Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

GENRE POLL:SCI-FI

  • Dark City (1998) 193
  • The Transformers: The Movie (1986) 84
  • Watchmen (2009) 336
  • Forbidden Planet (1956) 115
  • Fantastic Voyage (1966) 57
  • The Book of Eli (2010) 230
  • 2026-11-06
  • —2026-11-09
  • 1015 votes
{'title': 'GENRE POLL:SCI-FI', 'choices': [{'text': 'Dark City (1998)', 'votes': 193}, {'text': 'The Transformers: The Movie (1986)', 'votes': 84}, {'text': 'Watchmen (2009)', 'votes': 336}, {'text': 'Forbidden Planet (1956)', 'votes': 115}, {'text': 'Fantastic Voyage (1966)', 'votes': 57}, {'text': 'The Book of Eli (2010)', 'votes': 230}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 9, 6, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 6, 3, 54, 51, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1015}

Content

During the Pick a Flick LIVE we sorted the leaderboard by genres and drew 6 numbers from 1-25, these were the picks for SCI-FI!

Comments

Justin Samlal

Oh man 1986 Transformers! Do it for Peter Cullen!

Knight Squirrel

May I request The Director's Cut of Watchmen if it wins?

Jimmy Reyes

If Dark City don't win. You need to watch it. It's a trip.

LukeG84

I hope Watchmen wins. I’ve been meaning to rewatch it for a second time for a while. Can barely remember it.

Billy DuBose

More votes 🗳️ for Transformers The Movie please!!

Justin S.

Dark City is one of the best films of the 90s that people don't really talk about much.

Charles Briggs

If watchmen (2009) wins please make sure its the Director's Cut not the theatrical cut

Chris Thom

Dark City was one of my favorite finds at the video store ever. Knew absolutely nothing about it, but it was in the Employees' Picks section and the cover was interesting. Fun to see how much it influenced The Matrix.

Robert Kern

mine too one of the most classic and ahead of its time sci fis ever

Chris Thom

I have a hard time remembering plot points for movies with super dark color grading for some reason. Same with The Ring. But also the story went all over the place, if I remember right. Very pretty to look at though.

CJ Holden

I really hope for Forbidden Planet. An incredible, very Star Trek-y (although it came out before that) movie that still holds up. I also would be okay with Dark City, although I want to recommend the director's cut for this, since in the theatrical version the mystery is pretty much spoiled in the opening narration.

Christopher Brown

Watchmen is so good you need to watch the director's cut though if it wins.

thebeefmaster

Yes, the "Director's Cut" brings the film from its theatrical 162 minutes to 186 minutes. Scenes include expanded action sequences, and additional exposition. It was Zack Snyder's true vision of how the story should be handled, making many see it as the definitive version.

Clay F

Awesome that Cassie did random selection from Requests for genre polls. Hope for more of that in the future. Sci-fi is my last choice for genre. I would have preferred the genres mystery, thriller, crime, war, or western over sci-fi. I am happy with drama, history, and romance. Sci-fi is top genre choice among patrons. I have always been a sci-fi fan but enough is enough. Tiresome. Not really a fan of the choices in this poll. I voted for Forbidden Planet. The Transformers: The Movie (1986) would be my last choice. I saw Book of Eli (2010) in the theater -- have mixed feelings. Watchmen Director's Cut is 3 hours and 6 minutes. I may skip that reaction.

Mark Vaderr

You want to know where The Matrix came from, Cassie? Watch Dark City. This movie has been my pick-a-flick for months. Such a brilliant film. I just knew that Watchmen would be the top vote getter. Sad to see that Forbidden Planet is getting such little recognition, it's a good movie. This poll is stacked.

René Ferland

How about the Ultimate Cut? 215 minutes!

Above Average Dave

Director’s Cut if Watchmen wins, OK, Cass? It’s definitive as they come.

Tyler Foster

Dark City should be the director's cut, whenever it happens (since it doesn't look good right now).

Above Average Dave

Also, I still haven’t seen a Transformer movie, and hope to never do so (hey, we all need that one big flaw, right?🤣)

Art of Free Speech

Ugh... "The Watchmen." Prestige movie making at its worst.

