La Gradiva (2026, Marine Atlan) (Patreon)
Content
69/100
RIYL: Margaret's classroom scene in which Lisa and her fellow students and two teachers argue about 9/11 for a small eternity. (A+ insult I'll be stealing: "Three hairs on his ass and he thinks he's a bear.")
Grabbed me immediately, as opening credits dissolve into a train-compartment sex scene that we then find is being observed by a teen boy standing in the aisle, who is himself being covertly watched from further down said aisle by a teen girl. Those are the film's main characters (along with a teacher), but La Gradiva makes room for just about everyone amongst a French Latin class on a field trip to Pompeii (thereby re-imagining Journey to Italy from an adolescent's near-solipsistic perspective), orchestrating emotional turmoil while repeatedly complicating our understanding of who's feeling what and why. Elements that would constitute a more conventional movie's narrative spine, like one kid clearly being in love with his thoroughly straight best friend (hence the initial spying), or that friend silently following the teacher to her bed late one night (the door left open for him), or a girls' dorm scene in which the semi-ostracized roommate (we see girls groan upon discovering they're stuck with her) gets invited to illicitly drink, with unexpected sincere friendliness, and winds up designating herself the necessary ugly despised one who makes the others seem fuckable by comparison ("That's just in your head," someone accurately notes)...all of these arise for a brief, vivid moment and then recede to let life flow onward, sometimes then focusing on people we barely know and will barely get to know. It's a long sprawling inquisitive delicate glancing exploration of suspended time in a foreign locale at the close of life's most fraught chapter, so gorgeously unemphatic that it could be ruined, or at least badly crippled, by anything truly dramatic happening, especially right at the end.
Yeah. I don't want to dwell on that part. Not everyone feels as I do. But La Gradiva reaches what I thought was a nearly perfect conclusion, appropriately indeterminate, blending celebration with sorrow, and then keeps going in a direction that to me felt like a betrayal of everything that had preceded it. (Didn't help that I sensed it coming, with the thought "God I hope [X] isn't about to [Y]" popping into my head.) Doesn't come out of nowhere, Atlan lays groundwork throughout the movie, but I still found it overdetermined, as if Margaret had ended like Mouchette. That's the only thing holding this back from being my film of the year, so we'll see whether a second look can get me there.
A few of you are French, right? Meaning you live in France, or once did. Is it true that every college in the country posts its acceptances online simultaneously, as depicted here? Everyone finds out about every application on 24 May at 7pm (or whatever)? That's so bizarre from an American perspective. (Granted, it's been over 30 years for me, but used to be you got letters in the mail that might well arrive weeks apart. And you knew without even opening the envelope whether you'd been accepted or rejected, based on how large or small it was.)