Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

41/100

Many jumbled thoughts = bullet-point time.

• On the one hand, disliking all three of Schoenbrun's films (to varying degrees, but I'd be thumbs down on all of 'em in a Siskel & Ebert format) inevitably makes me fear coming across as transphobic, or at least so hidebound that I'm incapable of appreciating radically queer work. The latter may well be true. On the other hand, treating a trans filmmaker with kid gloves seems far more offensive, even if it might not superficially appear to be so. And apparently there are trans critics who aren't fans either. In any case, all I can do is respond honestly.

• Schoenbrun isn't making movies for me. Not because I'm cisgender per se, but because I don't remotely identify with (or even understand, really) the impulse to mediate your personal identity via the pop culture you love. Which might sound odd, coming from someone who's spent his entire adult life writing about movies. But I'm into cinema generally, not obsessed to the point of dysfunction with any particular film or actor or genre. (Even vintage Beatlemania clips of shrieking teen girls make me mutter "Relax.") World's Fair tackled online phenomena that I'm genuinely too old to be conversant with, so my disconnection seemed natural enough. But TV Glow and now Camp Miasma view a landscape I recognize through a lens I find emotionally and psychologically opaque (but not, however, "Pink Opaque"). These characters' struggles don't resonate with me. Even when I grasp the intended metaphor, I don't feel it. There just plain isn't any media I'm that intensely invested in.

• And if there were, it certainly wouldn't be slasher films. All the same, it bugged the hell outta me that Camp Miasma's film-within-the-film, seen at length, looks nothing whatsoever like Friday the 13th (he said, without ever actually having seen it; nonetheless, I know I'm right!) or Sleepaway Camp (which I have seen) or any other '80s slasher. Obviously, Schoenbrun is well aware that those films didn't feature long, elaborate oners, or have literal geysers of stage blood erupt from decapitated victims' neck stumps, or employ ironic needle drops during kills (it's even fuckin' Counting Crows, as an additional deliberate anachronism); I cannot argue that these choices are "errors." But neither can I think of a good artistic reason for them, and they're so damn irksome to me that looking up interviews with Schoenbrun for an explanation has zero appeal. What's the point of paying homage to the past if you're going to misrepresent it this wildly—not in one key aspect (as e.g. Far From Heaven does, with Haynes adding overt racial and sexual elements to an otherwise slavish Sirk imitation), but in almost every particular?

• (Also, did I miss something or does the original Miasma's fakeout make no sense? Dylan-on-Severance tells campers the Little Death story, with which they're all clearly unfamiliar, and then a girl sneaks up behind Young-Billy-as-Whoever, seeking to scare her by wearing Little Death's head. Which she knows about...how? At that point in the first movie, Little Death shouldn't yet have been seen by anyone. Right?)

• To be honest, I was pre-emptively annoyed by this film's very title, which according to taste reads as either playfully self-conscious or (my own view) too cute by half. Camp Miasma, yuk yuk yuk. Also, this is a movie in which self-awareness reigns supreme, with Kris excitedly pointing out split-diopter shots and noting at one point that it feels like a jump scare's coming, yet somehow nobody even once remarks upon the franchise killer's name being (you should have seen my eyes roll when it was first spoken) Little Death. That felt outright insulting. I think it's too dumb regardless, but at least have someone onscreen acknowledge the origin, since you're doing that with literally everything else.

• Little Death's concentric squares—described as a heating vent but often looking more like a very early camera, especially when seen from LD's POV; furiously scribbled by Billy and decorating the walls of her house/cabin—likewise seem overly intellectualized. I get what it's meant to suggest but it should also make at least a little sense within a mass-market context, as this invented franchise's version of the hockey goalie mask or the Shatner mask. Instead, like "Camp Miasma" and "Little Death," it comes across as someone trying to give future scholars material.

• Need to reiterate that there are definitely elements of this film that are just inaccessible to me. For example, per its Wiki page, "Schoenbrun elaborated that a significant theme would be learning to enjoy sex after transition, noting the difficulty of having good sex in the wrong body pre-transition." I can kinda see that after having it pointed out to me but would never have picked up on it without help, despite knowing that Schoenbrun is trans. Kris is either lesbian or bi (the former, I think) and also poly (rather grudgingly, it seems); there's enough surface queerness that adding an additional layer of metaphorical queerness on top of that simply didn't occur to me. Like I said, old and hidebound.

