Seducing My Homophobic Friends - Part 12 (Patreon)
Content
Connor's Afterglow
As we parted ways that night, my mind was racing. I knew that I liked both girls and guys, but I never really pictured myself getting fucked. I figured I would always be the top and for some reason I was okay with that. I wasn’t really sure how I felt about having bottomed.
Don’t get me wrong, the sensation was amazing. I could still feel the throbbing, as if he were still inside me. But, if I had to pick someone to lose my bottom virginity to, it wouldn’t have been Connor. He was a nice enough guy, but I didn’t really have an emotional connection with him. Holy shit though, he knew how to fuck. The more I thought about it, the fewer regrets I had. It was an amazing experience. Maybe Connor was exactly what I needed for my first time.
Sure I could have tried to get Tyler to fuck me or asked Skylar to, but I suspected that neither of them would have given me the mind altering orgasm that Connor had.
He was still being coy about who had told him about hooking up with me when I dropped him off at his house. When I got back to my place I continued trying to get it out of him.
Connor, why won’t you just tell me?
Sorry babe. Been sworn to secrecy. I could almost envision him grinning as he typed it.
Oh fuck off.
There was no response for a few minutes. He finally messaged me, Wait a second.
It showed him typing for an agonizing amount of time. Finally he said, The only reason you’d be asking who told me is if you’ve hooked up with more than just one of our friends.
Shit. He was right. Why didn’t I realize that until now?
I quickly typed a response. Oh, just kidding. I totally know who told you. I knew that he would know I was full of shit, but at this point I was just trying to make him laugh. If you ever wanted to pull information out of Connor, getting him to laugh was an almost surefire way. If that didn’t work, bribe him with weed.
Oh yeah smartass? Who was it then?
Fuck. I could almost hear the Final Jeopardy music playing in my head. Connor had obviously topped before. That meant that this other guy bottomed for him. I ran though my hookups.
Skylar took it like a champ but he’d practiced with a toy and I could tell that I was his first. He wouldn’t have been able to hide it.
Hayden’s asshole was way too tight and I’d bumped up against his comfort zone and it was well below letting Connor rail his ass.
Dylan was way too timid to let Connor fuck him. And I didn’t think that he would have told Connor about hooking up with me. Dylan was great at keeping secrets.
Tyler was a strong possibility. But again, he didn’t seem like the one that would tell Connor. Even if he had hooked up with Connor, Tyler’s loyalty was with me. He and Connor were just casual friends at best.
That left Jack. Fucking Jack. My dick went into him way too easily.
Jack loved my dick. I hoped to God that I was guessing right.
There was no response for a few minutes. Shit shit shit shit.
Yeah Jack does really enjoy it doesn’t he?
Hallelujah, I guessed right. He sure does. I can’t believe he told you though. He told me he wanted to keep it a secret.
Yeah, well I think he wanted to brag to someone about being fucked by you. The thought had never occurred to me. Anytime any one of us hooked up with a hot chick, we loved being able to brag about it with the group. There were times during my conquests that I would have bragged if I was able to, but my main concern was protecting my friends’ privacy and not ruining my chances of hooking up with all of them.
Now that I’d had them all, I didn’t have to worry about the later.
Who else have you fucked Chase? He was simply guessing.
Just chicks.
I don’t buy it. You didn’t know who told me.
I didn’t respond. There was no correct answer. Connor wasn’t stupid and he wasn’t the kind of guy to let something like this go.
Come pick me back up. Let’s go for a blunt ride.
I grabbed my dab cart and jumped back in the car. I was tempted to text Jack and tell him he was an asshole for telling Connor that we had hooked up, but I decided against it. I had enough damage control to do with Connor, I didn’t need more drama added to the mix.
Connor was waiting outside for me when I pulled up. He jumped in the car and immediately held out his hand. I handed him the dab pen. He took a long hit as I pulled away. “Is there anywhere in particular you’d like to go?” I asked him.
“Drive someplace scenic.” I headed north out of town and made my way out into the countryside.
