Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Odds are I won’t be seeing quite as many films as in previous years—certainly not overall, as I’m heading home after seven days rather than after eleven—but Day One is always a scheduling nightmare of Cannes titles and notable premieres. Saw five, wish it had been 12.

Tender Loving Care (Mike Leigh, UK): 66

A summary work drawing from Leigh’s entire corpus: starts out looking like a less-twitchy Career Girls (though both women have in more common with Happy-Go-Lucky’s Poppy), then expands in much the same way that ensemble pieces like Life Is Sweet and Another Year did. Making two of the characters social workers who are frequently seen in action gives the film a slightly therapeutic tinge early on, but enough of it’s personality-driven that such moments play like minor speed bumps; Kate O’Flynn (making her fourth appearance in a Leigh film) has more or less adopted Alison Steadman’s blend of flighty and compassionate, while Alice Bailey Johnson (who had tiny roles in Mr Turner and Hard Truths) gets to deliver one of those hilariously eccentric performances that one finds almost nowhere else. (Imagine Penelope from The Brothers Bloom, only much more so. She even looks a lot like Rachel Weisz.) Initially thought the epilogue unnecessary, as I’d remembered and thought of that character on my own, but that final shot, coupled with one’s awareness of Leigh’s situation, has real power. If he isn’t in fact able to make another movie, as he’s suggested, TLC will be suitably valedictory.

Everytime (Sandra Wollner, Austria/Germany): 60

Relentlessly interesting, which you might instinctively grasp is a descriptor that cuts two ways. (Also you saw my rating.) For close to 90 minutes, I’d estimate, it’s essentially a study in deferred emotion—something tragic (and quite unexpected, if you go in cold, plus the shot in question is a real stunner) happens toward the beginning, following which Wollner leaps ahead…well, not all that far, actually, but far enough that everyone’s already processed their grief and moved on, at least superficially. That in itself was Interesting to me, though less so as the film progressed and what had been skipped over began resurfacing. But then things take a paranormal turn that’s really…Interesting. And becomes still more Interesting as it vacillates between seeming purely symbolic and being something that’s clearly actually happening. “That was very Interesting,” I thought as the closing credits rolled. Which is by no means synonymous with Satisfying, and in truth I respect Everytime more than I like it. But what I saw of The Trouble With Being Born didn’t impress me, whereas now I’m…Interested.

The Unknown (Arthur Harari, France): 79

Screenplay of the year, or if not then something truly phenomenal awaits us. It’s been years since I’ve seen a film this intricately worked out at the story level, with a masterful unexpected/inevitable balance; that all of it proceeds from a banger concept/premise (not without predecessors, certainly but never quite this before) means I spent nearly the entire movie in a state of high giddiness. And there’s a rich thematic subtext to boot—at the risk of stepping in it, I (a cis dude) found The Unknown a more potent and moving trans allegory than any of Schoenbrun’s films to date. Which I realize is like declaring The Color Purple superior to Spike Lee’s first three features, though actually I’d stand by that if we push Do the Right Thing to movie #4 by counting Joe’s Bed-Stuy Barbershop. In any case, my rating isn’t 80+ only because I’m still grappling with what happens let’s say post-mortem, as the title’s true significance abruptly comes into focus. Don’t want to get into spoilers so I’ll reserve questions (most pressing: whither Malia?) and speculation (I feel like Harari’s saying something quite bold about the nature/importance of personal identity in the penultimate scene, with David’s mother) for an eagerly anticipated second viewing.

Wild Horse Nine (Martin McDonagh, Chile/USA): 57

Often very funny, but it’s ultimately too funny for my taste. Or too glib, rather. In Bruges and Seven Psychopaths (both of which I liked; this is the first of his films I’m mixed on) reveled in bad behavior, but they never felt to me as if they were being cavalier about real-world horrors. I can shrug off all the stuff here about Malkovich’s CIA assassin being responsible for JFK (though trotting out the three fucking hobos as gunmen is pushing it), but everything involving Allende and post-coup torture/execution/disappearance—note that Wild Horse Nine is set in 1973 but prior to 11 September (and it ain’t an Inglourious Basterds fantasy), so there’s a lot of casually frank dialogue about impending violence that will in fact take place, albeit unwitnessed by this movie—left a bad taste in my mouth. McDonagh unquestionably intends for such scenes to be brutal and discomfiting, but juxtaposed with his usual profane badinage and one character’s ostensible redemption, I dunno, it just didn’t sit well with me. No idea whether it bugs anyone else, at this writing. Pretty good movie if it doesn’t, I’d think.