Luke

Please watch Dark City (Director's cut) even if it doesn't win, its one of my favorite movies of all time, its an underrated masterpiece imo

JL_83

Dark City is a gem 💎

LukeG84

For me I think it’s just that I only saw it the once and it was so long ago. Crazy to think k how many years there are between now and then. 👀

Keith Brown

The classic movies like Forbidden Planet and Fantastic Voyage will need another category for Classic Sci-Fi movies before 1970. Those two entertaining movies I know Cassie and her family would enjoy !

Cole Jennett

Unfortunately, in order for her to enjoy the cartoon movie, she would have had to have watched the cartoon growing up. She’s just not going to get anything out of it with no prior context to the story.

Brian Shannow

Dark City is very much a Directors cut only if that gets chosen

Clay F

Cassie seemed confused much of the "Your Name" (2016) cartoon. I've never seen a Transformer movie (except bits/pieces looking over my kid's shoulder), and don't care to. They seem horrible. The only Transformer movie I would be willing to give a try is "Bumblebee" (2018).

Mark White

Forbidden planet please 🙏 Absolute classic!

Shehab Dawoud

I think the best of the best Sci-Fi movies have been watched a long time ago. Time for other genres to have their chance. There are so many great ones left in crime and thriller.

Karl Heinz

No Last Starfighter? Dark City is an great film

Richard Maurer

Watchmen. Because Forbidden Planet doesn’t stand a chance - because it’s old , and the patrons won’t vote for anything old.

Jake McNulty

When you do eventually react to “Dark City”, Please make sure you are watching the Director’s Cut! This cannot be stressed enough. The theatrical cut spoils the big mystery of the entire film with a voiceover narration in the opening seconds. Please make sure you watch the version without the voiceover.

Mojo One Thousand

As it says in the description, the selections were random from the top 25 movies of the relevant genre from the PIB website. "The Last Srarfighter" was in this list, but missed out. It was done during the PAF live drawing.

Matt Dellarosa

Unfortunately its not winning right now but Cassie I have to plug The Book of Eli. I think thats one you will love. Great movie.

Bill W

I don't consider Book of Eli a sci-fi film. Doesn't really belong here....but it's been on a few polls already and it deserves to win one soon. Cassie will love it.

Sam Hiraoka

I wish Watchmen was in a comic book movie poll. It's taking up a slot for The Time Machine 1960. ;)

Greg S.

Watchmen is such a snooze fest.

Richard Maurer

Is Time Machine about cloning, Clarences? It would have lost to either Watchmen or Book of Eli anyway. You know old movies have no shot at winning here.

Richard Maurer

Typically any movie from before 1980 has little to no chance of winning here. I’m starting to think they just use them for poll filler.

Richard Maurer

Clay - but she ultimately liked Your Name. Anime is from a different culture so it can be hard for people to adjust to right away. Of course it helps if you keep an open mind. As for the Transformers live action movies, they remind me of the Fast and Furious series - they both start out mediocre (at best) and go rapidly downhill from there.

Clarence Newman

There need to be More Locks on this channel!

Richard Maurer

Mark - most polls here are stacked - one or two contenders, the rest are just filler. I voted for Watchmen, because I like it more than Book of Eli. Dark City, Forbidden Planet, and Fantastic Voyage never had a real shot at winning.

Keith Brown

I'll keep watching ,voting and submitting because Cassie once in a while will look at the older films and when she does she always comes away glad she did. Some of her best reactions after watching an older classic that she was unsure about is "wow that was so good I'm going to rewatch it with my family." Classic movies stay classic when someone watches an old movie and tells another generation about it.

Richard Maurer

Wouldn’t mind a western poll. But the war genre is more overdone than any genre here. We just had A Bridge Too Far a month ago and Kelly’s Hero’s is coming soon. The war genre needs to rest for at least a quarter.

Andrew Heller

I can see the story being a little convoluted to people, there was a lot of back and forth of the past and presented

Timothy Williams

Come on, kids! Forbidden Planet is a Sci-fi classic!! Why do newer movies always win? Fantastic Voyage is also a classic. The Book of Eli is a favorite but I can't vote for it with the two classics mentioned above in the poll.

Just Plain Bob

Forbidden Planet and Fantastic Voyage never stood a chance. The recency bias of this community is staggering. Anything earlier than 1980 has little to no chance. And most people’s idea of good sci-fi is something with lots of CGI (whether it’s needed or not) and, preferably, an explosion or two.

Rob

When you see the opening of Forbidden Planet, you'll understand where the opening of Star Wars came from.

