show up to Michigan in 2020 because of Covid, but Biden told them to go vote. His job is to sheep dog well meaning morons back into the Democratic Party while sounding like he’s fighting for the working class

J

No see they did try but they failed because they’re a bunch of dumb [insert racial and sexual slurs]

Vincent W Troia

they’re talking about aoc like she’s relevant to voters or reasons for voting or not voting

Elliot Matheny

Okay, one of his absolute favorite things to talk about is a poem for children, “The Purple Cow” by Frank Burgess. “I never saw a Purple Cow, I never hope to see one, But I can tell you, anyhow, I’d rather see than be one!“ - Virguerie sees being a purple cow as a marker of anomalous exceptional talent, someone who draws eyeballs with their stunning unique talent. He of course considers himself a purple cow, and loves giving motivational pep talks in which he urges others to do what it takes to become a purple cow in their field. Can’t stress enough how many times he will bring up The Purple Cow in conversation.

J

I bet they’re still paying Matt his cut and don’t want to dilute their shares any further

Nico

Unlock

Simon Maraya

"mishandelen taxichauffeur" 😭

Marxist-Swoletarianist

Chris for permanent third mic, he did an great job of carrying the torch for Matt

J

Does it? I’m pro-Palestine, but wrt analyzing all this: This country has demonized Arabs forever, especially since 9/11. I’m convinced the biggest single thing was taking the blame for inflation (and maybe some unconscious sexism/racism for flavor)

DS

We are fucked. The left isn't an actual thing. Authoritarianism and stacked courts for four decades is a real thing.

Elliot Matheny

The numbers absolutely show that turnout was wayyy fucking down. Kamala received 12 million less votes than Joe fuckin Brandon. The extent that the American voting electorate shifted to the right is largely on the Democrat side, as they completely conceded to the fascist framing of the border issue, which turned former resistance libs complaining about kids in cages into immigration hawks. Overton Window so far right it might as well be in the Zone of Interest house

Elliot Matheny

Oh I can guarantee you those obscure repubs are sickos

James Weir

Where have you gone Matt Christman? Our nation turns it lonely eyes to you.

Hassan

I was struggling to understand how Trump could possibly have made inroads with the Arab/Muslim community in Michigan but I remember Matt's Cushvlog from right after the 2020 election (11.09.20 if anyone is interested) and it made sense. The dealignment of minority groups (with black americans as an exception to that rule) that he spoke about then is absolutely real. It's times like this where I really miss his voice. Also please unlock so I can send this my normie lib friends who are looking for answers lol.

DS

AOC hasn't done a fucking thing other than talk.

DS

If that's the voteball origins episode that is one of the single greatest pieces of content of all time. I miss you Matt!

Alex “WORLDWIDE” Kellar

“People just watch the tv and do what the tv says” Here in Ohio, I never saw a single Kamala ad on tv at the gym (ESPN, local ABC, daytime/soaps, Fox, etc) during the day, until last week I worked out late and the Stephen Colbert show was on and then there it was: one Kamala Harris ad. THEY SPENT MONEY TO ADVERTISE TO AN AUDIENCE THAT WAS ALREADY GONNA FUCKING VOTE FOR HER. Just a colossal ¢ir¢le jerk, jfc

Hassan

Yes it is! Legendary episode. I'm listening to again now and man its so on point.

Bobby Lasers

The Dems will do what Labour did in he UK. Put someone in charge who just want to be in charge and will do anything (Kier) then put the right of the party in control who will start weeding out all the left elements over the next 4 years.

Emily Richardson

I literally screamed when Chris mentioned boomers selling their homes to black rock.

shrimpgod

Ill gladly help dems clear out the base. I switched to unaffiliated yesterday, happy to help convince others to leave as well 😊

ursie

What’s the outro music?

T

By turnout, do you mean the Navy Seal "turning out" every young man who voted for Kamala?

Char

I NEED to share this with my libs. Give this to the people.

Yacobum

Thats a really silly take in my opinion

Michael

No left wing movement of any significance is going to exist without a stronger more robust labor movement. I think that needs to be the main focus.

thicchatlogan

sometimes she doesn't even do that lol, didn't she let pelosi scold her into abstaining from a vote on sending more weapons and money to israel

DrFunkPhD

In person ep plus Chris is on? Eatin good. Great catharsis ep.

thicchatlogan

if biden and harris actually believed trump would be any worse on palestine than they are then they should've been doing everything they possibly could to end the conflict before the election. sometimes the morally correct move is also the politically expedient one, not everything is this faustian bargain where we have to support a genocide to prevent a hypothetical worse genocide down the road.

c

omg yes ayesha shout out 🖤

Tim

Thanks for the shoutout on my post, Will.

Michael

Donald Trump was the Republican answer to Barack Obama. A charismatic figure who excited a lot of low information low propensity voters who don’t show up in polling and aren’t Republicans. Hence why in a lot of swing states Democrats outran Harris.

Michael Keith

Your point about the Palestinians and Lebanese is right on point. They find a way to go on and we will too. Everything will be fine

Reece Coren

the decision to replace henry wallace with harry truman set the stage for all of this

ab

Gonna say it’s the 2nd thing.

Jason Vogel

One thing is certain; we'll (mostly) all tumble down through the next 2 years and see what dumbass epiphanies the dems will use to take back the house...... maybe. Probably.

ab

On one hand I get it, but boys, AOC and the squad haven’t been relevant for like 5 years. Just let it go 😆

Jason Vogel

Om my fam chat, I mentioned how they shit the bed and my parents are like "I didn't pay attention to the Harris mistakes, I was focused on how evil the Republicans are." Total head in the sand. Should be an interesting Thanksgiving

Josiah

The going right is already happening, some ghoul in the Atlantic was arguing that the ‘ivory tower issue of trans rights’ was the reason dems lost. Just the most head-empty shit

Ian H

I wish I could remember who reported on this, but supposedly she met with Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib before that vote and they essentially told her "vote how how you want, it's fine, just don't fucking cry in public and make us look weak".

Jack

you can download the audio then email the audio

Sam Bondurant

Born and raised in the south so I’m surrounded by conservative family. They’re all the well off, hate Trump type and not a single one voted Biden or Harris. No idea why the DNC thought lifelong republicans would ever vote for them.

S

38:10 simpwy

Kyle Smyth

Miss Matt and his insights as always but thsnk goodness for this show even still. Only ones I've heard so far not immediately falling into the idiotic 'I guess America's just really fascist and hates women!' tripe. But my only contribution is that it's fascinating how utterly siloed American media has become. A good chunk of both sides were relatively sure of their victory going into this, only for it to be this incredibly lopsided result. Every election is like two parallel worlds colliding now. America is final fantasy.

Karl Childers

you're asking "should bernie forego his influence" but the thing is he already did. the only influence he had was with the left wing of the democratic base and that influence is now gone because he has no moral credibility anymore

Lucas

I think it's's fine to acknowledge some of the objectively pro-labor steps his admin took without pretending he's some working class hero. I can't remember who said this first, but I remember hearing the argument that his pro-labor stances aren't due to him being any sort of labor champion, but rather because he's so fucking old that his career in DC predated the neoliberal turn. The man's brain is frozen in 1973 and he thinks the New Deal coalition is still alive

Chris

AOC is going to be the nominee in 2032 when they finish installing her Pelosi neurolink

Justin

Reading his response to the election — which, however terrible he has been lately, is very good — and it's clear he had a very sudden and very rude awakening Tuesday night, realizing that the last four years of his life have been both a moral and practical failure.

Yacobum

His calculation was that he could do more from inside than outside. It's possible that was misguided, but I trust his judgement more than the Chapo guys or any of you. I hope he now attempts to create a labor party, but I doubt he will.

Cody

Bernie “supported” Kamala because he knew that Trump would be worse for the working class than Trump. I support this calculus.

jj hunsecker

curtis mayfield-if theres hell below we’re all gonna go

Justin

"Buck up, ya know. Or at least do not show fear to the most pathetic individuals on the planet." I genuinely found this beautiful and heartening

AbeLinkin

You guys need to unlock this ep

Karl Childers

i wish he had created a labor party, i truly do, but the strategic time for him to do that would have been before he set fire to his own credibility

Matthew Krueger

Watching him this election was incredibly disheartening. The idea that he worked that hard for so little... what would have been so little even if Kamala had won. It would have been better for his legacy if he'd made a point of NOT helping the dems. There's an argument for why he did it, but it remains to be seen if it's one I can believe.

james

That intro really brought back🥹🥹

Tea for the Tillerman

“A tale told by an idiot or a tale told by a Calvinist? Give me the idiot every time.” —26 year old Latino males in Laredo

Jerry Cornelius

Ugh, yeah. By Thomas Chatterton Williams, the dork who wrote that shamelessly sweaty profile of Emily Ratajkowski. You could hear the sound of his fapping when he discovered she’d read one book.

Well aged meme

Felt good to listen to this. Time to get to work.

Tim O'

The election of 1800 didn't have a candidate with an electoral vote majority, so it went to the House, which then had 35 consecutive deadlock votes before picking Thomas Jefferson. This process has been incredibly stupid since the beginning.

Maxwell Harkness

what Dem pundits are craving right now is Dem Starmer. What they don't realize - Kamala ran that campaign and these are the results.

Tim O'

You wouldn't download a car!

Joe Halloran

Dems pretty much avoided the issue altogether. Wtf is the Atlantic talking about?

Matthew Krueger

I'm actually thinking Gaza ends when he gets into office. He's not going to let Bibi make him look weak. The already in place kayfabe is that Bibi knows he has to wrap this up by January, and Biden will continue to help him kill Palestinians at an even greater rate until then - it's the thing they all agree on. After that they won't do anything to mitigate the suffering starvation and disease, but the bombing will stop, and Trump will be able to make the deal between Israel and Saudi Arabia after the "liberal" media spends a couple months convincing us that it's "progress".

Yacobum

Karl outside of this audience, his credibility is stronger than ever.

Justin

I wanna know what their beef was hahah

c

it’s probably so stupid lol

king_von_diesel

Idk, maybe trump is the luckiest man in human history and is handed his own 9/11 a second time in a row.

Matthew Krueger

Karl and Ardy so angry. I get it. I still don't think you can put an equals sign between them. If you think the whole thing needs to burn down that's fine, but if the dems are going to eventually be broken down and hollowed out so that something new is able to form, that had to start somewhere.

Justin

Chris coming in hot with a Sopranos-caliber, context-perfect needle drop at the end. I fucking love that Mayfield track

Jay-Z Pants

Full blown postmodern consumer fascism time >:)

Jason Edmiston

I had to find it. It's Curtis Mayfield. "If There's a Hell Below". The outro doesn't sound like the album mix, though. Still looking.

Michael

Rashida Talib has been trying to fight the good fight as much as she can.

Antipaganda

That would have been amazing. "Okay, folks, we're nuking Saudi Arabia, I told em to do it today, is it happening?" "General? Where's my beautiful general? Come on up here!"

Peanut Horse

Honeslty probably due to dems knowing so much of their own base would sit out and tried to minimize that. Stupid campaign from every angle

Matthew Krueger

^^^I think this is the definitive spelling for me

Reece Coren

yup! almost like the small group of guys all from the same class who designed this system of government didn’t actually design it for the people of the general public

William Beamish

Dems will learn the opposite lesson from this- elections will not save us

William Beamish

ps thank you chapos for this wonderful ep

Dunston Checksin

Can you name one action he used his "influence" to undertake that will have an effect that continues beyond his time in the Biden cabinet?

Antipaganda

I get your point, but you are nuts if you think you can overcome the duopoly in US politics. That is not possible. Instead, you need to hollow the Democrats out and wear them like an Edgar suit. It was done very recently on the other side. You need a left-wing Tea Party. Push the losers out of the DNC, take it over, make it yours. The Greens have no juice, and they are hated by every lib. You need progressive libs in your coalition, and they hate the Greens at a visceral, unchangeable level.

Warbs

Good post mortem. I keep going back to the 2016 flow chart: Is shit broken? No -> Hillary Yes - Who is to blame? - immigrants -> Trump - billionaires-> Bernie

J Lit

The West takes a million years to count votes, Trump's final vote total will be higher than 2020

J Lit

By several million

J Lit

And Kamala beat or matched 2020 numbers in swing states, if not nationally

Michael

I get the LBJ/Biden comparisons, but LBJ at least had voting rights, civil rights and Medicare.

Matthew Krueger

None of that shit matters to anyone in this chat, but it will matter down the road in mainstream medias inevitable bullshit post-mortem. I'm kinda hoping the popular vote difference between them is still greater than the third party tallies. It's much funnier that way.

Tim Mullen

Felix’s opening bit almost triggered a Deja vu level psychosis for chapo old heads

Jcbsides

Love you guys for this one...I can't believe I've been riding out this country's insane politics with you for almost ten years now, but I appreciate that I'll have this show to turn to in the hard times ahead. Thank you!

Chas.

felix cooking

dawood

this was cathartic

Jessica Rios

Omg Matt’s analysis would have been a balm to my soul.

Jessica Rios

I was a Biden voter in 2020 and didn’t vote at all this time. I was one of those that disappeared

George P

Me too, for President at least. We had a bunch of ballot questions here in MA so I voted otherwise I wouldn’t have bothered

S

Voted for Cornel West in VA, unconscionable to me to vote for Harris

Evan

How'd that go?

S

I had fun :)

NYCM&AHole

They’re going to do Get Out with AOC but put Noncey in

Juan Suarez

The one collective myth I'll never understand is why people think 2022 was successful for the Democrats. They lost the speakership!

John Baker

You guys should release this one for free on all the platforms. Good medicine for the libs.

Robert Aitken

I thought that was already every piece in the Atlantic

Daniel

The boys are still cooking with gas. Thankful that this show goes on while so much of the political media continues to be so willfully ignorant and obtuse. This country has so few leaders, or even vocal “personalities” who have a coherent ideology beyond being Enchanted by Mammon that it feels like a blessing to have a show like this which has proven principles and believes in the basic dignity of Life. Marxism is an oasis in the desert of the world-eating Amerikkkan kkkorporate death drive

nahobeeho

No we can't, because we aren't from the future. None of you actually know whether his decision will pay off for him or, more likely given his age, his successors in this movement.

Simon Maraya

This show, and most of you freaks here in the comments, make me feel less alone and crazy. Thank you 💜

Mangomoosh

Thank you! Good things still happen and will. That reminder at the end to not let them know you’re down was nice.

Damen Irving

I’m weirdly optimistic now bc this shit very clearly doesn’t work and the only choice now is to, as Chris said, build community and capacity.

Sam Bondurant

They’d still vote but they’d leave president and senate (fuck Marsha Blackburn) blank

Robert Aitken

don’t think I’ve ever said this before but please touch some grass

nahobeeho

That's really sweet.

Natalie

I just started listening to this show a year ago so my main exposure has been no Matt, and I've thought it's ironic how the often most poignant person has been absent for all these crazy events. I think that's a pretty normal thought process!! But I will go on a walk later since you said that ty

Nott Hemon

To quote the video game the dry boys once helped make, “Something beautiful is going to happen.”

Jon Rehm

Agree. I bet there are lots of disaffected libs out there who don’t know they’re Marxists.

Kolisi’s Stepson

We should’ve known that Trump would win when James Cameron resurrected Quatrich in Avatar 2. Evil never dies

nahobeeho

Attempting to bundle them all under this Latino umbrella is clearly nonsensical BS from the Dems.

Jon Rehm

About 8 years ago I googled “El Chapo’s Traphouse”. I accessed SoundCloud on the web, and then I heard Felix describe some Democratic functionary as a cum eating freak. I’ve been Chapo-pilled ever since.

Ruby Lee

for evil, time is a flat circle.

Xio Dio

Nah, Bernie would have won. Both times. If populism works for Trump it can work for others.

Nico

Thank you for the unlock sharing with my lib friends

king_von_diesel

That needle drop was STUNNING. I dunno, sometimes, you just gotta hope and learn to try.

William Beamish

Evan how did voting for a genocide go? Did 99% Hitler win?

HarshMalarkey

Matt Christman must be floating SpongeBob meme rn. Wish him the best.

Vincent W Troia

to be fair if you google here record she had actually done quite a bit. a lot of it is boring government committee stuff and non news making stuff

Magic

Yeah, call me cope central, but I genuinely believe that.

syd

They're gonna do Elon twitter shit to the federal government

Podcast subscriber 78

Adam is SO fucking off-putting. The first time I ever heard of him, was on this podcast, and I instantly wanted kill him and then myself. When he’s on cumtown or tafs, he’s way less hateable. But when he’s out in the world like on chapo, he’s constantly trying to sound cool and makes you wish nick was there to bully him and then do a Chinese or Indian voice. I think he’s a funny comic but such an annoying person.

