Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

GENRE POLL:ROMANCE

  • Kate & Leopold (2001) 159
  • Adventureland (2009) 131
  • Phenomenon (1996) 179
  • Cinema Paradiso (1988) 94
  • Strictly Ballroom (1992) 55
  • Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) 235
  • 2026-11-06
  • —2026-11-09
  • 853 votes
{'title': 'GENRE POLL:ROMANCE', 'choices': [{'text': 'Kate & Leopold (2001)', 'votes': 159}, {'text': 'Adventureland (2009)', 'votes': 131}, {'text': 'Phenomenon (1996)', 'votes': 179}, {'text': 'Cinema Paradiso (1988)', 'votes': 94}, {'text': 'Strictly Ballroom (1992)', 'votes': 55}, {'text': 'Joe Versus the Volcano (1990)', 'votes': 235}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 9, 6, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 6, 3, 54, 24, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 853}

Content

During the Pick a Flick LIVE we sorted the leaderboard by genres and drew 6 numbers from 1-25, these were the picks for ROMANCE!

Comments

KyloJames

Cinema Paradiso!!! God, that movie makes me cry.

Chris Thom

This is a tough one. I remember liking Phenomenon at the time, but remember zero about it. Heard Cinema Paradiso is a classic. Adventureland was charming.

Jimmy Reyes

Excellent picks Cassie. Each a fantastic film.

LukeG84

OMG this is a tough poll! 🤯 Wish I could vote more than once. Can’t decide between Phenomenon, Kate & Leopold, and Joe Versus the Volcano. I may have to play the odds and vote for whichever one of those three has the best chance.

Crystal Banks

I think Phenomenon would've been better for the Sci-Fi category, it definitely would've had my vote under that category

Mister Lou

Adventureland is so good, never seen a reaction to that before!

Robert da Spruce

I went for Kate and Leopold I would have thought you already seen this one Cassie

Justin S.

Phenomenon was a classic John Travolta flick that's been forgotten by a lot of people but it's pretty good.

Justin S.

Yes, sort of like Starman, which is also a combination of sci-fi and romance.

Patrick Gibbs

I know it won’t win, but as someone who ballroom dances for fun, I LOVE Strictly Ballroom. Give it a watch for good laughs, good music, and a good ugly-duckling romance.

LukeG84

Can’t believe Phenomenon isn’t ranking higher. It will be my PAF once Cassie has watched Temple Grandin. It’s a must-watch for Cassie.

Chris Thom

Does it have all the neat Baz Luhrmann color and flash and quick cuts?

Justin S.

One of my favorite romance films is The Piano (1993) and I'm a little surprised it hasn't been requested more often.

Lamar Savage

Kate and Leopold is a must-watch for you and your sister! Soon!

Mark Vaderr

I went with Kate & Leopold, only because Hugh Jackman is in it. He does a good job in this silly movie.

thebeefmaster

Tender November - Romance and more The Music Man (1962) The Sound of Music (1965) Brigadoon (1954) Seven Brides for Seven Brothers (1954) Bells Are Ringing (1960) What's Up, Doc? (1972) You Can't Take It with You" (1938) The Great Race (1965) Born Yesterday (1950) Ball of Fire (1941) My Man Godfrey (1936) The Solid Gold Cadillac (1956) The Pirate (1948) It Should Happen to You (1954) Bell, Book and Candle (1958) I Married a Witch (1942) Sullivan's Travels (1941) Ninotchka (1939) His Majesty O'Keefe (1954) Holiday (1938) The Awful Truth (1937) His Girl Friday (1940) Charade (1963) Roman Holiday (1953) Sabrina (1954) To Catch a Thief (1955) The Palm Beach Story (1942) The Miracle of Morgan's Creek (1943) Annie Get Your Gun (1950)

CJ Holden

Joe Vs The Volcano for me. I have an incredible hatred for Kate & Leopold though, which was a smart career move for Hugh Jackman (It showed the world that he can also be a romantic and funny lead before they could typecast him as action hero after his breakthrough with X-Men), but how Meg Ryan plays an absolutely horrible person while the movie tries to tell us it's the usual, lovable Meg Ryan RomCom persona, made me grind my teeth for most of the runtime.