I didn’t speak. I had no clue what to say. Connor didn’t seem like he was going to turn the drive into 20-questions, which I was thankful for.
We were well outside of town when he finally spoke. “How did it happen with you two?”
I almost told him before I realized he could simply be bullshitting about Jack having told him. “Show me your messages with Jack.”
He smiled at me. “Can’t pull a fast one on you can I Carter?” He swiped open his phone and pulled up his message history with Jack. Just based on the last few messages it was clear that they had hooked up. “Happy now?” he asked with a smile.
“I delivered a coffee to him while he was in the shower.” As soon as I said it, I got a strange feeling. This wasn’t me explaining to Skylar why the guys wouldn’t hate him for being gay. This was the two most sexually liberated guys in the group both knowing that I was bi and that I’d hooked up with them both.
“You just got into the shower with him without knowing if he was into guys or not?” Connor chuckled.
“Yeah, how did you hook up with him?” Two could play this game.
“I got him drunk and put on some porn.” I couldn’t say that I was surprised. That was a pretty solid strategy.
I turned down a dirt road. It led to some fields in the middle of nowhere. I parked the car and got out. Connor followed me into one of the fields. We laid down and looked up at the stars. I glanced at my phone. It was already after 3am.
Connor took another long drag on the dab cart and handed it to me. “So who else have you hooked up with?” he asked.
I took a smaller hit. It was already really late and I had to drive back so I didn’t want to get too high. “Who have YOU hooked up with?”
“For guys?” he asked.
“Yeah. For guys.” I handed him back the dab.
“You, Jack and Braden.” He took another hit.
“Braden? Kelsey’s brother?” Kelsey was a girl that I had hooked up with a while back. Her brother was on the school lacrosse team and was super hot.
“Yeah. I actually fucked him the same night you fucked her.” he started laughing. The weed was clearly starting to affect him. He was laughing so hard that he was crying.
I couldn’t help but start to laugh along with him. “Is he gay?” I asked.
“No, he’s straight, or so he claims. He seemed to enjoy fucking me though.”
“Oh you bottomed for him?”
“Yeah.” Connor’s voice had changed slightly. It suddenly had a serious tone. “So how about you?”
“I… I’ve hooked up with a couple other guys, but I can’t really name names. I’d be breaking their trust.”
“It’s one of the guys isn’t it?” his voice sounded excited. Knowing Connor, he wasn’t excited because it was a juicy secret. He was excited because he had his eye on someone else in the friend group.
“I don’t know, maybe.”
He pulled out his cell phone and began typing a message.
“What are you doing?” I tried to grab his phone.
“Chill. I’m just messaging Jack.” He showed me the message. Would you be interested in a threesome with me and Carter?
“Dude! I never said I’d be down to have a threesome with you two.” I scowled at him.
“Carter. Would you enjoy having a threesome with me and Jack?” He stared me straight in the eyes, daring me to lie to him.
“I… yeah.” What was the point of lying?
“See?” He smiled and raised an eyebrow. “Now if you’ll just name a name, I’ll see if we can turn it into a foursome.”
“I’m not gonna name names.” As soon as I said it, I realized my mistake.
“Names? Plural?” Fuck, he caught my slip up.
“Name, I just misspoke.” My voice was convincing.
“Bullshit.” He rolled over and climbed on top of me. “You’re going to tell me if I have to drag it out of you.” He smiled playfully.
“Good luck with that.” I grinned at him.
He grabbed my wrists and pinned my arms above my head. I was stronger than him and could have gotten out of it easily if I wanted to. I didn’t want to.
He leaned down, his face brushing against my ear. “You have to tell me Carter.” he whispered. His breath tickled my neck. I felt his lip brush against my ear lobe. He took it into his mouth and bit it gently. He ran his tongue down my neck. My pulse began to quicken.
He reached down and slid my shirt off. His mouth found its way to my chest and he gently bit my nipple. I smiled, remembering how much Tyler loved that. He licked his way across my chest to my armpit. He planted his face in it and took a long slow breath.