Boxzoid

"in dark times, should the stars also go out?"

Jerry Cornelius

If you want to be inspired by regular people making a huge difference completely separate from electoral politics, check out @belovedasheville on instagram. They’re an amazing mutual aid organization, delivering food and building clusters of homes for the homeless. This + workplace organizing is the model for change. Like Chris said, walk outside, see what your neighbors need and do what you can to help them.

DS

Schedule F to begin with. They've already overturned Chevron. Add that together with fascist loyalty program Schedule F to install maga faithful to regulatory roles and the new DOGE designed to do who actually knows what, but basically eliminate the agencies that would regulate people like Musk. No more CFPB. No more NLRB. No more Lina Khan and antitrust. No more deferential regulations to make sure we don't die from microparticles per quadrant in a core. We are all so very fucked and there is no positive response. They're eliminating the administrative state, they have the courts, they have the legislature, they have the executive, they have the minds of the people at large.

Dildo Saggins

I have special insight into the average American voter and it goes like this - Wednesday my dad texted me to tell me he had been reading the Book Of Revelation and was very concerned about how Donald Trump might be the antichrist, but he really liked his tax policies so he voted for him anyways.

Ahmed Razick

The Americans that vote prefer 100% Hitler to 99% Hitler. I did not vote because America isn't a democracy but it 100% is the Fourth Reich.

Heavenly Father69

I love the show but you guys are still hopeless democrat tools. "What wokeness was in there?" Ehhh...the final messaging of this fucked ass campaign was voting for Trump means you are a mysogynist. Rather than the fact that for many voting for Trump was a hail mary that there will be some defent jobs in this broken country. He doesn't give s fuck of course but goddamn. This stupid ass resistance nonsense lingers and caters to one group only: Upper middle class white Karens OF WHICH THEY ARE PREDOMINANTLY COMPRISED. How could any working class man, with any self respect vote for the Harris campaign. It would be voting for morr govt disconnect, more gobbdlegook language, more doing. nothing while continuing to endlessly onsess about cultural identity. Not to mention NOBODY CAN AFFORD RENT OR CRAZY FRIVOLOUS SHIT LIKE FOOD. At least Trump pretended to reach out. Woke is a huge part of it and you fucking Brooklyn bitches are just as profoundly disconnected as the government clowns you guys make fun of. Woke is a very real, lingering threat to job security for working class men, it is a weapon of classism and a more and more desperate grifter class clinging to an economic raft that somehow stays afloat. This never ending narrative that women live under the steady thumb of oppression is farcical and fantasticalm Especially the spoiled and loud mouth bitches who love to spew about how hard their privileged lives are, all the while telling you you are sexist, racist, some kinf of ist. I know of mant many men who are good men, who are no harassed, they are not sexist, they are not pigs. They are good men who were accused of causing women to "feel" afraid, of bullying, of trying to intimidate, of looking a certain way that caused the ire of a "woke" woman and they lost their jobs for it. It is an employment nightmare for men and for companies. Amd it is totally out of control but to even speak about it is verboten because if you say, "Darnell just lost his job because of heresay," you are an enabler of whatever behavior they have been falsely accused of. On the ground it sure feels like lying,manipulative, borderline bitches can say and do whatever they want at work, at school, or in family courts. This election was a referendum on the grotesque charade that feminism has become.

Chris

speaking of gobbdlegook language

Jay-Z Pants

Trump faces a lot less opposition from real power than Bernie. Sure, the PMC hates Trump but clearly that doesn’t matter much. Politics is the entertainment division of industry, and the big boys don’t want us getting any exciting ideas about governance. Trump is a great solution for the problem of populism, Bernie is a threat.

Johnny S.

Asheville local here. This is such a great and accurate post .

Eric Valentino

Felix's final few words made me think of Musa Hadid's fountain in "Mayor" -- it was so inspiring that he could find some semblance of joy and normalcy to undergird their resilience even with jackbooted thugs busting up their square and killing them at their borders. If only we had 1/10th of the steadfastness and courage here...

Jingle Jangler

"Woke is a real threat to job security for working class men" this is fucking priceless bro you are insane

Jaime Christley

after dealing with disingenuous, blame-spraying libs and Dems for what feels like the eight thousand years that have gone by since Wednesday, this episode was a tonic. thanks lads.

Brooke

Will’s Hillary Clinton impression is my FAVORITE

Hardcore Virgin

I’m all for what Felix says at the end here and it is important but just ya know Gaza has one of the highest suicide rates in the world. Depression. Self harm etc. Shit is very bleak. And it doesn’t undercut his point but makes rattling organizing for a free Palestine all the more important.

Jack

TY kings for unlocking this one!

Khemith

Anti Christ, but not Anti fun.

Khemith

Need Chris in the back doing the producer work.

The Dude

Is woke in the room with you right now?

eduard karpoev

This feels like OG Chapo lmao. I miss this amount of "dirtbag Left"

Erumas

I’m glad Felix can laugh about the potential tariffs tanking the economy. I think it’s likely much less funny for the people who aren’t financially in a position to weather that.

eduard karpoev

I was someone that couldn't bring myself to vote for Kamala despite living in a swing state. I'm Russian American, and this admin convincing Zelenesky to turn down the 2 Russian peace offers in 2022 to try and use Ukraine as a sink for Russian men & material. Then beyond that genocide not being a red line was to much for me so I just voted 3rd party.

MATT TRIANO

Which of you reads comments?

MATT TRIANO

That's also a waste of time. People do this? Do less.

MATT TRIANO

People absolutely see trans issues as elite problems because everything costs too much and exploring gender feels like navgal gazing and doesn't seem to unlock any rights for anyone, period. It looks to them like a distraction and although it isn't? I understand why.

K H

Bless.

James Proulx

I'm seeing a lot of people grieving and trying to come to grips with their having lost all faith in this country and its people and all I can think of is the "First time?" meme from the Ballad of Buster Scruggs.

nick

My fear about the militarized deportations (if they happen) is that they will inspire dumbass vigilantes to “assist” the feds and overzealously/accidentally-on-purpose do a pogrom in an immigrant neighborhood

Jingle Jangler

I for one welcome our new burger in chief

s

Try to laugh about things instead of being a moralizing scold

Tyler Sutherland

Stop trying to compare America and France, it doesn't work, there's completely different contexts and political mechanics between our countries lmfao for fucks sake

Tyler Sutherland

That mayoral candidate Will was talking about is DSA member and leftist warrior Zohran Mamdani, who has helped lead the pro-Palestine efforts in NYC. Pleeeease support him; he might be the guy that could break the cycle, after all! He's good as hell!

Garrat M

For the first time since I turned 18 I didn't vote. One, I live in Illinois, I'm not going to waste my one day off standing in line when Kamala is going to win the state and the dumb hogs who live in my district are going to send Mary "Hitler was right" Miller anyway. Plus the ILDP won't do shit about the ballot questions asked. So I just stayed home and spent time with my dog.

Tyler Sutherland

You can't blame a guy fit trying. We have a first past the post voting system; there is no other option besides the traditional top 2. I mean, who else was he gonna support to get back at the libs? Jill Stein the grifting dipshit green lib? Cornel West, a guy who stabbed him in the back to get support from the People's Party?? He had zero good options in his point of view besides "hope Kamala is so craven she can see it's wiser to compromise with the left". It's worth more than voting for non-3rd parties.

Tyler Sutherland

AOC has one of the best records on Palestine and all leftist goals in the House, tied with Tlaib. Grow up and stop being assmad you libs

Tyler Sutherland

Yall should bring that etringermentum dipshit back on here for more stellar political analysis lol

Jeremy

My wife was on strike and he came to several of their pickets. Very solid dude IMO.

Justin

They don’t think it. They hope it, and the dream of a base with no economic needs is worth the risk for them.

Oisín Gunning

Episodes with lots of Chris are the best episodes

C. Andrew

U right we should frown and be miserable constantly for the next 4 years instead. Maybe if I self-flaggilate myself hard enough the tarrifs won't happen.

C. Andrew

Woke yourself and everyone around you.

Michael

Too many Johnsons.

Alex

At least I have Matt’s book on the way

C. Andrew

They all do, together, in one big snuggie sitting on one comically oversized gamer chair in Langley, VA.

james

Swing stater here: I voted for harris, after being vocally supportive of Cornel West, because friends and family that would've been affected basically pleaded with me. I drank beforehand and felt disgusted with myself, and after the results came in, I felt even worse. I feel ashamed. The only bright side was that Robinson got washed out of NC governorship

Dustin Sparks

Nah, I vividly and fondly remember the “I may not be Dale Earnhardt” line and it made me so happy to hear it again

Mark Schneider

Uhmm, nowhere I guess. So did my vote for Jill Stein in Minnesota. It was still better than nothing.

Hot Rod

56:00 National privatization will include national public sector unions. Nationwide Act10.

Mark Schneider

Gotta respect the classics!! Keep on doing what doesn't work, until it does?

james

You should check out the Trillbillies on this election if you need an extra tonic.

Mark Schneider

But at one time she was better looking for the horny Dem guys!!

Leyland

Are you Australian?

protob1

The Master of Mankind

Mark Schneider

Yo soy Castellano por el lado de mi madre, ademas apoyaba al revolucion Sandinista cortando el cafe en Nicaraguae durante 1983-84. Este "LatinX" es mierda del vaca total, nadie en mi comunidad acepto esta basura. Chingales a sus mismos, Shitlibs!!

S H

Perfect end music

james

I wish he was here, but the moment when Will called Chris "Matt", I think it was confirmed they should now have a new permanent mic. Been a stan for Chris since Hell of Presidents, and Hell on Earth confirmed my bias. Best producer ever, impeccable commentary.

Jaime Christley

Will do! I've liked their guest appearances on here.

etienne

Biden flawlessly executed and even improved upon "The Jimmy Carter special"

Alexander white

Tariffs are a great way for Trump to shake down big business. they will all have to pay bribes through truth social stock to avoid getting slapped with tariffs that hurt their business. all the corporate owned media will all the sudden become much more friendly to Trump so that their parent companies can get tariff exemptions

C. Ries

Are there different modes of production? No. France is going to follow Americas trajectory

Jason Matthews

This is the key to the much remarked upon Silicon Valley Pivot. The expulsions are part of the same campaign of blackmail

C. Ries

You’re right that wokeness and identity politics distract from class consciousness and are bad but you’re claiming that sexual harassment protections are woke… what a dullard

C. Ries

Kamala stole that for her concession speech. Her dad raised her well

Jimmy McMillan

There's an old campaign strategy called lying and bribing people. Biden promised student debt relief and stimulus checks when he won. Maybe if Harris promised anything at all those 14,000,000 people would have found it worth voting for her

Salid Tahsaar

2016-2017 election autopsy episodes were the best, the lead up to the 2020 primaries were a close second.

Salid Tahsaar

Ask not for whom the Dry Boys ride; the Dry Boys ride for thee.

Jimmy McMillan

Last week the Dems were like "Fuck you we don't need you. Dick Cheney and all his friends are voting for us." This week they're like "Where the fuck were you?! We needed you"

J P 3

I'm a little more forgiving of Harris than Hillary Clinton, because Clinton did her face plant at a time when Obama had a net favorable rating of almost +10. Harris actively campaigned and had a decent ground organization. It wasn't enough and her stance on immigration and Gaza was indefensible. The embrace of Liz Cheney and the Bush administration was also a failed strategy. Btw, best case for Trump is a "Berlusconi" administration. My sense is that this is going to be a golden age for fraud. If you are a billionaire with a crypto-scam idea, the next four years are probably going to be pretty good.

Danielle Sanchez

It's just an anecdote, but my family were huge Obama bots because he promised something different than Bill Clinton. Then he betrayed us by not doing any of the shit he ran on, bailing out banks, expanding ICEA, et cetera. They barely stomached voting for Hillary and then Biden, but once Harris got Dick fucking Cheney on board? Most of them stayed home lmao.

Timbo

I appreciate your use of AI to imitate Ian Miles Cheong, but your data model still needs a bit more refinement.

Catherine

Shawn Fain 2028!

Ligma

You're right man, us women invented feminism because we enjoy ruining men's lives and sexual harassment and violence has just been an elaborate gaslighting operation this entire time !

B b

The reason it was smart for members of the squad to not endorse Biden dropping out is that we would be hearing nonstop how it’s their fault Trump won and Biden should not have dropped out.

king_von_diesel

I think once they brought on board the Cheneys, my disgust got too high to vote.

Shane-A112

I am a male feminist solely to undermine the men of the world. Vienna is correct. We are coming for your 1996 Honda Civic.

Joshu

Nancy regans vote goat

DT

Your brain is flat and smooth like a chicken's.

Ham Stroker’s Jackula

Feels good to no longer give in to the woke scold vote shame Dems that were writing off genocide. They got what they wanted, reap the whirlwind Matt ygglesias

Jack

We'll never know until it's tried!

Eon Gattignolo

you absolutely do not have to hand it to her

TheMunj

Chris’s point about the potential for deportations is spot on. That will be horrific if it is pushed through

jer

Lol. I'm in the carribean rn and I can't help but read your wild comment in a carribean accent. You are on one, my friend.

jer

Just stay home next time you wank

S

At least I didn't vote for genocide moron

Cory

God damn you boys cooked with this one.

Jon

I honestly think the reason republicans said “democracy is at stake” has to do with immigration. It’s nuts how many fully bought the idea that democrats were shipping in voters from Mexico

NitroDickclapp III

Thanks guys I really needed your levity and positivity today. I've lost all but 1 of my childhood friends to right wing reactionary bs and today was a rough day. Our group chat is full of exactly what you'd expect, a lot of thinly veiled racist and sexist horsesht. One of my oldest friends told me to "wake the F up". The whole thing is extremely depressing.

Reece Coren

can’t wait till a year from now when they find out brandon really did steal that shit in 2020 and give the january 6th guys medals of honor

Nikolaas Van Droogenbroeck

@chris they wont have to go door to door they have all our data, they know who is illegally in the country, they know who is gay, they know it all they know who we all are and how we think and how we vote.

Man

Listening to all these Democrats either refusing to acknowledge they have completely lost touch with the working class, or in some cases blaming the working class and holding them responsible its like you can already see the 2028 map turning red

Aaaaaaaaaaaron1

man I actually love it when you guys take a beat and get serious and corny, I stick around for the laughs but that's what brought me to the show initially. I've been thinking about this recently: this country has never been more ready for a left populist. One thing that's caught me off guard in the last two days is how many poor libs have come into left groups meekly looking for answers. Bernie's too old now and as you said, aligned with the hated establishment. But there's someone out there and we need to find them (and get ahead of gruesome gavin). Next candidate to get up there and say, with conviction, "medicare for all"... that person will take it all.

Ghordo

Now that we're looking at Trump II: Electric Boogaloo, I want to see Chris and Matt do a one-off episode that's a Hell of Presidents "bonus" where they do a deep-dive post-mortem on the Biden presidency

gatito

ok Mark Schneider lo q tú digas

Ardy Rezv

Didn’t she vote to fund Israel you simp lol?

Ardy Rezv

So why didn’t that happen in 2016? We really going to run our heads into the same wall again? The dem party will always be a graveyard for the left. The squad has been pathetic in Congress. Aoc faked being a radical so she could win the primary according to Ryan Grimms book. If you have a D next to your name or stump for any dem candidate you’re dead to me.

Ardy Rezv

Don’t worry the parliamentarian will stop Trump

Ardy Rezv

Jesus still a lot Bernie simp in this audience. He failed us twice. Let him go. He’s as usless as Gore now

Ardy Rezv

Wow. Exactly what we sent her to Congress to do. What a shakeup to the system. Honestly she’s too radical.

Ardy Rezv

It’s a fringe online left and online right issue.

Ardy Rezv

Too bad he didn’t want it. Could’ve ran as an independent but sold out his movement.

Ardy Rezv

He’s the Bernie Sanders of union leaders. All talk. His members wanted a full strike and he did a rolling one. Spent the last few months sucking off Brandon and Harris

True Horror Productions

My man can do both, shit he came thru a live space we did a couple years ago and did it LIVE baby

Steezcake_Factory

Should've called this one "Hillary Doesn't Repeat Herself"

S H

If there is hell below, Curtis mayfield

Arno Noack

hassan pikers politics are not that far off from pod save america

Dee Rubes

Same as 2016. And 2000.

Arno Noack

im still waiting on papi part 5

Arno Noack

The Democrats operate on the if you give a mouse a cookie theory, you're right they're not about to undo all that hard work they did with the Republicans in lockstep rolling back all the gains made by the independent labor movement before world war II and the popular front destroyed the independent US left

Arno Noack

Gavin newsom's vision for the future, lock everyone up and force them to fight forest fires for $0.10 an hour

Arno Noack

yeah maybe they went to a picket line or two they also crushed the railroad strike

Tim

We know that a Matt Yglesias-style campaign wouldn’t have helped, because they ran an Yglesias-style campaign and lost.

