Festival Flashback: Bitter Christmas, Elsinore, Minotaur (Patreon)
Content
Resuscitating reviews I wrote at festivals that Patreon’s crap search engine wouldn't previously have delivered because the titles weren't in the subject line. The film(s) in question will generally have just opened theatrically in New York City when these posts appear.
Bitter Christmas (Pedro Almodóvar, Spain): 55/100 [TIFF '26]
Second consecutive movie (across two days; previous instance was Paradise Lost) that I thought had lost me until it unexpectedly rallied at the end by going totally nuts. This was a very different experience, though, perhaps unique in my long filmgoing life: I had a laundry list of complaints about Bitter Christmas—most of them structural; the film seemed bizarrely incoherent, forgetting all about key characters while abruptly introducing others far too late—and also felt mostly annoyed by its meta-frame whereby most of what we’re seeing is yet another blatant Almodóvar avatar’s semi-autobiographical script-in-progress. But then Almopseudóvar's long-suffering assistant delivers a withering critique of said script that I kid you not hits every single mental objection that I’d filed over the preceding 90 or so minutes, making it clear that those weaknesses were deliberate, part of the film’s grand design. Not unprecedented, I just realized—it’s kinda like Adaptation's janky home stretch, which doesn’t “work” but nonetheless does because we understand it was written by Donald Kaufman. In this case, you have to apply that understanding retroactively, and I’m not convinced that the present-tense frustration (which makes the movie feel much longer than its 111 minutes—nothing drags like apparent randomness) is really worth it. Still, bold move from an oldster.
Elsinore (Simon Stone): 42/100 [AFI Fest '26]
Bold move to open with Daniel Day-Lewis' infamous onstage meltdown, even if that is why Ian Charleson got tapped to play Hamlet at the National—by the end, I dearly wished to have just watched an entire film about that production instead. Though I wouldn't trust either Stone (whose little-seen 2015 Ibsen adaptation The Daughter, while not great, was far superior to this lachrymose tribute) or screenwriter Stephen Beresford not to botch that, either, since Elsinore depicts theater as an artistic pursuit almost exclusively devoted to actors memorizing their lines. Lost count of how many lame montages we get in which every shot shows Charleson running his fucking lines with someone else who's holding a dog-eared copy of Hamlet—it was probably only two, actually, but that's two too many. Stone has an extensive theatrical background and clearly knows what rehearsal actually entails; he's deliberately pandering to the groundlings here, asking us to marvel at the fact that Charleson was dying yet still remembered everything he was supposed to say. Andrew Scott's a fine actor, but the awards buzz around this performance is very Hamnet-esque, with folks being unduly bowled over by raw intensity. (See every "it's not called Most Acting" diatribe.) I don't love what ludicrously little we see of Scott's Hamlet, either (unclear to me whether he's reprising his own celebrated West End performance or attempting to replicate Charleson's), and the less said about Olivia Colman's doctor learning that there's more to treating disease than just mechanically prolonging life, the better. Scenes featuring a testy Derek Jarman are quite good, though. Glad to see Juliet Stevenson still has enough stature to land a "with" designation in the cast list; wish they'd given her (and the other Hamlet cast) more to do.
(Oh, and if you can't predict exactly how this sucker's gonna end the moment said ending is related in dialogue near the beginning, maybe you'll be more moved by it than I was after nearly two hours of awaiting the inevitable. Plus of course "flights of angels" does double duty too.)
Minotaur (Andreï Zviaguintsev [sic, that’s what’s onscreen], France/Germany/Latvia): 61/100 [TIFF '26]
Saw beforehand and then totally forgot that this is Chabrol's La Femme infidèle, which is still in my to-watch queue. Narrative and atmosphere have been thoroughly Zvyagintsevved, though, and I once again (as with Leviathan) found myself slightly resisting a first-rate portrait of institutional corruption, simply because it feels reflexively easy (even if true) to suggest that people can get away with any imaginable horror provided they’re allied with the national power structure. Where Minotaur diverges from its source, it does so in exactly the way that you’d expect from this filmmaker, and I correctly guessed where we were headed despite not knowing said source at all. (Well, I did see Lyne’s Unfaithful. But I barely remember that. Didn’t like it, 49/100.) Still, it’s totally engrossing moment-to-moment, anchored by a lead performance that positively oozes fatal weakness of character counterbalanced by (accurately) perceived untouchability. It’s just also the kind of film in which you know what a banner being torn down will consist of at least 30 seconds before its face is shown to you.