The Road (2009, John Hillcoat) (Patreon)
Content
53/100
There's something about this film that's so gray, it's like, How much more gray could this be? And the answer is: none. None...more gray.
Perhaps that radically desaturated aesthetic—a color film without any colors—was bracing 17 years ago. (Though even then I'd likely have compared it to Roger Deakins' bleach-bypass work on 1984's Nineteen Eighty-Four.) But I've come to The Road late and it's no longer far enough off the beaten path to pulverize me with its pallor. Likewise not the movie's fault, but an obstacle nonetheless: Casey Affleck took the same basic idea and made what I consider to be a richer and far more affecting post-apocalyptic father-"son" survival tale, featuring stronger performances (I find Smit-McPhee less annoying here than in his subsequent teen roles, but Anna Pniowsky was nearly my top Actress pick for 2019) and a singular "hook" (we know the dystopia's root cause and it places our heroes in very specific danger). What The Road has going for it, mostly, is pedigree, plus Hillcoat's commitment to honoring the book's by-all-accounts (still haven't read it) unremitting bleakness. Seems as if Joel and Ethan may have adapted the sole Cormac McCarthy novel that's sufficiently narrative-driven to be well suited for cinema—Billy Bob Thornton's attempt at All the Pretty Horses got Harvey Scissorhanded down to incoherence, while James Franco's Child of God was simply a disaster. (Apparently László Nemes plans to make Outer Dark, but I can't tell whether that's actually begun shooting.) And merely glancing at any page of The Road reveals the foolhardiness of seeking to translate purple-tinged poetic prose into barely chromatic nihilistic images. Being enveloped in this film's cinematography for two hours never comes close to capturing the feeling that McCarthy pulled off in just 11 words on page one: "Like the onset of some cold glaucoma dimming away the world." Don't try to film that. Create your own singular vision, directly.
Anyway, y'all know my standard leave-it-on-the-page rant. Let me instead focus on the one aspect that interested me, viz. Boy's increasing discomfort with his father's ruthless worldview, tailored to how little remains of the world they'd once known. No civilization, no civility. The hard question of whether life is still worth living gets repeatedly raised by flashbacks to the unspecified event's aftermath, with Charlize Theron arguing for (and eventually settling on) No; in the film's second half, however, when Man and Boy start encountering others (in circumstances that don't involve just running and/or hiding from them), the dilemma shifts slightly, with Boy unwilling to accept, as Man clearly has and teaches by example, that to stay alive requires divesting oneself of empathy, and indeed of humanity. I dearly wish that the eye-for-an-eye scene with Michael Kenneth Williams (R.I.P.), in which Man catches the dude who stole their cart of belongings and effectively leaves him for dead by taking all his clothes, as Boy pleads for mercy on his behalf, were more integral to the movie, rather than feeling like a discrete highlight. It's admittedly a bit philistine-y to want some sort of conventional dramatic Red River-style showdown from a McCarthy adaptation about the end of the world, but that would at least have filled the sizable void left by reducing The Road to its meager narrative. There's ultimately too little here that's compelling in the moment, after your eyes have adjusted to the grayness and you've internalized the lack of any real hope.
(That we in fact do get some at the end feels meretricious, though it looks to have come straight from the novel. I did enjoy Guy Pearce saying "You're kind of weirded out, aren't you, kid?" Is that McCarthy? To judge from his Counselor script, I suppose it could be.)