Richard Maurer

Bob - 💯 so tired of seeing films in polls that I’d love to see a reaction to, only to realize they have no shot because so many patrons here won’t vote for anything “old” or foreign.

Richard Maurer

It’s nice when Cassie chooses to watch an older movie, but notice she has to choose them because you can’t count on the patrons to vote them in. They should make more strictly classic polls and stop adding them to polls with newer movies where they are just cannon fodder.

Dooly

I don’t really get Transformers: The Movie. I’m sure people who grew up with the eighties cartoon thought it was ‘rad’ or whatever but I thought it was pretty boring.

Clarence Newman

Lock Stock? I think we have a poll here.

Clarence Newman

To balance things up, I think Cassie should agree that all of her Popcorn picks are pre 1980.

Richard Maurer

But then we’d just get a bunch of old romance films ;-)

Clarence Newman

War can take a break once she’s done Heartbreak Ridge and The Dirty Dozen.

Keith Brown

Good thoughts. Here's hoping . Another great site I belong to is TBR Schmitt , they've been doing classic polls lately for noir movies. If they find a classic actor or director they will run polls for those movies. PiB and TBR Schmitt are my favorite go to on Patreon sites.

Clarence Newman

Time Machine is romance. He tries to get his wiener in Weena.

Clay F

Agree we had two war polls. The winners were Kingdom of Heaven and Dr. Strangelove. Kingdom of Heaven not my top choice but ok. Dr. Strangelove did not satisfy my craving for a good war movie. A Bridge Too Far was runner up - a mediocre 1970s war movie that admittedly I liked better than expected but still. Kelly's Heroes 50+ year old war movie I have no nostalgia for. Agree that war has gotten attention but Bridge Too Far, Kelly's Heroes, and Dr. Strangelove not high on my list.

Clay F

I am not picky. There are plenty of Top 25 War genre movies that I crave: The Killing Fields (1984) The Deer Hunter (1978) Empire of the Sun (1987) The Thin Red Line (1998) Three Kings (1999) Downfall (2004) Warfare (2025) The Wind That Shakes the Barley (2006) maybe Rob Roy (1995) Instead, I get Bridge Too Far, Kelly's Heroes, Kingdom of Heaven, and Dr. Strangelove

Richard Maurer

So romantic. You should write greeting cards for Valentine’s Day

Richard Maurer

Well from a strictly neutral standpoint, that’s a fairly high amount of war films - way higher than western anyway.

Richard Maurer

As for your list of war films, I don’t see Sisu so I don’t care - not that Sisu would win a poll, being foreign and all.

Richard Maurer

Is The Northman listed as a war film? If not that just proves how random Requests genre definitions are. But I’d make an exception about there being too many war films if Cassie picked The Northman.

Joe J

TBR is much better with showing older and niche movies. Everything gets an edit and he doesn't care about YT views.

Clay F

The Northman not listed as war. Instead, is action (#98), adventure (#67), fantasy (#33). In the next genre random selection, I might give points to push into the Top 25 fantasy in case she chooses fantasy as a genre. Sisu is war but way down in the rankings. I would willing to give Sisu points but would be a lost cause unless others gave it points.

Clay F

I would love a third of the Top 25 war. I am that way with other genres too. But not for Top 25 sci-fi. For history, romance, and drama, there were many in the respective Top 25 that I liked and several randomly selected -- but they not winning the polls.

Richard Maurer

I’m a patron of TBR Schmitt. They do more foreign films too, which is another pet peeve of mine about PiB.

Richard Maurer

See The Northman has multiple battles yet isn’t listed as a War film, but Stripes is? The Requests genre filters are nonsensical.

Clay F

The Time Machine (1960) is not in the Top 25 sci-fi. Instead, it's #109 sci-fi. Has 24 upvotes (which is decent) but no priority points.

bknsty14

The Book of Eli should be absolutely running away with this

Joe J

I'm still here only because I like Cassie much more than the films that get watched.

Joe J

Clarence, you're not under the delusion that Cassie will ever watch a requested movie are you?

Joe J

Specific decade polls have been requested many times over the years, but Cassie won't do them.

Clarence Newman

I live on delusions, Joe. It's the only thing that keeps me going.

Clarence Newman

Clay. I would've given it priority points if I'd known a sci fi poll was coming, but there wasn't time.

