Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This wild story has been on my radar for a while, but now that there's a lawsuit involved, I've convinced Andrew to give us a breakdown! But Andrew doesn't just take us through the lawsuit. We go through the accusations, and what it might take to try to prove a low frequency event to a jury. Along the way, there's a poker cheating accusation scandal as well!

Files

Comments

Quark Twain

A "low frequency event" is that what the kids are calling it these days? (Seriously though, I'm glad you're covering this wild story!)

Amanda Horne

I'm on team Thomas on this one, but I tend to be painfully naive when it comes to trusting people. I also don't have much outside knowledge of the story to go off of

JustAGuy

As somebody who has functionally less than no understanding of poker or any such games; If I was stupid-rich enough to be able to go high-stakes poker-playing, the moves the 'influencer' made in the story sound very much like stuff I would do. Because I'm an asshole. Experience has taught me that often the best way ruin things for people who know what they are doing, is to do stupid shit that makes no sense, then follow up with nonsense guess justifications if questioned. It works surprisingly well across a number of different games.

Opening Arguments

hooo boy. I'll get that posted separately. Thank you for notifying us.

Aran Jackson

Maybe bleep the attorney’s phone number

Honore de Balzac

Hearing about how much the Chess adjudication world is on the side of Karlsson gives me flashbacks to the King of Kong documentary: Steve Wiebe had to fight so hard to be counted as a world record holder, because the Twin Galaxies staff were all such close friends with Billy Mitchell...although the cheating accusations went the other way, Mitchell's cheating was more readily accepted than Wiebe's legit record. I just think of this situation as a jackass who's ranked number 1 thinks that means no one could EVER beat them, and then reality ensued when his game got sloppy.

Quark Twain

Fascinating discussion! Like Thomas, I view the chess.com report with a lot of skepticism. Their report goes like this: 1. Here are some fascinating behind-the-scenes details about how we monitor cheating on our website. 2. We used those methods and many other secret techniques to check if Niemann cheated. 3. In conclusion, here are some impressive looking numbers and charts showing he cheated more than 100 times, which are impossible to verify or double check. Also, Niemann's lawsuit has a few strange passages. Does the following sound like a reasonable legal claim that should be in the complaint? "Carlsen, having solidified his position as the 'King of Chess,' believes that when it comes to chess, he can do whatever he wants and get away with it."

Stormy Decisis

I'm team Thomas with regard to looking-but-not-seeing cards. I don't know much about poker, so I can't weigh in there, but from a cognitive psychology perspective, I can tell you that looking-but-not-seeing is a very well-recognized phenomenon - yes, even in important, high stakes situations. Visual perception includes both bottom up (perception shapes thought) and top down (thought shapes perception) elements to a degree that is very difficult to intuit

Sidewinder

That's fair but to say that it's absurd for Andrew to think the explanation "I thought I had the card that we all saw in the flop the entire game" is a bad answer is a little too far. Is it possible she misread/thought she had that card? Sure! Does that mean folks are crazy to say "that doesn't make any sense because XYZ", nope.

Jake Miller

Just a quick note on the poker takes. I play a bit and have some insights on the hand itself. When Lew makes the call, she is technically behind Adelstein's equity (Lew's 47% to Adelstein's 53%, side note this must exclude dead cards already). However, she only needs 40% equity to make the call a profitable one in this situation because there is already 51.7k in the pot. So it goes she needs to call 109k to potentially win 269.7k. This translates to pot odds of 40.4% to call (109k/269.7k). So her expected value of a call is +$17.7k roughly, making this a profitable call if you know your opponents hole cards and equity. Therefore, I disagree with the premise that it doesn't make sense to call if you are cheating.

WiseThat

Is it REALLY so hard to believe that a professional poker player had a feeling in her gut that the opponent had bupkiss, and that in the heat of the moment they took a long bet? Or that a man who has been one of the top chess players since he was 11 saw his opponent make a mistake and acted on instinct to choose a good reply? What I'm seeing out of Magnus is wounded pride ("This kid didn't grovel enough to me, he must be cheating!" & thinking that because HE didn't see the weakness in a move he was about to make, NOBODY should have been able to). C'mon, Andrew, I thought you were a baseball fan? Statistics and averages are fun and all, but what is sports without the occasional instance of a wild instinct by an underdog snatching an unlikely win!

TMoney2007

She's not a professional poker player. She's an occasional high stakes player. That's not the same thing at all. Also, professional poker players don't play based on "gut" feeling. Few successful players even make significant decisions based on live reads.

Just a Little Guy

Don't forget the classic "We unequivocally are not accusing Niemann of cheating OTB. Now, here are 20 pages of why we're suspicious of his OTB play."

Ray Kosby

Niemann's interviews where he said the chess speaks for itself and walked off, and where he described his play against Carlson mad me think of the film Ratatouille. If only he had been wearing a hat.

Just a Little Guy

I wonder if this goes to the tactics of trying to cheat without getting caught. It makes sense to call if you're cheating and willing to brazenly do whatever is the optimal play given all information. It doesn't make sense if you're cheating but trying to make it look like you aren't cheating.

Tim

Great episode! Long time chess player here. You got the chess facts largely correct. I only had a few nits (ex/ chess "solvers" are called "engines") but overall great stuff! Personally, I don't think Hans cheated over the board but I totally get why people are very suspicious of him. It also doesn't help that he's a bit of an asshole.

