Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 671111546.mp4

Downloads

Content

A bit of a fan favorite today - and seeing as it involves one of my favorite pieces of evidence in any case, I decided to tack on a mini addendum at the start - which still wound up being 35 minutes. Just a bunch of extra details about and around the impossible timeline that obviously couldn't fit into the original without interrupting flow. It's a pretty fun topic, I hope you'll agree.

Creator Commentary starts at 36:07

UPDATE:

I've been working on a video on the Arielle/Gerhardt Konig case. Probably quite a lot of you will know it as it's been in the news recently. If ya don't you can either go in fresh or look it up if ya like. There will be some twists and turns, so going in cold is probably ideal as usual if possible, but the final product should work well as an explainer regardless. Interesting dynamic we haven't really had before!

I'm aiming for end of June for the Patreon release, but will let you know closer to the time if things get hairy again!

Sources:

A Deadly Game: The Untold Story of the Scott Peterson Investigation by Catherine CrierHeavily on the guilt side, which is a feature not a bug. Also pretty widely regarded as the most thorough stand alone book on the case. Crier had access to quite a few materials not in the public domain.

Erin’s blog, of course: https://crimepiperblog.wordpress.com

And the innocence camp got a fair hearing too. I watched the A&E series The Murder of Laci Peterson, and aside from that consumed a hodge podge of podcasts and miscellaneous web sources making the case, including Scott’s official innocence blog: https://www.scottpetersonappeal.org/

Links:

Here's Erin debunking the pathetic mailman rebuttal in more detail: https://crimepiperblog.wordpress.com/2020/08/17/scott-peterson-testimonies-of-mailman-russell-graybill-and-neighbor-karen-servas/...If you'd like to learn more about the case through her, she's got a lot of great stuff. Just browse the Scott Peterson tagged posts: https://crimepiperblog.wordpress.com/tag/scott-peterson/Chuck her a follow on X too! https://x.com/TabbyKent

Files

Comments

Lewis

Matt, you're the goat. Genuinely your videos see me through so many shifts at work 🙏

SP

Appreciate your work 😁😁

AR

oh my god yes

Nathan Seth

I think your Eastburn video is worthy of a youtube upload to tide over that crowd, it's up there with my favourites of yours and I don't think people would mind the less editing heavy style, I think Watcher is a perfect example of production values not being necessary if your storytelling skills are strong!

Mel T.

YES, this is one that I've been dying to see a commentary on!

jesse m

An follow up to my fav video and posted during my night shift? Lets gooooo

Ian Creedon

Wow, Karen really did a service, huh.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Nice. Yeah, I love those super low key heroes in true crime. Just a normal lady doing a mundane helpful little thing, and she totally ices the most hated man in America without realizing it.

Claire

Yaaaaaaay!! Evening sorted! How do you always know when my kid is at her father's house 🥰 I've got the beer chilled and fried chicken in the oven.

Claire

Nah stuff em hahaha

Claire

My sister is a Major in the Australian Army (she's 34 fkn overachiever lmao) and our Army father served in Somalia in 1992-1993 (very probably alongside Tim fucking Hennis) so while she's laid up recovering from ankle surgery I've bought her a month's membership so she can watch the Eastburn video while I creepily attend via video chat so I can tell her when the best parts are coming up. She's gonna be so pissed with me talking all the way through it. I can't wait 🤣

Ian Creedon

I noticed that indefinable wrongness about Scott's voicemail too. I'd hazard a guess that it's the sound of him smirking while trying to sound like he isn't. We know he's one to inappropriately smirk against his own interests.

Charles Haught

I’m American and I find it very odd to call your wife’s father “dad”. Idk anyone who does it personally. Everyone I know just uses the first name. I have heard of it, though.

Don't worry about it

We are SO back. This pushed MOCAS from "one of the Youtube channels I subscribe to" up to "I am a fan, and new uploads are an event" for me

Jean Pierre Linares

The Eastburn case was so good that it ended up getting me addicted to the style of the Patreon exclusive content—hearing your thoughts and logic isn't a treat I can find elsewhere. I've become a born again patron who'll never leave!

