Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

GENRE POLL:HISTORY

  • The Killing Fields (1984) 119
  • The Iron Claw (2023) 160
  • Malcolm X (1992) 210
  • Apocalypto (2006) 300
  • Hamnet (2025) 67
  • A Night to Remember (1958) 105
  • 2026-11-06
  • —2026-11-09
  • 961 votes
{'title': 'GENRE POLL:HISTORY', 'choices': [{'text': 'The Killing Fields (1984)', 'votes': 119}, {'text': 'The Iron Claw (2023)', 'votes': 160}, {'text': 'Malcolm X (1992)', 'votes': 210}, {'text': 'Apocalypto (2006)', 'votes': 300}, {'text': 'Hamnet (2025)', 'votes': 67}, {'text': 'A Night to Remember (1958)', 'votes': 105}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 9, 6, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 6, 3, 53, 47, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 961}

Content

During the Pick a Flick LIVE we sorted the leaderboard by genres and drew 6 numbers from 1-25, these were the picks for HISTORY!

Comments

Anthony Carlson

The Iron Claw has my vote! One of my favorite wrestling movies!

Edgar Gonzalez

I don't think I've seen any of these besides "Malcom x" 🤔

Terry In the UK

I'm voting for A Night to Remember.... Cameron's Titanic looked amazing, but for a much more realistic movie about the events that night, this is vastly superior.

KyloJames

The Iron Claw ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

WestBound

Apocalypto! Also Nov is native American heritage month

John

No favorites in this crowd... I'll go with the least uninteresting (personally speaking, of course).

Chris Thom

Was Hamnet good? Haven't seen it yet, but I want to.

John Neiberger

The Killing Fields is an incredible movie

Shawn Kildal

I lived in Dallas for most my life. The Von Erichs and WCCW were almost as big as the Dallas Cowboys. The Iron Claw, while it doesn't tell the whole story, gets my vote

Robert da Spruce

I voted for Hamnet. Only because I haven’t seen it

Anthony Carlson

WCCW was also responsible for debuting wrestlers who became huge stars in the WWE. Namely; Stone Cold Steve Austin, Shawn Michaels, and the Undertaker.

Shawn Kildal

The Big Show (known as The One Man Gang), Rick Rude, the Dingo Warrior (later known as the Ultimate Warrior)

Shawn Kildal

I loved the Chris Adams vs Steve Austin (Williams) fights. True classics.

Anthony Carlson

What about that Steve Williams (Austin) vs Punisher (Undertaker) fight?

René Ferland

I agree but it's not gonna win. :-(

Shawn Kildal

I'm going to have to look that up. I don't recall that.

AceofSpades501

Kind of surprised Downfall isn't included in this, because it's been in the top 50 and 100, but I appreciate the variety.

John Neiberger

Nope, sadly. Hardly anyone knows about it any more.

CJ Holden

This is a rough one, because I really don't have a favourite here. Not saying they are bad though. I probably would've put Apocalypto in an Action Movie poll and for Cassie's first Spike Lee joint I would've picked a different one than Malcolm X (Which is very good, but not his best.)

Christopher Brown

Out of these choices I would go Malcolm x only because of Denzel Washington's performance I don't really have a dog in this fight though I mean the iron claw is good but I mean not everybody likes wrestling.

KyloJames

Don’t forget about Goldberg! Still my favorite wrestler

Chris Thom

Haven't seen it yet. Only ever heard professional movie critics mention it. And some people here on Patreon.

Above Average Dave

Jeez, A Night to Remember is a near perfect movie and scared the living everything out of me at age 10.

Clay F

The Killing Fields is the best movie in the poll. Nominated for 7 Oscars including Best Picture. Won Oscar for Best Cinematography. Based on true story. Watched several times over the decades. One of these days, I am going to visit Phnom Penh.

LukeG84

I voted for The Iron Claw. I haven’t seen it, but given how Zac Efron transformed himself for the role, I’m curious to see if it’s any good.

Clay F

Gets good reviews.