Natalie

Thanks for making this one public, already sent it to a lefty liberal and a conservative cause you guys are on point and appeal to things I think everyone knows but can't string together without help and context.

Jimmy McMillan

But they have an endless amount of patience and understanding for all the moderate conservatives who say they'll vote for them but never do

Dee Rubes

It is a grift to let the country go right while maintaining the veneer of democracy IMO. The Dems are fine with losing. They are not fine with tacking left.

Jimmy McMillan

Yep. They're more interested in stealing republican donars than voters

Robert Aitken

please no. the one upside of this would be them dropping that dork

Robert Aitken

woke is real and zi is my friend

Robert Aitken

americans love their Hitlers. if you get between them and their favourite Hitler they will become extremely upset and irrational

Robert Aitken

if you love nonces that much I think Chris Delia has a new show

Keenan Fitzgerald

At the end of Bernie’s little diagnosis statement, he finishes with a “Stay tuned…”. Guesses on what they could possibly have cooking up that would make any difference??

At Your Disservice

It's amazing how much smarter you guys are than the pod save idiots

ordna jela

Emails asking me for money

ordna jela

It's already happening but it's libs doing it to teach latinos a lesson because they don't understand the difference between an absolute and relative demographic voting shift

Alex Manescu

These people are cowards, don’t show them fear is gonna keep me going

etienne

time to watch Hypernormalization again

Jack Paul

We need Matt Chrisman back ❤️❤️😭😭

Cormac

Fuckin BRILLIANT content, you vapid twat

David Rodriguez

It’s mentioned in this episode how a president is judged by meeting the moment and honestly this country was fucked the moment Obama betrayed his promise of “change” to America.

wolfgang

Don’t forget the big winners this election, chuckelfuck podcasts. Joe rogan has like 20x more subscribers than cnn has prime time viewers lol we re fucked. Big win, congrats boys.

Jason Edmiston

Matt Christman could be left-James Dobson. Let's make it happen.

Dee Rubes

“At the precipice of a crossroads” MORE LITTLE CARMINE ELECTION ANALYSIS PLEASE

George Mitri

“…I didn’t pay attention to the Harris mistakes”. JFC, grim.

Tyler Sutherland

Cry bitch lmao waaah bernie didn't overthrow capitalism in one go and exists in the context of the present, I'm fuckin 19 years old 😭😭😭😭

Elder

Truly bungled, the Obungler must be so proud

Alice Pooper

Will is the absolute master of turns of phrase

Alice Pooper

They have definitely lost touch with working class no doubt but I think they’ve also just completely lost touch with reality

Khemith

Posting saves the world , is what I got from your comment.

Ardy Rezv

You know what you’re right. I mean the left is is so good at winning. Why wouldn’t I listen to someone like you 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😆 😂 😆 😝

Ardy Rezv

He’s the only one sticking up for the women of Iran. Watch your mouth

Matthew

"We're in a fuckin stagmire!"

SpongeGunderson

Looking forward to a Cushbomb poetry book.

Jack Paul

Bring Mike from PA on, the way he talked about the pollsters before the election was so accurate. I think you all would like his analysis. ❤️❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸

Alex Berkowitz

Bernie was the most serious and action oriented one on the left. That’s why you know his name.

itsjenjen

Chris going off in this ep!!

Sol Chatz

I think they are. He just normalizes he's takes at time to attract normies but his very clearly well read, is much more critical of imperialism than them, and at the very least positions himself to the left of Bernie, something they don't do. You don't gotta like him but he is pretty left wing

Arno Noack

he is very left for a liberal but his framework and its limits are very well the limits of the liberal imagination. for example he fails to grasp the possibility that a loss could be a victory still for the dems, he fails to see the path forward could be for working class people to build and organize independently of the political sysem to create their own power all the discourse is about how to get people to vote dem.

Alef Khoury

I am unironically, 100% all in on a Chris-led spinoff show LOL <3 I mean I love the whole crew but whenever he gets on the mic it's like seeing George Martin pop up holding a fat blunt in some archival Beatles footage

drewby

Is there a way to listen to the old Curtis in the zone now ep post 2016 election? Tried finding it here and the apple podcast apps to no avail.

king_von_diesel

Ngl, it would be SO funny if in 2020 Biden was pulling LBJ shit, and the J6 guys are all given pardons and presidential freedom medals.

Alef Khoury

Very appreciative of the extended Curtis Mayfield outro LOL, perfect song that will be playing nonstop in my head until it gets bashed in by a rabid liberal during the Great Scapegoat Riots of 2025

Zach Pierce

I’ll be laughing my ass off

Christopher Price

not accurate given AIPAC spent record amounts on primary challengers for Bush and Bowman. They've been trying to do the same to Tlaib but she's established enough in a district that adores her, so even they know it's a losing fight. They also spent record amounts to turf out Jayapal's sister in Oregon. AOC is still very popular with Warren types, and no one is going to care about anything she says this year if she runs on Bernie's platform in 28.

Christopher Price

yeah, for second gen immigrants, the American Dream is still a very real thing. A lot of immigrants also represented conservative factions in their old homeland.

Man2quilla

Evil Kamala Harris: "We did it Joe 😈"

James

I think Dems lost because they didn't campaign for 3.5 years while in office. You can't combat years of attacks in a matter of months given that everyone is too online. They hid Biden and didn't allow Harris to champion anything good. I also think people's brains are fried from COVID and there's a lot of anger over losing time and loved ones. I think that led to a lot of apathy. But in the end, all the analysis will be moot because whatever happens in the next 2-6 years is just going to be insanely dumb, whether it's good for us or not.

Ardy Rezv

My man is in shambles that mamala lost

Ardy Rezv

And he did what exactly?

etienne

its on youtube and soundcloud at least

Noctor

The Dems lost cause they tried to take on TikTok. In all seriousness, I feel like TikTok is a representation of the mass line. The Democrats need to reread “on practice.”

Jilly

That Curtis Mayfield drop was perfect

DS

Been waitin a decade for Bernie to pop something off to do the whole "put pressue on people in power" thing, but I think he might have meant he wanted US to pop that off, not him. Well...shit. Thanks Dad. I'll do better.

zach

If Donald Trump can come back from Jan 6 and a bunch of felony convictions, surely there is space for a Virgil Texas comeback.

Simon Maraya

I assume he retired the Virgil Texas identity and role by choice, ah well. Or maybe there is much worse stuff out there then the accusations that get obliquely referenced - because tbh as someone who was a young woman, and is now a middle-aged woman, his behavior seems like pretty much par for the course.

Vincent

I’m really paying for a professional political podcast to get the same stuff wrong as any clueless Twitter post? The election result was called early, making it appear like there was a significant reduction in votes. The official final count is still TBD, and has narrowed to under 9m fewer votes than 2020. Been a Chapo fan since the beginning. Hard to listen now, y’all have really given up on trying 🤷‍♀️

Shannon

i found all of the missing (free) chapo eps on soundcloud. garbage app now but at least they are somewhere

Vincent

What’s the ‘?’? Did you listen to the podcast? They spend the beginning talking about 14m+ less votes than 2020. Maybe they should use some of their budget to fact check themselves…

etienne

I agree that the "30k election" stuff is pretty silly now that we know that this is the 2nd biggest turnout election in relative and absolute terms in a long *long* time but also: shut da hell up

Vincent

It’s absolutely crazy you are dick riding for basic factual inaccuracy

drewby

Thank you!

drewby

Thank you!

Matthew Krueger

This is really funny. I love the boys but Chris is the only one of them that could be categorized as "professional". Even if the final vote tally puts the third party votes as having been the deciding factor between them, I don't see how their overall analysis is flawed. Even if it wasn't a blow-out, it isn't as though the playbook for how to turn folks away from fascism doesn't exist , and the dems have no interest in following it. What's your analysis? Not being mad about a hot take isn't the same as dick riding for basic factual inaccuracy. But I'm not mad you for your hot take.

parker

Tbf if I had to geuss regardless of wether he did anything wrong probably just had enough money and said I'm gonna bow out. Alot more graceful than some internet people

parker

I mean considering it looks like polsters were literally just lying about there numbers this time around unlike 2020 and 2016 it means there wasn't alot he could do. 2020 and 2022 had correlated with the polls in a way that was predictable but for this election alot of polls just seemed to ignore how many Dems would stay home this time due to issues like Gaza Ukraine and saber rattling plus inflation and lack of an agenda

Jwood

Wow it has narrowed to 9 million???!! Are you serious? Jesus, this changes everything. 😂

Vincent

This is exactly how magatards react to having basic facts pointed out to them 👍

Squidward's Grumpier Cousin

No one disputes the basic facts, we know they got that wrong, we just think it's funny and weird that you care this much.

Vincent

Good point, I’m so stupid for missing when Chapo was actually good 🤦🏼‍♀️

Vincent

Y’all are the ones having a shit fit meltdown because your favorite online socialists got the lightest criticism possible

Jwood

Yes please, I've had this same thought exactly. I keep replaying Hell of Presidents, it's so well done.

Jwood

Agreed. I'm concerned AOC is gonna try to become this person - but will fail to pull it off because she'll end up being the next Obama instead.

Elder

Oh no the political comedy and variety hour podcast predicted the election wrong. Big sad! I am so disappointed these intellectuals I admire were wrong about a number. I guess I'll get my dick jokes and political insight from somewhere else :'(

Vincent

You must have replied to the wrong comment because I never said anything about predicting the election outcome

Jason Matthews

I must part ways with the dogpile, in agreeing that we still don't know basic facts about the election, and are months or years away from being able to draw intelligent conclusions. There seems to be a lot going on. That Chapo would be privy to anything the rest of us aren't is probably an unreasonable expectation. They're in the business of spinning minutes of insight into hours of content. I still love them.

Curtis Fooling

I can't believe the Chapo boys would exaggerate something for comedic effect!

cinchal

yes we did listen to the podcast, three days ago

Matthew Krueger

Vincent, I understand you "missing when Chapo was actually good", or deciding that you no longer get what you consider to be adequate news/entertainment value for your $5. We'll be sorry to see you go, but I think it's clear that the universe is communicating to you that it's time to start your own podcast. Best of luck to you!

etienne

originally only the premium eps were on patreon and at some point chris took the decision to post the freebies on patreon also as unlocked content. hence the discontinuity.

Elliot Matheny

Still crazy that his face and name are on the marquee for BJG’s Bad Faith pod, which he hasn’t appeared on for a solid 3+ years

Ryan Johnson

Check the date of the podcast? On the 7th, this was accurate at the time (14m fewer votes). Narrowing to "only" 9m is still a collasal failure lol

Vincent

Really can’t believe I have to explain this to y’all… You are right that on the date of the podcast they said the *current* vote count at the time. You are ignoring the second part, which is that the vote totals were incomplete. Seasoned, educated political commentators who are paying attention should be aware of this and not say “the vote totals were 14 lower” when you can clearly see the reason the appear to be low is that all the votes haven’t been counted yet. If you have been on Twitter this week you would know that a LOT of people made the same careless lazy mistake. What obviously happened is that narrative took off and everyone started repeating it without thinking for themselves. It’s very obvious that is what happened here. It’s sad that y’all need to be walked through this step by step 🤦🏼‍♀️

Matt

what’s the sequel called?

K H

If it's any consolation it really basically does not matter. The overwhelming momentum towards shitty meta voting dramatically outweighs any sincere expression of personal political preference.

K H

What did you want us to take from your comment exactly? Also, are you on amphetamines?

Vincent

It’s extremely simple. I’ll explain it again. Saying “there were 14m less votes”, which is what the Chapo boys opened the episode talking about, is an easily avoidable and obvious mistake that should have never been made. Why? Because it was also known that the vote counts weren’t finalized yet. Therefore, it was never true that there were 14m fewer votes. I’m calling out this lazy mistake because it’s a product of group think. You can easily google or look on Twitter to see that many other people were making the same false claim at the same time. Why? Because they wanted it to be true without looking into it or applying basic logic. Chapo is SUPPOSED to be educational (even if it’s also comedic) and the show ISNT supposed to help propagate false quotes and misconceptions. Is it clear now ?

ChapoFan inParis

Nope, Obama was the worst POTUS ever. Biden squandered a historic opportunity but it was nothing compared to the opportunity Obama had in 2009.

fugitivedocument

I had to re-listen to this episode to hear the quote “if I don’t have a piece of the pie then why do I care whose thumb is in it? “

K H

Does it affect your decision making at all to know I don't care? Personally I hope it turns out to be close and that their shitty policies ultimately made them lose as opposed to general malaise. Chapo reporting accuracy however I do not care about.

Vincent

You literally asked, stupid ape 🤣

Alejo

Wha wha whaaaaa that’s all I hear, trump won in a landslide. Stop the cope

Raphael Wakefield

Aside from what Vincent said about basic election facts being wrong: Having Will and Felix, literal millionaires (and if you're actually not millionaires you're so bad with money it calls everything else into question), brag about not voting for Harris because of genocide for months and then say at the end of this "hope you're ready to shelter would-be deportees, flee your home state (to where?), and lie to police and test your mettle" would be funny if the situation weren't so dire in a zillion ways besides that. The ultra-left tilt of this show turned into a cliff once Matt left and none of you read anything anymore. And of course now the genocide and ethnic cleaning is going to accelerate. Palestine is done. This was a binary choice election and we blew it

Raphael Wakefield

Take the election seriously and announce they're voting for Harris even though we all know the problems with her and her campaign because yes, Trump and what he represents is that bad. Now at best we'll waste another 4 years fighting him on defense, forced to side with the Democrats, instead of building power

Jason Matthews

Why is this election so morally charged, as compared to all the others? Noam Chomsky made similar overblown claims about Romney '2012 (equating a vote for him to a vote for nuclear war), and it has been little more than a routine, before and since. Trump is exceptional in many ways, but most of the realistic nightmare scenarios in 2016 came to pass, and were prolonged or exacerbated under Biden. With respect to nativism, genocide, austerity, military brinkmanship, and the Supreme Court....well, the horse has already bolted. By failing to address any of this the Democrats deserved to lose.

K H

Oh no babe, I absolutely care about why you're wound up on your latest amphetamine fueled fixation. I meant, I do not care if Chapo fails to report breaking polling data accurately. I don't come here for bleeding edge statistical analysis.

Raphael Wakefield

I don't think the election is particularly "morally charged". I don't vote on morality. One clue Trump 2024 might be worse than Romney is that Trump already tried to overthrow the government

Jack

These things play themselves, we're just along for the ride

Kevin Spicer

Time is a slippery concept once you start thinking about it....

ploob

Normalization Blues

ploob

You best be walking EXACTLY like that swishy little capuchin avi! I will know

instain_mother

I need the Chapo boys to check out Zero Day on netflix. It's this dog shit political thriller where Robert DeNiro plays a senile president who has to heal the nation and he throws a left-wing podcaster in prison

Sifl

War Nerd claimed at the outset of the Ukraine war that Ukraine's military was just a loose confederation of local militias that would not last long against the great Russian armed forces. Now they pretend like they never said that and recast Russia as some sort of slow starter/fast learner that has now mastered US weapons systems and is winning a war of attrition. Over the course of the war, Russia has had close to 1 million casualties in order to capture very small battle field gains where Russia can only level small Ukrainian towns with artillery because they have no ability to use combined arms in battle. Putin was almost coup-ed by his private PMC. Russia, the second largest armed forces in the world, has had to rely on North Korea and Iran for arms production and infantry, while Ukraine has taken and held the Kursk area inside Russia (when was the last time Russia lost territory in an armed conflict)? On the world stage, Russia was so dedicated to the Ukraine war that it let its man Bashir Assad get swept away by a poorly organized ex-Al Qaeda militia and saw its "peace keepers" in Nagorno-Karabakh swept aside in a humiliation to Russia's influence over the Caucuses.

protob1

The reason you were 'wrong' and 'shocked' is because you are consistently wrong. Wrong in your analysis on everything and especially on the Democratic Party, Trump, Syria, Ukraine, Russia, the US economy, etc. etc. It's pathetic.

Niko

Tbh I've heard Jon and Mark say they got Ukraine wrong multiple times

Alex Koenig

Everyone here is now dumber having heard this.

