Gemko Quibi: September 2026 (Patreon)
Content
As a reminder: These are brief (though they always wind up growing longer and longer) thoughts on films that I'm revisiting mostly just because it's been at least 20 years and I’m feeling nostalgic and/or want to have a rating for them. Mostly stuff that's about to be removed from a streaming service to which I subscribe, so far. See the original post for a fuller explanation. (I'm now throwing in repeat viewings of more recent films as well; those generally used to get no additional words unless my opinion significantly changed or something new occurred to me.)
NOTE: Shorter than usual this month because I wasn't watching old movies while attending TIFF.
King Kong (1976, John Guillermin): 53/100
Previously seen: ca. December 1976, San Jose, CA (Pruneyard).
Original opinion: Unrecorded for obvious reasons.
Now: Obviously inferior both to the original and to Peter Jackson's remake...but just as those who were kids when the Star Wars prequels came out feel a fondness for them, I still feel a nostalgic tug for "my" Kong, seen at an impressionable age. (I was eight.) Plus of course there's now some additional nostalgia when Kong climbs a building that no longer exists and leaps to another that no longer exists. (Relieved to find that he doesn't straddle the towers, as in the ads, which would not be possible unless he were like 250 feet tall.) Story remains rock-solid, though it does help if you're young enough not to question the logic of an oil tycoon suddenly deciding to turn impresario. This was my introduction to all of the film's stars, and I was stunned to discover that Lange, who was pilloried at the time, in no way embarrasses herself (even Dawn re-naming herself Dwan seems less silly now, in a world of Gaga and Coolio and Eminem), whereas Grodin, who I love in practically everything, stinks on ice here. Not sure whether he was trying for some offbeat comic tone, but if so, it doesn't land. (Bridges is fine in a role that offers few opportunities to be anything else.) Finest element is arguably John Barry's stirring score, which does much of the heavy lifting toward the end.
La libertad (2001, Lisandro Alonso): 37/100
Previously seen: 28 September 2001, New York, NY (at the Walter Reade, NYFF press screening).
Original opinion: D–. Didn't write anything, as far as I can tell, and doubt I'd have had much to say beyond "bored out of my skull."
Now: Still don't find it of much interest, but there's considerably more variety to it, both formally and "narratively," than I'd remembered. Would've sworn Alonso serves up a full hour of wood-chopping action, but in fact we only watch Misael cut down (then strip of its branches and bark) one tree. Lasts roughly 12 minutes, and then we get to watch him prepare lunch, take a nap, drive over to some other dude's place and drop off the logs, kill and cook an armadillo, etc. A little such "unmediated behavior" goes a long way for me, but I'm no longer driven mad by the absence of dialogue and story—indeed, I'd rather watch this sort of nothin' much than what Angela Schanelec considers to be drama. (Having just endured My Wife Cries really put La libertad in perspective, in terms of what I find borderline intolerable onscreen.) Also, it looks like my perception that Alonso locks the camera down much more in Double Freedom is accurate: Whilst looking for any nerd-group comments I might have made (there were none) I found Michael Sicinski complaining as follows: "There were numerous moments where the activity itself was interesting to me (woodcutting, armadillo preparation) but the filmmaking lacked control, rigor. Too much camera movement, only to keep Miguel in center frame. Dude, don't you know that a fixed camera, and no reverse shots, is the only way to do this thing and win a small coterie of admirers?" Waz, you'll be glad to hear (and of course you already well know) that Alonso did eventually figure that out.
The Long, Hot Summer (1958, Martin Ritt): 54/100
Previously seen: 25 June 1993, San Jose, CA (on AMC, back when they exclusively showed classic Hollywood movies).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, don't remember.
Now: Not bad, by any means, but most of what it does well (a) feels a lot like second-tier Tennessee Williams and (b, vis-à-vis Newman) would be significantly enhanced a few years later, by Ritt himself, in Hud. Haven't read the relevant Faulkner stories, but there's not much of a Faulknerian feel, what with Orson Welles giving an even more aggressively Southern-fried version of Burl Ives's performance in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (if memory serves—been a long time for that one, too). Part of the problem is that Long, Hot Summer features arguably the worst sound of any major-studio production since the early '30s—not only is much of the dialogue visibly ADR'd (Welles is often clearly speaking completely different lines when he's viewed from a distance), but I swear you can sometimes actually hear the sterile room actors are standing in when ostensibly having a conversation outdoors. I will give Long, Hot Summer credit, though, for being one of very few films that manages to sell me on a woman resisting an obnoxious man's attention for the duration and then falling into his arms at the end. Helps that the two stars in question got married that very year and remained so for Newman's entire life. (Woodward's still with us at this writing, age 96.)
Nothing in Common (1986, Garry Marshall): 52/100
Previously seen: ca. August 1986, San Jose, CA (Century 22).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, don't remember.
Now: I really miss Tom Hanks' young brash smart-ass mode, which he more or less abandoned after winning his first Oscar. (To be fair, youth also abandoned him. And you still kinda get it via Woody.) He's playing a version of the early Tom Cruise role here, Selfish Dick Who Needs To Learn What's Really Important In Life, but Cruise always seemed grimly monomaniacal whereas Hanks is having a flippant blast, putting weird topspin on every line and just generally seeming so energized that rooting for David to change becomes difficult. Advertising-industry scenes are stronger than the parental stuff (just as ad-agency storylines eventually crowded out cross-dressing comedy on Bosom Buddies), though Jackie Gleason and Eva Marie Saint (also still alive at this writing! she's 102) both have truthful moments. Given the formulaic contours this ain't gonna stray from, it's not half bad. (I suppose 50/100 would be exactly half bad.) Dreadful score and needle drops, and I do wish David had looked insulted rather than touched by Dad's final line: "You're the last person I thought would ever come through for me." Oh, and seeing Sela Ward here makes me think that I was dead-on in naming her as a real-life equivalent of Misty Green in Chris Rock's new movie.
