Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 653928256.mp4

Downloads

Content

DO NOT READ COMMENTS AND DEFINITELY DON’T GOOGLE ANYTHING BEFORE FINISHING THIS ONE!

…So, I did a thing. 

This is a presentation in a similar vein to the addendum videos I’ve done, on a case that doesn’t have the usual sorts of materials I typically rely on, but that I personally think is one of the most fascinating cases of the 20th century.

It consists of a step by step walkthrough of events that transpired and new revelations that came to light over a multi-year period, as well as a case theory which is, as far as I know, original to me. A bit of a first, as my specialty is normally conveying other people’s ideas. So if you’re already familiar with it, you’ll hopefully get a lot out of this anyway. If you’re not, man are you in for a ride. 

I really hope you all find it as interesting as I do, or close enough anyway. I’m excited for a Patreon exclusive on a case that hasn’t been covered on the main channel, even though, maybe especially because, it got away from me a bit. This was supposed to be like 90 minutes!

Lord knows you all deserve it. Thanks so much for your support! Let me know if you have any questions or challenges to my ultimate theory in the comments. I love talking about this case, as you can see :)

Files

Comments

Claire

YAAAAAAAAAYY!!

Alan Holding

Three hours when I'm already on the couch with a sleepy cat? Yes please! Cheers Matt, see you on the other side.

Claire

IT'S THREE FUCKING HOURS LONG?? Thank you Matt 🥹

Little Bear

I mean, “dead ringer” seems pretty right. I mean that’s crazy haha

Jacob Jones

We're so back!!! Very nice surprise!

MyNameFits

surprise 3 hour listen on my day off? You spoil me Matt

Ben Harrington

1.5 hours in and I do declare that this format is just as absorbing as your usual mainline videos! More, please!

AR

ahhh can't wait!!

Little Bear

Ah wow, maybe I’m just dumb as rocks, but that fucking completely blindsided me.

Little Bear

This format works gangbuster by the way. Two big thumbs up from me. Even if they aren’t nearly as long as this one going forward haha. Lots of interesting cases that don’t have a great narrative structure for a video. This seems like a solid, much less production required, solution, that still feels really satisfying. It’s still really clear how much effort you put into all of it, which I hope is good to hear.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Really appreciate it :) And yeah, this was a bit of a low scale passion project. Wildly under talked about case given how many layers of bonkers it is.

AR

I can never remember the victims' names in this case (which is indicative of a lot, I know) but I was listening along like 'when will I recognize what case this is' and all it took were the words 'two military families.' it really is that kind of case.

caleb

What an awesome surprise. I'll start this as soon as my coffee is ready

Timothy Lane

Definitely hit like a ton of bricks. Was kind of hopeful it would go the other way or there'd be a surprise suspect. Sad to see someone who has what most people would consider a good life just throw it away. Loving friends and family, supporting even after he was convicted the first time couldn't have been easy Also can't even think about the husband who knew all along but tried to stay professional about it. I hope the best for him. As for the format I loved it! Hope to get more of these.

Alan Holding

Now I'm on the other side of 3hrs+, and no spoilers, this was great. I didn't know anything about the case and I loved the whole presentation. To think I struggled to get through Scorsese's The Irishman but this had me glued to watching a flickering orange orb for the whole thing, that's the best compliment I can think of. Definitely worth the Patreon subscription, and I look forward to more like this.

Gigi

Matt you have outdone yourself once again 👏👏👏

Clare

I have never felt more satisfaction than when you called him a c*nt after the reveal. What a horrific case, but an excellent video and I love this format. Thanks as always Matt

AR

I think your theory of the crime is more or less right on the money! I have always thought Hennis must have premeditated this both because he knew her husband wouldn't be home, and because of the sliver of corduroy pants indicating he brought that extra set of clothing. It honestly reminds me so much of Bryan Kohberger. Although there were certainly plenty of hints in the build-up to Kohberger's explosive violence, I feel like if we had a better closer view of Tim Hennis in 1985, we'd probably see similar glimmers of obsession and controlling behaviors.

Amber Green (Israel)

I have to say, I feel like we owe you way more for this episode; you’re undselling yourself. It’s simply amazing. You’ve made my week.

Samantha Pullen

Home sick for the day but Matt just dropped a new video?! A much needed treat ❤️

Samantha Pullen

ALSO: The moment. THAT moment. My heart plummeted. And then just a feeling of horror. Because I probably wouldn’t have voted to convict him. Even if I thought in reality he was guilty, I would have (so) reluctantly said I must be sure. THE FUCKING ATM WITHDRAWAL WHILE ON DUTY. It was the grain that tipped the scale for me. Absolutely brilliant story-telling Matt!

Steven M MOELLER

Excellent! Really enjoyed this one and would love move in the future. Within reason for you, of course!

kat

nah i was blindsided as well! there was a tickle in the back of my head thinking "well, matt hasn't presented any other suspects or motives or random coincidences... but weirder twists have happened... it could be an absolute rando with no connections whatsoever who went off to live a normal life and whose family member took a 23 and me test and oh drat.... there's the pesky DNA presented directly into COTIS." brilliant presentation mr orchard! looking forward to more of this type of video.

Amber Green (Israel)

Are you kidding me?! To say I loved this audio-video would be the understatement of the century, right up there with saying Russell Williams stole just a 'few' pairs of underwear...

Gil

Please more of this! I know you can't do these all the time but this one was great!

Ferdia Dwane

Fantastic work! Definitely one of the most captivating cases you have covered, I'm glad I forgot I had heard it a few years ago as your storytelling is second to none.

Virginia

Why not the baby girl? He had a baby girl at home. Could be that simple - even psychos can love, and that might just have been too close to home.

Mae

I’m sorry: up at the fart of a sparrow????

Lee Basil

me halfway through a Matt Orchard video after he told me it's gonna be twisty: "wow, the pieces are all coming together. I'm confident that nothing else truly world shattering can happen" me two thirds through the Matt Orchard video, every time: :^O thank you for sharing this one!! I knew NOTHING about it, and now I'm going to be haunted by it forever. your West Memphis Three video is another one I think about all the time--weighing reasonable doubt against the odds, the cultural narratives and counter-narratives, the behavior of the suspects, and the things we really really hope to be true. I'm sure surviving members of that second jury were horrified, even if I think they made the "right" decision given the info they had.

Deanna & Kurt

A three hour matt orchard video... its not my birthday or Christmas, wtf is happening?

Deanna & Kurt

Il be honest, your jon benet addendum is my favorite video overall. I would love something similar on the west Memphis three and holtzclaw. Hearing you lay out your theory of the case is great content

CJ

I am new to the Patreon, and this is my first “new video” (as in wasn’t already upload when I signed up) TAKE MY MONEY SIR!!!!! What an absolute home run of a first surprise video! I hadn’t heard of the case (non American, and born in the mid ‘80s). Absolutely consumed by the story. Thank you!!

James Fairbourn

Outstanding. Like a great book, I couldn’t turn it off. This is first class journalism

Dustin

Top tier Matt.. more of this. I’ll pay double!

Jess Davis

Matt, you are impeccable. I love your humanity.

Matthew Thayer

Weird comment, but I found out about this right as I was going to bed(needless to say, couldn't watch it then). Dreamed about watching the video, the subject of which I know nothing about, so my brain just made up a case. Don't remember all the details, but the scratches on one of the girls' backs were important, the murders didn't happen all at once, and a hospital and a rabbi were involved somehow. And most people thought the mom did it, but that wasn't universally agreed upon by any means. Maybe someone else finds this interesting.

Mister TIBBS!

Honestly this was just as entertaining as a regular episode. Great job.

Ian Tommerup

Incredible work as always, your videos have a perfect combination of research/respect for the subject and an entertaining flair. I would love to see more content like this for cases you wouldn’t normally cover

James

Hot damn Matt. You’ve outdone yourself.

cool_ranch

you are my goat Matty Ice, this was a great upload. btw calling you Matty Ice now, hope you don't mind

Matthew Thayer

Marking it at the point where you said you wanted us to make up our minds: I have reasonable doubt. At least with the information presented.

Evan Monroe

I paused the video at the court of Matt moment where you asked “Is he guilty beyond a reasonable doubt?”. The reason that I said guilty was in part because the killer in question had so much time to clean the scene. Barely any evidence was discovered in the house, but that’s accounted for by the cleaning. And while eyewitness testimony is infamously prone to influence, that composite sketch (particularly the nose for my money) was rather compelling. Coincidences happen, but I don’t think the oddities are enough to acquit. Now that I’m finished with the video, that was one hell of a roller coaster. I think the severity of the crime, and that guttural sense of “we can’t let the bastard get away” makes it difficult to be objective in a case like this. The crime scene was left for days, because of that much of the evidence is unreliable or sanitized. Therefore, at the beginning the jury mainly had somewhat hazy eyewitness accounts. Coincidences happen, but when it comes to “reasonable doubt” the coincidences pointing away from Tim went beyond reasonable back when the evidence at the first trial was presented. Love this format with minimal editing, and I think it’s brilliant for a case like this or JonBenét Ramsey. So glad I took your advice and didn’t Google anything, because this is one hell of a true crime story.

Aurora H.

For a case about the army there sure was a lot of discussion of the navy seamen

Aurora H.

Also tbh a huge part of the reason i love your content is because of your voice. Its just got a great radio-man tone. So a podcast version of your content is welcome and greatly appreciated

Brandon Tingle

Bravo Matt. I’d never heard of this case before now, and as such, my jaw dropped when you declared the DNA matched Tim. Really appreciate you taking the extra time you did with this one. Feels like it was warranted and I’d look forward to more.

Robert Lupo

What a treat. The last 3 hrs of my shift flew by. Thank you!

Hope Luther

Don’t get me wrong, I love your videos, but if you regularly put out content like this, it would for sure be my favorite podcast. I mean your videos are my favorite YouTube channel.

Sherlock Holmes

Just yesterday I was doing the calculation on when we might see your next video, and thinking it would almost certainly not be before beginning of July at the earliest, and then what do I see this morning, but a new video! And not just any old video, but a THREE HOUR LONG video! On a case I didn't know! I am absolutely thrilled. For the data's sake, in the Court of Matt, I did not think there was enough evidence to convict him beyond a reasonable doubt. One thing that I thought was shaky was the certainty on the date of the murders. I didn't think they could use the number of piled up newspapers as the evidence of that. I was thinking that the perpetrator could have had them held hostage in there for a while and just not bothered to leave the house and get the papers. I WAS surprised to find out that the DNA was his, but only because I thought that with so much more time remaining that it had to be someone else, and not because I thought he was innocent at any point. Great video, and just as engrossing as your usual stuff with more visuals. I honestly listen more than watch anyway.

Violet Lucca

I came to the comments to mention this fantastic book. I have no problem asserting that Tim Hennis brought skills he learned at work over to the Eastburn home that night. (The meticulous cleanup, for example, is something an operator would do.) God only knows what he got up to overseas.

Reiken Kayzer

I'd just like to say, this format was amazing. Not all cases lends themselves as grand video productions, but their stories deserve to be told. I would be really pleased if you kept this up. Not all of them needs to be three hours, but if that's the time it takes to get the story out, then so be it. I'm already happy with the commentary and addendums we get as patreons, so this would be another great add to that. I were also among the people who didn't know anything about this case. And I thought I'd do part of it now, the rest later. It is three hours after all. But three hours flew by! Keep up the fantastic work. We're all here for the quality, not the quantity.

caleb

This was great, every bit as enjoyable as your regular videos. Made my day

birdie

my jaw genuinely dropped at the reveal you got me fully

CMC

Funny enough on that question of how long for a welfare check, my mom is a bit of a worrier. I once left my phone dead for about 12-15 hours because I left the charger in the car and didn’t want to go get it before bed, and slept in as I’d been working a lot and had a day off. Due to unanswered texts in calls in that span, my sisters were on the way to my place by the time I got the charger. So depending on familial situations, at least for me, that’s the longest I guess I can go without getting a form of welfare check.

Merglo Mclaughlin

Ok just wanna say this was an amazing episode. I think you did an amazing job making it feel like an off the cuff addendum video, but slowly revealed it to be given the same time and effort as your main channel stuff. For the first half i truly believed this was a case that would forever be unsolved just by how you presented it. Like at the beginning i was thinking "oh the dna will reveal who did it itll just take years to get there" and right before the reveal (for lack of a better word) your delivery had me convinced this case would reman forever in limbo. 10/10 may he rot in hell

Anna Loos

I went in completely blind and I felt like I got punched in the fucking face when you got to the DNA evidence. I'm still reeling.

hithere

I gasped when the DNA test results dropped. you have a real poker face with your presentation as always, i didnt see it comming at all.

gurufabbes

Absolutely stellar work here. Delivery, details... presentation. Please keep up the great work.

gurufabbes

Same. That's an apt description.

Lyric

holy wow. i'd never heard of this case and I absolutely did not see that coming. Please please please more of these.

Laura Grimm

Excellent storytelling! As always. As a woman, I thought of the dog detail right away; my dog is my personal security alarm and I was worried as soon as the dog was adopted. When you revealed the DNA evidence, I was SHOCKED. I figured "there's another hour and half or more in this video, we will surely go through several more suspects." But no! It was him. Wild! What a tragic and horrible case. Thankfully Mr. Eastburn was able to remarry and I hope he has found some measure of peace and happiness in his life.

AleValdez

I did not know anything about the case going in and I took this wild ride willingly. My only regret: I cannot re-experience it again. What a masterclass!

Aaron Palmer

I started my run about 90 minutes in and that reveal made me stop in place. I was absorbed and it fucking left me standing in the middle of the sidewalk saying “no way!”.

Peter Mather

Very well done ! Liked the the length,the presentation style, and most definitely the no spoilers, more like this please

Brigitte Colbert

"Up at sparrow's fart" is a pretty common Brit/Aussie/Kiwi term to complain about getting up / being awake SUPER early; AKA complaining you've been up since "the crack of sparrows" or "half past sparrow fart".

George

Joke's on you, Matt. I always just listen to your videos instead of watching, so this was basically a normal 3+ hour banger from you as far as I'm concerned. I'd pay for the higher Patreon tier if we got these regularly.

Fugue

How much was the Nancy Brophy case in your mind while researching this one? I say this as someone who came in blind but was gut-locked on Tim's guilt from beginning to end, I could not help but keep thinking that it was similar to the Brophy case in that they were able to get away with on a direct evidence level but we're dead to rights on a circumstancial level.

Jesse

one thing you left out of the conviction dilemma is that it isn't: between A) convicting the wrong man or B) letting the killer off the hook, because convicting the wrong man also actually includes letting the actual killer of the hook. I'm not done the video yet, I just wanted to mention that because the "convict him just in case" idea lets oneself of the hook a little too easy

Jess

first hour of this video: i cannot believe they convicted him, there is so little hard evidence to convict him beyond a reasonable doubt. hour one - two: ya see, he’s a real stand up dude. he was set up! that FUCKING BOMBSHELL RIGHT AT THE TWO HOUR MARK MATT?! WHAT. hour two - three: “not so smart are ya now, cunt?” is the appropriate reaction. semen. semen. semen. the act he put on for years after he was acquitted … oh he is sick. shout out to Gary Eastburn and his parental intuition for being convinced it was him even after Tim was acquitted. this was a fucking roller coaster and you knocked it out of the park. what a fucking video Matt.

Sylvia

I think in terms of affirming the "serial killer next door myth" idea, the only one I could throw as a counter is the Golden State Killer, but even then I think he only blended in as well as he did because he masked his need for violence by being a cop. He had a history of extreme threats of violence to a girlfriend which likely wouldn't be known by most people in his later married life, so he may have actually seemed pretty normal. His wife was a divorce attorney for most of their marriage and would have been financially independent and obviously aware of her rights in a divorce and she did not divorce him until months after his arrest. DeAngelo may have been one of the best at blending into society. Not an expert on his case though. You also said yourself Russel Williams qualifies as a serial killer, and he's definitely a contender. But that's all I've got. Otherwise yeah, totally agree most serial killers are known antisocial or violent people, even the most neighborly types typically are domestic abusers. Aaaaand I love this format btw

Jesse

great video... was blindsided by the sperm thing, wow

Claire

Okay. As is usual for me, I have a lot of thoughts. So numerous are they that I am considering turning them into a voice message to post on the Discord; is it possible to post voice clips on there? What I CAN say at the outset is this: a key feature of this vid is no clips edited in, just VO 'n' logo. This means I could put it on to fall asleep to as there aren't any sudden toilet flushes in interrogation rooms iykyk. And it's THREE HOURS LONG. It's perfect. We are truly blessed Patreons.

Steve

So, he was like Bryan Kohberger. Great video! You inspired me to get the Innocent Victims audiobook.

Claire

It was the perfect application of that particular noun indeed.

Claire

"See, my attention span is just fine!" is what the kids say in your Irishman scenario these days 😁

Claire

Also, tangential question - was the orange orb flickering or pulsing to you? To me it looked like it was pulsing, but I had shall we say retired for the night by then.

Claire

Was it noticeably less time to edit to make it worth doing others?

Claire

One of the rare times I found myself more and more delighted by increasing mentions of semen! For the avoidance of doubt, I'm plenty fine with a COUPLE of semen mentions but it's not often you'll see me getting excited over a LOT.

Claire

George I must tell you that you're missing out on many sly remarks from Matt in the form of silent images or comments or arrows on-screen. But I respect your choice.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Oh this format is way quicker to make in terms of minute of work to minute of content ratio, the voice-over especially. I mean when you take into account I was working on this basically since Nancy went up on YT, that's like one month for a 3 hour vid - night and day. Wasn't supposed to be this gigantic though, and unfortunately it's just not good business spending a month on a bonus, much as I love you all. So 100% there will be other vids in this format going forward, but nothing on this scale in the near future. It was just a matter of I really think this is one of the most fascinating cases of the 20th century, so lets fucking do it right. I certainly don't regret that decision and am very glad to give everyone a real proper bonus.

2bit

Incredible work, as always. Really, you’re the best at what you do. Huge respect for you and your research and storytelling and for giving the tragic subject the respect it deserves. I never come away from a Matt Orchard video feeling like someone’s tragedy was exploited for entertainment; i very much appreciate the respect given to the victims.

shad

Fantastic video! I feel so lucky to be a supporter. As someone who often listens to those like podcasts (only occasionally scrambling to get my phone when a photo is mentioned), this is really great. This may not be what you're going for in your polished, main channel videos, but I think it's great content. When you mention cutting stuff, I often find myself wishing you'd go off and include every little thing, I'd be very happy with a 10h Matt video 😂 As for the case, I think I was in the same boat. Not guilty. If someone asked me if I think he did it, I'd say yes, but that's different to "beyond reasonable doubt". What a relief to hear they at least got him in the end. One thing I caught myself on though is failing to keep in mind how far the forensic science has gone in the last 40 years, and weighing that evidence appropriately.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

A lot of people have been asking for a WM3 Addendum, and I've finally figured out what to do. I am going to do one, I am going to do it right...but I'm going to do it in PARTS. And they'll be spread out between main releases, meaning months and months, probably well over a year before I've said all I want to say. That's the bad news. Good news is no compromise on completeness. The reason I've been putting it off so long is I know how much I want to say is...a lot of stuff. Even in this format it'd probably take a comparable amount of time to a main video, and I can't afford to not upload to the main channel for that long. Release schedule is ridiculous as it is. So next goal is to figure out wtf the next vid even is and seriously hit the ground running on that to make up for some of the time ol' Tim took from me, then hit the ground running on the next video after that to see if I can do better than once a quarter again, THEN I think I'll put part 1 of the WM3 Addendum together. More good news, Part 1 will be "The Two Big Things" which will lay out what I see as about 85% the basis for my position on that case. So although I'll still have way more to say, you'll get to know the what and lot of the why of my position from the first part.

Jess

LOL!!! SERIOUSLY 😂

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Another amazing thing about this case is how much clarity knowing it was 100% him gives to things that were previously tricky. ATMs is a perfect example. Pre 2006, it's a really good reason to be skeptical it could be him. Then when you know about the DNA and look at it again it's like, "Oh yeah, obviously he did that to cover himself, duh"

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Shit, that's not a bad point actually Violet, I wonder if he did have opportunities for nastiness while deployed. He wasn't a combat soldier (not sure why, big fn dude) but still... Will add the Fort Bragg book to my long list.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah I don't think BK is similar in the sense of you'd never guess he was a psycho like you say, but the basic apparent psychological drive of wanting to do it for the experience of it is essentially the same...assuming my theory is right that is.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah, another good potential explanation there. And I do believe Tim genuinely loved his own family, which is sort of hard to get your head around when considering the sort of person I'm positing, but there ya go.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Ya know I was actually a radio host for 2.5(?) years before this gig...At a small alternative station, because despite your kind words (appreciated) I DON'T have a classic radio voice at all. My favorite online insult I've ever gotten was "this guy sounds like an elf." Brutally on the money.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Fair call. I still say (hard) 7, but honestly I'm not sure I could just about ever give a police sketch more than an 8 seeing as they do leave a little bit of vagueness lest members of the public dismiss sightings they shouldn't (I'm guessing). Not taking away from how crazy it is Pat described him so accurately off of a seconds long interaction in the dark from several nights ago. What a fucking legend.

deadbeef33

As someone who came into this completely blind. To answer your question, the DNA reveal *did* hit me like a ton of bricks. I'd been skeptical of Tim's guilt from the start, and although you said that the eyewitness was clearly not the culprit to the point to where you didn't bother going into it, he seemed quite suspicious to me. Not necessarily to the point where I was sure that he was the culprit instead, but suspicious enough to where I would have heavily discounted his testimony. Maybe I would have benefited a bit more if you had gone into the reasons why you said he clearly wasn't the culprit. But because of all of that, I was convinced Tim was innocent up until the point of the bombshell DNA reveal. Well done.