Preston

best true crime channel on youtube since jcs started the trend in my opinion

Maya_01

Would love to hear your take on the Adnan Syed case

sunny crays

Was having a shitty day, new vid from my favorite content creator, now all is well.

William Sokol

Wm3 next would be cool. That is one case where multiple people i respect have different opinions.

Owned by Corgis

Another Matt orchard gig, thanks. Seen the Mackenzie Shirilla affair? Like Sarah Boone it’s a gift that keeps giving.

Ty P

God, I sure hate Scott Peterson but in a very wholesome way. So It's probably fine. 😄

SpergGurtDirt

As an American (in the Midwest, mind - maybe it’s different in California) calling your in-laws mom/dad would not come naturally to me, and would strike me as dishonest coming from someone else

sunny crays

Matt already did the West Memphis 3

sunny crays

Me too! I think he's guilty as hell, but want to know Matt's take

sunny crays

I think he doesn't sound contrite enough for someone saying they didn't do something they said they would. Because he knows she isn't alive to be peeved...

Ian Creedon

Right, even if he did think she was alive the casual presumption with which he sends his heavily pregnant wife on a sudden errand he was supposed to have done sounds terrible.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

That's a good point Sunny. Also, now I'm thinking about it, he itimised an unnatural amount. Vella Farms, the basket, for Papa. If it's really *for* Laci, you'd think the message would be more "hey honey, sorry but I'm running way too late to get the basket, really hope you get this in time. Sorry, love you, bye." I dunno if most people really explain the context in those sorts of messages.

Adam Berck

American family here. My Uncle's wife called my grandma mom. Wasn't the oddest thing I've heard but was unusual enough that I still remember it.

William Sokol

I meant a commentary on the wm3 video.

cool_ranch

this upload almost makes it feel like Friday, cheers

Haili Devillier

1:11:02 has me dying laughing, stellar job always matt😄👍🏼

Andrea Saenz

American here - I find it a little eye-rolling when someone refers to their in-laws as Mom/Dad. It feels fake. But also my husband’s sister married a guy who referred to our mutual in-laws that way, and he was a giant douchebag, to put it mildly. So my first thought when I heard Scott say “papa” was “of course he does”.

klufenza

I'm from Poland, it's expected to call your in-laws mom and dad. I've been married 13 years and still find it uncomfortable to call them that 🥲

Ember Bennett

I’m American and I call my in laws “(husband’s name’s) dad/mom”. My husband has a step mom he’s closer with who I call by her name. Though, neither of us come from one of those types of families. I think, in general, it’s wealthier families who insist on being familial with in-laws. Perhaps it’s a legacy/inheritance thing, especially with men who marry in. It’s less common in newer generations, but wealthy families tend to keep tradition longer lol

Amber Green (Israel)

Well, I'm Israeli, and my brother-in-law calls my mom 'Mom'. I kinda hate him for it, and yeah, it's definitely weird

LeeBee

I’m really excited to hear Matt’s personal take on WM3. You could infer some of his opinions throughout the original video but I would love to hear everything hashed out at once (or, as much as can fit into a commentary). I lean towards guilty but those three did not get a fair trial and I wish a retrial could have been had.

William Sokol

I've listened to 3 or 4 different podcasts on wm3. All of them were from law enforcement personnel and all of them fell different. Though almost all agreed not enough to convict. Some fell on the probably did it not enough evidence. Some they didn't do it. It's such a horrible case because no matter what the perpetrators are definitely walking around free.

Laura Grimm

American here - I think it's weird to call in-laws "mom" and "dad." I do call my aunt-in-law "auntie" but idk...even non family members call her "mom" or "auntie," that's just her way of relating to people. But my husband calls my parents by their first names...that is more normal from my American POV.

Jesse Hilbun

Another great commentary Matt! I think the Casey Anthony case would be a great one for you to cover. Whenever you decide to do so, I would highly recommend reading the reddit series by /u/hysterymystery which systemically goes through all the evidence explaining why the jury made the decision they did as well as (I believe convincingly) argues in favor of Casey's innocence. It also debunks a great deal of misinformation, and the authors perspective is not one you will often find when it comes to this case. The same author also published an amazon ebook which goes over much of the same information as the reddit series, but includes some new content which I think is well worth the price. Link to reddit series: https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/5evyc0/casey_anthony_the_timeline_evidence/ Link to amazon book: https://www.amazon.com/Everything-didnt-about-Casey-Anthony-ebook/dp/B079WKF7J8/ref=sr_1_1?nsdOptOutParam=true&sr=8-1

Max

I agree hearing about Laci’s “annoying” nature makes me all the more sadder. I smiled during that description of her at the party.

