Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • AnotherChristmas_Final.wav

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

HELLO MY LOVES.

Well, it's that time of year and here we are.

First of all: there are so many new patrons, and I'd like to just shout a huge WELCOME, HELLO!!!...to all of you. 

It's so wonderful to have you here, and thank you for supporting my art and my writing. I don't take a single one of you for granted and it's been a very stumbly season of trying to balance life, family, work, art, house, kid and health. 

You've all been the rock-solid foundation on which I've been building my new life here in Upstate New York, and even though I'm feeling constantly behind...you've all hung in there. 

I love you all so much. To the new people: I'm especially glad to have you here in the wake of what feels like a very dark shift on social media. Twitter feels like it's collapsing, and I am praying that we can all find good, safe, kind places on that internet where we can gather. This patreon has always felt like one of those places, and especially so right now. So thank you for taking the plunge.

And thank you all for the beautiful posts on this morning's invitation to share the List of the Great Unfinished. I'm slowly reading all the responses and wow...I just...love you all as usual. I love learning about our many flaws. You always make me feel less alone. It's a two-way street, y'all. Hang in there, everybody. This time of year is always extra bumpy. Give yourself as much extra love and patience as you can.

...............


NOW. Music and story time.

I wrote a brand new song...and I have to say, this one was a magical little struggle.

It's the first song I've finished since getting back to the states in June, and I think it's good enough to be on the next Dresden Dolls record. But I also really wanted to demo it and GET IT OUT IN TIME FOR CHRISTMAS...because, well, isn't it obvious. 

I've released so many songs in so many ways, and I think we're entering a phase where I'm going to be using this patreon platform as a lab, a workshop, a place to motivate me to write and share the little song-seeds that are going to eventually germinate into the fully-grown entity that will (if all goes according to plan, and we all know how PLANS GO LATELY) be the beautiful garden that is The Next Big Record: the first full-length album that my band will have created and released in about 15 years. YIKES....our last official album, "No, Virginia", came out in 2008. 


The cover photo for this demo was taken by me, just down the road here in Woodstock, and the design was created by Andrew Nelson (who also did the art of Theater is Evil and There Will Be No Intermission).

Here is my offering: the song is embedded here, and $3+ patrons: there will be a second post coming shortly with a link to DOWNLOAD the song.

$5+ patrons: as a little treat, we're gonna send out the lyric and chord sheet out so YOU CAN PLAY THIS SONG AT ALL YOUR CHRISTMAS PARTIES. Watch for that post in a moment.

And if you love the song...as I hope you all will....and you want to share it - like a special underground bootleg of holiday joy and sorrow - with your friends, family, and loved ones...go for it. 

Maybe you know someone who really needs to hear it.

Maybe you telling them that this is an unreleased Amanda Palmer demo for the new Dolls album will make them happy. Maybe they'll even make my day and join the fold. Or maybe it's just the song they need to hear right now. and if this song can reach one heart this season who needs the message - our job here is done. Deal?

All I ask is that you don’t post this link or file anywhere on the public internet. Everyone has been really good about that, and I trust you.

So listen. Then go share it privately if you wanna. Share the file with loved ones via text or email, or give them the link to this post and tell them to join the patreon ($3 patrons will obviously have the file itself to share, in a moment). 

This isn't the version that the dolls will release many moons from now, but that doesn't really bug me. It's a song. It lives. It breathes. It can have a few different lives. I'm not sure how the band is going to arrange it - maybe guitar and sleigh bells? Maybe piano and drums? But I know we'll be tinkering with it at upcoming shows...and we'll certainly be playing it at the New Years' show in LA...and we'll learn what we can do with it.

............

I wrote this song two Mondays ago. I was so excited that I wrote a post (well, made a Voiceramble) about it.

Later that morning, I texted my new local friend, Holly Miranda, and asked if she'd be game to learn the guitar part that I had in my head...and Holly is a wonderful friend and a trooper, and she said yes. 

So I hired her (with your money, indeed) to record the song with me and produce, engineer and master this little sonic gift. 

The recording happened a few days later at Holly's house, and then she went to town adding some extra vocals and synth sounds. The result is just wondrous.

Here we are recording at Holly's place:


....

Some songs arrive fully formed.

