Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Some important updates thrown into this one!

Files

Previews only

Thoroughly Analyzing "Rainbow Falls" (+ Updates) [MLP:FiM Episode 75]

"Despite the contrived failure of a narrative, it's actually pretty good!"

Comments

David Nadler

Just caught this - you have an interesting take on the episode and I love running into a different perspectives on things. I don't think you're completely off the mark even - it probably would have been more cohesive if the Ponyville team actually seemed to have even a slim chance of success, or barring that even seemed to care about the event as more than just a "Ponyville, yay!" kind of deal. Still, Rainbow Dash's arc seems to be about her learning that winning isn't everything, which I think this fits in with nicely. It's just odd to try and deliver that message by going through the lens of a quasi-Olympic event, which in the real world is one of the places where winning, in fact, is everything. Regarding the updates, I'll say that, for what it's worth, I was happy to see you get Elements of Brony 2 out there to the masses. I look forward to seeing what you do next.

digibro

This is the best comment on this video so far just thought I'd let you know.

Athenor

I know this isn't much of good comment but I just wanted to say thanks for the great analysis! Also the little bit on EqD was quite interesting.

Anonymous

If anything this episode was more jarring for me than Daring Don't. I admit that with Daring Don't I knew a lot going in and just enjoyed the ride without thinking too much about the quirky framing, but with Rainbow Falls I only had a slight inkling what the episode would be about and I found myself actually annoyed though much of the character interaction. I've had this odd feeling about season 4 for awhile now and with each episode it gnaws a little more at me. Much of what I see going on reminds me a lot with how season 1 flowed and I do not like it, I do not like it whatsoever. They have one again fallen back to using Twilight as a plot device, placing her either just enough in an episode to help drive the story, or shoehorn her in for the sake of trying to make her presence more relevant than it needs to be. Mind you, I always love seeing Twilight and Rainbow Dash get some screen time together, as they have a very interesting dynamic that does show through. However, the fact that Twilight basically scolded Dash without even a consideration of seeing things from another perspective while offering no advice, not even a nugget wisdom to reflect on, irked me to no end. This was already an internal struggle Dash was dealing with, making the whole conversation pointless exposition. The following scene showing that rather than make a choice between the Ponyville Team and the Cloudsdale team she chose not to choose by faking an injury, further raised my ire about what was going on. This episode was suppose to be the shining moment when Rainbow Dash's of Loyalty and devotion is put to the test. Her loyalty have never been just to her friends and Ponyville, but also to her childhood home, Equestria at large and to her own dreams and aspirations. With Rarity Takes Manehattan we got a lesson in how that generosity can be taken advantage of just as easily as it can be payed forward. The fact Rarity was taken advantage of made her start questioning her very view on the world, starting to demand compensation for the favors she has done. In the end she realizes that none of her potential success is worth it, if her friends, whom gave their all to help her, were not there to enjoy it with. I don't see Dash getting a similar lesson, or having an existential crisis. She basically leaves both teams hanging, Cloudsdale unable to compete from lack of a third and Ponyville's team just not athletically ready for such a competition that is meant for professionals. The sheer fact that Fluttershy and BB fully understand why Dash would want to switch team and even fully expect it is something she would do if the possibility came up further confounds this issue. Their comments were not of them not thinking highly of Dash and that she would ditch them at the first opportunity, but their understanding that they probably don't belong there and don't care about winning while Dash does and they know how badly she wants to win. The only thing that really paints Dash going with the Cloudsdale team, is because thy acted like jerks and we cannot have one of our mane cast choosing to side with the antagonists. I do not feel it was necessary to Fleetfoot as the villain of the episode, the Wonderbolts could of come to Dash in a much more humble and sincere fashion, expressing how they need her to be on their team or they will have to forfeit. That would of been a lot more of an impact than them acting all sneaky and subversive, basically manipulating Rainbow Dash. As well as a scene where Dash does decide to join the Cloudsdale team and have to tell the Ponyville crew about her decision, which could of still had Derpy introduced as the alternative. The sheer feels that could of been in this ep were squandered and I felt like the moral was wonky. It is okay to give up on your dreams and winning competitions kids, just as long as you stick by your friends that are no were near your level of talent.