Trevor Albert

Do you have an angle in mind if you were to cover Kasey Anthony? On the one hand it feels like everything has been said about her. On the other, everyone is dying for a satisfying theory of what the **** happened. Something like what you did with Tim Hennis.

Stephen Schiavone

One of facts of the Laci Peterson Murder that really gutted me when I learned it was that Laci was the one who doggedly pursued Scott when they first met.

Ember Bennett

He does have kind of a curvy mouth but he is able to talk while looking sullen in the same interview. Odd that the smirk comes out specifically when talking about his wife being dead 😬

Matthew Thayer

While watching, I was thinking a lot about why this guy has so many supporters. I agree that he's guilty with just this, and without it, but I think it goes so far that he is guilty, beyond a reasonable doubt, without the pings, without THE BODY, and without the golf story, just to be generous to him. That's how guilty he is. To boot, he's not remotely sympathetic, he's not the kind of person you just can't imagine doing this, and he's not a great artist or anything like that. And yet he has so many supporters. Normally, I attribute it mostly to the fact that people are reluctant to admit they are wrong: They hear exculpatory arguments first, make up their minds in favor of innocence, and refuse to admit they were conned when exposed to inculpatory evidence. But I think it goes deeper than that in this case. In South Park, they once mentioned the idea that, if you troll someone online, some people will be so sanctimonious in their defense of the insulted person that others will begin to take up the cause of the troll. I think something like that is what happened here. He was so hated, and so dogged-on, that some people felt the need to defend him, whether it was out of spite, general contrarian impulses, or a genuine, though very misplaced, fear of mob-justice.

Tracy McClendon

American here: would not call my husband's mother "Mom". But also, I am extremely awkward around her and don't know what honorific to use - her first name? Mrs. ____? - so I don't think I've ever used a name to address her at all lmao! And we've been together for 6 years, married for 2.

Virginia

American here, from the Midwest, and I’ve never heard anyone call their mother in law “Mom”. I would be really weirded out by that…

Kenneth Wilkins II

This is probably my favorite video by you. I’m happy you’re finally getting around to it!

birdie

i’m american, unmarried but i do find calling your in-laws mom or dad or similar weird and haven’t heard it at all i don’t think in my life. i will note my dad is an immigrant but in all my circles i would call that weird

Queen of Hearts

Last he said he’s working on a series of mini addendums about it. I am also really interested in what he has to say there. I feel like with that one, even though I can see why the stuff with Jesse would be incriminating, I still don’t feel like there’s anywhere near enough evidence that they did it. I think where I currently fall is the camp that they didn’t do it but also certainly didn’t help themselves either.

Aurora H.

The Kohning case was the first trial I watched in full (currently in the process of enrolling in law school and wanted to see what real trials are like) and it was fascinating. Really excited to see your take on it and the verdict handed down!

Evan Monroe

The key thing I remember about this video was that it was the first time you went full out "the bastard is guilty". You're not lying in the video when you say that you pride yourself on being fair. You really do try to play devil's advocate and entertain the idea of coincidences/bad optics. It made for an incredible closing note when you drop the act and say Scott Peterson is guilty beyond a reasonable or even unreasonable doubt.

