A Review of Survivors of Death II| Kingdom Death Monster (Patreon)
Content
With the release of a second (expected) Survivors of Death, I think that we can comfortably assume that the Echoes of Death is “complete” and going ahead it will be Survivors of Death that takes up the flag for strains. This is something I am quite content with, currently Strain Fighting Arts are very difficult to utilise if you are running Arc Survivors. This discord between the two mechanics makes having a release with four strain fighting arts (and associated miniatures) less desirable, so the evolution of this line makes sense.
In this release we get another four new characters, with each of them featuring elements of the Tyrant, the Screaming God, the Red Witches and Crabman. If you're not familiar with Crabman, he was a survivor from Gencon 2024 who beat the odds multiple times and became something of a legend before he fell off a mountainside.
The game contents gives us four new character cards (2 impairments, 2 abilities), the first Indomitable Resource pattern weapon for the L3 Tyrant, two paired seed weapons (one of which requires Atnas), a strain fighting art and a Knowledge for the Collective Cognition milestone of 22.
As always, because I am traditionally among the last people who gets physical access to KDM content, I do not at this point have access to the miniatures, so I cannot review that aspect of this box (and I test out these cards with proxies until they arrive), but the pictures I have seen give us models that are of the high standard we come to expect from APG releases. The Survivors (and Echoes) releases tend to be models that I find very useful in game, and I am sure these will be no exception.
The Gameplay Content
Fast Twitch Strain → Soaring Advance Strain Fighting Art
Our lone strain fighting art is Soaring Advance and the unlock for this one is a lot more straightforward than others. All one needs to do is have a survivor with Quixotic and gear that can allow them to Pounce, Slam or Charge. Quixotic is a disorder that can get handed out by the game directly in addition to gaining it via natural progression during a campaign. Pounce is a White Lion ability, Slam is an Antelope ability and Charge is a Phoenix ability; so these are all available simply by adding a relevant quarry from that group to the given node. Actually performing the act 7+ times during a showdown is also not that difficult, you don't even need to connect with the monster in order to gain progress, you only need to do it 7 times in the showdown. The only possible roadblock here is waiting to gain Quixotic again and as mentioned that's a disorder with a higher drop rate than many others.
Soaring Advance is a relatively simple strain fighting art that makes use of momentum tokens (also used/generated by the Dung Beetle Knight fighting art Propulsion Drive, so there's synergy to be found). As long as you move 5+ spaces in a straight line either from movement or knockback you will gain a momentum token. If you get knocked down then you will lose all your momentum tokens. But if you have 3+ of them, then you may archive 3 in order to make your first wound attempt automatically succeed in an attack. This is not a critical wound, but it is an automatic success against whichever hit location you want (First Strike Hls will still take priority). Because you can choose the HL order you want to resolve in, and because you also choose when you want to activate this fighting art, you get a lot of control over this and can line it up for the highest possible benefit.
Gaining the momentum tokens is still a slow process, the straight line requirement is definitely awkward at times, but Dash, Monster Movement armor sets, higher than normal movement and knockback can all help and the aformentioned Propulsion Drive gives you the ability to generate momentum tokens for moving 4+ unique spaces that do not have to be in a straight line. Running both on the same survivor allows for a lot more generation of momentum tokens and having two options for using them gives a bit of flexibility.
Overall this is a solid, well designed Strain Fighting Art that has good power combined with reasonable limiters and I think it is great. The only real issue at the moment is the aforementioned difficulties that strain fighting arts have for Arc survivors and the solution is a simple house rule to allow Strain Fighting Arts to get the same treatment as Secret Fighting Arts. I honestly think that a rule like that should be printed in Campaigns of Death and that would greatly assist the situation for strain FAs, but we'll see what the future brings.
Inquisitorial Saw – Tyrant Indomitable Resource
Note: This content requires owning The Dragon King expansion and can only be gained in People of the Stars when fighting the L3 Tyrant.