Paul Ark

Love that you put Strictly Ballroom on there. That is very much a Cassie & Carly-type movie, but I’ll be very surprised if it gets any traction in these polls; it’s a quirky little Aussie film that did really well when it came out but which almost no one remembers or has heard about since. But I will vote for it every time you put it on in the hopes that one day I’ll see it on your channel 🤞🤞🤞

Sam Hiraoka

Surprised Joe vs the Volcano is in the lead. I'm going to enjoy the feeling while it lasts.

Christopher Campbell

I will die on the hill that Joe vs the Volcano is Tom Hanks' best movie.

Tyler Foster

Fingers crossed that Joe versus the Volcano prevails. Love it.

Above Average Dave

Cinema Paradiso is a movie-lover’s movie. I watch it at least once a year. The last 20 minutes will catch you by surprise and have you in the best kind of tears. Avoid the director’s cut on this one, though. The theatrical release is note perfect.

Patrick Gibbs

Sounds like he has a certain style, haha! Yep sounds accurate!

KingofCoo1

Need a none of the above option.

LukeG84

Great movie. Cassie would really enjoy that one.

LukeG84

It certainly would have made this poll a little easier.

LukeG84

Yeah I was surprised by that too. It’s right up her alley being a romcom.

Chris Thom

He did Moulin Rouge and The Great Gatsby and that latest Elvis one.

LukeG84

I rewatched it not too long ago. It never gets old. It’s a must-watch for Cassie, that’s for sure.

Keith Brown

WOW ! You've got some great classics that I hope Cassie will watch ! I watch Turner Classic Movies just for these type of movies when they turn up I record and keep them in my Library of Movies !

Clay F

I love Kate & Leopold. I think Cassie would too.

Clay F

Did you upvote or give priority points? beta.popcorninbed.com

Clay F

My top 3: 1. Adventureland 2. Kate & Leopold 3. Phenomenon

CJ Holden

Jackman absolutely saves the movie. I would totally buy disgusting butter from him.

Jens Kristensen

"Cinema Paradiso" is such a great movie and a true love letter to the world of cinema.

Richard Maurer

I don’t care about any film in this poll, so I just won’t vote. You’re welcome.

YodatheHobbit

John Travolta was the king of dopey trailered "Hey look at this guy, this guy is special and is changing my life for some reason" movies in 1996. The same way Rob Schneider was king of "Rob Schneider is..... DE DERP!.... DErp DE Deerp De Derpidy DERP!" movies for a time.

Matt Dellarosa

My vote is gor Phenomenon. Ive been recommending that one for the channel for a long time. Doesnt look like its winning but I still hope it gets a watch..

Clarence Newman

First thing I ever saw him in was Boy In The Plastic Bubble. Very derp-de-derp.

Clarence Newman

I voted for Joe Versus The Volcano, but only because it's a Tom Hanks film. Cassie loves a bit of Tom.

Clarence Newman

Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan? Wouldn't be surprised if Cassie voted for that one herself.

Clarence Newman

That sounds like a honey-crotch anthill kind of death, Chris.

Clarence Newman

Excuse me while I pluck The Great Race from that list and wave it in front of Cassie's face. "Psst. Oy. Hey. Look. Hey."

Richard Maurer

Did you miss the part where I said “I don’t care”? I was going to vote for Cinema Paradiso because Bjorn likes it but it’s a foreign film and naturally has no chance at winning here.

crazyivan

Please do not let Joe vs the Volcano win this poll. Worst Tom Hanks movie since The Bonfire of the Vanities. Phenomenon is much better, with a better supporting cast - Robert Duvall included.

Grant

I think we've missed a trick. We could have covered the only three films to have won the big five (Screenplay, Actress, Actor, Director and Picture) at the Academy Awards. It Happened One Night (1934) Rom-Com One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest (1975) Drama, and The Silence Of The Lambs (1991) Sci-Fi. (It was fiction and he was psychotic. It works!)