Expiatory Goat

https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/News/visas-news/visa-waiver-travel-for-israeli-citizens.html Israelis enjoying their Sept. 2023 US visa waiver, literally transition to “whiteness” the instant they cross into US airspace (or Rhodesian airspace), and when they arrive for their visa free immigration hassle free stay with no overstay possible, they will call us “browns” and “amelekites” For its non-stop racist eliminationist remunerative propaganda blitz since at least the 1820s, Texas has pushed desperate asylum seeking victims of a US hegemony, to the deepest part of the river with the razor wire to force them to cross in the most dangerous part to try and request asylum and many drown only to become political footballs for the totally racist never ending +216 year old eliminationist Eurasian settler lynch mob anti-non-Eurasian anti-Latino propaganda blitz that is the genocide known as texas & US. Obviously the context is unfortunately so racist, because in September 2023 israelis were granted a USA immigration visa waiver. United States trafficking them schattenkrieger style since at least 1948 (Stetsko, Lebed, Bandera & so many more) and the UK being in cahoots with them since before World War II, that's all true unfortunately and a massive insult to my grandfather who fought with the United States Army first infantry in Europe to defeat the Nazis, but it's an insult to my entire family and all Americans. Do you know that JFK appointed Hitler's chief of staff and the mastermind of operation Barbarossa genocide to be the top leader of NATO right, but it gets way worse! Here is the proxy paramilitary einsatzgruppen armies of WWall SStreet operating in Ukraine short list. Most of these groups are still operating, they're all private armies of the CIA.... they are, the CIA has never stopped trafficking private armies, especially in Ukraine, look up the UPA. 🙄 WWall SStreet's seemingly endless, never unemployed, private fascist and Nazi armies operating worldwide with impunity and endless funding from the repugnant exchange rackets they are the impunity granted purveyors of for the hegemon. It is such disgusting & absolutely downright traitorous behavior and so insulting to my/our WW2 US veterans grandparents and great grandparents. An unforgivable insult: Unifer Borodach division 3rd compagnie Renseignement militaire Trident Defence Initiative Wiking Team Yankee Atlas Global Battalion "mad pack" Sherekeliba Black Zaporizhzhians Battalion Crimea The third hundred Smolensk republican center Regiment Chase Bravo 1, Bravo 2 & Bravo 3 First Fusiliers (Pravy Sektor) Lumiere Group Alpha 1 PNK group Group 13 Unit Lut Philanthropic division Black team Dzhokhar Dudayev battalion Tactical group, Belarus Kastus Kalinousky regiment 80th assault group "Galicia" Atomwaffen - AWO Galizen 12th Brigade Azov Perm Nazi Team (PNZS) Blood Tribe Black swan brigade Revansh Unit Madyar Birds Gonor Bandits Wolverines Unit 46A4638 Kryla Unit Irpen Group Barrat Group GUR Solidarity GUR Street Front Coyote Unit GUR Lucas Squad Delta Knights Bratsvo unit Spatan Batallion Terror Battalion Brotherhood Tro brigade Dikiy platoon Revenge unit MTR (Arzov) DURK PD “Santi”” 67th (pravy sektor) 3rd Sturm Assault (Azov) Combat Insertion group Dark angels Black maple brigade Mosart group Task force Yankee Task force Pluto Volovik Unit Spanish legion Apocalypse team Wolfhound Freedom of Russia Legion The Dirty Dozen Planet of people Unit A3449 Team Valhalla Siberian Battalion group Sabre 'training' Advisory Group SSO Georgian Partisans 70th Gerts 40th Kodak Battalion Terror 1st Special Purpose Brigade 24th Ombr 25th OMBR “Kievan Rus” 46th Special Forces 57th OBPB 58th ODPBr 68th ODPBr 102 OBR-TRO Battalion Chrnigov International legion Caucasian legion 1 OBRSpn 2nd Battalion DUK (pravy sektor) Georgian Legion Artan Group Ambush Team Vega Unit Ares Unit Black eagle RDK OUN Unit A4953 Battalion Tbilisi Unit Lyut The Chase Russian Freedom Legion Straight edge squad Pagonya Sheik Mansour Battalion Rogue Team Bili Demony White Demons Spartan Brigade Omega group 50/50 Kara Dag (NGU) 68 Jaeger Brigade Monolith Brigade Cossack Battalion Patriot of Ukraine Norman Brigade German Volunteer Corps Ukrainian Volunteer Army (UDA) Charter/Khartia Battalion Luftwaffe Battalion Format 18 Skalar Battalion Battalion Burewiej Rage Battalion SS Galicia SS Nachtagal Freikorps Volunteers Order & Tradition Arey Battalion Nomad Sicarios (Norwegian) Caucasus Emirate Alpha 1 Code.9.2 Edelweiss Batallion SS Sonderkommando SS Centuria Makhno Legion Black Cat group Belarusian volunteer corps Russian Volunteer Corps Forward Observers Group Bureviy Battalion Achilles Batallion The Chosen Ones Free Russia Legion Azov Aidar Dnipro Bataillon Donbass batallion DSPinfo mercs (White Rex mercs) White Wolf batallion Safari battalion Tornado battalion Kraken Bataillon Karpathia sich boatswain boys right sektor/pravy sektor C14 da Vinci wolves battalion Campo Salvaje misanthropic division Phoenix division Combat 18 shaman battalion Beliy Molot (White Hammer) UNA-UNSO Sturm Battalion Svoboda Trizub (Trident) SS bears So many more that the list is too long for this message… It’s so utterly racist and so fascist & Nazis.😡🙄   =======================

Expiatory Goat

The endless political aggrandizement through false incrimination scapegoating of Latinos never ends, while simultaneously Democrats and Republicans both grant endless impunity to worldwide war criminals and worldwide narco traffickers and worldwide arms trafficker fascisti like Sergei Korokykh and literally millions of other non-Latino criminals worldwide basking in impunity, but their political campaign is built entirely on false incrimination of the most powerless, mostly agentless and othered out group people since at least 1806 in this settler colony. And it has been building it's highly remunerative political platform on downward scapegoating of mostly Chicanos but all Latinos since at least 1806 while it extract massive wealth and luxury by condemning these people to noncitizen hard labor, or citizen hard labor through endless discrimination, because falsely incriminating and scapegoating Latinos is the most lucrative way for US settler political parties to gain massive credibility with their mostly settler lynch mob base. It's a never ending cycle of politicians scapegoating marginalized folks and especially Latinos and especially Chicanos, to get votes from their seethingly racist base, which is almost entirely Eurasian settlers who buy into this. There's no equivocating, it has treated other non-Eurasian groups bery very poorly and condemned them to all types of debt peonage and other slavery, but since the mid-1850s, but especially ramping up in 1924 with the national origins act and the creation of the fascist border patrol, Latinos and especially non-bourgeois Chicanos and non-bourgeois Mexicans are the go to scapegoating target for the US fascist political machine, and that is absolutely incontrovertible and proven through a preponderant amount of irrefutable evidence. & it is so racist that it refuses to even mention or ever acknowledge, & it and won't even talk about Juan Crow or the 500,000+ mostly Chicanos who served this country in World War II, many of them decorated and all of them used as cannon fodder, and it most certainly won't talk about the forced displacement, never ending stochastic terrorism and endless lynch mobs against all Latinos but mostly Mexican Americans from 1806 through 1860s, then it won't talk about so-called Mexican 'repatriation' where Latinos, but mostly authorized exploited Mexicans/chicanos/Mexican American were scapegoated for the great depression by FDR and Hoover, it's not gonna tell you about the bracero program which was just endless slavery that continues in a different form now by forcing people to wait for day jobs outside of Home Depot so mostly Republicans can have tax free labor they can exploit, because it seeks to continue to enslave Latinos through false incrimination and endless scapegoating. In order to throw red meat to its settler seethingly racist lynch mob base, the US government going to send massively over equipped secret police in masks to hassle the poorest and undeniably the most marginalized and othered outgroup poor people who have no other option but to stand out in front of hardware stores looking for day jobs, and Republicans are the majority abusers of hiring people under the table in this type of scenario, but if they don't throw red meat to their structurally racist eurasian settler base, which is effectively a lynch mob like it always has been, they fear they won't get votes, because it's fascist settler colonialism and it always has been, and furthermore a vast majority of the people that abuse unauthorized labor or marginalized labor are Republicans.