Aurora H.

the updated mackenzie theory is such a stark example of the sunk-cost fallacy... people were so determined to undermine Karen's timeline that they posited a dog that can seemingly walk through walls and put on his own leash

LapisScarab

I think you're being too nice about the coincidence thing. The witnesses claiming to see a woman of the majority race and average age, with the most common hair color and length, the most basic/common color clothes, and famously the most popular breed of dog barely counts as a coincidence, surely?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I honestly don't know a ton about the case, so I guess I'd give myself 2-4 weeks of pure research to look at everything - including the angle of innocense, and figure out what themes land with me the most before settling on an angle. One PRELIMINARY angle I've thought of is making a video that's more trial strategy focused, as I'm not sure anyone's really done that. No matter how enraging people find it, and perhaps rightfully so, it appears the jury delivered that verdict in good faith - more so than OJ, or Karen Read for instance, by my reading. So say she's as guilty as most think she is (again, preliminarily, that's most probably what I'll wind up thinking) - HOW exactly did the defense pull it off? WHY did the jury feel the pros just couldn't quite stick the landing? Focusing on the why of the outcome rather than just foaming at the mouth over it could be an interesting path less traveled. But again, after a deep dive I might not feel like that's actually the story I want to tell in the main.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Good call! It's a much different experience than watching edited, commentary supplemented coverage, isn't it? Were you on the fence after openings? Good luck with law school!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I dunno, maybe you're right. I would have thought even if they're common traits, if there's multiple of them stacked and they're showing themselves in the right neighborhood on the right day it counts as a coincidence, but that's only my intuition, I dunno what the actual quantified statistical probability would be. Anyway, we can both easily agree it doesn't rise to anything like the level of coincidence that would justify this case deserving an earnest second look.

Aurora H.

I was on the fence about the details & mechanics, but not so much about the summary of events. Especially b/c of the defendant's reaction to & actions after the attack—the botched "cover up" ended up being some of the most damning evidence.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Gotcha. [Potential spoilers ahead depending on how my actual video plays out, but this definitely gives away my basic take] I ask because I went in thinking it would be a "no shot" one. Then after the end of the defense opening, GKs atty actually had me quite intrigued. His narrative seemed to make some sense, and the holes he was poking were making some contact. But turns out he just over-promised. As the trial in chief progressed, basically all of his claims systematically fell apart - especially the idea AKs injuries "weren't that bad." Not life threatening in and of themselves - big gap between that and "not serious."

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

If you go through the Eastburn comments you'll find a reply from my laying out the rough plan for an extended WM3 follow up :)

Aurora H.

Yeah, I did feel that as well. The texts were the stand out for me—the damning treatment they were given in the opening ended up being miles from reality. The doubt for me was mainly around how the attack started & progressed, and how much it was premediated vs spur-of-the-moment. And I don't know if you'll cover this, but my final determination was also swayed by evidence that was discussed with the judge on record, but that I don't think was allowed in front of the jury (mostly from Konig's prior relationship), and I wonder if that's been the case for others online as well.

AR

That "basket for Papa" line from Scott's alibi voice mail jumps out at me as odd and stilted every time I hear it, so it's not just you twigging to that. I watched the Scott Peterson video earlier this week. It's become kind of a comfort watch for me entirely because it's so satisfying the way you walk through the case and then dismantle the innocence argument so thoroughly. Also because Scott is suuuuch a cad that it's a karmic victory every time to see him so thoroughly deconstructed and reduced to his scumbag sociopath essentials. One of my favorite things about this case, which I think comes from the book his defector sister-in-law wrote, is the anecdote that when his mom found out about Laci and Connor's bodies washing ashore, she told Scott "well now I know you didn't do it, because not even you would be dumb enough to go fishing the day she went missing in the same location her body was found." Such a revealing glimpse into both her full awareness that he definitely did it and her ability to frame the facts in the most contorted way possible.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah that's some peak re-framing right there. Another classic "only an innocent person would act this guilty" argument. And again, what people who make that argument ignore is that **there's good evidence Scott's PLAN A was to hide the "fishing trip"** Three separate people heard him claim golfing at different points that day. It stands to reason some time between then and talking to the cops, he decided he had to cop to visiting the marina. And I still like my theory that he suddenly remembered name checking Berkley in the voicemail, and that's what triggered that decision. Speaking of Scott's delusional/shameless parents. His dad lied hard on the stand for him. He said, "I'm more the golfer, Scott's more the fisherman." His dad was an avid fisherman, whereas Scott had never owned a boat until shortly before the 24th, and was so into golfing he had aspirations of going pro following high school. Just brazen.

