Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Hallllllloooowwwweeennnn Poll

  • 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016) 151
  • Split (2017) 219
  • Van Helsing (2004) 146
  • They Live (1988) 189
  • Friday the 13th (1980) 242
  • 2026-09-23
  • —2026-09-26
  • 947 votes
{'title': 'Hallllllloooowwwweeennnn Poll ', 'choices': [{'text': '10 Cloverfield Lane (2016)', 'votes': 151}, {'text': 'Split (2017)', 'votes': 219}, {'text': 'Van Helsing (2004)', 'votes': 146}, {'text': 'They Live (1988)', 'votes': 189}, {'text': 'Friday the 13th (1980)', 'votes': 242}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 26, 5, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 23, 21, 33, 47, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 947}

Content

Ok just to get us started, dipping our toes in the metaphorical halloween movies black pond of dread....

These are some of the movies that were almost winners or did well on previous polls! Lets Pick the first one of the season (besides the Blob)

Ps-Extra Butter tonight at 6:30pm MST we are watching the bloooobbbbbb. I'll post a seperate announcement in a second

Pss-I have 5 locked in movies I am watching this year and will be polling the rest! Coming Soon!

Comments

Jimmy Stewart

I sure hope Abbott and Costello meet Frankestein is locked in, crossing fingers!

KyloJames

Van Helsing!! What a fun rewatch that would be.

LukeG84

Please, please, please let SPLIT win this poll! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 I’m never going to win PAF so the only way Cassie is ever going to complete this trilogy is if Split wins a poll! Please let it be now!

Blake Evans

The only correct choice on this list is Split. For James McAvoys impeccable performance alone! But 10 Cloverfield Lane was also a surprising experience.

Geoff S.

Sounds great! Hope you're feeling better. Tonight will be fun!

Alex Gorell

I really hope you watch Van Helsing this year. It’s a fun campy movie.

Maria Soberanis

She'd love Val Helsing. Just a fun watch

Miguel Tapia

Hereditary should be on this list

MrKsummer7

It's not October without Night of the Living Dead (1968). Sure like to see it on the locked in movie list.

WestBound

If split doesn't win ....

JPDotCom23

I’ll watch ‘They Live’ again if it wins because it’s John Carpenter but it’s not really a horror movie

Vlad D

I vote They Live. But it really isn't a horror movie though

Robert Jewell

Hmm. Hard to choose.3 good films. 2 stinkers. Not sure why people suggest Friday the 13th. Is it nostalgia for the time period? I mean it's not a good movie. I am struggling with other 3 for Halloween atmosphere movies. To me a Halloween movie either takes place in the autumn or has a gothic atmosphere or has a classic I wanna be that monster on Halloween! feel. That's why the old Universal horror films are so iconic. They Live meets that agenda best I think. 👍 🎃

Story Archer

Split, come on - this is a no-brainer...

Story Archer

You can never go wrong with Kate Beckinsdale in a corset...

Mo

I love Van Helsing but Split would be fun.

Wesley White

Even though I know it's gonna probably lose this poll, but dag nabit🤣 "Van Helsing" better be watched this year lol! "Friday the 13th" was on one of the polls I sent you with my fan letter, that makes me smile😁 I hope you enjoyed reading my fan letter Cassie🥰😇🙏🤗😉✌🌹

John

Speaking as someone who's spent the last twenty-five years writing about the world of horror, if Cassie doesn't watch Friday the 13th, she'll be missing out on a truly iconic horror film.

Russell

Both Friday the 13th and Split are great for this year's Halloween. Carly might be ok with Split but for a classic Carly acceptable choice Forbidden Planet (1956).

JONATHAN REDFERN WILLIAMS

I would love Cassie to watch the classic BBC horror drama GHOSTWATCH (1992) one day but it's not easy to get copyright clearance on YouTube for most BBC shows.... Oh well!