Emmaly Withnell

This was the best surprise! The audible "YESSSS" that came from me when I saw it..... Thanks for this!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Good thoughts Evan, and a legit take. And now you know the ending you also know your instincts were on the money. I agree with your priorities as well. I could fairly easily look past about everything else - even the bin fire. Looks super, super bad, but people do burn their trash sometimes so should that really be the straw that breaks the camels back in a death penalty case? ...But that Cone sighting is just incredible, and if I were to vote to convict the first time round, it would be on the basis of not being able to get past that.

Jess

all 4.2K of my followers who are strictly there for my NBA content are going to hear about you every time you drop. i’m holding them hostage about you Matt. MUCH LOVE ❤️

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Especially after only taking 2 hours. I wonder if some of them thought, "we should have at least taken the prosecution a bit more seriously." In fairness though, reporting suggests the defense really did wipe the floor with them in presentation the second time round. Gary Eastburn even said, politely as ever, he felt the second pros team phoned it in a little bit. A case is only as strong as you convey it.

ajla

The level of research you do down to the last detail does not go unnoticed. Another great video!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think possibly a majority of viewers are like this, which is fine, though a little bit heartbreaking because they are designed to be watched. Even this style, though to a much lesser degree. And thanks for the higher tier offer, though you'll never have to!...Unless I have to eventually bump it up a touch for inflation (If Patreon don't already do that). I don't love paywalling proper content, so the compromise is keeping it at a super accessible price that only real dickheads can earnestly complain about lol.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Well picking up on the Direct/Circumstantial lesson in the Brophy vid - Another reason it's silly to want to argue over which one is "better", is it's often difficult to say where Direct Evidence ends and Circumstantial Evidence begins - because they're foundational, meta categories. Like in Brophy - technically the security footage is direct evidence. How do we know her car was there? Because it was captured on video - direct. But she's not being charged for driving her car in the area, she's being charged for murdering Dan. Her driving in the area creates a (extremely clear and inescapable) line of inference to the conclusion she murdered Dan, and that's the circumstantial part. Here, Cone's eyewitness testimony is Direct Evidence. "Can you identify the man you saw", *Cone points at Hennis*, if you take what Cone's saying as true, that proves Tim was the guy leaving the house - direct...and yeah, I guess you still need to draw that (also utterly inescapable) line of inference that that makes him the killer, so technically his leaving the house becomes a circumstantial piece again. It's honestly more of a distinction for lawyers to know that jurors and the general public don't even need to worry about. Categories of evidence presented in court. Jurors don't need to even know what categories of evidence are and what said categories mean, just what they're allowed to weigh and consider and what they're not.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I do actually say that during my spiel you're referring to ("the former does involve the latter, but it's just a rhetorical idea anyway") I don't think "convict just in case" would be a tricky dilemma. I would never do that, or think of doing it. So if after taking in the first round you're of the mind the state's case is just piss weak and Tim more likely than not didn't do it (a reasonable enough position, even while I disagree) then you're pretty off the hook. OK, he MIGHT have done it, but convicting someone of a crime like that when you're not even 50/50 convinced would be crazy and wrong. Wouldn't expect you to lose sleep over that. But what if it's a case where the crimes are THAT horrible, and you're like...65, maybe even 75 percent convinced? You're still not supposed to convict, but man that would make me sick to my stomach if I was in a position where I thought the guy more likely than not was the guy...but the state was like one strong piece of evidence short of getting it over the line, so I'm still going to hand him his freedom, and they'll never be able to get him again (so far as I'd know). THAT would be awful, and I do not envy jurors in cases like this one bit. I'd have half a mind to walk up to the judge and be like, "Look, can I just drop out now and have you sub in an alternate? I didn't know it would be this hard when I said I was up for it."

Claire

Pretty sure Tolkien had those elves getting the most tail, so there is that.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I agree, Russel Williams (another military man!) is another rare example of someone who fits the bill well enough. EVEN there, if I wanted to be REALLY anal about it, I could argue the troves of stolen panties and cross dressing photographs (not besmirching cross-dressers in general but come on, if it's in panties you stole) cut against it. So it's still an example of once you catch the serial killer, his house betrays him as a sicko. But of course, those things are a part of the criminal behavior itself, and also hidden completely from the outside world. So yeah, even though Tim Hennis is an even starker example, I'd still have to hand you RW. Dunno enough about GSK - he definitely looks like a sick fuck in photos!

Claire

Truly the MVP 🙏

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Good choice, I got both the kindle and audio-book editions, and the audio-book is fortunately voiced really well - they can be hit and miss. It really is a great book, and here's the really impressive thing about it...So, Scott actually still thinks Tim Hennis is innocent, or at least that there's a good chance. How? That's just the thing, in my humble opinion, I don't think he can really articulate a proper reason. Every time he sort of does, he goes on to essentially explain why it doesn't work without admitting outright that's what he's just done - cognitive dissonance, really. I've actually asked if he'd be up for an interview, we'll see. Back to his book - IV is pretty unabashedly pro defense, even while stopping just short of explicitly stating a position. There's lots of books that are (rightly or wrongly) supportive of the defendants' innocence, where if an absolute smoking gun like in the Hennis case were to drop, the book would no longer be worth the paper it's written on - just an utter laughing stock. IVs not like that at all. Scott puts all the most important evidence on the table and represents it properly, and there are TONS of things in the book that would have been effective in one way (innocence narrative) pre-2006, that are now still super effective in a completely different way with the knowledge of Tim's guilt. Just ONE example: "[Fort Bragg witnesses] Sherry Whitney and Patricia Parces remembered Hennis putting together a two-story dollhouse for his daughter [at base on the Friday night after the murders]…Tim and Angela went to a class every Wednesday to learn how to put the house together…Hennis’s job on [Friday night] was to glue tiny cedar chips onto the roof to make rows of shingles, a tedious task perfect for CQ duty….The sight of Hennis trying to fit together tiny shingles on a dollhouse for his daughter warmed both of them. “Nobody’s gonna kill two children and then spend all night doing that.” " Bone chilling when you know that is exactly what he did.

Gigi

Is it too far fetched to think that he didn’t kill babyJenna because she had been napping when Tim picked up the dog and sleeping when he went back that night? Could it be possible that he never know she was there? If not, I’m inclined to think he was satisfied and tired after his 3rd murdergasm and just didn’t have the energy. Or it wasn’t a trill to kill someone too small to understand and fear what was happening or put up a fight of some kind.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thank you! Yeah there will be more stuff like this - but probably no massive epics in the foreseeable future. There's simply a really finite amount of cases that I find as interesting as this one. Isn't it WILD??

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Well the actual real reason it's a total non starter was something I couldn't say at that point - the semen. I would have just felt a bit wrong floating the idea Pat could have done something like that knowing for a fact he didn't - especially after he put himself through a lot of stress and hassle doing right by the Eastburns. But OK, here's my pre-2006 pitch on why Pat's a non starter: For that to be the case, you'd need to argue Pat brutally murdered a family that lived around the corner from him just to score some money, or because he's just a sick fuck unbeknownst to anyone - I guess that last parts true of Hennis, but Pat basically had the same "seems like a good guy" defense Tim did, just with a little more of a blemished record by the time of trial 2. But seriously, petty theft and public drunkenness fall so shy of supporting the capability of these actions he may as well have a clean record. THEN you'd have to posit his girlfriend and her family all lied about his whereabouts during the murders to cover for him, AND his own family either missed anything being off about him after or, again, lied about it. Again that last part is true enough for Hennis, but again it's not making Cone a stronger suspect. THEN you have to posit even after going to all the clean up effort, Cone decided it was worth the risk inserting himself directly into the case - wagering that if he walked up and described another guy the police would just totally believe him, and nothing would ever seem off and make them want to take a closer look at him. And then he just totally lucked out in damn near perfectly describing their first person of interest. So yeah, even pre-2006, Cone as a suspect would have been dead on arrival for me.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Dunno if it's impossible, but highly improbable. First he would have been on scene for quite some time with all the clean up - I GUESS he'd have no reason to peek inside Janas room but pretty crazy she'd never alert him to her presence. And then second, on that, I'd be shocked if Jana never woke up and started crying through all of that.

Natasha Gray

Thank you, Matt! This was amazing. So glad to be a member, you never disappoint.

ChiralSpiral

Your Patreon “podcast” releases are actually my favourite content of yours, so this was a very welcome treat. I’d love to see more. I was basically unfamiliar with the case going in (the detail about the military calling him up again rings a bell so I must have read about it some point, but I obviously didn’t retain much). I had a feeling where it was going to go just because of the amount of time left, but I was far from certain. I agree with you that the evidence presented at the first two trials didn’t cross the reasonable doubt threshold. If I had been in the jury for either of those, I don’t think I’d have argued to convict. Especially since a lot of the things the defence brought out—intimidation from police, eyewitness unreliability—are known to have put away innocent people, although maybe that wasn’t as widely known in the 80s.

Steve

Matty Ice is who Miami should have taken in 2008. Are you a fan of the Atlanta Falcons?

Kenneth Brandt

***SPOILERS IN MY COMMENT! TURN AWAY IF YOU HAVEN'T WATCHED THE VIDEO!*** Matt! Excellent video, my friend! This was completely absorbing, and just a terrific listen. I had no knowledge of this case, and didn't predict the twists and turns that came my way. I'm so thankful they eventually got the right guy, and I think your theory on the killer's motivations seems quite sound. And yes, Gary Eastburn ... what a unit. We should all strive to demonstrate such grace. In any event, thanks for your hard work.

Steve

I just listened to the audiobook of Innocent Victims. Matt did a great job of distilling its twelve hours. I highly recommend it—at least through the acquittal that ended the 1993 edition. I just wished I’d skipped the epilogue. In less than an hour the epilogue discusses the cold case investigation and conviction. And much of that time is spent attacking the army and DNA lab before conceding it was Tim’s semen and he benefited from a military jury. My impression is Scott Whitman wanted to update his book—but had no interest in wrestling with how Tim fooled so many people including him. For example, Scott says arguing “consensual sex” was hard for the defense because it cast shade on the victim and upset people. Well, yes. But it also meant Tim had lied to everyone for years. The biggest problem is Scott does not address how circumstantial evidence is like a rope composed of strands. One strand is weak but several together is strong. And here what was found in victim needs to be added to such things as Tim’s lack of an alibi; the fact he was one of the few people who knew the husband and dog would not impede a home invasion; and eyewitness testimony given before Tim was a suspect that nailed both his appearance and car. I have no doubt Tim is guilty. And Matt’s exploration of what that means is why he’s so great.

Steve

I just did a review of Innocent Victims and my stupid app is not letting me make edits. So my apologies for the typos. More importantly, I forgot ask if Patreon has a feature like buy me a coffee. I’d like to give a thanks for the great video—and encourage more.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

The Epilogue is curious, isn't it? It's like Scott has the intellectual honesty to basically explain how the DNA says exactly what it appears to say, and can't reasonably be fraudulent...but he doesn't have the will to really follow through on what that means. And he seems to want to still have a pre-2006 argument in a post-2006 world at the very end of the epilogue.

deadbeef33

Thanks for the clarification. I think that actually does a great job to help explain why I *was* suspicious of him. In the terms of the physical evidence and motive, Pat and Tim both had exactly the same level of evidence against them - none. At that point in the case, most of the things you could say about Tim could be said about Pat as well, the only difference being that Tim had a witness testifying against him. I had reasoned that it could be a case of where Pat happened to know about the dog adoption from chatting with Katie or something, maybe they were neighborhood friends. And maybe he saw the dog adopter so he knew what he looked like and what car he drove. Pat then committed the murders during the time window when he was supposedly out walking at 3 AM and witnessed Tim leaving the house and getting into his car, and decided to tell the police about the dog adopter to cover his tracks. The cops then singled onto Tim as a suspect, and started reading way too much into admittedly suspicious things that Tim happened to do, like burning a pile of trash in his backyard. The timing piece was one thing that I didn't follow too closely in your video, so maybe that's the one thing that would have led me off of this.

George Temby

I couldn’t recall the case so was along for the journey the entire time. You are a amazing articulator and storyteller so I would love for anymore cases like these you’d be willing to cover :D

Noella

Loved this! I agree with others we're spoiled. Not sure I could get a higher membership, but definitely think it's worth that. Funnily enough the Daliha video helped me with this one. Like the cut that was just not deep enough, the trips to the atms were just close enough to be possible but appear not. Each withdrawal was just around the time he could and not when he literally couldn't like someone else vouching for him. My instincts were unhappy when you said he won the appeal and described him after, and I wondered if it was just me, and then we had the turn around. It's a little gratifying to know there was something ringing off for me

Steve

Right. And there’s no longer doubt. Just compare it to when my best friend from law school got a MPLS jury in 2022 to convict Jerry Westrom for a 1993 murder. Both cases rested on 1) the lack of a meaningful alibi, 2) a defendant who was aware the victim was vulnerable but denied any relationship with her, and 3) undisputed semen (not touch) DNA. This case was even stronger because of the amazing eyewitness.

corvdb1992 .

*SPOILERS! HEED MATT'S WARNING AND LOOK ELSEWHERE* I honestly did not see that bombshell coming. I'd expected the real perpetrator to be someone out of left field. I actually went and checked the dates on Ed Kemper, just to be sure. As you cover in the final part, it's really peculiar that someone has one single bout of such outrageous, wanton violence. Even the killers who are portrayed as good maskers buckle under scrutiny of their personal lives. All of this you've described in the video. I can follow your hypothesis of the serial killer who was scared straight. However, without smaller scale killings/deviance, he did really explode for his first killing. This animal went fucking HAM. That can work in multiple directions: - Unrefined serial killer, kinda bumbling about on his first killing and getting in over his head. Not as easy as he thought, he got away with one instance, he got his taste, that's it for Tim. - Conversely, first time killer gets this unleashed on his first go and somehow manages to contain this violent side of his forever after? Still... I do not know which alternative hypothesis would be better. Barring any evidence of prior deviance, he probably IS the odd serial killer scared straight.

Steve

This issue of Katie calling Tim that night reminds me of another family massacre in 1985: the White House Farm murders. There, Jeremy Bamber claimed that, before being killed, his father called to say his sister had a gun. UK phone records of the era could not confirm the call. Jeremy was convicted of the UK’s most notorious family massacre. But, in late 2025, the New Yorker published an article arguing that new evidence casts doubt on the conviction. Then, late last year, In the Dark devoted its fifth podcast season (“Blood Relatives”) to the article and whether Jeremy Bamber is wrongfully imprisoned. Matt, it could be a good case for you.

SimplySnaps

Went into this with zero knowledge of the case. Your delivery of the information was perfectly neutral. I decided there was reasonable doubt when you told me to pause. I was thinking critically. And then you dropped the reveal, and I thought to myself "Oh my GOD." Very well done, it's such a delight to have a twist like that genuinely knock you onto your ass. Absolutely horrible stuff, one of the more heinous crimes I've ever heard of. But I will say this: With the information they had, jury #2 did the right thing. There WAS doubt, and as awful as it is to imagine that man getting away with it, I would rather let a monster go than kill an innocent man. And this case was a very good way to test my principles there. If there's reasonable doubt, you MUST let him go. You cannot write fanfiction about a hypothetical monster getting away with it. You have to prove that man is real. And trial #3 proved it.

cool_ranch

not a Falcons fan but I know my way around a Natural Ice

JabboMC

i will listen to you talk about paint dry man the visuals are just gravy

James Jones

Another top video, consistently the only channel I ever recommend to people and this is exactly why.

CJ

I recently listen to your commentary in which you mention your ideas for T-shirt murch (love the “Tigers love eating people” idea). If you go this route, may I suggest “but the seamen keeps telling the same story” 😂

Jay Winters

I went into this blind and that twist at 2:02:47 hit me like a sack of bricks. Especially with the “epilogue” of post-second trial behavior, I did not see that coming at all

Austin G

Just upgraded my membership after listening to this episode. Pay this man whatever he requires to release stuff like this every 2 weeks. Cheers Matt!

Evan

It hit me all of a sudden that I did know this case. It's so crazy. Have you heard the case of Mel Ignatow? It's sort of similar with this one. Ignatow was on trial for murder, there was enough reasonable doubt for acquittal but then a year later during renovations of his home he sold to fund his defence they found pictures of him murdering the woman taped inside a vent. They ended up getting him on perjury for claims of innocence while on the stand during the murder trial. It was the only thing they had left to get him on.

Ian Creedon

I had never heard of this case, and the twist got me as I absent-mindedly followed along while working. Well done and looking forward to more audio episodes.

Tracy McClendon

you got me Matt. I was like this motherfucker is guilty af the whole way through. I even felt bad ignoring your good evidence against his guilt at the end of trial one. I was still like, no, I think he did it through trial two. And then you go and say, what a normal nice guy for years after and I'm like damn...I would have strung up an innocent ma-NOPE. HE FUCKING DID IT. JUST LIKE I KNEW.

Grace Wagler

I was in a similar boat as you at first: too much reasonable doubt to convict, but oooooooh Pat's white guy with the white Chevette is really throwing me through a loop. God-fucking-dammit. He really was the mass murderer/baby killer/rapist next door. Poor Gary and Jana.

Grace Wagler

I can't imagine your family's murderer going free for 20 years, and when they're finally dead to rights the explanation their defense offers for the smoking gun is "well, maybe your slaughtered wife/mother was a slut, ever think of that?"

MG

What an incredible video, thank you! It was so well crafted, I thought he was innocent then guilty then innocent and when it turned out to be his DNA, I almost fell out of my chair. Just such a beautiful job, it was a pleasure to watch and listen to it. ❤️

Sylvia

I finally got to the reveal and that hit me like a ton of bricks and I felt genuinely nauseous. Fantastic storytelling. This one of the craziest cases I'd never heard of. Re: my earlier comment about the neighborly serial killer, I wrote that at first mention and had no idea it was the thesis of this whole video! I think it's DeAngelo, Russel Williams, and this fucking guy, few are able to blend like them.

Jonathan Gill

Thrilling video. I wasn't expecting something like this to be uploaded in April. Your storytelling abilities really shine through: when I finished it, I wanted to Google more about the case, and as you called out it's much less interesting when getting a Wikipedia summary or what-have-you. Answering the question midway through: I wasn't expecting the reveal of the semen analysis per se, though I had clued in on just how damning the witness testimony was before you were discussing it. It's unworkable to assume the witness at the key hours of the event hallucinates a man with a very, very close appearance to Hennis and who drives the same exact model of car as Hennis. Not just a "white car"; fortunately the witness even knew and remembered the exact model. I couldn't watch the video all in one day, so I paused two-thirds of the way through. I went through my day sadly ruminating on how someone as evil as Hennis was able to get away with it--only for the surprise in the last third that they found a loophole to bypass double jeopardy. That's quite the upswing. Your theory sounds immanently plausible to me; the gear we can infer for the crime strongly speaks to the theory that it was premeditated.

Spike Sketch

omg....what a case! Wonderfully crafted and executed, as always. Thank you Matt.x

GeekTriangle

I'm at 2:30ish, so a bit after the reveal. I didn't know of this case and my heart freaking dropped. First I was so relieved, and then I was so so so so angry!!!! Great freaking vid man, great vid

Ethan Fox

Amazing video, one of my favorite projects you've ever done. I would absolutely pay extra for more videos in this style if you find the time!

Jonathan Gill

Another thought: even before the big reveal, hearing that Hennis was leading some Girl and Boy Scouts groups made me really uncomfortable. I understand that legally speaking he was an innocent man at that time, but what parent would want their little girl in the company of a suspect for a series of crimes that heinous? In fact I would be very curious to hear the impressions people had of Tim who encountered him in these very normal social situations. I know you summarized accounts that he had an impeccable record, but it would be fascinating to hear his acquaintences' thoughts of him during that presumed-innocent period of time and how much of the case they were familiar with.

nickotine

Made me finally join the Patreon, keep up the good work 👍👍👍

Connor

Second this

Sylvia

It's the same with GSK as with RW - a lot of escalation from burglary, serial rape, and then murder that he managed to keep totally hidden while also not being notably asocial or violent in his regular life. TH is truly exceptional for having no known escalation, a normal life, and then a horrific crime, as you concluded -- GSK or RW just come damn close but not quite. I've heard of nothing else like this. And that TH "needed" no escalation to get used to the horror of the crime is terrifying.

nebulazer

good god that was a fucking rollercoaster. thank god for dna testing. i blurted out "WHAT?!" when you revealed that the semen sample was his the whole fucking time. just sitting in a little specimen jar, waiting for technology to catch up. i really appreciate the emphasis on the good people in the story. while it's horrifying to know that monsters lurk amongst us, it seems that the good people outnumber the monsters.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I can't remember where I read this, but at least one parent who was a peer through either girl or boy scouts did give a quick quote to some outlet. I don't believe they even voiced an opinion as to whether they thought he did or didn't do it, but they said that they were totally shocked when he was re-charged, and they had *no idea* about that part of his past. And yeah, like everyone else, they said he always seemed like a stand up guy. It makes enough sense, like it's obviously a big chapter in your bio (there's TV movie about it for gods sake) but are you really going to be in a rush to bring it up at a PTA meeting? I'm sure he had a spiel about his side of the story whenever it had to be brought up, but when it didn't he was more than happy to just stay as boring Mr. Hennis.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Copy pasting another reply to a similar observation: I agree, Russel Williams (another military man!) is another rare example of someone who fits the bill well enough. EVEN there, if I wanted to be REALLY anal about it, I could argue the troves of stolen panties and cross dressing photographs (not besmirching cross-dressers in general but come on, if it's in panties you stole) cut against it. So it's still an example of once you catch the serial killer, his house betrays him as a sicko. But of course, those things are a part of the criminal behavior itself, and also hidden completely from the outside world. So yeah, even though Tim Hennis is an even starker example, I'd still have to hand you RW. Dunno enough about GSK - he definitely looks like a sick fuck in photos! ALSO: If GSK does check out in fitting the bill (as now two people have reckoned he does) that makes two military men, and a police officer. Interesting...