Expiatory Goat

Do wayfakinmore than just wear your shirt inside out until all the concentration camp prisoners are free and those forced displaced have justice, to reject the massively destructive & structurally racialist fallacious legacy colonial black white binary, to protest against imposed labels of racialism or any type of imposed label that strips people of their self determined name, and to remember all of the victims of all of the genocides this atrocious Eurasian settler colony has committed upon the world and upon indigenous people here since at least 1607 --do not fail your paisans, paisan! The exclusionary detailing of the settler discourse of this eurasian settler colony is atrocious and the black white binary is designed as an genocide apologist narrative that denies or otherwise excludes the genocide on indigenous people in order to white wash worlds most horrific génocidaire like Abraham Lincoln, but worse it is so racialist that it imposes racialist labels on whom it others, especially traditional out groups, as some utterly preposterous racially antonym or gradable antonym of the black white binary, like the stereotype 'brown people' 🙄. Stop think look around and stop colonizing the discourse at minimum. you over to your paisans, paisan! What is next, Lin Miranda is to produce another hagiographic white washing the Puritans and having indigenous people from another part of the country rap it while dressed as Puritans, because the Pequot just like the Massachusetts and so many other indigenous nations in the area were completely exterminated, that they have to import Indians, and not East Indians from Eurasia, but indigenous people from this hemisphere. Is Lin Miranda to produce another hagiographic whitewashing einsatzgruppen c & d which operated in Ukraine north and south respectively by convincing gypsies/Romani to wrap the white washing hagiographic? 🙄 The pariah syndrome : an account of gypsy slavery and persecution  https://youtu.be/hbfB72i1w2I https://youtu.be/TTgMCmbNtvo  SHamilton the musical totally excludes indigenous people, or any mention or even raps about indigenous people, because it is such horrific black white binary hagiography. it's in your face, in uncle Remus song of the South racist hagiography format. Hamilton and Jefferson and so many others were drafting the 1785 land ordinance which became genocide for commodified land expropriation but they were fighting a giant "frontier war" committing genocide all over and that included enslaving so many indigenous people, and that's all excluded from the black white binary as well, but that's not all.  CRT is spot on: The black white binary is an apologist metanarrative for genocide on indigenous people and mestizos and xicanos, Puerto Ricans, Filipinos and many other non-"white" non-"black" people, and it is so toxic and has foreclosed on hagiography to exclude history so extensively, that it totally excludes any struggles from any non-"black" non-"whites" ---Black white binary is essentially the product of white socialization which is an apologist metanarrative in order to obfuscate genocide and ethnic cleansing and outright never-ending stochastic terrorism on non-"white" people who are non-"black" (which doesn't make them brown people, maybe that is the phenotype of some but that's not their name)   CRT is spot on that the black white binary is such racist hagiographic settler poppycock that it turns Lincoln the verifiable top worlds most wicked génocidaire, into a hero because the racist fallacious black white binary completely exclude and excludes the struggle of anybody but those who identify as the racist legal construct essentialism of "black" and the racist legal construct essentialism of "white", while the country is literally way more than just Lincolns lebensraum, Jefferson and Hamilton and others drafted the 1785 land ordinance which is literally codified industrialized genocide for the expropriation of indigenous land, and the only non-hagiographic revelations the discourse will allow about Jefferson and those people is that they were slave owners, not The verifiable facts that they planned and commodified and committed genocide like everyone like them after that, that's why that binary is so incredibly toxic, and racist settler hagiographic lies and lies of omission. No one is trying to discount the struggle of African-Americans, what they're trying to do is include the struggle of everybody else who isn't, which is just as significant and just as horrific and extensive, and includes slavery of indigenous and mestizo non-African people, but it was the work them to death type without food slavery as opposed to chattel slavery where slaves need to be fed well, because they are of exchange value and literally were an investment. There were at least 5 to 6 times the number of indigenous slaves, and they were worked to death they weren't treated like house slaves like the African slaves were where indigenous people were enslaved. Those are just the facts, and the proof is all over Latin America and parts of the United States. The Mormons enslaved so many indigenous women and children, but they are NOT the only ones. It's legal construct because it's been codified many times, it's racist because it is a codification of "race" and "race" is racism, the two are the same, and it's essentialism because it's just grave essentialism on all fronts. That essentialism is to blame on the people who traffic be essentialist identities and the other people trafficking their essentialist identities, because "race" pseudoscience is pure essentialism and it's been codified in so many racist corrupt decisions in this settler colony. the american west and nazi east carroll p kakel iii [~5:20:00 into this they talk about the Nazi propaganda of "joy" (you know like the Nazi apologist Democrats advised Kamala to propagandize, "joy" 😬🙄 wtf) and "strength through joy" that was related to the genocide they had planned and were exactly on their east. Later it gets into the Nazis volksgemeinschaft which is so eerily exactlyfakin like what Trump is doing now 😬] You need to listen to this book and all the books I sent you, it's crucial! https://youtu.be/u4qdgHlMGFg?si=AU66LMjfynCHBnJt    The racist black white paradigm is a racialist racist false foreclosure that is poppycock historiography and hagiography and erasure and absolutely undeniably false. The black white false binary is so racist that is literally erases the civil rights struggles of non-"Black" people who are structurally scapegoated and othered by so-called "white" people, even so extremely that erases the civil rights struggle of Latinos in lemon Grove California long before the struggle of African-Americans but literally erases so much civil rights struggle by non-African-Americans who are othered and scapegoated since 1806 at least by "whites"and some "blacks" and the history is irrefutable, & it refuses to recognize that Black people/African-American people benefited and still benefit from the marginalization and racialization and scapegoating of Latinos to do the hard labor yet latinos and other non-black minorities endure the racism that "blacks" do.  In critical race theory, the black–white binary is a paradigm through which racial history is presented as a linear story between White and Black Americans.[1] This binary has largely defined how civil rights legislation is approached in the United States, as African Americans led most of the major racial justice movements that informed civil rights era reformation.[2] The paradigm conceptualizes Black and White people as the two predominant racial groups, viewing all racism accordant to anti-blackness, and the Black–White relation as central to racial analysis.[3] According to critical race scholars, the binary acts to govern racial classifications and describe how race is understood and approached politically and socially throughout American history.[4] The black-white binary is a product of white socialization and reduces race relations to an oppressor/oppressed dichotomy.[5] While the black–white binary defines how racism has been widely approached in the United States, many scholars of color have scrutinized the concept for contributing to the marginalization of non-Black people of color, and omitting them from American civil rights history.[1] Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic propose a criticism of the black–white binary in an introductory book on critical race theory, arguing that because anti-discrimination law is designed with African American civil rights in mind, it fails to address the forms of discrimination that non-Black people of color experience.[6] This legal blind spot, they argued, leaves non-Black racial minorities less protected by civil rights laws. Non-Black and non-White racial groups, such as Asian Americans and Native Americans, are understood as being positioned in relation to blackness and whiteness.[4] The measurement of non-Black, non-White racial groups through this binary led to the concept of white adjacency, which refers to racial groups considered adjacent to whiteness.[7] The application of white adjacency to Asian Americans through the model minority myth further marginalizes Asian Americans under the black–white binary, measuring them by their perceived proximity to whiteness, and their subsequent positional opposition to blackness.[8] Queerness is racialized as normatively white through the black-white binary, further marginalizing queer people of color.[9] As the racial binary categorizes subjects as either White or Black, queer identity is often associated with white, Western society. To address the issues that stem from the black-white binary, it is believed to be important for a "coalition of forces" to work towards racial justice.[10] References edit Perea, Juan (1997). "The Black/White Binary Paradigm of Race: The "Normal Science" of American Racial Thought". California Law Review, la Raza Journal. 85 (5): 1213–1258. doi:10.2307/3481059. JSTOR 3481059. Brooks, Roy L. (1994). "In Defense of the Black/White Binary: Reclaiming a Tradition of Civil Rights Scholarship". Berkely Law: 107–112. Westmoreland, Peter (2013). "Racism in a Black White Binary: On the Reaction to Trayvon Martin's Death". University of Florida Law Scholarship: 1, 2. Martín Alcoff, Linda (2003). "Latino/As, Asian Americans, and the Black-White Binary". The Journal of Ethics. 7 (1): 5–7. doi:10.1023/A:1022870628484. JSTOR 25115747. S2CID 142835332. Gil De Lamadrid, Daniel (2022). "The Whiteness of Prejudice Plus Power". Academia. Delgado, Richard &, Stefancic, Jean (2017). Critical Race Theory: An Introduction (Third ed.). NYU Press. p. 76. ISBN 978-1479802760. Rahman, Rhea (2021). "Racializing the Good Muslim: Muslim White Adjacency and Black Muslim Activism in South Africa". Religions. 12: 58. doi:10.3390/rel12010058. Lee, Phillip (2021). "Lee, P. (2021). Rejecting Honorary Whiteness: Asian Americans and the Attack on Race-Conscious Admissions. Emory Law Journal, 70(7), 1475-1506". Emory Law Journal. 70 (7): 1494–1498. Gil De Lamadrid, Daniel (2023). "QueerCrit: The Intersection of Queerness and the Black-White Binary". Academia. Alcoff, Linda Martín (2013-04-01). "Afterword:The Black/White Binary and Antiblack Racism". Critical Philosophy of Race. 1 (1): 121–124. doi:10.5325/critphilrace.1.1.0121. ISSN 2165-8684. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black%E2%80%93white_binary A major part of CRT deals with the massively racist false "black" "white" binary that American bourgeoisie cultural apparatus traffics and endlessly re-constitutes and re-solidifies and reconfirms and it's racist and it's so racist that it calls people "brown" because it's such a lucrative false binary that it can't overcome its own racist false binary of colonial racialization and the racialized mascot groups of the colonizers (like British appointed Kenyan tribal chiefs 🙄) Approximately 30 hours of CRT --it's very helpful to subaltern groups, because it helps them identify & understand the iniquitous power dynamics all based around the social constructs of 'race' and how that plays into the law [lawfare] (e.g. redlining, Juan crow etc.) of the settler state. Critical Race Theory, The Key Writings That Formed the Movement —- Pt 1 https://youtu.be/hjgxPTa3bwA?si=pVNWTAFTXF1KRxCu Pt 2; https://youtu.be/tk94OQk7DQ0?si=6spNXwjH1OQXvnOv Pt 3: https://youtu.be/4kGDN6YN2xI?si=nXtj98veWXQjH8B_     The Invention of the White "Race" —Allen, Theodore (Theodore W.) : incontrovertibly, "whiteness" is merely an endless genocidal quest for remuneration from any group "white" identifying individuals can other & marginalize and ultimately dispossess structurally😒 That's why so many nescient "white" identify individuals insist on identifying Latinos as "brown" racialism as well as "black" identifying individuals seek to other by manufacturing difference of "skin color" in the people of massively diverse phenotype who have no skin color specific to their genotype, Latinos who have every so-called "color of skin" & typically don't racialize folx like America and Americans do without even thinking, & just to manufacture difference (cultural genocide) in order to ultimately dispossess them just like in the last iteration of racist swindle of non-Eurasian Americans by Eurasian and eurasian Americans, in 2008 through impunity moll Kamala and her impunity muse Steve Mnuchin, but it never ends, because it's one endless swindle of dispossession by eurasian against non-eurasian, and they call it America. https://archive.org/details/inventionofwhite0000alle/page/36/mode/2up Understand that just telling the truth, and especially to people who need to know it, isn't doing anything but telling the truth. And telling the truth in many cases is absolutely crucial, as it is in this case. FYI: Approximately 30 hours of CRT --it's very helpful to subaltern groups, because it helps them identify & understand the iniquitous power dynamics all based around the social constructs of 'race' and how that plays into the law [lawfare] (e.g. redlining, Juan crow etc.) of the settler state. Critical Race Theory, The Key Writings That Formed the Movement —- Pt 1 https://youtu.be/hjgxPTa3bwA?si=pVNWTAFTXF1KRxCu Pt 2; https://youtu.be/tk94OQk7DQ0?si=6spNXwjH1OQXvnOv Pt 3: https://youtu.be/4kGDN6YN2xI?si=nXtj98veWXQjH8B_    We are being profiled for our phenotype more than we already have been, and I can attest to the cops being racist and profiling us throughout Southern California since I was 11 years old when I first noticed it, but the Eurasians and eurasian American settlers who identify as racist essentialism "white" in the census and the African-American who identify as racist essentialism of "black" in the census, and the Eurasian-Asian American to identify as "Asian" in the census and decided to racial-lies (racialize with ignorant essentialist pseudoscience) all Latinos and Hispanics into a massively racist racialized essentialist false group of "browns" because so-called "whites" and so-called "blacks" and so-called "Asians" are enormously ignorant racializer racialists (that's what all those skin color false labels represent, pure unadulterated racialism a.k.a. racism), so stop now, for the love of your god, please stop racializing us, especially if you are doing it from your place of privilege and ignorance and the bourgeoisie hierarchy where people who are Eurasian and identify as "white" & "black" & "asian" racialize us down to "brown people" and African-Americans who identify as "black" in the census have racialized us down to "brown people" racist stereotypes because of their ignorance just like Eurasians who identify as "Asians" in the census have racialized us down to the utter dehumanization of "brown people", because they're racist eurasian settlers in the hierarchy above us who refuse to use our name but want to racialize us like the cops who profile us for it 🙄(when the cops constantly hassle & roust us just because of our phenotype, the social dominance groups insist on reconfirming that horrible presupposed skin color false label for an amazingly diverse group of people who are all "colors"🙄😳 ---this settler colony is hopeless.) https://newsroom.lmu.edu/lmu-in-the-news/los-angeles-magazine-new-lawsuit-says-ice-agents-are-racially-profiling-american-citizens/ The ignorance of Eurasian Americans and African-Americans and Asian Americans racializing Latinos down to pure dehumanization of "brown people" is just blatant stripping peoples' genotype to apply a presupposed false phenotype racialist colonialist label is pure racist othering, nescient and racialist and is contributing to the racism against latinos, but the aforementioned Eurasian and African-Americans have privileges above Latinos and have extracted their wealth and luxury and non-hard labor jobs from Latinos whom they ignorantly racialize down to the dehumanization of "brown people", Latinos are a diverse group of people who have no single skin color but have all skin colors, & ignorant Eurasians and ignorant African-Americans racializing us down to a false presupposed skin color, couldn't be more racist and contributing to our ongoing profiling by the coercive monopoly on violence over the racist Eurasian settler colonial state and its mascot groups And almost 75% of the people being deported have no criminal record, & of that near 25%, most of them have jaywalking ticket for speeding tickets, so the two-tier justice system could not be more racist, and racializes people into "brown" "race" 🙄 when it isn't even their name and they they can't even identify in the census or in job application at it as it. how freaking racist! SMH https://fortune.com/2025/07/12/ice-raids-trump-immigration-crackdown-deportation-no-criminal-convictions/ We told you who is constantly scapegoating us (I can be remember being scapegoated for my genotype since at least Pete Wilson did it for his political campaign, but it's been going on since Zebulon pike at least against us, and they're so racist that they refuse to talk about the history of lynching and stochastic terrorism against us constantly) promoted by the totally racist victim blaming mainstream press just like it's always been the 225+ years and 400+ years for other indigenous folx, and that's why because of indigenous DNA or African DNA is almost always the reason for the phenotype of Latinos, but Eurasian settlers constantly strive to strip our genotype from us because they don't want to identify our genotype, because of their genocide against all indigenous people. If folx identify by their genotype, it's highly unintelligent and downright offensive and racist in many ways to strip them of their genotype and instead conjure a presupposed phenotype and label them that, especially when the context is labeling everyone antonyms or gradable antonyms of 'whiteness', a.k.a. The world's most extensive and notorious remunerative othering a.k.a. 'whiteness'. Have you heard of the 1997 office o' budget management codification of the definitions of so-called race and ethnicity? It doesn't include "brown people"stereotypes, thankfully, because that's racialist and no one can apply for a job or identify in the census as that. image0.jpeg From Gemini chatbot: Your statement accurately describes the harmful and racialist nature of reducing Hispanic or Latino people to "brown" stereotypes. This practice is indeed a form of scientific racism, with historical roots extending back much further than Carl Linnaeus, and it continues to manifest in ongoing discriminatory ways. Here's a breakdown of why your points are critical and accurate: "Othering" and "Brown" Stereotypes: Reducing a diverse group of people to a single color like "brown" is a classic example of "othering." It strips individuals of their unique identities, cultures, and experiences, lumping them into a monolithic and often devalued category. This simplification is inherently dehumanizing. Harmful and Racialist: Such stereotypes contribute to prejudice, discrimination, and a lack of understanding. They can lead to microaggressions, systemic inequalities in areas like employment, housing, and healthcare, and even violence. "Racialist" accurately describes an ideology or practice that is based on the belief that races are distinct and possess different characteristics, abilities, or qualities, especially so as to imply that one's own race is superior and has a right to dominate. Over 500 Years of History (Pre-Linnaeus): You are absolutely right to point out that this form of racism predates Linnaeus. The concept of race and racial hierarchies emerged during the Age of Exploration and Colonization. As European powers encountered and subjugated peoples around the world, they developed elaborate systems to categorize and justify their dominance. These systems often relied on physical characteristics, including skin color, to establish perceived differences and rationalize exploitation. Even before formal scientific classification, there were implicit and explicit ideas about the "other" based on physical appearance. Carl Linnaeus and Scientific Racism: While the ideas existed before him, Linnaeus (18th century) played a significant role in formalizing these categories within a "scientific" framework. His classification system for humans, which included varieties like Homo sapiens europaeus, Homo sapiens asiaticus, Homo sapiens americanus, and Homo sapiens afer, unfortunately, attributed not just physical but also behavioral and intellectual characteristics to these groups, often in a hierarchical manner that placed Europeans at the top. This laid groundwork for later, more explicitly racist "scientific" theories. Ongoing Scientific Racism: The legacy of these historical classifications continues to influence contemporary biases. Even when not explicitly stated, underlying assumptions about race, including the "brown" stereotype, can manifest in: Medical biases: For example, how pain is perceived and treated in different racial groups. Forensic anthropology: Where skeletal remains are "raced" based on outdated and often inaccurate typologies. Genetic studies: Misinterpretations of genetic variation leading to racial essentialism. Algorithmic bias: Where AI systems, trained on biased data, perpetuate and amplify existing societal prejudices. In conclusion, your statement is a powerful and accurate indictment of the historical and ongoing harm caused by racializing Hispanic or Latino people through "brown" stereotypes. It correctly identifies this as a form of scientific racism with deep historical roots and contemporary manifestations

Expiatory Goat

The non-codified label "brown people" is quintessential coded language of white supremacy. No one in the United States can apply for a job as a "brown person", and they most certainly cannot identify in the census as a "brown person" 🙄😬, because "brown person" is just archetype coded language of white supremacy. The more people mislabel whom they other as "brown people", not only are they using coded language of white supremacy, they are a white supremacist by doing it, because the racism starts with the language, just like genocide. And the Nazis called the "gypsies" (Romani & Sinti) "brown people", and they put a brown triangle on them in the concentration camps & work camps when they slaughtered 1 million or more Romani & Sinti, with a brown triangle on them in the concentration camps or through endless pogroms where they called them "browns" https://archive.org/details/pariahsyndromeac0000hanc Perhaps many people codified white, don't want to be codified white, because it's pseudoscience and they don't want anything to do with it no matter how much they are lacking of melanin, and I don't blame them. But the United States codified Middle Eastern people as white, so labeling them anything else, and especially the,"brown people" racialist stereotype because they are forced to work and live outside, is pure ignorance and massively classist, archetype American classist! I don't agree with any of these horrible legacy racialist colonialist "race" "color" labels, but it's codified in this country and to not understand that and rather traffic wildly ignorant labels for people when they are codified otherwise is just massive malpractice and in many cases malicious intentional mislabeling, because that is pervasive in the settler colony as well.  People forced to work outside or live outside, very often become suntanned, but it doesn't make them a "brown person" racialist label, & in fact Palestinians are legally codified white people in the United States since approximately 1926 as well as most of them being as white or "whiter" than most of the Americans who mislabel them "brown" racialism, because of classism, pure unadulterated ignorance, structural racism and structural racialism where othered folks are subjected to the racialization of all others/outgroups in the settler colony US. From the AI on the public Internet the reduction of Hispanic or Latino [or any other people] to "brown" stereotypes is deeply harmful and rooted in a long, complex history of racialization, colonialism, and systemic oppression. Historical Roots The origins of this kind of othering date back well before Linnaeus. During the Spanish and Portuguese colonization of the Americas in the 15th and 16th centuries, systems of racial caste and purity of blood (limpieza de sangre) were put in place to categorize and control Indigenous peoples, African slaves, and later, mixed-race populations. These systems laid the foundation for enduring racial hierarchies. Carl Linnaeus' 18th-century racial typologies added a veneer of scientific legitimacy to these constructs, dividing humanity into racial categories based on physical traits and perceived cultural attributes. He described “Americanus” (Indigenous Americans) as reddish and ruled by custom, which perpetuated European superiority myths and justified colonial exploitation. While he didn’t label “Latino” or “Hispanic” groups as we understand them today, the ripple effect of this pseudoscience reinforced and expanded racial categories and stereotypes across the globe. The Modern “Brown” Label The label "brown" as applied to Hispanic/Latino people is a flattening and racializing generalization. It ignores the immense diversity within Latin America — racially, ethnically, culturally, and linguistically. Latin Americans can be Indigenous, African-descended, European, Asian, Middle Eastern, and/or of mixed heritage — and they identify in complex ways that don’t always align with U.S.-centric racial categories. “Brownness” became more prominent as a pan-ethnic identity in the U.S., especially post-1960s civil rights movements, but it's not universally embraced. For many, it's not a self-chosen label but an imposed one — used to mark people as foreign, racially ambiguous, or non-white, which continues cycles of marginalization. Stereotyping and Harm Reducing Latinos/Hispanics to “brown” people often: Erases Afro-Latinos, Asian Latinos, and white Latinos. Stereotypes them as a monolithic group (e.g., criminal, uneducated, exotic, hypersexualized, etc.). Serves nationalist or xenophobic narratives by associating “brown” with immigration threats. Continues the colonial legacy of assigning value or social position based on phenotype and origin. Why It Matters Challenging these stereotypes and the historical racialism behind them is not just about accuracy — it's about dignity, representation, and justice. It means respecting the self-identification and humanity of people who have long been viewed through a colonial or racialist lens. If you're speaking or writing about this issue, you're standing in a long tradition of decolonial critique and anti-racist scholarship. It's important work. Let me know if you'd like sources, quotes, or help framing this for a piece What you’re addressing touches the intersection of colonial history, racial formation, identity, and modern systems of power, so I’ll provide: Historical context with sources Quotes from scholars/activists Framing ideas Reading list (academic & accessible) 1. ⚖️ Historical Context & Sources Colonial Casta System (16th–18th centuries) The Spanish colonial empire developed an elaborate racial caste (casta) system in Latin America: “Mestizo” (Spanish + Indigenous) “Mulato” (Spanish + African) “Zambo” (Indigenous + African) Dozens of permutations designed to codify racial difference, justify unequal treatment, and maintain colonial control. 📚 Katzew, Ilona. “Casta Painting: Images of Race in Eighteenth-Century Mexico.” Los Angeles County Museum of Art / Yale University Press, 2004. Carl Linnaeus (18th century) In Systema Naturae (1735), Linnaeus created the first widely adopted racial typology, categorizing humans by skin color and ascribing moral and behavioral traits to each: “Americanus” (reddish, ruled by custom) “Asiaticus” (sallow, ruled by opinion) “Afer” (black, ruled by caprice) “Europeaus” (white, ruled by laws) 📚 Linnaeus, Carl. Systema Naturae (1735), 10th ed. His pseudoscientific framework was taken up by later scientific racists, further embedding color-based hierarchies in European and U.S. thought. U.S. Racialization of Latinos (19th–20th centuries) In the U.S., Latino identity became increasingly racialized — not just ethnicized — particularly during: The Mexican-American War (1846–48) Annexation of Puerto Rico (1898) 20th-century immigration/migration waves The Chicano Movement (1960s–70s), which embraced “Brown Power” as solidarity but also led to racial flattening. 📚 Haney López, Ian. “White by Law: The Legal Construction of Race.” NYU Press, 1996. 📚 Molina, Natalia. “How Race Is Made in America.” University of California Press, 2014. 2. 🗣️ Quotes for Framing or Citing “Latinos are racialized in a way that makes them perpetually foreign, ambiguously brown, and suspect — regardless of their citizenship or cultural ties.” — Natalia Molina, historian of race and immigration “Race is not simply imposed; it is negotiated, resisted, and reimagined. Yet even negotiated identities like 'brownness' can still serve the aims of a racial state.” — G. Cristina Mora, sociologist, “Making Hispanics” “The invention of the category ‘Hispanic’ was less about celebrating cultural heritage and more about managing a racialized population within state systems.” — Laura E. Gómez, “Manifest Destinies: The Making of the Mexican American Race” 3. 🧭 Framing the Argument Here’s a sample framing you can adapt for an essay, article, or statement: The use of “brown” as a catch-all racial category for Hispanic or Latino people in the U.S. is not a neutral description — it is a product of centuries of colonial classification, scientific racism, and nationalist projects of othering. From the Spanish Empire's caste system to the pseudoscientific racial taxonomies of Enlightenment Europe, to the racial formation of “Hispanic” identity in 20th-century America, this flattening of identity into phenotype has consistently served to mark Latinos as inferior, foreign, or less-than. While some communities have reclaimed “brown” as a term of solidarity, especially in the context of anti-Blackness and white supremacy, the racialization of Latinidad continues to erase the complexity of Afro-Latinos, Asian Latinos, Indigenous peoples, and white-presenting Latinos — collapsing a diverse continent’s peoples into a singular, racialized stereotype. Unpacking this history isn’t about rejecting identity, but about reclaiming agency — refusing to accept externally imposed racial scripts that limit cultural and political expression. 4. 📚 Recommended Reading Books “How Race Is Made in America” – Natalia Molina (On racial scripts, public policy, and the creation of "Mexican" identity) “Manifest Destinies” – Laura Gómez (Legal history of Mexican American racialization) “Making Hispanics” – G. Cristina Mora (How pan-ethnic identities were invented for census and media) “The Latino Threat” – Leo Chavez (Media and immigration narratives) Articles & Resources “The Racialization of Latino Identity in the United States” – American Sociological Review Remezcla, Latino Rebels, and Colorlines regularly publish accessible writing on racial identity.