Crush (1992, Alison Maclean): 57/100
Previously seen: 12 July 1999, New York, NY (MoMA).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, but I recall finding it weird in an unsatisfying way.
Now: I'm not remotely confident about my understanding of this film. It begins with a car accident that leaves one of the two women who were in the vehicle not just badly injured but also brain-damaged. That part's quite clear. Does the other woman (Marcia Gay Harden) also have her noggin rearranged, though? My sense is that she's a different person after the accident, having previously demonstrated no sign of sociopathy (afterward she's practically the Joker), but we spend so little time with her pre-crash that it's unclear to me whether the character has been mentally altered or whether it's just that surviving has fully unleashed her id. Regardless, Crush fascinates in a distinctly...let's call it "antipodal" way—it's a New Zealand film, but reminds me strongly of Australian cousins like Proof (1991, not 2005) and Praise. (Even the titles are similar.) Something about the mix of cruelty and seediness and thinly veiled perversion. This example, however, lacks a strong spine, whether narrative or thematic; scenes feel oddly disconnected from one another, and it's only when Christina regains some autonomy and leaves the hospital that things start moving in a detectable direction. Maybe that's why an adaptation of Denis Johnson's short stories served as the basis for Maclean's strongest film by far (which hadn't yet premiered when I last watched Crush, though it was just two months away).
The Wannsee Conference (1984, Heinz Schirk): 57/100
Previously seen: 6 January 1995, San Jose, CA (vhs).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, don't remember.
Now: Figured I might as well revisit this while Conspiracy was fresh in memory. (It's on YouTube.) Germany's imagining feels more realistic than the American version, but I slightly prefer the latter (61/100), precisely because it likely deviates from a theoretical transcript in order to explore certain psychological truths. A bit more artful, in other words. Wannsee Conference takes a straightforward banality-of-evil approach, with lots of raucous laughter among the assembled, Heydrich flirting with the female stenographer, one dude actually falling asleep mid-meeting à la Trump, etc. Which, again, I suspect is probably quite accurate, but to me less interesting than watching men unconsciously talk around the evil they intend to perpetrate. Also, while this film's Stuckart (the role Colin Firth plays in Conspiracy) is just as central, its Kritzinger remains mostly silent (as the minutes suggest was in fact the case), leaving nobody to be even marginally horrified by the prospect of gas chambers. It's just one long bureaucratic horror show, and I can understand why others might find that scrupulousness more "appealing."
BONUS FUN FACT: Checking to see whether I might have written anything about The Wannsee Conference in old emails, I discovered that I'm the individual who added it to the IMDb (which was still very much incomplete in 1995).
(No need to send me info on the other films mentioned. I ironed that out long ago. Had Sadhana's title wrong, for example.)
Field of Dreams (1989, Phil Alden Robinson): 55/100
Previously seen: ca. April 1989, San Jose, CA (Century 23).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, believe I was "mixed."
Now: Only the sappy aspects had stuck with me, so I was pleasantly surprised to be reminded of what a goofy film this frequently is. Forgot that the Voice says more than just "If you build it, he (which I misremembered as "they," thinking of the final shot) will come," and indeed barely recollected anything not directly involving Shoeless Joe and Ray's father. Kind of assumed that building the baseball diamond would occupy most of the movie, not constitute a three-minute montage. So I once again experienced the sheer joy of e.g. James Earl Jones' pseudo-Salinger solemnly announcing, weapon in hand, "I'm gonna beat you with a crowbar until you go away." Also quite liked Amy Madigan's genuinely touching performance as a woman who initially thinks her husband is crazy but supports his insanity out of love. It's really only in the home stretch that things fall apart, starting with Mann's big oration that superficially sounds high-minded and poetic but boils down to "Ray, you can monetize these ghost games. It's gonna be a cash cow. Better hire a financial advisor." And then I'm just not the kind of guy who gets weepy at the notion of finally getting to play catch with Dad. Also that's gonna be a parking nightmare, no? More like field of Buicks imo.
All of Me (1984, Carl Reiner): 66/100
Previously seen: Not sure, but probably no later than 1985. Wasn't in theaters. But I think my friend Chris and I showed the first split-body walk in our joint presentation on the history of movie comedy during junior year of high school (which was fall '84 / spring '85).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, but I definitely considered Steve Martin's physical performance a work of genius.
Now: Which it is. (Gratified to see that he won Best Actor that year from the NYFCC and NSFC. Los Angeles went with Oscar winner F. Murray Abraham, in a tie with Albert Finney for Under the Volcano, though they honored Martin three years later for Roxanne.) I think we can forgive exaggerated gender stereotypes as depicted by just half of the body, as a means of comic delineation; that initial tug-of-war is arguably more remarkable than Jim Carrey's peak contortions a decade later, but the attention Martin pays to divided body language throughout, in "subtle" ways (by comparison), never stops amusing and impressing. Tomlin's of course more restricted (and isn't the sort of clinician who'll precisely match Martin's movements in the mirror shots—nor was Reiner a director who'd insist on that, to be fair) but miraculously does manage to generate viewer sympathy for Edwina by the end, so that the final shot in which Tomlin replaces Tennant (and nearly matches Martin for goofy dancing) actually put a small lump in my throat. Plotting's so-so, camera's purely functional, and I'm less tickled by Libertini's mangled English than I was as a kid (when "baginbul" slayed me), but an inspired conceit executed with this much crazed invention goes quite a long way.
(No walkouts this month, excepting the ones I already addressed in my TIFF reports.)