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

The honorable-and-courteous-damn-near-to-a-fault Mr. Eastburn did make a point of saying that really pissed him off, as you'd expect, btw. Made a similar statement to mine about how Hennis should have got up on the stand and claimed it himself if he really wanted to get the idea in there. Another thing that really, really got his goat, is that when Frank Spinner (who I gave a bit of a pass) said that, you really could feel the air go out of the room. In response to that palpable vibe in the room, he turned to the pros side of the court and made a remark like, "Gee, looks like we really struck a nerve with the prosecution table!" Gary felt it was an extremely unnecessary, immature remark given the situation, and he's right of course. I get in theory lawyers often need to try every angle they can, but you'll never convince me floating the consensual sex idea in closing wasn't a massive own-goal. I think Spinner made the petulant remark sort of like Tim said, "getting an early start this morning!" - people have a way of blurting out stupid shit right after the realize they've stepped in it. Interview with Gary: https://www.wral.com/video/news/local/video/7447295/

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

No, I had not heard of that, and it does sound fascinating. I'll add the Wiki article to my evening reading - thanks Evan! That's interesting about the perjury angle - from my reading I would have thought that'd be a no go, because DJ essentially says you can't face the charges OR other charges stemming from the same event. Like say you acquitted me for first degree, then found out I 100% did it...you couldn't charge me with something else like second degree, reckless endangerment, or whatever else might fit the circumstances because it's still fundamentally the same action I've been previously acquitted of. But if I took the stand and said I didn't do it, it sounds as if my lying on the matter counts as a completely separate offense - how curious! Ignatow wound up serving less than 10 years I see - shame it couldn't be a more pure delayed justice like in Hennis's case.

Matthew Thayer

1. Mr. Orchard, I'm of the opinion that this is your magnum opus, at least from a writing perspective. We'll see if I still feel that way after it has settled for a week(it has very, very stiff competition), but that's how I feel now. It has everything that makes your work great, and it has it in spades. The unparalleled ability to put your audience on an emotional and investigative roller coaster. The incredibly thorough, comprehensive, and transparent consideration of evidence in a way that few other channels can match. Diving into the minds of killers and creating eerily plausible scenarios. The ability to always place stories in an appropriate context, so that they don't become simple whodunits to be consumed and forgotten about. Well done. 2. Also I thought it was weird that there were two family anihilation murders that set significant legal precedent at Fort Bragg(Macdonald murders is the other one, but it's a totally different case(Dad wiped out his family and blamed hippies)).

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah it's interesting with the ATMs - when it's only just possible as opposed to actually impossible it might be a sign of a deliberate false alibi. That's what I believe is going on the David Bain case with the paper run btw. The "4 before, 1 after" theory IS correct, and he took the massive risk because he had to - no paper run, no alibi. If Robin got up in the meantime, that would just be tough shit for David. He just had to do the run right then or he'd be cooked.

ashley

Dang, getting paid backpay by the military is nuts when other wrongfully convicted people barely get a million for serving decades while their name is cleared.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks so much! This is honestly one of my fav projects, especially adjusting for production value :) One early defense theory was that it could be a McDonald copycat. Also, get this, The Eastburn's babysitter was a staunch McDonald defender and even became pen-pals with him!

Stephan Tanski

Great presentation. As interesting and entertaining as anything else you’ve done. 👍

ashley

HAHAHAHAHAHA wasnt that nice for very long, huh?

sunny crays

Matt you are a genius! That was incredible. I was already familiar with this case, but your rundown was far superior to what I heard before. To be honest (hope this is not insulting) I often play your videos while doing chores and only listen, don't watch. So this format is great! I often wish you were on Spotify. Would you consider that? Anyway, fantastic analysis! Your theory at the end makes perfect sense to me.

sunny crays

Agreed! I can't believe I got something this good for only $5! Best deal I get. But please don't raise the price, Matt, I'm broke...

sunny crays

The "classic radio voice" I personally find so annoying. Everything over enunciated. Your voice is great!

Elkia Szczecinski

First time I’ve ever heard this case and I was SO SURE he was guilty from the outset. I really could not look past the witness testimony. It was so spot on, with the build, clothes, car etc. I just could not believe a random witness not connected to anything would say something to police that just so happened to be an almost identical match to someone the victim had met only days earlier. I never agreed that there was reasonable doubt. When you revealed the DNA match I was like I KNEW IT. I also completely agree with your psych analysis of him/the crime at the end. Great video as always.

Shaxx

Super super excited to watch this today!!! Thank you so much for the work you put in for us patrons, it is very much appreciated!!!!

Ryeman

I think this is a good format for Patreon that you should continue. Perfect for cases that are less visual or have some other problem.

My Name

I have a few thoughts about this video (spoilers): 1. Like everyone else commenting, I LOVE these types of videos and they make the Patreon insanely worth it. 2. I wonder if there's something instructive about 'true crime epistemology' from this case. When you outlined the first and second trials, I was right there with you in thinking that Hennis wasn't QUITE guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. By the end of the video, I was pondering whether this was correct given the information at the time. Like, would a sufficiently intelligent and good-at-reasoning hypothetical juror have convicted him pre-2006? I think the way you framed the forensic evidence made me lean in the not-quite-guilty direction. You pointed out that the forensic evidence: the lack of cross-contamination between the Hennis and Eastburn houses, the unidentified hand print, the pubic hair, and even the (at the time seemingly non-Hennis) semen, while not being exculpatory in any individual instance, all seemed to follow a pattern of contradicting what you'd expect if Hennis was guilty. The way you said it it was as if the prosecution kept making predictions about what you'd find in the house, and each time their predictions were wrong. It makes the case against Hennis feel shaky in a "beliefs should pay rent in anticipated experiences" type of way. Like my brain jumped to thinkng "what are the odds that each time we find a piece of physical evidence, it winds up at least nudging us away from guilt"? So in my head I thought of the case as having a strong eyewitness in Patrick Cone pointing towards guilt, and a consistent pattern of physical evidence pointing away from guilt, and at that point I probably let the hard-to-avoid vague heuristic of 'physical evidence > eyewitness testimony' sway me towards reasonable doubt. Then of course we get confirmation that he was guilty and in retrospect the (residual) physical evidence pointing away from Hennis seems relatively weak in retrospect and the Cone sighting seems undeniable. So what went wrong with my thought process before the big reveal? I think I didn't have much of a sense of the background likelihood of an unidentified handprint being in the house, innocuous transfer of a pube, and the cross-contamination of the semen with the victim's blood. If I had a better sense of what percent of similar crime scenes would innocuously have those types of features, and was able to come to the understanding that Hennis wouldn't have to get ridiculously lucky for them to be there, I think I could've given more weight to the myriad evidence against. But beyond that, like, does this case the way you presented it help us think more clearly about other crimes? Should I now update toward putting more weight on eyewitness testimony and less weight on what I at least perceive to be 'physical forensic evidence'? I dunno. I do think that, somewhat paradoxically, the extent to which Cone's sighting absolutely NAILED Hennis almost gave it less credence in my eyes. It seemed too good to be true, and I think I was probably anticipating some sort of other show to drop on that front This was way too long of a comment, and I'm not sure if it's anywhere near substantive enough to justify the word count, but hopefully its length serves as a compliment to the video, and shows just how much it got me thinking.

marrow

tbh i’ve had trouble focusing on this but i think that’s probably because of my adhd 🤔 still would love to see more videos like this, maybe with just an ever so slightly more condensed script

My Name

ALSO, on the topic of fascinating cases with insufficient video documentation...a while ago I came across your old podcast 50/50 Bias Both Ways, and after listening to the episode with Mark Pendergrast, I started to become interested in the Jerry Sandusky case. I know it's an absolute doozy both in terms of ickiness and sheer scale, but if you ever did an addendum-style deep dive on Sandusky I'd be hyped. While it's certainly one of those cases where anyone knowledgeable about it knows that it's a lot less clear-cut than the general perception, I ultimately don't know what to think, and would love to hear your take on it if you have one

AR

I meaaannn the other girls were old enough to identify him. the baby wasn't. he killed them out of expedience as well as gratification. but killing is also hard work and by the time he got to the baby he was probably tired and ready to start cleaning up and perhaps he just went 'eh, fuck it.' the thought of leaving someone alive also probably appealed to his god complex.

AR

can't wait!

Deanna & Kurt

Sounds amazing! WMT is a case that ive gone fully to the innocents camp on before shifting back towards the middle a bit. I actually listened to the last podcast on the left originally and which was a very pro innocence podcast on the case but recently I listened to most of the prosecutors podcast on it and realized there are alot of things the innocence camp seems to ignore especially about Damien that are serious red flags. Im guessing you would agree that whoever committed the crime must be truly evil. Il be honest, I just dont get that read off of the wmt suspects but maybe its a similar situation as Tim hennis

Max

This was really great Matt

Grace Wagler

I don't know if it came up during the first trial, but a piece of contextual evidence I would've loved to see is how common white Chevy Chevettes were in that particular area and time period. The Green River task force found flecks of paint on at least one victim that belonged to a particularly uncommon brand...which happened to be used regularly at Gary Ridgway's job. Even if they didn't have DNA evidence (which they luckily did), it would've been a tasty morsel for the prosecution if his case had ever gone to trial

AR

I was also thinking about the Russell Williams comparison earlier (as well as Kohberger) but to me RW seems way more methodical and long-simmering in his obsession. And actually a bunch of the killers who've been caught through forensic genealogy (as detailed wonderfully on the DNA ID podcast) fall into this category: they had no pattern of violence, killed once, and then never did it again and led totally upstanding lives. I think it's really possibly (terrifyingly) a lot more common than we realize for that to be the case.

cris gay

*sigh* you got me

Lauren Goff

This is possibly my favorite video of yours, though it’s a hard choice! I don’t often have time to sit down and watch your regular videos, so I enjoyed the fact I could treat this as a podcast episode. I’m very glad I signed up for your Patreon when I did! I was pretty firmly in the “Tim should be found innocent” camp even from Trial 1, so I was floored by the DNA evidence. I was also terrified they wouldn’t hold him to account, but thank God he was in the military! And that Gary Eastburn is such a saint. God rewarded him for his patience and longsuffering. +

Grace Wagler

That was so low, even as far as Jose Baez-esque "throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks" arguments go

Tyler Bentley

I absolutely love this format. It always makes my day whenever I see a new video pop up from you, no matter what it is. I truly appreciate your effort in making these videos, thank you and I can't wait for the next one my friend!!

Stevo

All of your content is amazing but this mixture of your main channel’s professional, in-depth projects & the more personable, candid style of your commentaries has resulted in undoubtedly one of the best pieces you’ve made. I really hope you can find a way to make more of these, perhaps via a second channel or something if that makes it more of a profitable endeavor. Incredible work, regardless.

Inge Berge

So, so good. Masterful! Remember when I told you you have a real knack for criminology? You pooh-poohed it and said you were more of a storyteller. Yeah, that you certainly are too. But your psychological profiling work here is excellent. Feasible. Likely. Almost certainly true, even. Kudos on this great work. A+.

Inge Berge

Oh, and I too, btw, like other commenters have mentioned, reacted with an almost physical ‘whaaaaaaa?’ when you revealed the DNA evidence. My eyes literally widened like in a cartoon. 😂

Sean McCafferty

Sounds eerily similar to In cold blood by Truman Capote (obviously the retelling of a true story). I think you'd have to have some career or hardened criminals to carry out something like this, not a relatively quiet, family man who just loses it.

Claire

Yeah I would even term the response 'overwhelmingly positive', perfect for the occasional bonus. Glad it didn't take quite so much out of you as a for-Youtube video. It's probably good for your brain to have a simpler video to make while still being able to scratch that deep dive itch you had.

FreddyAndersen'sFivehole

Well first off this is an incredible piece of work, one of my favorite watches in quite some time. So informative, detailed and respectful. H But I just had to say, of course THE reveal hits so hard, but when you mention the detail of Katie giving away the dog clicking in your mind late, that got a similar reaction out of me. What a horrific case.

Claire

Hahaha now you don't think I'm falling asleep to 'Creep Catchers' do you 🤣 (thankyou for giving that song to me by the way, it's so ridiculous I just love it) No, I use your videos while I'm writing these days. There is something really concentration-maintaining about hearing a well-written story while trying to write one of your own. Definitely gonna check out that sleep sounds video though.

sammer

Very good video! Though I still like your primary-source heavy format for regularly. I get the pragmatic arguments against the death penalty better now, as he probably would have not got a new trial let alone been released if he had received a life sentence. My answer to the "would you convict" question would be something technically invalid: 'I would imprison him on this evidence, but not kill him.

Owned by Corgis

Incredible. This is fabulous dude. Thank you!!!

Jane Brinkley

This was excellent!! So well done, thank you Matt. I was totally taken along for the ride of your storytelling - the reveal got me!

Luke

A master piece

albrechto

MILD SPOILERS BELOW: I think it hits for me with the jacket. There is just *no* good reason he did that. It's not like it's a suit or something that is "normally" dry cleaned, and it wasn't with a bunch of other stuff he was dropping off. Add to that the fact that he was dodgy about it. Like you said, though; really, not enough to convict someone for mass murder and rape, but certainly fishy enough. That, knowing what we know now, would have been just a bread crumb that would lead you to this.

Allison K Adair

When you told us to pause the video and form our own opinions, I said out loud "I KNOW he did it but you're gonna say not beyond a reasonable doubt, arent you" and had a good chuckle when I unpaused. For me weirdly enough it was the bank transactions that pushed me over the edge from I am fairly certain he did it to I know he did it. As someone who has chronic financial struggles it had all the markings and movements of someone who has chronic financial struggles, although I do not think those ladies at the bank actually saw him, I'm sorry. That being said I actually didn't Google this case until afterwards like a good noodle and found out this mf actually graduated from my highschool albeit decades apart as I was very much not alive when this crime was committed, but the fact we did walk the same halls and grew up in the same town shook me up a little. He is noticably absent from our Wikipedia page of notable alumni lol.

Fady Sedarous

Matt you should be a documentary director/writer in the biggest studios of TV and Hollywood. I am not kidding in the slightest. Love you and your content big bro. Talent, objectivity, humor, character, insight, attention to detail, creativity, narration. You got it all

Charles Haught

This is great. In my opinion you should totally post this to YouTube maybe on a second channel or something. Or maybe on Spotify it could function as a podcast

ezzy

I really loved this style of video, a great watch the whole way through and since I went in blind my frustration was validated after a very slow burn haha

Banana-anna

So good and the plot twist was so well hidden. Thanks Matt

Ahmad Haroon

Amazing work!! Well worth my first ever Patreon sign up

Mrs R

Saaaame. I was so convinced!

TendieL

What a treat this is! To echo other comments you really are a phenomenal storyteller Matt. Even without the production quality of your main channel vids I can still just sit here and listen intently, not even doing something on my second screen!

Richard Johnson

I’m with you and probably everyone else who watched this video in being unwilling to assign a charitable explanation to him not directly harming the baby. I suspect another thrill kill would’ve been just fine for him, but self preservation kicked in. Like you alluded to, he probably realized the undertaking of cleaning up the scene for 3 people was an tall order and a 4th would’ve taken that much more time, thus being that much more of a risk.

tk

Very interesting discussion of a case I hadn't heard about previously. On your point about Hennis being a failed serial killer, I find that many people correlate the compulsive killer's need to kill in very much the same language many use to describe drug addicts. Getting a 'fix' for example. For me, I view cases like this not as someone whose fix is murdering, but an addiction to power. In very much the same light as rape most often being a demonstration of power rather than sexuality, murder - especially such horrific ones like this family endured - is a total power control. Is it any wonder why he picked a family who could not even pose the risk of defending themselves? It didn't play into the fantasy. Likewise, there's really no need for him to kill again because the 'fix' isn't the murders and rape themselves - it's the knowledge he had that no one else did. His fix was constant, even if in slightly a lower grade. What's more powerful than being privy to a truth that would change everything, but nobody but you is aware of it? Also, him being military immediately made the psychological profile of a purposeful, sadistic killer fit more not less for me. As much as you can point out the individual good people within it, there is an insidiousness that will always linger in a culture with the notion that one can be trained to decide the "right" and "wrong" people to kill, and desensitization can lead to horrible outcomes in even the most stable psychological profiles.

FlyingAshtrays

Wow that was horrific. Amazing work as usual

Stephanie Bramer

This was absolutely outstanding! Just add a period after 1985 at the very end 😀

Ben S

Glad I didn't look this case up, this video was a roller coaster of emotions. The reveal really did knock me flat. Very well done video.

David Jones

(Spoiler warning) The thing that gave away the reveal for me was when you indulged on the lives of people after the second trial. Talking about Tim Hennis being less suspicious as time went on just sounded so…out of character from you given your stance on David Bain.

tom

Wow that was good

erin

2:03:22 hit like a ton of fucking bricks tbh

Bekka Berryman

Everything you do is freaking phenomenal.. excited to be a patreon member now!! So, I wanted to add a thought on to your serial killer scared straight theory based on my personal life experience and just my own opinion.. I agree with everything you theorized, but I also think that a part of it could be that he never acted anything out before because up until that point, things had gone relatively well for him and he had always felt an amount of control that was satisfying enough for him up until that point to where he didn’t feel the need to act on his thoughts. His dad was an IBM executive I think? Wealthy enough to pay for his EXTENSIVE legal defense… that’s a level of wealth that most regular rich people couldn’t afford. He had a young baby and was starting to fall in to financial problems and from what I know about the case, it seemed like for a tall, handsome, white man who came from a wealthy family, he was starting to lose control of his life for the first time, so to regain that control, maybe he chose to act on those thoughts of violence? A lot to unpack here. Loved the video!

Sebastian Frintzer

Really like the format. Then again, I've come to almost prefer the commentator's commentaries over the actual videos.

D

Matt, this is one of my favorite videos that you have done. Great work!

Alexandropher LRTV

I got patreon for this and I am feeling pretty fancy and exclusive.

Sasha Henriksen

wow, just wow. like i was fully ready to think, wow glad he got acquitted they mustve just been trying to pin it on him because they had no one else, wouldnt be the first time and like, then boom, dna. it never occurred to me that a murderer in the past might just bank on there not being dna testing. Also i never knew that you technically can be tried for the same crime because the federal government and states are like separate sovereignties. Like after the acquittal i was like, why is there still an hour left. You really have a nack for just presenting information about cases in an engaging way. What a horrible thing to happen, just from happenstance of "oh let me put out an ad to give my dog away". May he rot on death row and hope Gary and Jana have a relative good life despite it all especially with there being finally some closure. Seems Tim's most recent appeal in 2020 was denied, i doubt he's getting out of this again. This was very worth the 10$. cheers!

KatieASMR

this is amazing, thank you

Nicholas Piazza

3 hour Matt Orchard catch me swiping my card

LucasXpirt

Love it Matt, great video

zomb1elvis

Can't say I was that surprised. The witnesses description, combined with the fact they saw him get into his car was pretty damning combined with all the other little deviations from his normal routine with fires and dry cleaning. There was a incident that happened near where i lived in the UK where a teenage girl was murdered. Her foster father was tried and convicted and after a sustained campaign by his family, several newspapers, and a tv documentary. Three trials latter he was freed. Years later it turned out that several friends and witnessed him assault her on different occasions, also ex workmates mentioned he had an explosive temper. But even ignoring that, his actions on the day of her murder are so odd and defy explanation, it was clear he was guilty. Anyway great video as usual I'll probably watch it at least twice more to get the full experience!

Noah Francis

Do as much of this as you can i love it.

Trevor

I hadn’t ever heard of this case before so I was trying to think what I would vote if I was in the jury and as soon as I heard about the fire that was the final nail in the coffin

And Harry

As someone with a short attention span and a propensity not to finish long-form YouTube videos, I was genuinely on the edge of my seat for the entire duration. I literally shouted aloud “I KNEW IT!” when you made the big DNA revelation. Although I do have one slightly alternate theory on the late-night visit to the ex-girlfriend. I believe he was always going to kill the Eastburns that night, but I also wonder if a small part of him knew that it would be a bad idea, not necessarily because it was evil but because there was a likelihood he would be caught, so at the last second before going to Eastburns’ place he made the last-second decision to go to his ex’s house hoping to maybe fight off his urges, which I’m sure at that point were almost unbearable, with a conventional non-violent affair. She turned down his advances, so he went ahead with the plan.

Sammy

Loved this format and i'm so glad i went in blind, thanks Matt! Incredible work as always!

moogiewoogieboogie

Long hecking message incoming...many thoughts triggered! Late to the party, but here now. On my second listen rn. Incredibly interesting - new to the case. The comment on the overkill is interesting. I'm an avid reader ofJohn Douglas' works (with a grain of salt, I'm aware of his limitations), and my initial thought to the overkill was anger - at being rejected. His fragile ego crumbled. But that is based on statistics, as you mention yourself. Only thing I can think of - and I am just a common plebeian - is that, often, when killers are elated or excited about what they're doing, they'll drag it out or "play" and "explore" (for lack of better words). The wounds are often more torture like? That's also just based on statistics though, so back to start, I guess. (although! He also kind of reminds me of Joseph McGowan who had experienced an increasing amount of stressors up until the day, and he said that as soon as he saw Joan at his front door, he knew he would kill her. No premeditation, no planning, just that suddenly a vulnerable victim was in front of him and he was looking for a release for his "white rage".) Anywho, long message, sorry, but it's an interesting point you made! Got me going 😭 Another thing I noted is that you call him a monster - which I don't disagree on at all. But I saw someone make a point recently, that I thought was interesting. That when we call a person like that a monster (or similar), it dehuminizes them, as if they're almost otherworldly. It removes the very real element that they're human beings like the rest of us, and allows us to distance ourselves from them on multiple levels. When really...they're not some awful creature from hell, just a horrible, pathetic excuse of a human. Thought that was interesting nonetheless. Thank you for the video! Lots of good stuff. Keep up the good work, man ❤️

Addy

I went in not knowing anything at all about this case, and I was completely blindsided! I really thought he was not guilty of it, but DANG. I'm glad that he's not behind bars, for good this time!

Cor Jacobs

love the format! would love to see more of this style—it was the perfect way to acquaint myself with a case i was entirely unfamiliar with. thanks matt!

