Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 587503726.mp4

Downloads

Content

Another creator commentary to tie you over for the new year! Plus a little bonus, which might only serve to drive you crazy!

Here is the first 10 minutes rough cut of the Pam Hupp video that may well never be completed: https://youtu.be/6Rgf9hWBboo

The story: before picking up the Williams case, I had spent about 3 weeks researching, writing, and producing a video on the Hupp case, anticipating that I would be receiving the interrogation of Russ Faria, a man who was convicted of her first known murder.

It turned out the powers that be would not release it, citing ongoing legal procedures with Hupp, who had already pled guilty and been sentenced, but had (and may still have) some appellate issues in the air. My hunch is that it's bullshit, and they just know those tapes will make them look terrible. After I've finished the next project, I'm going to give myself a note to see if I can find someone to help keep sustained pressure on for the release of said tapes - maybe it's pulloffable. I'm pretty much settled that I will not make the video without them, as Russ's ordeal is more than half the story as far as I'm concerned.

LINKS:

A New Kind of Monster: The Secret Life and Shocking True Crimes of an Officer . . . and a Murderer by Timothy Appleby - drawn from quite heavily in this videos research.

John Norman the footwear forensics analyst is a real person! - Some misconceptions on the internet around this due to what I presume was Jim Smyth misspeaking in an interview

UPDATE: [Full Black Screen Update at 1:19:20]

I will be dead honest with you, I have barely sat at my computer since the Kendhammer vid hit youtube. Lots of catching up with friends and WAAAAAY too much drinking and poor eating. I'll hit the ground running in January so I hopefully don't lose too much ground to the Xmas break. I'm going to try to pick up Nancy Brophy as the subject, even though I only know about a sentence worth about the case, but it's been requested a bunch and I know at very least she took the stand, so there should be enough material to put a vid together even if that's basically the extent of the usable footage, which presumably it's not.

As soon as Nancy is done, I'm also going to look at putting together a special Patreon bonus (neither a commentary, nor an addendum) that I was initially going to see if I could put together casually on the side during the Xmas break, which obviously did not pan out!Thanks so much for your patience and support, everyone! Have a very happy new year, and let's all have a cracking 2026!!

Files

Comments

Claire

Yay!!!!!

Tianna C

Yay happy new years!

Devon

Glad you've been taking some time at the end of the year for a well earned break. Happy New Year!

George

Matt GOATchard for the end-of-the-year upload

Alan Holding

Thanks Matt, something to bide the time until the NYE party I feel way too old to be going to!

Fletcher Henery

Happy new year Matt! Hope you’re enjoying it with family

David Jones

Even though there’s a ton of channels that have done this interrogation before, I still think your video is unambiguously the best one.

index.html

> Hupp, who had already pled guilty and been sentenced, but had (and may still have) some appellate issues in the air. She hasn't been tried for Betsy's murder yet. Plus, others are now charged for their involvement in Russ's investigation. So there may be a non-BS reason to delay the tapes' release.

Samuel Stewart

I just rewatched this one the other day actually!

Patrick Murphy

I believe the concern with foot prints isn't identifying the exact shoes, but rather the defense is just "who's to say I was wearing my shoes?", assuming it was the only evidence

Ksenia Jurkovic

Happy New Year Matt, looking forward to watching this one, I think this may have been the first video of yours that I watched. I recently joined your patreon for the first time and have been enjoying your commentaries and addendums. Keep up the great work mate!

AR

the pam hupp case is one of those I will watch every version of every time, and many of us know every bonkers detail of it well. so even if you never get the interrogation footage, please consider finishing and releasing it anyway! would definitely be one of your repeat video watches for me.

Ty P

That guy is really scary. Had everything in life but just really wanted to assault and murder. What a monster!