Richard Maurer

She’s reacted to Silence of the Lambs

Grant

I give up.

Clarence Newman

Cuckoo’s Nest is an absolute must that is heinously banned from PiB because it still shows as watched on Popcorn Requests. This travesty needs to be addressed.

Zander

Kate & Leopold is a hidden gem that is beautifully written. Liev's character is the hinge that makes the story work. Little sis needs to join ya though...:)

Clarence Newman

Show Me Love would’ve run away with it.

Richard Maurer

Like Horror of Dracula did in the horror bracket poll.

Grant

These are two different channels that sound the same?

Shawn Conte

Joe Versus the Volcano! Written and directed by Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright John Patrick Shanley and executive produced by Steven Spielberg, Beneath its humor is a thoughtful exploration of mortality, conformity, courage, and what it means to truly live. Its visual symbolism, surreal production design, make it far more sophisticated. wonderfully unconventional film that Cassie would love.

Clarence Newman

Films she’s watched cannot be requested on Popcorn Requests. Cuckoo’s Nest shows as watched.

Grant

On a previous/different channel? (Sorry, I'm fairly new).

Richard Maurer

Popcorn Requests is the list of patrons requested films on the website. The list won’t allow you to add films she already watched - on or off the channel.

Grant

Ok. I don't mean to come across as a nit-picker but how do they what films she's watched "off the channel"?

Clay F

Her reaction to It Could Happen One Night (1934) if you want to watch. https://www.patreon.com/popcorninbed/posts/yt-edit-it-one-98663624 Her reaction to Silence of the Lambs if you want to watch: https://www.patreon.com/popcorninbed/posts/silence-of-lambs-55229938 You can use the search function at the upper right (blank field) to search to see if she has done a reaction. You can check her Letterboxd to see if she has seen a movie. https://letterboxd.com/popcorn_in_bed/films/ At the new beta sight, you can (1) search for her reactions, (2) enter requests, (3) discuss stuff in the forum. beta.popcorninbed.com

Grant

Ok.

Nolofinwe

Michael would be way better than phenomenon way more romantic, great music great sense of humor. Terrific story great cast

Nolofinwe

The other choices are lightweight. Couple are OK. Joe versus volcano has some real tidbits of wisdom in it. It’s only the silly ending that brings it down, but not that much.

Milton Reduxed

Girl Meets TV and Reacts & Snacks have members-only reactions on youtube

Clarence Newman

Ben and Cassie made a list while setting up Popcorn Requests containing all the films she'd already watched (that they could think of anyway). Those films are then unavailable to choose as Requests.

Clay F

Please additionally react to the runner up (2nd place).

Brownie Win

Joe Versus the Volcano is a family favorite, but Strictly Ballroom is one I think you would thoroughly enjoy.

prime78

I voted for adventureland not a great movie, but its the only one I remember/recognize

Juley

Cant believe Strictly Ballroom is doing so poorly!! It’s such a good movie!

Chris Thom

I know it's famous because of Baz Luhrmann. I can't remember if I saw that as a kid, but have vague memories around it. Love his other movies and the over the top style.

Chris Thom

Been wondering if it's better to vote or not on polls we don't feel that strongly about. Still not sure.

Richard Maurer

I don’t vote in polls where I don’t have anything I care about. I look at it this way, I don’t like it when people who don’t like horror films vote in horror polls anyway, so I avoid voting in romance/rom-com polls unless on the rare occasion that there’s actually a film I care about, because I don’t want to be a hypocrite. The only other exception I’ll make is if one of my friends here specifically asks me to vote for a film.

Richard Maurer

It’s a foreign film, which unfortunately means most people here probably have never seen it.

Tyler Foster

Do we know if they've both seen Moulin Rouge? I assume so, sadly, but I'd love to see that one, which seems consistently overlooked by reaction channels.

