Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The Mark

Cole. 18 years old. 6”3’, athletic build, short black hair, green eyes. High school quarterback. Known for his toxic masculinity and cockiness.

Me

Anders. 18 years old. 6’1”, slim / athletic build, long dirty blond hair, blue eyes. Not out but not really closeted. If people asked I would admit that I’d been with both girls and guys. Not afraid to use my body to get people I wanted into my bed.

The Setup

Cole and I had been best friends in kindergarten. We spent countless playdates at one another’s houses and had sleepovers on a regular basis. We started to drift apart sometime around 5th or 6th grade. By the time we were freshmen in high school he was ‘too cool’ to hang out with me. It didn’t really bother me too much at the time. He was concerned with sports and girls. I wasn’t overly concerned with either. A few weeks before we graduated, I decided that I wanted to fool around with him, if only for bragging rights. That night had gone better than I imagined. He had invited me over to his place not long after and had fucked me. Later that night, I had fucked him. Afterwards he took a walk to ‘think about things’ and we hadn’t talked much the rest of the summer. He'd shown up at my family's New Year's Eve party and after talking, things had got heated in my bedroom.

The Encounter

The party dragged on for a few more hours. Cole and I tried our best to keep our distance from one another so that we wouldn’t give away what we had been doing upstairs. It was hard though. I caught him staring at me from across the room a few times. We brushed against one another at the refreshments table and his hand rested on the small of my back for a bit longer than it probably should have.

The crowd finally started to dwindle and those who remained were tipsy enough that I figured it was safe to finally chat with Cole. His face lit up for a brief moment when he saw me approaching him. He must have realized it was a giveaway and quickly played it cool.

“Hey, so I was wondering if you want to stay over and watch some movies or something. I’m not really tired yet.”

Cole’s mother was within earshot and had clearly had a few too many. “Oh that’s adorable. You’re going to have a sleepover like you used to have when you were kids!” She gave Cole’s cheek a pinch and I resisted the urge to mention that the agenda was VERY different from what it was when we were kids.

We loaded a few plates with various goodies from the refreshments table and made our way upstairs. As soon as we plopped down on my bed, Cole started to blush. He smiled bashfully and his gaze drifted down to the plate of food in front of him. Seeing him act that way did something inside me. I was used to flirting with guys. I was used to hooking up with guys. But I wasn’t used to this. Emotions were swirling inside me that I was unfamiliar with. Normally I would be all over the attractive guy sitting on my bed, but for some reason I wanted nothing more than to sit and admire the guy blushing in front of me.

We sat looking at one another, neither of us speaking for what seemed like ages. Cole finally broke the silence.

“Thanks for inviting me to stay over.” At first I thought he was just being a wiseass, but when he looked up at me I could tell that he was serious.

“Of course. I figured we still had some more talking to do.” I didn’t want him to think that I’d just invited him to stay over so I could get in his pants.

“Yeah…” He seemed to get lost in his own head for a moment. “I’ve been thinking a lot about things.”

I slowly raised a Dorito to my mouth. He glanced up to me as I slowly slid it into my mouth and munched on it. He couldn’t help but crack a smile. “You and your fucking Doritos…”

“As if you don’t love them too!” I held one out tantalizingly close to his mouth. He leaned forward and I slid it into his mouth.

“I miss us.” He blurted it out and I think it caught him as much by surprise as it did me. We stared at one another as the statement sank in.

“I miss us too.” I said carefully. Even though we’d never been a couple, we had been friends and I missed that. We got along effortlessly with one another. Cole had a way of making the most mundane night memorable. That smile. The effortless charm. He was the first person who I really opened my heart up to.

The realization washed over me. I must have made some sort of face because Cole noticed and raised an eyebrow. “What?” I shook my head no but he didn’t give up. “Oh come on. I know you want me to open up to you about what I’m feeling, so you have to do the same.”

He had a point, but I didn’t want to risk oversharing and ruining what seemed to be happening between us. “I was just thinking about how close we used to be.”

