ETH/SOL trade(2), GBTC next risk (Patreon)
Content
Crypto markets virtually unchanged over the holiday season with volatility now sitting at one of the lowest points of the year. Majors have basically moved sideways with BTC and ETH continuing to hover at around the 16500 and 1200 level. The risk factor that’s capturing the market’s attention is the messy development around DCG/Genesis/Gemini/Grayscale.
Despite the sideways market trading. My trade idea from Nov 30th's crypto update had a wild ride. Long ETH vs short SOL gained more than 60% since I shared the trade idea before plummeting back to where it started within a week after Vitalik showed support for the blockchain. Thus showing getting the trade right is only half of the story, you need to be able to hold on to your profits too.

DCG and Grayscale
On Nov 29th, I wrote about how Genesis’s insolvency forced Gemini to halt its Gemini earn product.
Unfortunately, things have turned for the worse and all eyes are on DCG and its associated Grayscale product as the biggest risk in the crypto market. The escalation is partly due to the fact that the Winklevoss have gone public to accuse DCG’s boss Barry Silbert of not cooperating with the restructuring process. The open letter is here. In it, Winklevoss accused that more than USD900mn is owed by Genesis to Gemini. Genesis is owned by DCG, which is founded by Barry. Winklevoss further accuses that Genesis and DCG is “beyond commingled” and that Gemini’s money was spent by Barry on “kamikaze Grayscale NAV trades”.

So what are these Grayscale trades? Well it turns out that Genesis and DCG have been aggressively buying up GBTC shares in the market and now owns nearly 67mn shares which is more than USD500mn at today’s depressed value, with the bulk purchased in 1h2022 at a much higher acquisition price.

It was the same trade that spelled out 3AC’s ultimate demise. However, DCG actually had a better business rational to buy up GBTC, which acts as a cash cow at 2% management fee per year on more than 10 billion dollars worth of Bitcoin (more than 3% of the total supply). And Bitcoin is only one of a handful of Grayscale’s products. These so called passive trust products were generating more than USD300mn of fees annually for Barry. There were huge incentives for DCG to support this product.

However, the Grayscale product was in trouble. It once traded at a premium versus the BTC underlying due to the lack of investment option, GBTC flipped to a discount as more competing products arrived in the market. And because it is not structured as a ETF, it lacked the redemption mechanic which would bring discount back to par. It is now trading at a 45% discount which means that anyone who has bought GBTC over the last year is now sitting with significant losses with no way to exit at par. Grayscale has made several attempts to close the discount including buying shares in the open market, asking for permission to convert to ETF, and the latest attempt to make a tender offer for 20% of shares. None have worked so far.

But how is all of this related to Gemini Earn, Genesis insolvency, Grayscale unwinding, and potential DCG bankruptcy?
It’s actually not very clear. Some crypto folks on Twitter are simply arguing that Genesis owes Gemini money, and Genesis’s parent DCG owns Grayscale which owns 3% of BTC, so BTC should be sold and pay back Gemini. Well, that’s not how a trust structure works.
The reason why Winklevoss had to turn to Twitter to engage with Barry is most likely because DCG is legally ringfenced against any liabilities at the Genesis level. And even if DCG is impacted, Grayscale will continue to run as a legal trust, which is absolutely ringfenced against any Genesis or DCG liabilities. So despite that it’s a giant mess, there is probably not much fundamental impact to GBTC. But on the other hand, DCG won’t be clear of the negative publicity for a long time which would continue to pressure the discount.
Next Steps
- The next catalyst to look for is on Jan 13 when Grayscale have to file its reply to SEC’s statement that its original rejection of Grayscale’s ETF application is valid. SEC will have to file a further response on Feb 3rd. Unfortunately, it is unlikely for SEC to allow the conversion to ETF after all that’s happened.
- And in other development, a crypto asset manager, Valkyrie Investments have a open letter asking for a shareholder vote to fire Grayscale and instead elect them as the managers of the trust. Their main selling point is the reduction of the 200bps management fee to 75bps and to file for Reg M exemption. Reg M is the law that prevents GBTC from redemption activities. Although if it was that easy, wouldn’t Grayscale have done it already?
- Well, there are those who do believe that Grayscale have self-imposed the ban on redemption to retain it’s NAV. Remember that the management fees are paid on NAV, rather than on market cap (discounted NAV). If investors can never redeem, then Grayscale could in theory make more than USD300mn forever and ever. The hedge fund Fir Tree is suing Grayscale on that thesis and asking redemption to be turned on.
At the end of the day, at 45% discount, it may not be a bad idea to buy some GBTC and lock it away if one has a long term bullish view on crypto (but not more than 20 years because of the 2% annual fee). The current situation is untenable and will eventually change with multiple ways to redemption, but timing is extremely uncertain.