Clay F

Random selection from Requests Top 25 history genre gave great candidates for this poll. All good choices. My ranking based on my preferences: 1. The Killing Fields (1984) 2. Malcolm X (1992) 3. Hamnet (2025) 4. Apocalypto (2006) 5. The Iron Claw (2023) 6. A Night to Remember (1958)

Annie519

I know! And we need more Iron Claw reactions!

Clay F

"The Killing Fields" (1984) is the best movie in the poll. Sam Waterston. John Malkovich. Based on true story. One of these days, I am going to visit Phnom Penh. When I saw that Apocalypto was randomly selected, I was disappointed because I knew would win the poll. Apocalypto is primal and decent filmmaking but I much prefer The Killing Fields.

Choof

Was really hoping for Malcom X. Apocalypto has never interested me unfortunately so probably a skip for me

Shehab Dawoud

The LEAST historically accurate movie is winning the history poll. That's just wonderful. I'm biased but I think Malcolm X is long overdue, so I hope it gets watched soon. You're gonna watch Denzel in Training Day and wonder if he's ever been better in another movie. The answer is yes, in Malcolm X.

keoma songs

While I am not particularly looking forward to most of the 24 possible movies in the polls, I would like the powers that be to know that I am happy with the how the polls were done and related to the rankings on the website. I hope PiB follows through in the future with more polls but cycling through the genres. Only a small number of my requests were top 25 of any genre, but I'm glad to see the leaderboards used.

CJ Holden

They were picked at random. She pulled numbers out of a cup.

AceofSpades501

I voted and then watched the live, thx

Jens Kristensen

"A Night To Remember" is a must watch - just to compare it to James Camerons movie and the clear inspiration.

Mike Lemon

What's the connection there? Apocalypto is about Mayans from south Mexico and Central America (a sub-continent) , not Indians (what "native Americans" prefer to be called) or from America (country). For a heritage month, something like Smoke Signals (1998) would be better, but I hate watching something because it is (insert cause) month. Watch something because it is a good movie.

Richard Maurer

The Iron Claw. I know it won’t win but I’m voting for it anyway.

Bill W

I was a huge wrestling fan, and Kevin was my favorite von Erich, but Iron Claw was so cheesy.

YodatheHobbit

It's funny to me that these were among are the most requested History movies. Some I know, some I love though wouldn't be sure how historically accurate they are, most I've never heard of, but there are so many more which I'd like to see a reaction to which weren't even in the top 20.

Matt Dellarosa

Still haven't seen Hamnet. I wanted to see it in theatets but never got around to it. Heard it was great.

Clarence Newman

Apocalypto is a jolly jape. Very good advert for the importance of cardio.

Clarence Newman

I only knew Kerry. Didn't really like him/notice him that much because his Texas Tornado finishing move was so lame. He was built, though, so they could've done a lot better by him.

Clarence Newman

Big Show was The One Man Gang? Didn't Macho Man beat him in the elimination tourney at Wrestlemania V?

Richard Maurer

The Giant Claw (1957)? No, that wasn’t Jim Carry, it was a giant puppet bird.

Collar City Guy

Saw WCCW several times while visiting Texas in the early eighties at Reunion Arena, and give me the Free Birds versus the Von Erics, old school but clasicc!

aarswft

Insisting on Apocalypto in 2026 is wild.

Shehab Dawoud

Getting Malcolm X on here is difficult enough

Richard Maurer

Some wrestling super fans tend not to like it but that doesn’t make it a bad film. It’s another based on a true story film where they (wrestling fans) get hung up on the parts that aren’t factual, forgetting it’s a movie not a documentary.

Richard Maurer

Mexico is part North America. And Native American would include all the Americas - Central and South as well as North.

2-Can

I'm pretty sure that the Canadians do not refer to the Indians there as 'Native American', usually it is something like First Nations, Inuit, or Métis, with “Indigenous peoples” being the broader generic term.

Richard Maurer

I wish the winners were picked at random too. More fun that way and we might get some more interesting films as winners.

Richard Maurer

From what I’ve been told native Americans from the US refer to each other as Indians - but don’t try it if you’re not one of them. Unless you’re looking for trouble.