Mike Corrao

Hopefully The Craft will be in a poll soon. Cassie, I guarantee you will love it. I’m sad though, I’m going to miss my viewing of The Blob. I’ll still be at work 😪

Brian Wood

It would be too much. It would be the shining all over again. Haha

shaneth138

So I know that you had a super scary movie (assuming it was Hereditary 😆) that you were planning to watch last year but were feeling overwhelmed with all of the scary stuff before that. Maybe you should watch that movie towards the beginning of the season instead just so you’re not too burned out by the end of October. Just throwing it out there! As a horror movie fan I am excited for whatever you watch this season!

Budsfan67

I like all of these movies

Brian Wood

I'm torn between Van Helsing and Friday the 13th. As much as I love Van Helsing, she needs to complete the slasher trilogy of the bronze age of Halloween, Friday the 13th, and A Nightmare on Elm Street. Hope you're feeling better Cassie.

Clarence Newman

Jack Nicholson hasn't creeped Cassie out for a while, so I suggest Wolf (1994) for the next poll. Also stars Elvira Hancock and Raymond Reddington.

Popcorn In Bed

great idea, and yes, that is my plan-it wasn't Hereditary though. I don't know if I could ever do that one

Clay F

My top 3 choices are: -Split (2017) -10 Cloverfield Lane (2016) -They Live (1988) I voted Split.

Elliot Nesterman

I submitted some suggestions for "Spooky but not too Spooky" last month. For psychological horror I'll suggest: Rosemary's Baby (1968) dir. Roman Polanski, starring Mia Farrow, John Cassavetes, and Ruth Gordon (who won the Oscar for Best Supporting Actress) Don't Look Now (1973) dir. Nicolas Roeg, starring Julie Christie and Donald Sutherland. Based on a story by Daphne Du Maurier (who also wrote Rebecca) it is a classic of horror and considered one of finest psychological horror films ever made.

JONATHAN REDFERN WILLIAMS

One horror classic that Cassie has never seen: Don't Look Now (1973), directed by Nic Roeg and starring Donald Sutherland and Julie Christie. It was such an amazing experience for Donald Sutherland that he named one of his new born sons after Nic Roeg: Roeg Sutherland! He mentioned this in his BBC Scene By Scene interview!

Rob Nichols

Good one, also stars Michelle Pfeiffer.

ElmSt Reactions

Split is so good, james should won an award for that performance 💚🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

Bill Maurer

Another vote for Abbott and Costello meet Frankenstein !!!!

Clay F

+1 for Rosemary's Baby (1968) Don't Look Now (1973) is on my watchlist.

Shad Kanyak

Feels like every poll needs to be split into pre-internet and post-internet. Always a clear generalization divide.

MrKsummer7

Cassie needs to continue the Eastrail 177 Trilogy. I’m betting James McAvoy will scare the Split out of her!

Joe J

Cassie, another collab with Kat?

Dean Holt

Going for Split, but tbh I don’t mind if Cloverfield or They Live wins. Van Helsing ok but it had the potential to be a great movie had it been done a bit different. Might be in the minority here but I really think the Friday the 13th movie really don’t hold up anymore. Freddy v Jason is a fun film for all the wrong reasons 😂. But I genuinely believed the remake from 2009 & the fan made movies Never Hike Alone 1 & 2 that I think you can still watch free on YouTube. As the best films you can watch as regards to Jason. Movies I hope Cassie watches next month, Blade 2, As I really think it’s so much better than the original. The Conjuring, this really made me jump some many time, plus I think it’s one of the Scariest movies I’ve seen. Doctor Sleep, Better than the Shining imo, it has a great story and Both Ewen McGregor and Rebecca Ferguson were fantastic in it to. Happy Death Day, Ready, Not, Send Help or the Final Girls i think are all good Horror comedy’s Last Night in Soho, Red Dragon Abigail, Fright Night or From Dusk till Dawn. Are all good scary but not too scary options

Matt

Widows Bay for a Halloween series 🙏

Johnny

I think The Exorcist needs to be on this poll!

Annie519

I know!!! She needs to watch it just for James McAvoy’s performance!! Come on guys, let’s see it win!!

Mark Vaderr

But Cassie has not seen Dracula (1931) or The Wolf Man. Those are practically pre-requisites for this movie.