Alan Holding

OK yes, that intro teaser for the Pam Hupp case is a nice Christmas present but also arrrrgh, I want to see the full thing. Could there be a workaround? I was thinking about Louis Theroux's Scientology documentary where he has actors reenacting alleged scenes. Is the transcript from the interview available in full? It's probably a bad suggestion but maybe something along the lines of voice actors over animations, with "at best the conversation tone was like this", "at worst it was this." A bit too meta and finicky I suppose but I'll just hope the FOIA request gets granted one day instead 🙏

Andy

Thanks for this, Matt. All the best for the NY...just watch those hangovers, mate. I just had my first totally dry Christmas and NY since being an adult and it was great. It doesn’t take very long to get off the ride and wonder why we’re so tied to a drink. Oh, and I don’t think I will ever stop feeling the absolute horror of what was going through Williams’ mind has he looks back and forth at those footprints in silence without even really looking at them.

Vent

In regards to properly deleting files from a computer, I can tell you what I know: When it comes to naively deleting a file, as in the usual way of right-click delete, the computer does not actually destroy the data of that file at all. It only marks the area that file was taking up as free-to-use. When you write something else to the disk, it'll look for some free space that's big enough and write to it, which may be the area you just "deleted", or maybe not (probably not). This means that all the data is still there until it's actually overwritten, and it may remain only partially overwritten for a long long time. As a side note: this is why recovery tools always instruct you to power down the drive as soon as possible for best recovery, to stop anything overwriting the data you are trying to recover. So what's the solution? Well there's many tools for this, but the classic is Unix's 'shred' command, which will overwrite the file many times, with zeros, ones, and random data, before deleting. Analogous to shredding a document before throwing it in the bin. However it's not perfect. They're right when they say that the only way to be sure is to physically destroy the drive. Depending on the type of drive you have, you may end up with 'bad blocks', blocks which were written to but have since broken and can only be read from. If there's enough evidence against you in these bad blocks, no software tool can help you because the hardware itself is the problem. You have to "fix" your drive with a big hammer. Computers, and especially hardware, are complicated. I'm an embedded engineer, a programmer who focuses on hardware, and even I would be hammering drives if it were my freedom on the line. There's too much I don't know.

D

Thanks, Matt! I remember watching Datelines about Pam Hupp case as it was unfolding. Truly an all-time great crime story. I hope you’re able to release a video on it one day!

Shred Cadmium

At about 46 mins in the police officer talks about how they're executing search warrants at both the residence in Ottawa and the one in Tweed, so that's presumably the basis for the bit at the beginning about Williams not being able to get rid of evidence in time - he wouldn't have been able to clear out both houses

DK

This is exactly right. And to fill in the missing piece - there's a plethora of data forensics software that basically scans the "empty space" (the space that was released from deleted files, or space that hasn't ever been used at all) and detects blocks of data that look like video, or photos, or audio, or whathaveyou, and does its best to reconstruct it back into its original format. There's versions of this kind of recovery software available for free that you can use yourself on your drives (if you accidentally delete important photos), and also commercial alternatives that LEOs use which are even more sophisticated. It used to be easier to truly wipe data off of drives with spinning hard drives (by overwriting the deleted blocks a few times), but nowadays with SSDs and NVMe-based flash storage, it's significantly harder to do, as the underlying bits are stored in a much less straightforward, more dynamic way. Still possible, but there's way more pitfalls. Physical destruction is the only failsafe way.

Jonathan Gill

I had a bit of a similar Christmas experience. Not with drink per se, but general slothfulness. Told myself I'd only take a week long break, and it turned into two full weeks of not doing work. So I've been there. I really liked the Russell Williams video. I was completely unfamiliar with the case, though, but Smith's interrogation was extremely compelling to watch.

SimplySnaps

To answer your question of "If a file is "deleted," how come my hard drive says it has 2.0 terabytes?" It's because when a file is permanently deleted (as in, deleted from your recycle bin,) those bytes are all individually marked as "you are allowed to write over me!" in the system. But until the bytes are ACTUALLY overwritten, they still exist. So with enough expertise and patience, a video file that has not been fully overwritten can be, to some extent, restored by identifying the remaining bytes. If a 16gb file is flagged as "you can override me," the file itself still exists up to the point its overwritten. And even then, it's overwritten on a byte-by-byte basis. An mp4 file is just a nice wrapping on a buncha bytes. So even with the wrapping gone, if it's important enough, a digital forensics expert MAY be able to restore it. But it's never a sure thing