Brent

This was an absolute heater Matt. Love the format. While I didn’t anticipate the twist, I found myself agreeing with your ‘why’/motive theory, based on similar cases. There really are people among us who are fixated on living out violent fantasies, but aren’t so impulsive that they’ll strike at any moment. Give them the right opportunity and the believe that they’re smart enough to get away with it and you wind up with a Brendt Christensen case or similar.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

The Penn State/Sandusky case is indeed a bloody headache with so many accusations covering such a long period of time, and also a real third rail if entertaining the notion Sandusky is innocent...which in my mind is the only way the project would be interesting. Maybe one day, but it's not a priority right now. Glad you enjoyed the interview with Pendergrast, barely anyone knows about that or the 50/50 project in general - it was a fun experiment with some uneven results, but the Penn State one is a goodie, and the only one I had a lot of time to research beforehand. In terms of weighing evidence - I can't give a quantifiable answer on the odds of an innocuous transfer pube at a rape site. You just have to take it at face value, I think. Most probably a rather rare scenario, but in this case the rare scenario must have transpired. And in terms of what categories of evidence to weigh most heavily - it really is just a matter of every case having it's own context. There's probably a lot of people who would agree with the statement "forensic evidence is more important than eye witness accounts" just because that sounds like the smart, sciency stance. In reality though, it depends on the nature of the forensics and eyewitness accounts in any given context. Eye witness testimony has gotten a bit of a reputation as flimsy, largely for good reason (memory is fallible and prone to influence) but Cone provided a description that was genuinely remarkable in it's vividness, and also remarkably consistent in describing a man who's identity he had no knowledge of at the time he gave it, and was a person of interest to police for reasons he was not privy to. It's just a gold-standard eye-witness account.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I dunno how I'd get that stat, but I will say it's 100% a pretty devastating hit no matter what the answer is. Imagine for a moment, instead of being confident in "White Chevette", Cone had said it was something between white and beige and Chevette or Chevette type vehicle. He didn't to be clear, but go with that. Now imagine the stat is *1 in 20 North Carolinians drive a car that fits that profile* - this is almost certainly way over generous, but again, just go with it. That now means Cone got a 1 in 20 hit *in addition* to getting race, facial hair, eye shape, height, nostrils, almost hair colour, plus described an item of clothing Hennis took to the dry cleaners within 12 or so hours. What are the odds Cone would nail the polices prime suspect blind like that? I don't know, but whatever the stat is, I'm sure it falls under the category of "fucking low", and that's WITH arbitrarily positing a way-over-defense friendly stat on the car.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanksa Inge! You know I'll, humbly as possible, take the compliment on this particular occasion. I do think some of my legitimate original ideas on this one are quite clever - like stealing the phone number back, and I manged to make MOST of the timeline and evidence work pretty darn elegantly in an overall narrative save what i view as minor weaknesses here and there. Usually, I am just conveying other people's ideas, but I'll take my credit where it's due!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Good to hear! Another commenter was saying it was a detail that immediately hit her, which makes sense too, it is hiding in plain sight like I say!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

With time we'll see. Patreon is great as a bit of a sandbox for these sorts of things and we can see what happens long term :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I too thought the "laying it on thick" with how good he was post release was a bit of a hand show, but fortunately not too many people cottoned on. Well spotted! With Bain - I don't think his apparent wholesomeness post release is as inherently interesting as with Hennis. With his murders (just assuming you, or whoever, goes with my opinion he did it), they weren't for the thrill of it. There was a "pragmatic" reason behind it. David's family as a whole was reaching a level of broken dysfunctionality which was tormenting David. He was also, sorry to be blunt, a bit of a loser. A paper run at 22 is not exactly aspirational. Not much of a reach to say he felt stuck. Add to that, if his mother and father were to die at a natural age with all his siblings still around, he would have seen bugger all from it by the time that time came - not much of an estate. If they all went in one go, and the blame fell at Robin's dead feet, David gets a total reset, inherits the property outright, plus whatever his parents had to their names - not a lot, but surely a decent payday from where David was standing. It's no surprise he hasn't made moves to kill any of his current family, he wants THEM around. Fun fact I crazily only learned about the other day: My mum wound up on a plane sitting directly next to Bain many years ago. He gave her a friendly gesture. Mum responded with a stink eye and fixed her gaze directly out the window because she thinks he's a mass fucking murderer. David was soon given a warm hello by some supporters who wound up boarding. David spent more or less the whole flight crouched next to their seats. Onya Mum!

Grace Wagler

Oh, I wasn't implying you should grab that stat. I just really like when the prosecution/defense go hard with mathematical probabilities like that

Tamara

The red flag was the successful career in the American military

Haili Devillier

100/10 on format and very cleverly layed out on your part :). and to respond to your question, absolutely was blindsided by the twist! having never heard of it, i had to stop dead in my tracks while shopping just to close my eyes and process. i 100% would also not have convicted first trial, and while in retrospect i'm so so happy they did, it is making me question my sanity lol

Will nasenbeny

Holy shitttt, I’ve watched all your videos and this is far and away your best video. I was coming around to the guy before the smoking gun and that hit like a punch in the gut. Feel so bad for the father and husband of the victims and the rollercoaster of emotions he must have been on. Must be terrible to be certain, then have the guy released, and then be proved right. Jesus man

AR

Is it? Wasn't Sandusky witnessed at least once in the actual act of assaulting a child?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

*It’s been years and years since I researched this properly and I’m just going off memory here, so take the following with a pinch of salt, and if I get any details wrong, it’s not intentional. You’re thinking of the INFAMOUS Mike McQueary account, which was basically the thing that blew the case up in the media. That account was that that back in the early 2000sish, McQueary (then an assistant coach) walked into Penn State locker rooms after hours to find a boy being full on anally raped by Sandusky in the showers. McQueary then…basically ran away. That was the version that hit the media in the 2010s, and one of the big outrages (after the…you know, main thing) was how the fuck could McQueary just scadaddle like that? Shock? But why didn’t he do anything after the fact? That’s where the plot starts thickening a bit. So MQ did go straight to his parents at the time and confided in a trusted family friend about it - which confirms he definitely thought he was a witness to something serious. But he didn’t say he saw what I outlined at the start. He said he *heard* “rhythmic slapping sounds” (shudder), then upon opening his locker, saw a naked boy and Sandusky in the locker mirror…and he sort of coloured in what was going on in his head from that. Based on what he saw, or rather *didn’t see*, the family friend talked him down a bit, told him to raise it with the higher ups and just explain to them exactly what it was he witnessed - nothing more, nothing less. He did so, and the reason it didn’t go anywhere is the higher ups genuinely accepted after speaking to Sandusky that what MQ had walked in on was towel slapping/horse play, that, while inappropriate, was no kind of rape. Sandusky was told to stop showering with boys on campus, and that was it. From memory, MQ basically affirmed the version I just outlined on the stand, while remaining adamant he believed what he encountered was a rape, even if his eyes never saw Sandusky in the act itself. The consensus view is that PS were basically in a position to put an end to JSs child molestation back then, but wrote it off and swept it under the rug. JS and his defenders contend it was written off because it *was* just horse play. The man believed to be the boy in that story (I can’t recall if it’s stipulated fact, but there’s a strong case he’s the boy from MQs encounter) was actually going to testify to as much for Sandusky’s defense…then at about the last minute, he flipped and testified for the prosecution. You can listen to the conversation I had with Mark Pendergrast about the case here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YT0_PkKceqE First half is airing out the defense position as much as we can in half an hour, second half is me pushing back on what I see as the biggest weaknesses in that position. If you’re intrigued past that you can read Pendergrast’s book on it, and there’s also a podcast called “With The Benefit of Hindsight” which is an extremely exhaustive airing by John Ziegler who basically founded the “Sandusky was railroaded” school of thought. Then if you want the case against Sandusky, you can read or watch almost anything from any other person who has ever covered the topic, haha. My stance…honestly, I don’t know. As you’ll hear in the Pendergrast episode, I have my skepticisms for sure. But…it’s one of those things where the heterodox view seems significantly stronger than it *should* given how far outside of popular thought it is, and I’m just left feeling uncomfortable in all sorts of ways. It’s a bit like Michael Jackson where it’s like, well maybe he’s not a child molester, but if not, he’s the most child-molesting-acting-non-child-molester ever, so can you really fault the perception? Then I start to feel like that position just isn’t good enough in either event. Hmm. Uncomfortable.

itssomethingabout_mary

I loved this! I loved the semi formal and informal parts, I love the super super deep dive of the case. I'd never heard of this case before, and I was enthralled the entire time!

itssomethingabout_mary

So glad I'm not the only one! I knew it was technically possible, but I was expecting Matt to pull someone out of left field honestly!

JC Foster

Wonderful format. Also, this case has been living rent free in my head since I first listened to this last week. Horrifying and well told.

Ember Bennett

I genuinely thought the chevette was a coincidence. Why would he go back?!

Ember Bennett

Also, as an American whose husband was in the army: it’s pretty hard to win those trials. The military is harsh. I’d be way more scared to be tried in a military court than a civilian one.

Ben Lewcock

Fantastic video Matt. I enjoyed this just as much as the polished tentpole releases. Awesome job.

Emily

Superb work Matt! I dint know anything about this case and did shout out loud "you're fucking joking!" at the sperm result!

nassim

Quite a bit of patience on my part to delay watching this for as long as I did, like a steak with an indefinite shelf life. You did a hell of a job casting doubt on Tim's culpability until the midway point, but ultimately, the reveal couldn't floor me on account of the murders taking place two days after Tim adopted the dog. Just too much of a coincidence to override in and of itself, to me. "Random intruder" as an offender is rare in the absence of such occurrences, let alone in the presence of them. Perhaps too reductive, but whatever. Regardless, 3 hours that I did not want to end. Instead of looking at the time elapsed and thinking "fuck, there's that much more?", I did the opposite despite knowing the reasonable limitations of a case discussion ("There's *only* an hour left?") You're such an incredible storyteller, synthesizer, and analyzer and my favorite content creator on the internet, bar none. And to echo what others have said (and not to give you any ideas but if it does, so be it), your Patreon is a bargain. Thank you for being!

Ann Silberman

Matt!! You are so talented, it’s hard to decide what you are best at. Human psychology, legal theory, writing…accents? :). For sure, storytelling, you took me on a ride and I was right there with you the entire time. I didn’t hear of this case, and didn’t see the twist coming. Quite a shock as I’d come to the conclusion there was reasonable doubt as well and he was probably innocent. It’s odd that I didn’t know of it, considering true crime has been a fascination of mine for decades. I also didn’t hear you’d posted this until today, Patreon notifications are spotty at best. Still, I had a very enjoyable 3 hours puttering around and listening to this video. Thanks for your hard work and for having a mind that is crystal clear and a wit as sharp as a sword. The way you bring stories full circle is so satisfying. I agree wholeheartedly in your assessment why it was a one and done. You mentioned the Delphi case. I deliberately didn’t follow it when it started getting supernatural. But if you were to present a case, I’d happily listen. I enjoy this format but I’m not unbiased about your content. I’ll like anything you put out there.

Ann Silberman

What?! You haven’t read In Cold Blood?! Start immediately. I read it far too young, and it started an almost lifelong fascination with true crime.

Rosalind Margulies

Went in completely blind — I started suspecting Tim was the murderer after all when he was acquitted in the second trial and I saw that there was still an hour and a half left of the video, lol

My Name

I've consumed enough Ziegler propaganda to have nitpicks of your memory of the McQueary episode lmao. Dammit. Half of me likes having the hot take that he's innocent and the other half yearns for someone who thinks JS is totally guilty to make their case with as much detail and candor as the innocence camp does. Like you said though, the stuff that Sandusky fully admits to doing (I'd argue much moreso than with MJ btw) is enough to make any normal person VERY uncomfortable, even if if you can make the argument that there was no sexual intent.

My Name

I think with both the forensics and the Cone sighting, something had to budge. For the forensics, Hennis was either innocent or he got insanely lucky that they found someone else's pube, etc. For the Cone sighting, either Hennis is dead-to-rights guilty, or there's SOMETHING we don't know. Maybe Cone saw Hennis get the Dog from the family and he is secretly an evil trickster who saw the police there and thought it would be funny to implicate that guy in a murder/rape just for the hell of it. Or he had some weird vendetta against Hennis that no one knew about, or something. My point is that while the Cone sighting is more or less conclusive when taken at face value, it's still POSSIBLE for it to be wrong. I gave ridiculous examples, but they're not 1 in 42 quadrillion ridiculous. I think it comes back to having probabilistic priors for which seemingly very unlikely thing is actually less likely. The hypothetical genius 80s juror who got this case right would know how the world works well enough to know that the pube has to budge before Cone does. I'm just trying to make my initial comment seem insightful. I dunno

Asaph Bitner

Hi, I really liked this episode (is that what we're calling it? anyway, whatever we're calling it,) a lot, thanks. I'd encoureage you do do more of these in addition to your regular videos, if you're so inclined

Joey Saha

very nice, more please

Julia

I was one of the gullible suckers that thought he might have been innocent. What a boob I am!

Julia

Absolutely ate this up by the way. Excellent work!!

Steve

It reminds me of the Easey Street case in Australia where the infant boy was found days later.

Evan

Just watched this a second time so maybe knowing the reveal biased me, but I think if I was on the jury I'm finding him guilty in all 3 trials. For me the coincidence that the family was murdered by a different stranger mere days after a different guy picked up a dog from them, had no concrete alibi, was caught burning trash, and lied to the police on multiple occasions is just too great. And the eye witness nailing the car type and colour that he drives really cements it for me.

Rowan Yourell

The second I saw that sketch compared to him, I thought there was no way it could be anyone else (even though I said not guilty because of lack of hard evidence)

Mae

I finally had time to finish this and goddamn, this is a phenomenal bit of presentation. You set the mystery up so well that I was braced for an unsatisfying and unhappy ending. The fact of the twist didn’t shock me as much as the about-face from resignation to relief. 10/10. If you did more of these, I’d even pay at a higher tier. Maybe I’ve commented this before but oh well. True crime is a divisive genre and much of the hate it receives is accurate. The first book I read about serial killers was in 2001 when I was in 6th grade and I was hooked, but I am exceedingly choosy about what I consume. Michelle McNamara had a quote somewhere on her blog about ethical true crime that has nested itself deeply in my heart. Your output is the only one that I am 100% committed to next to the inimitable Harold Schechter. You meet that threshold of ethical true crime then blow it out of the fucking water. Although you craft stories with these crimes, you never sacrifice facts for sensation. You’re never trying to frighten or moralize. I appreciate the fuck out of you and your content. Also, I am a private investigator specializing in fraud detection. Whenever I find absolute confirmation of fraud, I still think to myself “We. Have. CRIME!” from your NZ episode. 🤌🏻 still the perfect intro. And the only downside to this format is the lack of intro.

Qcknd

I'd upgrade to whatever tier you want to create to get this on the regular!💖💖

Ashley Owens

I did not see that coming! Glad I went in blind. Great video!

LEGENDARYxCOW

I had only listening to the audio until about the three hour mark, to leave a comment. My original feeling was that he did it, but I had reasonable doubt, and I slowly felt more like he was innocent as the video went on until the big reveal. I was about to comment that I should have trusted my gut when I saw the picture of Tim and realized I would have judged that book by its cover completely correctly had I seen the picture of him from the beginning. The guy looks like a creepy guy with skeletons in his closet to me.

Iktma Mafo

Holy. Shit. Thanks for the content and I genuinely appreciate it.

Grace Wagler

I've been thinking about it, and not killing Jana might just have been a continuation of his fun, i.e. "Let's see if the noob husband and neighbors catch on before this one croaks. If the noob husband figures it out in time, he can keep this one as a consolation prize lol"

Grace Wagler

It wasn't perfect, but it was definitely compelling

Grace Wagler

Almost like putting the two of them in a Saw trap

Bethan Smart

I bought your Patreon after seeing all the comments this video and thought it seemed like one I couldn’t miss To say you blew my expectations out the water is an understatement. My new favorite video of yours. Your speech at the end about Gary made me bawl. One can only hope to be even 10% the person he proved himself to be. Just stellar work.

Carrie James

Count me in as gobsmacked when you said the dna matched him! I really did think he was innocent. Great case!

Big B

One of your best videos in a long time and I’ve never heard of this case and it’s extremely interesting (and tragic). You have a gift for storytelling.

Joris Oosterbeek

Hi Matt, as for the format of these videos: I personally usually listen to your content when doing longer busywork or hobbies such as mini painting. So for me episodes like this which are longer and less visual are great!

The Internet's #1 Herbert Hoover Stan

Your bit about the mindset of the killer was a revelation for me. When I read about these people, I've sometimes been guilty of pitying them. I imagine how I would feel if I had committed a monstrous crime and had arrest hanging over my head and I imagine that they must be living in Hell, eternally self-hating and paranoid about facing the consequences. I'd never even considered that someone could be gleeful about "getting away with it". These people are monsters, I shouldn't assume they would feel guilty or shame the way any normal prosocial person would.

bundaga borbo

can't help but wonder if 'getting an early start today' was actually framed as a question, just misread by cone. why that may be significant is tim could've been trying to trap cone in a conversation to work out how he could maybe sever him as a loose end, so to speak. i doubt even tim had high hopes that he would've been able to figure that out, but it parses to me that he'd instinctively think to try. when cone didn't bite because he thought tim was talking about himself, tim probably calculated that fishing through the bag for his knife to chase down somebody who wasn't a little girl without leaving evidence would be a little higher in difficulty than what he's used to, and so he decided to rely on the fallibility of memory. it hardly matters, but idk, it just sort of makes sense that tim might see somebody walking by at the exact, right time, and his inner monologue might be just the perfect cross section of frustrated and self-centered for him to kind of chidingly ask 'getting an early start today?' in the same way normal people say 'oh, so we're just gonna start raining now?' whenever they're inconvenienced by the weather. either way, thank god for patrick cone, and blame the devil for tim hennis.

Don T.

You have to be right for the right reason though. Maybe the prosecutors should've waited to charge until they had real evidence

Will nasenbeny

I was talking from the fathers/husbands perspective the video mentions how he was certain after the first trial and i was trying to describe how it would have felt to be him, not anything to do with the legal side im not very literate in that

Five Gallon Pickle Bucket

I'm a little late to the party here but I wanted to say that for me personally, I like this content even more than your main channel. I'm one of those who mainly uses Youtube as a listening experience, and I love it when I can just put something on that's super long while I sit here working. Edit: I'll also add that I like the loosely scripted style. It's kind of difficult to find the happy medium between personality and script, and overly scripted narration is usually much less enjoyable for me. I find all your content to be right in the zone I like, and your manner of speaking is particularly suited to it in my opinion.

Bunty

One of the greatest case breakdowns I’ve ever heard. 10/10 for the research, flow, themes, and overall layout. Listened to it twice already. The serial killer scared straight theory is something I am in lockstep with you on. He brought a change of clothes with him and cleaned up with gloves and brought a trash bag. He knew he was killing the kids before he got in the car. I believe stopping by the ex girlfriend’s house was an alibi for him because he didn’t realize they’d pinpoint the hour it happened and was likely hoping it would be much later down the road before he had to answer any questions, if at all

Katie Davies

Loved this format just as much as you usual videos! I liked how more relaxed your style was!

Nazerke

Wow! Absolutely incredible analysis of the case!!! I'll be honest even when you said there was DNA test, it took me another 15 mins for me before I realized he actually did the crime. Brilliant work, Matt!!!!

Fa Perreault

Dude amazing format. I will pay again. More more more 👌👌👌

Jessica

Buddy I'm at the 2:22:00 mark and not only was I completely invested in this entire thing, but my flabbers were absolutely gasted by the reveal. Maybe I'm naive or dumb. But it was incredible. This format was perfect by the way. Honestly I spend a lot of time rewatching your videos and not actually looking at them. So I didn't feel any loss from the video footage being blank. Big thumbs up. Would love more like this for patreon.

ihavecancerjk

Giving him the dog is such a revelation

Bunty

Tbf, had the witness been the killer, he could have seen the guy in the area picking up the dog and just described him to police as a red herring.

Bunty

I believe the stop at Nancy’s was to tighten up a potential alibi. “Oh Thursday? Left her place around 9 and had to go right to sleep because I was on base at 5am and busy that whole weekend.” Anything found at the Eastburn house as far as Hennis’ was related could be explained away by his visit to pick up the dog earlier that week. I wonder if he found time on Thursday in between dropping his wife off and visiting Nancy to get in a solid nap to ensure he could go through the night. Maybe he slept in late that morning before dropping his wife off. I believe he spent the entirety of Wednesday planning and prepping and fantasizing for what he was going to do

Jordan Post

37 minutes in I think I know who the killer is

Jordan Post

My fuck that reveal was a blindside

Lol W

Went in blind, I believed the first verdict, was slammed by the 2nd unshocked by the 3rd. What took by breath away, by a huge laugh, was the not so smart now xxxx line. I’m so glad I signed up to your Patreon to hear this. Thank you.

Nathan Boslem

Value of patreon subscription justified 10 times over, minutes after putting my card details in. Expected no less. Bravo! 💪

Matthew Thayer

I wonder if the baby starving to death was the plan. He wanted to kill her as slowly as possible, and figured she wouldn't be found in time.

Jove Tripp-Thompson

Loved this so much, especially the opportunities to come up with our own conclusion followed by the jurors decision. Something that affected my decision making was what you said during your Karen R**d addendum: weigh all evidence equally. The ATM eye witness? Could be damning. The burning of the clothes? Could be damning. The jacket the dry cleaners? Well, that could be damning, but none of it really matters if there is no DNA found in the house…well, I suppose it was found, then found out, eventually. Like most, I was totally blind sided. The way you presented the story was so much more enjoyable than a cursory view via Wikipedia. Happy they got him in the end.

