Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Another big one crossed off my cinephile list! This was different than what I expected….Did I love it? You'll have to find out. Did I appreciate it? Yes, but probably not as much as I should have or as much as a filmmaker would?

⚡Auto-Sync (Prime Video) | 🎬 Requests | 🍿 Pick-A-Flick | ▶️ YouTube | 💻 Watch/Download

Files

Citizen Kane (1941) | Full Reaction - Popcorn In Bed

Watch the full reaction to Citizen Kane on Popcorn In Bed.

Comments

UCOOLJULES

I had to watch this many decades ago as part of my degree. I hated it. Orson Welles may be a superb actor, but personally I feel his best work was advertising sherry. I'll vote it up and leave a comment for the algorithm, but I'm leaving my true thoughts here.

Rob Nichols

Orson Welles was well known for directing theater and radio dramas, his radio adaptation of War Of The Worlds was famous for creating nation wide panic among people who believed the Martian invasion was real. Citizen Kane was his first movie and he went in not really knowing what he was doing. The film wasn't well received at the time but is now considered among the best ever made. Check out the HBO movie RKO 281, it's a docudrama about the making of the film, and the real person who Kane was based on.

Cole Jennett

I remember being ambitious and deciding to watch this about 10 years ago. I watched the first 45 minutes and realized I didn’t care about being a cinephile, lol.

Above Average Dave

This was Wells' fictionalized account of the life of William Randolph Hearst, who would've been more recent in the memories of audiences in 1941. He was the first big American media mogul, had a large hand in starting the Spanish-American War and also flirted with running for U.S. President. There were wives, mistresses and lots of rich man's toys, but he remained restless and, ultimately from all accounts, quite lonely. Apparently, however, he threw tremendous, semi-intimate dinner parties (10 to 12 people) that were fun and he was an insightful host and great conversationalist. At least, according to Cary Grant, who was the guest at one.

John A

I think anyone under 60 or so raving about this movie just wants people to think they're a cinephile. It was a masterpiece in its time, but there's probably a million movies I'd rather watch

Cole Jennett

I’m fine with Orson Welles being famous for me because he was the voice of Unicron.

Walter Crockett

Hey Cassie so glad you watched this. First time i saw this was i film school. I do recommend the movie RKO 281. It’s about the making of Citizen Kane. It stars Liev Schreiber as Orson Wells. I just added it to my top 10 priorities on the request site.

Ike

Like CoolJules, I just can’t watch this again. I think perhaps there is a reputable minority of people (that’s me being generous) that work BEHIND the camera that have a great appreciation for this film. But like you, I believe a majority of us are scratching our heads like, “what is the big deal?” I can see my mother’s eyes roll into the back of her head when my father used to brag at family reunions that he “saw Leonardo da Vinci’s Mona Lisa once” [when he was stationed in Europe]. The answers to follow up questions after that were met by shrugs. This film, like the Mona Lisa, seems important to only select few. I am sadly not one of them, and I suspect most people are the same.

JL_83

Citizen Kernel time!

Just Plain Bob

Citizen Kane is not, IMO, the greatest film ever made. But it is a GREAT film, starring and directed by one of the all time great filmmakers, Orson Welles. All the nonsense about needing to have worked in the film industry or take film classes to appreciate it is just that: nonsense. I first saw it in my early twenties with my wife. We both loved it and neither of us has ever been in the movie industry or taken a film class. Listening to Cassie’s critique at the end, what I heard is a litany of the usual complaints of millennials that don’t like a particular movie - “it was sad”, “I wanted them to show him doing this or that”, “they didn’t explain this thing or that thing and I don’t know what to think about it”, etc. Well, that’s part of what makes the film so great. It’s the kind of movie that sparks conversations that go far deeper than, “the CGI was so good” or “the lead characters were so cute.”