Mark Vaderr

Cassie said that she wants to see the scariest movie she's never seen.

Mark Vaderr

The Craft is a sub-par movie.

Mark Vaderr

Yes, please! You two should watch "Buried"!

Mark Vaderr

"Split" is very good, even if it's not a Halloween movie. Same goes for "10 Cloverfield Lane". "Van Helsing" is a lot of fun. "Friday the 13th" is overrated, and nowhere near as good as "Halloween".

Catherine LW

No means no. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Catherine LW

I’ve never seen any of these so I guess I’ll sit this one out.

Jimmy Stewart

I respectfully disagree, Abbott and Costello are comedies, and this one can be watched without the originals since it's more of a spoof movie, everyone knows who these Halloween characters are without having to watch a movie. Just my two cents.

LukeG84

I know right. She’ll be blown away by his performance. Plus I just know Cassie will love seeing Anya Taylor-Joy in her breakout role.

Aaron Ritchie

As a big horror fan the first Friday the 13th is pretty boring honestly. Split is way more fun.

Paris M

Split would be perfect! Such a creepy and fun movie

Steve Mercier

Not gonna win, but 10 CLOVERFIELD LANE!!!!!

Eddie Perkins

Split and They Live are my first picks, which means Friday the 13th will most likely win.

Joe J

Cassie channeling her 16 year old brain will love it, lol.

Richard Maurer

Man I hope not. That movie is almost as bad as Van Helsing.

Richard Maurer

If they want do a Ft13th movie they should skip to one of the later ones - 3,4, or 6. Not that they’re good but they’re way better than the first one.

Eddie Perkins

I would love to see her play more of the Universal classics. I wouldn't ever pick Friday the 13th. I can think of so many other great ones for this time of year. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1931), The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957), The Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956), Fright Night (1985), Horror of Dracula (1958), Silver Bullet (1985), and Salem's Lot (1979). I'm not even gonna mention The Exorcist—whoops.

Richard Maurer

Thank you, Catherine. I appreciate you sitting out a poll you have no stake in. Wish more people would do that. I always sit out the Rom-Com polls and would sit any musical poll that didn’t have Rocky Horror in it.

Chad Laurence

She's not going to like a gory movie guys lol. Come on...

Eddie Perkins

They are the three best ones up there.

Richard Maurer

Agree with everything except Van Helsing. The only Van Helsing I recognize is the one played by Peter Cushing.

Richard Maurer

I would vote for the best movie in the poll, They Live, but I need to help keep Ft13th from winning, so I voted for Split (luckily it’s a great movie too).

Richard Maurer

The first Ft13th movie is especially bad, not that any of them are really good. Jason is an iconic character, it’s a shame they wasted him in all those bad movies.

Richard Maurer

That movie is boring. They actually made a werewolf boring.

Richard Maurer

I’ve seen much scarier movies than Hereditary. Great movie though.

Robert Jewell

No doubt, Eddie, all those selections are absolutely top-notch Halloween horror movies and I just watched Silver Bullet last week and it's perfect for a Cassie reaction. Of course every thing is mostlybased in polls and sometimes people are moreinterested in watching her squirm than enjoying herself and all the films you mentioned fill that bill. Exceptthe last one. I'm one of the few people I know who detests that film although I've watched several reactions to it to see what other people think. But Horror of Dracula? Yes! In fact Ithink I'll get my copy of that and watch it right now.

Clay F

Fri 13th and especially VH are crap to me, but I will watch the reaction to Fri 13th (apparently going to win). Like you, I voted Split (agree good movie) in an effort to prevent Fri 13th from winning. I am also fine w/They Live and 10 Cloverfield Lane.

Richard Maurer

Eddie, unfortunately that one classic poll is all we’re going to get. Everything else will be 80’s, 90’s, or 00’s. And if they do sneak a pre-80’s movie into a poll it will get buried by anything from the 80’ on .

Richard Maurer

It’s no worse than Nosferatu’24. Edit: by no worse I mean not scarier. They’re both great movies, especially Nosferatu’24. I wouldn’t want anyone to get the wrong idea.