Nyki Racey

This might be my absolute favorite video of yours. I watched it a few days ago and I have been unable to get this case out of my mind. Absolutely fantastic work, Matt.

muruba

This has been a five-parter for me. Had to watch it spread out over three days, coincidentally while my husband was out on a work trip alongside with our dog. The point you made about Dixie being out of the way and that making it easier to target this family... it sure made me think back to all the times my dog, who never even barks at other dogs or sirens and has no aggresive bone in his body, started ferociously barking if a man appeared 20 meters behind me while I was walking him at night. Or when he alerted me to a presence of a bear once and fully locked in to defend me, before I gave him an order to run. It made me appreciate the safety he provides by just lending me his nose, ears, and instincts and I think I might insist on him staying with me next time husband leaves for a few days, lol. But more to the video itself: It takes a real narrative skill to present such horrible, tragic event in a humane and analytical way without dramatizing it or coming off as cold. I really appreciate you took the time to do that for us, even though it was a hard one to process emotionally. Cheers from Czechia, as always. 🌼

Samantha W

Bit late to the party since I stumbled across the post on the YT page, and after watching the preview fade away like sand through my fingers, I finally got a Patreon membership. I had no idea about this case so I went in blind and…holy shit. I ironically think this might be your best work. I kind of do hope it gets the full video treatment in some form someday because the whole story is riveting. But I can see why you did it this way. There’s a LOT. Keep up the excellent work.

Katherine C

I have listened to this 3 times now. I absolutely love the format and presentation. It loses nothing on re-listens. Please more!!!

Billy Green - The Filthy Casual

When I heard it was a case from the 80s, I figured there would be a DNA bombshell. I was of the opinion that it REALLY REALLY looked he did it, but JUST not quite enough that I would have found him guilty on the jury. I'm glad DNA evidence is getting these bastards who think they got away.

Alex

Matt - this ones a beauty!! Amazing work, amongst your best. I loved the length - inhaled this in one sitting - and as someone who hadn't heard about the case, I had an actual "oh s***!" moment when your dropped the bomb. If you're weighing whether to make more or less of these, I'm firmly in the pro camp.

Amanda

Sorry for the comment so late after the video, but out of curiosity, did the DNA test that recovered a 1 in 426 match use different sources of potential DNA or did it use a different site of the DNA? Do you know if one used mitochondrial DNA and the other nuclear? Awesome video, by the way! This format works really nicely. It's a bit of an oldie, so I don't know if it quite fits, but I think it'd be cool to see you cover something like the Parker-Hulme case (the one the movie Heavenly Creatures is based on) in this format.

Koral Downey

39:43 wasn't there a Russian serial killer rapist with a different blood type in his semen than his blood?

Livia L.

The sample on Youtube hooked me immediately so I couldn't help but sub to check this out, and I am so happy I did! My stomach actually dropped when the DNA reveal happened, this was done so well. Will definitely be staying on as a Patron to catch more exclusives and anything other videos like this!!

Lanie Hall

Fantastic story by an amazing storyteller! I always enjoy your videos, maybe especially the ones I can just listen to as I'm usually cleaning or otherwise occupied as I listen. Sometimes, I listen at night while I'm falling asleep! Thanks for the videos! ❤️

gillygull

I had never heard of this one before, so my jaw dropped several times. My arms are sore from having to scoop it off the floor

frecklifox

A true crime story has never had me so emotional and straight up nauseous in increasing measure right up until the end.

Pharoah

This got me through my workday love the longform content keep it up!

Amandinha

GREAT video. Had the pleasure of watching your newest on youtube, which had already made my day. Only to then come to patreon and be blessed with this gift. [POTENTIAL SPOILERS] About your question of when did we see the plot twist coming - i must say all the descriptions of Tims military career as a point in his favour as an outstanding citizen and etc. were Bizzare to listen to. As a Brazillian person, to serve USAs military is to be paid to kill brown foreigners in the interest of capital, and a huge red flag in terms of character. Literally the guy going for the "murdering people impunely" career path after being accused of three accounts of horrible murders... I knew right then and there!

Ink

2:28:30; I hate to be that guy but I DID have to stop and scream, and I know I’m not the only one

Zombie Rights

This is amaaaaaazing. Love this for topics that don’t fit the channel format. Thank you so much for trying this out Matt! I actually like your unfiltered natural presentation just as much as your ‘pro narrator’ cadence.

Katie Bradshaw

On the topic of Pat Cone, all I can say is a criminal record doesn't make a bad person

Arcane

I really, really like the format here. Honestly, I've never been as interested in the interrogation footage as I have been in the storytelling. I'm a bad listener so I'd probably appreciate a little more editing, but I imagine that would go without saying for a main video. Hope this ends up on youtube someday!

scrubsplunking

i joined the patreon specifically for this type of content. this is exactly what i need to listen to for my marathon traning. i also loved you pausing on where our thoughts were on the case, but i did pause and think about it - i had reasons to doubt, but more so it was because my idea of what happened wasn't what the prosecution presented, and the credit card issue seemed so unimportant to me. it would have been easy to have someone else go do it. i think this is a very difficult case that hopefully cannot be repeated again due to advances in DNA testing; but at the same time. the prosecution's case was very clearly lacking early on and the tragedy of harm should not be used to excuse a lack of evidence.

Arcane

I also have to say that I love the way you actually include a 'victim' in a way that's relevant to the themes, theory, and analysis in the end. You mention it in the video, but the way victims are treated in true crime always really bothers me because of how insincere and tacked on it is. There's a sense of guilt or shame in such a senseless inclusion, as if to cover the writer's own ass somehow, and that bleeds over to me as a member of the audience. The way you do it here demonstrates legitimate thought, intentionality, and respect remarkably well in contrast.

julia

Legitimately had to pause this and walk around my yard a couple times. What. The. Fuck. This is one of the craziest stories i’ve ever heard in my life. You did the big reveal in a manner so effective I genuinely got a bit lightheaded. Matt, you are a fenomenal, absurdly talented storyteller. What. The. Fuck.

Justin Valderrama

This is awesome! I listen to YouTube in the background anyway, so it's just more Matt as far as I'm concerned but great nonetheless.

Tara McIntyre

I'd followed you here but as a free account. Heard your latest, and the tease for this one grabbed me. Signed right up & glad I did. Of all the TC creators that I follow, your analysis (and senses of humor and profound outrage) is absolutely top shelf. Thanks for yet another wild ride.

Catherine Duren

Ya got me with the YouTube pitch 😂💜

Vale

Never heard of this case before, but what a rollercoaster! I was totally shocked that he did it

Justin Valderrama

Damn, that was a wild ride. This guy really reminded me of the Canadian colonel Russell Williams.

roseh

i mean it's not exactly rare for soldiers to commit rape and murder and get away with it, so he easily could've satiated himself that way before and after

Kormai

I was admittedly not paying as close attention as I usually do but I was pretty shocked by the reveal. I also really like this format. I prefer longer format content in general, which your typical videos are great for as well. And I will always be excited for more Matt Orchard content.

Luthen’s Reality

Ok I’m not done watching but you said he “didn’t do anything bad after being acquitted”, he went and served in a war and probably killed mors people, just cuz they aren’t his neighbors doesn’t mean he’s not killing! I feel like you’re downplaying his role as a soldier who could have committed horrific crimes abroad with little to no scrutiny cuz he’s in the us military . Maybe I’m being too critical but serving in the military in the first place was a red flag for me, it would make sense that a sociopath might be able to mask themselves in normal life by being in the military, and the fact he went right back, and not just for the back pay cuz he stayed for so long afterwards, is evidence in favor of the prosecution imo. I don’t think it’s a make or break smoking gun but I just think your analysis of it is wrong. I love ur videos so much because you always tell the story in the exact same thought process i do, (“very intuitive” is how you’d describe it lol) which is why this part just really threw me off because i got the exact opposite impression. And yes i may have taken some edibles before watching 🍃 😆 Edit: after finishing the video and being blindsided at the reveal, i was very satisfied because all along i was thinking that he was guilty but we just needed one single shred of foresnic evidence. I had also mapped out the idea that he was looking for sex that night and probably did it as a crime of opportunity rather than cold blooded, but then other stuff made me think cold blood, I’m leaning more towards that angle. I do still think you missed the obvious red flag of him being military which is a place I think a lot of antisocial people are able to slip through the cracks or rather be pointed at our “enemies”. They kill people abroad, they get decorations and promotions. The discipline of the military also likely keeps them in check. It also allows them to justify their crimes, (I kill someone overseas who is no threat to me otherwise for the military and I get praise for it, how is this any different?) and it’s a fair point as a purely abstract/hypothetical conversation about the morality of what we do overseas. I’m not saying he did this as some sort of insane protest, I’m just saying he likely latched onto anti war sentiment as post-hoc justification for his horrifying actions. He was doing what the united states military does to whoever it wants to conquer which is rape and kill, which absolutely extends to children. And no one gives a fuck until it comes back to the states in a million different terrible ways. Maybe if there wasn’t a place for him in the military, that part of him never would have woken up. Or there might have been red flags. Even the fact that Gary was away from his home, the fact that the DOG HAD TO BE GIVEN UP CUZ HE WAS MOVING ABROAD are all directly related to the fact that America keeps an insane amount of men away from their homes, straining relationships, not to mention sending them abroad to kill and plunder and die. Obviously this is not me blaming Gary or any of the victims, that’s absurd, BUT his circumstances are a factor that gave Tim the opportunity to commit this crime. It’s actually giving me chills because I suspect tim has thought about this exact thing after the fact. But anyways my point is I found your analysis on the military part overall lacking, I gave you benefit of the doubt after the twist cuz I thought you were just being intentionally deceptive but you never really brought it up. I’d love to see a commentary or addendum or something on this point because I think it’s valid. Other than that this vid was incredible I had no idea what was coming although I had suspicions, gasped at the reveal. Ur videos rule!

chavonwright

I am almost done but I have to just comment on how much weight you've given to the most naive, unsubstantiated bullshit that is why jurors so often get it wrong. Crime, heinous monstrous crimes are committed by people with all types of reputations and there is not a type--- except statistically. And statistically, white men, with families, and jobs in law enforcement, with otherwise great reputations commit the most violent crime. He's an enlisted soldier so while he has been convicted of three murders, to believe that he has only KILLED three times, is absolutely asinine. The idea that this rape was his first and only is also ridiculous when you consider the rape reporting, indictments, and convictions in the 1980s. Tie in, once again, that he is an enlisted soldier, believe that he's never raped any other woman is simply foolish. The entire time I knew that he was guilty, however, I absolutely could not respond to this podcast without reasonable doubt, because your retelling of the case, while compelling, is not evidence. Reasonable doubt is not at all confusing, people just constantly form opinions without enough information or information that they erroneously consider important. For example, the acquitted murderer was only caught once....literally just like almost every other murderer. He didnt have to be scared into being a better person, he just needed to make sure he wore condoms, chose his victims more carefully, parked further from the house, and didn't greet the eye witness or like not a complete idiot, left out of the back door or checked for pedestrians next time. With any violent crime, it is imperative to look both at 1. the spouse and 2. any newcomers in the victims life. Spouse was out so what was literally the only difference in their lives the week of the murders? A random military bloke was in their home. His whole lifestyle is statistically sus, and he seems like he has a drug problem because why is he so broke in 1985 working in the military AND having a second job, with no mortgage and one kid? I don't know how often you've analysed witness testimony, but I have never in my lifetime seen such a clear, precise unprovoked ID in a case, ever. That sketch was absolutely a dead ringer. The whole element about the other dude? Waste of time/annoying. He didn't walk out of the crime scene, he hadn't been at the crime scene days before, and while he "looked like" Hinnis, the way that every white guy in the 1980s did, only one of them looked exactly like that sketch. A lack of evidence is not evidence. Anyone can drop a pubic hair of their own or someone completely random, anyone can avoid spreading blood around their car, anyone can wear gloves to a crime... Nothing provided by the defense excludes him at all. Coincidence in crime is not at all common so it was painful to keep hearing you say that to potential American jurors. Why would he risk awol - duh, to have a solid alibi. Why did he burn one fire at his house - duh to get rid of evidence. The majority of cases aren't complicated but sadly the majority of jurors are essentially illiterate. Your theory is almost right, but again, not being convicted of a crime means absolutely nothing. Especially if you're a white guy in the military in the 1980s in the south. To this day, police are not "solving" murders. Really, anyone killing a complete stranger is likely to never be found unless they made some wildly obvious mistake - like being seen walking out of the crime scene with your car parked outside. It is just as likely that he never did anything bad after his acquittal as it is that he was never caught again. The serial killer argument was wildly weak, btw. The people those two creeped out were NEVER questioned until the cases were incredibly famous. In the 1980s you could completely escape a scandal by simply moving a few towns over. If you are going to murder, obviously keep it hidden from those closest to you ---- because Jurors will weigh character witnesses far too heavily. All of that being said, I love your style and you are wildly talented at this. I wish his guilt wasn't so obvious, but of course it was. I wish the military angle hadn't been so predictable, but it was. I wish any of the defense theories were plausible but they weren't. (of course, ultimately I wish the crime had never happened, but contextually, for the video..) I am very grateful to see older cases being covered in detail despite the lack of video footage and can't wait until the general public accepts that the only difference between the good guys and the bad guys is that the bad guys were caught. Also, crime reports are not focused on the perp more than the victim because they are dead. It is very simply and obviously because victims of crime deserve their privacy and trial defendants have years of records about every element of their life, their crime, their trial, their sentence. Anyone who is complaining about law and crime commentary not focusing on the victims is a self-righteous idiot who wouldn't know a critical thought if it showed up at their home wielding a weapon. The last thing we should be doing is putting any victim's information on the internet without their or their family's consent, especially anything outside of the official court records.

roseh

exactly. and in general "everyone we've heard from spoke highly of him" doesn't mean there aren't people who we haven't heard from. it's a cliche lol "well he never did anything like that to ME"

chavonwright

Also not a fucking chance Mrs. Eastburn called him. He's probably just stupid and didn't realize how phone records work. At 9pm? With three kids under three? One reason defendants don't take the stand is because a juror would be a fool to not just assume the person on trial is lying about every single thing that's not corroborated. We know his first statement included lies, therefore, assume its all lies unless proven otherwise.

Irina Nesterenko

I subscribed just today and this episode just blew my mind. You had me at every turn, it’s almost embarrassing. I enjoyed every second of it. And gasped so hard at *the moment* i scared my family

Catherine Duren

Wow! Just wow, I was hoping the DNA would end with the killer. But this is one of the craziest cases I have ever heard. I hope that the Eastburns & Tim's family are healing from his horrible evil actions. This format is incredible. The fact that we may not have heard this with the other format?? Great job and please keep this kind of video.

Sasha

The teaser at the end of your latest youtube release was a very effective marketing tactic and I'm glad it got me. This is some incredible case coverage.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks so much - that's very kind :) I think the lesson there is basically if it comes from the heart it will seem like that, and if it doesn't, it won't. The sort of "innocent people being murdered is sad" disclosures you're describing probably don't literally run contrary to what the creator thinks, but because they're forced and probably quite generic they just smell insincere. Not that I'm dogging on any given creator, know there's plenty of sincere thoughtful people in the space!

Wobbles and Bean

I'm having some formatting issues, like the sound not working or cutting out. I'm not sure what's going on.

kcr

What a video, got a membership to watch it, and it was well worth it. Great coverage of a fascinating, albeit incredibly tragic, case.

misused alien

The only reason I wasn't super surprised was because I think I've heard this before. I wasn't completely sure, though.

Édua Kaszás

Subscribed after watching the He said/she said video on Youtube! Love this format just as much as your usual type of content, great work!

Daze Dawning

I'd entertained a Patreon sub before now, but the teaser absolutely hooked me, and I'm glad I followed through. After watching the full video, it really feels like someone combined Anthony Palma and Colonel Russell Williams into one horrific man. One of the things I find very chilling about criminal psychology is that, by necessity, we can only profile based on the psychology of criminals who have been CAUGHT, which means the most intelligent and self-controlled types of offenders tend only to be caught when forensic technology advances past their wildest imagination or when coincidence serves to undercut their concocted alibis (or both). I also think people are afraid of the serial killer next door, not because such killers can fool everyone, but because they can fool us as individuals. Maybe long enough to adopt our dogs and then stop in late at night. What's especially haunting to me is that I did conclude that reasonable doubt remained when grappling with Trial 1 as a potential jury member. The idea that a killer could be rewarded by simply covering their tracks well enough to invoke reasonable doubt is unspeakably infuriating, but the answer cannot be to tamper with witnesses or use psychological tactics on the jury when substance is lacking. It's also crazy how good of a witness Patrick Cone was, considering the circumstances, and thank goodness for him. To be walking home late at night, probably tipsy, and see a stranger through the drizzle, and to be able to give such an accurate composite image of him to the cops, along with the description of the car? He saved Gary and Jana Eastburn a potential lifetime of not knowing, and an unknowable number of victims from suffering a similar fate. Good on that guy. Anyway, I do think the case fits having been committed by an intelligent monster with a premeditated plan. The Russell Williams comparison is especially illustrative here, particularly with how he was largely able to show up to his military job with no one having the slightest inkling of there being anything off about him. "Nice" man, stable marriage, no red flags of psychopathy in daily life, with a monster simmering underneath. Great video, harrowing case, format makes it more of a podcast experience which is plenty nice in its own right.

Mila

Came here from your YT end of video teaser and I’m happy to report I’ll be staying ❤️ absolutely loved this format and hope you’ll make more! Cheers mate 👏

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

it was another sample of the same substance - semen recovered from Katie's body. The first smoking gun one was from the original swab, and the 1 in 426 one from later was from a slide taken by the original medical examiner. Dunno any other technical particulars.

Asa Brown

Unbelievable eyewitness testimony performance

adamoki

Great video 🤌

Erin

finally subscribed to the pateron. I love your content and this video was great. Definitely would love more of this type of content. I didn't 100% see that it would end up being Tim but you spending so much time on why he was innocent made me suspicious that you were going to bamboozle us. All the love from Australia. I would also love if you could do any kind of content on Peter Falconio's murder. I don't think any of the Aussie documentaries have got it right and I think you would do it such better justice.

Zanydruid158

Got brought into the Patreon by the plug on your latest video. You've always had good Patreon plugs which I appreciate and this one finally got me. Can't be happier for having joined to listen to this. What a bonkers case.

Beastman

Worth the patreon sub!

Corey Knowler

Hello Mr orchard, the little sample of this video that I heard in your most recent main channel video definitely got me hooked into signing up, and I must say this format is just as gripping as the main channel stuff. I really like the length as well as the more casual tone, and I was not familiar at all so this case definitely blindsided me. I will be going back through your other patreon items now and look forward if you decide to do more content in this format!

Liam Sullivan

What a rollercoaster. And smart idea doing the 10 minute preview, it really sucked me in and convinced me to take the plunge. Now to get caught up on all the other MOCAS patreon goodies that I've been missing out on

Robin Argent

I tend to be a pretty trusting person and very much on the side of "better to let 100 guilty people go than put 1 innocent person away", so that DNA reveal absolutely floored me! I'm so glad you included your theory, because even though it's only speculation and we'll never KNOW if it's true, it lets me walk away from this story feeling a sense of resolution. Fantastic video. I was a little worried that there wouldn't be any visuals, but actually I prefer the narration over courtroom or interrogation footage, which I tend to find a bit dull. I watch content like this because I want the narration. THAT'S the draw for me. And you do an especially good job of keeping everything straight, especially names and dates, which for me are really hard to keep track of in a lot of other videos. I have terrible short-term memory lol. I'm glad you gave this an extra shout-out on Youtube so I could come check it out. If I ever have the funds to be a real, ongoing supporter, you best believe I'll be back here to your patreon. Excellent, EXCELLENT work, Matt. Us true crime addicts are so lucky to have you!

Kroob Eklund

I actually gasped out loud in the grocery store when it was his DNA. I had no idea it was coming. The case seemed so weak before that. insane. I love this format and ran to patreon after the end of the He said she said video. Excellent stuff

Pia S

omg I was so sure he was guilty, you convinced me 100 % to "Oh no I think he is actually a really good guy" to being absolutely SHOCKED to learn he was guilty. What an emotional rollercoaster even though I was aware the 180 was the script you're basically known as. All of that aside. I am just so incredibly glad that the surviving daughter and the husband (literal angel btw) were able to move on and live a rather normal life after this clusterfuck.

V3NUS

I was waiting the WHOLE time for him to bring the semen DNA up, and I was getting a sneaking suspicion because of how long he didn’t mention it when we jumped to 2004. Still got me, though!

Tj Snape

Never heard of this case but so happy I went in blind. I knew it was him as soon as you made the spiel about plausible deniability in the first trial. Well worth the $2. Thanks Matt.

nomercyforswine

Absolutely worth the $2. Would love to see more in this vein, as I work long shifts and can't really look at my phone anyway. The visuals are nice on youtube when I've got a weather eye free, but - speaking for myself - if there's more of this coming then you can absolutely expect continued support. [spoilers buffer] Even at the beginning this reminded me a lot of the Russel Williams case. I think also of Jeffrey MacDonald in 1979, also in NC. Something about the military, especially extremely committed members of the service, seems to attract these kinds of high-control individuals with a propensity for violence. Shocking revelation, I'm sure. I went back and forth many times during the course of the video, but my gut reaction was always that he was guilty - and I know it took concerted effort in the narration to seed that doubt, which I appreciate. Ultimately, it was too similar to other military slayings to overlook the evidence to the contrary. Really compelling stuff. I'll reiterate that if there's more of this caliber on the way, I'm happy to put in my $2 every month.

Siad

Just starting but If you haven't read the recent investigative book "Fort Bragg Cartel", I heavily recommend it. (perhaps unrelatedly to this case) extremely fishy goings-on.

Jacob Ostler

I love this format. Just came from your YouTube video. The more the merrier! The only bummer for me is that if I close the app, my place is always lost in the video and finding it takes a minute. But that’s a Patreon problem, and may even be unique to just me. Either way- love the work you do. 🙏🏻

Toni Mauck

To answer your question without spoiling for others in the comments, yes, that hit me like a ton of BRICKS. Also, spot on Bill Clinton impression.

