Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

55/100

First of his films I haven’t quite liked (though I skipped Woman in the Fifth, which nobody seems to like much; honestly forgot that one even existed)…and, not at all coincidentally, the first of his films that could be categorized as a biopic. Opening scene’s fantastic, with August Diehl waxing morose on one half of a telephone conversation clearly taking place in post-war Europe, as his overnight guest silently dresses and leaves in the background, without saying goodbye; it’s not immediately clear that this man is Klaus Mann, talking to his sister Erika, and one wouldn’t guess that he’ll subsequently be seen solely as a specter. Must confess that my spirits instantly sank when the father they’d spoken of with affectionate derision turned out to be Thomas Mann, doing a national-rehabilitative lecture tour of Germany (including Weimar) with a reluctant Erika in tow as his assistant/manager. On the one hand, this is the sort of tightly focused biographical portrait that I can tolerate, unfolding over just a few days; Pawlikowski and his regular DP, Łukasz Żal, employ their usual headroom-happy Academy-ratio monochrome, which looks spectacular as always, and there’s no fault to voice regarding Hanns Zischler as Thomas or Sandra Hüller as Erika. My reservations lie not in execution but in conception: Pawlikowski seems to have been inspired primarily by the inconvenient timing of Klaus’ suicide (accepted as such by everyone in the film, however much it’s debated elsewhere) and by the opportunity that Mann’s lecture tour provides for a dissection of retroactive appeasement—the desire of some Germans to put the Third Reich behind them and the inability of others to entertain such a notion. I couldn’t help thinking about how much more potent that subject was when tackled decades later and fully fictionalized by The Nasty Girl; in 1949, it feels a tad obvious/blunt, especially competing with Mann’s unsentimental reaction to his son’s death (and how that affects Erika). As the title suggests, there’s also reflection on the meaning of home, which arises not only in dialogue but in such less-than-subtle moments as Mann (who was then living in California) switching the car radio from a United States Armed Services broadcast to a local German station and then turning it off as implicit acknowledgement that he now belongs nowhere. Solid work, but not remotely exciting to me apart from the aforementioned opening scene and an equally strong closer.

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.