Richard Maurer

Apparently you can, that movie’s awful.

Robert Jewell

Yeah, that keeps happening. It's some kind of resistance to good film history and often a pop sensibility. I wondered even if The Blob everyone selected (I didn't) were thinking of the '80s remake.

Bill W

Worst month of the year for movies.

Richard Maurer

Agree 100% Jimmy. Universal made those movies to wring every last dollar out of their monster properties when the straight horror movies started to tank.

Bill W

I fèel like pt 2 is more iconic than pt.1.

Richard Maurer

I hope they did think it was the 80’s version. All the complaining will be hilarious.

Bill W

Not if most people haven't seen it.

Richard Maurer

Or best. It all depends on what you like.

Paul Stelter

FRIDAY THE 13TH is a classic, but THEY LIVE is even more classic. (Also a lot funnier and thought-provoking)

Joe J

Only the worst if I don't get any scary movies I like.

Chris Thom

Friday the 13th seems inevitable on any channel. Surprised it hasn't been watched yet. A bit on the cheesy side, but it's a seasonal classic.

Chris Thom

I think Carly is pretty determined to sit out all of October from What Lies Beneath on. lol

Chris Thom

None of the Jason movies are particularly great. But the formula and creepy cabin vibes are essential to Halloween.

Apollo838

Van helsing deserves more love…

Robert Jewell

I don't know, Chris. I suppose if we were still all teenagers, but bad movies should only be essential to film historians maybe, but I can think of way better cabin in the woods movies for Halloween.

Mike Lemon

I said last year, and maybe the year before that, the remake would be much better for Cassie. You get the Jason-ness everybody thinks of without having to wade through a bunch of movies for a few good parts of each. Maybe add in His Name Was Jason.

Richard Maurer

You, Me, and the Movies reacted to Rocky Horror Picture Show. I don’t want to spoil the surprise, but one of them hated it. I’m sure anyone who’s watched their reactions can figure out who.

Richard Maurer

Only the worst if movies like Van Helsing win.

Richard Maurer

I’ve never seen the remake (I couldn’t be bothered).

Clarence Newman

Wash thy mouth out. Wolf is THE definitive Wolfman movie outside of Teen Wolf.

Chris Thom

I think of it more as a strange drama then a horror or Halloween movie. I enjoy pretty much anything Mike Nichols. Always some interesting dialogue.

michael d mcgee

You gotta watch "Fright Night" and "Silver Bullet" this year!

Russell

Agreed, it's a great movie.

Russell

She will never watch Exorcist but if she did it would have to be the director's cut.

Russell

I would say Friday the 13th and Halloween are on par for being horror foundations. Halloween extended cut was much better than what was shown in theatres- those extra scenes really helped the movie.

John

While Part 2 is undoubtedly a better movie, that doesn't make it more "iconic." The original Friday the 13th was the prototype for the dominant form of '80s horror, thus earning its status as an icon of the genre.

Lunaea Weatherstone

I would love to have you watch Gaslight. Not the usual Halloween choice, but it's eerie and suspenseful and moody with foggy London nights. Wonderful performances all around, including an 18 year old Angela Lansbury. Ingrid Bergman has never been more beautiful.

Russell

It must be a great feeling for Cassie to know how so many of us want to watch movies with her (and Carly). I remember when her channel was tiny, now... :)

Richard Maurer

The original Halloween is a true classic. The original Ft13th is a waste of time.

Richard Maurer

Clarence, you wouldn’t know a good werewolf movie unless I tell you the title.

Richard Maurer

Chris - like most mainstream directors, Mike Nichols failed to make a good horror movie. Taking a horror staple premise and turning into a strange drama is failing.

Richard Maurer

Ft13th was a cheap rip-off of Halloween. Sean Cunningham even admitted his goal was copy Halloween because it made a lot of money

Larry Darrell

I feel like the first Friday the 13th (1980) was the start of people yelling at the idiots up on the big screen. It just can’t be helped with this one. Some of the sequels do get better, but not all of them.

