The Fuck Files: Cole - Part 4 (Patreon)
Content
The Mark
Cole. 18 years old. 6”3’, athletic build, short black hair, green eyes. High school quarterback. Known for his toxic masculinity and cockiness.
Me
Anders. 18 years old. 6’1”, slim / athletic build, long dirty blond hair, blue eyes. Not out but not really closeted. If people asked I would admit that I’d been with both girls and guys. Not afraid to use my body to get people I wanted into my bed.
The Setup
Cole and I had been best friends in kindergarten. We spent countless playdates at one another’s houses and had sleepovers on a regular basis. We started to drift apart sometime around 5th or 6th grade. By the time we were freshmen in high school he was ‘too cool’ to hang out with me. It didn’t really bother me too much at the time. He was concerned with sports and girls. I wasn’t overly concerned with either. A few weeks before we graduated, I decided that I wanted to fool around with him, if only for bragging rights. That night had gone better than I imagined. He had invited me over to his place not long after and had fucked me. Later that night, I had fucked him. Afterwards he took a walk to ‘think about things’ and we hadn’t talked much the rest of the summer.
The Encounter
Christmas day was much like Christmas Eve. My mother found another way to create yearly drama. On Christmas that drama took the form of a yearly open house where friends and family would drop by for finger foods and drinks. The invitations always said anytime between 6pm and 10pm, which of course meant that everything had to be ready and spotless by noon.
My dad and I were used to it by now and by mid afternoon I had retreated to my room to relax for a few hours before people started showing up. I was surprised when my phone lit up with a message from Cole.
Hey, is it okay if I come with my parents to your open house?
I stared at the message for a minute. Was I pissed that Cole had been pretty much ghosting me since we hooked up? Absolutely. Did I understand why? Probably. Did I want to see him again? That was the real question.
Of course.
A drunken Christmas party wasn’t exactly the best place to have ‘gee, thanks for ghosting me for the second time in our friendship’ talk. Or maybe it was… I could totally see that as being made into a Hallmark movie. Plus, my mom was a fan of Christmas drama.
I waited for him to respond but he never did. Perhaps his parents were just dragging him along with them and he wanted to make sure I wasn’t going to make a scene. I’d love to say that I did even give it a second thought and just went about my afternoon. But that would be a lie.
I spent a solid hour figuring out what I was going to wear. I had to pick out something that my mother would approve of or I would bring her wrath upon me. But I didn’t want to wear something too boring and formal. I finally settled on a nice set of slacks that showed off my ass without being too obvious and a nice collared shirt.
I got dressed and looked at my phone. 5pm. I sat on the edge of my bed. My foot wouldn’t stop wiggling. Why the hell was I so nervous? Probably because I hadn’t been able to get Cole out of my head ever since we had hooked up. Yeah I fooled around with a bunch of guys, but with him it seemed different. Maybe it was because we had been friends our entire lives? Maybe it was because hooking up with the quarterback was hot? No, I knew damned well it was because I had feelings for him. Actual feelings.
I don’t know what I expected. He was going to a school hours away. It wasn’t like we could have had any sort of real relationship. Our lives were going in different directions. Yeah Anders, keep telling yourself that and maybe you’ll eventually believe it.
The doorbell rang. I looked at my phone. 5:35. I jumped off my bed and had sprinted halfway down the stairs before I realized that I looked WAY too excited. I slowed my pace before opening the door.
“Oh, Merry Christmas Mr. and Mrs. Wisemen. Come in!” I did my best to feign excitement at seeing my neighbors. The party dragged on. I started drinking to try to pass the time. I was really starting to feel the booze when a firm hand grabbed onto my shoulder and scared the shit out of me. I spun around and was greeted by Cole’s wide smile.
I’m not sure if it was the alcohol or the fact that I hadn’t seen him in months or just the Christmas spirit, but it felt like the party melted away and it was just the two of us standing there. We locked eyes and I could feel my face light up. I took a step towards him. I was close enough that I could feel his warm breath and smell his cologne. He suddenly looked a little nervous and the sounds of the party came crashing back down on me. Shit, there were people all around us. I quickly gave him a hug and stepped back to a socially acceptable distance for two guys to be standing from one another.
“Glad you could make it.” I said.
“Thanks, I was really looking forward to seeing you.” He said, his voice got towards the end.
“I missed you.” I said it without thinking but as soon as the words left my lips I started to get choked up. Cole looked like he’d been punched in the gut. He glanced around nervously.
“Is there somewhere we can go to talk?”
I nodded towards the stairs and he followed me to my bedroom. I took a seat on my bed and Cole closed the door behind us and took a seat at my desk.
I looked at him expectantly and he kept his eyes glued on the floor. “Look, I know that I fucking did it again, ok?” He glanced up at me. He wasn’t crying but I could see water starting to build up in his eyes. I opted not to say anything. He looked back down at the floor. “I got scared again.” His voice cracked slightly.
“What were you scared of?”
He looked up at me like I was crazy for even asking. “People finding out!”
“Why would people find out that we hooked up?” I asked. He looked at me and thought about it for a moment. I could tell that he wanted to open up about something.
