Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

(Mostly) Single-Location Horror Film Poll!

  • 1408 (2007)* 67
  • The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016) 39
  • Gerald's Game (2017) 38
  • Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum (2018) 8
  • Host (2020) 16
  • The House of the Devil (2009) 14
  • Hush (2016) 34
  • The Lighthouse (2019) 122
  • Oculus (2013) 33
  • Pontypool (2008) 15
  • 2026-06-01
  • —2026-06-11
  • 386 votes
{'title': '(Mostly) Single-Location Horror Film Poll!', 'choices': [{'text': '1408 (2007)*', 'votes': 67}, {'text': 'The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016)', 'votes': 39}, {'text': "Gerald's Game (2017)", 'votes': 38}, {'text': 'Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum (2018)', 'votes': 8}, {'text': 'Host (2020)', 'votes': 16}, {'text': 'The House of the Devil (2009)', 'votes': 14}, {'text': 'Hush (2016)', 'votes': 34}, {'text': 'The Lighthouse (2019)', 'votes': 122}, {'text': 'Oculus (2013)', 'votes': 33}, {'text': 'Pontypool (2008)', 'votes': 15}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 11, 4, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 1, 22, 16, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 386}

Content

Help pick the Horror film we will react to!

Please feel free to suggest other options in the comments for future polls!

NOTE: Polls have a shorter duration! Make sure to vote!

Sam has seen 1408, so this would only be Daniel's first time watching!

Comments

Chris

So many good ones, but in Eggers we trust

Backlog Andy M.

Wow! I dont know any of these films not one. Out of the loop on this one 😬😬

thebeefmaster

I wish that "Devil" (2010) had made the poll. Maybe next time.

Nick Ireland

The Lighthouse would be cool. Haven't seen many reactions to that movie.

Tyler Foster

Pontypool is one of the great horror hidden gems of the 2000s. Glad to not only see it here but see that it has at least a little support. Not that it matters, but you may end up wanting to do this poll again. The Lighthouse is a great movie, and I'll be excited to see a reaction to it, but I also don't know if "horror" is one of the genres I'd be inclined to slap on it, even though it is at times unsettling and strange.

Paul Cox

Horror's not my usual jam, so The Lighthouse is the only one of these I've seen. I gave it a vote, but it looks like it barely needs the help.

thansen

I haven't seen many of these. I loved 1408 and Oculus, both with unusual endings. I've also seen The Lighthouse. This seems to be a film people either love or hate. I hated it. I really hated it. I wish I could somehow unsee it and get that time and money back.

Shehab Dawoud

Looks like The Lighthouse is the heavy favorite. I couldn't be happier, it's one of the movies I've wanted to see a reaction to the most. Word of advice: If it wins, have subtitles on. They speak in a 1800s New England accent. It's not quite as complex as in The Witch, but subtitles will definitely help.

TBR Schmitt

There were so many movies I had listed for this poll! That was on the long list, but I cut it in half, so next time! -Sam

Tyler Foster

Almost all of these are indie horror movies and thus it is not entirely surprising that they may have slipped past your radar. As for the bigger ones: Not one, not two, but three of these films are by one of the most popular horror filmmakers currently working, Mike Flanagan. Flanagan really hit the big time when he made "The Haunting of Hill House" and "Midnight Mass" for Netflix recently. Flanagan is the director of Oculus (2013), Hush (2016), and Gerald's Game (2017) on here. He also directed the Shining sequel Doctor Sleep and is currently working on a new Exorcist movie, as well as a "Carrie" TV show. Flanagan loves Stephen King and does many adaptations of King's work. The other major film here is The Lighthouse (2019), current and almost certain eventual winner, which is by another very popular contemporary horror filmmaker, Robert Eggers. Eggers first broke onto the scene with The Witch (2015), and after The Lighthouse, went onto make The Northman (2022) and most recently, Nosferatu (2024). He's worked with multiple people multiple times (Anya Taylor-Joy, Ralph Ineson), but he's become especially close with Willem Dafoe, who first worked with Eggers on The Lighthouse and has already agreed to be in his upcoming movie, Werwulf (2026).