Blessed are the cheesemakers

Thank you for covering this story. It’s awesome to see my favorite podcast cover stories about my favorite game! Some comments: 1. Carlsen has a huge ego, but the theory that he insinuated that Niemann is cheating only because Niemann beat Magnus OTB and broke his streak is nonsense. Magnus cares more about his reputation than the streak. Magnus also had a streak of 120+ games prior to this, so this 50+ game streak is not really a huge thing. 2. Psychology factors into chess way more than you give it credit for. If Carlsen knew that Niemann was a cheater (even if it's "only" online), then this will strongly (negatively) affect how Carlsen plays against Niemann. I took this to be the main reason why Carlsen doesn't want to play Niemann anymore. It doesn't really matter if Niemann cheated against Magnus in Round 3. If Carlsen (or any opponent) suspects that Niemann might cheat, then this will negatively impact their game, and it may be reason enough to want to avoid Niemann going forward. This also explains why Magnus didn’t want to play in the first place, and why he didn’t play Niemann in the following tournament. 3. Besides the statistical anomalies of Niemann's sudden rise in chess, Niemann's main coach (Dlugy) has also been banned for cheating. 4. When Carlsen stated that Niemann has cheated way more than he admits to, Carlsen was referring to Hans' interview where Niemann admitted to cheating twice. I don't remember if this was an editing thing or not, but I don't think this was clear. This statement by Carlsen was prior to the chess.com report. 5. The cheating detection algorithms used by chess.com were created by Kenneth Regan (Computer Science professor), and were not created by chess.com. They are not secret algorithms created by chess.com as you suggest. 6. In my view, the fact that Magnus brought up that Niemann didn’t look worried/taxed during the event is much more important than you make it. Magnus is arguably the best chess player that has ever lived, and he would have a unique ability to determine when it was likely that chess players would be cheating or not. Of course, Magnus is partial so he may not be the best witness here, but he would definitely have the strongest sense of when someone would be cheating. 7. The lawsuit seems to be written (at least in part) by Niemann himself. Item 1 starts with the sentence “Niemann is a 19 year old self-taught chess prodigy.” Item 4 starts with “Defendant Sven Magnus Øen Carlsen (“Carlsen”) is a 31 year old chess player from Norway.” I assumed that these comments meant the lawsuit was not a serious one. You seem to think it will be taken seriously, so it will be interesting to see where it goes. Thanks again for the reaction!

Anders Hersvik

Thomas has a good argument, but I think the essence in the implication of cheating in chess here is not based on the result in that game in Sinquefield. It is the way Hans gainef that reserve seat. Taking in to consideration that any cheating over time artificially (and stepping up in small increments so as not to gain suspicion from the general public which is the not very well concealed message in the chess.com report) would enable him to play in the big tournaments and gain a large following, enabling him to make a living of chess rather than struggling in the «just below the top» players. He is undeniably a very good chess-player. (Mind you also that if any of the other players you mention in this category had been caught cheating at 12 they would already have been grandmasters and at a very high level, but such a reveal at that time would have resulted in them not being invited to larger events and thus they would not have been able to gain the rating in over the board classic chess that is sufficient to play the world elite) inthink the premise is here then that regardless if there was cheating in this particular game, i think there was a consensus among the top plater that this player should not have been able to play in this tournament in the first place) … very unforgiving the chess community it seems 🙄

Anders Hersvik

Might add that I don’t necessarily think any of these world class players in the top 20 or so need to be «in the know» with chess.com to suspect him cheating from earlier times. If they play each other in important tournaments i figure some of the prep work is to pull up an chess engine and analyze how their opponents play in the different situations, maybe analyzing all their games played in tournaments for the last couple of years, it might well be clear to any player of rating in the 27-2800 and above analysing old games when rating was lower for the opponent (which is likely the case against the younger opponents new to the elite scene) if this opponent then consistently has games where moves are made that even the highest rared players cant find but the chess engines suggest will be an advantage many moves ahead, they don’t need an algoritm to at least suspect foul play. We’re talking about people who have hundreds (probably thousands in some cases) of chess games memorized down to each move (who played, which year, which tournament, how the match ended). In the weeks leading up to a tournament like sinquefield they’ll have a set of openings ready to play tailored to each of the opponents, based on what the opponents weakness (which positions and openings they hav struggled with in the past and so on…) what would seem as not the best move by a very high rated player might be to steer the positions into such trouble-areas and then maybe be able to raise the chance to tweak out a win by making your opponent have to calculate the unknown (its a time limited game) instead of playing a dull book-draw.

Balloons in BOLD

Everybody here with chess hot takes and I'm wondering if we're gonna get a follow up on the musk Twitter deal next episode

David Dunsmore

I’ve relistened to this episode and I’m still confused: in order to defend himself against the defamation claim, does Carlsen have to prove that Hans cheated or only that he had a good faith belief that he did?

Quark Twain

Regarding Dlugy, I suggest reading his public response. I don't think he's a cheater, but his situation highlights how much power a site like chess dot com has. As for the cheating algorithms, they are very much secret. Even if they are based primarily on Regan's work, they incorporate proprietary methods. Unless the company releases the raw data from those matches and allows others to verify the calculations, they're doing secret stuff. That said, I agree with some of your other points, especially that it was awesome to see this story covered on OA!

WiseThat

As I understand it, belief alone is not enough, you can "believe something" and still have "Reckless Disregard for the truth".

Blessed are the cheesemakers

I haven't read Dlugy's statement about Hans, but Dlugy has admitted to cheating in the past. This admission has earned him a ban (I would have to look into whether it's temporary or permanent) from chess.com. I suppose chess.com has lots of power in this regard, but as a private company, I feel like they should have discretion over whether or not known cheaters get to play on their site. In fairness, I don't know whether chess.com is directly using Regan's algorithms or not, but I suspect neither do you. They very well may be doing "secret stuff," but I don't know of anything that would even suggest that. I'm very interested to see what happens next in the lawsuit, and I'm grateful for OA for instructing me how to best read a legal document!