Tyler Foster

Among foreign films, I would definitely say that Australian and British films have the highest chance of crossover appeal. Although SB is from Down Under, it has a huge boost in the fact that Fox and/or Luhrmann marketed Ballroom, Romeo + Juliet, and Moulin Rouge! as the thematic "Red Curtain trilogy" and sold them on DVD as a set, so I think quite a few people who might not have otherwise seen it saw it because they knew it was by the director of and associated with two other, much more popular American co-productions.

DAVID COSTELLO

Can’t miss with Duvall. She should seriously watch Lonesome Dove

Chris Thom

Yeah, Cassie herself said both she and Carly had seen it. Was kinda bummed about that. Would've been a fun one to see them discover on the channel. She also saw Great Gatsby. But talked about a possible rewatch of Romeo+Juliet since they hadn't seen it since a class in Jr. High School.

Chris Thom

She did at one point mention a possible rewatch of Cukoos Nest because she saw it in a psych class that she doesn't remember too well.

Chris Thom

Don't think she's seen that yet. That would be a good one for the channel.

Grant

Sorry. I'll be leaving soon.

Ozymandias

A better one for her would be Come Dance at My Wedding

Richard Maurer

Tyler - considering how poorly it’s doing I’d say most people here either haven’t seen it (for whatever reason) or don’t like it. My money’s on haven’t seen it. I can’t think of any other reasons it would only have 7% of the votes.

Shawn Conte

Joe vs. was my popcorn pick of the month and it lost😞 however, BOOM!right back in the game with a random romance poll !!! What a night!

Silver Machine

Joe vs the Volcano was released nine months before Bonfire of the Vanities.

Shawn Conte

Perhaps you need to watch it again with Cassie... it's the perfect reaction movie. I hadn't seen it since the 90's and just watched it again with a group recently and had an absolute blast. required for Tom Hanks fans

Clay F

Michael is not Romance in Requests. Instead: Comedy Drama Fantasy Plus, Michael is ranked so low -- would not qualify to be in a poll. You can upvote or give priority points. beta.popcorninbed.com

Clay F

She has shown interest in Kate & Leopold. I think Hugh Jackman and Meg Ryan has her interest.

Clay F

My personal ranking: 1. IMDb 6.8, RT 89%, Metacritic 76% = Adventureland (2009) 2. IMDb 6.4, RT 52%, Metacritic 44% = Kate & Leopold (2001) 3. IMDb 6.5, RT 51%, Metacritic 42% = Phenomenon (1996) 4. IMDb 5.9, RT 65%, Metacritic 45% = Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) 1. Adventureland (2009) – My fav in poll. Good setting. Talented cast. Funny. 2. Kate & Leopold (2001) – Goofy. Hugh Jackman + Meg Ryan. Cassie interested. 3. Phenomenon (1996) – I have nostalgia. I like Kevin Bacon's wife. 4. Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) – too goofy but will watch the reaction. I have not seen these two. Cinema Paradiso (1988) is on my watchlist. IMDb 8.5, RT 91%, Metacritic 80% = Cinema Paradiso (1988) IMDb 7.2, RT 88%, Metacritic 72% = Strictly Ballroom (1992)

Nick Ireland

Strictly Ballroom is actually the best movie on this list. Oh well

Richard Maurer

This is the least popular genre poll with 829 votes. The other 3 are all in the 900 vote range. The 2 most popular are Drama and Sci-Fi, with drama having a 2 vote edge at 986 votes.

crazyivan

I wasn't talking chronologically, I was talking the 2 worst movies he ever made.

crazyivan

I also remember you idiots saying that about Howard the (freaking) Duck, too.

Joe J

Pretty low counts for all four polls. Around a 1000 votes is less than a 3rd of paid patrons. I doubt I'll watch any of the winners this time around.

Richard Maurer

I’ll watch Training Day and Watchmen when they come out as YouTube edits. Otherwise I don’t care.

Milton Reduxed

If Cassie is reading make Adventureland your PPOTM sometime. Although I love the movie it is probably best enjoyed in summer

DAVID COSTELLO

I can’t believe Joe vs the Volcano is winning

bknsty14

I watched that in film class in college. I really liked it.