“Is there maybe more to it than just that?” I asked cautiously. His eyes were locked onto mine. I’d never seen him this nervous before.
He let out a sigh and put his head in his hands. He sat like that for a few minutes. I didn’t say anything else. Cole was clearly on the fence about opening up and I didn’t want to say the wrong thing and cause him to close up.
“That night that you blew me was great.” His voice was quiet and he was still looking down at the floor. “I enjoyed it and I knew that you really enjoyed it too. After I went home I convinced myself that it wasn’t even gay or anything. I’d just let you suck my dick because I was horny and you wanted to.” He glanced up at me and I could tell that he was ashamed of what he’d just admitted.
“Then after I fucked you, my mind was telling me the same thing. It wasn’t any different than fucking a girl. Totally not gay at all.” He didn’t look up after saying that. I saw a tear drop from his face onto the floor.
“But then… then I let you fuck me. That night I was just telling myself I was just horny and wanted to experiment and it was no big deal.” His voice cracked. “But that was bullshit. I enjoyed it, like a lot. And in the heat of the moment I just kissed you. I kissed you.”
Silence descended on the room for a few minutes. More tears were falling but Cole was managing to keep himself from sobbing. “I felt so close to you that night. And not just the sex. In the shower…” His voice cracked and he paused.
“While you were fucking me, I had a sudden desire to ask you to be my boyfriend.” A quiet sob escaped from him. “And that really freaked me out. After we finished my mind was swirling with a million thoughts. It was like I suddenly didn’t know who I was anymore. I started second guessing going away to college. Started wondering if I really wanted to play football. Wondered if I really wanted to find a girl to settle down with. And that fucking terrified me.” He managed to keep it together and took a long slow breath. “You don’t know how close I was to texting you to see if you wanted to be my boyfriend while I was on my walk that night. But in the end fear won again.” I could see him clench his fist. I worried that he was about to punch something in my room. “I shouldn’t be afraid like this.” he hissed. “I’m clutch when things are on the line. I love the rush of adrenaline in dangerous situations. Why the fuck does this terrify me so much?” He finally looked up at me.
“Because it's scary.”
“Then how come you seem to manage it like it's no big deal?” He wiped the tears away from the corners of his eyes.
“Because I’m lucky. I don’t care what other people think about me and my parents always made it clear that they didn’t give a fuck. They’d be thrilled if they found out that I was dating you.”
“They would?”
“Of course they would. You’re COLE.” I almost laughed when I said it.
“But would you be thrilled if you were dating me?” Cole asked. He looked terrified of the answer. Something told me that he was fearful of both options. If I shot him down he would be upset and his ego would take a hit. But if I said yes… he was scared of what might happen next.
“Cole…” I slipped off the bed and knelt in front of him and grabbed his hand. His fist finally relaxed. “I would love it if you were my boyfriend. I’ve cared about you since we were little. We have so much fun when we’re together. Dating would just take that and make it even more special.”
He smiled and tears started forming again. “I just don’t know if I can.”
“I understand. And I’m not going to be mad at you if you decide that you can’t. Just…” I squeezed his hand. “Just don’t ghost me again. It hurts too much.”
He launched out of the chair with such suddenness that I sprang backwards in shock. His hands grasped both sides of my face and his lips crashed onto mine. I was in such shock that I didn’t return the kiss for a moment. My hands found their way onto Cole’s back as my mouth finally opened. Our tongues touched and excitement coursed through my body. Did this mean what I think it meant?
Cole’s hands slid down from my face to my ass. He lifted me up and fell on top of me on my bed. Before I knew what was happening, he had my shirt unbuttoned and I’d taken his dick out. As much as I enjoyed making out with him, I wanted that cock.
I slid down and wrapped my lips around his head. He was rock hard and his balls looked huge. He must not have cum in days. I swirled my tongue around his head, savoring the taste of his precum.
“Fuck Anders. I want you so bad right now.” His strong hands caressed my hair. I slipped him down my throat and buried my nose in his pubes. As I slipped him out of my throat and inhaled, I was wrapped in his scent. A mixture of his sandalwood soap and musky sweat. I licked one of my fingers and slid it back to his hole. This time he didn’t hesitate at letting me in. As my finger found its mark, he began to thrust into my mouth with urgency. “Fuck…” he whimpered.
His body quivered for a moment and he thrust into me quickly. “I’m cumming…” he whined as he erupted into my mouth. Shot after shot hit the roof of my mouth. I swallowed as fast as I could, savoring the taste of him. He twitched as the final shot came out and then collapsed on my bed.
“Holy shit you are so good at that.” I couldn’t tell if he was blushing or if he was still flush from the exertion. I just smiled at him. His hand slid up my thigh to the bulge in my pants.
“Anders, come say hi to the McKenzies!” My mothers voice rang up the stairs. We shot off the bed like we’d been fired from a canon. In a matter of seconds we’d managed to get dressed and make ourselves look semi-presentable again. As we opened my bedroom door to head downstairs I whispered in Cole’s ear, “Stand in front of me to hide my boner.”
He simply smiled and nodded.