Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 605468579.mp4

Downloads

Content

Another Creator Commentary to tie you over!

Links:

The doctor who really didn't want to be there: https://www.youtube.com/live/QhiG72HBPqc?si=IQaFeXFepVmWxVMk&t=8223 [Go to 2:40:35 to see his reaction when he's excused lol]

Almost Friday: https://www.youtube.com/@AlmostFridayTV/videos

UPDATE [Full Black Screen Update at 1:31:21]:

I'm into the writing phase of Nancy Brophy, still somewhat figuring out my angle but definitely have a rough idea of the areas I want to go. I think I have a decent shot at getting it up by the end of February - that damn 28 day month can put the pressure on a bit though, so I'd give it maybe a north of 50% chance we're looking at first week of March. If it won't be out by end of Feb, I'll definitely put up an update post with a much clearer idea of what's left in front of me :)

Thanks so much as always for your patience and support!

Files

Comments

Claire

Yayyyyyy!!!

Clare

Excited to listen to the commentary, but in truth this is the one video of yours I haven't rewatched. I just hate this guy too much 😭

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It’s also among the less viscerally stimulating for reasons I sort of touch on in parts of the commentary! Still not without it’s merits though - good ep overall I think, owing mostly to a great heroine :)

August!!

This patreon has really held my hand through my PhD so far - nothing like a good analysis while you’re analysing lol - thanks Matt :)

Alan Holding

Thanks Matt! I don't know which commentary you said it but the "circumstantial evidence is still evidence" line has stuck with me ever since, so I'm curious to see a supercut of "the evidence is circumstantial at best" because it's become such a cliché. Oh and fuck Trevor, the fucking arsehole.

Claire

I liked the story you told about the adventures of the kids during the event. I also fucking hate that guy and I don't think he should have been allowed to cross-examine her.

ChiralSpiral

In regards to seeing yourself at fourteen, I’m in my late 30s now and I think I look like a fucking child in photos where I’m 19 😆

albrechto

Look into the "The Trial of Tim Heidecker" from On Cinema. It's fantastic. Tim ends up firing his lawyer after day one, and the judge does a great job acting it out.

Adam Berck

I think the argument he was trying to make with the teapot. Is that they were not fighting they were working together at that moment even having tea together. It was friendly / romantic not a kidnapping case. it really is weak evidence though with all the other stuff against him.

sunny crays

I think this is it. It ties in with the who normally drove question?

nebulazer

as someone who spent most of their childhood in alabama, excellent southern drawl.

Jonathan Gill

Tea: wild shot in the dark here, because I agree with your original video that his lines of questioning are unusually aimless. Since he just asked if there were any signs of disturbance in the photo of the kitchen, is he drawing attention to the container of tea a way of saying "see, no fight here; nothing messy or chaotic"? Second guess is that he wants to imply she was up all night after having caffeine?? I don't know man.

Felix V

Season 1 Episode 13 of The Wire, the lawyer Levy says "You have a voice on a tape. You have no seizure. You have no buy-money. You have forensic evidence that is, at best, circumstantial."

CMC

Did I miss it, was there an explaination why there’s a link to almost Friday TV? I mean they’re great just a a shoutout I never thought I’d see here

CMC

Oh gotcha, thank you. As a fan of you and them cool to see you give them a recommendation.

marrow

Hi Matt, sorry this is irrelevant but before my membership goes I have to ask. Do you think you’d ever do a video on Chimp Crazy or a similar topic? Since you mention the tiger video is one of your favorites and the subject is so interesting, I’d love to see your take on it.

Ifrah Majeed

12 angry men is a fantastic movie!

shad

As others have pointed out on the tea, he was definitely looking forward to her saying yes, to then follow up with the argument there couldn't have been a struggle in the kitchen, because it was undisturbed (which she didn't even claim on the stand, and if she did before, he failed to call it out).A skilled lawyer never would have given her the chance to say no to a supposition so fundamental for the entire line of questioning.

Nicholas Piazza

On the topic of your next vid don’t rush! Take your time and let the 10 or so holiday pounds burn off! 😂 I can’t speak for everyone but we’re patient, just do your thing

Jenifer Joseph

This was one of the harder videos on your channel to watch and I can't rewatch it even though I've rewatched other videos of yours. The work you do here is great but the trauma that woman went through and the judge overruling reasonable objections as she gets retraumatized by her abuser sickens me. I think when you say the video is 'quieter' I think there's just a lot more pain and grief visible to the audience than say Sarah Boone since in a video like that you can just focus on how dumb she sounds and acts. The levity here is just less, and I think that it's okay that not every true crime video be the most sensationalized thing ever. On an unrelated note, have you considered ever covering Diane Downs?

muruba

So excited to hear your take on the Nancy Brophy saga. Like another commenter here already said, I also can't watch this creator commentary because this particular video is triggering for me (women being re-traumatized and helpless face to face with their abuser usually is), but I'm glad for the update!

fuzzyclub

Love the channel, been a huge fan for years. Wondering if you would ever look at any UK cases? Lucy Letby is of particular interest right now, although I’m not sure if the full interrogation is easily available. Would love to see your take although it’s an extremely sensitive case.

Erin

I'd love to see a Lucy Letby video!

Erin

This is one of my favorite videos, thanks for the commentary!

Dapper Swindler

i feel like people dont say it enough but that woman is brave a hell and its insane that she had to confront this ghoul because he wanted to play legal games

Sherlock Holmes

I'll have you know, Matt, that you are personally responsible for making February the longest month of the year rather than the shortest, as every day I wake up lamenting that it's not over yet so we can get to the next video...!

rooklift

Re: "circumstantial evidence" - if you want a funny one, Star Trek 6 has a trial where Kirk's Klingon lawyer says "the evidence against my clients is entirely circumstantial" - you could find it on Youtube under "Klingon Show Trial".

Fay

https://youtu.be/gvjOA7Qg_oc?si=whKyy0PreP8a7Dt3 This is a great video talking about parent alienation. As a child of divorce my mother use to say all kinds of nasty stuff about my dad to me. But I think the most manipulative thing she did was to buy me stuff if I promised not to move in with my dad. I have mended the relationship with my mom, but it took about 10 years and it's still a work in progress. Also my dad wasn't a Saint when it came to bad mouthing my mom.

Grace B

i was surprised to hear you say that some people were underwhelmed with this particular case being covered. this is actually one of my favorite videos of yours! Summers farcical attempt at self representation paired with your style of humor really sets it up for a few great zingers imo. i’m also a big fan of the Anthony Wiener video for similar reasons :)

Billy Green - The Filthy Casual

Regarding the tea, I believe the point he tried (and failed) to make was an extremely weak "gotcha" moment to discredit her testimony: "Is this how it normally looks?" "Yes." "Is the tea normally there?" "No." "Aha, therefore this isn't how it normally looks and you seem less credible." Granted, this is very stupid, though that means it's still very realistically something he would do.

Katie Bradshaw

44:00 marital rape wasn't considered to exist until sometime in the 90s in the U.S., and there are few precedents set on rulings in favor of the spouse who was raped. It's literally easier to convict when it's called aggravated sexual assault. That's as far as I know, at least.

NW

Sooo I’m not sure why but when you pop in to add something, there’s an audio of you talking in the background? This is the second video on your patreon I’ve noticed it in. It makes it impossible to pay attention :(

Patrick Tanswell

Perhaps the argument with the tea was that he let her sit down and have a cup of tea, which takes time to make... So it couldn't have been a fast and brutal struggle like she claimed? Maybe?