As per all Indomitable Resources/Patterns, the more of these you have the less often you will see the individual ones. This is even more the case when considering a pattern for a campaign specific monster who appears at the L3 level just once. This is not something we are going to see too often, though right now (pre-Campaigns of Death) it is a guaranteed drop once per People of the Stars because it is the only one. So if you're wanting to experience this weapon, now is the time!
Cost: 1x Umbilical Phalanges, 2x Bone, 2x Broken Lantern, 1x Perfect Organ
The Inquisitorial Saw gives us a saw/scythe and while saw doesn't have a weapon proficiency card, I can't help but feel that given how much we are seeing this weapon type turn up we're due one at some point in the future. Scythe is good enough for the moment, as it is a very strong weapon type, though a little awkward to train in advance due to being somewhat rare.
The weapon itself is interesting with a baseline (1/6+/8/Reach 2/Barbed 4) profile that raises to a (4/6+/8/Reach 2/Barbed 4) profile when the wielder has a constellation. That is solid enough, Barbed 4 in particular is great with the higher speed profile, but the real meat of this weapon is in the Red puzzle, red, red, blue affinity ability. “Mutilate” as it is named, gives us immediate persistent injuries when they are drawn, this has the downside of removing the ability to generate wounds from them (and thinning the HL deck), which also can reduce the number of potential critical wound resources but the positive is 1+ automatic debuffs placed on the monster.
I really enjoy People of the Stars, narratively it is still the strongest of all the pre-generated campaigns we have seen to date, Anna's narrative writing is always among the best elements in the various expansions. But the campaign has always suffered a bit on the mechanical side due to its age, especially the finale being a lot weaker than the rest of the campaign deserves. So at the moment this weapon sticks out a bit, but it also (hopefully) foreshadows an evolution for People of the Stars that's coming in Campaigns of Death (aka the Fish expansion aka CoD).
This is a very solid weapon with some exciting abilities, especially the ones given by Scythe proficiency. The only issue being the previously mentioned low rate that you'll see the cards and get to use the weapon.
Perceptual Isolation – Collective Cognition (CC) Milestone 19
CC Milestone 19 is not a milestone occupied by the Gambler's Chest cards, which means it is not competing with Quarry monster milestones in the way that the previous Survivors of Death release was (One of the elements that almost that killed Ecstatic Dance on arrival). That is an improvement over the previous release which sat in CC16 (Smog Singers, Screaming Antelope) and competed with them.
Placid Mentality is a knowledge that provides protection against brain traumas by allowing you to spend 3 survival and suffer new perspective, which is this result here:
The strength of this particular knowledge lays in how you as the player are given the choice of when to activate it. While the first level of this is not great because you can only use it against the very first instance of brain trauma, the second and third levels allow you to use it against any brain trauma suffered, meaning you can choose to let the brain trauma occur if it is not too harmful for the survivor. It becomes an insurance against potentially fatal results, and in concert with the Accept Darkness Principle it gives the survivor a massive amount of protection from death by brain trauma.
It does however come with both the knowledge slot cost and the -1 evasion downsides and the highest level giving a +1 accuracy token isn't very valuable outside of Gourmands. Overall I don't think this is worth too much value for a settlement at the moment and in fact unless the new expansions really change the landscape for brain traumas I don't think I want this one in my knowledge pool for most campaigns. I will of course revise this opinion if the Red Witches or Pariah change the landscape, but for now brain traumas are the form of “injury” that I consider to be of least concern due to how they generate insanity to protect the survivor from the next trauma. Until then, the knowledge slot cost is too high for my tastes in respect to this "comfort" knowledge.
Seed Patterns – Dextral Crabaxe and Sinistral Crabaxe
Note: The Sinistral Crabaxe is an Atnas specific seed pattern.