This was one of those songs. I woke up at 3:30 am on that Monday morning and it was just knock, knock, knocking on my songwriting door. I knew I had this upcoming Christmas benefit to play, and nothing planned or rehearsed for it. And I knew it would be a wonderful feeling to finish something, especially a New Christmas Something, for the patreon this month. 

And I knew if I dragged my sorry ass out of bed and just wrote the damn thing, I'd be able to offer it up, thing this Thing, and make payroll. It's so unromantic, these motivations, but honestly: whatever works. 

This is why I love the patreon and the monthly ass-kicking to get something OUT. I can honestly say that if I hadn't had that looming clock and thing-button, I don't think I would have gotten out of bed to take this idea, write all the lyrics from beginning to end, take the inner dictation that the song was shouting at me, and, in the words of Nike and many buddhist monks, Just Do It.

This is why - as a songwriter who often flails to find motivation and focus - the patreon means so much to me, and why having you here as my secret little family of art-cheerleaders is so deeply important. 

I used to hate the feeling of writing a good song and knowing that it might not reach human ears for years while I waited to get it onto an album. But releasing music immediately and free to the Internet didn't work either. It was artistically and spiritually satisfying, but random people don't really pay to download single songs, much less tip musicians randomly on the Internet because they enjoyed something. I believe I've found the perfect balance and medium here. 

I can motivate my inner, sometime lazy, songwriter to demo new material and get that wonderful hit of sharing something fresh out of the songwriting oven, but I don't have to go broke doing it. And you can all take a special pride in knowing you're keeping my bills and team paid while I work work work, even though this song won't get "officially" released for a long time. 

(I did this, by the way, with a few songs on "There Will Be No Intermission". Both "Drowning In The Sound" and "The Ride" were released as demos just to the patrons before I gave them the full production treatment on the final record, and it helped greatly to know that the songs WORKED.)

........

So a little more about what went into this song, which is also the nice part about this little backstage lab. I can tell how how things are coming about, and the strange ingredients and synchronicities that go into the making of the song-sausage.

I had just spent the previous Friday in Coxsackie Correctional Facility, a maximum security state prison in Coxsackie, Greene County, New York. (It currently houses approximately 900 inmates - all men).

A handful of the men gave TED-style talks about their experiences on the inside. Some of these men are serving life sentences. Some of their stories were harrowing: murder, manslaughter, domestic violence. But the thread was always there, underneath, the way it was in the visit I took to another prison in Massachusetts that gave ride to the "Coyote" story I told on the "There Will Be No Intermission" tour in 2019. Always, there is hope. Always, there is a path to forgiveness. Always, there is a crack that lets the light in. I cried several times that day, seeing the parallels between their stories and my own. It was an overwhelmingly emotional, and one day I still hope to have more time to write about in detail. 

I am thinking about all the men I met right now. I am thinking about how it must feel to spend the holidays in prison. I don't know if I can ever know quite how that feels.

And then there was the bridge.

There is a massive bridge - the Rhinecliff - that spans the Hudson river near my house. I had just crossed the bridge. This isn't the sign about which I sing, but if you've crossed a bridge, you've seen these signs.


There is hope.

Make the call.

The sign on the Rhinecliff Bridge, though, is seasonal. It's a massive flashing construction sign. But instead of detour or construction information, it says THERE IS STILL HOPE, alternating with a phone number. 

Oh....god.

Like the Christmas lights that go out on everybody's lawns and roofs this time of year, it goes up when the suicide rates off the bridge go up. Suicide rates go up around the holidays. And so the signs sprout up along with them.

Like a perennial flower.

..........

I sang the song this past weekend at "The Sounding Joy", an annual fundraiser for The Washbourne House, a domestic violence shelter here in town. Playing it in front of my little local community was powerful. People understood it, and they...know that bridge. Holly was out of town so I asked a young local guitar player, Storey Littleton, to play the guitar part, and she nailed it beautifully. If you've been on the patreon for a while, you'll recognize Storey - she was one of the gorgeous voices on "Star of Wonder", a Christmas song from a few years ago....the one where we crowdsourced photos from all of you. 

We got a little video clip of it that I'm hoping to send you as well (just for you, again, and maybe I'll include it in the upcoming Althing for good measure).