“Anders, we know each other too well for you to be pulling that bullshit and expect to get away with it.” He gave me a playful swat.

The booze still had me a little tipsy and I was having a hard time resisting the urge to open up to him. “Fine, I just realized that I’ve always had a crush on you.” I cringed a bit as I said it. I expected him to be shocked by my revelation.

“Well, yeah.” He made a goofy face. “Tell me something I don’t already know.”

“A part of me was relieved when we stopped being friends.” Shit. I needed to get my mouth under control.

That one seemed to catch him by surprise. “Really? Why?”

“Because. Every time we hangout I had to suppress my feelings for you. You were everything I wanted in a…” I swallowed. “Boyfriend.”

Cole thought about it for a moment. “Yeah. I knew you were struggling. I’m not as oblivious as I seem sometimes. I knew that you were into me. And I think I’m finally able to admit that I liked the fact that you were into me. It turned me on. And the more time we spent together, the more I started to think about acting on it.” He reached over and stole a Dorito from me. “That terrified me.”

“Yeah. I can relate.” We had already gone over this, but it was still strange hearing him say it. My skin was beginning to tingle. Cole was admitting he was into me. Yeah we’d fucked. He’d kissed me while I was balls deep in him. But actually hearing him admit that he’d been into me for as long as I’d been into him meant so much more.

“So where do we go from here?” His voice shook slightly as he asked.

“Where do you want it to go?” I asked.

“Where do YOU want it to go ?” He counted. We smiled at one another.

“Cole, you know where I want it to go.” I said it good naturedly, but he suddenly got a serious look on his face.

“What if…” he looked up at me nervously. “What if I’m not ready to put a label on it yet?”

I waited to see if he would elaborate on the statement, but he didn’t. “So like…” I egged him on.

“Like we just see where things go without having to call it dating.”

“So you want to be boyfriends, but you’re not ready to admit you have a boyfriend.” I was an understanding guy, but I wasn’t about to let someone jerk me around. Not even Cole.

He sighed. “I know. It’s a fucked thing to say.” He twirled a piece of broccoli on his plate. “I can’t have a boyfriend unless I’m…”

“Gay?”

His eyes shot up and locked onto mine. I could see the terror in them. I reached over and took his hand in mine. “Cole, I don’t need you to be ‘gay’. I don’t even need you to be ‘bi’. I just need to know that we are on the same page. I don’t want to fall for someone that isn’t falling for me too.”

Cole’s thumb began to caress my hand. He smiled at me. “Anders, would you want to go on a date with me tomorrow night?”

His question caught me a bit off guard. I suddenly had butterflies in my stomach. I know, having a guy ask you on a date that you’ve already fucked shouldn’t be a big deal, but for some reason it was. I tried to play it cool. I failed miserably.

“Yes!” I realized that I practically shouted and quickly put a hand over my mouth.

Cole cracked up. “Shhhh.”

We decided that we should probably put on a movie and call it a night since it was after 3am already. I let Cole choose and he put on Get Hard. “Dude, we used to think this was the funniest movie back in the day.” He shot me a smile as he slid beside me on the bed. He left enough room between us for Jesus. I shot him a subtle scowl and he smirked at me. He lifted his arm and motioned me over.

I snuggled next to him and he wrapped his arm around me. His shirt smelled like a mixture of cologne, sweat and alcohol. Someone must have spilled some on him during the party. The opening scene hadn’t even finished when my hand found its way down to the bulge in his pants.

“Our date isn’t until tomorrow night mister.” He said with a smile.

“Oh, right. My bad.” I slid my hand off his bulge and went back to watching the movie. The devilish grin on my face grew as his bulge strained against his pants. He finally couldn’t take it any longer and slipped out of them.

“Excuse me sir, but are you in just your boxers with an obvious erection? Do I need to remind you that our date isn’t until” My wiseass comment was interrupted by Cole’s mouth latching onto mine.

