Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Kind of a rambly sort of analysis about an episode that fascinates me.

Files

Previews only

Thoroughly Analyzing "Rarity Takes Manehattan" [MLP:FiM Episode 73]

Or maybe it's like, thoroughly musing over. Who cares, it's just a title anyways. Lovely episode.

Comments

Jim

I've been thinking about the Princess Twilight conundrum for the last month or so, and I think I've come up with a plausible explanation as to why she doesn't get treated as a princess within the stories she is in. Looking over the situations which Twilight has been in, it would have taken focus away from the stories which are trying to be told, and the focus character/s in said stories. The whole "Twilight isn't treated as a princess" is the writers way of avoiding what would happen if she WAS treated as one. Take the cab scene from Rarity Takes Manehattan. If everyone saw her as a princess, there would have been a huge scene, cab drivers would have fought over her for hours, and the events of the episode would have gone nowhere. Or how about the play? If there was even a hint that "A Princess of Equestria" wanted to go to the play, someone would have made it so, either as a dedicated viewing or just kicking ponies out to make way for Twilight (and her friends I would hope). This would have made Rarity's gift and attached efforts....pointless. What does everyone else think? Is this the writers avoiding the obvious scenarios that would happen, or something else?

Sebastian Weinberg

One factor contributing to the weird treatment of Twilight might be that the writers, being freelancers, work in isolation. So unless Twilight's princesshood is part of the episode premise or they get specific notes about it, when they submit their outline and drafts, they will default to the material that was available for watching, back when they worked on the scripts: Seasons 1, 2, and part of 3. The writers therefore write her as a regular unicorn, just like before, and DHX stick wings on her when they animate the script. It's the unfortunate result of the organisational (and physical) disconnection between the writers and the rest of production. This is problematic, because they really have to be careful and walk a fine line between two equally undesirable possibilities. If they allow Twilight's ascension to change her character or the dynamic of the show too much, they risk screwing with the formula that made the show such a runaway success; fixing something that ain't broke, so to speak. On the other hand, if her alicornication changes nothing except the way she is drawn, the whole, big "Princess Twilight" three-parter is revealed as nothing but the hollow exercise in hype and marketing that so many fans accused it of being; just an excuse for glitzy media events and forcing little girls to replace their toys with the newest model. There's a lot of this season left to come, and I'm still quite optimistic. With a full, 26-episode season this time around, I do not begrudge them slipping in a few silly "just for fun" episodes, nor do I worry too much about the treatment of Twilight's new status. I'll wait and see, and try not to read too much into a few minor stumbles as the season gets into gear.

Sebastian Weinberg

As an episode about the concept of generosity itself, this is really quite excellent. If I was tasked with describing generosity, I'd pretty much boil it down to the three lessons demonstrated in this episode: 1. By being generous, you increase the net amount of happiness in the world, which is good for everybody - including you. The most obvious manifestation of this is that people may be generous to you in turn. 2. There is no guarantee that your generosity will be returned. In fact, you will almost certainly run into people who will take your kindness for granted and screw you over on top of it. Do not be surprised when this happens. 3. You can't DEMAND that your generosity is repaid. If it worked like that, it wouldn't be generosity, but a trade - specifically a trade that you made unilaterally, without getting the agreement of the other party, or even informing them that it is a trade, until after the fact. Bonus lesson: If you tell people that they owe you for something, and therefore have to give up the very thing that they supposedly owe you for, you are getting recursively mindfuck-y. Stop it.

Merle Blue

I figure most people think that Twilight's not REALLY an Alicorn Princess just wandering around. Wouldn't be surprised if there's a cosplay tradition in Manehattan much like a certain real-world city that springs to mind...