Seducing My Homophobic Friends - Part 13 (Patreon)
Content
The Threesome
As I dropped Connor off that night, he asked what I was up to tomorrow.
“I’m supposed to go visit Miss Mabel in the morning.” I looked nervously at the clock. I was supposed to be at her house in 5 hours. Fuck.
“Who the hell is Miss Mabel?” he raised an eyebrow.
“The elderly lady who lives next door.” She was sort of like an adopted grandmother and I was genuinely going to miss her when I moved. And not just because she had a habit of baking me treats on a weekly basis.
“Well make sure you get some rest.” he shot me a devilish grin and hopped out of the car.
I drove home and climbed into bed. My mind was going a mile a minute. Up until this point what I had done with the guys was strictly a private experience between me and each of them. Some had meant more to me than others, but there had been a purpose behind each encounter. They weren’t simply for sexual gratification… or at least that was what I had been telling myself.
But having a threesome with Connor and Jack would be purely for sexual gratification. It felt like a point of no return. I was nervous but excited at the same time. I was just about to doze off when my phone lit up. One new message from Jack.
Hey
I decided to fuck with him a bit. Hey babe… sup?
Hey babycakes, is it true?
So much for making him uncomfortable with joke flirting… Is what true?
Connor messaged me.
I took a deep breath. Yeah, if you’re down?
Totally, as long as nobody else finds out. It seemed like a reasonable request, but based on how things had been going lately, I didn’t have much hope of everything staying a secret.
I’m not the one who told someone about you and me hooking up. I felt the need for a subtle jab.
Hey, the only reason I told him was because he and I had hooked up and I knew he would be cool with it. Jack had a point, but by his logic, I could tell the entire group that I’d hooked up with him. He didn’t know that though. Unless of course Connor had already spilled the beans.
I’m still going to have to give you a spanking for telling him.
I was shocked when Jack sent me a picture of his ass. Spank me.
I’d hooked up with all of the guys and a handful of us occasionally sent each other random dick pics as jokes, but this was the first time one of them had sent me a pic and been serious about it. My dick twitched with excitement.
Oh I’ll spank you… don’t worry. I couldn’t help but smile.
The next morning I rushed through everything that I had to do. I visited Miss Mabel and mowed both her lawn and my own. By mid-afternoon I was nervously waiting for Connor to message me. After a half hour or pacing around my room I finally shot him a message. What’s the plan?
My place. 8 o’clock.
I sighed. That seemed like forever to wait. I’d been really excited about some of my past hookups, but nothing compared to this. I didn’t know what exactly to expect tonight but I knew it was going to be wild. I started to play out scenarios in my mind. Would Jack want to bottom? Would Connor or I fuck him first? What would the other person do?
I began to realize just how many options there were when you had three dicks and six holes to play with. I was too anxious to eat anything for dinner. I knew that I was going to be burning a ton of calories but we could always grab food after if we wanted.
At quarter past 7 my phone lit up with a message from Jack. I’m ready, can you come pick me up?
OMW. I jumped in my car and headed over to Jack’s. He was waiting outside for me. He smiled at me as he jumped in the passenger seat. I smiled back. Neither of us spoke for a minute. I could tell that we were both a little unsure about what to say.
“You got your dab pen on you?” he finally asked.
I handed it to him and he took a small hit. “I’m sorry for telling him about hooking up with you.” Jack sounded sincere.
“It’s fine. I’m not actually upset.” For a moment I considered telling him why I didn’t mind, but decided against it.
“I’m nervous about tonight.” he suddenly blurted out.
“Why?” I was too, but I tried to play it cool.
“Promise not to laugh?” He shot me a nervous glance.
“I promise to try my hardest not to laugh.” I wasn’t sure what he was about to say but just in case it was hilarious and I accidentally snickered I didn’t want to break a promise.
Apparently that was good enough for him. “I think I’ve finally accepted that I can fool around with you or Connor and it’s just two horny guys helping each other out and dosen’t make me gay.” I secretly rolled my eyes. Not this again. “But fooling around with two guys at once? That’s just really… gay.”
“Yeah Jack. Fooling around with two guys at once is gay. You are about to participate in a gay act. If that bothers you, then you don’t have to do it.”
“I know I don’t have to.” he was looking down at his feet. I turned and headed out of town. We still had a while before we were supposed to show up at Connors and Jack clearly needed to talk this out.
“Do you want to?” I asked.
He was silent for a moment. “Yeah I really fucking do and that scares me.”
“Would you rather fuck around with Connor and me or Kayla and Alexis?” They were two hot chicks that hung out with us fairly regularly but had never hooked up with anyone in the group.
“Kayla and Alexis.” he answered matter-of-factly.
“You sure?”
“Yeah.”
“Okay then last time I checked, that means you’re not gay.” I smiled at him while I said it.
“So what am I?” he asked. Clearly scared of what my answer would be.
“Jack, I’m bi.” I paused for a second. He glanced at me, clearly shocked. “I’m not saying that you are bi too. I’m just saying that if you decide that you might be a little bisexual, it’s okay to admit that to me because I am too.”
“Maybe I’m just like 5% bi and 95% straight.” he mumbled.
I couldn’t help but laugh. He tensed up. “What?”
“I think what you mean is that you’re bi and that you’re 95% straight and 5% gay.”
He immediately opened his mouth to protest at my use of the word gay but then realized that I was right.
“How gay are you?” he asked.
I thought about it for a bit. “I’m not really sure to be honest. Probably close to 50/50. I think I like girls just a little more than guys but it's close.”
“Oh.”
“Does that freak you out?”