Here we are, that's Storey behind me:


photo by Anthony Mulcahy

I'm going to donate a chunk of this Thing Money to the house as well.

If you'd like to make an additional donation to The Washbourne House, you can do so here: https://www.familyofwoodstockinc.org/domestic-violence-services/washbourne-house/

And on Christmas day - if the weather allows - I'm going to also play this song live on the radio in Woodstock (WDST) with Holly if she can make it. I'll post if we do it, and either way, I'm going to try to do a spontaneous Christmas Day webcast and invite you all to hear the song in person, and I'll do a little poem reading and send you all some winter heart-holding. I know we could all use it. No promises, there's family here, and the weather is crazy, and kids get sick But I'll try.

.........

OK. GO LISTEN TO THE SONG.

Wear headphones, please, it works better with THE FEELINGS.

Or listen in the car with the volume cranked way up.

Have a hanky handy.

I hope this song, like the lights, like the sign, like the domestic violence shelters, brings you a little bit of hope.

You all give me so much hope. Just you being here and reading my posts, and forgiving me my slowness nowadays as I hibernate and try to find my footing here, it means the world.

You've all helped my kid, and held my hand. 

Even though I barely know you. 

I love you all so much. I really do.

There is hope.

Make the call.

xxxx

Amanda

P.S. I usually post the lyrics...but I kinda don't want to. They're really clear and I want to make sure you listen with your ears. Am I mean?

P.P.S. I'm reading all the comments, as usual. Talk to me. You know I love thoughts and feelings.


........


CREDITS:

“Another Christmas”

Music & words by Amanda Palmer

Guitar, synth and extra vocals: Holly Miranda

Engineered, Produced and Mixed by Holly Miranda at Eye Knee Studios.





------THE NEVER-ENDING AS ALWAYS---------

1. if you are a patron and new to my work, don’t forget your patronage allows you access to ALL of my patreon releases to date. HERE is the link to download my latest big solo record, “There Will Be No Intermission”, and HERE is a link to download the PDF of the art/essay book that goes with it.

2. if you’re a patron reading this post via an email notification, please click through to comment on this post. at the very least, if you’ve read it, indicate that by using the heart symbol. that's always nice for me to see, so i know who's reading.

3. see All the Things (over 150 of them) i've made so far on patreon:

http://amandapalmer.net/things

4. JOIN THE SHADOWBOX COMMUNITY FORUM, find your people, and discuss everything: https://forum.theshadowbox.net/

5. new to my music and TOTALLY OVERWHELMED? TAKE A WALK THROUGH AMANDALANDA….we made a basic list of my greatest hits n stuff (at least up until a few years ago, this desperately needs updating) on this lovely page: http://amandalanda.amandapalmer.net/

6. general AFP/patreon-related questions? ask away, someone will answer: patronhelp@amandapalmer.net

Files

Previews only

Comments

Michael Sclafani

So I woke up the morning after seeing you play last Saturday with a very specific anxiety that this song will not make it on the Dresden Dolls album because it is a Christmas Song. I've heard you perform it twice now and it rocked me both times, but it sounded even so much better the second time. God this song is a jackhammer to the heart and PLEASE feature it on the album.

gerlinde

I can't wait to have this song on an album- I cry every time I hear you play it - in Brooklyn and in Nashville and in Poughkeepsie and my heart is full and broken and taped back together. Thank you for writing it.

Dahlia

I crossed the Rhinecliff bridge the other night

Rachel ~ Witch Weave

Can’t wait to get out to the car to listen, after I get unhooked from my magnesium infusion (migraines).

Alessandor Earnest

You’re spoiling us with all these happy posts! So good to see you grabbing it by the balls.

KarenD

headphones on. thank you. so beautiful. sending love to you for Christmas Amanda.

Michael Pollock

This time feels like a new beginning. I guess every moment has that potential. Can't wait to listen.

Marley Kendrick

This is the perfect kind of Christmas song in my book. Just real. Thank you for brightening my December

Ash Lozano

This song is so beautiful, and kind of just what I want/need out of this time of year. The arrangement with the sleighbells and guitar feels like sitting next to a fireplace. You just playing this piano only also hits me right in the heart. Thank you for sharing this. I made a little printable Christmas card with instructions on how to sign up for the Patreon if anyone is interested. Not sure the best place to share that. Shadowbox maybe? Let me know suggestions! Lots of love <3

Angel Rosen

Thank you for this song. I love witnessing what you're capable of. Never stop amazing me, okay? Only you could create a sad Christmas song and still be the brightest part of my week.