Tyler Foster

It's not really "cinephile" stuff to understand why this movie is important (unrelated to whether you like it or not). Think of Nosferatu. That is a traditional silent movie: long scenes in single static shots, without much camera movement. Kane uses filmmaking techniques we would now consider completely matter-of-fact, but Welles invented many of them, more or less. There is an early shot that starts looking at Kane outside playing in the snow, which then pulls out to reveal the camera is on the other side of a window, with the family inside talking to an attorney (if I'm remembering correctly). This is a stylish but also fairly straightforward type of shot in modern cinema, but you have to imagine that directors before then may not have ever thought to shoot it that way. It would've been a fixed wide shot of the kid outside, and then cut to a wide shot of the people in the house, with no movement of the camera or the idea of shooting in a way that would be revealed as the view through a window. The whole notion of framing an image for purely artistic effect rather than clarity, although I am probably paraphrasing or simplifying, this is to some degree what Welles pioneered.

Tyler Foster

In any case, I don't think it's necessarily important to care about Kane as a film if you don't enjoy it, but I do think that even if it doesn't change your opinion of the film, it's easier to understand why it was important than it might seem.

Ike

That’s kind of a weird, almost rude question.

Mike Lemon

So... how many times did you fall asleep watching it?

Damien beatty

I am under 60 and I love this film to me it is still in my top five films of all time. No American film has been so influential to every film afterward as "Citizen Kane" and to think that it was created by a 24 year old. Orson Wells was a genius in every aspect of the entertainment business. He created what many consider the greatest shakespeare ever brought to the stage at 21. He did the voices of many of most iconic voices to radio such as "The Shadow" and did the most well known radio show of all time H.G. Wells "War of the Worlds" which caused havoc in the U.S. This was done when he was a tender 23 years of age. He also made two other films that were taken out of his hands "The Magnificent Ambersons" and "Journey Into Fear" which before they were taken from his control and edited into oblivion are considered even better than Citizen Kane. One aspect he doesn't get enough credit for in this film is his acting a 24 year old playing a man in his 70's absolutely fantastic and worth every bit of praise it has ever received and more. But apparently according to John A I am just a cinephile, and not someone who knows art when they see it. I recommend to you Cassie that you look at biographies of him and there was one done by PBS ( American Experience) about Orson and the newpaper tycoon who was one of the references for this film William Randolf Hearst.

Steve Mercier

So, from a purely technical standpoint, I've always felt that this movie earned its place in Hollywood (and general filmmaking) legend: the bold angles, shadows, camera moves, and pacing, plus the non-linear storytelling. The acting here is also superb, especially from Orson Welles himself. But from a purely story standpoint, the movie's just about a self-made man who hasn't quite gotten over his favorite childhood toy and the actual joy and happiness it brought him, as opposed to all of his larger than life pursuits. It's always felt a little lackluster to me on the non-technical level, which is a big one. Other movies largely regarded as the best of the best, such as The Godfather or Vertigo, typically marry the two--the technical, and the non-technical--capturing our minds as well as our imaginations and our hearts. Then again, my own personal favorite movie list doesn't really match up with that of the American Film Institute, or similar organizations; and, is likewise in constant flux as I grow older, or sometimes just in keeping with my particular mood. I would imagine this would be the same for most people. It's certainly cool that you watched this, but I wouldn't put too much stock in someone else's list. On that note, it would be cool to see your list of top 5 or 10 movies, regardless of whether you watched them on your channel or in your own time (huh...time...like About Time, maybe?). Not to be nitpicky or judgemental about it or anything (hopefully), but just to see where you sit on things. Just a thought.

Choof

The technical aspect alone makes this a masterpiece and you can see the influence in movies like There Will Be Blood and The Social Network

Old As Dirt Bert

I probably saw this for the first time in the '60s. Growing up in Chicago, I was accustomed to the chicanery of both politics and the press. I was aware of the Hearst Castle because of Life magazine's coverage in the late '50s, and from TV stories when the estate turned it over to the State of California. It wasn't much of a stretch to figure out the models for this movie. In '41, such an assault on the Fourth Estate and politics was unprecedented. To do so creating new film techniques while making his first film showed how clever 26 year old Orson Welles really was. My favorite part of seeing it was that it encouraged me to see The Third Man from '49 so I could get more of the Mercury players featured in both films.

