Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

49/100

For my 10,000th feature film, I was looking for either (a) something hugely significant in cinema history (but somehow still not yet watched by me), or (b) a title that would be contextually amusing. Thought of this and realized it met both criteria. I feel like maybe someone might have suggested it as an option months or even years ago; if so, apologies for not recalling who that was. An email search turned up nothing.

Carl Sagan's Contact (the novel, but also its film adaptation, as I recall) imagines scientists receiving a transmission from extraterrestrial beings and discovering, encoded within it, footage of Hitler's speech at the 1936 Olympic Games. Ellie, the protagonist, points out that Hitler almost certainly signifies nothing to aliens—they have no idea who he was or what he represented, merely sent back mankind's first TV signal that was strong enough to travel reasonably far. In that spirit, I did my best to watch Triumph of the Will as an alien, rather than echo one of the film's popular Letterboxd reviews, which deems it "antisemetic [sic] trash" even though Jews are literally never mentioned (not even obliquely; one simply could not infer anti-Semitism sans extratextual knowledge). We all know the Third Reich was evil, and cinephiles are also well aware that Leni Riefenstahl has a sterling reputation from a strictly formal standpoint. (I saw The Wonderful, Horrible Life of Leni Riefenstahl way back in 1994, hence had already gaped at many of Triumph's most celebrated shots.) What might I think of it in a contextual vacuum?

Kinda zzzz, to be honest. Triumph of the Will may well be the greatest national propaganda film ever made (can't say I've seen many of the other candidates), but it's still national propaganda, hence of mostly historical interest to me. More specifically, it's self-aggrandizing propaganda, which is Kryptonite to Gen X. Hell, I turned on Liz Phair just for having the gall to sing "I am extraordinary"! (Came to mind because I'm seeing her at the Greek in a few hours. All is forgiven.) Even had the Nazis been sweetheart philanthropists doing nothing but good in the world, I'd have no desire to watch their leader wax narcissistic about how awesome they are and will eternally be. (RON HOWARD: "The Reich would not endure for millennia. Or even for a dozen years.") That's why I stopped watching even brief excerpts of Trump's rally speeches (except as ridiculed by late-night hosts) back in like 2017. Demonstrations of massive military might (a lot of alliteration for anxious anchors placed in powerful posts) get old in a hurry, too; there's only so much marching in formation I can be grudgingly impressed by the geometric and rhythmic precision of. And since Nazism was essentially a cult, many of Triumph's sequences are little more than tedious exercises in human idolatry. There's no denying the monumental quality of Nazi imagery and how Riefenstahl frames it, and watching Hitler speak at length can't help but fascinate (in part because he doesn't seem all that charismatic to this non-[I guess there's no German equivalent of "Francophone"]. But would I ever want to sit through Triumph of the Will again, just to marvel at low-angle God shots and symmetrical regalia in imposingly cavernous spaces that gave George Lucas a boner? Not really. I tried watching it as an alien and gradually got transformed into a mildly bored high-school student. This film may partially disguise the Nazi Party's iniquity, but the cringe is right in your face.

Also those guys are gonna go on to do some things of which, let me be clear, I do not approve at all. SMDH if you know what I mean.

Files

Comments

Cameron Watson

Any recollection of what you thought of Birth of a Nation? (Just thinking of a film with a similar historical significance/visual repugnance ratio)

Henry Adams

Would've never guessed this would be #10,000, so I burst out laughing when I saw the notification that THIS was what you chose after eagerly anticipating your selection. Just because, what a shocking choice! I'd actually been curious to read how you'd rate/engage with this + Birth of a Nation for a while, since it gets to the heart of this debate of evaluating things in a vacuum or with their wider historical context (though Griffith's film, while even worse with the context that it essentially birthed the KKK as we know it, is still extremely racist sans it). Glad to see you write about this. Congrats on the lifelong milestone!

Mike D'Angelo

It’s been 31 years but I recall being much more repelled than interested.

Devan Suber

Very unexpected choice. Your reaction reminds me of Ebert's Great Movies review where he started wondering where all the bathrooms and other logistics for the rally were. In fact he called it "paralyzingly dull".

Micah Levine

Mike, being a patron and therefore a piece of your professional work is an honor. The prediction of amusement won out here. I’m a younger patron, as in, came of age when Twitter expanded beyond 180 characters younger. Reading posts from that old nerd group, or rec arts movies, or whatever… I think it’s hard not to feel a little crestfallen for having missed that window of time on the web - early Internet chatting in vigorous detail without… well… the whole thing getting enshittened, rose colored glasses be damned. I’m grateful for your enduring work in the Patreon because it feels closer in spirit to that “space” than anywhere. Thanks!

Steve Ferra

I did Nazi this one coming as #10,000

Ian Danskin

*adjusts glasses* "alliteration for anxious anchors" isn't alliteration, is assonance

Sam Saper

I'd say the median pick for "greatest national propaganda film ever made" is probably Listen to Britain, though it's a short.

Victor Morton

I’ve told people for decades in making the same point … that this film isn’t antisemitic in the sense that DER EWIGE JUDE or JUD SUSS … that my memory is that that there is one late reference to Jews in it, an aside from someone other than Hitler, and a few oblique references to code terms like “international financiers.” I “admire” the film much more than you do, largely because I am more interested in historical context, political philosophy and rhetoric generally and the specific ways this film raises and approaches this subject. The way this film makes Nazism appealing is Belonging … “ain’t it great to be a Nazi” combined with national glorification in the wake of national humiliation. Also remember how all the banners say “Woke Germany.” That was awesome.

June Vaus

One of those titles I can't read without mentally singing it to the tune of "Riders on the Storm." It's my version of Mike's "Deck the Halls" sickness.

Nikita Komarov

Mike, you have this rated 35 instead of 49 on your 1935 page.