Amanda

You thank us for our patience like you haven’t been dropping things left and right this holiday season. Happy New Year to you and yours, Matt 🍾

TinTicket

I always thought you'd have a field day with how the police and prosecution treated Russ Faria. As much as I want to see it, I'm afraid I agree with you - you need the interrogation footage. I wonder if a "done to death" video subject is popular because it has been done to death and people are lazy - as in it is easier to watch a case you know and do the dishes, and clean the cat's litter then sit and pay attention to a new case. I must admit, when ill and needing sounds to wash me to sleep I either go with Cracking the Cryptic or a re-watch of MOCAS or MagooDog.

TinTicket

What I;ve wondered, is who is "we"? When you say "we believe" in a video who is we? Obvs yourself, but is that just stylistic or are there other people behind the scenes?

Ian

Re: the dramatization with the lady investigator. I wonder to what extent studios run up against employment law as well. Like if your productions for the year skew too male, does that create legal risk which you can abate by tweaking source material? It's often framed as them being "too pc" but in my experience executives mostly care about money. There's probably an actual reason hiding somewhere.

Noella

I had the help of a health condition to write off alcohol, which i don't recommend. I think it is just focusing on how you feel afterward and I'd suggest finding substitutes. The non-alcoholic game has really stepped up in the last few years.

Claire

There's a circus that comes to my town a fair bit called Brophy's Circus and for that and other reasons I find myself thinking about Dan Brophy quite a lot. He was a man of a particular template that has been in my life in some way or another for as long as I can remember; a quiet calm hard-working man. Nancy strikes me as the same kind of liar that Chris Watts is: "if they can't make me admit it, they can't prove I did it". The bullheaded clinging to the lie is pure ego. The complete lack of insight as to how their lies are seen by other people is breathtaking. Just because people don't call you out on your bullshit Nancy, doesn't mean they believe it. Looking forward to the vid Matt!

Clare

Just watched your Russ Faria draft and his 911 call was so deeply upsetting. I guess many of the 911 calls we hear on your channel are either from people proven guilty or with significant doubts surrounding their innocence. To know he was completely innocent must add an extra layer, but gosh I keep thinking about it.

Jenifer Joseph

Very excited for the Hupp video in the time you're finally able to release it!

Hamble

I can’t wait for the Brophy video. I’d also love to see you cover the Ashley Benefield case. JCS covered it briefly in a segment from one of his most recent videos, but it’s one that deserve more in-depth coverage. I think it’d be perfect for you style of delivery

sammer

exactly. which is why to actually delete something, you just have to write something on that space. To guarantee that this space does get written over, you need to either overwrite the file with junk before it is deleted (like shred on linux), or if you have already deleted it, make sure that you fill the entire hard drive with junk.

sammer

(I say this as a mildly paranoid person who has sold a computer)

Rob

The best video ever made

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I mean if it was somehow 100% confirmed that those tapes would NEVER be released to anyone under any circumstances, or that they'd been lost/destroyed, then I would probably look at doing the vid and conveying what happened in Russ' interrogation some other way - transcripts exist (though so far never published publicly in full), obviously Russ and his lawyers saw them and I presume they were played at his trial (woops). But barring that, I'm pretty certain I'll wait indefinitely. A video featuring those tapes would be elevated in quality substantially vs yet another vid lacking them, and I have yet to do a "do over" video on a case, having a real "one and done" approach.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Those sorts of things could be interesting to play with in the event it's 100% confirmed the tapes will never be released - transcripts exist somewhere, though also not currently published publicly in full. One commenter has pointed out that Hupp has yet to formally be charged with Betsy's murder (the case that Russ' interrogation is tied to), so there could indeed be a legitimate procedural reason it's being held back, and it may indeed be a (probably long) waiting game.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Andy, Though I'm not ready to go full teetotaler yet, I have had similar experiences to you when taking a 30 day challenge or whatever. Somewhere in and around a week clean, the "spell" sort of lifts and the thing you're supposed to be CHALLENGING yourself to not indulge in doesn't even seem that appealing anymore. I won't lie though, even then, there's the occasional sunny day where I'm hanging out with a friend and start to think, "man, it's dumb I can't even have a couple beers right now" lol - but, very limited, and even that's likely just owing to me building a habit around such situations all these years. I've been contemplating doing "75 Hard" to see if that might lead to a real paradigm shift.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Interesting stuff. I'm still a little confused as how space becomes available when that data is still being stored somewhere - am I correct in inferring it's kind of a function of time? The data will indeed be permanently overwritten (i.e. deleted) when the space is truly needed - and with most criminals, their device is very likely to be confiscated before that period of time and subsequent overwriting happens naturally, with software designed to replicate the process in a click being much better than nothing but still very subject to error. Obviously the temptation for criminals is wanting to appear genuinely clean rather than only getting rid of the smoking gun material. "The FBI went through my computer with fine-tooth comb and found nothing" sounds a lot better than "The FBI tried to look through my computer, but unfortunately it was run over by a truck the previous morning." Still better than them finding the smoking gun of course, but so easy to let the perfect become the enemy of the good!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah - never, you're right. If we're talking about the one particular hard drive in question, I was just saying he wouldn't have known that at the time, and it says something he didn't even attempt to completely destroy it after getting the phone call. Not that it could have made a difference to his chances in the main at that point.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