Jacob Wagner

Is this a great film in terms of filmmaking and historical relevance? Yes. Would I put it on as a piece of entertainment on a Sunday afternoon? No. Anyone claiming in 2026 this is their all time favorite film ever is intentionally trying to be a pretentious snob

Stick Figure Studios

That is an incredibly presumptious assertion. I'm 50 and it's one of my favorite films. Seen it a dozen times and it just gets better with each viewing.

Stick Figure Studios

RKO 281 is cracking good yarn. Much better than David Fincher's MANK.

fargoboyle .

I suppose those wanting to see a good Orson Welles film should give The Third Man a watch.

Stick Figure Studios

English poet Robert Graves once said, "The remarkable thing about Shakespeare is that he is really very good - in spite of all the people who say he is very good." There is no quote that I think better articulates the phenomenon of Orson Welles' masterwork CITIZEN KANE, a film that has been both blessed and cursed by it's decades-long reputation as "the greatest film ever made." This characterization has kept it simultaneously revered and reviled for over 50 years where it has sat at the #1 spot of the "Sight & Sound Top 10" list (until it was rather notoriously supplanted by Hitchcock's VERTIGO) earning both cheers of acclaim from believers and sideways glances from skeptics. Full disclosure: I am in the former category. Welles is one of my favorite filmmakers and I find KANE to be, if not necessarily his best work (several other titles -- including TOUCH OF EVIL, CHIMES AT MIDNIGHT and F FOR FAKE -- compete for that honor), certainly his most ubiquitous and the purest expression of his artistic vision. It is the kind of film that grows richer, deeper and more satisfying the more one revisits it and the more knowledgeable about the film and film history one is (for anyone who is interested,.I recommend Harlan Lebo's excellent book CITIZEN KANE, A FILMMAKERS JOURNEY). What Welles accomplished was truly extraordinary and yet I have noticed a worrying trend among younger moviegoers (with more iconoclastic tendencies) to approach KANE -- as they do with a lot of old classics -- purely from a contemporary perspective and criticize it for basically not being "the greatest film they've ever seen." Recency bias tends to make it more difficult to see the film the way audiences in 1941 saw it, especially since it's innovations have become old hat now (I'm reminded of that joke about the guy who sees HAMLET for the first time and hates it because he found "every other line to be a cliche"). While it is certainly possible to like KANE immediately -- I did; I first saw it as an adolescent in a community film class run by a fellow movie-loving friend of mine and I didn't realize until about halfway through that I had unknowingly seen it parodied in a TINY TOONS episode prior to that; because of that I figured out what "Rosebud" is-- it is not necessarily an easy film to respect/appreciate right away. One often has to sort of "grow into it." A single watch is never enough. A cold viewing with little education or background information about the historical, sociopolitical and creative context in which it was produced can yield very limited results (invariably,.one has to learn the name "William Randolph Hearst"). So many amateur film critics online today think that just because they have seen it and have an opinion on it, that that is sufficient. It is not. Everyone has opinions and those opinions are equally "valid" insofar as they reflect the thinking of the individuals who hold them, but not all opinions are equally informed. "I may not know art but I know what I like" is just not a god enough excuse when it comes to some works and KANE is one of those. It eserves better than that. The more one knows about the history, language and evolution of film, the more legitimate criticisms (because there are legitimate criticisms one can make toward it) one can have of KANE, but "boring" and "overrated" are not legitimate criticisms. Is KANE the "greatest film ever made?" To me, that's like saying, "Is Shakespeare the greatest writer who ever lived?" Perhaps it is, but these are the wrong questions to be asking. Appreciating art is not about deciding who is king of the hill, either upholding a conventional status quo or playing contrarian in taking down sacred cows. It's about recognizing the aesthetic, cultural and even spiritual value of any given piece. These works/artists are (in spite of their hype) still very good and as such are worth watching, analyzing, debating, etc. Whether or not KANE really deserves its alleged place in film history -- whether it truly is *the* greatest film ever made, *one of* the greatest or merely the product of a half a century of propaganda-- is ultimately irrelevant. CITIZEN KANE is a great film and as long as the conversation about the artistic merits of cinema continues, it will always have its place. At the very least, it is a worthy contender for that title. I can't wait to watch this reaction. I've been pushing for it for a long time (it was one of the five films I submitted when I won trivia night) and it's one of my favorite films. I've seen it at least a dozen times and it's just gets better and better. Regardless of what you thought of it (and so hope you liked it), I am so glad you finally watched it. It's like a rite of passage for every serious film buff. If nothing else, it's introduced you to to the monumental personality that was Orson Welles, one of the most discussed, controversial, admired and loathed figures in film history. Here's hoping you get to experience more of his unique brand of cinema.