Cole Jennett

But his best performance imo, is The Hurricane

Eric Mast

After October I just want to watch old classic Disney movies like Sleeping Beauty and Snow White and the Fox and the Hound. Can we just watch Looney tunes cartoons and Old Disney movies till December?

bknsty14

Hamnet at only 7% is insulting

Clarence Newman

I've never heard of it, bk. That's probably the main reason for most folk.

Shehab Dawoud

That's a respectable opinion, but I don't agree with it.

Clarence Newman

Fences is superb. Never going to be a popular movie so it won't get a reaction here, but what great performances from Denzel and Viola Davis.

Shehab Dawoud

Fences is phenomenal. My fav film of that year

Kyle K

Apocalypto will be fun.

Mike Lemon

@Richard- the OP mentioned a, misnamed, U.S. heritage month (signed 1990 by H.W. Bush), specifically for learning about Indians in present day U.S.- don't try to do that "is a hot dog a sandwich" overly invlusive definition nonsense that makes everything meaningless. You know "Native American" doesn't refer to the Incans, Mayans, Aztecs, or any group in South or Central America.

Richard Maurer

Mike - well, the US census and BIA include all indigenous Americans as Native Americans, although the various American, Canadian, Mexican, Central, and South American indigenous people can use their local names (Mayan, Aztec, Apache, etc.) if they so choose. Some Native Americans don’t mind if non indigenous people call them Indians, a former girlfriend of mine who was half Algonquin didn’t mind the term. But some do so why risk offending someone unnecessarily? I would do what I normally do when meeting someone - introduce myself and ask their name. If for some reason I ever needed to refer that person’s people as group I’d use their tribes name. It’s just being polite.

Catherine LW

True, Richard. I have worked with many Navajos and they call themselves Indians. Also have a friend who is S’Klallam and she and her family call themselves Indians.

WestBound

This got so deep lol

Clay F

Downfall is in the Top 25 History (the size of the pool she used). Downfall is #1 History. It just wasn't randomly selected. I would prefer Downfall over Apocalypto.

Clay F

Reacting to the runner up (2nd place) would give Malcolm X.

Catherine LW

Same here, but I did like Apocalypto. Great directing and acting.

Darryl Gaston

I have a lot of Cambodian friends, everyone lost somebody or had a horrible story to tell and one person lost his whole family. I spent close to 25+ years working with them! Many said they would go with me & be my guide if I choose to visit Cambodia.

Chris Thom

Badd Medicine just did some fun reactions for Sleeping Beauty and the two Maleficent movies.

Mo

But it’s soooo good.

Milton Reduxed

Thanks for clarifying the meaning of runner up in the parlance of our times

Mike Lemon

" the US census and BIA..." Remind me, what does BIA stand for? "Some Native Americans don’t mind if non indigenous people call them Indians" *most "But some do so why risk offending someone unnecessarily? " You already answered this and it is why Indians prefer "Indian." -And Native American would include all the Americas - Central and South as well as North.- It means nothing. You are trying to be so overinclusive, YOU are forcing the erasure of their identity because you want to be offended for them. "I would do what I normally do when meeting someone" Changing goal posts. Nice. Nobody is talking about an individual, we are discussing the group.

prime78

I voted Apocalypto. Cassie said she's liked everything Mel Gibson has done

JarHead0351

Haven't seen that in decades. Such a powerful movie and would like to re-watch it again.

Richard Maurer

BiA stands for Bureau of Indian Affairs which should be changed to BNAA. Why do you care so much? What about the term Indian is so special to you. By the way, how do know most native Americans are okay with being called Indians? Did you do a survey? Besides, even if it’s a minority that don’t like it , why use the term? Is just because was “okay” in the past? Since we’re not talking about your people (unless you happen to majority Native American, which I strongly doubt) why should you have any say in the matter? If only ten people don’t want to called Indians that overrides any non-native Americans need to use the term - because it’s not about you, or me. I want to be “offended for them”? Do you know who you’re talking to? I use the term Native American because they are all NATIVE to the AMERICAS. I don’t use Indians because I know some don’t like it that name, so I don’t have any reason to use it. Don’t try to make me fit into your silly woke agenda nonsense, it just makes you look like you’re parroting weak YT grifter talking points.

