Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

86/100

Second viewing, last seen at the Walter Reade in 2001. The occasion back then was a Pinter retro, and one could certainly start there (as Pinter reportedly made Robin Maugham's 1948 source novella his own), or with Losey (who was fresh off another perverse triumph, The Damned), or with Dirk Bogarde (giving arguably his finest performance; sidenote: Losey's The Damned isn't the The Damned in which Bogarde starred). But I'd instead like to first praise Douglas Slocombe, whose career as a cinematographer stretched from Kind Hearts and Coronets all the way to Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, and who here captures some of the most magnificent monochrome images that cinema ever produced. Not in a showy way, either, although he and Losey have fun with a concave mirror hanging on one wall. To steal a phrase that my friend Vadim inexplicably applied to My Wife Cries (the first roughly 10-12 minutes of which consist of a dude standing in front of a nondescript office wall plus reverse shots of two women sitting at equally nondescript office desks)*, The Servant is just absurdly gorgeous, composed and lit to perfection. At one point there's a close-up of a sink tap (its drip symbolically representing Tony's pulse) that I'd happily frame on my wall.

Losey also favors a variation on what I think of as Kurosawa's (Akira, not Kiyoshi) formal style, employing small, unobtrusive camera movements and actors' blocking to continually recompose images within a sustained single shot. (That's very distinct from "Let's follow the actors around with a Steadicam and make sure viewers can tell how difficult it was to accomplish," which is what I infamously get irked by.) Which of course is ideal for a story about shifting power dynamics. I'd remembered The Servant as a black comedy in which the title character gradually usurps master status, but it's more complicated and interesting than that—Barrett's true goal is moral corruption, and the film ends, rather shockingly for the era (though its notion of grotesque vice looks almost quaint today), with depravity triumphant. Early scenes of manipulation are nicely counterbalanced by Susan seeing right through Barrett from the get-go and challenging him at every turn; if you look closely, you'll see Bogarde do a full-body tremble when Susan, apropos of nothing whatsoever, asks Barrett whether he uses deodorant. ("Tell me, do you think you go well with the color scheme?" is her follow-up question when he doesn't reply.) Which makes it all the more hideous at the end when Susan capitulates in the most wretched instance of "If you can't beat 'em, join 'em" imaginable. This achieves its visual apotheosis when Tony and Susan cut short their visit to a friend's country house and catch Barrett and Vera fucking in Tony's upstairs bedroom; investigating the noise, Barrett appears as a clearly nude shadow on the wall (no dick, you can just see the figure isn't wearing clothes) and proceeds to silently stand his ground for a small eternity, challenging them with his lack of shame, until Tony finally walks away in despair.

Bogarde's ability to metamorphose from servile to lascivious and (incredibly) back again, plus occasionally suggest both at the same time, is nothing short of miraculous. Hard to imagine another actor playing this role with remotely as much twisted gusto—my single favorite moment sees Barrett follow Susan to the front door and then close it behind her with visible mustard, so that it looks for all the world like he's violently slamming the door, yet the door does not in fact slam. It's a physical gesture for himself alone, as if he'd flipped her off. But far more elegant. Also intriguing is the way that Barrett gets expressly coded as female in act three, after he's apologized to Tony and ostensibly returned to service; the joke is obviously that they become a bickering gay couple, but this time it occurred to me that designating Barrett as the woman—cleaning, cooking, feeling unappreciated, etc.; his dialogue becomes 100% unhappy-wife cliché—creates (inadvertently?) a feminist subtext as Barrett gradually asserts himself, culminating in Tony suggesting that maybe they should be equal partners in housekeeping. It's a bit like the useful cognitive dissonance that arose from having a woman be TÁR's sexual predator. Heady stuff, but I must emphasize that concentrating on the film's themes can be difficult, because one gets preoccupied with how immaculately every single shot has been constructed. It's as ravishing a portrait of sheer ugliness as you're ever likely to encounter.

Was surprised to discover afterward that three of The Servant's four top-billed stars are still alive. Bogarde died in 1999, but James Fox, Sarah Miles and Wendy Craig are still with us at this writing, ages 87, 84 and 92, respectively. That's gotta be pretty rare for a 60+-year-old film.

* A gratuitous stray fired at an unrelated film, obviously, but I'm sticking it here because an opportunity to naturally drop it into conversation never arose when I hung out with Vadim and others at the Town Crier in Toronto. Absurdly gorgeous how? Not, like, to look at, surely?

Files

Comments

Tiger Inn

I would say that MY WIFE CRIES is also “absurdly gorgeous, composed and lit to perfection.” (I love THE SERVANT as well)

Mike D'Angelo

I genuinely want a fan of the film to explain this to me. What’s absurdly gorgeous about the initial 5- or 6-minute-long shot of a guy standing in front of a nondescript wall? Or the subsequent shots of the women sitting at desks? I can at least theoretically comprehend appreciating the film’s formal approach in a multitude of other ways, but much of it could not possibly be more visually banal.

Tiger Inn

I would say that it’s the tension between the nondescript locations and the pleasing delicacy of the lighting and color that’s very beautiful to me, both here and throughout the film, but Vadim can definitely put it better than I could.

Mike D'Angelo

Ah, if it’s mostly color then much is explained. (Note that this film has none.)

jamsheed siyar

After the reading the review, I'm curious why this isn't a 90+ / 5-star film for you. I myself think it is a near perfect 5-star film, so wondering what your reservations are.

Mike D'Angelo

It doesn’t work like that. I don’t need to have specific criticisms or reservations. All 86 signifies is that I don’t love it as much as I do films I rated even higher.