Stick Figure Studios

I first knew him as Lew "Prepare the standard rich and famous contract" in the penultimate scene of the original 1979 MUPPET MOVIE Even though I didn't yet know who he was, I could tell even as a child that he was important because the movie treats him very reverently.

Stick Figure Studios

Thats a great film (even if Orson Welles didn't direct it). Another great film he directed is MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONS and TOUCH OF EVIL

Stick Figure Studios

Also ME & ORSON WELLES is good. Christian McKay is fantastic as Welles.

Stick Figure Studios

The more one knows about it, the easier it is to appreciate.

Keith Brown

I am from that generation that loves this movie and I do love this classic. I know that the top twenty list of greatest movies does not always match up with everyone's list. I sometimes will try and suggest people watch Westerns from the 30's,40's or 50's and their only idea of westerns are just the ones with Clint Eastwood or maybe Kevin Costner. The subject of movies will come up and their history starts with "The Matrix" , "Stars Wars" for some is ancient history. Movies , will always have so many choices and not everyone will love the ones the way you hope they will.

Jacob Wagner

If its their favorite film I rather not know em..they're probably a joy at parties

Richard Maurer

I would say there are certainly people who pretend that this is their favorite film just to be pretentious. But I’m just as certain there are people who love this film, even to the point of it being their favorite. Trying to say that no one loves this film is just as ridiculous as saying everyone should love this film.

Jacob Wagner

Don't get me wrong I actually "like" the film and respect it..but if someone is genuinely like "omg thats my favorite movie ever I watch it every weekend and attend every screening" I just imagine some hipster at the local coffee house sniffing their flatulence and calling it seasoned aroma..it's more like I'm against the people that love it than the film itself

Simmeland

You’re essentially saying, “I don't understand how this could be someone's favorite, therefore they're lying about their taste.” That's a pretty narrow view of what people can actually enjoy in movies.

Jacob Wagner

Call me a cynic and a realist

Patrick Flanagan

I can understand not particularly caring for this movie, it IS of its time and even though I think it's great I admit that nothing is above critique...but the number of people casually exposing their brainrot when this movie is mentioned always astonishes me. "YES he changed cinema for all time before he turned 30 but I prefer the time he voiced a Transformer or when he did those old wine commercials which I probably never even saw personally but have always heard people mention when they want to dismiss Welles as beneath their notice" - what? Why waste your time and ours typing something so ridiculous, it's a failure at sarcasm and a failure at a sincere opinion.

Patrick Flanagan

"I am against this movie because people I made up in my mind love it too much and I can't stand them"

Patrick Flanagan

Well you didn't really say anything except to imply that since the movie didn't speak to you then anyone who says it spoke to them are weirdos who aren't worth talking to

Patrick Flanagan

So there's no possibility that someone could simply have watched it and enjoyed it? It's all pretense and posturing? Why?

