Gemko Quibi: October 2026 (Patreon)
Content
As a reminder: These are brief (though they always wind up growing longer and longer) thoughts on films that I'm revisiting mostly just because it's been at least 20 years and I’m feeling nostalgic and/or want to have a rating for them. Mostly stuff that's about to be removed from a streaming service to which I subscribe, so far. See the original post for a fuller explanation. (I'm now throwing in repeat viewings of more recent films as well; those generally used to get no additional words unless my opinion significantly changed or something new occurred to me.)
(Fewer entries than usual again this month, due to AFI Fest + caring for my dying dad.)
Mrs Dalloway (1997, Marleen Gorris): 55/100
Previously seen: 1 March 1998, New York, NY (Angelika).
Original opinion: C+. Was preoccupied with a new, crazily intense romantic relationship that spring and wound up writing haiku reviews for some films, including this one:
Much like Orlando,
This proves that film directors
Should leave Woolf alone.
Now: Mrs Dalloway has to think about her entire life before she throws a party. Liked it a smidge better this time (55 is my lowest B–), mostly because the cast is so strong—in particular, Rupert Graves and Michael Kitchen really dig into their respective characters' nihilistic despair (Septimus) and rueful acceptance (Peter). Plus the details are superficially faithful to Woolf, who of course had a magnificent eye for them. But few literary adaptations so perfectly exemplify my standard complaint "Source material's greatness is intrinsic to its original medium." Without Woolf's stream-of-consciousness narration, which sometimes jarringly shifts POV mid-paragraph, all you've got (and this is even more true of Clarissa) are multiple storylines that briefly intersect (commonplace in cinema), one of which is repeatedly interrupted by flashbacks (ditto). It's just not formally galvanizing onscreen, and if one reduces Mrs Dalloway to its constituent narrative parts, those parts are fairly basic (and have precious little thematic overlap): Middle-aged woman semi-regrets choosing security over adventure when young; WWI soldier suffers from what we now call PTSD; etc. It's a perfectly watchable film, occasionally quite touching, but the book's greatness simply doesn't translate.
North by Northwest (1959, Alfred Hitchcock): 98/100
Previously seen: Probably several times between the mid-'80s and 1996, including one theatrical viewing that I think was in NYC but might have been in San Jose; 4 June 1999, New York, NY (MoMA, Titus 1); 13 November 2012, Oxnard, CA (Blu-ray).
Original opinion: For about a decade, this was my favorite film of all time. Supplanted by another Cary Grant picture, —Only Angels Have Wings. It's now "only" among my top 15. Rating's the same as my most recent viewing, 14 years ago.
Now: Only note I took reads "Abducted six mins in," which was me once again being amazed by how speedily this sucker gets underway. Nothing followed because the movie just never stops gunning it and I was transfixed the whole time, despite knowing everything that happens. Although when Eve tells Thornhill about the Indiana rendezvous (at a train station), my brain went OH RIGHT THE CROPDUSTER, because I had somehow until that moment forgotten all about North by Northwest's most iconic sequence. That's how many killer sequences it has. Every single sequence, just about, including one of the hottest seductions in all of cinema (precisely because she plays it so cool), R.I.P. Eva Marie Saint. I honestly don't believe a more purely entertaining movie has ever been made; the only reason it's no longer my all-time fave is a fundamental weightlessness, which is part of what makes it so fun but means it lacks the emotional depth charge of a few films I love even more (like Vertigo, though that's just two rungs on the list and one meaningless point of criticism higher). If I could only bring one movie to a desert island, it'd likely be this one. There's nothing I'd want to watch once a week for years on end, but here's one that I definitely could.
The Buddy Holly Story (1978, Steve Rash): 49/100
Previously seen: I believe this was among my rentals from the video store I worked at in 1990–91. Sometime around then, anyway.
Original opinion: Unrecorded, don't remember.
Now: In theory, this film has the advantage of its subject not having lived long enough to experience the standard musical biopic trajectory—Holly never had a career downswing, never got addicted to drugs, never really feuded with his bandmates (though Story pretends there was a rift, manufacturing an intended surprise Crickets reunion The Day After The Music Died), never alienated a wife/girlfriend by fucking groupies, etc. So we get strictly the rising action, with significantly more uninterrupted performance footage than usual. I appreciate the songs being played live, but Gary Busey just isn't Buddy Holly (and doesn't even much resemble him, except insofar as anyone—even Steve Buscemi, in Pulp Fiction—can don an instantly identifiable Buddy Holly getup), so watching the movie largely mimics the experience of seeing a mediocre cover band. Plus I got annoyed by all the fudging, e.g. we know the perfectly solid setlist of Holly's final show in Clear Lake, IA, but Story instead has him play all of his greatest hits in a medley, roughly 30 seconds of each one, as if that's something a live audience would accept. (I did see Prince perform such a medley, on solo piano, but it was one small part of a two-hour show, not his entire appearance.) "Fun" fact: The film was released 19 years after Holly's death; today's rough equivalent—he's 18 years gone now—would be The Heath Ledger Story.