Larry Darrell

This year is the 50 year anniversary of… The Omen (1976). Would be a shame to miss it… Cassie mentioned at the beginning of the year, she wanted to see her next scariest movie.

My_Cousin_Mose

@Richard isnt Friday the 13th the only true horror movie on the poll? I kind of expected your comment to say how thats the only one even worth considering this month.

Richard Maurer

Mose - There are many sub-genres of horror, and not all fans agree what constitutes a horror movie. Some don’t even consider Kaiju movies horror ( I do, for the record). It basically boils down to I know horror when I see it. The only film I say for certain isn’t horror is Van Helsing, somewhat ironically. I consider it primarily an action film masquerading as horror. But I mainly don’t like bad films - ripoffs of better films, money grab sequels, and especially sub-par US remakes of foreign movies films.

Clay F

I've watched a couple of their reactions but can't figure out who. I am curious.

MacGuffinStuff

I'm so torn between They Live and 10 Cloverfield Lane. Split is also great, not so much into the other two, just not my cups. But I think I have to give the edge to the master, it's always, John Carpenter's "POLL"

Richard Maurer

Reaction Spoiler Alert - well she has a reputation for not liking anything that pushes boundaries. She flat out said the film’s non-conformist sexuality made her uncomfortable. I actually expected this from her. The part that bothered me was when she started looking at her phone. If someone decides to react to a film then they should be watching. Anything else is a cheat.

John

I'm not arguing that it's a better film; it clearly is not. My assertion is that it is the more important film, in the same way that, while a Porterhouse steak is far better than a big Mac, the latter has had a much greater impact on the genre.

Logan England

I agree! My desire for her to see it is what made me stick around in the first place haha

LukeG84

Well at this rate the only chance we’ve got of her seeing it is if she watches the runner-up too. I won’t hold my breath.

Clarence Newman

I know my lycanthropy. I’ve watched Buffy.

Chris Thom

I don't know if it's that scary. Just disturbing. Ari Aster does angst and hopelessness like no other. Beau is Afraid was almost unwatchable.

Chris Thom

She has a pretty rad job. I know it's a lot of work too, but all in all...living the dream.

Richard Maurer

I won’t argue that Jason isn’t a cultural icon because he is. Shame about the movies he appears in. Anyway Michael Myers is very well known too. The two of them, along with Freddy Krueger, are all pretty much equally well known.

Richard Maurer

Yeah, that movie kept losing me, interest-wise, never did finish it.

Richard Maurer

Heard that Cassie’s planning on watching The Ring ‘02 instead Ring ‘98. If Ft13th wins this poll that 2 movies I won’t be watching this Halloween season. I don’t watch bad movies and I don’t watch mediocre (at best) Hollywood remakes of foreign films.

John

Agreed, I love all three franchises. I just think it's time Cassie crossed this one off her list.

Richard Maurer

I wouldn’t mind so if she just skipped to better ones, 3,4, 6.

John

Well, I wouldn't mind it if she skipped #5!

Richard Maurer

First it looks like the (close) second worst movie in this poll, Ft13th, might win this poll, then I hear that Cassie said she’s watching The Ring ‘02 instead of the original Japanese Ring ‘98? That’s 2 reactions I won’t be watching this Halloween season. I hope Split can make a comeback anyway.

Nolofinwe

Come on can we get off the murder slasher sick-o bloodletting -porn. At least Rowdy Roddy Pipers in in this one LOL

Eddie Perkins

You're referring to Friday the 13th, correct?

Eddie Perkins

I will watch it, but it wouldn't be my first pick, nor my 2nd or 3rd.

Joe J

Will we get any wins this October? Last year was good, this year may fizzle. We all have a few favorites we pull for, but my expectations are always low.

Joe J

With her amazing personality and charisma, Cassie's success with the channel was always a foregone conclusion. She's also very attractive, and that always play a factor in on-screen success.

Joe J

I love "They Live", but as others have said, it's not horror.

Eddie Perkins

Split is the only film with a chance to beat Friday the 13th, so everyone should help ensure it wins. Split is so much better.