Patrick Flanagan

...well this comments section has been a depressing read, back to lurk mode

Ike

Now you’re putting words in my mouth. I said a “reputable minority” appreciate the film and a select few really do but sadly I am not one of them. My choice brother. I disparaged no one except my own father. But this conversation - right here, right now - is why I stay away from this GD film. Thanks for making it awkward, Patrick. 😁

Jacob Wagner

Made up in my mind? I went to film school, I socialized with the Truffaut Bergman Fellini idolizing fart sniffing windbags. I did my time screening films in a local art house...trust me those people are the phoniest , pretentious, pseudo intellectual fancy wine glass pinkies out nerds I can live without...anytime I watch the Criterion closet I wanna vomit from the sanctimonious horseshit they spew...Gas Pump Girls (1979) now thats a movie with heart and soul!

Mike Lemon

Not everything can be as great as Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990), sometimes you have to slog through something like Citizen Kane. :-)

Just Plain Bob

You got me on Gas Pump Girls. Probably Kirsten Baker’s best film not named Friday the 13th pt 2.

Stick Figure Studios

As Mister Rogers said, "look for the helpers" and there are still plenty of them here.

Jacob Wagner

She was so good in it! Shame didn't do much else other than F13 2...

Elliot Nesterman

There are two films that I saw in my youth which have stuck with me and which, I suppose, have informed my taste in cinema: Lawrence of Arabia, which I saw first run when I was nine or so, and Citizen Kane, which I saw when I was eleven.

bgb1975 (Brian)

Never seen it. Not that interested in the movie, but I'll watch the PiB edit for sure.

Carol_White

Is this the most bitter civil war since Tim Burton's Batman? If you want real drama, don't watch Citizen Kane, just read the comments.

Mannygogou

my friend's "best movie" is Citizen Kane. I be like... uh, I'd rather watch Singin' In The Rain again... I mean, "gotta dance..." !! Some reviewer says of Citizen Kane, it keeps you at arm's length. I like the dude though, Orson Wells, what a guy. I also like the soviet film Solaris.

Clay F

First watch. I liked it. Rosebud is a nice touch. Noticed there wasn't much of his son. Agree Charles has some of same vibe as Howard Hughes. "What would you have liked to have been?" "Everything you hate."

Mannygogou

This I will say of Orson Welles... it was badass when he was broadcasting a live band playing ballroom music and then interrupting it with "live" news segments about strange landings at Grovers Mill... of strange meteors spawning tripod machines...!

Gray

I enjoyed this way more than I was expecting, I thought it was going to be a bit of slog like (for me) GWTW was. I do blame the first 10 seasons of The Simpsons for spoiling the whole plot though 😂.

Christian Becker

I'm really more curious about your reaction to the movie than about the film itself. I've seen it once or twice and may have been too young to understand the brilliance of the moviemaking. This one sits firmly in the category "must have seen once," and that is enough for me ;-)

Mannygogou

in relationship power dynamics, it's good to feel the "one-down" position sometimes for those who are always "one-up"

Mannygogou

a bit of a spoiler there perhaps

WestBound

Finally watched the most overrated movie of all time

Clay F

The PBS American Experience documentary about the 1938 radio broadcast by Orson Welles (then age 23) is great imo. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/films/worlds/ War of the Worlds [We interrupt our program to bring you a special bulletin...] Peter Bogdanovich (in the documentary and close confidant in a decades-long friendship with Welles) directed "The Last Picture Show" (1971) - a post-1960 black and white movie I like. Bogdanovich and his mentor Orson Welles agreed that black and white would look better and enhance the film's gritty feel. Wikipedia: “After discussing the proposed film with Orson Welles, his houseguest at the time, Bogdanovich agreed with him that shooting the film in black and white would work aesthetically, which by then was an unusual choice.” The Last Picture Show stars Jeff Bridges, Cybil Shepherd, Ellen Burstyn, Cloris Leachman, Ben Johnson.

Clay F

Thanks Manny. I edited to cut out.

KingofCoo1

Holy crap! If anything seeing it again made me realize how incredible that movie is again. Besides the filmmaking, just the acting alone, is insane! That's probably the most convincing I've ever seen actors portray young and older versions of themselves. And Cassie actually got the meaning of Rosebud at the end! The cherry on top!