Doc Larry/old geezer

Sometimes I wonder if people vote for certain movies in these challenges just to give Cassie a terrible viewing experience! Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) is often considered one of Tom Hanks’ more disappointing films. I know everyone has different tastes, but I actually feel bad for Cassie sometimes. Maybe it’s all meant as a joke, but I’d rather see her enjoy a good movie than suffer through one!

Richard Maurer

I don’t believe most people want Cassie to have a “terrible viewing experience”, in fact I doubt any do. Some people just happen to enjoy films others see as bad. I tried to watch Joe vs the Volcano once, couldn’t get through it. And I am surprised so many people like it. But people like a lot of films I can’t stand, so I’m not that surprised it’s popular among some. As a fan of horror movies, I’ve been on the other end of this situation many times. Plenty of people hate horror films and think the entire genre is worthless. And while I see those people as close-minded and judgmental, I’m not really surprised that some feel that way. I mean modern rom-coms leave me cold, but a lot of people, including Cassie, enjoy them, so to each their own. I can’t speak for others, but I recommend and vote for films because I like them and am interested in seeing Cassie’s reaction to them. But unlike many people here I don’t try and anticipate whether or not Cassie will like them. In fact I’d rather she watch something outside her comfort zone and not like it than watch something that doesn’t “broaden her horizons”, as she put it at the start of PiB, and have the same basic reaction we’ve already seen so many times.

Doc Larry/old geezer

@ Richard Maurer Oh, I agree with you on most of this. I’ve discovered movies and television shows I never thought I would enjoy. Game of Thrones is a perfect example. I had absolutely no interest in it until I watched it with Cassie, and it became one of my favorite television series. But Joe Versus the Volcano is a different story. It has long had a reputation as one of Tom Hanks’ weaker films, much like Howard the Duck has its own notorious reputation. Granted, some people genuinely enjoy these movies, and that’s perfectly fine. However, I sometimes wonder whether certain people vote for notoriously bad films just to watch Cassie’s reaction. Perhaps that’s the old geezer in me talking, but I do think it happens occasionally. I certainly don’t believe everyone has that intention. Ultimately, I agree that Cassie should explore films outside her comfort zone. That’s part of what makes her channel enjoyable. I just think there’s a difference between introducing someone to an overlooked gem and deliberately choosing a cinematic disaster for the entertainment value of watching them suffer through it!

Richard Maurer

Since you brought up Howard the Duck, that was definitely a troll, but it was by YouTube viewers, not patrons. Even the Last Dragon, which is the closest thing to HtD, had genuine, if inexplicable, support here. There probably people here who just want to troll Cassie but I don’t believe their are enough of them to effectively change a polls outcome.

Milton Reduxed

Tom Hanks' star power won it for arguably the weakest film on the poll

Doc Larry/old geezer

@ Richard Maurer Howard the Duck was actually voted in, I believe during an Extra Butter Live “Surprise Me” selection. Most patrons take this channel seriously, but perhaps it was one of those giddy moments we all experience. Needless to say, I didn’t vote for it! I think you’re right, though. Remember, most of this channel’s audience consists of millennials, not geezers like me! They have their own quirky sense of humor, just as we did back in the 60s and 70s. Different generations, different humor. Anyway, I hope Cassie gets something out of it and actually enjoys herself. After all, even terrible movies sometimes develop devoted cult followings. Sometimes being spectacularly bad is what makes a film memorable!

Clay F

I think most patrons voting for Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) actually like it, or at least like it better than the other entries in the poll. Yet, I can see why you suspect trolling with it arguably being the weakest film in the poll. However, I thought that Joe Versus the Volcano would win the moment I saw it randomly selected live as a poll candidate. Tom Hanks star power. Plus, nostalgia. I voted Adventureland (2009). Doc - what did you vote for? If Kate & Leopold (2001), Adventureland (2009), and Phenomenon (1996) remain in Top 25 Romance, each have chance of being in next Romance poll configured by random selection from Requests romance genre. And Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) will be out of the way.

