The Fuck Files: Cole - Part 3 (Patreon)
Content
The Mark
Cole. 18 years old. 6”3’, athletic build, short black hair, green eyes. High school quarterback. Known for his toxic masculinity and cockiness.
Me
Anders. 18 years old at the time. 6’1”, slim / athletic build, long dirty blond hair, blue eyes. Not out but not really closeted. If people asked I would admit that I’d been with both girls and guys. Not afraid to use my body to get people I wanted into my bed.
The Setup
Cole and I had been best friends in kindergarten. We spent countless playdates at one another’s houses and had sleepovers on a regular basis. We started to drift apart sometime around 5th or 6th grade. By the time we were freshmen in high school he was ‘too cool’ to hang out with me. It didn’t really bother me too much at the time. He was concerned with sports and girls. I wasn’t overly concerned with either. A few weeks before we graduated, I decided that I wanted to fool around with him, if only for bragging rights. That night had gone better than I imagined. Now I wanted to take things further with him. He had invited me over to his place not long after and had fucked me.
The Encounter
I followed Cole into his bathroom. We were both drenched with sweat and I was covered in my cum. He turned on the shower and let it warm up. “Do you want to get in first?” He asked.
I eyed his shower. “Pretty sure we can both fit in there.” He smiled and we both stepped in. I decided to take control of the situation and grabbed his shampoo. I began to lather up his hair and he gave me an adorably awkward smile. After rinsing his hair I grabbed his bar of soap and began to wash him. Having sex with someone is undeniably intimate, but I would argue that washing someone head to toe is just as intimate. I washed his muscular shoulders and arms. I gently lifted his arms one at a time to wash his armpits. He squirmed when I did, apparently still ticklish just like when we were younger. I lathered up his chest and washboard abs while he watched me with a grin on his face. I knelt down in front of him and soaped up his dick. I scrubbed his pubes before focusing on his dick. It was still a bit engorged from fucking me. I rubbed the length of his shaft before cleaning the head. There was a little cum left in his slit that I wiped out. Next I washed his balls. They weren’t as large as they had been a few minutes ago, but they were still large. I enjoyed their heft in my hand. I glanced up at Cole and he was still staring at me intently, the grin was still plastered on his face.
I washed his legs and then instructed him to turn around. I scrubbed his back and then soaped up his ass. He had a nice firm ass and after washing the cheeks, I slipped my hand between them. Cole let out a nervous chuckle but didn’t pull away. I knew he wanted to have round 2 and decided to make sure he was clean. I slid a soapy finger inside him and he let out a small gasp followed by a drawn out moan.
I wanted to pin him against the wall of the shower and fuck him then and there. I wasn’t certain he would let me, but he seemed to be enjoying my finger inside him. I resisted the urge and had him rinse off as I quickly washed myself. As we were stepping out of the shower, Cole laughed nervously. “That was the first time I’ve had someone else wash me. Not gonna lie, it was awesome.”
“I live close by anytime you need someone to give you a good scrubbing.” I was only half joking. After getting dried off we just tossed our boxers on. Cole went upstairs to get us some snacks and I flipped on his TV. I was scrolling through Netflix when it suddenly hit me. I’d just had legit sex with Cole. My head poured over memories of the two of us. Never in my wildest dreams did I think that one day I’d be laying on his bed after having sex with him waiting for him to bring me snacks.
All those times I watched him on the field, with the cheerleaders fawning over him… his jersey revealing his washboard abs. Not once did I suspect that one day he’d be jerking me off while inside me. He appeared in the doorway holding a pair of drinks and a bag of pretzels. “Are you still a Pepsi guy?” he asked?
I smiled. “You actually remembered that?”
“Of course! Your favorite is Pepsi unless we are outside on a hot day, then you’d rather have lemonade or iced tea. And you like pretzels if we are hanging out watching a movie and Doritos if we are playing video games all night.” I was amazed. He handed me the can and I cracked it open. “What did you pick to watch?”
“It’s called Handsome Devil.” He laid down next to me. A little ways into the movie he picked up on the plot’s similarity to our current situation.
He looked over at me. “Really Anders? I don’t play rugby… I’m a quarterback.” He gave me a playful swat.
“Hey, this was the closest I could come up with. It’s not like there are a lot of gay movies to choose from.”
“Really?” he sounded surprised.
“Yeah dude, I can probably count on my fingers all the semi-decent movies with a gay main character I’ve ever seen.”
“I guess I just assumed there were a ton out there, you just had to look for them.”
“Nope. I wish that were the case.” We went back to watching the movie. I rested my head on Cole’s shoulder. After a few minutes he moved his arm and put my head on his chest, wrapping his arm around me.
Part of me felt totally content and relaxed. But another part of me was horny as fuck. I rested a hand on Cole’s waistband to see if he was really interested in a round 2. A bulge immediately began growing in his boxers. I slid my hand under the waistband and grabbed hold of him. He was rock hard. I slowly stroked him as we watched the movie. Eventually he couldn’t take it anymore and he reached down and slid his boxers off.
I slid down between his legs and took him into my mouth. By now I knew exactly what he liked and wasted no time in making his toes curl. “Jesus Anders, you’re so fucking good at that.”
I slid his dick out of my mouth. “Do you want to try?”
