Today, In Bad Wrestling Journalism: Santino Marella & TNA Becoming #2 (Patreon)
Content
Today, in bad wrestling journalism, I present to you a new Fightful.com news article title, "Santino Marella On TNA: Once We Get That TV Deal, We're Number Two. I Know Tony Khan Has Lots Of Money, But The Fans Speak," published by Skylar Russell.
Full disclosure, I've worked with Skylar in the past, and Skylar has a few bylines on Voices of Wrestling. This is not an "attack" on Skylar specifically, but rather an attack on the very nature of how pro wrestling news is presented and released to the world.
The highlight of this news hit is TNA contracted talent Santino Marella speaking with Lucha Libre Online that when/if TNA had a TV deal, they'd be the number two promotion in America.
"The people from TNA in the past are happy for us. Obviously, the current locker room is ecstatic about the growth. When I came here, it was not like this, I know sometimes we were in Nashville or even Toronto, we had 350 or 500 people. But we believed in ourselves. Now we have the audience size that feels right and we deliver every time. Every time we've had a sold out crowd, we've never not had a good show. We've never wasted an opportunity. Bound For Glory is going to be another one, we're going to capitalize on that audience, we're going to send the message out to the wrestling world, we're here. We're knocking on the door. You better look out because once we get that TV deal, we're number two man. I know Tony Khan has lots of money, I get it, but the fans speak. The fans dictate who's number one, number two, number three, not your bank account. Of course WWE is number one, they're so far ahead that we'll never catch it in my lifetime. Number two is attainable, number two is something we can really do. If we accomplish that, that's humongous."
And look, it's fine for Marella to gas up his current employer amid negotiations for a new TV deal.
It's pro wrestling, it's a pseudo-sport propped up entirely by lies, half-truths, and promotion.
That's what this is.
I won't get into the specifics here, because this conversation has been done to death and is entirely baseless, but it's going to need to be a HELL of a TV deal for TNA to eclipse AEW as the all-important (not important at all) "Number Two." A year ago, AEW agreed to a three-year, $555 million deal with Warner Bros. Discovery.
AEW routinely outdraws TNA at the gate between live TV and PPVs.
AEW is the last pro wrestling company to make a significant dent in the PPV market.
Again, I don't want to engage in that argument here because it's a very weak one.
The problem here isn't what Marella said; it's that his quote is being presented to the audience without context and without pushback.
You can publish the quote, and you can even use the headline, as it makes it clear that Santino is saying TNA is going to be number two. However, the article itself allows you to push back on it and explain how, even with a new TV deal, it's unlikely that TNA will become number two.
But that doesn't happen here. The entire content of the article is:
Lede about Santio saying TNA wants to be number two.
An introductory sentence about TNA trying to land a new TV deal and how a new TV deal would "almost certainly" make the product more accessible to fans worldwide. We actually don't know this at all, but whatever.
But it's this line that really hurts the piece:
"Speaking with Lucha Libre Online for a new interview, Marella spoke on the current status of TNA, saying that the promotion will be number two when they land a television deal."
This is then followed by the quote in full, which I presented above.
And that's it.
The article ends with:
"Fans can check out the current lineup for the September 25 edition of TNA iMPACT! by clicking here. Fightful will have full coverage of the show as it airs."
Nope. That's not going to cut it.
This article needs to be expanded—point blank. When someone claims this, one that is easily disputed, it is your journalistic duty to add context or push back.
Many people believe that news should not include opinions, but it should also be truthful.
It's not an opinion to say that TNA would need a massive TV deal and a complete top-to-bottom turnaround of all their business metrics to pass AEW for "number two."
That's a fact.
Last night, Seattle Mariners star catcher Cal Raleigh hit two home runs to bring his season total to 60. One of these homers was one of the best moonshot home runs you'll ever see, by the way. Even if you aren't a fan of baseball, you need to check this one out.
Anyway, this put Raleigh in rarefied air when it came to Major League single-season home run totals.
Only 10 times in MLB history has a player hit 60 or more home runs in a season, with only Mark McGwire (70 in 1998) and Barry Bonds (73 in 2001) topping 70.
Anyway, if, after yesterday's game, Raleigh told a reporter from The Seattle Times in a post-game scrum by his locker, "I have the most home runs anyone has ever had in a season," nobody would publish that article.
Likely, someone would immediately push back or, at the very least, ask a number of follow-ups to try and figure out what the hell Raleigh is talking about or if he just doesn't know the history of baseball.
It would be a journalistic sin for The Seattle Times to publish an article with the headline:
"Cal Raleigh: I Have The Most Home Runs Anyone Has Ever Had In A Season"
In wrestling, we do it all the time.
We just did!
Worse yet, even if that Cal Raleigh article were published, it would be a complete disgrace not to include additional context.
Sure, you can publish that Raleigh thinks his 60 home runs are the most ever. He did indeed say it, but that doesn't make it accurate.
Any reasonable article about this hypothetical quote would include significantly more context and thorough research.
Hell, maybe Raleigh is making a statement about performance-enhancing drugs in the sport; perhaps he doesn't respect or believe that Aaron Judge's 62 home runs in 2022 count, who knows? Let's find out!
Either way, I'm pretty fucking sure the article would include details about what the actual record is—73—and include some pushback to Raleigh for his incorrect statement—he doesn't even have the most in American League history.
Again, that's not adding your opinion to a news article. It's adding the truth.
We can do that in wrestling journalism, too. We just so often choose not to.
-Rich