Joe J

@Doc - Do you prefer she only watch highly-rated movies and movies considered classics? It seems most patrons don't really care what she watches, only around 30% even bother to vote on polls.

Joe J

Earth Girls are Easy also won a YT poll....but Cassie so far has refused to watch it. Cassie is living dangerously with the random draw polls, lol.

Joe J

Knowing Cassie, she'll probably love it Milt...lol.

Richard Maurer

That’s the weirdest thing to me, the relatively low number of poll voters when compared to the number of paying patrons. Maybe they just want to watch Cassie react and don’t actually care what it’s to?

Miss Lee

I choose it as my PaF . Such a hidden gem - I rewatch it every so often. They would adore this movie!

Clay F

Current Romance genre Top 26 at Requests at beta.popcorninbed.com 1. Charade (1963), 21 priority entries, 48 upvotes = 1,037 points 2. Out of Sight (1998), 14 priority entries, 50 upvotes = 934 3. Show Me Love (1998), 8 priority entries, 13 upvotes = 556 4. The Goodbye Girl (1977), 7 priority entries, 25 upvotes = 506 5. The English Patient (1996), 7 priority entries, 39 upvotes = 435 *6. Cinema Paradiso (1988), 8 priority entries, 21 upvotes = 432 *7. Joe Versus the Volcano (1990), 7 priority entries, 31 upvotes = 418 *8. Strictly Ballroom (1992), 5 priority entries, 19 upvotes = 296 9. Sing Street (2016), 5 priority entries, 17 upvotes = 292 10. Marty (1955), 5 priority entries, 19 upvotes = 288 11. Vanilla Sky (2001), 8 priority entries, 38 upvotes = 278 12. Real Genius (1985), 2 priority entries, 27 upvotes = 270 13. Garden State (2004), 6 priority entries, 24 upvotes = 266.9 14. CODA (2021), 3 priority entries, 13 upvotes = 266 15. I Love You, Beth Cooper (1992), 2 priority entries, 10 upvotes = 233 16. The Quick and The Dead (1995), 2 priority entries, 49 upvotes = 219 17. Harold and Maude (1971), 6 priority entries, 22 upvotes = 216 18. Mr. Right (2016), 3 priority entries, 21 upvotes = 209 19. Chasing Amy (1997), 3 priority entries, 27 upvotes = 207 20. Weathering with You (2019), 2 priority entries, 1 upvote = 206.6 21. Vision Quest (1985), 5 priority entries, 14 upvotes = 205 22. Father Goose (1964), 5 priority entries, 12 upvotes = 197 *23. Kate & Leopold (2001), 3 priority entries, 21 upvotes = 194 24. The Lady Eve (1941), 3 priority entries, 8 upvotes = 193 *25. Adventureland (2009), 4 priority entries, 17 upvotes = 186 *26. Phenomenon (1996), 6 priority entries, 36 upvotes = 184

Clay F

Click on “Continue with Patreon” (see image). If you want to upvote or assign priority points to movies to influence what movies are ranked high enough to be considered for a Romance genre poll (or any genre poll), go to Requests at beta.popcorninbed.com = easy to access. Just make sure (see image) to NOT click on Sign in at the bottom but instead click on “Continue with Patreon” at the top. If you have trouble getting in, post a comment on Patreon. The beta site is user-friendly = easy to use.

Doc Larry/old geezer

@Joe J That’s not it at all. There are so many quality films across different genres and decades, including simple, quirky, overlooked gems. I just watched The Young and Prodigious T. S. Spivet, a wonderful little film I guarantee most people have never heard of. What makes Cassie stand out among other reactors is her willingness to explore classic films and lesser-known treasures. I enjoy that! What bothers me is when people deliberately vote for movies notorious for being terrible. It sometimes feels more like trolling, to use the younger generation’s terminology, than genuinely wanting her to discover something worthwhile. There are too many wonderful movies out there!