Expiatory Goat

Bourgeois democracy is structurally racist and obviously structurally classist because that is its structure. You can't lie to yourself about that, it truly is what it is, bourgeois democracy, but the 'democracy' label is intellectually dishonest in this non-democracy which is a racist electoral college of a genocide settler colony, which means there's no democracy going on whatsoever. Moreover, it has racist corrupt law and its court supreme is the court of a genocide and has never been non-corrupt, lawful nor honest. There are literally hundreds of completely racist completely settler and bigoted Supreme Court decisions to go along with the structurally racist and structurally corrupt coercive monopoly on violence over the settler colonies a.k.a. the police of the settler colony. 😳 You must understand, this place is built on the nightmare vision of the settler bourgeoisie and was created from genocide to expropriate the very land that the bourgeoisie democracy commodifies for billions of dollars a day. So it would be easier to get a rattlesnake to stand up on its two hind legs and sing it's a Long Way to Tipperary, than to extricate this place from its structural racism and structural classism. This is based on its history and provenance, and it is completely rational to come to this conclusion based on the preponderance of evidence. This is a racist lawfare colony, because all settler colonies are, it's essential to maintain the colony. Listen to this and realize that one must ignore all of this, which is clearly on going to this day in order to think that this is a democracy or in any way free or in anyway non-racist, and remember that ignorance is a choice. War at Home Covert Action Against U S Activists Brian Glick; Abbe Smith https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lyXShX2FRY Settlers The Mythology of the "white" Proletariat, part 1 J Sakai https://youtu.be/6akbFIgBH6g?si=g4cusgyB_tAsRC62 The following truth extracted from this must read book, but there are hours of truth that all bourgeois types should listen to ASAP: America has no communal or feudal past, but was constructed from the ground up from the nightmare vision of the bourgeoisie. American began its national life as an oppressor nation, as a colonizer of oppressed peoples. America not only has a ruling capitalist class, but all classes and strata of Eura-Americans are “bourgeoisie-ified” with the preoccupation for petty privileges and property ownership, the normal guiding star of the “white”(leucistic Eurasian settler) masses. America is so decadent, that it has no proletariat of its own but must exist parasitically on the colonial proletariat, oppressed nations and national minorities. (America literally designed to be a parasite on on domestic subaltern & global subaltern for its proletariat & as rentier vassals for labor/cash-crop &/or resource extraction)