Kathryn Drew

Major typo(omission) here: "All I ask is that you post this link or filed anywhere on the public internet." Xx

Judy Donofrio

Powerfully and beautifully Christmas ❤️Thank you ❤️

oona cava

Ahhhh. So good. Thank you.

Aimsel Ponti

I listened, and I let myself feel it and halfway through. I lost it and cried for my mother. First Christmas without her. It’s almost too much to bear but also, listening to it I felt held and loved. Thank you for this gift.❤️❤️

Kathryn Drew

your song reminds me of Leonard Cohen <3 i love the shit done/not done post too

Tracey Stokes

I Love you , fancy face 💜 Only you , I hold you close. "Not for just an hour, not for just a day, not for just a year....." Rock on beautiful.

Michal Lahav

So in this part of the world it is the last hour of my 39th birthday, and I'm driving back home to my girlfriend and toddler who are already sleeping and I'm thinking about the sticky bits, the sadness that seems to hover over birthdays, even the ones in which you feel connected with enough strings from your heart to others to feel seen and loved. And your song arrives, and I park and keep the engine running and I let your voice and Holly's guitar echo through me and sink in. And I breath. Thank you for this firework of strings delicately and fiercefully laid, I picked it up over the atlantic and am holding it close to my heart.

Genevieve Smith

Oooooof, thank you for this. This song is sonically how I'm feeling this holiday season. I had started a longer response but my phone ate it so I'll just ask the question I had and then try again on a device with an actual keyboard. If we change our patreon level to $5 for a bit, are we still eligible for the lyrics and chord sheet? Thank you again for creating and sharing and being in this world. <3

Len Tower Jr.

Amanda & Alex: I believe this sentence needs a "do not" added: "All I ask is that you post this link or filed anywhere on the public internet. Everyone has been really good about that, and I trust you.". Best -Len

Lisa Claire

When I listen to your music, you make me feel feelings and access places in my heart that I didn’t even know existed before I discovered you. Thank you for being such an exquisitely beautiful soul and sharing the consequences of that with us. I truly hope that you do have a Merry Christmas and a 2023 that sees you rise from the ashes like the Phoenix you were born to be xxx

Caren Helms

Thank you for this early Christmas present! It was seriously sad, yet also held lots of gratitude and connection. Sometimes even when we're grown-ass people, new-to-us people and friends show up to be exactly what we need. I've had to disconnect from my family of origin, which is something I never would have thought could happen, so this time of year is especially hard for me. This will be the third Christmas I haven't seen my mother. I wish things were different, but she's 83 and I doubt they ever will be. So thanks again for this song that seriously touched my heart and all my feelings!

Bane

Me too, mom passed in October and Granny just yesterday 🥺

Len Tower Jr.

Yes, the Shadowbox. If you're on Facebook, the Official & Unofficial groups as well (need the web links?). -Len

Bane

Beautiful!! Now how do I find it in my phone after I download it? It’s not in Files or Music or Drive.

Len Tower Jr.

Sung lyrics are very clear in this version & last Saturday's benefit live cast. (I couldn't understand most of the lyrics in the $10+ crowdcast. The piano overpowered your voice.) Both versions are sublime & super. The sleigh bells & live performance in one way. Holly's mastering etc more polished. -Len

Jenna Tomlin

The beauty of melancholy sweetness. I love it.

Mark Hunter

Raw & real. Very beautiful. Merry Christmas AP, and everyone else here.

Skyeanna Malito

I would love to be able to see the lyrics, because I have a hard time making out some of the words. But I don't need them to enjoy the song.

Bane

Oh! I misunderstood that part - makes sense now!

Chris Valentine

❤️😢⭐️it’s beautiful. I can’t wait to hear you perform it at the New Year’s show. Happy Xmas, lovely humans.

James Cowie

Marvellous,but I couldn't quite make out all the lyrics can I read them anywhere ?