Shook1

I really enjoyed all of this. Cheers Matt! This was a case I had never heard of. As a fellow kiwi I would love to see you cook on the Scott Watson case. Surely it has crossed your mind?

nihilfev

I loved this, please give us more!! And personally, the longer the video, the better

Gloria Hernandez

Hi Matt, I signed on to Patreon specifically to watch this, and wow, what a story. I went into it knowing nothing about this horrible crime. Hard to believe. And, I wholly agree with your theory. I like this format as much as your regular fare. Great job.

ilzee vk

I didn't know anything about the case. The reveal didn't exactly surprise me, but I have watched too many of your videos to not expect some kind of twist. That and the moment the semen was mentioned in 1985, I was immediately curios if it was ever retested.

Aidan Daly

Absolutely incredible breakdown of this story. I came here to subscribe after the preview of this you showed on your most recent video, I just had to see more, and I was not disappointed. I would love to watch any more content you decide to put out in this format, I don’t think I’ve ever found true crime content as engaging, thoughtful, and respectfully presented as your work, and it is a steal at 2 dollars a month. I really look forward to seeing more.

MandyxLola

Tim had me, I also voted not guilty. I was shocked at the DNA results

Sam Patterson

joined the patreon bc i had to finish this after that preview on yt! excellent format, pls do more

Caleb Mitchell

Best 2$ I've ever spent. It actually is as crazy as advertised. Thanks Matt!

Carl Mears

Joined bc of the ad from ur Hawaii vid. Binged through all ur addendums and they were all fantastic. Great insights. This vid is near the top of your vids mainly on the how you organized the narrative to make it so gripping. Love these long form videos and hope there are more to come! (Just don’t burn out, I would severely miss your videos)

Alya Smith-Hatton

yeahh that reveal still got me. damn. this was a ride.

Kai Topet

Bro I just couldn't see a dudes blue balls leading to such a horrific crime. I am a sap. 😭

Kristen Surya

LOVED this! and i love the format. one thing though: i generally love your takes and learn a lot from your insights, but i’m surprised that “military man” is a sign of “good upstanding guy” to you. of course every military is different but the us military commits violent atrocities abroad all the time. perfect outlet for someone like tim hennis, who could perform violence under the veneer of duty.

Hank J. Wimbleton

I agree with your speculation that he was the extremely rare example of the devil in plain view, that he had bad intentions for a long time, and that he took advantage of a situation that presented itself to him. I speculate he visited Nancy almost as a cope; he's giving himself an out. If Nancy throws herself at him, maybe he'll let the whole evil fantasy go. He knows that won't happen, so when it inevitably doesn't, it's a sort of psychological excuse for him going all-in, because it's "meant to be" or something like that. You see the same sort of weak self-excusing cope in the Denise Richards case.

Keydoesstuff

Came here to watch from your latest YouTube video. The teaser had me hooked and I am exceedingly pleased to have joined your Patreon. Another banger, dude! Edit: oh my god. I just got to the bomb drop. Fuck me.

Hime Takamura

Fantastic video, I love this format. Admittedly I'm a bit biased though, as I'm not as big of a fan of courtroom testimony.

Mary Stribley

Matt, this was incredible. Just incredible. The way you speak, think, analyse, storytell – you're just the best out there. So thrilled to be here on Patreon & supporting you!

just another tree

One thing that i think is of note when talking about his psychology is that he was a military man. when you say he spent years suppressing that urge before and after he was acquitted, he actually may have had an outlet, just a legal one. Makes you think of how many serial killers have never been caught because the government was the one to hand them a gun.

Sian Cole

Great work! Took me a few sittings but was always keen to return and listen to the whole 3+ hours.

ryan

Holy shit. I did NOT see it coming. Extremely well presented. Thanks so much for the video

Dionysus

I had the biggest frown when you dropped that bomb shell. This video alone was well worth the subscription.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Kristina! You've got to bear in mind, at the time of the murders he was *peace-time* military man. He'd never been deployed to combat, and in fact wasn't post-release. He was basically in charge of logistical type operations. Now I dunno if it follows being a military man actually necessarily makes you more likely to be a good person - but superficially speaking it falls in that "clean-cut-member-of-society" perception bracket regardless of whether it should. And I wouldn't go the *other* way and say it actually makes you more likely to crave murder, unless you were knocking on a recruitment door the second a war is announced!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Clever of you to spot the foreshadowing - discussing the masking issue was one moment where I was conscious I could be giving the game away if I wasn't careful to treat it sort of like everything else.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It has, and don't hold your breath because there's a bunch I've got on the back burner, but SW is one I've specifically thought could be good for this format as it's a bit too thin on visuals and clips for the mainline treatment. Mark Lundy too maybe - some day,

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Jacob! Sorry to hear about the playback issue. Might be worth asking help chat about or something though, especially if you're using the app, because everything resumes for me.

Erin's Page

This was excellent. You absolutely have the narrator charisma and writing chops to carry a video this long without the added courtroom or interview footage. I did see the twist coming, but mostly cause I think I found myself pretty much in agreement with your read- Occam's Razor said he was the most likely culprit but the original case just wasn't beyond a reasonable doubt, as frustrating as that is. I was watching I was also sitting here formulating the exact theory you laid out at the end. That this was something he always wanted to do and finally got his opportunity. It's disturbing how well people can hide themselves. A less extreme but more common example is people discussing a sudden change in their partners, especially women with male partners, as soon as engagement or marriage or a baby is on the table. They feel they have their target locked down and a perfect mask that was maintained for potentially years comes right off. I would also theorize that the release after potentially years of fantasizing would even explain the overkill that was attributed to rage. And then when the thrill of getting away with it died out and he faced the cold hard consequences, it was enough to snuff out the satisfaction and keep him scared straight. Its absolutely a discussion being had over here that the U.S. having next to absolutely no means for overturning double jeopardy can potentially be an issue. I don't think its been a common enough problem to warrant widespread debate or movement to change it, but I have heard it brought up by people in legal circles. There's definitely a reason why we have it in the constitution to prevent harassment via prosecution, but as with many things in constitutional law it also comes with the side effect of inflexibility in the face of changing technology. The inflexibility of the constitution in general is a whole issue unto itself, especially seeing as, if I recall correctly, it was the intent of the original writers that we re-evaluate and rewrite it as need, but that's a whoooole other kettle of fish. I came running to the patreon the moment I heard there was 3 hours of yapping to listen to and absolutely wasn't disappointed. Would love to see more content like this, either here as bonus content or even on the main.

Lady Bryght

I feel like I've even heard this case before and I was still blindsided!

Nicki

the way i fell over myself running from yt to patreon to sign up so i can hear more of this 😅

Molly Laich

Incredible. So glad you promoted this and made it so affordable.

Delia Titzell

Incredible Matt, this is no less a working than your usual content, and as comprehensive and interesting as breakdown as ever. I really hope you keep you do another deep dive like this in the future!

Lee O'Driscoll

OM actual G 😱 I obediently followed Lord Matt’s instructions not to look up the case - and no I didn’t see it coming!! I don’t want to drop spoilers but I thought perhaps it would be one of the other people mentioned earlier on - not who it ended up being. Love this format, love the detail and storytelling and could happily listen to these all day everyday (no pressure 😬). Thanks SO much for all your hard work Matt 💗🇬🇧

Mrs. Kip Dynamite

I will take 1000 of these 3 hour audio deep dives. I usually listen while doing something else and I was thrilled to have to look up less often. I subscribed just to hear this and will stick around if there will be more. Well done.

c b

I've laughed at your ads for patreon for ages, but you finally got me with the teaser for this one! I'm hooked. (A bonus is, as a kiwi expat living in australia, I miss that snarky kiwi humour and accent)

mackie poo poo

When I listen to you narrating a true crime story, I just go along with you for the ride. Never heard of the Eastman case so I’m one of those that yes, it hit me like a ton of bricks when DNA tested positive for Tim’s sperm. Crazy, a 3rd trial! Love your opinion/synopsis at the end. You’re the best Matt! Always worth the wait.

josh obrien

The click bait did 90% of the work my genuine pride to support New Zealand did the 10% but here we are and I love it

Emma

What a great video. I was thinking at the first pause that Cone could have done it, and seeing Hennis earlier that evening taking the dog, decided he had a convenient patsy. It was a bit strange to me that someone would run up out of the blue with a witness testimony that was so perfect. That's a bit of a stretch, but still, I didn't feel convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Hennis did it either. I was fixated from beginning to end!

Emma

I had exactly the same thought. Cone could have hypothetically seen him earlier and made him the fall guy.

Rita Inverno

Well done Matt, this alone has worth the membership. I must confess i was a bit disconnected from the channel because i was covering already covered cases so this one, although doesnt have media worked wonders, although i bet i gave tremendous amount of work. To the theory that he just stop i might add that, he pursued an active military so that ich must been scratched in some capacity

NW

no yeah that completely caught me by surprise. holy shit!

Adam Burchett

Matt thoroughly broke my ankles in the Holtzclaw video. Except the opposite way, being completely convinced of his guilt all the way to I think he might be completely innocent. Matt has broken my brain a few times now that I think about it. Such good stuff.

Katie

This was great.

em

Twist got me like a bitch, and i remember picking up on your hints as you went. My mind just willed them away, so come the DNA evidence i was totally lost in the sauce.

Lee Swain

This format works great for me because I usually like to "watch" while I am working on some art, so even with the full video presentations I am only watching in my peripheral vision and glancing up for specific moments of information. So this was an absolute perfect companion to my work environment! More of this please for sure!

Rebecca

I thought there was reasonable doubt, so the death penalty in particular made me uncomfortable. I did not think his good deeds before or after the crime spoke to innocence versus guilt. I do believe that there should be an amendment that allows for a retrial for things like advancements in technology or the discovery of major evidence like a body in a no body or partially recovered body case.

Hunt Westbrook

Just joined the patreon after the 10 min snippet from the most recent YT video and am SO glad I did. What a ride!!

zhyyo

Incredible video, I'm glad I watched it all the way though. I was completely blindsided by the final reveal, I was honestly expecting you to bring out another suspect who for some reason or another never ended up in prison for this- but no, fortunately even if it took *decades* this monster was locked away again. It really blew me away, I'm glad so many others were also totally unexpecting too! I just love your deliveries on these, I think this was a great introduction to your patreon! Super glad I decided to check it out. <3

D Swampson

I somehow didn't see the Hinnis match from 100 miles away. You convinced me that he probably didn't do it despite the evidence against him

Marcus Larraga

I got hooked by the sample on ur recent video, tbh going into trial 1 i thought the twist was going to be that he had some accomplice to explain the unknown hair and other holes amd even though i thought he was probably guilty i was still surprised by the drop. It makes me wonder about his military time deployed, like he may have been too scared to try again at home but in these unstable war torn countries would be a lot easier to get away with. Its hard to imagine someone who would do something like this just giving it up

Sophia A

i’m of the belief that many men who are the “would be serial killer” type got their fix from being in the military. worth considering just a little

David Moreira

Damn. I thought I could not be more blown away since the "coldest crime ever solved". But this one... Fuck me.

Emily Maupin

So good! I wish there was more. Or rather, that there are more to come.

AR

fwiw in the U.S. military recruitment post-9/11 comes disturbingly close to a mix of "come kill brown people with us!" and "hey, do you like first-person shooter games? guess what!"

Kristen Surya

yes that’s exactly my point. the history of the u.s. military is notoriously ugly too (i’m thinking specifically of my lai but there are endless examples). and soldiers are well incentivized here but treated very poorly overall, especially with regards to mental health and trauma processing. to me it’s just not a green flag when someone says they’ve done time in the us military; it’s very much the opposite.

Crownic B

oh my gosh if anyone sorts comments by new before watching something in the odd chance I catch someone LISTEN WHEN HE SAYS DO NOT GOOGLE YOU WILL BE SO HAPPY. And to matt: ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. well done. well done.

Daniel Lee

I enjoyed this very much. Thank you.

rika ♡

Hey! Came from the youtube video's 10m preview. I've binged pretty much every vid on that channel and figured supporting your content and getting hours more of your yapping wouldn't be a bad deal. Went in blind, was fairly convinced there was reasonable doubt through the halfway point. Some of those weird details just didn't add up. But when you mentioned the confirmed DNA evidence, the shock lasted for a moment, and then I thought, yeah, I guess so. Matt didn't really entertain any other suspect, and the narrative build up as neutral as you sounded was so heavily focused on the circumstances surrounding Dixie's adoption. And although so many things didn't particularly add up, so many things did (like the composite sketch). It's as if there was just as much room for unreasonable doubt as there was reasonable doubt. I feel so truly for Gary Eastburn, the much more honorary example of a stand up guy, who went through the experience with more grace than I ever could have. I also feel for Angela and her daughter. Even if they outwardly say they're convinced of Tim's innocence, I think behind closed doors deep down they know. It may just be easier on their psyche to delude themselves into thinking there's no way it could have been Tim, after the 17 years of perfection he performed. Wonderful delivery and presentation as always! I have to admit there's a charm to these more "yappy" versions where we don't have to sit through court/interrogation footage, as well as getting to hear your more candid voice and feelings (sort of like Simon from the Casual Criminalist!). I'll be binging the rest of your creator commentaries and mini addendums now, thanks for the hard work!

Ashley Brown

Oh, you magnificent bastard! I've heard of this case before but had forgotten the names. Your storytelling was so captivating that it wasn't until the twist that I realized it what case this was and what was about to happen next. You really had me considering the facts and ethics from so many different angles, and appreciating all the human and downright stranger-than-fiction aspects of the case. Thanks so much for pitching this little gem on your recent Konig video - it was worth checking out!

Dr. Thomas Rasberry

I think this case reminded me more of the Michelle Martinko case here in Iowa more than anything - in that case, a completely (outwardly) peaceful man who lived in a town 45 minutes away from Cedar Rapids decided to drive to the mall, pick up a girl, and commit murder. He didn't even assault her sexually. He just killed her. He never so much as jaywalked before or after that, he was never even a suspect when the crime happened in '79, and he just went on with his life with nobody around him knowing any better. A similar case happened in Oklahoma City where a young man killed a friend in cold blood just to know what it was like. I think he turned himself in if I remember correctly. Yes, he could've been an aborted serial killer after the death penalty reprieve scared him straight. But I think that's unlikely. I think these other cases show that some people out there just want to do something like that **once.** They get an itch, one that grows and grows, with that burning tug in your stomach as your feelings leap between sickness from knowing it's deeply evil on one hand, and exhilaration from just thinking about carrying it out and experiencing that thrill on the other hand. I had a similar feeling once in my twenties, except that it was about hard drugs. An unlikely but wide-open window suddenly opened up for me to try one, and as the days went by I had that same feeling. I'd get sick knowing how wrong it was just possessing that drug, more or less consuming it, knowing the risk I'd put my health in by subjecting myself to possible addiction (more or less consuming something dangerous and risking a health emergency from the actual cut I wanted to score). On the other hand, it was **precisely engaging in that same risk** that drove my exhilaration and sent that tension within me into meltdown mode. One day, I just couldn't stop thinking about it, and I finally pulled the trigger, got it and put it into my body. Thank God it wasn't cut with something poisonous; thank God I didn't become an addict. I just kept rolling along, and for years I looked back on that one moment with secret pride in myself. And i just needed to get that one hit. Just to try it. I think what happened here was for a far, far darker and more serious crime, but I think the driving mechanism was the same in my case and in theirs. We just wanted to try it once - and once was enough.

Dr. Thomas Rasberry

Also, how much did this bring up memories of Russell Wilson? I wonder if this guy had the same kind of feeling, since he carried a similar level of ability, prestige and rank as that degenerate Colonel did. Like you, I wonder if he tried something that always worked for him before, some fetish that was a Williams type of thing. In this case, you meet a woman whose husband is away or an ex or someone who you can have a quick tryst with when your wife isn't around. His ego is bruised when something he took earlier as a "signal" that always worked in this situation before blew up in his face. The violence was perhaps not planned in this case, but it was under the hood - he knew it was tied to his overdone sense of self-worth, so if it ever failed I bet he had a sense of the volcanic explosion that would follow. It just didn't happen until that night. He lashed out in retaliation, perhaps even taking down the kids as she was tied up for part of the revenge before turning the violence on her. I wonder if their acts were some kind of release from all the stringent expectations, discipline, and rigidity they were known for and defined their self-worth for following. For big rule-followers like military, there could be a temptation in finding a way to secretly break those same rules in the worst way possible - and not get caught.

Elkia Szczecinski

I agree in general but I think the circumstances here make it so unlikely. I find it almost impossible to believe that anything he could have gained as a black man in the 80s by immediately inserting himself into a murder investigation to accuse some random person (who could have had an iron clad alibi for the murder night for all he knew) could not have been outweighed by the risk. I’m sure the 2026 hindsight comes into play here a bit, but I just find it so hard to imagine making that choice if he was the killer.

Bridj

So glad I joined Patreon! Your ad at the end of the Koenig episode on YouTube totally worked btw

josh obrien

Am I crazy to think I've meet the man behind this voice at hide club?

Lisa Dokter

Her phone number not being found actually points to his guilt. Of course he couldn't know this, but once he spoke to the police and had to mention the phone call, where is his phone number in her house? Who else, what other suspect, would have the need to get rid of the piece of paper with his number on it? And yes, he is evil.

XX Slendermom XX

And they say you can't get anything good for 2 bucks these days... Outstanding as always!! Thank you so much 🩷 The theory is spot-on in my opinion; I mean one of the kids was in bed under the blanket, right? She probably never even woke up, they were all doomed from moment one. My guess is he didn't even know about the baby... Maybe on the initial visit she was napping or out of sight or something so he thought there was only two kids? Neutral on the format switch. Tbh I almost always consume my YT content as audio only, like podcasts or whatever because 95% of the time I'm doing something else while it's playing. Not that I don't appreciate good visuals ( I'll make a point to look at say like a suspect sketch or a map or something, I simply don't have the down time to stare at the screen like I used to lol) Anyway brilliantly done, I really enjoyed it thank you again!!

Kevin Amos

God bless you bro! Thank you!

12 o Clock in the Midnight

The second I wondered why you were really pushing how nice this guy reportedly was I knew something dark was coming. I might have missed something but was he originally going to assault the ex Partner?

Justin Walker

Just brilliant. The best 2 quid I've ever spent.

Queen of Hearts

This really helped me put into words my own thoughts on the case

Van

Hi Matt. I just saw your latest YouTube video last night, and it was amazing work. I saw the advertisement for this case at the end of it. I was so excited to see this and to be able to afford the amount required to support you and watch this particular case here on your Patreon. I haven't logged in to my Patreon in years and years, I literally ran to my laptop to find your page for this. Thank you for making an affordable tier option! I'm so keen. Hi five from Australia.

sarah koltonuk

I think Baby Jana being left out of it also has something to do with the fact that he had a baby of his own. Maybe it’s the 22 month old reminded him too much of his daughter to do it

Bill Papapetrou

You did an excellent job of selling this Patreon exclusive episode at the end of your last YouTube video; got me subscribed for the first time for sure.

Austin

joined the patreon for this, it's perfect for my nighttime listen (it's more chill without the cuts of interrogation/news footage)

Matt Molewski

Can't deny it: That was absolutely worth $2.

january chung

there’s smth about this story that’s so eerie to me… idk if it’s bc i went into it completely blind or just the way you’re telling the story, but it gave me absolute CHILLS !! such a good and detailed video, i love the way you told it step by step and got us fooled until the dna evidence. feels like highway robbery to watch this and all other videos for a price THIS LOW 😭😭😭

Jace Wood

Something about your presentation of this case that makes my stomach turn is the profound impact it has had on my assessment of the Jon Benet case. I think the intruder is the second trial.

Kaddy Kay

This was great! I've always wanted to sub to the patreon but that 10 minute intro did it! so congrats, and I hope it got a lot of others who may have been on the fence about it here as well! I loved this, you have an amazing storytelling skill- I'm sure you've heard it 1000's of times by now but holy moly. Every time I see a video pop up on youtube I audibly shriek LOL and this was an amazing listen. Can't wait to listen to some of the other patreon exclusive content!

Naif Alqahtani

Wow! i enjoyed every bit of it. I got to say this format is growing on me. Can I suggest one thing? I often see a need for a “discussion session” after everything has been laid out. Usually, I would jump into the comment section to see others thoughts and perspectives. That is because videos in the genre usually abruptly end right after announcing the final verdict. Nothing after that. This video (audio) felt like a 3 hour discussion + conversation on top of story-telling. Maybe introduce a short 30 minute debrief/discussion in this style after your main yt videos? Perhaps posting it in a second channel for those keen on follow-up discussions.

PityTheHateful

Well that was a ride, well done. It's a known prosecution tactic when they are worried about the strength of their case to put a lesser charge in. Central Tendency Bias exists. That's a "safer" option for a juror with doubt, and fear. Easier to rationalize to themselves. It's not legal but nobody else ever need know unless they say something. From the comments of the jury members that spoke to reporters, it absolutely sounds like this is what happened. An innocent person in prison rarely comes back on a jury, even if they are freed. That comes back on those who investigated and prosecuted. Acquitting someone who is either widely believed to be guilty or commits further crimes does come back on the jury.

kerianna

Came from the youtube preview! I did genuinely expect there to be a sudden second suspect, my jaw dropped for a sec when I heard the semen results

Susie

I’ve definitely heard this case before but a long time ago and I didn’t remember the outcome. I thought Tim was innocent at first, but as it kept going on… not *everything* can be such an unfortunate coincidence. I’m happy justice was finally served. Very well done video, loved the format!! I normally listen to your videos like a podcast anyway so it was no change for me

Bitch

This is absolute peak Incredible work

Hillary and Ian M.