My Wife Cries (Angela Schanelec, Germany): 6

No, I didn’t omit a numeral. Schanelec has never been my thing but her new one (with apologies to Blake, who predicted that I’d at least prefer it to I Was at Home, but… and Music) goes hog-wild with bland actors robotically reciting inane words. Sadly, I didn’t take notes, but one example so dumb that it stuck with me has a woman tell her friend (this might not be verbatim, but it’s very close) “I notice that I like some things more than others, that I have preferences. But why should that be?” Please explore that scintillating question in another medium, Angela. Hated the entire cast, particularly whoever plays Carla, but I can’t in good conscience blame them because I saw what Schanelec’s direction did to Maren Eggert, who can definitely act. Occasional dialogue-free shots of characters cycling around or a band concert in the park that gets rained out are tolerable, but the 85% of My Wife Cries that consists of talking made me wish that mankind had never invented language. By the time Schanelec threw in a Simple Men-style group dance (to Leonard Cohen, in this case), I was so fully alienated that it just made me angrier. Almost literally nothing here for me. Strike three!

Files

Comments

Scott Tobias

Holy hell, what a day at the movies!

Travis Warren

My Wife Cries is your first ever 6/100.

Tiger Inn

I can’t tell whether I’m more happy to see your rating for THE UNKNOWN (which I also adored, but don’t have a definitive answer for your question) or for MY WIFE CRIES (Schanelec is one of my favorite contemporary filmmakers)!

Mike D'Angelo

My friend Vadim loved My Wife Cries, gave it four Lbox stars when virtually every film he sees is either 3 or 3.5. (But his defense of the copious terrible dialogue amounted to “Treat it like the audio clips on ambient recordings that use the words non-linguistically, as a compositional element.” Which doesn’t work for me when the words are so pervasive.)

Devan Suber

Do you typically have a limit of how many tries you'll give a director before giving up? Cannes Competition and NYFF selections excepted of course.

Joel Rackel

🚨we have a 2026 79 rating🚨 🚨🚨🚨we have a 2026 6 rating🚨🚨🚨

Mike D'Angelo

No. I mean, if a film didn’t appeal to me at all, I’m not likely gonna stick that director’s next one on a fest schedule. But what I watch outside of fests is rarely a matter of personal preference (because I don’t trust my personal preferences). It’s all dictated by reviews and completism.

Devan Suber

I need to be better about not trusting my own preferences, honestly.

Chris Rasmussen

Schanelec might be the only director to have multiple films be MD'A's lowest rated film of the year!

Aharshi Roy

What are your 4-5 favourite (or even objectively best in your opinion) screenplays to date btw?

Mike D'Angelo

Please ask me that question when I’m not at a film festival. Requires consideration I don’t currently have time for; I don’t have a ready answer.

AuntieEm

Well I guess I feel bad for skipping The Unknown at Telluride then.

Arkaan Semere

My first instinct was that I bet Bergman has and indeed - Winter Light (1963) and Cries and Whispers (1972) are MDA's lowest rated films from those years. I can imagine Winter Light being "dislodged" but the latter's teen score might prove difficult.

Aharshi Roy

Hey mike, have you had more time to think about it?

Mike D'Angelo

Have I had more time? Yes. Had I in fact thought about it? No. I forgot, sorry. Let’s say Double Indemnity, The Prestige, Brief Encounter, Unforgiven.

Aharshi Roy

(Yah you dont need to say sorry lol 😂). Ooh interesting list. I was inspired by this questiom by you saying The Prestige should replace Chinatown for the greatest screenplay ever written (which I agree with btw). So you have 2 97s and 2 100s hmmm. What about yr favourite movie which doesn't have that great of a screenplay (Se7en jumps to mind ig)?

Aharshi Roy

Fairs. Was there even A screenplay 🤣?

Devan Suber

Regarding Wild Horse Nine: the tone didn't bother me as much but it does feel like he's trying to thread a very difficult needle and only occasionally making it work.