Mariana Song

Super Christmas Song! Your voice is gorgeous and leads up to a wake up to something deeply relevant right now. Thank you for doing your beautiful work in the world! So glad I am part of this community now and looking forward getting to listen more! Wishing you and all supporters a Merry Merry Christmas & Happy 2023!

EmVT

devastating--thank you for telling us what you saw. I believe you. justice in action. already vintage afp outta the gate ❤️

Jen

❤️❤️❤️

Lesley S

I've listened what feels like a dozen times already... And in the way of good song earworms I've got the tune memorized if not all the lyrics... And in true new mom music lover fashion I've made up my own lyrics to sing randomly to my now 10 week old kid. Whose existence I give a lot of credit to you, Amanda, and the Shadowbox. So many amazing people there. A real community. The song works as a lullaby, a playtime song, and a walk around the house song. He sometimes 'sings' along. I melt. There just might still be hope.

Maura Curry

I Love You and i say not posting lyrics is a bit of a slap for those of us with learning/nuro divergent... my dyslexia affects my hearing in that i cannot hear sung words about 90% of the time even when totally clear in music ... its just sound for me ... beautiful but i have no idea what ur saying about 70% of this song specifically ... it sounds amazing and took me on one hell of an emotional roller coaster... grief mourning hope loss deeplove reaching striving overwhelming sadness ... im gonna up my patreon so hopefully i can get in in time to get the lyrics

Jennie Bibbings

5.30am in the UK, my kids are still asleep, I am at the kitchen table in my dressing gown, crying for I don't know what, for everyone, thank you Amanda for a thing of such expansive beauty. Wish you all a good Christmas x

Zoltanina

I get the thing about not wanting to post the lyrics, but there are so many non-native speakers here. Maybe someone who got all of it could put them up over on the Shadowbox?

Bloody Zero

It’s a beautiful song, Amanda, thank you! It’s something many of us really need 💙

Jo Swift

Beautiful, thank you Amanda, I love you x

Eva

Thank you so much, Amanda. I can not tell you how much I needed a song like this right now. Sitting here, crying

Lindsay Hannon

God, that's a proper grown up Christmas song isn't it. Deep deep feelings, but not about santa. There's a different magic now. Thank you ❤️‍🩹 *fyi when I opened the email the 'do share' typo was still in it *

Damian Masterson

I wasn’t paying enough attention the first time and played this at 2x speed. I didn’t catch on right away on cause it still worked at that speed. Real good bones on this one.

Jane Sharp

Beautiful song. Thank you. Xx

Lynn Robinson

Oh wow so powerful. Listening to it has made me decide to contact my brother - we’ve has a long distance relationship for over 20 years - even though he physically only lives 3 miles away. Thanks you xx

Michelle Brun

Beautiful song. Will share this with my husband this Christmas. 💜 I love the idea of it being on either the new Dresden Dolls album or a Christmas album. Random songs released on the internet are hard for me to keep up with. I still need to download and compile most of the songs you’ve released the past few years. I’m the type that needs a physical album, so news of any type of album is very exciting!

Anna McCotter

I was just sideswiped with immense endurance and gratitude. I’m speechless with relief. Don’t stop writing sad songs. Thank you Amanda. We love you so much.😭 🤍🙏

Laura Wellner

This is beautiful, I'm so happy that you wrote it. Thank you.

Josh Pennino

Thank you, Amanda. This song is beautiful and perfect and it captures the immense melancholy I feel every year at this time.

Jessie Howard

Just got back from 4 days in Texas seeing my parents and siblings, and it was a really rough trip emotionally. My mom is on the verge of killing herself via alcoholism amongst other less savory family afflictions. Your song carries such a beautiful and relevant weight to it at this time of year that just reminds me that I am lucky to have a beautiful young family of my own that I can treat differently and raise without that weight. Thank you. It was a lovely song to wake up to and journal with today.

Joe Redston

Lost for words [in a good way] ... which, I guess, is why I need people like you in my life. Thanks 🙏

EmVT

"Share the file with loved ones via text or email, or give them the link to this post and tell them to join the patreon" if anyone wants to share the file, I can tell you how to make a smaller version if your mail program doesn't reduce the file size automatically. the posted file size is 78 meg and the 3 meg version (.m4a) sounds just fine, and is easier to attach to an email.

