Tony (2026, Matt Johnson) (Patreon)
Content
63/100
Went into this grudgingly, because I generally dislike biopics and have no interest in Bourdain (or indeed in what I'll for lack of a better word call foodie-ism—my palate's total garbage and that's fine by me). But while Tony's surname remaining unspoken until literally the movie's final word constitutes a cutesy gimmick (especially since that faux-twist gets instantly undermined by an opening epigraph), virtually nothing here, prior to the very last scene, suggests that you're watching the formative years of someone who'd go on to become world-famous. Owen Gleiberman cited Adventureland as a kindred spirit, and that's dead-on (though I much prefer Tony): This, too, is fundamentally a portrait of youthful dicking around (literally, in Sal's case), with a that-mildly-crazy-summer vibe that in no way heralds any sort of career-based epiphany. It feels autobiographical, not biographical. What's more, Johnson's evolving into a remarkably assured filmmaker, both in his handling of actors (Sessa fulfills his promise and then some; Banderas makes the crusty but soulful mentor role look effortless; Jones, Woodall and Halkias all add rich flavor) and in casually impressive formal touches—one shot of Tony leaving a house party looked so gorgeous it nearly made me gasp aloud, and there's a prolonged learnin'-the-biz montage, cut to the Stooges' "Down on the Street," that's orchestrated and edited expertly enough to land it on my Best Scene shortlist. All indications are that Johnson and regular co-writer Matthew Miller completely revamped a Black List script and made it their own, which seems plausible (the ostensibly Listworthy version is hilariously awful); populist remnants emerge toward the end, though, with the nadir being Tony's sudden conscience-stricken confession upon seeing Nancy standing before him naked and at last willing. Uh-huh. Plus the downside of eschewing grand ambition is that you wind up making something appealing but quite modest, which takes potential greatness off the table. Still, hard to imagine a movie about Bourdain that this non-fan (signifying ignorance, not antipathy; all I know is that he wrote books and hosted TV shows and committed suicide) would have enjoyed more thoroughly. Wish I'd gone in (were the film epigraph-free) entirely unaware of Tony's identity, so that the final line could have provoked a burst of "well played" laughter.