Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

Comments

Catrenya

I want to believe that the actual book looks like a ransom note.

Russian warship, Go clownhorn yourself

Test answer is B. The same restrictions apply to all organizations, so it's not an undue burden specifically on the church. Real world answer is the FSWs on the Supreme Court would manufacture a false narrative that will allow a *Christian* church to do whatever the hell it pleases.

Chris Wiswell

A! If Peyote church wanted to have a hash brownie bake sale, that would also be prohibited (in most states) as bake sales aren't religious exercise. Lotto fundraising is also not a religious exercise, so A, it's illegal.

Abrea

A. Abreon and Abrea's secondhand lawfirm says B though.

Erin Hutton

A. They can raise money in a different, legal way, but the actual lottery has nothing to do with the practice of the Peyote religion directly, so no violationoccurred. B doesn't quite fit. Maybe because we don't know exactly how the state law is worded, but I don't think we can rule out an exception . C is interesting. It is a state law, so Federal doesn't have jurisdiction, (right?) But the Constitution is Federal, so do they? Either way, the answer doesn't fit with the question, so not C. D can't be it. If the state law can not keep a religious organization from using illegal means to raise money, then they could sell drugs and health insurance policies with no repercussions, too, yeah? My final answer is A.

Erin Hutton

Chris, that was much more concise than my answer. Well done! I've never been good at the shorter emails.

Robin - Books That Burn

A. The lottery itself isn’t a religious practice, so the application of this generally neutral law isn’t a violation.

Amanda Horne

In a normal world, B. In our current reality? I'm afraid that the Supreme Court would say D, but only if you're Christian

Kevin (Nevu)

Are you supposed to answer this as if you're a law professor or as if you're a supreme court justice? Those groups have two wildly different opinions on this topic. I think B was the correct answer for most of my life. However, the SC has now asspulled "most favorable treatment" for religious liberty tests (with an implicit understanding of for Christians only). Both C and D feel crazy though. There's no mention of the feds being involved in the question, and the 10th amendment isn't generally relevant outside of federal courtrooms. Unless they're looking for the idea that religious liberty is a right preserved from being impinged by any state? In that case, D.

Ilan Woll

Assuming they still consider the Lemon test valid, A.

Renee Z

That is just what I was thinking!

Renee Z

When I first read your response, I thought it said, "Lemon zest." I think I need new glasses.

Renee Z

Religious and non-religious organizations in Illinois hold raffles all the time. I haven't heard of any being charged with unlawful behavior. The only things I know about these raffles are that the winnings are taxable (gambling) income, and the purchase of the tickets are not charitable contributions (they are gambling expenses). I suspect that ticket buyers often deduct the purchase price of the tickets.

NeedToStopAndCatchMyBreath

Of the two ‘no’ answers, the A is a reasonable test. B leads to stuff like “we also ban non religious organizations from serving sacramental wine”.

Measure76 from the exmormon reddit

First of all, why do these question images look like they're cobbled together with words cut out from other books? A- Interesting candidate but I don't see why the reasons for the law have anything to do with whether the rights are violated. B- At least everyone's rights are violated the same way? This seems like the best answer. C- Who got the federal government involved here, and why would their involvement lead to a yes answer if they shouldn't be involved? Seems like nonsense to me. D- Yes because of the 10th amendment? So the 10th amendment is responsible because the lottery got involved? This answer just confuses me. Final answer B.

TheEthicalJerk

Probably scanned from a real book across two different pages?

James Weingarten

I believe the correct answer is B. Lotteries are illegal due to state statute. The religious or non-religious context is irrelevant. They are illegal for all entities.

Quark Twain

It cracks me up that the test is trolling us. "Peyote church... hey, this sounds like that famous peyote case! Is that a clue? Or is it a trick, maybe this is different. Or maybe they want me to think it's a trick..." Anyway, I guess A?

Mary R

Some churches can't have bingo anymore because of state gambling laws.

Mary R

Oops. I'm going with A.

Ellis Valentiner

The correct answer is A because I fed the question into OpenAI's GPT-3 model, which told me: "No, Peyote Church's freedom to practice their religion has not been unduly burdened. The state has the right to regulate activities such as gambling and lotteries, and this restriction does not unduly burden the practice of the Church's religion. In most cases, the Church could find other ways to raise funds for the parsonage."