These two crabby weapons are the tribute to Crabman, both of them require a fair investment in Crab Spiders, and also have tight timing windows where you can craft them. This means that for a good crabby experience you'll need to seek out and stockpile Crab Spider resources ahead of time. There is more than one Crab Spider in the Vermin resource deck, but this is still up to chance, so it's hard to make these weapons. The difficulties in crafting either of these weapons is very high, it seems intentional that Team Death have made the chances in which you craft these weapons very low. You need to be as lucky as Crabman to get both of these in one campaign it seems (note I have not forgotten the character cards in this release).
Dextral Crabaxe
Crabting Cost: 4x Crab Spider, 2x Leather, 1x Perfect Organ, 2x Bone
Crabting Requirements: Lone survivor returning from victorious showdown, Family innovation
There are ways we can engineer the “Lone survivor” situation thanks to the Homicisalism philosophy, but outside of that this is something where we'll need to plan in advance by collecting the Crab Spiders from as early as possible. That can be a bit of a sacrifice due to that resource also being a hide, but if you want to experience carcinisation for yourself then sacrifices must be made.
The weapon is a bone keyword axe with a (1/6+/10/Reach 2/Paired with Sinistral Crabaxe) weapon that also has a Puzzle Green, Green, Green affinity ability that gives you crab tokens. When you suffer a severe injury you can archive between 0 and 4 crab tokens to add +1 to the roll result per crab token archived. This is again something you get to do after you see what the severe injury is so it is a very solid ability to have on a weapon with a good attacking profile, which this weapon is.
I'll go into the paired section after we look at its companion piece, but the verdict on this Crabaxe is that it is worth the effort of crafting, but you're also not going to see it too often.
Sinistral Crabaxe
Crabting Cost: 2x Crab Spider, 2x Leather, 1x Perfect Bone
Crabting Requirements: A survivor resolves 10+ Sword Craft cards in the previous lantern year showdown and survives.
This one is a really tough pattern to craft, I've yet to have a showdown where I've had that many Sword Craft cards resolved by a survivor, have any of you experienced that and with what level of Atnas? As such I can't really write about this one with actual real experience of using it, however we can see that it is a (3/7+/5/Savage) bone keyword axe. The real gem of this one however is the Blue puzzle, blue, blue affinity ability that gives is the ability to archive gained crab tokens (and either weapon can gain us crab tokens) in order to increase our total luck for an attack. Now the tricky part here is we need to archive “when we attack” which means we're doing this before we draw the hit locations, so a whiff is not good and the weapon only have 7+ accuracy, but it can roll 4 speed with assistance from its paired sibling.
That brings us to paired, this is my favourite way of using paired in the game, it feels kind of awful to run two paired weapons of the same name because the second copy is just +X speed (and affinities), so often you're giving up a slot for something that the given survivor might not even want. Certain weapons do benefit from this, but those weapons have an individually strong base attack profile.
Paired weapons with different names however do not get blanked by the game's base rules, and they provide flexibility. The Dextral Crabaxe benefits because it becomes a (2/6+/10/Reach 2) weapon and the Sinistral benefits because its low accuracy desires speed to offset that. Most of the time the Crabby survivor will be attacking with the Dextral, but once enough tokens are built up you can then switch across to the Sinistral weapon for a high luck attack.
The tricky point here is those affinities, it's hard to get both of them activated on the same survivor, but of course Cycloid Scale Armor exists and that's your first port of call if you want to try these out together. Atnas + Sunstalker in a campaign.
I think that all of this is very fun, it is always nice to see tributes to interesting Gencon events (and the community as a whole) rolled into these promotional releases, it just feels right.
The Character Cards
Our final part of this release is the four character cards who represent the four miniatures that came with this box. We have two positive abilities and two negative impairments. Character cards are a very, very competitive space due to the correct number of them being the bare minimum (24 + 1 legendary). So each new Character card needs to out compete the previous ones either by mechanics or theme. It's unfortunate that the diminishing returns on these cards is high, but that is just the nature of decks. If you want to see more character cards in your games I'd recommend building the smallest deck possible (25 cards total) and then after you draw a given character card you archive it and then draw a random character card of the same type from the archived pool of cards. That'll keep things fresh and surprising while also increasing the number of different characters you'll see over the campaign. It feels better if you don't get to play as often as you'd like.