“A little.” he admitted.
“Why?”
“If you said you were straight then it would make hooking up with you less gay.”
His statement was silly but at the same time I actually understood what he was saying.
“Why are you so worried about labels?” I asked.
“You know…” he glanced up at me as if it was a silly question.
“Yeah I do. The guys are all assholes when it comes to gay shit. They constantly flirt jokingly and push boundaries but then tease the shit out of anyone who says anything thoughtful or considerate to one of the other guys. It pisses me off. That’s why I did something about it.”
“What did you do about it?” he asked, clearly confused.
“I made sure that they couldn’t make fun of anyone anymore.”
“How?” Jack clearly hadn’t put it together yet.
“You can’t tease someone for doing something ‘gay’ if you’ve hooked up with a dude.”
He considered my words for a minute. “Wait.” He looked at me with confusion all over his face. “Did you…” he thought about how to say it. “Hook up with the guys?”
I simply nodded.
“All of them?” his voice gave away how shocked he was.
“Yup.”
“But you told me that you hadn’t done anything with a guy before when we were in the shower.”
“You were my first. That wasn’t a lie.”
“Fuck.” he seemed upset.
“What?”
“That legit made me feel all special and gave me butterflies in my stomach and that’s gay as hell.” he laughed at himself.
“Now that you know it’s safe to be bi, can we go tag team the shit out of Connor?” I asked him.
He looked up and locked eyes with me. “Say that again.”
“Can we go tag team the shit out of Connor?” I asked in a low serious voice.
He bit his lip a little. “Fuck yes.” His eyes glimmered mischievously. “Hearing you say that legit got me hard.”
I reached over and grabbed his dick and gave it a gentle squeeze. He smiled at me. As I parked in front of Connors house, I felt like everything was playing in slow-mo. Jack and I stepped out of the car like a pair of alpha wolves moving in on their prey. He looked over at me and gave me a smile and a nod.
We walked into the house and Connor met us in the living room. He was smiling excitedly but wasn’t prepared for the energy we walked into the room with. Jack placed a hand firmly on his chest and pushed him backwards towards his bedroom.
Connor’s eyes grew wide in shock. I caught him licking his lips in anticipation. Jack pushed him firmly backward onto his bed. I closed the door behind me. Jack and I stripped Connor’s clothes off him. We then undressed ourselves. Jack reached into Connor’s nightstand and pulled out a bottle of lube. He had clearly used that before while visiting. He lubed up his already hard dick. The sight of Jack’s glistening lubed hardon got me rock hard. Connor was panting excitedly.
Jack and I got him on all fours. He looked up at me and we locked eyes for a moment. “I want you.” he whispered to me. Jack slapped his dick against Connor’s ass. Connor wiggled his ass a bit and arched his back, longing for Jack. Jack rubbed his dick against Connor’s hole for a moment before slipping into his ass. Connor moaned and as he did and I slid my dick into his mouth. He attacked my dick with his tongue. I looked up at Jack fucking Connor in the ass. Jack looked at me fucking Connor’s face. We locked eyes and smiled at each other. All inhibitions that either of us had melted away in an instant.
I stared in awe at Jack’s sweaty ab muscles flexing as he thrust his dick deep into Connor. He saw me enjoying the view and flexed his biceps as he kept slamming into Connor’s ass. The sight made my dick even harder than it already was. Connor was making ragged moans as my dick slid in and out of his mouth. I was keeping my thrusts fairly shallow so he wouldn’t gag.
“Yeah, fuck his face Chase.” Jack said with a smile. He reached around and began stroking Connor’s dick. Connor began to moan in earnest. His pitch began to rise until he was making little high pitched whimpers.
“I want to see you cum in his ass Jack.” I demanded.
“I’m getting close.” Jack moaned. His eyes fluttered a bit. He shot me a look and I understood what he wanted. He wanted to finish at the same time. I began to thrust faster. I was getting close too. I did a few hard deep thrusts without thinking. Connor managed to deep throat me without gagging too bad. I felt my balls begin to tense up. I locked eyes with Jack and he nodded. We both picked up our pace. I saw his muscles tense up as my own orgasm began to build. Jack’s head tilted back and he shouted “Fuck” just as my first shot of cum hit Connor in the back of his throat.
We pumped cum into opposite ends of our friend for what seemed like ages. As we pulled out Connor collapsed onto the bed. Jack and I looked at each other’s sweaty bodies and smiled. “You good?” I asked him. He simply nodded, clearly unconcerned about labelling what he’d just done with his friends.
Connor rolled over onto his back. “That was crazy.” He was still breathing heavily. He wiped away the cum that was smeared on his face. “I’m a fucking mess.” he smiled as he said it, clearly pleased with what Jack and I had done to him.
“Do we get to double team you next?” I asked Jack. He looked at me nervously. I shot him my most seductive smile. I could tell by the look in his eyes that he secretly wanted to try it.
“I need a shower and some weed first.” Connor peeled himself off of the bed. “You two gonna join me?”
“In the shower or the weed?” Jack asked with a smirk.
“Both?” Connor shrugged. Jack looked at me and I shook my head.
We didn’t bother grabbing our clothing as we made our way towards his bedroom door. Before Connor could grab the handle, the door swung open and Skylar stepped in. He had his custom Xbox controller in one hand and a bag of chips in the other. He’d apparently stopped by to play some video games with Connor. Little did he know, we were playing an entirely different type of game with Connor.
Skylar’s eyes grew wide with shock. He glanced down at Connor’s exposed dick. His gaze sat there for a second before he looked over at me. I shot him a smile and shrug.