He looked down at me for a minute. “What if I don’t like it?”
“Then you say, I’m not really into this and you stop.”
“You won’t be mad?” He asked. I couldn’t help but grin at how cute he was.
“No, I won’t be mad if sucking dick isn’t your thing Cole.” I gave him a reassuring smile.
“Okay.” I slid up beside him and tossed my boxers on the floor. He slowly moved down between my legs and after hesitating for a second, took my dick in his hand. He slowly jerked me off for a bit, inspecting my dick. He didn’t try to stroke my ego by making comments about how big it was, he simply seemed intrigued by being this close to another dick. Cole leaned forward and sniffed me. I tried to suppress the smile that was growing on my face. Watching him build the courage to put a dick into his mouth for the first time was adorable and erotic at the same time. “This stays between you and me right?” He looked nervous.
“You have my word.” I assured him.
He looked at my dick for another minute or so before finally opening his mouth and slipping the head in. He closed his lips around it. I felt his tongue move slightly. He had a pensive look on his face. His tongue finally wound itself around my head.
He pulled it out of his mouth and looked at me for a minute, trying to gather his thoughts. “It’s nothing like I thought it would be.”
“How so?”
“I guess I thought there would be more of a taste? And I guess it would feel more… gay? Sorry if that seems weird to say. I dunno it’s kinda weird in that its your dick in my mouth, but it doesn’t really feel like sex.” He put me back in his mouth and began to slowly bob up and down. I placed my hands on his head and began to dictate the pace. He slipped me out again. “Okay now that’s feeling like sex.” He cracked a smile and wrapped his lips around me again.
I could tell that he wasn’t really into it so I decided to change things up. I dragged him back up onto the bed beside me. I gave his nipple a quick pinch before sliding back down between his legs. I know that he was assuming I was going to suck on his dick again, but I had other plans. I spread his cheeks and flicked my tongue against his hole. His eyes shot open in surprise. I grabbed the lube that was laying on the floor and lubed up a finger. He watched me intently. I half expected him to tell me to stop, but he didn’t. I caressed his hole for a while. After a minute Cole closed his eyes and laid back on his pillow. His hole began to relax and I slowly slid a finger in. He clamped down for a second, but I was patient and he eventually relaxed and let me in. As I slid deeper in his breathing began to get more labored. He reached for his dick but I swatted his hand away. “You’ll cum too quickly if you jerk off.” I wanted to have some fun before he nutted.
I slowly slipped a second finger in. Cole took it like a champ and his dick began leaking precum all over his abs. I wasn’t sure if he knew where this was going, but after my comment about me wearing the condom for round 2 earlier, I suspected he did. I got a third finger in and after working him for a while I decided it was time. I reached over to his nightstand and grabbed a condom out of the drawer. He opened his eyes and simply looked at me. I could tell he was super nervous.
“Do you trust me?” I asked. He nodded. “Just say stop if you want me to stop.”
“Okay.”
“I’m not gonna lie, it's going to hurt for a minute but then it turns into this pleasure I can’t even describe.”
“I can take pain.” he said without hesitation. I rolled the condom onto myself and applied a liberal amount of lube.
“Roll over on your side. I can be super gentle that way.” I instructed. He rolled over and I spooned behind him. I slid my dick up and down his crack a few times before planting myself against his hole. “Deep breath.” He inhaled and I pressed against him. My head slid in with a pop and he let out a gasp.
“Holy shit that’s big.” He hissed.
“Thanks for the compliment.” I teased and he let out a little laugh between panting breaths. I took my time, letting him stretch out. When I finally got all the way in, Cole let out a little moan. I’d be lying if I said that didn’t turn me on. I slowly thrust into his tight ass. He was surprisingly vocal, letting out moans and occasional ‘fuck yea’s. Once I was sure the pain had begun to change to pleasure, I rolled him onto his back and took position between his legs. I slid back inside him and immediately began to rub against his prostate with my dick.
“Oh shit!” he practically yelled. His eyes were wide now and his voice was quivering. It was go time. I leaned over him and began to hammer into his ass. The wet slapping noise reverberated in his room. I was hovering over him. Sweat dripped off my nose onto his face. I was debating if I should lick some of the sweat off him when he shocked me by leaning up and kissing me. It wasn’t just a quick kiss either. His lips locked onto mine and we made out with the same intensity that I was fucking him with. He tore his face off mine and moaned, “I’m cumming.” His dick erupted onto his chest without either of us touching it. The sight was enough to send me over the edge. I erupted inside him. We stayed intertwined for a minute before I pulled out and tossed the condom into the trash bin with the one from earlier.
“How was it?” I asked him, genuinely curious what he thought about it.
“That was a crazy orgasm.” He seemed lost in thought.
“You okay?” I had a feeling that it was a bit too much for him to process.
“I… I don’t know.” He slid off the bed and quickly wiped himself off with a towel. He threw on his clothes. “Not to be a dick, but I need some time to think about some shit. I’m gonna go for a walk.”
I could tell that he wasn’t inviting me along. I suspected that he didn’t want me to wait here for him either. “I’ll just head home then. Text me that you’re home safe after your walk?” He nodded. “No seriously, promise me you’ll text me when you get home later.” He locked eyes with me.
“Okay promise.”