The Crabby
We'll start with the Crabman's card, this turns your survivor into a Crabman (carcinisation, nature loves to evolve into crabs!) and gives them the ability when returning from a showdown to archive a resource and turn it into a Crab Spider. This is the intended way to assist in paying the high Crab Spider cost, and it's also a good ability even without the Crabaxes because Crab Spiders have the hide keyword, making them more valuable than many other resource options. Because armor is a 5 gear card affair (most of the time) and hide is what we use for it, that's always a great conversion to make use of. This is pretty much an automatic include because without this Character you'll struggle to make the Dextral Crabaxe which comes in the same box.
Sanctimonious
Impairments with upside are always a bit more interesting than normal, however the negative here is up to -9 points of survival. That requires quite a bit of work to mitigate, things like the Sonorous Lantern or Arrival Survival (Dragon Armor, Lantern Armor), Monster Meat etc can give survivors way to replenish the lost survival, but for early settlements with a low Survival Limit this essentially reads “This survivor cannot depart” until the Survival Limit is sufficiently increased.
Overall I think this is an interesting one, I'm not sure how far up the old Impairment tier list I'd rank it but I think it's in the upper half due to the strength compensation.
The Disinterested
On the other hand, a survivor who does not gain departing survival or insanity bonuses is incredibly difficult to use. You are very much dependant on gains of survival during the hunt phase and showdown, so this Character card is going to be something of a campaign meta call. If you've got potential gear options that generate survival outside of departing survival and there is enough tools available to you that you can ensure the Disinterested doesn't depart with 0 survival then there's something you can play around here and that is interesting. It is not as much of an “immediate retirement” situation as being unable to gain survival at all, but it is still significant. I don't think this is as “good” as Sanctimonious, but it does have fascinating play patterns.
The Ardent
Our last character ability card is the Ardent, this gives you a reroll token the first time a survivor dies during the showdown (Yeah, the wording is different, but that's basically what we have here). That's not something I value much at all, I think this shouldn't have the “Limit Once Per Showdown” clause on it, the death of a survivor is sometimes the sign of a showdown turning away from the survivors, but the second and third deaths tend to represent a showdown spiralling out of control (Yes there are exceptions, Homicidalism is a nonsense Philosophy). I think this is a middling attribute at best because of the limiter, it would have been more interesting without that.
Final Thoughts
The highlight of this entire collection is Crabman's enshrining into the game's mythos through both miniature and mechanics. So much of what is present here however lands in the category of “fine”; I've worked hard to find the upsides and benefits of everything I can, but we have gear cards with limited presence (some of these cards might get onto players tables once in a lifetime), we have designs being held back by limitations they didn't need, or the numbers being too high when dealing with the downside. I'm not sure why the design team feels 3 survival is a good baseline number but we see it a lot and it generally makes the mechanic it is used with hard to interact with.
There's nothing in here that is bad, but the only thing that sparks joy for me is the Crabman related stuff, which makes this an expensive purchase where a lot of weight is place on the value of the miniatures. I do really like the Strain Fighting Art, but it is frustrating how the divide between KDM's core advancement systems leaves Fighting Arts kind of stranded and releases like this with a knowledge and a fighting art have something that's always going to be left in the box. In fact, being left in the box is a big risk that a lot of these cards could fall victim to. There's so much that is very specific in what situations it can be gained in and for an expensive release like this that is a very real concern when considering the value proposition.
Perhaps when I get to see the new expansions there may be additional areas where these improve (and if that is the case I'll come back and update sections of this review), but I can only really see the knowledge gaining from the current releases (Pariah, Red Witches). So as it stands now there's a lot of things that are not good enough to justify their existence over other already present options.
It gets a recommendation, but also I wish we'd just had “Crabman of Death” which would have received a two thumbs up and a “must buy” stamp.