Creepshow (1982, George A. Romero) (Patreon)
Content
50/100
Can't accurately deploy my standard "source material's greatness is intrinsic to its original medium" criticism, as Stephen King wrote three of Creepshow's five tales directly for the screen. (The other two were adapted from his short stories.) Still, I'd likely have recognized the E.C. influence even had Romero not used comic-book pages as a transitional device, and it's easy to imagine even the film's strongest segments being more effective as a series of drawn/inked panels. E.C. trafficked in stark moralism, favoring unambiguously evil characters who inevitably receive some ghastly comeuppance on the final page; that degree of simplicity just works better at a higher level of abstraction. Even when giving deliberately cartoonish performances, as many do here, actors kinda get in the way. The pure nastiness sure comes through, though.
Guess I'll re-use my Ballad of Buster Scruggs format, tackling each story individually in ascending order of preference. Won't rate each one but the five ratings I blithely noted do in fact average to 50.
Con
"The Lonesome Death of Jordy Verrill": I assume this is almost everyone's least favorite, if only because it's a one-man show and King himself is that man. I get that he's intentionally overacting, but that, too, can be done poorly; a little of King's goggle eyes go a mighty long way. Originally a short story (less poetically titled "Weeds"), "Lonesome Death" lacks any E.C. moralism—Jordy's a dimwitted hick who does nothing to deserve his fate, unless you want to judge him for dreaming of a $200 payday for the meteorite. Consequently, there's little to this apart from the production designer's team adding more greenery for each successive scene and the makeup team applying mossy appliances to the world's most popular horror author. Who, again, should not have tried acting. I seem to recall him having acknowledged that at some point.
"Father's Day": Hard to make Ed Harris boring, but the opening tale somehow manages it. This one's arguably the most quintessentially E.C. in its construction, a first-rate approximation of their writing stable's house style; it's also the one that most cries out to be in comic form. Everyone onscreen is varying degrees of awful (except Harris' bland son-in-law, who's underwritten to the point of seeming almost lobotomized), which quickly grows tiresome even at roughly 20 minutes. And while "zombie patriarch rises from the grave to demand cake" couldn't be more E.C., the way that it plays out lacks the necessary grotesque flair, arriving there only with its (fairly predictable) final image. Also, is it just my own family that's never once made/ordered a Father's Day cake in the 81 years (and no longer really counting, sadly) that my own dad's been alive?
Mixed
"The Crate": Creepshow's longest segment, I believe, and another that King had previously published as a short story (unread by me, as is "Weeds"). Romero milks the crate itself for maximum tension, to good effect, and I don't overly mind that the carnivorous creature within fails to reward one's anticipation, looking as it does like an ape with Venom's teeth. Again, though, the E.C. shorthand characterization—combined, in this case, with King's penchant for the recurring "catchphrase" ("Just call me Billie, everyone does") with a final ironic twist—becomes pretty laborious after a while. Adrienne Barbeau does her best to make Billie amusingly unbearable, and Hal Holbrook was an inspired choice for Mr. Henpecked (I'm less keen on Fritz Weaver's histrionics), but the extra attention this was given isn't really warranted.
Pro
"Something to Tide You Over": Honestly, this is no less thin and one-dimensional than its fellows, but its central idea is so horrifying to first contemplate and then witness at excruciating length (no coincidence that the two stories I like best are the ones that do to some extent benefit from live action) that it overcomes those drawbacks and is guaranteed to lodge itself forever in your memory. Something about the inexorability of drowning in that particular way—I'm likewise upset by sequences in which a room gradually fills with water as characters poke their noses up to the few remaining inches of air, but slow tidal oscillation might be even worse. Plus you've got young Ted Danson as the primary victim and Leslie Nielsen, playing against what became his type, as the vengeful cuck. Climactic turnabout's meh but this is impressively unpleasant.
"They're Creeping up on You!": Same deal, really—it's just incredibly gross, taking full advantage of our atavistic revulsion toward roaches. Not sure how much time E.G. Marshall actually had to spend being crawled upon (finale's clearly a dummy, albeit a decent one, and many inserts are likely body doubles), but to be game for this project at age 68 merits respect no matter what. Romero has great fun with the setups (including some randomly goofy distorted peephole views when the super briefly shows up), the Kubrickianly sterile white apartment set provides an ideal contrast for filthy scurrying, and Marshall has the time of his life playing a cheery sadistic asshole with Larry Fine hair. Were Upson Pratt a minor character in a standard narrative horror film, this sequence would almost certainly be considered a classic.
(Nothing much to say about the wraparound bit, except that it ends nicely and I recognized Tom Atkins from his recurring Rockford Files role.)