A Straight Line: How MJF and Mistico Proved Simplicity Can Deliver a Match of the Year (Patreon)
Content
The shortest distance between two points is a straight line.
One common and consistent theme throughout my writings and audio is: wrestling is simple; stop inventing ways to make it harder.
Somewhere along the line, we all decided that pro wrestling stories needed to be complex, they needed to be thorough, they needed twists, turns, and peeks behind the curtain, and long-drawn-out explanations that can only be revealed to the audience through lengthy in-ring promos or cinematic video packages.
And yet on Friday, one of the best matches of 2025 (Mistico vs. MJF) occurred with the simplest and most basic of stories.
The basis of thousands of pro wrestling stories since the sport's inception was the same: playing to a raucous, sold-out crowd in Arena Mexico, living and dying on every pinfall and submission attempt.
On Friday in Arena Mexico, the American-born MJF entered the ring with patriotic music, donning the red, white, and blue, with his Spanish-speaking mouthpiece, Jon Cruz, donning an Abraham Lincoln-style tophat. It was as over-the-top and ridiculous as you could imagine. Not a first for MJF, he's done this same over-the-top American gimmick several times in his career in Mexico, in England, and even in America (AEW All Out 2020). It's a timeless premise: don another nation's colors in enemy territory. You can call it "basic" or "baby's first heel" or whatever you want to say... it fucking works. Whether it was wrestling nazi's waving the German flag before getting destroyed by the all-American babyface or various Hawaiian men being forced to pretend to be Japanese or wrestling Soviets, time and time again, year after year, it works. The entire basis of Japanese pro wrestling for decades was foreign, usually American, invaders losing to native Japanese wrestlers. It's not as usable in American pro wrestling anymore, as most American fans seem less keen on booing foreign nations, but it still works quite well elsewhere, especially in Mexico. That's why MJF has gone to that well so often in his Arena Mexico stops. It's a built-in, immediate way for the fans—ones that popped huge when he debuted in the building in 2024 against Templario—to understand he's the bad guy.
After MJF entered, next up was pro wrestling's biggest and most consistent draw: Mistico.
Now, Mistico ALWAYS gets a big pop in Arena Mexico, but this one had some extra stakes and juice to it. There are big Mistco pops, and there was this crowd reaction on Friday.
In June at AEWxCMLL Grand Slam Mexico, Mistico defeated MJF by DQ. It was an unfulfilling finish on purpose. Mistico wanted and needed his revenge. In July, the two men crossed paths during the Casino Gauntlet match at AEW All In, but nothing was settled. Mistico wanted MJF one more time, on his terms, in his building: Arena Mexico.
A lot of speculation in the buildup to the match was that we'd get a hair vs. mask match with MJF putting his, uh, newly-fully-healthy hair on the line against Mistico's mask. Unfortunately, MJF didn't want to part with the luxurious locks, so instead, we went with the CMLL World Light Heavyweight Title. MJF had won the title in August, defeating Averno in Arena Mexico.
The title is relatively meaningless to Mistico (and CMLL), but it provided at least a modicum of stakes to the match. Though, really, it didn't need it. The simplicity of just seeing Mistico, their hometown hero, in their building taking on the foreign invader heel was probably enough.
But these two and this moment didn't need probably enough.
This night was the celebration of CMLL's 92nd year in business, so things had to be ratcheted up a notch, but did so without losing sight of wrestling's pure simplicity.
In the early portion of the match, MJF ripped Mistico's mask—a common practice done by rudos (heels) in Mexico. Simple, but effective, as it's seen as the ultimate sign of disrespect. Then MJF threw Mistco and his ripped mask to the outside, grabbed his head, and threw it right into the corner post. Mistico didn't get his hand up or protect himself from the throw, forehead right into the steel post.
Mistico came up a bloody mess; the Arena Mexico fans gasped. Blood in wrestling is, of course, a widespread practice across the world. But, it's one that almost always worked to raise the stakes or feeling in a match. It's a delicate balance, though. If you have blood too often in your matches (remember the infamous Jon Moxley run) or too frequently in a single show, it loses its impact.
If you save blood for the right time and the right moment, it can be something special and take a match up a few rungs.
This blood was particularly notable since Arena Mexico has a ban on blood.
The origins and background of which are unclear to me, but it's only been broken a few times recently, and usually with some harsh penalties. Mistico did his best to make it appear that he was busted open hardway, but it was clear when MJF threw him to the mat that he had bladed. Who cares how the sausage is made, though? When Mistico got up from the post attack and blood was pouring down his head, and I do mean pouring, the crowd was electric.
Did Mistico, MJF, CMLL, AEW, etc. get the okay from Arena Mexico to do blood in this match? Who knows. Part of me wishes Mistico knew it would work for this moment, knew his power in lucha right now, and his importance to Arena Mexico, and said, "I dare you to punish me."
luchablog had some additional insights into the match and the blood ban workaround. In his mind, the CMLL doctors not rushing out to check on Mistco was a tip-off that everyone involved in the match knew the blood was coming.
No matter who made the call, it was undeniably the right one. The blood, as simple as it was, took this match to another level instantly.
The rest of MJF vs. Mistico was textbook pro wrestling simplicity.
Mistico, a bloody and battered babyface, is fighting from underneath, trying to take out the hated heel MJF.
Time and time again, MJF would pin Mistco, and he'd kick out, each time the crowd coming more and more unglued. Finally, MJF said, to hell with this, and tried to get Mistico counted out. When Mistico slid in just before the bell, the crowd came unglued. Mistico even had trouble getting into the ring with the story that his blood is all over the ropes and all over his hands.
None of the world was out-of-this-world dynamic, none of the spots were things you haven't seen dozens of times, but who cares? Mistico is the clubhouse leader of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Thesz/Flair Wrestler of the Year Award and rarely, if ever, wows you with spectacular moves. He doesn't need to.
For Mistico, it's all about crowd connection. He and the fans are one when he's in the ring, and the most simple of moves still get the loudest reactions because he's doing them.
Finally, at the match's conclusion, Mistico locked in his famed La Mistica submission hold. Traditionally, opponents will tap out almost instantly from the move, assuming that they are locked in, can't get out of it, and it's better to just give up now and save their arm for another day. But MJF bucked the trend and fought it, inching closer and closer to the ropes. The fans, used to seeing people insta-tap, are now losing their minds at the sight of someone fighting through the La Mistica, but Mistico isn't going to let his home fans down, he drags MJF to the middle of the ring, locks in the submission tighter and MJF has no choice but to tap and save himself.
Mistico, with half his face revealed out of his mask, but hard to make out because of the blood, has won. He's returned a CMLL title back to the company but more than anything he's defeated a hated, dickhead American heel and sent him packing surrounded by his people, in his building.
It doesn't get any simpler or better than that.
Mistico knows the importance of simplicity, but I hope this is a nice wakeup call for MJF, too. I often talk about how MJF thinks about wrestling on a level higher than a lot of his peers, but that's not always a positive. Often, MJF OVERTHINKS wrestling and tries to do too much when the most basic, straightforward, and simplest path is often the best.
Again, the shortest distance between two points is a straight line.
Both Joe and I will have more to say about this match and the entire CMLL 92nd Anniversary show on this week's episode of The Flagship.
-Rich