Choof

What an incredibly dumb strawman argument

John A

How dare people have an opinion that doesn't align with yours! this movie is the definition of overrated and no one cares that you can't handle other opinions

John A

He's not narrow minded he's right. The only jackass is the one throwing a childish fit because people don't like something you like. Grow up

Myles Away

Oh, look, there's the cane from Citizen Kane!" //// "Wait a minute... there was no cane in Citizen Kane!"

Patrick Flanagan

It's like you were so eager to argue with someone that your eyes glazed over the very first sentence I typed.

Ike

Imagine that? Some folks go through every comment that doesn’t align with theirs and call it insufferable. They could have just written a persuasive argument on why THEY liked it and perhaps changed some minds. Patrick.

Shad Kanyak

The Roger Ebert commentary helps. Turns the movie into a film school. Citizen Kane was way ahead of its time. New techniques done so well you don’t really see how until it’s pointed out.

Mojo One Thousand

Due to its place in cinema history, this got "The Simpsons" treatment, but it was a whole episode compared with others that may have only got shorter "Tree house of horror" format. Although I was aware of "Citizen Kane" when I saw the episode when it first aired, it did basically give away the story, so it did make me put off seeing it. And, yhis maked me think again that Cassie should react to "The Simpsons" content that parodies movies she has seen. I am also very much of the generation that was first introduced to Orsen Welles through I think his last (or close to last work) voicing "Unicron" in "The Transformers: The Movie", although I do remember for some reason learning about "War of the Worlds", the radio play in school. "The Transformers: The movie" recently come back in my thoughts because of the passing of Peter Cullen who was the iconic voice of "Optimus Prime"

Nick Hewett

This is only the 3rd time I've seen this and it flew by, well the first bit with the newsreels was a little slow but once the great B&W cinematography kicked in I was hooked and I think you were too Cass. Orson was great as usual but I really liked Mr. Bernstein and Leland too (old Leland was funny). Glad you watched this now and not 5 years ago, I think you would've fallen asleep lol. You've punched your cinephile card with this one, well done. More classics please.

K, Zachary

In college film class. We compared and contrasted "Rosebud" episode from the Simpsons and Citizen Kane. Professor argued that "Rosebud" was the the best episode of The Simpsons ever. I argued that "Last Train To Springfield" is widely known as the best episode of The Simpsons ever. However "Rosebud" comes in close second.

Tim Heron

That last plot twist is one of the great dramatic ironies of all time. As his debut film, Orson Welles was given an unprecedented degree of creative freedom for a first-time filmmaker; he was allowed to make the movie he wanted to make, with little to no studio interference, he was allowed to hire the cast and crew he wanted, and he had final cut privilege.

K, Zachary

Here is a piece of movie fluff for you **Orson Welles was in 12+1 or 13 Chairs with Sharon Tate (her last movie) It seems Sharon used to talk to her baby in private the crew thought she was talking to herself however she was talking to her baby as if he was already born making jokes about Orson Welles. Once they heard her say to her baby " You can be fat like Orson Welles is my friend but only if your talented like him Otherwise, you won't eat much" Now people think she was fat shaming him however this was 1969 there was no such thing as fat shaming. Sharon had a very wicked sense of humor even Steve McQueen said that about her. The whole reason Sharon signed on to do the picture was to work with Welles She always spoke to her baby in the masculine she was 100% convinced he was a boy recalls the director. **Source: https://www.instagram.com/p/C3-540_P05r/?stkn=MWRqYTh2eTJvaXBscA== 12+1 (13 Chairs) is extremely hard to find but we bought it on Amazon streaming. It's pretty famous in Italy.

Brian Lowery

It’s a movie that should be appreciated for the precedent it set in terms of filmmaker autonomy. Without Citizen Kane, there would be no film noir movement in Hollywood, no 60’s Indie revolution, and no 90’s indie resurgence. It would basically just be what we have now, a bunch of cinematic blockbusters with no real heart and soul. That being said, it’s a mid movie at best. The story is kinda boring and the acting is atrocious.