Shutter Island (2010, Martin Scorsese): 70/100
Previously seen: 16 February 2010, Los Angeles, CA (press screening, venue unknown, might've been the Paramount lot); 20 February 2010, Los Angeles, CA (definitely on the Paramount lot, saw it again with a girlfriend who worked there at the time).
Original opinion: 70/100 both times. Reviewed it for Las Vegas Weekly.
Now: Oh, this was where I originally encountered "On the Nature of Daylight." Wasn't familiar with it at the time. Not much I can add to my contemporaneous review, as it's still primarily the oppressive atmosphere that I find so impressive; one could perhaps quibble with the plausibility of certain remarkably lengthy and detailed conversations (thinking of Ms. Clarkson in particular), but why would one want to? Apparently there's some dissent regarding the final scene, with no less an authority than Lehane opining that Teddy just experiences a "momentary flash" of clarity that immediately dissipates; to me, it's far stronger if we understand that he's intentionally faking a mental relapse.
Victim (1961, Basil Dearden): 65/100
Previously seen: 5 August 2001, New York, NY (Walter Reade).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, don't remember.
Now: Remarkable that Dirk Bogarde starred in this film and The Servant within a two-year period, as his roles could hardly be more diametrically opposed (apart from shared surface decorum). Here, he's a closeted gay man torn between preserving his reputation and helping to catch the asshole who's been blackmailing every covert queen in London, his every move fairly radiating decency. There's a tentative quality to Victim rooted in its era and the limits of perceived viewer tolerance—Farr may feel sexual desire for men, but apparently has never acted on those feelings beyond wet gazes and remains platonically devoted to his wife, who knew his orientation and married him anyway. I found the latter aspect quite moving, though, and rolled my eyes only a little at the film's gay-in-thought-only cowardice (which to some degree gets balanced by a fairly progressive Detective Inspector who clearly empathizes with those forced to hide their true selves and keeps scowling at an underling's casual homophobia). And it generally looks and plays more like seedy noir than it does a didactic message movie.
Wit (2001, Mike Nichols): 49/100
Previously seen: 9 February 2001, Berlin, Germany (the one time I attended the Berlin Film Festival).
Original opinion: C+. Addressed in the Berlin report on my site.
Now: Got choked up this time by a completely different moment, but it was still something language-specific. (Literally just the word "comma," in the movie's very last line. Callback to an earlier debate about how one of Donne's poems should be punctuated.) Otherwise exasperating again—Wit falls in the 99th percentile for staginess of a theater adaptation, with something like half the dialogue spoken directly to camera (typical example: Vivian says "fuck" while puking, then turns to us and wryly annotates "You may regard that my vocabulary has taken a turn for the Anglo-Saxon") and the protagonist confined to a hospital bed. (I rewatched this while my dad was in the hospital dying of cancer, but that's a total coincidence. Was randomly selected via shuffle.) Nichols does his best to open it up via memory-induced flashbacks that now mostly occur in their original time/locations (with spillover), but it's still closer in spirit to the Hamilton "movie" than to actual cinema. Surprised to discover that I probably first heard "Spiegel im Spiegel" here, a year and a half prior to seeing Gerry at TIFF 2002.
The Secret of My Success (1987, Herbert Ross): 36/100
Previously seen: ca. April 1987, San Jose, CA (Century 21).
Original opinion: Unrecorded, don't remember.
Now: I tend to romanticize the '80s as a banner period for Hollywood comedy—cherry-picking Midnight Run and Spinal Tap and early Tim Burton and so forth—so it's good to keep getting these reminders of how many mediocrities were released as well. Final stretch features some of the worst slamming-door bedroom farce I've ever seen, but prior to that it's just kinda lame and half-assed, far too confident in Michael J. Fox's ability to rescue weak comic ideas with sheer likeability. Helen Slater can do nothing with the female lead, but Margaret Whitton has great fun playing a riff on Mrs. Robinson and Mercedes Ruehl, still a couple years away from her breakout role in Married to the Mob, steals her single scene as a nosy diner waitress. That's about it for stuff that doesn't feel labored. Nightmare fuckin' '80s music throughout. I knew we were in trouble early on, when someone says, of an ordinary NYC skyscraper, "There are 30,000 people working in this building alone"—looked it up and sure enough, there aren't even 30,000 people working in the Pentagon, much less at 599 Lexington (maybe 6,000).
ANAL-RETENTIVE TITLE CORNER: You could make a case for The Secret of My Succe$s, which is where the title ultimately lands. "Success" appears first and then the second 's' gets replaced by a dollar sign. That's a judgment call imo—I went with Drive-Away Dykes, because Ethan and Tricia were clearly strongarmed into Dolls and rebelled, but no such battle took place here and I choose to deem "Succe$s" just a joke.