Just Plain Bob

Agree 💯. The voice over narration at the beginning of the theatrical cut absolutely ruins the film. The mystery of the strangers is a big part of the film. It’d be like watching a murder mystery only to have a narrator proclaim in the first scene of the movie that the butler did it and here’s why.

Just Plain Bob

I actually voted for Dark City because it’ll never get reacted to otherwise. But I’m a big fan of Watchmen and disagree completely with its haters. I think it’s Zack Snyder’s best film. I also think he did a great job of adapting the graphic novel and prefer his ending to Alan Moore’s (I’m a fan of Moore’s, but I said what I said and I mean it).

Russell

Forbidden Planet and Dark City are must watches, both are Carly acceptable too. Fantastic Voyage is a classic but it can wait. Looks like Watchmen will win, good for those fans, but not for me- I thought it was a forgettable mess.

David Patterson

There's only one I can vote for, but the 3 I'm rooting for are the lowest 3 spots. Unbelievable.

Russell

I am with you, a super great movie that inspired so many other films.

Russell

I agree, there should be a before 1980 category. So many fantastic classic movies (far better then most of the slop of today) need a fair shake.

Russell

Watchmen is a big no for me, especially director's cut... over 3 hours? Nope

OddThomas

Dark City but director's cut only

Richard Maurer

I like Watchmen a lot, I wouldn’t have voted for it I didn’t, but I would have probably voted for Forbidden Planet if I thought it had a decent chance. However Book of Eli is in second, and too close to Watchmen in votes for my liking.

Just Plain Bob

I’m absolutely on board with a Forbidden Planet reaction. Love that movie. As for Book of Eli, I frankly don’t understand the love for it. It’s ok but nothing special. I suspect Cassie would like it because of Denzel Washington. Personally, I’m much more interested in whether an interesting story is being told and how well it’s being told. “Star power” holds no interest for me whatsoever. And whether Cassie will like a movie is perhaps the only thing I care about less than the film’s star power. Only picking movies that Cassie will like defeats her stated purpose for starting the channel. Why not just do rom-com reactions?

Richard Maurer

Bob - Agree with everything you said.

thebeefmaster

No thank you to the Ultimate Cut. This is from a reviewer and expresses my opinion. Since supplemental content is the issue, it's easy to assume that the Ultimate Cut would be an even better movie than the Director's Cut. That's not quite the case, however, as that version of the film has the opposite problem. It intersperses the animated Tales of the Black Freighter movie into Watchmen, thus making it feel even more like the comic book, which did the same thing. Sadly, this narrative device doesn't really work in a movie, which handles story differently from a comic book. It doesn't help that Zack Snyder didn't intend for Watchmen and Tales of the Black Freighter to be mashed together in such a way. The result is essentially fanservice that actually ruins the pacing of the movie, as the main story is now interrupted with something completely different.

Chris Thom

Heard it was fitting in a lot of material into one movie. A lot of fans of the comic thought it might be unfilmable at the time.

Clay F

Yeah, I would have given points to Moon (2009) if I knew sci-fi poll was coming. What I did is I guessed (hours before she did the selection) that drama and romance polls were coming, and adjusted my points accordingly (which wasn't really that much adjustment - just adding a couple of movies to my priorities).

Just Plain Bob

Clarence agreeing with himself about The Time Machine may be the one way to guarantee I’d vote against it when it comes up in a poll again. If he’s that certain, he’s gotta be wrong. I’m sure of that.

Clarence Newman

I don't like Cassie that much. I'm just here to annoy Richard.

Clay F

Yeah, Fantastic Voyage and the 40-yr old animated Transformers not in big demand among the voting patrons. Old movies typically don't fare well with modern movies in a poll. I voted Forbidden Planet (1956) but often will vote a modern movie.

Clay F

I saw The Book of Eli in the theater when released. I didn't like the religious aspects. I have mixed feelings about the movie. I voted Forbidden Planet and I typically vote a modern movie (not an old movie) in a poll.

Andrew Heller

That’s probably why the uncut version is like 4 hours long

Mo

It’s an odd one for sure and super uhh “inspirational” let’s say for the matrix.

Cole Jennett

It needs context. The movie is a continuation of the cartoon series. I expect Cassie would react the same way. Still voted for it as I have no interest in any of the others personally.