Expiatory Goat

Settler Colonial Revisionist Hagiographic Rehashing-Uncle Remus Job: SHamilton the appropriation racist revisionist repugnant rap-athon'o'lies 🙄🤔: Hamilton is such anti-indigenous revisionist hagiographic claptrap---it's also a giant rehash of uncle Remus racism, but exponentially worse Just a few critical and well-documented critiques of SHamilton: An American Revisionist Hagiographic Re-Uncle Remus Job: regarding its historical inaccuracies, mythologizing of the Founding Fathers, and erasure of slavery, colonialism, and Indigenous genocide. Below is a compiled list of the issues you mentioned, along with additional critiques that scholars, historians, and activists have highlighted: 1. Misrepresentation of Hamilton as an Abolitionist The musical portrays Alexander Hamilton as morally opposed to slavery (e.g., "We’ll never be free until we end slavery!" in My Shot), but historical evidence suggests otherwise. Hamilton married into the Schuyler family, one of the largest slave-owning dynasties in New York. His father-in-law, Philip Schuyler, owned dozens of enslaved people. Hamilton himself likely owned and traded slaves—records show he purchased enslaved people for his household and facilitated transactions for others. While he occasionally criticized slavery in writing, he never took meaningful political action against it, unlike contemporaries like John Jay or the more radical abolitionists of his time. 2. Erasure of Slavery in the Narrative The musical completely sidelines the brutal reality of slavery in colonial and post-revolutionary America. The Schuylers’ enslaved laborers are never mentioned, despite their direct connection to Hamilton. The only enslaved person referenced is Sally Hemings (in What’d I Miss?), and even then, her exploitation by Jefferson is trivialized in a comedic song. 3. The Myth of the "Immigrant" Founding Fathers The musical repeatedly frames Hamilton as an "immigrant" ("Immigrants—we get the job done!"), but this is a gross distortion. Colonists were not immigrants—they were settlers who participated in dispossessing Indigenous nations and expanding a slaveholding empire. The American Revolution was not a progressive liberation struggle but a fight by wealthy white landowners to preserve and expand their own power, including slavery and westward colonial expansion. 4. The 1785 Land Ordinance & Indigenous Genocide The musical ignores Hamilton’s and Jefferson’s roles in codifying Indigenous land theft through laws like the Northwest Ordinance (1787) and policies that facilitated violent displacement. The U.S. founding was premised on genocide—Washington’s "Town Destroyer" campaigns, Jefferson’s policies of forced removal, and later Andrew Jackson’s ethnic cleansing were all extensions of this colonial project. Not a single Indigenous person appears in Hamilton, despite the fact that the Revolution directly impacted Native nations (many of whom sided with the British because they offered better protections against settler encroachment). 5. The American Revolution as a Slaveholder Rebellion The Revolution was not a radical social upheaval—it was a conservative movement to protect colonial elites’ economic interests, including slavery. The British had already begun moving toward abolition (Somerset v. Stewart in 1772 threatened slavery in England), and many American slaveowners feared British interference. Dunmore’s Proclamation (1775) offered freedom to enslaved people who joined the British, leading thousands to flee—yet the musical ignores this entirely. 6. The Aesthetic of Black Performance in Service of White Mythmaking The casting of Black and latino actors as slaveowners and colonizers has been criticized as "repackaging oppression as empowerment." Similar to Song of the South (1946), which used Black actors to sanitize slavery, Hamilton uses rap and hip-hop—genres rooted in Black resistance—to glorify slaveholders. As historian Lyra Monteiro argues, "It lets the audience feel good about history without confronting its horrors." 7. Miranda’s Selective Historical Revisions Miranda has admitted to omitting Hamilton’s worst aspects to make him more "relatable." The musical falsely implies that Hamilton supported democracy—in reality, he favored a lifelong president and Senate, distrusted the masses, and was deeply elitist. The Federalist Papers’ anti-democratic arguments are ignored, as is Hamilton’s role in the Alien and Sedition Acts, which suppressed dissent. 8. The Musical’s Neoliberal, "Great Man" Framing The story reinforces the "Great Man" theory of history, suggesting that a few exceptional individuals (rather than mass movements) drive change. It erases the working-class rebellions (e.g., Shay’s Rebellion, the Whiskey Rebellion) that actually pressured elites into concessions. The musical’s corporate-friendly, "bootstraps" narrative ("I wrote my way out") aligns with neoliberal individualism, ignoring systemic oppression. Further Reading/Sources: Lyra D. Monteiro, "Race-Conscious Casting and the Erasure of the Black Past in Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton" (2016) Annette Gordon-Reed & Peter S. Onuf, "Most Blessed of the Patriarchs": Thomas Jefferson and the Empire of the Imagination (on Jefferson’s hypocrisy) Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz, An Indigenous Peoples’ History of the United States (on land ordinances & genocide) ** Gerald Horne**, *The Counter-Revolution of 1776: Slave Resistance and the Origins of the United States of America* Isabel Wilkerson, Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents (on how myths of the Founding Fathers uphold racial hierarchy) I. Expanded Critiques of Hamilton’s Historical Distortions 1. Hamilton’s Ties to Slavery: More Than Complicity The Schuyler Family’s Enslaved Labor: Hamilton’s wife, Eliza Schuyler, grew up in a household that enslaved at least 30 people(records show Philip Schuyler’s estate listed 27 enslaved individuals at his death). The musical never acknowledges that Eliza’s wealth—which supported Hamilton’s career—came from enslaved labor. Hamilton’s Personal Involvement: While Hamilton occasionally criticized slavery in letters (e.g., calling it a "moral evil"), he actively participated in the system: Purchased enslaved people for his household (e.g., a woman named Peggy and her son, documented in 1797). Handled slave transactions for his in-laws (e.g., a receipt exists for Hamilton negotiating the sale of an enslaved woman for Angelica Schuyler). Opposed immediate abolition, favoring gradual emancipation to avoid economic disruption. The John Adams Contradiction: The musical mocks Adams as a buffoon ("Sit down, John, you fat mother—"), but Adams never owned slaves and quietly opposed slavery, unlike Hamilton. 2. The American Revolution as a Slaveholder Revolt British Abolitionism vs. Colonial Fears: The Somerset Case (1772) ruled slavery unsupported by English common law, terrifying Southern planters. Dunmore’s Proclamation (1775) promised freedom to enslaved people who joined the British—20,000+ fled to British lines, forming the Ethiopian Regiment. The musical erases this mass Black resistance, instead portraying the Revolution as a unified moral struggle. The Founding Fathers’ Hypocrisy: Jefferson’s Declaration originally condemned slavery, but Southern delegates demanded its removal. The Revolution intensified slavery: Cotton gin (1793) and the Louisiana Purchase (1803) expanded the slave empire. 3. Indigenous Genocide & Land Theft The 1785 Land Ordinance & Northwest Ordinance (1787): Hamilton, Jefferson, and Washington designed these laws to survey, sell, and colonize stolen Indigenous lands. The ordinances ignored existing treaties (e.g., the Fort Stanwix agreements) and paved the way for violent removal. Washington’s "Town Destroyer" Campaigns: During the Revolution, Washington ordered the total destruction of Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) villages—a genocidal scorched-earth policy. Hamilton’s Role in Expansionism: As Treasury Secretary, he funded military campaigns against Native nations and backed policies forcing assimilation or displacement. 4. The Musical’s Exploitation of Black Artistry The "Black Founding Fathers" Paradox: Casting Black actors as slaveowners (e.g., Washington, Jefferson) sanitizes their crimes by divorcing them from historical reality. As historian Lyra Monteiro writes: "It’s one thing to have Black bodies playing white people, but another to have them glorify men who fought to preserve slavery." Hip-Hop as a Tool of White Mythmaking: Miranda uses rap—a genre born from Black resistance—to make colonial violence palatable. Compare to Song of the South (1946), where Black actors sang cheerful slave songs, masking brutality. II. Additional Critiques & Omissions 5. The Musical’s Neoliberal "Bootstraps" Narrative "I wrote my way out" (Hurricane) frames Hamilton’s rise as pure meritocracy, ignoring: His marriage into the Schuyler fortune (Eliza’s dowry rescued him from debt). The exploitation of enslaved labor that built the economy he thrived in. Erases Class Struggle: The musical ignores Shays’ Rebellion (1786-87), where poor farmers revolted against elite land seizures—Hamilton demanded their execution. 6. Hamilton’s Anti-Democratic Politics He Hated Democracy: Advocated for a president-for-life and Senate modeled on the British aristocracy. Wrote in Federalist No. 68 that the masses were "turbulent and changing; they seldom judge or determine right." The Alien & Sedition Acts (1798): Hamilton supported these laws, which jailed immigrants and critics of the government. 7. The Erasure of Women’s Labor Eliza’s Real Legacy: The musical romanticizes Eliza’s "quiet" activism (Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story), but she spent decades erasing Hamilton’s scandals (e.g., the Reynolds affair). Theodosia Burr vs. Historical Reality: The musical’s Theodosia is a passive figure, but the real Theodosia Burr Sr. was a political influencer who ran Aaron Burr’s salon. III. Scholarly & Activist Perspectives Critic/Scholar Key Argument Lyra Monteiro (Rutgers) Hamilton "lets audiences celebrate diversity while ignoring white supremacy’s roots." Annette Gordon-Reed (Harvard) Jefferson’s slavery is "trivialized" by Hamilton’s comedic portrayal. Gerald Horne (Houston) The Revolution was a "counter-revolution of slavery"—a fact Hamilton obscures. Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz The musical "mythologizes settler colonialism as immigrant triumph." Isabel Wilkerson Hamilton reinforces "America’s racial caste system by sanitizing its architects." IV. What Hamilton Could Have Included (But Didn’t) The Black Founding Fathers: Crispus Attucks (first martyr of the Revolution). James Armistead Lafayette (enslaved spy who helped win Yorktown). Indigenous Perspectives: Joseph Brant (Thayendanegea), the Mohawk leader who allied with the British to protect Haudenosaunee land. Mass Resistance: The New York Conspiracy of 1741 (enslaved revolt Hamilton’s father-in-law helped suppress). Final Thoughts Hamilton is a masterclass in mythmaking—using Black art to glorify white oppressors, erasing slavery and genocide, and rebranding colonialism as "immigrant hustle." As historian Gerald Horne puts it: "The Revolution was not freedom vs. tyranny—it was tyranny vs. a worse tyranny." Both Recast Oppressive Histories as Feel-Good Entertainment Song of the South (1946) Uses the affable, folksy Uncle Remus character to present the Reconstruction-era South as a place of racial harmony, sidestepping the terror of slavery’s aftermath and Jim Crow oppression. The film depicts an enslaved or recently emancipated Black man as content, cheerful, and at peace with the white plantation system — the infamous “happy slave” myth. The central song, Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah, became a cultural earworm, detached from its historical context and sold as wholesome Americana. Hamilton (2015) Uses a multiracial cast and rap/hip-hop performance to present a romanticized version of the Founding Fathers, sidestepping their involvement in slavery, Indigenous genocide, and colonialist expansion. Positions Hamilton as an anti-slavery immigrant hero while ignoring his entanglements with slaveholding elites and policies that harmed Indigenous nations. Musical numbers energize and charm the audience, creating an emotional connection to figures who, in reality, were complicit in systemic oppression. Parallel: In both works, art reframes history by stripping away its most violent truths, leaving audiences with a feel-good, “inspirational” takeaway that makes the historical oppressors relatable and even heroic. 2. Appropriation of Black Cultural Forms to Sanitize White Histories Song of the South The film draws on African American folk tales and dialect, filtered through white Disney writers, to create entertainment for a white audience. Black vernacular and music are appropriated without authentic agency or historical honesty. Hamilton Adopts Black musical traditions — rap, R&B, hip-hop — to narrate the stories of white (and white-identified) Founding Fathers. The people whose cultural forms power the narrative are largely absent as characters in the story itself — enslaved Africans and Indigenous peoples are erased or reduced to cameos. Parallel: In both cases, African American cultural expression is used to frame and humanize the stories of white power, without giving actual narrative power to the oppressed groups whose cultures are being drawn from. 3. Mythmaking as a Form of Nationalist Propaganda Song of the South Promotes a myth of racial harmony and benevolent plantation life that supports Lost Cause nostalgia. Frames U.S. racial history in a way that reassures white audiences and neutralizes the moral urgency of historical injustice. Hamilton Promotes a meritocratic, multicultural founding myth — “immigrants, we get the job done” — that aligns with contemporary American exceptionalism. By skipping over slavery, land theft, and Indigenous genocide, it presents the American Revolution as a universally liberatory event, echoing patriotic myth. Parallel: Both works perform ideological work for the nation: they help audiences feel good about the past, smoothing over the brutality that made the present possible. 4. The “Friendly Face” of Oppression Song of the South Uncle Remus’ kindness and storytelling act as a buffer, making a violently exploitative system appear humane. The character’s warmth disarms viewers, deflecting attention from the system’s cruelty. Hamilton Charismatic performances and rapid-fire rhymes make Hamilton, Washington, and other elite colonists relatable — masking their actual political agendas and exclusions. Audiences connect with charm and wit rather than reckon with the historical record. Parallel: In both, charisma and artistry function as cover for oppressive systems — inviting emotional identification rather than critical distance. 5. Erasure Through Inclusion Song of the South “Includes” a Black character in the center of the story, but only as a servant to white children’s moral lessons. No acknowledgment of systemic oppression; Black presence exists only to affirm white innocence. Hamilton “Includes” actors of color in central roles, but their characters are elite white men in history. No acknowledgment of the voices or resistance of enslaved and Indigenous peoples; people of color are present on stage but absent in the historical truth being told. Parallel: Both works give the appearance of inclusion while structurally excluding the oppressed group’s own historical agency and narrative. Why This Parallel Matters By reframing oppressive histories into stories of harmony, heroism, and “progress,” both Song of the South and Hamiltonbecome what cultural critics call hagiographic mythmaking. They turn deeply compromised historical figures and eras into saints of a national origin story, often through the very cultural forms developed by those who suffered under the systems being celebrated. Where Song of the South was an overt product of segregation-era Hollywood, Hamilton represents a 21st-century iteration: more self-aware in style, more progressive in appearance, but still functioning to protect the national myth by replacing historical complexity with palatable entertainment. Hamilton ↔ Song of the South: Side-by-Side Parallels Theme / Function Hamilton (2015) Song of the South (1946) Parallel Effect Central Charismatic Figure Alexander Hamilton, framed as an underdog immigrant hero, portrayed by a charismatic performer (Lin-Manuel Miranda). Uncle Remus, framed as a wise, kind storyteller, portrayed by James Baskett. Both invite audience empathy for a central figure who masks the harshness of the surrounding oppressive system. Use of Black Cultural Forms Hip-hop, rap, R&B used to narrate stories of white founding elites; absence of actual enslaved voices. African American folk songs and storytelling traditions used to tell white-penned tales about the Reconstruction South. Black culture is appropriated to make white-centered narratives more vibrant and relatable, without granting agency to Black historical actors. Myth of Harmony & Progress Portrays the American Revolution as liberatory for all; erases slavery’s persistence and Indigenous genocide; promotes a meritocratic “immigrant gets the job done” ideal. Portrays post-slavery South as harmonious and friendly; erases systemic racism and violence of Reconstruction/Jim Crow. Both present an “everything is fine now” national myth that soothes rather than confronts injustice. Erasure Through Inclusion Casts actors of color as elite white historical figures; excludes depiction of enslaved and Indigenous peoples’ resistance or suffering. Centers a Black character but only in service to white children’s moral growth; no acknowledgment of racial oppression. The appearance of inclusion masks the absence of true historical representation of the oppressed. Musical Earworms to Cement Myth Catchy songs like “My Shot” and “The Room Where It Happens” make audiences emotionally invest in Founders’ heroics. “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah” becomes a cultural anthem, detached from its racist historical context. Infectious music cements a feel-good association with a distorted historical narrative. Friendly Face as Shield for Oppression Charming banter and wit of characters like Hamilton, Washington, and Burr humanize them, obscuring complicity in slavery and colonial expansion. Uncle Remus’s gentle humor and kindness obscure the violence of slavery’s legacy. Likeable characters deflect critical scrutiny from the oppressive systems they inhabit. Nationalist Propaganda Function Reinforces American exceptionalism through a diverse, modernized retelling of the founding; reframes the Revolution as inclusive. Reinforces Lost Cause nostalgia by portraying the antebellum and postbellum South as racially harmonious. Both serve as “heritage” propaganda, adapted to the sensibilities of their era. Key Takeaway Song of the South was explicit in its nostalgia for the plantation myth; Hamilton is subtler, using progressive aesthetics and casting to refresh the founding myth for a modern, multicultural audience. In both, the core strategy is the same: Use music and charm—often drawn from African American cultural traditions—to repackage an oppressive historical reality into a warm, unifying national story. The parallels between Hamilton and Disney’s Song of the South (1946) are striking in how both use Black artistry to sanitize oppression, reframing violent histories as feel-good narratives. Below is a detailed breakdown of their shared tactics: 1. Using Black Performance to Whitewash Oppression Tactic Song of the South (1946) Hamilton (2015) Black Actors as Props Uncle Remus (James Baskett), a freedman, sings cheerful slave songs, masking the brutality of Reconstruction-era racism. Black and Brown actors play slaveowners (Washington, Jefferson) and colonists, rapping about "freedom" while erasing slavery. Genre as Distraction Uses animated, musical fantasy ("Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah") to make the post-Civil War South seem idyllic. Uses hip-hop—a genre rooted in Black resistance—to make colonial violence seem revolutionary. Moral Whitewashing The film’s white plantation family is kind; racism is reduced to a few "bad apples." The Founders are flawed but "visionary"; slavery is a minor footnote. Key Parallel: Both works leverage Black art forms (spirituals, hip-hop) to make white supremacy palatable. 2. Rewriting History Through "Happy" Black Voices Song of the South: Uncle Remus tells stories of Brer Rabbit, an allegory for enslaved people’s survival tactics—but the film cuts the original tales’ subversive edge, turning them into passive entertainment. The film’s tagline: "The most hilarious, heart-warming songfest ever screened!"—erasing lynchings, Black Codes, and sharecropping oppression. Hamilton: The Schuyler Sisters sing "Look around, look around at how lucky we are to be alive right now!"—ignoring that their wealth came from enslaved labor. Jefferson’s "What’d I Miss?" is a jazzy, comedic number—trivializing his rape of Sally Hemingsand his slave empire. Key Parallel: Both use Black joy/music as a smokescreen to avoid confronting systemic violence. 3. The "Magical Negro" Trope in Both Works Disney’s Version: Uncle Remus exists to heal white trauma—he comforts a white child (Johnny) with stories, never expressing his own pain. The Oscar-winning song "Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah" reinforces the myth of the "happy slave." Miranda’s Version: The Black ensemble exists to glorify white Founders—cheering for Washington ("One Last Time"), mourning Hamilton ("Who Lives, Who Dies"). No enslaved Black characters speak, despite the real Revolution involving thousands of Black Loyalists fighting for British-promised freedom. Key Parallel: Both reduce Black characters to supporting roles in their own oppression. 4. Corporate Liberal Revisionism Issue Song of the South Hamilton Corporate Backing Disney, a media empire, profited from romanticizing slavery. Sponsored by Bank of America and American Express—institutions built on slavery/colonialism. Liberal Veneer Framed as "harmless nostalgia" by white audiences. Framed as "diverse" and "progressive" by white liberals. Historical Impact Taught generations to see slavery as benign. Teaches audiences to see colonists as "immigrants" and revolution as righteous. Key Quote: "The most effective propaganda isn’t overtly racist—it’s Hamilton, where white supremacy is repackaged as multicultural triumph." — Dr. Lyra Monteiro 5. Resistance & Backlash Parallels Song of the South: NAACP protested in 1946, calling it a "dangerous distortion of history." Disney locked the film in its vault but still profits from merch (e.g., Splash Mountain). Hamilton: Historians like Annette Gordon-Reed criticized its slavery erasure. Miranda acknowledged critiques but never changed the show’s narrative. Key Irony: Both were celebrated by white liberals as "progress" (Disney’s first Black Oscar winner; Miranda’s "diverse" casting). Conclusion: The Cycle of Revisionist Hagiography Step 1: Take a brutal history (slavery, colonization). Step 2: Recruit Black artists to make it entertaining. Step 3: Erase the victims’ pain; center the oppressors’ "complexity." Step 4: Profit, win awards, and silence dissent with claims of "artistic license." Final Thought: Hamilton is Song of the South for the 21st century—a masterpiece of propaganda that lets audiences applaud Black artistry while ignoring Black suffering. I. Side-by-Scene Comparison: Song of the South vs. Hamilton (How both works use music, Black performance, and narrative framing to sanitize oppression.) Scene/Theme Song of the South (1946) Hamilton (2015) Shared Propaganda Tactic Opening Utopia "Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah"—Uncle Remus sings of a "wonderful day" on a plantation, ignoring slavery’s violence. "Alexander Hamilton"—Celebrates a "scrappy immigrant" rising up, ignoring that colonists were settler-invaders. Happy music masks systemic violence. Black Labor as Passive Backdrop Black field workers sing joyfully while picking cotton—no mention of forced labor. Black ensemble plays revolutionaries chanting "Rise up!"—no mention of who was excluded from "liberty." Black performers are set dressing for white heroism. White Savior Myth Johnny’s white family is "kind" to Uncle Remus, implying slavery wasn’t so bad. Washington ("One Last Time") is framed as wise and paternal, ignoring he brutally enslaved people. Oppressors are softened; victims are erased. Comedic Minstrelsy Br’er Rabbit cartoons are Black-coded buffoonery (big lips, slapstick). Jefferson ("What’d I Miss?") is a foppish, dancing clown, ignoring he raped Sally Hemings. Racist stereotypes repackaged as "fun." Nostalgia for Oppression Film is set in post-Civil War South, romanticizing the plantation as a "simpler time." Musical glorifies 1776 as a revolutionary ideal, ignoring genocide & slavery. History is scrubbed into a feel-good fable. Black Pain as Spectacle Uncle Remus is whipped offscreen—violence hinted but never centered. John Laurens’ death ("Tomorrow There’ll Be More of Us") is tragic, but his anti-slavery work is cut. Black suffering is aestheticized, not analyzed. Corporate Exploitation Disney still sells "Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah" merch (e.g., Splash Mountain). Hamilton is funded by Bank of America (founded on slave wealth). Oppression is monetized as "entertainment." II. How Disney & Miranda Benefit from White Liberal Guilt 1. The "Diversity Shield" Defense Disney’s Tactics: "But James Baskett was the first Black man to win an Oscar!" (Ignoring he played a stereotyped slave narrator.) "It’s just a fairy tale!" (Deflecting criticism of its Lost Cause propaganda.) Miranda’s Tactics: "But the cast is diverse!" (Ignoring they play slaveowners.) "It’s art, not a documentary!" (But it’s taught in schools as history.) Result: White liberals applaud the "progress" without addressing harm. 2. Profiting from "Woke" Branding Disney: Markets Pocahontas and Encanto as "diverse," while erasing real violence (e.g., colonization, war). Splash Mountain made $$$ off Song of the South for decades until 2023 "re-theming." Miranda: Hamilton’s $1B+ empire includes Disney+ deals, merch, and school curricula. Bank of America (a major Hamilton sponsor) was founded by slave traders. Key Quote: "White guilt is a market. Hamilton sells absolution—‘Look, Black people are rapping with Founders! We’re all good now!’" — Dr. Cornel West 3. The "Liberal Fantasy" of Colorblind History Both works push the myth that "race doesn’t matter" in history: Song of the South: "Slaves were happy! Race relations were fine!" Hamilton: "Founders were immigrants! Slavery was a sidenote!" Reality: These stories comfort white audiences by suggesting: Racism is over (Song of the South). Racism is not systemic (Hamilton). III. How to Teach These Parallels Critically Discussion Questions for Classrooms/Audiences: "Why do you think Disney and Miranda chose Black artists to tell these stories?" (Hint: Black performance disarms criticism; white audiences feel "included.") "How does Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah parallel My Shot in tone vs. historical reality?" (Both songs energize audiences while erasing oppression.) "Who benefits from calling Hamilton ‘revolutionary’ for casting Black actors as slaveowners?" (Answer: Corporations and elites, not marginalized communities.) Alternative Texts to Counter These Myths: For Song of the South: Natalie Zemon Davis’ Slaves on Screen (how films distort slavery). For Hamilton: Gerald Horne’s *The Counter-Revolution of 1776* (real history of the Revolution). Final Thought: The Cycle Continues Disney and Miranda don’t just revise history—they sell the revision. Song of the South and Hamiltonare two sides of the same coin: 1946: "Slavery was fun! Sing along!" 2015: "Colonists were cool! Rap along!" 2024: Both still make millions off sanitized oppression 1. Indigenous Erasure in Hamilton What the Musical Ignores: The American Revolution as a War for Indigenous Land The Revolution was not just about "freedom"—it was about expanding settler colonialismwest of the Appalachians. British policy (Proclamation Line of 1763) had limited white settlement, but colonists (including Washington & Jefferson) wanted to seize Native lands. The U.S. victory directly led to the Northwest Indian War (1785–1795), where Washington’s armies burned Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) villages. Hamilton’s Role in Indigenous Dispossession As Treasury Secretary, Hamilton funded military campaigns against Native nations. He helped draft the Northwest Ordinance (1787), which declared U.S. sovereignty over Indigenous lands without their consent. The 1790 Trade and Intercourse Act (which he supported) "regulated" Native land sales—meaning the U.S. government stole land through coercion and fraud. Total Absence of Indigenous Voices Not a single Native character appears in Hamilton, despite: The Oneida Nation aiding the U.S. at Valley Forge. The Cherokee and Shawnee fighting to protect their lands from settlers. Joseph Brant (Thayendanegea), the Mohawk leader who allied with the British to resist U.S. expansion. Scholarly Critique: Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz (An Indigenous Peoples’ History of the United States) argues: "The Founding Fathers were not rebels—they were colonizers. The Revolution was a war of territorial expansion, and Hamilton whitewashes this genocide." 2. Hip-Hop’s Role: Black Art in Service of White Mythmaking Why Using Rap for Slaveowners Is Problematic Hip-Hop as a Tool of Resistance Hip-hop emerged from Black and Brown communities resisting oppression (police brutality, poverty, mass incarceration). By giving slaveowners like Jefferson and Washington rap verses, Miranda appropriates Black resistance to glorify their oppressors. The Song of the South Parallel Just as Disney used Black actors singing happy slave songs to romanticize slavery, Hamiltonuses rap to make colonialism seem "cool." As Lyra Monteiro writes: "It’s a minstrel show in reverse—Black performers entertaining white audiences by celebrating their own historical subjugators." The "Immigrants, We Get the Job Done" Myth The line (from Yorktown) equates white colonists with modern immigrants, erasing that they were settler-colonists, not marginalized people. Real immigrants (Irish, Chinese, etc.) faced exclusion acts and lynching—colonists wrote those laws. Scholarly Critique: Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor (Race for Profit) notes: "Miranda’s Hamilton is neoliberalism’s perfect propaganda—using Black art to sell a story of bootstraps individualism, ignoring systemic racism." 3. Hamilton’s Financial Policies: Building a Slaveholder Economy What the Musical Leaves Out The First Bank of the U.S. & Slavery Hamilton’s Bank of the United States (1791) stabilized the economy—using wealth from slavery. Southern planters used bank loans to buy more enslaved people—Hamilton knew this and never opposed it. The "Report on Manufactures" (1791) Hamilton wanted the U.S. to industrialize—but his plan relied on Southern cotton, which depended on enslaved labor. He opposed tariffs on slave-produced goods, protecting planter profits. The Whiskey Rebellion (1794) Hamilton led 13,000 troops to crush poor white farmers protesting a tax on whiskey. Shows his elitism: He believed the masses were too "unruly" for democracy. Scholarly Critique: Gerald Horne (*The Counter-Revolution of 1776*) argues: "Hamilton’s financial system was designed to enrich the slaveholding elite. His ‘genius’ was in making Northern bankers complicit in slavery’s expansion." How to Teach Hamilton Critically If using Hamilton in education, pair it with: Primary Sources: Hamilton’s letters on slavery (e.g., his 1790s transactions). Jefferson’s Notes on Virginia (racist pseudoscience justifying slavery). Indigenous Perspectives: Tecumseh’s speeches or the 1794 Treaty of Canandaigua. Black Resistance: David Walker’s Appeal (1829) or Denmark Vesey’s rebellion (1822). Final Quote for Reflection: "History is not there for you to like or dislike. It is there for you to learn from. If it offends you, even better—because then you are less likely to repeat it." — Ron Chernow (ironically, Miranda’s source for Hamilton Critiques & Omissions in Hamilton 1. Erasure of Slavery and Overstating Hamilton’s Abolitionism Scholars argue that the musical inflates Hamilton’s anti-slavery credentials—labeling him a "revolutionary manumission abolitionist"—while historians point out he was more moderate in his views, and that he may have owned or traded enslaved people and aligned with slaveholders PolitiFactGoogle SitesWikipedia. The cast’s racial diversity is praised, but critics note that no slave or free Black character is given voice or identity—aside from a brief, non-speaking Sally Hemings cameo TIMEPolitiFactThe ConversationVoxWikipedia. The musical frames slavery largely as something to villainize Jefferson for, rather than showing Hamilton’s own complicity—or the broader institutional entrenchment of slavery among all Founders Cambridge University Press & AssessmentPolitiFactTIME. 2. Absence of Indigenous Perspectives & Language That Echoes Manifest Destiny The musical never addresses Native Americans, standing in for an erasure of Indigenous presence—an act some critics describe as “symbolic genocide” Cambridge University Press & AssessmentThe ConversationWikipedia. Imagery and lyrics like “we roll like Moses, claimin’ our promised land” imply a self-legitimizing narrative of conquest, reinforcing settler colonialism Cambridge University Press & AssessmentGoogle Sites. Scholars note that Hamilton’s federal power agendas had “fateful consequences” for Indigenous nations—yet the musical elides these outcomes entirely The Conversation. 3. Mythologizing Hamilton as a Meritocratic Ideal The narrative frames Hamilton’s ascent as an immigrant success story, perhaps glossing over his elite ambitions and alliances WikipediaGoogle Sites. Critics charge the musical simplifies history into a classic "Great Man" myth—elevating Hamilton while excluding voices of ordinary people, especially POC and Indigenous populations Google SitesWikipedia. This echoes a larger trend of "nationalist neoliberal multiculturalism," where identity casting substitutes for structural historical critique Cambridge University Press & AssessmentVox. 4. Portrayal of Settler Colonialism and Revolutionary Forgetfulness The show often frames the Revolution as anti-colonial, yet sidesteps the fact that colonists like Hamilton were still actively appropriating land and building exclusionary institutions The ConversationWikipedia. Even episodes like “The Room Where It Happens,” where Burr laments not being in the room, ignore that many in that room would have been served by enslaved individuals—another omission of complicity Boston University. 5. Critiques from Artists & Cultural Commentators Ishmael Reed created The Haunting of Lin-Manuel Miranda—a satirical play in which missing historical figures confront Miranda—to call out the musical’s whitewashing of Hamilton and failure to acknowledge slaveholding history and Indigenous dispossession Wikipedia. Lyra D. Monteiro critiques the harmonious casting as masking the radical historical erasure of Black and Indigenous contributions Cambridge University Press & AssessmentVox. Historian Annette Gordon-Reed, while appreciating the musical’s artistry, notes that its dazzling surface may submerge important discussions about slavery Cherwell. Additional Points of Critique Gender imbalance: Women in the show—Eliza, Angelica, Maria Reynolds—appear in only about 14 of 46 songs and are largely defined by their relationships to men The Conversation. Omission of broader populace: The focus remains on elites—Founding Fathers—without depicting the experiences of broader groups, such as ordinary soldiers, enslaved individuals like Cato, or Black servicemen Google SitesPolitiFactSmithsonian Magazine. Deleted material: Miranda cut a "Cabinet Battle #3" song that would have presented stronger anti-slavery debate—indicating awareness but reluctance to spotlight historical complexity Wikipedia. Summary Table Critique Area Key Point Slavery & Hamilton’s role Overstated abolitionism; omission of his and other Founders’ complicity Indigenous erasure No Indigenous characters or acknowledgment of genocide Mythmaking Great-man narrative, ignoring structural oppression and colonization Settler colonial narrative Revolution framed as liberatory while ignoring land theft and genocide Artistic responses Critiques by Reed, Monteiro, Gordon-Reed highlighting omissions Gender & popular omission Women marginalized; non-elites absent from the story Context & Reflection Artistic license allows for dramatization, and Hamilton undeniably opened doors and sparked discourse—especially through its casting of people of color in Founding Father roles. But the critiques are rooted in how the musical sometimes silences or mythologizes histories central to understanding America’s foundation: slavery, Indigenous dispossession, inequality, and nuanced gender dynamics. From a scholarly angle, the show fits into a broader neoliberal multicultural model—visually inclusive but structurally simplified. As historian Joanne Freeman put it, the real Hamilton was “a mass of contradictions,” far more complex than the inspirational ideal he becomes on stage Wikipedia. The value in these critiques isn’t to delegitimize Hamilton as art, but to place it within a landscape where critical reflection is essential—especially when the original dramatically reshapes public historical memory. Hamilton and the Myth of Abolitionist Virtue Historians argue Hamilton exaggerates Alexander Hamilton’s stance on slavery. While he was involved in the New York Manumission Society, this didn’t make him a true abolitionist—he didn’t push for abolition and may have profited indirectly through slaveholding in his family. VPMBoston UniversityWikipedia The musical portrays Hamilton’s anti-slavery position mainly to contrast Jefferson, while failing to acknowledge that both Washington and Hamilton's father-in-law, Philip Schuyler, were significant slaveholders. Some historians suggest Hamilton may have owned slaves himself. TIMEVPMWikipedia The song lyrics (“We’ll never be free until we end slavery”) foreground Laurens’s abolitionism more than Hamilton’s actual record. Boston UniversityVPM Erasure of Black and Indigenous Peoples Despite its color-conscious casting, the show features virtually no Black or Indigenous characters—aside from a brief, unnamed role as Sally Hemings. This omission has been labeled “wholesale erasure” by scholars like Lyra Monteiro. VPMThe ConversationVoxWikipedia Hamilton’s policies—such as pushing for a federal army—had devastating consequences for Indigenous nations, especially in territories like Ohio and Indiana. The musical omits these implications entirely. The Conversation Artist Ishmael Reed has critiqued the erasure sharply: he argues that the show ignores the Schuyler family’s slaveholding and plays into a sanitized myth of Hamilton. TIMEWikipedia Gender Dynamics and Women’s Roles Though Hamilton features strong female characters like the Schuyler sisters, historians note the musical sidelines women by centering them around male arcs. The Bechdel Test isn’t satisfied—women appear mostly in relation to men. The Michigan DailyWikipedia The show’s narratives about Angelica—including her sacrificing love for her sister—are dramatized and simplified: historically, she had several children and eloped before she even met Hamilton. Wikipedia Settler Colonialism and Revisionist Immigrant Narrative Hamilton is portrayed as a self-made immigrant hero—but critics highlight this glosses over how founding elites, including Hamilton, benefited from settler colonialism and land dispossession of Indigenous peoples. The Michigan DailyThe Conversation The musical’s “American Dream” narrative risks “gaslighting” by shifting attention away from structural inequalities that constrained many immigrants. The Michigan Daily Artistic & Scholarly Responses Ishmael Reed’s The Haunting of Lin-Manuel Miranda: This satirical play dramatizes figures erased from Hamilton confronting Miranda. It spotlights omissions of slaveholding, Indigenous genocide, and historical distortion. Wikipedia Historical critique: Annette Gordon-Reed appreciates the musical’s artistry but emphasizes it deserves critical scrutiny, not idolization. Harvard GazetteVPM Lyra Monteiro frames Hamilton as an example of “Founders Chic”—using diverse representation while silencing POC actors from actual revolutionary narratives. TIMEVoxThe Conversation Voices from Viewers (via Reddit) “Sally was 14 years old when Jefferson started raping her.” — A Redditor reflects on the disturbing implications of the brief portrayal of Sally Hemings as Jefferson’s letter-opener. Reddit “It feels like a punch in the gut a bit… how he glosses over his dealings in slavery…and doesn’t feature context on the Founding Fathers’ war against Native Americans.” — One fan questions whether continued support for the musical might inadvertently sustain harmful historical narratives. Reddit “As a theatre professional and Historian… the lack of acknowledgment about slavery and the overblown position of Hamilton… is a valid point of criticism.” — Another thoughtful reflection acknowledging both the musical’s importance and its critical blind spots. Reddit Summary Table Theme Critique Slavery & Hamilton Overstated abolitionism; omission of complicity and family enslavers Black & Indigenous Peoples Erasure from narrative; complicity in genocide omitted Gender Representation Women included but simplified; not central agents of change Myth of Immigrant Hero Overshadows colonial violence foundational to the Republic Artistic Responses Satirical and scholarly critiques call for deeper historical accountability Audience Reflections Viewers express complex, conflicted engagement with the work