I closed my eyes and enjoyed the sensation of his warm wet tongue brushing against mine. He tasted like a mixture of alcohol and Doritos. I had to suppress a smile.

His kisses started soft, but slowly became more aggressive. He slid off my mouth and began to kiss my neck. “No hickies!” I warned.

He smiled at me. “Good point.” He nibbled on my ear for a moment before slowly making his way down to my pants. As he undid them and looked up at me, I realized what was about to happen. Cole slid off my boxers and positioned himself between my legs.

My dick was rock hard and he took it in his hand and gave it a gentle squeeze. He looked up at me and we locked eyes. Without breaking eye contact, he slowly opened his mouth and began to lick my dick. I let out a little gasp and I could see his eyes light up, clearly pleased by my reaction. He held my gaze as he slipped my dick into his mouth.

He wasn’t nearly as timid as he had been last time my dick was in his mouth. He seemed to be enjoying it as much as I was this time. He tried to slide me down his throat but gagged slightly.

“Sorry.” he apologized.

“It takes practice.” I assured him. He slipped me back into his mouth and began to massage my balls. I reached down and placed a hand on his head. Cole was sucking my dick.

The more I thought about it, the more my balls began to tingle. “I’m getting close.” I warned him in a whisper. He just nodded and kept at it. My other hand found its way onto his head. Cole had coated my dick with his drool and was stroking my shaft as he bobbed up and down on me. My hips thrust a few times as the orgasm built. “I’m gonna cum!” He popped it out of his mouth and began jerking me quickly, pointing it as his tongue. I erupted and the first shot landed on his tongue. The second hit his cheek and Cole began to lose control of where my shots were going. By the time my orgasm subsided, half his face was coated in my cum.

He looked up at me in a mixture of shock and disbelief. I tried my best not to laugh, but I failed miserably. “I’m sorry, but you’re a mess.” I grabbed my boxers and began to wipe off his face.

“That was actually kinda hot. I’ve always wondered what it would feel like taking a load in the mouth.” His voice was quiet.

“Well that was more of a porno caliber facial…” We locked eyes and smiles spread across both our faces. “No regrets?” I asked.

He thought for a moment before shaking his head. “No regrets.”

We shed the rest of our clothes and slid under the covers. Neither of us paid any attention to the movie. I could tell he was coming to terms with what was going on between us. I didn’t pry and gave him time to process everything. I rested my head on his chest and wrapped an arm over him. He held onto me and nuzzled his head in my hair.

Even though I felt safe in his arms, I couldn’t seem to fall asleep. My mind was still racing. What did this all mean? Were we actually dating now? He’d basically admitted that he wanted to be boyfriends but just not use the label. Why did a part of me secretly fear that I would wake up tomorrow and he’d be gone from my life yet again? I wanted desperately to ask him if he wanted to be my boyfriend but I knew that wouldn’t help things. I had to give him time.

All that mattered was that he was snuggling with me. For tonight, he was mine. My Cole.

Files

Comments

blaxkrage

So what happened with Cole? Did they just end it after the date?

The Gay Gh0stwriter

This storyline sort of got lost in the shuffle of some of my new ones. Don't worry, I'm going to continue this one though. I'm emotionally invested in it.

blaxkrage

Oh ok cool thanks man

enzorence

so, i just finished read all the parts of this collection that have been written so far. i am enjoying the pictures you are putting in with your stories. each one really fits the written description of the guys. i am half in love with Anders. he, to me, would be a great friend to have. i do want to hear more about Cole. he is one of my favorites here along with Tyson, Brayden and Austin. each one of those four spoke to me in different and yet similar ways to the point where i wanted to give each of them a big, warm, comforting hug.

Devin

You write beautifully. You make the story so real, that you can become part of the story itself. This particular story is both happy and sad. I’m not sure Anderson will actually ever truly get Cole. I’m not sure Cole would allow himself to “be gay”. If not, he will marry. Have 2.5 kids and a dog. And then he will always wonder “what if”.