The Last of the Mohicans (1992, Michael Mann) (Patreon)
Content
63/100
Second viewing, last seen during its original theatrical release*. Had to remind myself that Mann had directed only three features prior to this one, and that my sense of him at the time would almost certainly have been "dude who makes badass crime pictures" (I didn't get to The Keep until quite recently), not "obsessive explorer of modern masculinity and its quasi-mystical discontents." Either way, Mohicans is a real outlier. I need to tread carefully here, because phrasings things poorly might come across as dismissive/patronizing/sexist, which isn't my intention. But finally watching this again, 34 years later, I was caught well off guard by how boldly, unapologetically XX-oriented it is, by how much of the film constitutes pure, unadulterated, capital-R Romance. While there's more than enough action to ward off "chick flick" accusations, the line between Day-Lewis' Hawkeye and the protagonist of any Harlequin novel with a cover for which Fabio served as model is really razor-thin. He's a long-haired, soft-spoken hunk for whom nothing is more important than protecting Cora Munro—I of course remembered the oft-quoted/-clipped line "Stay alive, no matter what occurs! I will find you!", but had forgotten that it's merely the most memorable and emphatic of many such ardent moments between them, most of which are dialogue-free and erotic as hell. There's a shot of Cora simply looking up and holding/reciprocating Hawkeye's gaze for an uncomfortably long time—it's a bona fide female gaze, ultimately objectifying him in what amounts to a come-hither I'm-rubber-you're-glue dynamic—that's arguably hotter than is the film's actual hips-a-thrustin' sex scene. Part of me kinda bridles at the common female fantasy of being powerfully desired and then heroically rescued by a strong silent type, but I read enough of my mom's second-wave feminist lit as a teen to know that it is in fact common, even among highly independent women. (Flip side's all the male captains of industry who secretly yearn to be dominated.) And Mann shaped Cooper's novel for the screen in a way that foregrounds heightened raw emotion (plus hotness), paying comparatively little attention to the French and Indian War's political and tactical intrigue.
All of which is totally fine by me, even if I'm not part of what I perceive to be the film's primary target audience. (I like my romances Brief Encounter realistic; for me, there's a ceiling on anything in which people who barely know each other are ostensibly soulmates, no matter how skillfully the actors convey passion using only their eyes.) Problem is, the movie falls apart pretty much immediately following its iconic beneath-the-waterfall scene. I neither believe nor find remotely satisfying almost anything that happens thereafter. And now I know why: It's all made up. Some of it by Mann and his co-screenwriter, Christopher Crowe (whose only other notable film credit was writing the mediocre 1996 Wahlberg-Witherspoon thriller Fear), some of it by Philip Dunne way the hell back in 1936 (his script for the Randolph Scott picture gets official credit here).
Actually, let me retract that. I'm not opposed in principle to wholesale revision/invention, and this collection of writers certainly could have come up with some sort of marginally happier ending (Cooper's is quite bleak) that wouldn't have felt utterly false. After peaking with its best-remembered line/moment, however, Mohicans can't quite find its way out of the book from which it's been adapted so loosely that nothing within shouting distance of either the actual source or the earlier Hollywood movie feels organic, or even appropriate. For example, there's a point at which it appears as if Hawkeye's going to sacrifice his life to save Cora, and what prevents his sacrifice is another character doing something that he would never in a million years have done, based on literally every other action he has taken throughout the entire movie. I understand that it's supposed to be his face-turn act of redemption, but nope, not credible. (That was apparently Dunne's idea for the '36 version, though he at least complicated it a little with an archery contest between self-proclaimed Hawkeyes. Also, that film swaps the sisters, with Hawkeye falling for Alice, not Cora; near as I can tell, there is no Hawkeye love story in the novel.) Hawkeye's pledge to find Cora, so stirring when spoken, becomes simply CUT TO: Hawkeye instantly arrives where Cora is being held captive, arms up in surrender. I mean, he did find her. Quite speedily, in fact. And then the climactic battle on the cliffs feels rushed and almost arbitrary, apart from the self-sacrifice made by a character whose near-silence and strictly background presence since being introduced makes her barely seem worth mourning. (Very distracting for me at the time, since I knew Jodhi May from A World Apart; she'd jointly won Best Actress at Cannes. Has zilch to do here until her final 30 seconds onscreen.)
Still, that I sat down to revisit what I assumed must have been another implosively macho Michael Mann movie (by now I'd become more familiar with anecdotes about Day-Lewis' intensive wilderness training than with the film itself) and instead got a sweeping, quivering tearjerker fully justifying that rapturous theme (which I'm amused to discover was originally composed for a Loch Ness Monster exhibition!) is an example of why it can be so rewarding to wait decades between viewings. Mohicans felt like a departure then; it seems singular now.
* This is one of the films I clearly remember seeing at Movieland 8th Street, a theater that was purchased by NYU around 1996 and is now called the Cantor Film Center, a screening facility for students only. Was conveniently located about a four-minute walk from my freshman year (1992–93) dorm on Fifth Avenue at 10th St. Also where I first saw Unforgiven, days after moving to NYC. I found a photograph taken in '93.