Mike Corrao

Bumblebee was really good for a Transformer movie

Mark Vaderr

Neither does Transformers. Darl City has performed good in the poll.

prime78

I would have watched transformers amongst this group of movies because that's my childhood, but this is Cassie, so Watchmen? I don't know. The only other one I seen beside transformers and watchmen is The Book of Eli, which was not memorable at all.

Richard Maurer

It’s okay. But nowhere near as good as Clarence makes it out to be.

Richard Maurer

I like Cassie well enough. You are like a mime, amusing for a few seconds then easily ignored.

Richard Maurer

Dark City has a small chance of overtaking Book of Eli, but things don’t usually change much after the first day or two.

Dirk-Jan (DJ)

OMG, Watchmen is not even a Sci-Fi movie. Why are these 'fantasy flix' always combined with this genre?

Richard Maurer

They use the genre filters on the Request list to pick the films, and those genre filters have verrrry broad definitions as to what belongs in a genre. For instance, Kate and Leopold is also listed in the sci-fi genre. And Watchmen is much closer to pure sci-fi than Kate and Leopold. But anyway if you check out any genre filter on the Requests list you’re guaranteed to find several films that will make you think wtf?

Dean Holt

It’s been a while since I’ve seen it, but I wouldn’t really classify The Book of Eli as a Sci-Fi.

Dean Holt

I do like that idea, but I’d include the 80s tbh as there’s loads of great Sci-Fi movies she hasn’t seen from that era. But whatever she does isn’t going to please everyone unfortunately. Maybe the only way to stop people voting for the most recent film. Is she picks a genre, and then does 3 polls (so it’s 3 movies to watch over 1 week) b4 80s (as you suggested), 80s & 90s and after 2000s.

John Casamassa

I agree, but a first time viewer needs to watch the Director's Cut. The feeling of following the main character and learning about the world along with him makes the Director's Cut almost a different film entirely.

Tyler Foster

To be clear, though, it sounds like Keanu Reeves first read a draft of The Matrix in 1996, before either film was made. The similarities are obvious, but there is no chance The Matrix ripped off Dark City.

Tyler Foster

The most important thing here is just making absolutely sure she understands there are *three* cuts and that the Ultimate is different and much longer than the DC.

Tyler Foster

While I'm most interested in Dark City, it would be a great excuse to give my new Forbidden Planet 4K UHD a spin.

Tyler Foster

I care less about recency bias (perhaps because it's more or less insurmountable) and more about taste. Dark City is recent and great. Watchmen is recent and a big shrug. In this case, I am surprised to see that one taking such a dominating lead, as I guess it didn't feel like it generated this kind of heat on other channels. And as for Book of Eli...well, let's just say I don't have anything nice to say about that one at all.

DAVID COSTELLO

I agree. I hope it remains under consideration for later. She should watch more films that are unconventional.

Chris Thom

I thought they literally used some of the same sets and locations because they were in production at the same time...?

Joe J

For no logical reason post-apocalyptic fiction is lumped under sci-fi.

Richard Maurer

Lots of movies are lumped into the wrong categories on the Requests list by the genre filters. The Fantasy filter is even worse than the sci-fi one.

Dean Holt

Joe, Sorry if I’ve got this wrong, as sarcastic comments are hard to read sometimes. But if you are being sarcastic, I’d personally class it as more of an action adventure done as a modern Western, over a Sci-Fi as where’s the science part of it. It’s just like how Munich won a poll for the Olympics, yes it was something that happened at that Olympic Games but it didn’t have anything to do with the games themselves.

Richard Maurer

I keep meaning to check out Molly Bee’s reactions but we’re just coming out of October and I’m a horror fan so I have a bit of a backlog right now..

Joe J

The Requests genres are auto-populated from "The Movie Database", which of course is no more accurate than a dozen other sites.

Dean Holt

Joe Still don’t know if you’re being sarcastic, even that last one sounded sarcastic 😂.

Joe J

No sarcasm intended in either of my comments Dean.

Justin S.

Existenz is more bizarre and came out the same year as The Matrix. Some similarities.

Richard Maurer

Joe’s comments always read as a little sarcastic for some reason ;-). As for what database the movies are populated from, it doesn’t really matter if it just throws every movie into whatever genre it has even the vaguest connection to, because it makes the genres filters worthless as far as I’m concerned. Instead of genre polls they should use either the by decade filter or just do random selection directly off of the Leaderboard.