Lunaea Weatherstone

A Night to Remember is my favorite Titanic movie, by far. It doesn't have the gazillion-dollar effects, but it has a great script and truly heart-breaking moments.

Chris Thom

Might rent that tonight. Been wanting to see it.

Chris Thom

Bet she would enjoy Do the Right Thing.

Chris Thom

Was that a big budget thing at the time? I know I grew up with James Cameron in the news and stories talking about how much money he was spending on this and that. But having a hard time picturing a smaller-budget movie about the Titanic. But maybe it was possible?

Mike Lemon

"Why do you care so much?" Why do you? "Since we’re not talking about your people (unless you happen to majority Native American, which I strongly doubt) why should you have any say in the matter?" You are the one calling them something other than what they want, so I think you may want to answer the question. You may want to watch this video- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kh88fVP2FWQ " I don’t use Indians because I know some don’t like it that name" Many don't like "Native American," so what now? Do you see what you are doing? (tangent) For a recent example of what that does- it is because of that thinking we don't have the Redskins anymore (68-90% of Indians supported the name) and when asked about what word Indians most associated with the name, it was "proud." Robert Doore of the Blackfeet Reservation said of the Redskins- -" This team means more to me than many things in life! It is personal for me, it’s part of me and it’s my story. I cried when we lost, cheered when we won and when we won the Superbowl…this time INDIANS WON—I WON! I AM PROUD AND HONORED TO BE A REDSKIN! To all the supporters of the Washington Redskins I want to say what my parent tell me all of my life: “EEE GAWK EE MON” which means TRY HARD….always! HAIL TO THE REDSKINS!"- "Don’t try to make me fit into your silly woke agenda nonsense" I wonder why you are bringing that up? I know I didn't. "it just makes you look like you’re parroting weak YT grifter talking points." You need to step away from the politics. It would also help to stop thinking of everyone who doesn't think like you as a "grifter," but one step at a time.

Walter

I love that Apocalypto is leading

Dean Holt

Talking about Wrestling movies she really needs to react to The Wrestler & Fighting with my Family.

Above Average Dave

According to the Interwebs, the production cost in 1958 was approximately £500,000-£600,000 or $1.6 Million. Inflation calculators put that cost at £13M-£15.4M or $19M$–$20M in 2026 dollars. That was in line with other similar scale British productions such as: - Henry V (1944, Laurence Olivier): about £475,000–£500,000 - The Red Shoes (1948, Powell & Pressburger): roughly £500,000+ (it overran from a lower figure) - Dunkirk (1958, Ealing/MGM): around £400,000 But well behind American biggies such as: - The Bridge on the River Kwai 1957 $2.8–3 million - South Pacific 1958 $5.6 million - The Ten Commandments 1956 $13.3 million

Chris Thom

Oh wow. Curious how they pulled that off.

Above Average Dave

My guess is, with no digital effects, it was a lot of models in tanks and a "wet" stage for the flooding and sinking scenes. The Black and White (which I am sure was a choice with effects in mind) helps. The effects are pure 1950s Great Britain film industry, but the acting and panic are gripping. Certainly not the James Cameron scale, but what is?

bgb1975 (Brian)

Swiss Family Robinson and Darby O'Gill are two of the Disney non-cartoons that I grew up with and still love. Long before Disney went downhill.

Richard Maurer

I started to write a long reply to your post covering every talking point but I can see it’s a waste of time as you’ll just cherry pick my comments and ignore the parts that don’t fit your narrative ( I already said I would not use either Indian or Native American in a individual conversation instead just use their specific tribal name). You’re the one who felt the need to direct your comments at me, and it’s clearly a big deal to you for some reason, to the point where you start referring to what “they” all want as if you represent this group of people and know how they all feel about this. And don’t try to gaslight me about politics, I’m not the one who feels the need to comment whenever anyone mentions something that doesn’t agree with my personal views. Go re-read your comments - they sound very familiar to anyone who, like me, only pays even minimal attention to the YT grifterverse. Final comment (because I’m not interested in playing your boring game) : What do you call people from India?