Doc Larry/old geezer

@Richard Maurer Your observation is spot on! I’m never quite sure how these polls work, especially with so few voters compared to the number of paying patrons. Cassie is one of the best movie reactors on the Internet. Movie reacting is practically a new profession, for lack of a better word, and she’s at the top of her game. Frankly, I think she could react to chocolate commercials and people would still watch her! She’s an amazing personality and a natural at what she does. Perhaps that explains why such a crappy movie was chosen. I’ll never understand it! Again, no spoilers. This is just my opinion of this particular film, and I won’t be watching this reaction. Fortunately, she’s already reacted to so many wonderful movies, with many more to come. That’s what keeps me coming back!

BriGuy

It's certainly better than Joe Versus the Volcano, which is leading by a wide margin.

Richard Maurer

How are Real Genius (comedy) and The Quick and the Dead (western) romance movies? The answer is they’re not. They might have some romance in them, but not enough to have romance as even a sub-genre. The only thing the genre filters are good for is a laugh.

Mike Lemon

I thought she already saw Beth Cooper. I think she mentioned it passing somewhere...the podcast, perhaps?

Clay F

Richard -- that's 2 out of 26. Any more? As for Real Genius (1985), apparently the light (charming) romantic subplots amongst the campus shenanigans (pranks) were enough for some sources to list romance as a genre. Real Genius (1985) genres: -Wikipedia = Comedy, Science Fiction, Romance -Letterboxd = Comedy, Romance, Science Fiction -IMDb = Comedy, Romance, Sci-Fi -The Movie Database (TMDB) = Comedy, Romance, Science Fiction -Metacritic = Comedy · Romance · Sci-Fi -Box Office Mojo by IMDbPro = Comedy · Romance · Sci-Fi Quick and the Dead is not a traditional romance, though it includes a subtle, tragic romantic tension between Ellen ("The Lady," played by Sharon Stone) and Cort (Russell Crowe). Some sources apparently list romance genre for Quick and the Dead b/c of the minor romantic/dramatic undertones.

Richard Maurer

Clay - I’m sure there are more, every genre filter list has many films that don’t belong in the genre they’re added to, but I’m not going into the romance genre filter rabbit hole because I don’t care that much. Subplots - are not enough to change a films genre. Real Genius is a comedy about college science geniuses - I know because I’ve seen it many times . It’s not sci-fi, and the very minor amount of romance doesn’t qualify it for the romance genre. The Quick and the Dead is a Western. If the tiny amount of romance in that movie qualifies it for the romance genre then almost every western is in the romance genre. I like to use the example of The Lord of the Rings movies. Those movies are fantasy. They are not fantasy, horror, action, romance, war, comedy, etc. movies, even though they have aspects of all those genres. Using multiple genres just dilutes and confuses the meaning of genre in regard to a film’s narrative.

Nolofinwe

Phenomenon sucks Michael is much much better than phenomenon. Why is that not on the pole? Travolta is much better than that and the cast is much better.

Clay F

Richard - I often go with your opinion but here for Real Genius I am going with the sources I listed over you. There are other sources that don't list romance for Real Genius but I prefer a broader reading/characterization, i.e., in that not listing romance would be to ignore a relevant aspect of the movie. In general, I don't like the way people (I am not saying you) perceive romance genre pigeonholed either as (1) a full blown romance with no other focus in the movie or as (2) a rom-com. First, romance genre movies are generally a mix of romance with other aspects of the movie. Second, it's amazing how people (I am not saying you) equate romance genre as only rom-com. Many romance genre movies have little/no comedy.

Richard Maurer

Well apparently every movie is multiple genres then. Forgive me for calling movies by their main (real) genres and not wasting everyone’s time by naming every genre they might have a tangential relationship to.

Damon Corrigan

Joe vs. The Volcano is a weird one. It is one of my favorite movies and if you can dig deeper than the crazy and weird surface, there is actually a really good and wholesome movie there. I know it has it's detractors, but it is worth a watch.

Clay F

You're forgiven.