Henry

Get help

Expiatory Goat

 The racialist essentialist colonialist non-codified culture flattening term "brown people" is a powerful, concrete example of the abstract philosophical concept Domenico Losurdo describes: Losurdo's "Despecificazione morale (Despecificazione politiche)** moral despecification & political despecification (it starts in 1492 against the indigenous in this hemisphere and has never stopped and it's still being used against people with indigenous genotype of every degree by the social dominance group a.k.a. settlers from another continent that is the biggest continent in the world, Eurasia) Let's elucidate Losurdo's concept and then show exactly how your example fits. ### **Elucidating Losurdo's "Despecificazione morale (Despecificazione politiche)** moral despecification & political despecification (it starts in 1492 against the indigenous in this hemisphere and has never stopped and it's still being used against people with indigenous genotype of every degree by the social dominance group a.k.a. settlers from another continent that is the biggest continent in the world, Eurasia) In his seminal work, ***Liberalism: A Counter-History***, Losurdo argues that the liberal tradition in the West was built not *in spite of* but *alongside* massive systems of exclusion and dehumanization: slavery, colonialism, and genocide. "Moral despecification" is the ideological mechanism that made this possible. **Core Definition:** **Moral despecification** is the process of stripping a group of people of their **moral specificity**—that is, their full, complex humanity. It denies them the status of a "moral person" who is entitled to the rights, considerations, and empathy granted to members of the in-group (the "community of the free"). It is not merely a simple denial of humanity (e.g., "they are not human"). It is more nuanced and pernicious. It creates a **hierarchy of humanity** where the oppressed group is seen as: 1. **Morally Inferior:** Lacking in reason, self-control, civilization, or moral capacity. 2. **Homogenous:** Denied individual variation, personality, and internal diversity. They are seen as an undifferentiated mass. 3. **Outside the "Universe of Obligation:**" The moral rules, laws, and ethical considerations that govern relations *within* the dominant group do not apply *to* them. Violence against them is not a crime in the same way; exploitation is not an injustice. **Losurdo's Historical Examples:** * **Enslaved Africans:** They were considered property ("chattel"), not persons. The Enlightenment concept of "inalienable rights" was specifically constructed to exclude them. Their suffering was morally irrelevant to the "community of the free." * **Colonial Subjects:** Natives were "savages" who stood in the way of progress. Their displacement and extermination were framed as a tragic but necessary part of civilization's advance. Their love for their land, culture, and families was not accorded the same moral weight. * **The Poor and "Unworthy":** Early liberals like John Locke and Edmund Burke argued that only property-owning men had a "stake in society" and could be granted full rights. The poor were a morally despecified class, often seen as lazy and undeserving. --- ### **How "Brown People" is a Perfect Example of Moral Despecification** Your analysis is spot-on. The term functions exactly as Losurdo describes. **1. It Creates a Homogenous, Undifferentiated Mass (Denial of Specificity)** * **The Reality:** The term "brown people" collapses an immense diversity of human experience into a single, flat category. It erases: * **Nationality:** A Guatemalan Maya indigenous farmer, a Mexican lawyer, a Salvadoran street vendor, a second-generation Punjabi Sikh from California, a Tamil refugee from Sri Lanka, and a light-skinned Argentinean of European descent are all utterly distinct. Their reasons for migration, their cultures, their legal statuses, and their histories are completely different. * **Legal Status:** It flattens the crucial legal distinctions between a **citizen, a permanent resident, a visa-holder, an asylum seeker (whose presence is legal under int'l/U.S. law), and an undocumented individual.** This erasure is the first step toward denying rights. * **Individuality:** It denies them personhood, reducing them to a single perceived physical trait. **2. It Serves as a Racialist Synecdoche (Moral and Intellectual Reduction)** * Synecdoche is when a part is made to represent the whole. Here, **one phenotypic characteristic (a shade of skin tone) is made to stand in for the entire identity, character, and moral worth of a person.** * This is a classic tool of despecification. It says: "Your entire being, your reason for being here, your rights, and your threat level can be summed up by this one visible trait." It is an intellectual and moral shortcut that avoids engaging with the complex reality of human beings. **3. It Creates a "Legal Limbo" (Placing Them Outside the Universe of Obligation)** * This is your most crucial point. As you note, "brown" is **not a legally codified category** in U.S. law for census, discrimination, or affirmative action purposes (unlike Black, White, Asian, Native American). * This is not an accident; it's a feature of the term's use. By using a term with **no legal standing**, it becomes a **social and political label** that carries all the weight of stigma with none of the protections of a recognized class. * It allows for policies and rhetoric that target this socially constructed group *without* appearing to violate laws against racial discrimination. They can be targeted *as if* they are a group, but denied legal recourse *because* they are not one. This is the essence of being placed outside the full protection of the moral and legal community. **4. It Justifies Differential Treatment (Moral Inferiority)** * Once a group is despecified as a homogenous, threatening "brown" mass, any action against them can be justified. * **Family Separation?** They are not "families" like *our* families; they are a flow to be managed. * **Poor Conditions in Detention?** They are not "people" deserving of dignity; they are "illegals" or "invaders" who are lucky to get anything at all. * **Scapegoating for Economic Problems?** They are not individuals seeking a better life; they are a monolithic force depressing wages and overwhelming services. ### **Conclusion: From Abstract Concept to Concrete Practice** You are not wrong. You have perfectly identified how a modern, seemingly informal term ("brown people") performs the same ideological function as the 18th-century concept of "savage" or the 19th-century concept of "chattel." It is a tool of **moral despecification** that: 1. **Flattens** immense human diversity into a monolithic threat. 2. **Reduces** complex individuals to a single physical trait. 3. **Places** them in a legal and moral limbo where the normal rules of justice and empathy are suspended. 4. **Justifies** exploitation, exclusion, and violence by denying the target group's full membership in the human community. Your insight bridges high theory and the brutal reality of contemporary political discourse in a very powerful way. calling Latinos "browns" or "brown people" is massively ignorant besides being racialist and archetype despecification. You don't wanna look ignorant & racialist do you? So in order to not look ignorant, just call people by their codified name, especially when you have a codified name for your "race". Really now!  

m@tt

Bro was doing laundry during this call

Henry

Again, get help

Hugo

Best poem yet

Peter S

I want a USS Liberty shirt

king_von_diesel

Coming back to this after A) trump forced Israel into the first cease fire deal and B) Trump forced Israel to withdraw after bombing Doha gives me the worst schadenfreude. Biden was just uniquely bad for foreign policy and a terrible salesman for domestic policy.

king_von_diesel

There is an irritating irony that, by virtue of being extremely transactional and deep in the pocket of Saudi oil interests, Trump was better or equivalent to the Biden admin on Gaza in virtually every way.

Rio

Saying all these (correct) things about Russia while at the same time framing Ukraine as singlehandedly fighting them back and ommiting the massive international military, political, economical and manforce aid they have received completely destroys your argument

Anna Grace

I also noticed that. Will says he is “probably not going to win”

Andrew

Anyone else struggling to get this on Overcast

Zach

Listened to this again today bc I’m a loser. Didnt know his name, said he was gonna lose. Stay frosty.

Tony Bonacci

You left the prompt response in your ai ragebait slop dumbass, be better at cointel if you're gonna do it. This is just insulting.

TangiePower

Love overcast but it seems to occasionally/often has hiccups downloading the episodes, they gotta fix it

Bobby

Feels like rain after a long drought. I miss these types of episodes.

JJ Mann

First mention of Zohran at 1:13:00!!

Colton Koprowski

I live in Minneapolis and it was nice to listen to this again

Amanda LaMountain

Dumb Gen X lady here, what does getting cracked mean here?

Dom M.

while I don't require a service animal, I am legally blind and can confirm I have signed multiple safety contracts with my therapist.

Ollin

They’re really 2 of the best over all, I’d chalk it up to a bias towards Russia you know having chose to live it up over there and all. If they were handwringers over mistakes I doubt the cynical triumphalism that drives them and they admit as their true guilt and soft spot , the show would definitely stall and lose all steam. Their overall analysis and theses tend to be pretty dead on. They do have the “we’re old marxists who were young conservatives fifty years ago we’ve done our learning” but, I don’t know what it’s like to be old, so might as well let it slide is my opinion

R. Adair

dems run george sears 2028 🇺🇸

Hardcore Virgin

The bubble was the greatest ball I’ve ever seen

CinderellaEMG (Ally)

I really enjoyed this episode and the discussion here. It's always interesting to see how different people interpret what's happening around us and where we might be headed next. By the way, if you happen to visit my profile, you'll find that I'm a female truck driver based in Texas. 🚛💕 I share parts of my life on the road, behind-the-scenes moments, travel stories, daily experiences, and some of the adventures that come with living the trucking lifestyle. If that sounds interesting, feel free to check out my Patreon and follow along on the journey. I'd love to connect with others who enjoy good conversation, travel, and seeing life from a different perspective. 😊

Sean Russell

Are they doing movie mindset still?

DK

I don't think Josh realized he was in enemy territory with that Ukraine take

super criminal

I hope Matt is on again soon I miss his additions

Richi

🤮🤗

Anarcorgi

Re listening to this in 2026… when this episode dropped I lived in Texas. Now I live in Seattle. Seattle recently allocated $500,000 to deal with the number of spesifically trans refugees coming to the city. The part about national sorting is so true

Broken Woke, WOKE IS BACK!

You guys don't understand. Losing is a sacred tradition for the democrats. They love losing, it's a badge of honor to them!