• I laughed aloud at "Psycho from the perspective of the shower curtain," then later was surprised to discover that it apparently wasn't meant to be an absurdist joke. Repeated in deadly earnest.

• All of that's Ed, I liked this film more than I did TV Glow, if only because it's fundamentally a two-hander between Hannah Einbinder and Gillian Anderson. Neither's gonna make my Skandie ballot (Einbinder's performance is largely indistinguishable from Ava Daniels; Anderson leans too hard on a campy Southern accent for my taste) but they're solid enough to keep the dynamic interesting throughout. Also generally enjoyed the look, particularly some gorgeous, blatantly artificial matte paintings (I assume) in "exterior" shots of the camp.

• Best post-credits bit I've seen in a long time. It's worth sticking around for.

Files

Comments

Cameron Watson

This isn’t meant to come across as interrogative, but have you yet to actively enjoy any fictional films that foreground transness?

Mike D'Angelo

A lot of what I wrote can’t be disagreed with, though. “Didn’t connect with it.” “I disagree, you did so.”

George Hawtin

I was one of the people who originally requested WORLD'S FAIR in your poll - as a queer person, I maybe get more from their movies than you do, but as a cis guy, there's still a lot that isn't meant for me. And that's okay. It's way better to own "I didn't get this, because I'm not in the audience that this movie was made for" than to try to pretend something resonated, or, worse, to say, "I didn't get this, therefore it's terrible." Schoenbrun is trying to make art that lands with a marginalized community---this isn't supposed to be GREEN BOOK.

Sam Rhayader

We're at a point in time where there are directors (beyond Schoenbrun) who are sufficiently inspired by literary overanalyses of cinema that their own artistic sensibilities are informed by them as opposed to predominantly the actual works themselves, which is why we see so many post-modern layers embedded in their films that necessitate some degree of extratextual awareness. Apparently, Little Death's name is partly a reference to a French euphemism for climaxing during sex (la petite mort) so you see what I'm saying. I'm not sure whether this is a post-Tarantino phenomenon or not but for some reason, I feel like it might be. Then again, I'm reminded of when Hitchcock was asked about the recurring motif of stairs in his films (primarily in reference to Notorious, I think?), which was met with a dismissal that went along the lines of him saying that he puts stairs in his films because it helps people go up and down.

Mike D'Angelo

Yeah, that’s why I found Little Death kind of insulting. That it means “orgasm” is something I’d expect most culturally literate people to know (whether or not they speak French). To name your killer that and then not acknowledge the other meaning *in a film this relentlessly self-aware* makes it seem ultra-dorky. To me, anyway.

June Vaus

For whatever it's worth, I'm trans and I don't find much resonance in Schoenbrun's first two films, metaphorical or otherwise. Anna Cobb's performance kept World's Fair semi-interesting but it still took me multiple attempts to get through it. And TV Glow just plain did not hold my attention, though all of my friends who've seen it are big fans. I dunno. There's something there I admire but it has yet to translate into actual engagement, although I'm intrigued enough to still want to check out Camp Miasma and whatever comes after it. But yeah, I don't feel Schoenbrun is making movies for me either, not yet anyway.

Wells Oliver

I don't feel like World's Fair or TV Glow were in any way trying to speak to trans issues or resonate as queer material, Miasma arguably more so but not overwhelmingly. Feels like Shoenbrun's interest runs more in the direction of pop culture and media obsession and a fracturing of self, or introspection, or something more along those lines. Anyway, though, I thought a charm of Miasma was its sense of humor, you didn't find that in their prior two movies and felt it was really on display here and strong evidence of a strikingly improved writer (and also a more assured filmmaker). Love the progression in these three films.

Mike D'Angelo

Schoenbrun is on the record many times disagreeing with you. Here’s just one interview with Gregg Araki. https://filmmakermagazine.com/125395-interview-jane-schoenbrun-gregg-araki-i-saw-the-tv-glow/ On TV Glow: “Also, because it’s a movie about dysphoria, obviously—a movie about what happens between childhood and adolescence to a trans person—I wanted there to be a pronounced shift from the character when he’s a kid and is maybe able to inhabit his body in a way that’s un-gendered versus what happens just two years later after these changes start happening physically.” On Camp Miasma (not yet shot at the time, but still): “It’s funny, my next movie is all about sex—essentially a movie about learning to enjoy sex after transition. Pre-transition, it wasn’t that I was asexual—I had plenty of desire—but having good sex in the wrong body was impossible.” You can be interested in other things about Schoenbrun’s films, to be sure, but to say they’re not in any way trying to speak to trans issues just seems incorrect. Unless Schoenbrun is lying.