Alyssa E

Lovely, truly lovely. Your voice, the guitar and all the feelings… it helps to encapsulate some of the mixed emotions the holidays can bring. Thank you for this.

Neil P

It's beautiful. It's almost too much to bear. ❤️

Dorit

❤

Anna Nolan

I love the hope and joy in the image of Christmas lights, juxtaposed against the sound of your voice, so slow and sad. It’s a beautiful song. Thank you.

Dahlia

I love it so much. I texted it to some friends and family along with the Patreon link as well. I’m feeling really sad today. I’m watching the rain drop off the roof and the trees sway. I feel the crushing grief. I also feel love, gratitude, and a glimmer of hope in this burning world. It’s not either or, it’s both and. The work is in finding balance.

geek grrl

In this time where everyone focuses on the holiday cheer! And family etc - this song helps highlight beneath the veneer of cheer and all the good stuff that everyone is probably missing someone (gone off this planet or just out of our lives) or hurting or trying to get to the other side. This song captures so much of that and the reach towards hope. We are all of us in the gutter staring up at the stars- Oscar Wilde. It helps sometimes to turn our heads and see the others looking for the light in darkness. To all- have a safe, gentle, hopeful holiday. ❤️

Coila

This is beautiful. Thank you! I grew up in a DV situation and my mom, siblings and I were thisclose to needing one of those shelters. I need to seek out my local shelters and donate. Thank you for the reminder!

Cate Whitehead

Oh, Amanda! I've almost sobbed through your beautiful, sad song just now and it's Christmas Eve! What can I say? I love the arrangement, your voice in its deepness and emotion; lyrics of course...it does make me think about a lot of things and the Christmas stuff we tend to ignore or find trivial - well, we will go to my family for Christmas Day with some rarely expressed love and compassion. Have a beautiful Christmas Amanda, whatever you do. You'll be singing in my heart and in my bones.

Kris

Really loved your performance with Storey (I watched the livestream) and I love getting to hear the song again. Thank you 💚

Ana

I emerge as a temporary ambassador of anyone who is not an English native speaker to beg for the lyrics 🙏🏻 The song is beautiful Amanda. Happy Christmas 🥂🎄❄️🌿♥️✨💫🙏🏻

Gabrielle Shearer

This is so beautiful, loving, and painful, well done. Im glad it will be on the new album. I cried a little hearing this when you performed the other night. Partly be cause we were with you through the covid times, and still are, and we've all gone through a lot. And still are. I also cried a bit because Christmas still feels pretty fucked. I miss a lot of people. I also love a lot of people, and I made Irish Cream that's pretty delicious. So it all works out, I guess. Lots of love, and peace to you

Rebecca Ryan

Hoping to tier up one day 🤨 Can’t wait to hear 💜 But my kids do have presents to unwrap in just a few hours! Go me. xx Love

Derek Bishe

I just typed them for myself... not sure they're perfect, but is there a way to message them to you on here?

Ise The Human

Thank you for this gift, Amanda. I love it. It's a bit awkward now that I have nothing for you

Jerry Peckery

I got excited when I saw audio in patreon instead of bandcamp but that was premature cause it doesn't work of course. I could play it 1 time when it gets to the end it stops forever. The play/pause button is invisible in dark mode on Win Firefox and neither forward or reverse 15 works at that point. Starting over is no help as it comes back at 6:43 end. Good thing there's a link to the WAV file - that works. Awesome addition to Christmas Cheer ? !

SewTara

Love it. Reminds me of the Barenaked Ladies lyrics from War on drugs, about the bridge in Toronto on the Danforth. Steven Page’s voice is gutting in it, just like yours in this song. “Near where I live there's a viaduct Where people jump when they're out of luck Raining down on the cars and trucks below They've put a net there to catch their fall Like that'll stop anyone at all What they don't know is when nature calls, you go” Beautifully done Amanda.

Grace Beaster

Finally stopped still enough by the flu to listen to this on my bed today. It’s very sunny in Porirua, and I have the window open. I wish you could have seen how deeply it affected me. Thank you for hearing everyone and reading all the signs. Thank you for capturing the whole human experience. Love from the lower North Island.

Marie O'Reilly

It's beautiful Amanda, thank you And Holly did such lovely work on it