Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Watch my mind unravel as season 4 breaks me!

Files

Previews only

Let's Just Talk About "Bats!" [MLP:FiM Episode 72]

I'm finally broken. The ride never ends.

Comments

David Nadler

Nice... talk! I don't always agree completely with your analysis every week even though I think it's well thought out, but I'm pretty well with you this week. I was at least hoping that they'd tie the Flutterbat plot back into the main plot by having her connection with the bats allow her to communicate easily with them, and perhaps the ponies could discover the bats aren't bad or even unreasonable, and thus AJ could learn something and the sanctuary plan would be more than a "screw it, we're going home" solution. As it stands the entire purpose of the bat storyline is a buildup towards a confrontation and moral lesson that simply never happens.

Jim

I think the comparative issue here is that season 3 was narratively tight. They only had 13 episodes to build to the season finale, so there was little wasted airtime. Now they have 26 episodes to play with, fill in and extend the various lessons and it shows. The production team need to apply proper pacing and arc structure, as well as better 'filler' instead of pop culture references. As for this episode, it is as you said, fun and enjoyable, but not fulfilling. A number of the mane 6 didn't need to be there (Pinkie, RD and Rarity) and the various human cultural references were more distracting than immersive. Lets hope this is all a buildup for the mid season, then moving towards a better arc for the second half of season 4.

Jim

PS. THANK YOU for bringing up the "Princess" Twilight thing here. It has been shitting me off for over a month now.

Sebastian Weinberg

Okay, let's make something clear: Fluttershy was NOT right, and the other five should not have given in to her, just because they felt (rightfully) guilty about forcing her into supporting their own plan against her convictions. Oh, and about turning her into a bat pony (which was frickin' awesome). Applejack's argument was weak, because it was emotionally coloured and relied too much on demonising the bats rather than the facts - but Fluttershy's argument was even weaker, amounting to little more than "Animals are cute. We should give them whatever they want." The only two actual points she makes are that the bats are beneficial to the trees and that they spread the seeds around. The first of these appears to be a load of horse apples she apparently pulled from her own plot; Apple trees do not magically grow stronger faster, just because their apples are eaten by bats instead of ponies. The second is true (though from the looks of it, they aren't "spreading" the seeds much farther than the base of the tree they came from) but entirely irrelevant in the context of the argument, as I'll explain below. If anything, this episode undermines Fluttershy's status as an animal expert, showing that merely loving animals and wanting to pamper them is not an adequate substitute for basic knowledge of Biology and Ecology. An orchard is not a natural structure. It's an unnatural over-abundance of equally unnatural fruit trees that have been bred over generations to bear much more and much juicier fruit than a tree could possibly afford to produce in nature. This means they must be constantly tended, cared for, and protected from sickness and parasites, through lots and lots of hard work. The Sweet Apple Acres orchard is not some natural resource that Applejack has staked claim to, unfairly denying it to the bats that have the same right to it as anyone. It is a resource that four generations of the Apple family have CREATED with their own hooves, in order to sustain their family. Fluttershy argues that the bats are "mommas and poppas, too," who want to feed their families and are loyal to their own kind. So... just like every other living creature, then? How is this an argument for letting them have the (literal) fruit of the Apple family's labours? And if they are not stopped from feasting on the orchard's unnatural food bonanza, what's going to happen to those cute little bat families? They're going to grow, of course. Explosively. To the point where nothing can possibly sustain them except an orchard. And while the orchard is sustaining them, it's NOT sustaining the family of ponies that created it and makes its continued existence possible. Which means that orchard is going away, fast. Then what happens to a bat swarm that can no longer subsist on naturally occurring food resources? They starve and die, or course; including all the mommas, poppas, and widdle bouncy baby bats. Good job, Fluttershy. Way to love animals. But let's look at it from another perspective. We can assume with some justification that bats in the pony world are at least semi-sapient - even if Fluttershy can't yet communicate with them - and are actually aware of what they are doing, rather than being dumb beasts reacting instinctively to a sudden food explosion. In that case, they are thieves and parasites, stealing from the Apple family, without giving back anything in return. Fluttershy argues that they improve the trees and spread the seeds. Maybe she is referring to bat guano acting as fertiliser, but the value of that fertiliser is nowhere near equivalent to the value of the lost produce required to create it. On top of that, Applejack has a full farm, with pigs and cows and chicken, etc. She's not hurting for fertiliser AND she can use it where it's needed most, instead of just spreading it around randomly. As for spreading the seeds, that's fine - if you happen to be an apple tree and therefore have an innate interest in that. If, however, you are an apple farmer, trying to run an orchard, randomly spread seeds are a nuisance, not a help. Any seedling that sprouts from those seeds is likely to disrupt the carefully planned layout of the orchard and take away light, water, and nutrients from the other trees as it grows. So, on top of everything else, the Apples would have to hunt down and remove those seedlings, making more work for them. An this is supposed to be their payment for parting with some of their crop? No, in the situation as portrayed in the episode, the bats can't be viewed as anything but pests or thieves at best, and even the writer could not come up with any good arguments for Fluttershy to use. Thus they had to gloss over it and make the ponies suddenly change their mind and follow Fluttershy's plan for no reason, even though nothing at all has changed. No new facts have come to light that somehow disprove Applejack's position or lend any support to Fluttershy's "Just give them part of your orchard for nothing" plan. As enjoyable a romp as this episode was, the message it conveys is muddled at best, and wrong-headed at worst.