Wells Oliver

Yeah, I guess I should say rather, I didn't feel those movies depended on that, or were necessarily even primarily about that: their first two films seem to speak as much to loneliness and alienation and the broader ways the internet and media fandom shape those experiences. I feel like you could have replaced the character with less queer centric identities and the themes there would have worked just as strongly, at least for me. But it's certainly more pronounced in Miasma though I think there too the movie has a lot going for it where it's still wonderfully sustained if those particular themes don't personally connect.

Wells Oliver

I also kinda wanna argue about whether I have to honor a director or author's intent of a movie or book as the authority on my interpretation but that's another thread!

Mike D'Angelo

I support interpretations that are contrary to an artist’s stated intentions, because none of us is fully conscious of anything we do in life. But you can’t really say “I don’t think the film’s even trying to X” if the writer-director has talked extensively about trying to X.

Dekkay

Great review, saw it last night and had similar feelings. Left before the post-credits though, what was it?

Mike D'Angelo

Kevin McDonald and Patrick Fischler (as the actors in the franchise) talking about doing the sequels because their careers didn’t take off as they’d hoped.

Raúl

I think he likes Funeral Parade of Roses too.

June Vaus

Afterthought: as a counter-example, I do find quite a bit of resonance in Jonni Peppers's animated films, which grapple with trans-ness (among other things) in various ways -- plus she's got a scrappy, hyper-expressive cartooning style that I respond to. I've yet to actually like one of them, but I get the sense that they're for me, if that distinction makes sense.

Michael Sicinski

I don’t know that you would “like” Louise Weard’s films, but I’m certain you’d find them more interesting. In reductive terms, she is making Cassavetes / Rivette inflected psychological horror films. It often gets ugly but is always sincere.

Mike D'Angelo

But they’re soooo long. Maybe that’s fully justified, but I’m inherently skeptical of the epic impulse.

Scott Huddleston

Great review, Mike. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I actually think it would read fine without the bullets, but I get why you included them. Maybe it's because I'm so used to your writing. Also, I agree with you that the best aspect of the film is the performances by the two leads. I actually prefer TV Glow, largely because I like the look of that film (and how utterly weird it is). It does feel a bit like Schoenbrun is dipping into the same well twice here, which I think is to this film's detriment. It doesn't feel as fresh. Lastly, I do have a question for you: what do you think LD's concentric squares is meant to suggest?

Mike D'Angelo

It’s the physical manifestation of sexual dissociation (as seen on the ceiling while being assaulted), plus it’s a hypnotic-ish pattern (as seen in Billy’s art and on her walls), plus as I said it’s also reminiscent of very old cameras (germane for when Kris is instructed to watch herself through Little Death’s eyes).

seth

Re: the big Counting Crows oner--how I read that was not that it was literally what the film-within-a-film Camp Miasma was doing, because obviously a film that low-rent wouldn't have the ambition or resources for it, but us looking at it subjectively through Kris' adoring eyes, where it looks like (ostensibly) the coolest thing ever. The needle drop is less cutesy and ironic than it is trying to evoke her euphoria. Otherwise i agree with your review--i'm a fan of their previous two features but this felt too glib, too on the nose, too fixated on ostensibly clever deconstruction to work as anything else.

Joel Rackel

I loathed that scene (hearing rave review for that scene in particular on Filmspotting podcast irked me), but I like your reading of it the reason for it.

Benjamin Thernstrom

Also Tangerine, Boys Don't Cry, and depending on your definition of "foreground", Dog Day Afternoon.

Lino

Gotta thank you for introducing me to Jonni Peppers. Added 3 new movies to my watchlist just now

Webb

this seems clearly correct to me. Kris enjoys the Camp Miasma films because they serve as cathartic revenge against perceived bullies. there is clearly an intentional switch to subjectivity (hence the blending of the film stocks)

Adam Wisniewski

Finally saw it and listened the Big Picture interview with Jane, Hannah, and Gillian hoping for a little depth of their intent regarding the song and some other choices. Didn’t get it. Turns out the song was going to be “Nightswimming” as it’s a favorite, but their second cousin was the guitar tech for Counting Crows in the 90s, met them, and remains a big fan. So the anachronism meant nothing. Was just a cool song.