Rosario

If Watchmen wins, the intro/first 5 mins alone will be a great reaction.

Michael Daw

Lots of greats. But Watchmen is an all time fav.

Kevin O'Donnell

If watchmen win definitely watch the directors cut!

Doc Larry/old geezer

I think Science Fiction Masterpieces deserves its own category! Classics like Forbidden Planet (1956), Metropolis (1927, silent film), Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea (1961), Fantastic Voyage (1966), The Day the Earth Stood Still (1951), The Time Machine (1960), The War of the Worlds (1953), 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954), Silent Running (1972), and The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957). Cassie has already seen 2001: A Space Odyssey and Planet of the Apes, so I left those off the list. These films helped define science fiction and deserve special recognition!

Richard Maurer

I agree, but one small correction, she has already reacted to The Day the Earth Stood Still (51).

Joe J

Ditto!

BriGuy

Can't believe "Fantastic Voyage" is polling at only 6%.

Richard Maurer

The film was is from 1966, which unfortunately means the majority of patrons here won’t vote for it.

Clay F

While I generally prefer modern or newer movies, I voted Forbidden Planet. At least Forbidden Planet (1956) beat the 40-yr old animated Transformers. Voting patrons wanting old movies (e.g., pre-1970 or especially pre-1960) are a smaller minority on the channel. I've seen that on other channels. Old movies generally don't stand a chance in mixed time polls. Typically, the poll has to be pre-1970, pre-1960, or pre-1950 for old movies to have a realistic chance to win the poll or come in 2nd. That's not always the case. For example, the stars were aligned for The Philadelphia Story (1940) in being a famous old movie w/high name recognition as the only old movie in a poll with 14 modern movies. Old movie patrons apparently ganged up to vote for the sole old movie with modern movie patrons dividing their votes among the 14 modern movies. Such that Philadelphia Story finished 2nd. Striking. She reacted to the 2nd place Philadelphia Story.

Clay F

No action genre poll this time but she is reacting to: -"The Long Kiss Goodnight" (apparently her choice) (#1 in Requests action) -"Desperado" (1995) (PAF winner) (#42 in Requests action)

Clay F

Kate & Leopold (2001) is primarily a romantic comedy and not hard sci-fi, but can reasonably be characterized as sci-fi genre. The plot is driven by time travel, made possible because a modern physicist discovers a time portal.

Clay F

It’s arbitrary how narrow or broad you want to be w/genres. The Book of Eli is a post-apocalyptic science-fiction western that merges traditional sci-fi tropes w/gritty, sun-scorched wasteland setting. The movie is classified as science fiction (post-apocalyptic sci-fi and a sci-fi Western) primarily b/c of its setting and genre conventions rather than hard scientific technology. With post-apocalyptic worldbuilding, set 30 years after nuclear holocaust that burned ozone layer and turned Earth into a desolate ash-choked desert, the film fits neatly (e.g. w/Mad Max) into classic sci-fi subgenres.

Clay F

In film + literature, post-apocalyptic dystopian worlds (even w/philosophical, spiritual, or Western elements) fall under broader umbrella of speculative + science fiction. The film has sci-fi tropes + technology, e.g., includes sci-fi/dystopian staples like scavengers, solar flare + nuclear fallout effects, etc. Info as technology + control, e.g., the last remaining King James Bible treated not only as religious artifact, but as a high-value data storage medium. Neural and sensory sci-fi = Eli navigates wasteland w/superhuman precision despite being blind. See “This 2010 Denzel Washington Sci-Fi Film ...” https://www.syfy.com/syfy-wire/book-of-eli-on-peacock-denzel-washington-wins-wasteland

Nolofinwe

Watchmen is a successful comic and a dreadful attempt at a movie just dreadful it was a shame

Richard Maurer

To be fair many newer movies do poorly in polls too, especially when there are one or two extra popular movies in the polls, popularity is the biggest deciding factor in what wins a poll here. While I don’t think that there’s enough interest here to do monthly older film polls I do think there’s enough interest for 1 or maybe 2 a quarter. But putting these older movies in polls against movies like Training Day or Watchmen is just a waste of time and only serves to aggravate the people who do like older movies. They should either do the occasional older movie polls, perhaps using the decades filters on Requests, or just stop putting them in polls with new popular movies, because they will never win those.