Chris Bruneau

1408 scared the crap outta us, its getting my vote!!!

f hf

I'll give Lighthouse a rewatch. I watched it in theaters and it put me to sleep lol

EdmanXERO

Great list, but the purest "single-location" movie that is pure phobia: "Buried". I highly recommend this movie.

Forrest

The Lighthouse is one of those films that's been on my watchlist for a while, and this finally gives me extra motivation to watch it.

Future Boy

So many great little horror gems on this list. It wasn't really a fair fight for them against The Lighthouse. Maybe the runner up could get a reaction at some point! I think Daniel and Sam would love both Hush and The Autopsy of Jane Doe. Hush has very similar vibes (but a very different story) to Don't Breathe, which they loved. And Autopsy of Jane Doe has a mystery in it that would be pure heaven for Sam. It's kinda like someone made a god-tier, supernatural episode of CSI!

DM DC

I agree, :Devil"(2010) is super good!

mikethemotormouth

Also recommending Sinister(2012), Barbarian(2022), and Cube(1997)

David Wilkins

Good ones here. For future reference in this criteria I suggest Bug (2006), from William Friedkin (The French Connection, To Live and Die in L.A.). It’s more psychological horror rather than conventional.

John Zelinka

The entire Dr. Phibbs collection.

Eric

The Lighthouse is one of my favorite movies of all time, so I'm glad to get a reaction out of y'all, but I'd push back on it being a horror movie at all. It's a weirdy, and has a couple of scary bits, but it is genuinely more a dark comedy character study than anything. The House of the Devil will never win, but it's a magnificently shot and directed film (that I think doesn't have the best story or storytelling) and is probably worth checking out if you are ever looking for something that is technique-first. In any case, I'm looking forward to whatever you guys watch!

Birdie Num Num

FYI Sam, House of the Devil was directed by Ti West who directed X which reminds me, do you have any plans to watch Pearl, the prequel to X?

Garry Michael Allen

Some crackers on there. I’d second the criminally underrated Sinister, Barbarian and add the wildly original You’re Next for next time.

Florian Meier

I only know The Lighthouse Andy :) i think this is the first poll i know shit :)

Florian Meier

Same Paul, never heard from the rest

Dan Holmes

1408 is lots of fun! Gerald’s Game is good too, both Stephen King I believe. Lighthouse is great as well but it’s barely if at all a horror

OddThomas

Malignant, Dead Silence, Sinister

Keith Brown

Still hoping someday that someone will do a salute to classic Universal Studios Horror and Sci-fi . Another salute would be the Horror and Sci-fi movies that the Hammer Studios did .

Nick of Time

Devil is good. so is Circle (2015)

Max Rinaldi

Yeah, I'm glad to see Pontypool given any consideration by some reactor.

Max Rinaldi

I love "The Lighthouse", but I vote for "Pontypool", 'cause it's forgotten. I’m kinda glad you didn’t consider “The Void” (2016). I like that film, but I’m afraid its ending could mess you two up like “Trainspotting” did.

Future Boy

The House of the Devil is one of my favourite horror films. I'd love to see it on the channel someday. But it's not one I recommend to many people because it's such a slow burner some people just can't stand it. But if you like style, atmosphere, and the 80s vibes, it's incredible.

Garry Michael Allen

I’ve got to be honest, all of this director’s movies do for me.

Christian Rennie

I feel like Oculus doesn't get enough love. But i'm down for 1408 or Jane Doe any time. Lighthouse I missed (never seen) so that's cool for me if it wins.

madeline howe

It might not be immediately but I do hope someday you react to both Hush and Gerald’s game because it’s done by Mike Flanagan who gave us Haunting of Hill House/Bly Manor, Midnight Mass and Fall of the house of usher!

The Film Effect

Damn, that sucks. Eggers is probably my favorite director working right now.

The Film Effect

Not a fan of surrealist horror or was just this movie? You like David Lynch?

thansen

I have no problem with surreal film of any kind. I can take or leave Lynch. Some of his work is quite good.

Richard Maurer

Definitely pro Hammer films, particularly Horror of Dracula with Christopher Lee