Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Persuasion might feel slow to get started, but those first four chapters contain the keys to understanding and appreciating Austen.

You can see Austen's art of the incidental description (Proust, similarly, is a master of the relative clause), negative character description (evoking character by virtue of what's left out), irony, and an all-pervasive sense of mortality. 

Video Timestamps:

  • 0:00 have you felt the pain of persuasion?
  • 2:30 "Nobody can give you advice" (Rilke)
  • 7:30 a daily self-love reflection practice 
  • 16:00 the excellent judgement of Lady Russell
  • 19:00 how to read Austen (and Proust)
  • 24:00 the singularity of suffering 
  • 26:00 what is character?
  • 29:00 social proof 
  • 31:00 "Kellynch Hall was to be let"
  • 41:00 Anne as sailor's wife 
  • 43:00 the binaries of Persuasion

Questions to ponder:

1) How does Austen's introduction of characters compare with other writers? Do you believe her characters? Does she do anything different from, say, Tolstoy or Dostoyevsky?

2) Have you benefitted from good counsel? What about bad counsel? Have you ever been persuaded to do something that was not in your best interests? How did that go?

Of course, let us know any other thoughts that strike you as you read or reread through.

Happy reading!


Files

Previews only

Deep Analysis of Persuasion: The Singularity of Suffering (Ch. I - IV)

0:00 have you felt the pain of persuasion? 2:30 "Nobody can give you advice" (Rilke) 7:30 a daily self-love reflection practice 16:00 the excellent judgement of Lady Russell 19:00 how to read Austen (and Proust) 24:00 the singularity of suffering 26:00 what is character? 29:00 social proof 31:00 "Kellynch Hall was to be let" 41:00 Anne as sailor's wife 43:00 the binaries of Persuasion

Comments

Emma Yap

Thanks for this video! I can definitely relate to a time when I was persuaded to take a certain career path which I knew instinctively was wrong for me - it led to a lot of suppressed unhappiness, and eventually I had to take a painful U-turn and figure out what I wanted to do next. With regards to Persuasion, I actually found the sections about letting out Kellynch Hall a little bit boring. I found my attention drifting. It's only upon a re-read that I can see how much one needs to read between the lines. And with regards to character, I think Lady Russell is interesting. She is well-intentioned and agreeable, but I can't help disliking her just a bit. She lacks self-awareness and is very conformist. I don't like how important rank is to her. Even the 'big' words that Austen uses to describe her - 'benevolent', 'good', 'charitable' - feel a bit like words that society would use to describe her, rather than actually reflecting what that character is truly like. I'm sure that to the eyes of the social world in which she moves, her conduct would meet with a lot of approval, but I think she is very flawed. It's impressive that Austen managed to portray her so fully in such a short space

Matthew Long

Well Ben, I joined the HLBC a couple years after the fact so I am doing some catch up on past reads and I am so glad I selected this book as my first dive into the club. Having never read Austen I really had no idea what to think or expect or than that I was supposed to read her according to all the "Must Read" lists out there. I absolutely love this book so far. I completed ch. 4 and am following along with the lecture series as well. Thanks for the wonderful insights and tangents that come with the lectures. I never expected Austen to be so funny. To the best of my knowledge I am thoroughly American but I seem to have a very English sense of humor. Her subtle inferences are amazing. I am particularly enamored with her use of the relative clause. There are some real rabbit holes to go exploring there. I am finding the characters to be quite intriguing. Sir Walter is a complete ass! But I can't help but laugh every time he speaks as everything he says is so over the top. There are definite themes of anxiety, pain, frustration. Looking forward to the next few chapters.