Sebastian Weinberg

After thinking about it some more, I feel that there would have been a much better way to get Applejack and Fluttershy into a conflict where Fluttershy is in the right, even including the topic of species-ism that you mentioned in the beginning of your video. Let's say that there's a natural spring on the area of Sweet Apple Acres, and because Applejack wants to win the price for the juiciest apples at the annual Juicy Apples Festival, she wants to use the entire output of the spring to water her orchard and wants to prevent all the animal living in and around the orchard from using any of it. Now Fluttershy can rightfully argue that the spring is a natural resource that Applejack didn't create and that she has no right to claim it exclusively for herself, just because it happens to be located on the area of her farm. Furthermore, by denying the water to the animals, she is hurting the very ecosystem that her orchard is built upon. To make sure that Applejack doesn't come across as being suddenly unreasonably greedy for no reason (like other, similar sudden character changes that last just one episode, for the purpose of the plot), she can argue that winning the price is not just some idle vanity project for her. She is selling her produce at just barely over cost, constantly riding the razor's edge between the ability to run the farm and financial ruin, all for the good of the Ponyville community. That's why, in past episodes, the farm always seemed to be just one mishap away from being lost (Continuity!), and without PR moves like the competition to give her a boost, she'd have to jack up prices or give up the farm. That's where you could get into the species-ism argument: what exactly makes the pony community more special than the animal community, so they deserve preferential treatment? In the end, Fluttershy could prove her point by having all the animals move over to her cottage for a while, demonstrating to Applejack that her orchard doesn't exist in a vacuum and actually needs those animals around to keep down pests, aerate the soil, and whatever else keeps the ecosystem balanced. No need for handwaving, glossing over arguments, or just plain making shit up. (Seeds magically become improved when bats eat the apples they're in? WTF, Fluttershy?)

Anonymous

While I would not have been quite as "barbed" about it as you are (are you perchance a farmer IRL) I actually agree with everything you just said and I have enough farmers in my extended family tree that the "reality" of what the bats would do to the farm did disturb me and make it hard for me to enjoy the episode. And on a non farmer note, common sense would unravel Fluttershy's argument real quick. Fluttershy's argument relies on Apple Jack having an abundance of orchard, and thus being able to part with some of it. We have cannon evidence that this is not so. Whats more, if any animal that eats apples was to move into the orchard and then be owed a part of it, then the apples would be left with less and less orchard with each passing year as sanctuary after sanctuary was set up. The Apples have to keep whats theirs and wild animals have to live in the wild.