2 weeks off in December is more than okay, Jon! Going ham on your body because you've come to associate it as a prerequisite for having fun is a different story, and something I need to clean my act up with a bit!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

With this and the previous comment on the matter, I think I get it. Say I have a fresh 1 TB hard drive. I download a 2 GB video - say it's the directors cut of Rob Schneider's The Animal, and I don't want anyone to ever know I watch such rubbish. If I delete it, and remove from recycling, and the FBI investigate me for poor taste, they will likely find the full 2 GB video. If I do the same, but also DL an additional 0.89 TBs of files to my computer before deleting those, the FBI will quite probably still recover SOME of the Schneider movie. If I delete the Scnheider movie, and then absolutely fill my hard drive to capacity before deleting the files, preferably rinsing and repeating multiple times, then in all likelihood the FBI will have nothing on me...but burning the hard drive is still the only 100% fail safe. Right?

SimplySnaps

#notlegaladvice of course, but that is the general idea! Bytes never go back to being "unused," but if you replace every single byte with new data, it will be impossible to tell what used to be in those spots. Picture a deleted byte as a dirty hotel room. The previous customer might be gone, but the room still has their sweat on the bedsheets, their hair in the drain, etc. THEORETICALLY, if the hotel room is occupied by 10 more customers and is cleaned 10 more times, any remnant of the tenant you were hoping to find is completely gone, overwritten ages ago by new information and stains. In the most logical extreme of this, cycling through 2TB of new data should leave not a single byte of your horrible movie taste, as not one byte of data from "The Animal" would remain. But if about 100mb of The Animal remained, and it was just the right info, they might be able to retrieve several complete frames of the film, and then you'd have some serious questions to answer to your Film School professor.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

On Popular Subjects: While I don't make such conscious considerations when deciding on subjects to pick up, I believe your theory is about right. People are more likely to click on subjects they know about. So while a subject like Russ Williams will make me groan a little in anticipation of the "I've seen this a million times!" comments, it will probably in all likelihood lead to a higher view count than an obscure subject - though there are always exceptions. "Coldest Case" being a stark one from my channel, then in the opposite direction, Joel Guy, for instance, got relatively underwhelming numbers despite being an often requested case...might wanna try a thumbnail/title adjustment on that one when I have a moment now I think of it. On "We": It's just a Royal We. Stylistically, because my vids are made in an omnipresent narrator sort of style, even though it's no secret that it's me, with my name being in the title of my channel, I believe saying "I think", or what have you, will snap the viewer out of the story a bit. So I try to find ways to avoid referring to the authors subjective interpretation wherever I can, but when I can't, I go Royal We.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

May well be...if it was a Canadian production, especially with government finding, it'd make even more sense, because I think they're all about that sort of stuff ("Hurrr! Durrrr!")