I didn't see that coming, I thought for sure the twist was that the husband snuck away and was a family annihilator! ETA: Just realized that it's because I was subconsciously remembering the Jeffrey MacDonald case, that's why

KT

The preview is the reason I subscribed to the patreon. And oh man, I'm so glad I paid for this instead of just looking up the case--the way I GASPED when they found who gave the semen sample. As for my thoughts: the first trial, I was convinced he was guilty, but after he was found not guilty, I accepted the academic reasonable doubt. At the second trial, I was still convinced with the academic reasonable doubt, allllll the way up until the semen sample was tested. Also, I really love these deep, deep dives. I understand creators not wanting to make their videos too long and wanting to edit them down, but I always like the deepest dives possible.

Jess J

I can’t believe I thought I could watch that preview and not get tempted to subscribe 😭 This was such a great video, can’t wait to see the next!

Dan Skahen

Your primary sources are cool. Your storytelling is what collects the Patreon cheddar. I’m sure this format feels like a radical departure from the production side of things. But from the consumer side, feels remarkably like any other Matt Orchard vid, as good or better. More Matt Orchard in a Matt Orchard video cant make it worse.

Mango_Pipette

Me too! I have never had my jaw drop like that!

Doaa A.

I joined specifically for this video, and found the creator commentaries a fun bonus, but this video is absolutely everything I want. I did NOT look anything up, I was COMPLETELY floored, the whole premise was gripping anyway but the way you told it and organized the events and the flow of the story was really really well done and I enjoyed the kind of podcast with occasional visuals medium here. Thanks! More! Yes please! Yay! All sorts of exclamations come to mind.

Dan Skahen

I’d actually take it a step further now that I’m two hours in — this format has gold that the other hasn’t really accessed. To the same point of “more Matt Orchard,” your relationship with the lower stakes of this production comes thru in the vibe, and results in something more laid back, direct, often funnier. When you’re debating out loud whether we saw it coming or not. When you declare PARAPHRASING after an obvious and cutting paraphrase. Idk man, the constraint serves something fresh.

Connor

Hey! As somebody who only ever listens to ur videos anyway this format was honestly better for me, much more description rather than relying on photos which I can’t look at (I listen at work in headphones so I can’t open my phone). Great job! Fantastic vid!

Ninez

My thoughts throughout the video because why not: To start, I went in fully blind. So when you first asked the audience what our opinions were after the first trial, I felt pretty sure he was guilty, its mostly the fire that was making me think this way, but I also thought that if I was really on a jury, I would hav to deliberate on this for hours. I think when it comes to convicting someone who’s innocent or letting someone guilty walk free, I would personally slightly prefer the latter, although, with the horribleness of this crime it is hard to risk anything close to that happening again. After you went over the second trial, my thoughts weren’t changed much, but when you were reemphasising the witness testimony, my attention was brought to something I did previously see as very incriminating again; the car identification. For me (I am decently bad with faces though) lots people look similar too, but the guy who does match the description also having the exact same car, that definitely looks more guilty. And like you said, the witness seeing the guy getting into a car is really obvious to me that he only could have saw the perpetrator, not just some night walker. I still dont know if I could find him guilty, risking him being innocent and convicting him would be awful, but outside of a jury scenario, yeah I thought he was pretty guilty. Despite all the above, especially after you went on to share how he went on to be a pretty decent guy, I was feeling like he was probably innocent again. Its important to note that I did stop the video after the second trial to sleep and then most of the next day had passed before I got back to the video, so the evidence that made me think that he was guilty was less in my mind. This definitely would have been a contributing factor to me seeing him as more innocent. But anyways I did, so, even when you said the new DNA test found a match, I was thinking someone else would be revealed You misdirected it perfectly and it did hit me like a ton of bricks. Not so much shock or surprise, more so just a wave of disappointment, in that it was him and he got set free. If that makes sense. Its so good that he could get re-trialed, awful that it had to wait 20+ years, but still. Now onto your theory, I like it a lot for this case. No non-evil person, even if pushed to there absolute limits, could do something as awful as that. Maybe someone “normal” enough could be pushed to spontaneous rape and murder of one victim, but her kids too?! And even if someone was willing to say that yes, because of the circumstances he “had” to “deal with” the witnesses, I feel like someone who didnt fully want all of that would, at the very least, try to kill them in a slightly more “humane” way, not to the point of nearly beheading one of them. Plus, if your theory isn’t accurate, how was he able to clean up SO well, that not a trace of DNA evidence (other than the sperm) could be found anywhere in the house. They found a tip of a glove for goodness sake! One not linked to the house in any way, it had to have been brought with him. Thats a plan going on there. And like you said the knife, was also brought with him. Your reasons behind saying he planned all of it I also agree with. He wanted to do it. There’s the phone number, written down but never found. This connection of yours is so smart and makes complete sense! And I also like your understanding of the comment he made to Patrick Cone being a “hey, im just a regular guy doing regular things so you can just ignore me!” It makes so much sense as the irrational gut response someone would have. Your explanation for how he seemed so normal the next day makes a lot of sense too. And the ATM trips to both get the money, but also as an alibi. Anyways, thats my thoughts, essay over. Really impressive analysis.

Gautham Seran

Matt, this has to be one of your best ones.

Van

Hey Matt, not sure if you'll see this or read it, but I forgot to mention a few things and really wanted to comment - this format is still as amazing as your other vids. It works great and I'm pretty certain from the other comments everyone would be keen on both formats. You explain things so well and paint a vivid picture even without available video footage and photos. Bringing such a complex story and case together like this, for 3+ hours, weaving together the whole true story with your own script full of analysis, well researched facts, and a lot of information, in a way that keeps our full attention throughout, onviously takes a lot of passion, skill, and talent that doesn't go unnoticed. You're also great at keeping it real, showing respect for the families and victims involved, and being objective, using common sense, along with letting your own personality show through while you do it - it's a great part of your vids. Also, I was BUMMED when I realised I knew this case already. I was so excited to go into something blind, but it didn't matter at all. I was absolutely hooked on this deep dive, and as far as true crime audios and videos go, you've covered it in more detail than anyone out there. Thank you so much for this awesome work, I really enjoyed it. P.S. I thoroughly enjoyed your casual dropping of a C-bomb around 2hrs in. Keeping the Australian and New Zealand language alive. I mean. It was also the most apropos word for the perpetrator. But you did your corner of the world proud with that one. I also agree with your speculation and thoughts on a serial killer scared straight. I had been thinking along those lines and it was neat hearing you share your thoughts. Thanks Matt!

Teal

I went into this completely cold, knew nothing about the case. And I was full on thinking he did it but as a juror in the first trial I do not think I would have convicted as I think there was room for reasonable doubt. Now with the DNA then I would convict for sure. Also burning things in the back yard with a barrel was something my family did growing up (we lived "out in the boonies" as they say). We burnt paper trash in the barrel, composted food waste, recycled plastic and cans at the city recycle and took our trash to the county dump once a week. This was in the 90s with a family of 6 (two adults four kids), plust my dad had a garden he used the compost in. Much less waste over all for that size of family. However if they lived where neighbors could see the back yard, and this was not a normal occurance for that household then the burn barrel is super sus.

The Big Fiddler

He transported the bag full of evidence back home but presumably left no evidence at all in the car? No blood and no hair, which one might assume may somehow find their way into the car considering the violence of the murders. A stray hair caught on his face or on his body that falls off? Id assume he would give the car a quick clean at the very least considering how thorough he would have to be about everything else, but hair from the dog was apparently still in the car. Unless he only cleaned up directly where he sat (and the bag) and not where the dog was. IF he was "only" having sex with her though consensually I would still assume you may find some traces of her in the car? Especially considering he presumably wouldnt have had to change outfit before sitting down in the car. The staying up all night and then completing the run at work later though? He was in the Air Force. If he was in the Army it wouldnt be surprising since I assume they arent strangers to staying up 24+ hours and having to physically exert themselves. I have no idea how the AIr Force compares to that however but I assume they still arent strangers to it. I honestly cant say I would have found him guilty without reasonable doubt. It seems strange to me that he would plan out the timing between the ATMs, pack and prepare, clean the crime scene, clean himself, etc, but still NOT clean the car? Unless he did go over the car without it being obvious. At the first hour mark I did feel a Not Guilty was the only sensible verdict. After the full 3 hours though I'm not sure how I feel. The semen obviously tells us there was sex, he never outright claimed he did have sex with her which is strange. He has obviously not been entirely forthcoming with the truth since the beginning. IF he was such an upstanding and great guy you would think he may feel it important to tell the investigators that "yeah, we had sex"? The fact that he didnt tells me he does care about appearances at least to an extent that he withholds information even in really serious situations.

OdeliaTenpenny

i'm wondering whether tim didn't receive a call from her, but instead, was the one who called. i've searched up on it the tiniest bit, and they say that it was only towards the end of the 1980's that it got way more easy to determine who called whom; and maybe he knew that. and it makes much more sense, too: a) he does not seem like the type of person to leave things up to chance, which leads to b) this way he could ensure she was home, find out if there was gonna be another adult present AND have it be way more likely for her to allow him to come in, because she was expecting him - vs. her getting a weird feeling of this guy she only met once showing up at her house unannounced at nighttime c) him getting her number "just in case something comes up regarding the dog" wouldb't make her be suspicious, especially because she surely loved that dog, and d) it's easy for him to fabricate a reason for actually having to go to her house one more time, now that he has her number e) him planning it for THE ONE DAY where his wife & kids aren't home AND he's off duty seems way more calculated and matching the rest of his actions - rather than leaving it up to chance that she >hopefully< calls him on the right day just to check up on the dog; also, would be very interesting to hear from his wife whose idea it was for her and the kids to spend mother's day at her parents' i hate this guy.

Daniel Paulsson

Matt, the sucess of this format means that you CAN delve into NZ cases that lack video footage. I apologize for pushing the same agenda for the third time, but one can always hope that you will one day do your take of Jim Donnelly or something like that.

bumblebee

Finally decided to join Patreon after hearing the preview for this video on the recent upload, and you did not disappoint. This is great stuff and I'd love to hear more like it!

Shahryar Tariq

I subscribed to your patreon specifically for this video, and man I am so glad I did, this was amazingly produced.

JB

Gives a whole new meaning to post nut clarity

Brandon Hoelle

Gotta say, I’m surprised by how invested I am in this case. The format actually works quite well for me. I usually save your videos to play during my commute to work, and knowing I’m not missing anything by, you know, focusing on the road, helps me pay attention more to what’s being said. On another note, I thought I’d leave my two cents regarding army CQ shifts. I served as a paratrooper for seven years, where I was stationed at Fort Bragg. This was around 2015 and on. So even though quite a lot of time has passed since the events in question, it still hit close to home to hear all of this. That said, there’s a proud culture at Fort Bragg, and most units take tradition very seriously - more than other units within the larger Army as a whole. If there’s ever been a military unit to remain static for several decades, it would be one of those on Fort Bragg. I can only speak to my time serving, but when it comes to CQ shifts, you hit it right on the money - but you’re also a little off the mark. On paper, everything you described is exactly as presented; it’s taken very seriously, it’s an enormous responsibility, abandoning your post is tantamount to desertion, yada-yada, etc. That’s all technically correct. But the reality - especially for anyone who’s been there for a while (a year or more) it’s much different. There must be two people at all times, usually a senior and a junior enlisted (think SGT and SPC). That way there’s always one person at the desk to play receptionist if other responsibilities come up, and this allows each person to leave and return for food, restroom breaks, or naps. Sometimes you can pay another person to cover down for you for a short while, or even all shift. It really doesn’t matter who they are either. Depending on the location CQ was being covered, he could’ve had plenty of opportunities to grab someone, offer $20 (or $5? Whatever the 1980’s equivalent would be - a nickel?) to cover the shift for an hour while he ran off to use the ATM. He wouldn’t even be risking that much. My leadership made it blatant that they never cared who actually covered the CQ shift, as long as there was always a body present. Ultimately, it would depend on his leadership in the unit, and even if they were super strict, I don’t think he’d be putting himself at much risk as long as he found someone to cover down for him while he was gone. And if he had a buddy with him like we do these days, he may not have even had to do that. He could’ve just said he’s popping out for food and that would’ve been that. I want to make it clear that you’re not wrong. It’s just that most people - even the strictest old timers - aren’t going to get super caught up in the details of a CQ shift on post, stateside, during peacetime. Those same rules apply to conflict zones, and it’s important to train as you fight, but for a thing a mundane as CQ shift, there’s a surprising amount of leeway regarding what’s acceptable and what’s not. Still watching/listening, but I wanted to add my two cents now before I forget. Love your videos, and thanks for the great entertainment! You’re one of the best.

Carl Mears

Love everything you do. Can’t get enough! Also, looking back at the David Bain commentary vid you mentioned it was harder to do New Zealand content since they don’t have interrogations, trial footage, etc so it’s harder to make your normal YouTube videos. Hopefully if this is successful enough it will let you make more commentary vids on cases from around the globe (specifically NZ).

Kara Alexander-Eames

Subscribed to listen to this when I get a quiet moment at work. No regrets

Sophie

I just subscribed to the Patreon and this is the first video I'm watching/listening to. I can't stop listening and I really like how in depth it is, not too detailed at all in my opinion. Very captivating.

OdeliaTenpenny

that's so interesting, thank you for putting that into perspective

G◇nSqu¤chn

To answer your question: Call me naive, and I have listened to countless True Crime podcasts, but I did not see the reconviction coming. Although my initial answer as to whether or not he was guilty was that he was. What an unbelievable story! Just listened to the whole thing straight through, and about to start it again.

G◇nSqu¤chn

This officially moves JCS and puts C&S in my all time #1 spot. He is so good

Koda Chimera

For a bit there I was thinking the whole legal interest in this case had to do with the “reasonable doubt” debate. Then you came out swinging with the prosecution using gore imagery and court room set up in order to literally position him as guilty in the mind of the jury and- wow, just wow. That’s psychological manipulation at its finest, good god. Edit: TALK ABOUT EMOTIONAL MANIPULATION!!!! MATT ORCHARD YOU TRICKED ME YOU BASTARD!!!!

Dobey

Just commenting to say I loved this stuff. If you do more I'd watch it; this was worth the patreon subscription alone. also holy smokes I've never heard of this case before and it rocked my socks off

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Very good info thanks Brandon! The one thing I do still doubt is that Tim would have brought his absence to anyone's attention - asking someone to cover for him. But in any event, it is good to know the notion of him slipping out undetected doesn't beggar belief.

Abdullah Murad

great video. Although, I disagree about there being reasonable doubt at any point after Patrick walked in the police office and give his testimony. The witness siting just destroys any other theory. What are the odds that someone saw a guy, who looks exactly like the suspect, who was driving the exact same car at the time the crimes were committed? Is your doubt that some other dude who looks just like him, drives the same car, happened to commit the murders to a family that Tim had happened to meet at that time? The state doesn't have a great explanation, timeline, or bombshells, but there is just 0 other possible scenarios that don't involve Tim in this crime.

G◇nSqu¤chn

I actually think he may have gone to his ex girlfriends house BECAUSE he was having thoughts of committing this crime, and if he "satiated" the sexual element, his motivation to follow through would subside. On another note, are there any other unsolved cases where he could be the suspect? I cant imagine this was his first crime (r***/murder)..

Bug

can’t lie, maybe not a dead ringer but before you even started explaining the similarities i saw the composite next to his face and did a little gasp… obviously assumed he was the guy already but that was crazy

Kite 9d3

This was such an epic tale, well told as always. Please do make more like this. I think I can speak for at least 80% of your fanbase that we would gladly sacrifice visuals if it meant more MOCAS more often. However, I would suggest still making an intro patreon ad at least sometimes. Those are some of my favorite bits. The Departed one on karen read was a ray of sunshine in an otherwise infuriating story, it made me laugh so hard

Molly

Absolutely killer video Matt, seriously. That DNA reveal completely blindsided me, especially because I was pretty much convinced that it couldn't have been him. What an insane case.

Charlie Barker

Thanks for all your efforts Matt, this was great :)

Jean Godbout

Well worth the 3 Canadian dollars.

Stu

I went in blind for this one, and it does seem on paper like there was reasonable doubt in the original trial, but I decided on reflection that it would really come down to the testimony of the eyewitness; if he convinced me on the stand, I would vote guilty. Because if it was Tim coming out of that house at that hour, Tim did it. It also occurred to me very late in the story that he probably chose a woman with children deliberately, because he could threaten her to be quiet more effectively. I'm not a regular patron but this was very worthwhile as a stand alone!

Evelynn Rose

Hi Mr. Orchard, new patron here: I downloaded this app and joined because the prospect of a 3 hour Matt Orchard video was just too tantalizing to resist, so don’t take me lightly when I say that this video should be a main channel video. It’s truly a masterpiece IMO, and covering interesting cases that no one else will cause of the lack of video footage would be a good niche to occupy. Love the content, wishing you well from America.

SynonymRoll

1:56 min in and im worried about how much longer the video is.. it can’t just be “this is where they are now” the whole time..

SynonymRoll

Oh my god. The whole time I was like “well… reasonable doubt…” THE SEMEN!!! OH MY GOD!!

kristen

"That lingering.. spectre.. of the semen." What a sentence, Matt. Bravo.

notthis.mp3

incredible work, the format is a banger! my personal conjecture concerning Tim (although i do like the scared-straight theory as well): his military service, or career rather, presents to me a very obvious avenue to "release" some of his monstrous tendencies without it getting clocked as negative (maybe even heralded as positive) or at least without his actions having any kind of lasting impact in his civilian life. We simply don't know what he got up to on his tours during the Golf War for example. not to be crass but it's not like the U.S. Military has a stellar and unblemished reputation when it comes to ethical behavior during times of war (or in peace time really). "Raping and pillaging" has been a horrific but expected part of warfare for forever. We know what lots of soldiers did during the Vietnam War, - just because we don't know what Tim did during his deployments, doesn't mean he didn't commit atrocities that he simply was never caught or punished for. - just my two cents. thank you!!!

FuzzyDunlop

Maybe the best true crime video I ever watched. Incredible work Matt

Dane

Format is great! Especially if it helps you get videos out quicker. You're doing incredible work!

Jewell Soriano

The TWIST!!! Absolutely insane. Well told and explained as always ❤️

Thomas W Zizzo

this video is astounding--incredible work matt. I do have one question: where did you get the info about the dime-sized piece of burned corduroy being recovered from the barrel? every article I've come across online doesn't mention it anywhere. not that it makes me any less certain of Hennis's guilt, I was just curious because it seemed like a pretty crucial detail at the time that doesn't seem to come up anywhere else I can find (Gemini also keeps telling me I'm wrong for suggesting it and that there was no corduroy that was ever recovered from the barrel)

Karrako

I was completely unfamiliar with this case and I gasped out loud on the train and got weird looks for it when you got to the new DNA test result. Really like the format btw!

lauren bothwell

I have only ever subscribed to 1 Patreon: JCS, during their peak. I cancelled that a while ago, and I would only ever subscribe to something I think is absolutely 100% worth it. Your channel is that!! Love these videos.

John B

More

John B

Yes. Moar.

Arsenal Fan

I’m so glad I went into this video blind because what a story you’ve told. One of the best works you’ve ever put out. So glad I joined the Patreon!

srahhh

I'm not reading the comments, I just blindly scrolled down, but I'm halfway through and really want to know how you use a Kindle in your recording process!?

srahhh

(Spoilers below) 2:03:06 - Fuck you Matt, I gasped the hell out loud LMFAO. God up until that point I had even been mentally congratulating myself all smug like "nice try Matt, I can tell you're trying to make me think it's him. I'm staying objective up until the very end because I know how you work!!" I went into your first pre-verdict question like "That's absolutely reasonable doubt. Matt, you're being too soft." Felt like I was really exercising my critical thoughtbox, disagreeing with the trajectory of your narration. "You can't fool me. Every time you try to fool me, I only become more certain you're setting up a big reveal where it's someone else. (*checks video time* hmm about an hour left is probably enough... maybe if it's someone we've already met, or the main thread is already thoroughly woven into the narrative...)" So genuinely, congrats, you used my MOCaS-literacy against me to excellent effect, yet again, you asshole, good job on another spectacular production. Ton of bricks indeed.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I mean, who can say for sure, but I really don't think so. Like I mentioned, it's alleged (and very easy to believe) that there were people keeping tabs on him and what was happening around him.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

It's a very defensible position, and as we now know for sure, the right one. Also - who knows what I would actually think if I was assessing this case before the DNA. I can only try to imagine, and I may actually be going softer on Tim in part because I know the sort of story arc I have to create. Having said that - my reasoning is in the video, right after I state where I think I'd land. The Cone sighting is absolutely incredible for all the reasons you highlight. It's just that after you get so many forensic misses, a part of you that wouldn't have entertained the notion a man could get that unlucky starts to go, "...but what if I'm wrong?" I mean, if I floated the idea that maybe a guy who looked almost exactly like Hennis and the Cone sighting guy regularly walked down that street at ungodly hours of the night, you might think that was far fetched until I showed you JR.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think if you accept the notion he preformed a full change of clothes (possibly even took a shower, but that's not compulsory) in the house, last thing before leaving more or less, no trace evidence in the car makes enough sense. Shit, sometimes people can get that lucky without anything particularly elaborate. Consensual sex as an explanation for the semen is totally unworkable - his lawyer shouldn't have even floated it. It was never going to work and only serves to undercut future claims of innocence once you've [via your lawyer] shown yourself willing to grasp at such a straw. Option One: Consensual sex on day of dog adoption. Katie just decided to have a random quickie with a stranger while her children were still in the house, contrary to anything that is known about her. Her vagina miraculously holds on to enough of the semen in the days between then and the night of the murders that it not only gets swabbed, but is actually "favored" over the rapists semen. I'm no expert, but that sounds totally impossible. Option Two: Consensual sex on night of the murders. Same thing re Katie's character, Tim is now whole new layers of catastrophically unlucky, and even though his semen would be significantly fresher than Option One, you've still got a situation where the swab is collecting semen from the guy she had consensual sex with *before* she was raped and killed by the other guy. And she *had* been raped. Panties *cut* off aside from anything else. So yeah, If it's Tim's semen, he's guilty. And it is.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Van - I'm surprised more people haven't known it tbh. It's nowhere near as big as others, but it's not *that* obscure! Glad you still enjoyed it :)

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah that was the biggest thing I thought could be a give away - laying it on kinda thick with what a good guy he showed himself to be. It's still tough to figure out how his ex factored into things. Police theory is that he went there wanting to get some (no murder intentions) and when he didn't, that pent up frustration was part of what led him to kill Katie when he went there and got rejected for a second time in a row. As I say in the vid, I don't really buy that. I also have no idea how his visit to his exes fits into the overall picture. I could throw out random guesses, but that's it.