KyloJames

It’s good, but it’s just sad. Like the whole movie is depressing, not a fun watch.

Mike Lemon

"as you’ll just cherry pick my comments" I think in points, that is just how I am. "ignore the parts that don’t fit your narrative" I ignore parts that have been answered, are irrelevant, or don't belong in the particular conversation, such as- "I already said I would not use either Indian or Native American in a individual conversation..." Which, as previously stated, is a different matter. We are not talking about Cherokee Bob or Miami Carol or Algonquin Ted or Nez Perce Alice. This was about what the whole of the tribes in the contiguous U.S. prefer (for my argument) or what you want others to use (your argument). " You’re the one who felt the need to direct your comments at me" ??? You replied to me in WestBound's thread. You weren't even on my mind when I initially replied to him. "and it’s clearly a big deal to you for some reason," Again you replied to me so...??? "to the point where you start referring to what “they” all want " Yeah, 'they' is the plural, third-person pronoun in American English. For example- -What do the fourth graders want for lunch? THEY want pizza. -What do the residents of Paris, Idaho want? THEY want clean streets. That doesn't mean every single person in that group wants the exact same thing. American English is a language that includes a lot of vague language. (edit out a rant, I really went on a tangent there) "...and know how they all feel about this." I can know what they have said about it. And I'll again point back to what you have been typing in this thread and ask, do you see what you are doing? "What do you call people from India?" Usually, 'people from India.' Or if I am talking about Nikki, I call her Nikki or Miss (last name).

WestBound

Mike you seem to complain a lot on many comments I post . Also if you hate watching movies based on month or day themes why haven't you ever said anything when she watches scary movies in October or Christmas movies in December ..or patriotic movies on 4th of July etc etc 🤔

Mike Burr

He was just pointing out that Native Americans refers to all indigenous people of the Americas (notice the s at the end) including the Mayans. This a common European misconception as they think "America" means the United States. Don't know why it pivoted to a conversation about the term "Indian" but they don't use this term. It's based on Europeans believing the Americas were India and Asia back in the day.

Mike Lemon

"Mike you seem to complain a lot on many comments I post ." I do? I have never noticed your name before, but I'll trust you if you say I do. "Also if you hate watching movies based on month or day themes..." -'...but I hate watching something because it is **(insert cause)** month.'- The highlighted part is important. Christmas and October (Halloween) aren't causes.

Mike Lemon

@Mike Barr- "He was just pointing out that Native Americans refers to all indigenous people of the Americas" Not in this context is doesn't. OP specifically mentioned "native American [Indian] heritage month." That is a U.S. specific month meant to celebrate and learn about Indian heritage. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/101/hjres577/text https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_American_Indian_Heritage_Month "Don't know why it pivoted to a conversation about the term "Indian" but they don't use this term." Except, they do. Richard even said it and Catherine confirmed it in this very thread.

bknsty14

It was nominated for best picture last year and Jessie Buckley swept the award season for best actress. It was really good. Better than the trash movie that won best picture (my opinion, don't anyone freak out).

MacGuffinStuff

Apocalypto, it's a well done movie, incredible action. It's also even less historically accurate than Braveheart, by hundreds of years. But, great story, Mel Gibson is not a historian but he does make great movies!

Michael Reade

I'm not sure Cassie would survive Hamnet. I never cry at movies and I was bawling 😭

Richard Maurer

And the winners of the four polls are: Training Day, Watchmen, Apocalypto, and I don’t care.

Chris Thom

Looks like October will continue with Apocalypto. I would consider it horror-adjacent. But with some civilizational history mixed in. I know you've been to Mexico before, so this could be interesting. The Mayans were southern Mexico and Cancun, down thru South America I think.

Nolofinwe

I guess Malcolm X it should’ve been better Spike Lee a moron