[Crypto] ETHE still at 15% Discount (Patreon)
Content
Finally, the Bitcoin ETFs were approved by SFC in one single batch as many analysts have called for. There were great fanfare, however the first few days of activities have been underwhelming so far. In the short term, I expect pull back from recent high as major events like this often marks a temporary high (just like the launch of CME BTC futures in 2017 and BTC futures backed ETF in 2021) and continued volatility as market will be paying full attention to these ETF inflow data and sentiment could swing wildly from day to day.
In the long term however (few month or longer), it’s clear that the superhighway between crypto and tradfi is now established. The flows can only be one way (tradfi to crypto) so demand will absolutely increase, but the question is just at what pace.
Many analysts were expecting billions and billions of inflow on day one which must’ve been a difficult call to make but captured a lot of attention in the crypto community, hence expectations were fairly high leading into the launch with Bitcoin peaking at around 48.5k, up from 42k. But afterwards, prices did a round trip and dropped right back to 39k down around 20% from the peak.
Bitcoin ETF – First Few Days
There were significant chatter in the crypto community in the first week of the year that a ETF approval was coming, so the market wasn’t surprised when the SEC announced a simultaneous approval for all ETF applications on Jan 10, with trading starting on Jan 11th. The ETF approvals also included the approval for the conversion of GBTC into a ETF, almost erasing the discount to NAV.
GBTC discount completely erased from -45% just a year ago
The 180 degree pivot by the SEC was well received by the market. Even Standard Charterd was calling for USD50-100 billion of inflows from Tradfi into BTC. To put that in perspective, the entire marketcap of crypto asset class is less than 2 trillion dollars. Even Jim Cramer turned bullish BTC.
The first two weeks of trading was below many crypto folk’s expectations of billions of dollars of inflows. In reality the total inflow is around USD 1.3 billion. With $2.9bn flowing into the new ETFs but at the same time $1.6bn flowing out of Grayscale's GBTC.
A huge chuck of that was from FTX's bankruptcy estate dumping 22 million shares. At the same time, many institutions who previously created GBTC at NAV, hoping to sell at a premium, were stuck holding GBTC when it fell to a discount. With GBTC now being fungible into Bitcoin and trading at NAV, these holders would be another selling force in the market.
Market
Following the spot ETF launch, BTC price broke out of $45000 jumping as high as $48500. But that proved to be a false breakout and peak optimism. The price has since corrected and even fallen below recent support of $40000. In a short timeframe (a few weeks), this is a negative development as the base that was building between 40k-45k is rejected.
Longer term, I think the fundamental story for Bitcoin is still there. And now with US-listed spot ETF allowing more tradfi and institutions to participate in crypto + increasing regulatory clarity should provide tailwind to this asset class.
On the weekly chart, the trend is still up. With the big rally that started in Oct, BTC's price is overextended vs its 50week and 200week moving averages. So in this timeframe, a correction like one we are seeing now is not surprising. And what's more important if it meets support once and if it reaches those moving averages.
Trade Idea
As mentioned in the last update, I believe that the GBTC trade is over after a 300% run. However, along the similar vein, I now like the ETHE trade which is also a Grayscale trust product holding ETH, instead of BTC. ETHE is still trading at a 15% discount to NAV which I believe will gradually close similar to GBTC as ETF expectations starts to also build for ETH.
ETHE is similar to GBTC that it is structured as a Grayscale trust. The current discount is 15%. And of course Blackrock’s Larry has been on CNBC recently hinting at the next ETH ETF. Legally, this will be a more difficult one but expectations would certainly lead actual events which should translate into price action. Not to mention that ETH fundamentals are also looking very strong now with the resurgence of defi and nfts leading to deflationary ETH supply.
The trade would be either to hold ETHE outright or hedge it against another ETH instrument to purely bet on the discount to narrow.
1) Direction trade: Holding ETHE outright. If you want long Ethereum exposure and hope for the 15% discount to narrow eventually to 0.
2) Relative trade: Long ETHE vs Short another Ethereum instrument. In this case, you are hedged on Ethereum market risk and are taking a view on ETHE's discount level.
On the short side there are several things to consider besides the cost of capital (which is quite high with US interest rate at 5%)
If you are shorting a perpetual future, then need to observe the funding cost. If the future is trading at premium to spot, you would be paid to hold a short position.
If you short a future with maturity (e.g. CME listed ETH future). Consider the premium/discount of the future price vs spot. Similar to above, if it is trading at a premium, you are collecting funding.
If you short another ETH ETF (like those listed in Canada), Consider the borrow cost to short.
Disclaimer: The content of this post is solely for entertainment and not investment advice. Any views expressed in the below are the personal views of the author and should not form the basis for making investment decisions, nor be construed as a recommendation or advice to engage in investment transactions
Files
Previews only