Crypto Update - Nov 16, 2022 (Patreon)
Content
Crypto markets suffered a near-death experience over the past two weeks, and the affects are still lingering in the markets with aftershocks reverberating across the industry. The sudden collapse of FTX was a giant surprise to everyone who’s marginally involved with crypto. The financial impact and the reputational impact to the industry is clearly reflected in the price action. Had there not been a positive risk-on news in the way of lower CPI, crypto prices should be at a much lower level.

- BTC declined around 17% over the past two weeks and is trading at $16.9k
- ETH declined around 19% over the past two weeks and is now $1250
- Total market cap declined by 17% and is now at $900 billion (the peak was over $3 trillion)
What happened?
To make a long story short – FTX and it’s founder SBF committed fraud that swallowed up $10bn of deposit funds who were using the exchange (my YouTube video explaining this -> here). The events were triggered by a tweet by competitor Binance’s founder CZ who announced that he would be dumping FTX’s token FTT.
Once considered as one of the most legitimate exchanges in the world with stadium naming rights (FTX Arena), celebrity endorsements (Tom Brady, Steph Curry), famous private equity investors (Sequoia, Temasek), and political connections, FTX attracted deposits from crypto traders from all over the world and was a trusted counter party to many crypto hedge funds globally.
Post CZ’s tweet, there was a bank run on FTX’s reserves resulting in FTX halting withdraw and seeking for a bailout by Binance, which ultimately did not happen after 36 hours of DD conducted by Binance. The market was completely in the dark at the time and especially since SBF and other senior FTX leadership have stated publicly that FTX never lends/invests user’s deposits.
But now, it is almost certain that FTX fraudulently lent money to its affiliated hedge fund Alameda from its depositor base through a backdoor, resulting in more than ~USD10bn of losses in depositor funds
Both FTX and FTX.US are now in chapter 11. SBF has stepped down and been replaced by John Ray of Enron restructuring fame. Remaining tokens has been consolidated into cold wallets post a hack that commenced after chapter 11. And in another twist, withdrawals resumed randomly one night only for Bahamian residents, which is the jurisdiction that FTX is based. It turns out that the withdrawals were illegal as Bahamian regulators has denied ever instructing FTX to allow withdraws.
Impact on Users, Counterparties and Investors
The impact on users is pretty significant not in the number of users, but rather in the value of the capital at risk. FTX had only 1mn users across the world by its own accounts. To compare, there's around 300mn total web3 users in the world. Unfortunately, Korea users is again hurt by this crisis after experience Luna crash already this year.
More importantly, the losses on the exchange experienced by users is estimated to be $USD10bn, which means that it is $USD10k per person assuming a equal distribution. But of course based on the power law, 20% of that 1mn users probably bore the blunt of the impact. Several institutions have publicly announced their impact including PEs, hedge funds, large crypto prime brokers. Some to note including a hedge fund called Galois Capital who successfully shorted the Luna crash and grew its AUM to USD200mn, but unfortunately had 50% of their AUM stuck and lost on FTX.
By all accounts, the potential recovery by depositors are estimated to be pennies on the dollar likely after multiple years of litigation.
In addition to the depositors losses, major PE and VCs had investments in FTX as well. The full list of its investors in FTX’s previous rounds are listed below. FTX was valued at $32bn at it’s peak, which unfortunately will be marked to zero now. Some of the major PE investors in FTX includes Paradigm ($290mn), Sequoia ($213mn), and Temasek ($205mn)
Impact on Other Exchanges
The entire market was on the edge after FTX collapsed as trust simply went out the window. Attention was directed at the remaining large exchanges and questions on their balance sheet were asked. Everyone was afraid of another FTX, and exchanges were afraid that bank-runs would become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Most exchanges rushed to publish so called proof-of-reserves which is basically a list of wallet addresses that contained their assets.
But the problem with this approach is that 1. A random list of wallets can not verify the completeness nor the actual owners of the wallets 2. Simply disclosing the asset side of the balance sheet does nothing to show the liabilities and 3. Exchanges don’t disclose their deposit amount so we don’t know of their assets actually cover the deposits
As a result, continued outflows from centralized exchanges is still happening in real time. We’ve heard withdrawal issues at several small exchanges such as AAX and BitCoke, but no major exchange have succumbed to the pressure yet.
Impact on Investee Companies
FTX was not only just an exchange, it was a massive ecosystem that included FTX, FTX.com, Alameda, and FTX ventures. This ecosystem made prolific investments into web3 and crypto startups who now lacks a important source of funding that’s required in this down cycle. The survival of this portfolio is now at risk, especially given the lack of follow-up appetite by the surviving funds.
Trading Opportunity
The major other indirect casualty is the Solana network and the SOL token which has dropped more than 50% on the news. This could be a trading opportunity.
FTX was the largest support of the Solana ecosystem along with multiple Solana projects. Alameda was the market maker for Solana and also held significant amounts of SOL tokens. The death of FTX means that there will be no continued support for the entire ecosystem that’s now depleted of capital and projects. SOL is still a $5bn dollar project and could be a candidate to short, especially given the aggressive token unlock schedule to come.
Disclaimer: The content of this post is solely for entertainment and not investment advice. Any views expressed in the below are the personal views of the author and should not form the basis for making investment decisions, nor be construed as a recommendation or advice to engage in investment transactions