“I like the way you smell Carter.” I just smiled at him. He leaned back up to my ear. “I want you to fuck me… right here, right now.” He ground his ass against my dick. I reached down and grabbed his hips and thrust against him, lifting him up off the ground a bit. “Yeah. I want your dick inside me Carter.” He stripped off his shirt and tossed it in my face. It smelled of sweat and lake water. It was the same shirt he’d been wearing earlier in the night during our visit to the lake.
He slid my shorts and boxers off as well as his own. He kissed his way down my abs before taking my rock hard dick in his hands. “I want this in me.” he said as he slipped it into his mouth. Connor was good at sucking dick. I instinctively reached down and grabbed his head. “Fuck that feels good man.” He got my dick nice and wet and then licked one of his fingers before slipping it into himself. He positioned himself above me and grabbed my dick, guiding it to his waiting hole. “Do you want to fuck me Carter?”
“Yeah.” I smiled at him.
He rubbed the precum from the tip around his asshole. “Who else did you fool around with?” he grinned at me.
Fuck, he was good. “Who do you think it was?” I thrust gently, seeing if he would let me in. He arched his back in pleasure, clearly aching for my dick to be in him, but he wasn’t letting me in yet.
“Tyler.” he responded instantly. “You and he are crazy close, and you smiled when I bit your nipple. I remember him saying he’s into that shit so I bet you and he have done that before.”
Damn, Connor was an impressive sleuth. I didn’t respond, simply smiled.
“So is that a yes?” he raised an eyebrow.
I continued smiling. He smiled back and slid my head into his ass. It went in with a little pop. He was tighter than I had expected. His eyes rolled back in his head and he bit his lip. He bobbed up and down gently a few times before lowering himself all the way down on my dick.
I had fucked a few guys, but I’d always been the one in control. Even though Connor was bottoming, he was on top of me and was the one doing all the work. He was clearly hungry for it and enjoying every second of it.
He began to whimper as he rode me. He was doing things with his hips that I’d seen chicks in porn do and it felt amazing. He began to pick up the pace. He went from just sitting on me, to leaning over me. I reached down and grabbed his ass with both hands, spreading his cheeks and thrust into him with more urgency. His face was hovering inches above mine. His eyes were half shut and he was making soft whimpering sounds. Sweat had begun to bead up on his face and it was dripping down onto mine. “Who else?” he moaned.
“Who else what?” I panted.
“Who else…” he gasped for air, “you fooled around with?”
I picked up the pace even more, slamming into him with ferocity. “All of them.” I looked up at him, my face oozing with alpha pride as I pounded his ass.
“Really?” His voice was high pitched from the combination of shock and pleasure.
“Yeah, I’ve had them all. You were the last on the list and I’m about to cum inside you.” I bragged.
“Holy shit Chase. I want your cum in me.” his words had begun to run together. He reached down and began to jerk himself off. It only took a few strokes before he erupted onto me. The first shot hit me in the cheek. I felt the second land on my chest. He arched his shoulders back as the orgasm took control of his body. My dick suddenly swelled and with a few quick thrusts I erupted into Connor’s tight ass. I kept thrusting as his insides became warm and wet with my cum.
His orgasm subsided and he collapsed onto me. I wrapped my arms around him and held him against me, my dick still buried deep inside him.
Our breathing began to slow after a minute or two. “Shit Chase, you’re good.” he said without lifting his face.
“Thanks dude, you are fucking amazing too. Both as a top and a bottom.” I was impressed.
He laughed. “Thanks.”
We were silent for a few moments. “So you really fooled around with the whole gang?”
“Yeah.” I was much less cocksure about it now that I’d cum.
“Fuck dude. You’re a braver man than me.” he chuckled.
His phone buzzed beside us. He grabbed it and lifted his face off me to look at it. He smiled and held it so I could see the message.
Yeah, I’d be down to fuck around with both of you together.