Van

Aaabsolutely loved it. It's painful waiting on new vids and so exciting when they drop. Been following you for a long time and it's a part of what got me interested in being a legal student as an adult. I'm a shit but tenacious student so far. Thanks for the inspo! Haha.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Curious! If that's Christchurch Hide Club, then no, not there specifically you wouldn't have, because I've never been BUT you are probably conflating something with something else because I am from chch and that seems like too massive a coincidence. I was breakfast host at RDU for about 3 years, ending when COVID hit - so maybe you heard me on the radio and that's getting mixed in with other music things? I was never much of a club goer, even when I worked there.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Aside form the military man aspect, Williams does come up when trying to think of other examples that fit the "serial killer next door" concept.

Lucas Kelly

Excellent work as always. I for one was completely shocked that the DNA match came back for Tim. But I’m chronically too trusting of the eventual monster in the beginning, unfortunately.

Ode

I spent this whole episode going 'alright, alright, reasonable doubt, reasonable, doesn't have to be ironclad, I get it, reasonable, it's reasonable, I'm the unreasonable one--' and then the DNA evidence came out and I couldn't even feel victorious about it bc seconds later I said, out loud, "SHIT, double jeopardy!" Never been so relieved to hear about a court martial, lol.

Conrad Molden

Matt you are a sensation. It grows, it evolves, it becomes more elaborate but you need lose your unique flavour. JCS lit the fuse but you’re taking the rocket intergalactic. Bravo! P.s. Your teaser at the tail of your He Said/She Said video sent me straight to Patreon to pay a bargain for what not other platform can offer

Lina Bariani

I mean. He was in the military. Maybe he had never been a monster to white Americans before.

Valerie Schmitt

long-time youtube watcher here who popped over to patreon after the plug in your trouble-in-paradise case vid, and i'm so glad i did! i enjoyed all three hours and i'm excited to comb through the patreon backfiles now too. to answer the vid’s question: the reveal did hit hard. i figured we’d have a big twist, given the whole “don’t google this or look at the comments!!,” but i was really expecting someone other than tim hennis to be the guy, even though the evidence from trial one did convince me of guilt (though i agree it wasn’t beyond a reasonable doubt). the fallibility of the human mind when presented with circumstantial and character evidence should never be underestimated, i suppose. 10/10, give matt orchard an emmy. lastly, re: “true crime creators don’t do justice by the victims” – you are the only true crime creator i watch, and that (among other reasons) is why. i used to be a big true crime consumer, and it’s from that phase that i watched your jonbénet masterpiece, which is what got me hooked on you and is still my favorite video of yours. even after i stopped engaging with true crime content/that community, i still love your content because i can feel the extent of your care for the subjects and your commitment to getting it right, however that manifests. mad respect man, keep doing what you’re doing.

Yes Way Ted!

You GOT me!! I was NOT expecting that bit about the semen and you DID a stellar job with the misdirect. I sat at the red light with my mouth hanging open and barely noticed the light turn green. Got honked at!! (Reminiscent of The Coldest Case Ever Solved, which got me hooked & now you have a fan for life.) This can’t be true! I was positive he didn’t do it when the blood type wasn’t a match. I am thoroughly enjoying this upload and sad I waited for a long drive to listen to it! Still more to go but had to drop this note to mention you fully hooked me. Yay!

jonesn18

Matt I just have to say that you are a fantastic storyteller. My family’s favorite true crime guy!

Eva Preuß

Regarding the baby. You said the house was rather small, but is it possible he didn't even realize she existed? Maybe she was napping when he came by the first time, and then she was sleping when he murdered the rest of the family and he just overlooked her. Or maybe it was part of his fantasy to let her die a slow gruesome death, who knows.

Jonathan Gill

It's not a 'good' guess or anything, but I wonder if the ex-girlfriend visit is another attempt at creating an alibi. We know he was thinking about alibis, after all, so maybe he thought going to a known person's house that night would give him a layer of cover. (Coincidentally this was actually Cone's alibi). Obviously it's a weak alibi: a late evening visit doesn't prevent you from staying up overnight murdering people. But he wasn't planning on an eyewitness spotting him at 3:30, giving investigators a rather exact timetable of when the murders happened.

amro

Matt, thank you so much for this. This format is absolutely phenomenal. I genuinely wish I could erase my memory just so I could experience this all over again for the first time. The case itself is absolutely gut-wrenching, but the depth, pacing, and storytelling are on another level. Easily one of the best things you’ve ever made.

AnitaCatnap

I really like this content format! It's podcast-like and since it doesn't require any visuals I can listen to it while playing games or doing work. I have to put off watching the Youtube videos as it distracts with from my work since the video compliments the narration so well I would love more of this kind of content

Adam Schade

Wow, this was absolutely worth the $2 admission. This was a total rollercoaster, and I fell for the bait hard enough to almost double over when you revealed the DNA test result. Bravo! Now I guess I'll be bingeing the rest of your patreon backlog this week. And funny little story, I was moving out of my apartment last month and my procrastinating ass was slow to clear out my place. So an hour before my redeye flight at 2am I was lugging full trash bags over to my apartment's dumpster. I don't recall seeing anybody out at that time, but if I did I definitely wouldn't feel like giving any quips about getting an early start.

Matilde van Niekerk

So true when you said there's a difference between how he acted and how you think you would act in that situation because in the beginning of the video I literally thought to myself, this guy isn't going around murdering people.. He just got a new dog he's gonna be at home bonding with his new dog and then I thought no that's what you would do, not everyone haha

Pierre-Luc Cyr

I started this on youtube despite clear warnings... I got sucked up!! loved it

Twig

that hit me totally off guard! i was totally on tim's side for pretty much the whole video..

Margaret Graham

I actually gasped out loud. Did not see it coming whatsoever.

Margaret Graham

I'm not sure psychopaths can actually love. They can idealise; they can appreciate devotion, which they are likely to get from very young children. I don't believe you can love if you can't empathise.

Margaret Graham

I've been following on YouTube since the start, but although I always appreciated the very funny and self-deprecating Patreon plugs, I never actually signed up. The audio preview after the Konig case is what finally got me here -- after 10 minutes I was hooked. I only apologise it took me so long to support you properly. TLDR keep appending previews of Patreon content, whether audio-based or not. It's super effective!

Margaret Graham

This is a really good point. What, does he need it pressed for a formal engagement?

Nour ElKott

Hello Matt!! This was a phenomenal video. Even with minimal visuals, my husband and I thoroughly enjoy your commentary. We’d like to request a future video idea. I’ve watched quite a few videos on this case, but I think you’d be the best one to cover it. The Menendez brothers, who were convicted of murdering their parents. Having you explain the exact details and a walk through of the night in question, actions before and after the murders, etc etc etc, I think you’d be the best Youtuber to take it on. Thanks in advance! We’re looking forward to your next commentary and your next case!

Tearyawna

Please keep doing this format!!! I love the hybrid podcast YouTube video. Especially for cases that don’t have a lot of footage

bromeatmeco

Leaving this comment at 1:02 before going through the rest. Not sure if I missed something or am biased but I think in a courtroom clear not guilty. I don't doubt what the witness saw - I think him praying could easily just be not wanting to condemn an innocent man - but that's kind of it. The jacket stuff etc. is circumstantial, but way more importantly the physical evidence mismatches him too much, esp. the boot print and prints. I know it's not an exact science but that's a lot of non matches. edit: Just finished, damn. I like the breakdown, good video.

Nel H

Not so smart now, are ya c*nt? 😂😂👏🏼👏🏼 You’re one of the only true crime content creators that uses humour tastefully and is actually funny. Your work is top notch!

Richard Clift

I didn't expect to be amazing as it is not ahigh production vid so I had it on while I was in bed and managed I was hooked. It had a feeling of you figuring out what is going on with a friend as it conversational so it was great. And as always I have no F**ki idea if he did I neither think he did it but I don't think his innocent 🤔

Ronnym

I find this info loaded format much better than the videos, which I love. I, like you, thought reasonable doubt applies and I'm not sure hindsight proves us wrong, even though we were. That MF sure made me feel stupid, but you can only work with the data available.

Tm Szafranski

Pausing the video to leave this comment— I didn’t see the DNA twist coming at all (although maybe I should’ve?) and my jaw HIT THE FLOOR.

L Sung

Joined your Patreon after hearing your little preview on YT. My partner and I were so hooked we were both like, "WAIT WHAT" when the preview ended. You're amazing at this storytelling thing and staying respectful (or disrespectful) to all the right parties.

hman70

I was waiting most of the entire video, even for a little bit after the DNA, for the reveal that the neighbor Bob who let Katie borrow milk and seemingly lied to the cops was obviously the real killer who the police were willfully refusing to investigate wanting to pin it all on their first and only suspect. Felt so proud of myself like “it’s been so long since he got mentioned I bet Matt thinks we completely forgot but I remember that nugget, I’m going to be the smartest boy in the room”. I also thought the extent of the cleaning of the crime scene implied that the killer had stayed in or visited the house over a much longer time than just the few hours Tim had access to between the murders and 3am. Plus with the severity of the physical damage to the victims I thought the killer had to be someone who knew them well and had serious hate in his heart for them. And then the mundanity of Tim’s evil being revealed was as disgusting as it was disappointing. Like oh it was just him. He was the only suspect because it was obviously just him. I guess fantasizing about some more crazy plot twist as if this were an episode of law & order or something is just another way of avoiding the actual horror of the case, the fact that it really happened. The “boring” answer is correct because that family was really killed.

Haz

I feel like I’m robbing you only paying two dollars for this

Squash Konrad

You are a great storyteller, Matt. This is why I decided to support you on Patreon. P.S. I was surprised that he was guilty. You played it well. Thank you for your work

Karla J

I love this format. And I love hearing your little asides that you don’t do in the main channel content. Thank you for taking the time to put this together! I’ve never heard of this case so it was fascinating. And yeah, I thought he was innocent and truly gasped at the DNA results. Damn.

Sydney Dorawa

I really like this format! I'm a long-time listener, first time caller (Patreon subscriber) but I plan to stay subbed!

BlüddShövel

Matt Orchard: I love your patreon channel. I watch and listen often. Very insightful and powerful commentary. Thank you for the outstanding work. However, there was a killer from Texas who was on Death row twice. Kenneth Allen Mcduff. in 68 he was on the row, but was released only to be found guilty of several crimes later and eventually executed in the 90s in Texas. Although he was not condemded twice for the same crime as is the case with your subject here Anyway, thank you for the excellent work.

Elijah

I sniffed it out on the 2nd trial when it was rebrought up the witness identifying the specific car… just too specific to let slide. Still sunk my heart when the semen reveal hit.

Shannon M.

Oh, wow--I'm definitely in the "wait wait wait WHAT!?" hit-like-a-brick camp. I had no idea that was coming. (Edited to add: I like both formats (more formal video/informal like this); do whatever makes you happy.

Ira Rosenberg

I'm 45 min in and I'm loving this, Matt. Became a patron specifically for this deep dive. Will remain a patron. May the 3+ hrs long deep dives continue!

Kate

This was a fantastic listen. You conveyed a complicated story with a lot of grace and intentionality.

Jim B

New to Patreon…you got me with the last 15 min plea on YouTube…I can’t believe what I’ve been missing! Love these videos in this format. Cheers from Michigan 🍻

Kit Walsh

Listening to this for like the third time. Please make more of those 🙏 Also it dropped for me only when you said that the witness guy wasn't guilty. Because my answer to the question "why would a dude approach the cops and get himself involved in a case like this knowing the kind of shit he's getting into, especially with all these details he knows suspiciously well?" was "because he did it". I'm glad I was wrong and the explanation was actually wholesome

Alexandra

I've done innocence work in the past and the first half of the video was just full of red flags; Central but wavering eyewitness testimony with police coercion and a six pack lineup is an infamous recipe for a wrongful conviction. That said, I found Cone to be an especially reliable eyewitness. He didn't have any pending charges or notions of a cash reward, and correctly describing the make of Hennis' car was such a significant detail. I was shocked by how angry I felt at the big reveal, and was scared Hennis wouldn't be re-convicted. I definitely felt you were laying it on a bit thick with his stellar track record post-release, but then I might have a different view of the military as an American. It doesn't surprise me that someone of his profile thrived there, and likewise suburban culture can create the illusion of community while keeping family units isolated and leaving space for secret indiscretions. Incredible work!

Babs Hsock

Simply AMAZING video. I find I often need a bunch of background music or visuals for other documentary vids but dang! Your narration is so enthralling. Loved it!

CaptainJZH

I feel like one of the lessons here is that the advances in DNA evidence has been a major milestone for law enforcement and prosecutors, and that it was a LOT easier to get away with crimes (especially sex crimes) before DNA matching was able to be used reliably.

Jerichode

I have never been so confidently wrong and subsequently absolutely fucking befuddled by a case before. What in the actual fuck

Caddy

fuck me my heart dropped at that twist.

Zdravko Verguilov

This new format is exactly what I needed. I love your videos exactly because they’re long and thorough, and I always play them while doing something else, without watching, so the lack of visuals is not a problem at all.

Ruth Randall

Armchair detective here. I'm at the part with all the unknown hairs. I reckon he planted them. He went to so much effort to clean up after the fact. I think he took hairs from wherever (military base probably), who is going to test all the men on the base? I also think he planted the finger of the glove. Just my thoughts...

owlfeathers

I for one don't think being in the US military is a sign of virtue, especially when one accounts for things like Abu Ghraib. And the military provides a lot of external structure and discipline that could have made it easier for him to stay out of trouble. The other parts of his life (bus driving, etc) were considerably more compelling to me than the military stuff.

Consistent Escape

No idea how I had managed to never hear about this case but I am not complaining because this video was such a great experience.

Barbara Boynton

Because of this video I got to be cool at a party yesterday and tell people about this case, so thank you.

Grace Baker

reminds me of Russell Williams. Military man, seemed nice all around by everyone who knew him. Had sick fantasies that he eventually acted on.

Ruth Randall

Armchair detective here. I think he planted the random hairs, pubic hair and glove tip. He could have quite easily gotten them from his army base. If he goes to so much attention to clean, and burn, and use debit cards etc. I think he could quite easily deposit random hairs about the scene to put the police off the scent. Just my opinion...

An P

*Spoilers* The reveal made my stomach drop, not because I thought he might be innocent but because I was hoping I was wrong after the acquittal and it made me worried he wouldn’t be able to be tried again. I’m so glad they got the fucker in the end. The whole time I thought that Cone’s description was so incredibly spot on (and actually him getting Hennis’s car exactly right in addition to the composite sketch was what really sold me on it, that guy has near-photographic memory) and I thought realistically the only way the killer *wasn’t* Hennis was if Cone had seen Hennis around the neighbourhood when he first dropped off the dog and was intentionally trying to frame him, there’s just too many details that align perfectly with Hennis, the blonde/light brown hair thing to me is still super close considering everything else and honestly I’ve had a lot of disagreements with people as to who counts as being blonde vs brown haired to think that’s in any way an indication of inaccuracy to not be sure about that detail. My initial thought was that maybe the twist was that Cone did it, but since you ruled him out, I would have leaned towards convicting Hennis at both trials because innocuous transfer of the pube is more likely than Cone lying if he’s truly completely cleared as a suspect (though I would’ve liked to know a bit more detail on why it’s not Cone, but I assumed since he’s so close to the case that they ruled him out as the source of the pube and all that). My doubt was right around the threshold of reasonable, though and I could’ve gone either way in the jury box. I know eye witnesses can be unreliable but in my mind there’s far too many details in that description that are so detailed and closely matched to Hennis that Cone’s initial memory of the intruder is basically the human equivalent of grainy CCTV footage (not quite, since humans can confabulate/ make false memories sometimes, but it would be so incredibly unlucky for Hennis if Cone had confabulated those details in the exact, precise way that would falsely implicate Hennis without ever having met him). Basically, once we rule out the possibility of Cone lying, I think it’s extremely unlikely he’s describing anyone but Hennis. A close lookalike with the exact model of car would be a such a stretch. I thought from the get go that Cone praying before pointing at Hennis from the lineup to me was just an indication of him taking it seriously, as opposed to implying that he’s guessing and if anything it makes his account appear more truthful - if he was lying you’d think he’d want to seem more decisive. I think any decent person in a situation where the stakes are that high would feel an incredible amount of pressure to get things right and I think he fundamentally was a decent person to even go out of his way to testify and give so much information in the first place, regardless of his criminal record. I also did consider that the ATM withdrawals being logistically difficult but not impossible was more suspicious than exonerating from the outset. In a way it would seem less suspicious to me if the withdrawals were logistically easy for him, considering how methodical the rest of the killing was. In a way it made me think of David Bain and how he (probably) did the murders in such a tight timeframe and left Robin for after the paper run for the same sort of reason, to make himself seem like he couldn’t have logistically done it when in fact it was actually very much possible and the whole point of doing it like that was to give himself a shaky sort of alibi. Either that or Hennis was just in such a tight spot with money that he felt he had to do it straight away. And one last thing, I did think from quite early on that if Hennis had done it, regardless of the precise motive, that such extreme violence would have put him in a high-adrenaline state, regardless if he was thrilled or horrified with himself. I could see that lasting for hours if not days afterwards given just how extreme the crime was, which would explain him being able to perform normally at physically demanding tasks despite exertion and lack of sleep. If anything I think having to run a bunch would be easier for him to get through than having to act normal, but then again people like Russell Williams were able to act normal after doing horrific stuff so I don’t really know. I do find your explanation of his exact motive more plausible than any alternatives I could think of by the way and I agree that he almost certainly premeditated it.

Grim Princess

This format worked really well for this case! I was a bit sceptical at first about the different format coming from the YouTube channel, but figured I'd give it a shot anyways, and I really enjoyed it! It was interesting because I didn't know anything about this case before the video, and it really helped not give anything away while watching to not have footage of Tim actually speaking in it, but rather just the facts of the case told second hand. Sometimes, even when a narrator in these types of videos will be trying to misdirect or give the benefit of the doubt to the accused, it's very apparent when someone is acting strangely just by listening to them speak or watching them speak, even if what they're saying isn't incriminating. I'm not really talking about body language, since I don't believe in that type of analysis at all, but more just.....sometimes when you've seen this type of thing before, you can just tell. Not saying that should be used by a jury or anything, but just as a watcher of an internet video like this. I came from the YouTube video about the hiking couple where the guy was trying to say he was acting in self defence, and at one point he was describing a conversation he and his partner were having on the hike, and the narration was attempting to lend some plausibility to the potentially made-up or potentially true conversation he was describing to the court at that point, but as someone who has had their fair share of run-ins with people who are obsessive and (for lack of a better term) crazy, it was very apparent to me the story he was telling was fabricated (even if perhaps he himself believed it happened due to being mentally unwell, I don't know), long before the video had gotten to any very substantial evidence for the case. Anyways all that to say, I started the first third of this video believing there was a reasonable doubt that Tim might not be the guy, and I do think a large part of that reasonable doubt was due to the fact that I did not see any footage of the way Tim was acting or speaking, especially given that this video ended by remarking on how investigators were very suspicious of the way he was acting and speaking the whole time. So it was a good and interesting change up in format for this type of video/case, and I think definitely helped keep the suspense up.

Katie

You're so freaking good. Thanks for all your work!

BruBish

Well... fuck me. If I wasn't right in my gut all along

Shelby Robinson

Honestly the part where the worm started to turn for me was how perfect he was after being acquitted. Doing time will really do a number on you in the best of circumstances, let alone if you’re innocently convicted. Being that perfect, Girl Scout dad and all, just reeks of someone trying to overcorrect to me. But maybe I’m just overly cynical. Amazing vid!!!

Beck

I enjoyed this video, please let us know again on youtube if you post another like it!

C.

HOLLY SHIT. I was coming completely blind to this; not even ever heard of it before. Right until the point of the match, I was “I’m listening, I’m sure this is just the end, what else can you say? But okay, loving the narration. (…) What the actual f?” So to answer your question, no, I didn’t expect this at all. I honestly was thinking that was it. I think my exact thought was: I also kinda feel that reasonable doubt was not absolute and they won’t ever prove it.

Jonathan Bennett

Ida paid much more than $2 for that... Also I was so ready to find out who the "real murderer" was at the DNA reveal. You did an almost scarily good job concealing that.

Fuega Pants

I am late to the game --- but I DID NOT see that coming! It hit me like a ton of bricks! Classic Matt Orchard! :) But great coverage, great story telling. It took me back to the first video I saw by you - The Highly Controversial Case of Daniel Holtzclaw - I was not prepared for that rollercoaster. Love your work!

justKate

I didn’t see the twist coming, but I did see how they sidestepped double jeopardy. I was in the US Air Force, and the way they write your contract you have 4 or 6 (3 was also an option once upon a time) years of active duty service, then twice that as an inactive service member. That means they reserve the right to call you back into active duty status at any point during those 6 or 8 or 12 years. Because you signed the contract, you have no legal way to say no. My contract was for 4 years active duty and 8 years inactive duty. We all just desperately hoped they’d never have a reason to call any of us back up. I was a radio & television broadcaster. From one video creator to another, this worked really well, and I enjoy your narrative and editing style!

Kels ?‍♀️

Didn't think this was going to be for me, but the 10 minute preview had me hooked. For what it's worth, I didn't see the eventual reveal coming AT ALL

Kels ?‍♀️

Also realizing I lived in Fayetteville when his last trial happened; my dad was stationed at Fort Bragg. Gotta ask him if he remembers anything about the court martial