A King in New York (1957, Charles Chaplin): 59/100
Previously seen: 19 April 1996, New York, NY (MoMA).
Original opinion: Favorable. Which I did not remember, but fortunately I e-mailed my reaction to a friend: "I was prepared for this to suck, but it was surprisingly funny, though of course not remotely in the league of Chaplin's great silent films. His son Michael Chaplin is excellent in a supporting role, as an obnoxious communist brat. A decent satire which takes on advertising, television, McCarthyism, and (give it up, Charlie) CinemaScope and "noisy" jazz."
Now: Actually, King's biggest problem is that it's kind of all over the place, with Chaplin unable to decide upon a target. Individual sequences are often hilarious—the dinner party that's actually a hidden-camera live TV broadcast in which one woman keeps reciting ad copy like Laura Linney in The Truman Show is a highlight, and I did crack up again at 10-or-11-year-old Michael Chaplin (who, like Geraldine, is still alive at this writing) delivering revolutionary jargon via stentorian shouts—but the jumble of overt political commentary and broad advertising-age satire and Old Man Yells At Cloud never remotely starts to cohere. Ending's particularly dissatisfying. Still, pretty vital for a titan of the silent era, working in exile. (I have yet to endure A Countess From Hong Kong, which has few defenders as far as I can tell.)
Conspiracy Theory (1997, Richard Donner): 47/100
Previously seen: 14 August 1997, New York, NY (Loews Village).
Original opinion: 2½ stars out of four. Reviewed it on my site.
Now: Didn't find it as formally beguiling this time, but I'll chalk that up to 35mm vs. Tubi. Would rubber-stamp my contemporaneous review in every other respect, and am relieved to find (having retained mostly fond-ish memories, though I knew my overall feelings were mixed) that I did recognize the movie's third-act nosedive into risible bullshit. As I noted then, the zenith's a deranged interrogation/escape sequence, which I'd forgotten until making this memorial viewing choice features the late Sir Patrick Stewart as a honey-voiced villain (he's basically been tasked to reprise Olivier's "Is it safe?"), nearly 20 years prior to his neo-Nazi Green Room badass. Gibson's performance now strikes me as a tad showy, but on the other hand, subsequent events (both directly involving Gibson and not) have retroactively enriched his character's nutjob ravings. I remain livid that someone came up with the A+ plot idea "conspiracy theorist is right about one of his many theories, hence targeted by The Man, but has no idea which one it is (plus still believes all of 'em)" and then blithely tossed it aside. And the ending suuuuuucks.
Year-end's within sight and that means W/Os are back baby!
Two Seasons, Two Strangers (Shō Miyake): "Nothing really solves the basic fact that the actors in the first part...are so much more interesting than the actors (and emotions, tbh) in the second," concludes Theo's positive review—an almost terrifying prospect, since I find it hard to conceive of two characters less engaging than the ones he preferred. They're both sodden lumps imo, and only the inconvenient fact that this film won Locarno's top prize prevents me from confidently asserting that nobody would agree to make a movie so aggressively tepid.
Maddie's Secret (John Early): Didn't get what Early was up to (in part because I'm completely unfamiliar with issue-oriented '80s TV movies generally and Kate's Secret specifically), but this is a rare case in which I'm gonna blame the filmmaker rather than myself. Took me a while just to grasp that he's a man playing a woman rather than a trans actor (don't really know Early, either, despite having seen him in three previous indie films), and then the playing-camp-straight aspect that inspires Sirk and Haynes comparisons escaped me—it looked like failed comedy, thanks to Early throwing in lame jokes like a parody of The Bear called The Boar (get it? The Bore). Plus many of the supporting actors are giving what appear for all the world to be comically heightened performances. I wasn't laughing, so I bailed. Might try again at year's end.
Forastera (Lucía Aleñar Iglesias): Nothing to say about this one. It just never captured my interest. One of the two teen girls keeps allowing people on the phone to believe that she's her grandma (who dies in a fall early on), which I have to assume eventually leads somewhere (there's a scene right before I bailed in which she tries on one of grandma's dresses and seems to go into a trance; I also see critics calling this a ghost story of sorts), but either get to that more speedily or make the setup more compelling, please.
Minions & Monsters (Pierre Coffin): If this is the surprisingly good Minions movie, I'm very happy to have skipped all the previous ones. To be fair, Frick and Frack (I'm not gonna look up their actual names) had barely even arrived in Hollywood when I reached my W/O point, but that in itself is a major liability. And the classic-cinema references I did see (Minions in the Modern Times gear machine, Minions knocking the house's frame over Buster Keaton, etc.) were just that: references. Wasn't gonna overcome my not finding the Minions themselves very funny.