John Rando

I think all horror fans would say Friday the 13th (1980) is required reading. They Live (1988) is a must see, also funny. Both make for good conversations. I hope either Child’s Play (1988) or Fright Night (1985) are a lock. Gotta love the 80s

Joe J

I like Mrs. Movies, she's pretty feisty. Her and hubby watch some off the grid stuff from time to time. She just got on her phone, that's hilarious. Cassie should have done that with a few movies I can think of, lol.

Dustin Nelson

Technically she needs get to F13th part 3 so we definitely need to start that series

Richard Maurer

I find her close-mindedness to anything out of the norm grating at best. I mostly tune her out and listen to Mr. Movies as he’s got a much better attitude.

David A. Cruz

I will support any chance to get x-files reactions

Joe J

Without Mrs. Movies, nobody would be watching Mr. Movies (haha).

Joe J

I voted for They Live, but it looks to be out of the running. Seems like every reactor gets around to Ft13, now will be Cassie's time.

Richard Maurer

If I was going to recommend any Ft13th movies it would be one of the later ones- 3,4, or 6. She could skip the rest, It’s not like there’s a story line that matters.

Richard Maurer

Yes it definitely is. Have you seen those aliens?

Catherine LW

Haha, Richard, maybe we can bribe each other to vote in polls we sit out.

shaneth138

Aww you could handle it!!

OddThomas

Split is great but I voted Van Helsing because it's the most fun/Cassie type movie

Joe J

Do you watch any solo men reactors Richard? I find them mostly boring. Married couples have more entertaining interplay from what I've seen.

Brett Richey

Friday the 13th is actually a horror movie... unfortunately it's bobbins

Christian Becker

Well, in this poll I have to go with They Live. Van Helsing is a really bad movie, IMHO, but Kate Beckinsale was eye candy enough for me to watch it a couple of times. Watching Split only makes sense if you complete the trilogy with Glass afterwards. So that's a commitment. Concerning Friday the 13th, I think, in contrast to many fellow patrons, that if you watch the first one, you can skip the rest. I'm rather indifferent to 10 Cloverfield Lane. It is a creepy movie, though.

Dean Holt

I actually didn’t mind watching them as a kid and in my teens, but they are really bad and as you’ve said the first one is the worst one. And obviously as it’s the worst one on the list it’s going to win the poll 😂.

John Rando

I think for the lore, Parts 1-3 matter most. I don’t want to give any spoilers here. After that, the movies get… funner?

Richard Maurer

Unfortunately inevitable. Also inevitable - the calls to watch the rest of the series. Hopefully she will ignore those requests.

Richard Maurer

Not liking the Ft13th series of films is weird? Proudly weird then.

Gray

Was hoping some of the other picks would win as I'm not a huge fan of slasher films, they are normally the most boring in the horror genre but i've not seen Friday the 13th so will give it a watch.

Steven Perez

Might as well throw my two cents in. Pulling for you to one day watch DAUGHTERS OF DARKNESS (1971), Cassie. Some classic horror from the 70s.

Geoff S.

The Fog, The Car, The Conjuring are the three that first come to mind.

Richard Maurer

Oddly in their relationship the roles are reversed. He’s the enthusiastic one, meanwhile I often wonder what contribution she’s making, other than staring at screen with a sour look on her face. Honestly I only check out their reactions based on the film they are watching, which thanks to their highest tier patrons are often interesting and rarely reacted too (if ever), I probably would only very rarely watch their reactions otherwise.

Richard Maurer

Sounds like a plan. Vote for Split and next Romance or musical poll let me what you want to vote for. ;-)

Richard Maurer

Don’t agree with order but those are definitely the best 3 in the poll. I’d move They Live to the top, leave the other two in that order.

Richard Maurer

The Fog is great, The Car is good (for a tv movie) and The Conjuring is……a movie, I guess.

Richard Maurer

Don’t expect much and it will likely still disappoint you.

