Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

It begins! We have now officially moved into the realm of patron support on non-pony videos. I remind you all again that it's possible to cancel your payments on a video-by-video basis if you really don't want to support this progression, but I warn that this will become the norm soon!

Files

Previews only

Why and How I Play Games (And Why Reviewers Should Be Telling You This)

Introducing Digisauros! My video game and film review avatar! Today's discussion is on the nature of playing games, and how reviewers need to be exploring it.

Comments

Sebastian Weinberg

I don't believe that "Autonomy" refers to the customisation or sandboxyness of a game, but rather to the feeling of being in control of the action; does the game make you feel like you're the one playing it, or does it feel like it's spooling off a series of set pieces that you are (grudgingly) allowed to interact with, as long as it doesn't deviate too much from what you're supposed to do? Have you ever played a game with "sticky" controls where the character never quite seems to do what you intended for them to do? Stuff like always jumping a little too late or reacting sluggishly to your input? Those are very hard on the controllers, because players unconsciously press harder and more violently, as if that would make the game react better. How do you feel about being presented with three dialogue choices, none of which are anywhere near what you want to say? How about dialogue options that only vaguely represent what your character is going to say, making each conversation feel more like a random gamble, rather than a decision you made? (In Dragon Age II I chose what looked like a gentle ribbing of a lifelong friend, but instead turned out to be "Fuck you, bitch! I hope you die! I never liked you anyway." Boom, friendship over. That character's gone for the rest of the game.) Then there's Cutscene Incompetence ( <a href="http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CutsceneIncompetence" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CutsceneIncompetence</a> ), where your character suddenly fails at a basic task that - in actual gameplay - you have mastered long ago, or stupidly walks into an obvious trap that you saw coming miles ahead. All of these things undermine the sense of control that makes games enjoyable, and they can happen just as much in wide-open sandboxes with player customisation out the wazoo.

digibro

These are all great points, and if I ever were to expand on this video more, I'd probably include all of that.