Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A VERY tricky question in which Thomas analyzed it correctly but picked (D) over the correct answer (B).  He's now 156-for-299 (52.2%).

Files

Comments

Becca

Yessss!!! My sheer guess worked.

Quark Twain

Exams for nursing students are like this. If none of the answers are great, which one is least wrong or most kinda-sorta-correct? (I only know this from helping a nursing student to study a few years back.)

Renee Z

Hoorah, Becca. I was disappointed that Andrew and Thomas stuck only to the social media answers, especially when nobody had a correct answer on Twitter. I'm not on social media, but that wouldn't help me. I rarely pick the correct answer. Thomas and Andrew used to pull answers from the Patreon responses from time to time, but I haven't heard them do that for a long time. When I read your answer a few days ago, I was impressed. It seemed correct. (I'm not a lawyer, but I liked your reasoning.) "B, oral contract exists, teacher asked for work-the student asked for payment. The teacher upped the antie by placing forced retaliatory threat (and servitude) for non performance. This one action made the teacher also liable for damages (Plus the original payment)" Great job! (Better than Russell's answer, although his was funny.) You may not have won never-ending fame and fortune, but I think you deserve it!

Ilan Woll

Still confused why A is wrong. If there was a contract, there was no breach as there was negative consideration. If there wasn’t, then also no breach

Becca

Thank you. I'm ok without fame. 🤣 I was not 100% certain it was right. It just feels good to know I got it. Thanks again.

Renee Z

I think this test book was written by a team that included Lewis Carroll and some lawyers who studied non-US law.

Quark Twain

I'm still confused too. I think A is wrong because it assumes the existence of a contract. If A had said "No because there was no contract" it might have been the best answer. As for negative consideration, that seems questionable. Even if we give the teacher the benefit of the doubt that it would have been reasonable for them to report the student to the principal, I don't think "do this or you'll be in big trouble" qualifies as a contract.

Ilan Woll

That’s fair. I was thinking of the getting in trouble as another item. If it was blackmail, I still think there was no contract, but that gets us to B if there was one where the consideration was illegal

Eric Brewer

I don’t understand how a contract existed in the first place. And threatening the student if they didn’t do the thing feels like coercion to me.

Becca

As I understand the contract, its like negotiating mowing the lawn. It's a oral contract. Teacher needed work, student said they would do it for a price. (That creates the contract) At that point either can say... no... and walk away. The teacher making a threat creates servitude or forced work, after the contract was in place. That is how I read it. ------------ Change the "books" to "build me a house" and increase the request for money to $30k.... then have the teacher say, do it for no money or I will turn you in.