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I do keep Coopers Zero in the fridge, and you're right, it does work a treat when on a break. Another tip along the same lines: Make vodka, lemon and soda your poison of choice when on and then remove the vodka when off. Tricks your brain pretty good I've found. Sorry about the health condition, but hopefully the onus on removing the booze winds up being a long term blessing.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah, I haven't even rewatched it but I remember that being gut churning. I have also by the way, never come across a confirmed liar who put on an act like THAT. I respect there's some hindsight in play, and a part of me understands he was SO beside himself that it came across as over the top...still though, to repeat, I have not personally seen anyone fake that level of over the top where they're just absolutely breaking the register. Also, there was a lot more to the case at the time than just interpreting Russ' behavior. A story for another day!

Jeff

I put away alcohol completely after a night of terrible drinking with a distant relative. Haven't looked back once and am feeling great.

Rob

I've watched this dozens of times over the years. It's not often you see these guys accept their fate & he even says aloud "its hard to believe this is happening" & you can feel it sink in, like your life is completely over. But it's also like the moment they sat down they both knew this was how the interview was going to go. Then he very calmly walks him thru his crimes not bragging, not proud. It's a unique interrogation imo.

Theresa Mary

I'm an educator in my 12th year, and I have to say the two weeks off for the holiday break is a necessity. I aim to do as little as possible each day, and I generally succeed. I also had to google Silly Season, and it sounds delightful.

Nicholas Piazza

My god you’re right, the Hupp teaser gave me intense “blue balls.” Very compelling narrative 😭

AR

I think previously I just watched the pam hupp video and I'm just now returning to the actual commentary. one thing to consider re: the unduly feminist TV movie lol is that actors' contracts are very very strict about credits, and a lot of actors contractually have to have a set number of minutes on-screen in order to justify their film credit. And I'm not entirely sure how this part works but I think a production that doesn't offer equal top billing to the actress could potentially run afoul of industry union casting guidelines, which are also very specific. So I would chalk the change up to industry requirements before I blamed Woke lol.

Lol W

When I introduce people to your channel, this is the video I send them. It’s a glorious piece of work, matched only by the detective.

Lol W

One thing I picked up on from his confession was that he hit one victim with a torch and was surprised it didn’t knock her out, he then did the same again on another victim! He doesn’t learn well.

Lol W

Oh! And on remorse but enjoying the act, as someone who got sober 20 years ago, I remember enjoying drinking at night and having remorse about it in the morning.

Adrien

There is actually a 100% fail safe without burning the hard drive, assuming you trust the software. There are programs that will literally go through every single byte of a hard drive and overwrite them, no need to gamble on having filled those particular sections of memory with other videos or data. There will then be none of the movie for the FBI to find on the drive. However, these tools leave quite distinctive patterns, compared to normal use, so they will know that you went to quite some effort to erase _something_, though not exactly what.

misused alien

I don't say this to be disrespectful or crass, but I probably own no more than 15 pairs of underwear 😬

Toma Kontrimaitė

Hey hey, new patreon here, just wanted to appreciate your humor some more. When you did the “he was so good and then he walked in and killed this and that and took pictures and blah blah blah” - I had to rewind the tape several times when I watched the original video to get all of my snickers of “Matt, you so funny” out. Really really appreciate that, Matt🫡🫡🫡 There are months of me not hearing your commentary and so I have to hop on youtube again and again to hear how your brain works and feel content with life. Thank you😌

Heather

Yes it is essentially a function of time (and a testament to how much storage even the smallest of consumer electronics have these days) — if I heavily used all of the storage across my entire computer including all types of memory, it would “safe delete” the earlier versions of what was previously in that free-marked memory.

Belinda Davey

Not know he has a new mostly audio approach!

Paracelsian

It’s never been easier lol. (Most) SSDs have manufacturer tools to cryptographically wipe the drive with a single click in the BIOS (or even a program from their website). Failing that (or in addition) you can just run a couple full disk encryptions -> format. The encryption key becomes useless and the encrypted data is inaccessible barring a decade of quantum computing being thrown at it. Multiply that 100x for each full disk encryption -> format you do. I used to never resell hard drives but I feel far more confident doing it with SSDs.