Sebastian Weinberg

Even though the episode was entertaining enough (and Derpy's return is obviously welcome), I was also put off by the contrivedness of the situation they constructed for Rainbow dash to display her trademark loyalty. Unlike Rarity Takes Manehatten, which contained good, real-life lessons about the ups and downs of generosity, I struggle to find anything particularly teachable in this episode. The only way that the relay team could make any sense at all, is if there is some kind of rule that, in order to take part in the games, a town has to field a team in EVERY event and each team has to at least qualify. It would make a certain cynical sense to put their best flyer into the dump team temporarily, to lift them through qualification, only to "restructure" later and put her where she's at her best - but that's way more cynically pragmatic than I consider my little ponies to be. The emerging pattern for the presumed keys seems to be that they are physical tokens, earned in the process of embodying their Element, and the repeated rainbow sheen motive makes me suspect that the season finale will once again be a direct and obvious marketing tie-in to the "Rainbow Power" thing that's been going around. I'm not overly worried about that, though; seasons two and three ended with blatant, unabashed marketing events, and the writers made them work. The Canterlot Wedding may have had enormous, gaping plot holes, particularly in that Chrysalis's plan made no apparent sense without handwaving fan theories (Example: What if Canterlot was already fully infiltrated with disguised changelings like Chrysalis, and the whole "threat to Canterlot", the highly visible shield to remind everyone constantly of the threat, and the dramatic failure of said shield and invasion was all a ploy to instill fear and make ponies cling more tightly to their replaced "loved ones"?) - but it was certainly way more exciting and memorable than anyone would reasonably have expected from a toy-mandated "Royal Wedding" tie-in episode. The "Princess Coronation" was ridiculously over-hyped by Hasbro and the Hub, and the abbreviated season forced the creators to squish it all into a single episode, but they pulled it off by deploying the time-skipping effect of a musical montage to great effect, and managed to make it emotionally meaningful and resonant. I'm sure many a proud parent or teacher got misty-eyed at Princess Celestia's song. A lot of liquid pride was shed that day. So, yeah. I'm not too worried.

Sebastian Weinberg

I agree with Jay. The same set-up could have been used to teach kids meaningful things about the ups and downs of loyalty: * Why Loyalty is generally a good thing and is considered a virtue. * How loyalty can bring you into conflict, such as trying to stay loyal to your home town and to the town you were born and grew up in at the same time. * How misapplied loyalty can make you do the wrong thing, such as setting your friends up to fail spectacularly in a competition they are neither suited for nor, apparently, very interested in. Instead, they made it into a not very original retread of the old saw about loyalty winning over temptation, even if they had to resort to ham-fisted emotional manipulation (again!) to paint the logically wrong choice as the obvious "morally right" choice. Whether you make Fluttershy collapse to the ground, shaking in terror because her friends DISAGREE WITH HER OPINIONS (The Horror!!1!i) or suddenly make the Wonderbolts into cynical, lying jerks to shoehorn them into the designated villain role - Having to resort to such anvilicious emotional manipulation is a clear sign that you're attempting to teach a wrong lesson.

Anonymous

Digi, You rock! I am so glad that a brony with an audience as big as yours got this side of the debate out there. This episode made me feel very bad for Rainbow Dash. All of her friends reasons for being there revolved around supporting her. So they should have supported her in her decision to do whats best for her athletic career and fly with the town of her birth. This episode feels like it disagrees with one of the morals of Rarity Takes Manehatten, when the group learns to put their short term wishes aside so that Rarity can achieve something really important to her. It bugged me that now that it's Rainbow in a similar situation, the show paints it as the bad choice for her to do whats best for her career, and pursue a lifetime dream.