Clay F

My OP is misleading -- I just threw my 3 top choices down in no particular order except to list Split first b/c that is what I voted for. I want others to vote for Split. My order of preference is: 1. 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016) [no real chance to win] 2. They Live (1988) [on my watchlist - read good things but is 80s] 3. Split (2017) [not a huge fan of M. Night Shyamalan but Split is surely good]

Dustin Nelson

If we were to just see one, I would vote for Part 6 or the 2009 remake but we gotta hit the classics

Joe J

The 70s was the golden age of TV horror movies. The Night Stalker, The Night Strangler, The Norliss Tapes, Scream of the Wolf, Trilogy of Terror, Salem's Lot...good times.

Geoff S.

Gargoyles is my absolute favorite from that time.

Clay F

Split closing gap w/Friday 13th. Currently only 2% (18 votes) down. VH dead last. 1. Friday 13th – 233 votes (25%) 2. Split – 215 votes (23%) 3. They Live – 185 votes (20%) 4. 10 Cloverfield Lane – 145 votes (16%) 5. VH – 144 votes (16%)

Dustin Nelson

As someone who knows the genre extremely well Idk if I'd actually count Split as a horror/Halloween, strange to me it made this list 🤔

Rod Reavern

I had to vote for "Friday the 13th" (1980) because it's the closest one to a Halloween movie. Objectively, the greatest Halloween-themed movie is "Trick 'R Treat" (2007). There is no debating this; it is an indisputable fact. The only reason anyone would dare to argue against it is if they haven't seen it and are therefore ignorant of this fact. The reason why many people haven't seen "Trick 'R Treat" is because it didn't get a theatrical release, through no fault of its own. It had an early screening at a film festival in December 2007, which was overwhelmingly positive -- but the movie's distributor, Warner Bros., didn't want competition against the SAW franchise, which it was also distributing, so "Trick R' Treat" wasn't released in October 2008, as it should have been. Oh... and there were a couple of little things dominating people's attention at the time: the 2008 Great Recession and the historic 2008 US Presidential Election. In 2009, I watched "Trick 'R Treat" at the After Dark Film Festival in Toronto -- it was awesome! THE BEST Halloween-themed movie experience of my life! I have watched "Trick 'R Treat" every Halloween ever since -- and at least a dozen more times because it's a top-notch scary movie. Back to 2009: There was ANOTHER Saw movie released in October 2009, so in their infinite incompetence, Warner Bros chose NOT to release "Trick 'R Treat" for Halloween. Instead, it was released Direct-to-DVD in 2009, which is why "Trick 'R Treat" doesn't get the recognition it deserves. I sincerely hope that Cassie reads this and chooses to watch it without relying on a subscriber poll. It's just not going to happen. If you're not going to take my word for it, Cassie, PLEASE contact your friend Kat Watches Horror Movies, whom you've collaborated with multiple times. She watched and reacted to "Trick 'R Treat" (2007) in October 2023. I'm sure she'll give it her recommendation. (BTW Kat's reaction is great -- she dressed up in an orange onesie, like the character Sam. It's definitely worth watching.) "Trick 'R Treat" is ideal for Cassie because it's scary but not too scary.

Richard Maurer

What constitutes a “horror movie” is highly subjective amongst horror fans. Personally I consider Split, 10 Cloverfield Lane and They Live all to be part of the horror genre. I consider Kaiju movies to be part of the horror genre too. What I personally don’t consider to be horror are Psychological Thrillers, which are often mislabeled as Psychological Horror. Movies like Se7en, Silence of the Lambs, The Lighthouse, etc. are not horror movies. All good movies, certainly, but not horror - imo.

Richard Maurer

Come on people, vote for Split. It’s a good film, unlike Ft13th.

Richard Maurer

People here are dreaming if they think Cassie is going to watch all the Friday the 13th movies after the first one. It didn’t happen with the Halloween or A Nightmare on Elm Street franchises (thankfully), and it’s not going to happen with Ft13th either. She only does that with films she likes. At most F13th 2 will get put on a poll and most likely lose.

