Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Wow it's almost like there really was an armed coup on January 6th on our nation's Capital. Stewart Rhodes and Kelly Megs have been found guilty of sedition. But when it comes to their sentencing... it's actually not very clear how much time they will do. That's because there really isn't much precedent for this. Andrew has the breakdown! Before that, though, we have a follow-up on the music episode. We share further thoughts inspired by some of the response we got. And we got a lot...

Links: 18 U.S. Code § 2384 - Seditious conspiracy, 18 U.S. Code § 3553 - Imposition of a sentence, Sentencing_Table.pdf, trump-lawyers-sanctioned.pdf, Trump sanctions stayed?

Files

Comments

Jacob Greenleaf

We NEED a deep dive on software copyright law! GitHub Copilot, ZFS/Linux, AGPL/Amazon/Elastic, copyleft, Google vs. Oracle, DD-WRT / FSF vs. Linksys, Unix/SCO-Linux, Facebook-React-reciprocal-patents 🤩

tony

For the Philosophers in Space theme question: I have a small background in classical music, and listen to a lot of film scores, especially of the sci fi/ fantasy genre. I hadn’t heard philosophers in space before, so I had never heard the theme before Thomas played it. I immediately thought of the Star Trek theme and a few other “space themes” but under the context of - “that’s not a composer I have heard. I wonder who that is?” That “feel”, imo, is why I think it’s not copywrite infringement

bella ciao

To Thomas's question, a follow up question: not sure how this fits in. My partner is a jazz musician and in one band, he plays keys. He "quotes" songs all the time in his solos. (Eg he's been learning "blue" by Eiffel 65, a dance track that was popular in the late 90s, and took a part of the melody and integrated it in a solo). Jazz musicians do this all the time in live music - it's a known practice and it surprises and delights the listeners. You're not exactly quoting, you seem to be adapting or using inspiration from another song to build your song, which doesn't seem like it's copyright infringement to me (otherwise wouldn't all music be an infringement?). But if you directly quoted the melody, would that be infringement? Are Jazz musicians infringing when they do this?

Stormy Decisis

I think the clearest analog to Thomas's Star wars like song is sound alike music. You know, those songs that are written to leave the listener with the impression that they have heard a familiar famous piece of music without paying royalties to it. Those are pretty clearly allowed since they are used all the time and they are designed to be just different enough that they are free from copyright. So, if you wanted to develop a test for what is different enough, I would go compare sound alikes to their original songs and identify what the differences are. P. S. I wish I could fine my students the way that judge did for submitting something so stupid I shouldn't have to read it.

Stormy Decisis

What day of the week will you be harvesting Patreon names for the shout outs? Is it the same as before?

I'm pretty New Hampshire, but I'm not Libertarian Walks Into a Bear New Hampshire

Copyrighting "the feel of" something, even if all it would demand is royalties, would kill art entirely for anyone who isn't independently wealthy and/or a publishing company. Works inspired by or in the style of or making outright references to other works or artists have been part of all domains of human art for all of recorded history.

Salt Prairie Photography

For the sentencing decision - if the analogy is to obstructing an election, could an aggressive prosecuter make the case that this was analogously an attempt to obstruct multiple elections at the same time? (Just more efficiently than obstruction them at the state/precinct level)

Morgan Vega

I can't believe people complained that you were defending the politics of Blurred Lines. That's SO dumb.

Jake Maas

Just want Andrew to know I got his Zaphod Beeblebrox reference in the opening

Just a Little Guy

A deep dive on software copyright? I’m looking forward to the first ever 7 hour OA episode!

Jack Baumruk

Thomas describes needing to look at the level of “granularity” when assessing substantial similarity in copyright, but this is almost exactly the Nichols “Abstraction-Filtration” test which is still used and is foundational to the more modern tests. That has become a part of the “extrinsic” test in the 9th circuit, but the way they do it is bad because they don’t really keep ideas and unprotectable expression away from the jury the way they should. Also, the extrinsic-intrinsic test is a 9th circuit thing (a few others followed them). The 2nd circuit (the other most important circuit for copyright law) uses a different test, though they are kinda inconsistent and their tests aren’t much better. For a good discussion on this, see Sprigman & Hedrick, The Filtration Problem in Copyright’s “Substantial Similarity” Infringement Test, 23 Lewis & Clark L. Rev. 571 (2019). https://law.lclark.edu/live/files/28480-lcb232article3sprigmanpdf

AtheistEagleScout

Andrew, listening to the opening... Were you channelling hitchhikers guide? Zaphod's just this guy you know?

Jake Maas

There is no doubt in my mind. 😁

David in Brooklyn

The Apple vs. Microsoft suit was ridiculous. Apple's graphical user interface was taken freely from research done at Xerox's Palo Alto Research Center in the 1970s. Both Steve Jobs and Bill Gates had toured their facilities and seen the Xerox "Star" and "Alto" desktop computers demonstrated, well before either company produced graphical OSes. -- Thomas, if you want to hear what the "Star Trek" theme is based on, listen to the introduction to the first movement of Mahler's Symphony No. 1.

Bench Appearo

I know this is more of a trademark point than a copyright one, but Thomas describing the "ripping-off" of Star Trek made me think of genericization of product names like Kleenex or Frisbee replacing the base product name. At a certain point of popularity, a name becomes a cultural force unto itself and I think some motifs in music could theoretically become similarly foundational to understanding culture. Evoking Star Trek in order to evoke a more philosophically based sci-fi vibe makes sense to me in that context. I'm not sure how one would fully articulate or build a test for that though. As a slightly different aside there are also situations like the sampling of the Amen Break becoming the backbone of multiple genres of techno for decades. Who does one even sue in that situation? The amen break has become a cultural force unto itself in the world of techno in my opinion.

Mitch Gresko

I'm surprised no one has brought up how John Williams "borrowed" from Holst's "The Planets" for a lot of the music in Star Wars. It's pretty clear that he was using a similar feel, and even some nearly note-for-note progressions.

Mitch Gresko

As much as I hate that dick, I don't feel like we should continue to make fun of him for maiming himself. I get the schadenfreude, but it kind of reminds me of when people on the right make fun of liberals who are injured/killed by police. Losing an eye has to be terrible, and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. There are so many other things about him we can ridicule, I kind of hope Thomas and Andrew let this one die.