Richard Maurer

Low voter turnout on this poll. Most likely because the poll choices are pretty weak in terms of popularity

Dustin Nelson

Isnt Split more of a thriller as you define it here?

Brian Lowery

They Live is a sci fi film. And, while Friday the 13th has its place in horror history, Split is a masterclass in acting and storytelling. She’s already seen that 2000 M. Night film, so Split and its sequel need to happen.

Richard Maurer

Except *SPOILER ALERT* one of the main character’s personalities has superpowers which puts the film in the realm of the fantastic. And seeing as he’s a serial killer with superpowers that makes it horror. If he didn’t have a powers it would be a Psychological Thriller - imo.

Joe J

A few good choices here IMO.

Richard Maurer

I’m not saying they are bad movies ( well, 2 are), I’m saying they’re not really that popular - which has nothing to do with how good a film is. Lots of good films are not popular. And lots of bad films are.

Chris Thom

I remember waiting forever for that to come out. And I followed the pre-production and filming too, so it was like 'what is going on with this movie, are they making the Gone With the Wind of Halloween movies?' Assumed they had major problems making it, so was really surprised it turned out so well.

Chris Thom

I kind of started with Scream, so I didn't get all the meta references until later.

RJ MacReady

I'm good with Friday the 13th or They Live.

Richard Maurer

Mac - answer this question for me: were either you or Childs the Thing at the end of the movie? Or was it both of you? Or neither one of you?

michael d mcgee

You should choose all of your horror movies from the '80s. What an era!

WestBound

Wow come on guys the first F13 is terrible

Shehab Dawoud

Friday the 13th is not a great movie, but it is classic, iconic, all that. You can't be getting into horror movies without watching it. So, let's just watch it and get it over with.

Richard Maurer

Well, doesn’t make a difference at this point, it’s getting watched anyway. I won’t bother to watch it, but to anyone who is going to - have fun.

Richard Maurer

Only if she skips the sequels, the 80’s sequels were even more terrible than most sequels.

Shehab Dawoud

I will be having fun with one scene, that's for sure. I'm certain it will be in the jumpscare Hall of Fame.

LukeG84

Can’t believe SPLIT didn’t win another poll. I really hope Cassie puts me out of my misery and decides to watch the runner-up too! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Just Plain Bob

I would love to see reactions to the first four Fridays. But I’m also a realist and you’re 100% correct. She doesn’t like horror movies, is unlikely to enjoy the first one and the others will never win polls.

Richard Maurer

This is another reason I wanted Ft13th 3, 4, or 6 to get watched. At least then she would have seen one of the better Jason ones.

K, Zachary

To be frank and honest with you the only that fits Cassie is Van Helsing or maybe Split. Of the 16,000 movies I have seen. They Live ranks among the worst. 10 Cloverfield Lane I just watched with Kat. Split yeah maybe? Van Helsing she is a big Kate Beckinsale fan that fits her Friday 13th my gf thinks is way too violent. She thinks maybe it won because of the new Crystal Lake series coming out (Oct 8) which is a prequel to the first one. She doesn't know though and she is really interested to see Cassie's reaction I guess we both are. This was a movie I first saw when I was 12. My gf seems to think she would love the movie Send Help. Kat did

Just Plain Bob

It will be interesting to see if she even realizes that Friday the 13th is the Jason Voorhees franchise. One thing I’d like to see is her surprise at realizing he only dons the iconic mask starting midway thru the third movie. Also, given how freaked out she was by Scream, she very well may be freaked out by the first one.

Richard Maurer

Well, if it a good jump-scare I’ll catch it on the poppies.

Joe J

All the best bits will be in the YT edit. With some exceptions, that's why I only rarely watch full-length reactions.

Chris Thom

Yeah that was good. I always forget about that one. Didn't realize until later how similar some of it was to that Wes Craven flick Shocker.

Richard Maurer

The best thing about this poll is that Van Helsing came in last. Hopefully we’ll never see it on a poll again. Awful movie.

Just Plain Bob

Truly awful movie with terrible CGI. It’s like watching Who Framed Roger Rabbit, without the imagination and whimsy.