AR

From what I can tell, the defense in that trial did something kind of similar to the Gish Gallop, where they just rapidly and relentlessly questioned every tiny case detail, whether or not it made sense, and it added up to a smoke-and-mirrors effect that clearly confused the jury. Racehorse Haynes did the exact same thing in the trial of the extremely guilty Cullen Davis (you'd have a field day with that case) and it had the exact same effect and outcome.

AR

His parents are pieces of work, and they remind me so much of Chris Watts' parents as well. Scott didn't even have a license to fish, he hadn't had one since the mid-90s. I feel like Scott's head was all over the place that whole day. We know people saw him at the marina and I kind of feel like he realized they'd seen him and decided spontaneously to change his alibi as he was leaving the marina, then left his oddly chipper voice mail. After that he very well might have completely forgotten about it and tried to revert to the golf alibi before remembering again that he'd likely been seen at the marina. What I can't ever get over is the sheer lunacy of him driving that far away on Christmas Eve, on a holiday, to a popular public spot, on the remote off-chance that nobody would see or talk to him. Just absurd.

Jay

Matt, I want to kind of second this suggestion. I totally get that it wouldn’t make sense for you to take that video out of your exclusive catalogue anytime in the near future, but I have to say the eastburn video is one of my all-time favorite videos of yours. like if i were recommending your channel to a friend or something, that would be probably the first video I’d mention. So if you’d consider releasing that one to the general public, maybe in like a year or so, I’d highly recommend that you do. It’s really a fascinating case and I love the way you told the story.

Addy

I’m Malaysian and my husband is Nigerian. My husband calls my parents “mom” and “papa”. I call his mom “momsy”. His dad has passed so I don’t call him anything.

SpergGurtDirt

A good halfway of this you could do is what defunctland does for some of his patreon only videos, where he cuts out a small segment (like 20ish minutes out of a multi hour long video) as a kind of “taste” for the patreon - speaking for myself, it convinced me to sub to his patreon, it could work for you too

William Sokol

I'm sure you get recommendations all the time but from my area Hugo selenski is an interesting case. You've got a charming psychopath, a backyard full of bodies, a not guilty verdict, and a daring prison escape. I've noticed in the past few years it's starting to gain steam in the documentary true crime world.

Kiirah Smith

My Mother in Law really really wants me to call her mom and it’s so so weird. It’s gotten to the point where I just do it once in a while to get her to stop begging me to say it.

Positivelypolarized69

On the subject of 'mundane things that are damning when you think about them more' I wanted to quickly bring up the Alex murdaugh murder case which recently got thrown out and will likely be retried. One aspect of that case that sticks with me is the phone usage, obviously the kennel video blew up Alex's alibi completely as he was there very shortly before the murders but it's even worse when you consider that paul's phone went totally silent and that Maggie and Paul were found dead at the kennel. In order for Alex to be innocent he needed to play with the dogs then go to his mom's house, Paul doesn't touch his phone for like an hour while he and his mom stay at the kennel and get killed by some evil people who want to do him harm and then poor Alex comes back and takes the fall. The Defense wants us to believe a Zoomer stayed off his phone for a whole hour no texts no social media nothing only for some crazy guy to come onto the murdaughs' property and kill them. It's often treated like a side-fact but it's just really tough to believe.

MG

I loved the original Scott Peterson video so this was a real treat for me, thank you! I live in the US and I’ve never heard anyone refer to their in-laws as mom and dad and I think it’s a very odd thing to do. ❤️

Queen of Hearts

I never realized this until hearing you say it but any mental image of what happened between her and the burglars is just really really fuckin funny. Option A: heavily pregnant woman with dog exits her house, locks eyes with burglars. Rather than employing the Cindy Lou Who method (just lie and pretend they’re taking things away for legitimate reasons) they decide to aggro onto her like a hostile mob Option B: Laci Peterson, heavily pregnant, has absolutely no sense of self preservation and makes an immediate beeline for a mob of violent criminals, presumably shouting “you have committed crimes against -Skyrim- Modesto and her people”.

Jonathan Gill

I understand there can't be "Christmas videos" every year, but this was a worthy followup to JB Ramsey. Interesting to hear the remarks on the creative process--like how the "come full circle" discussion at the end was something you manufactured after the start had already been written. The tonally off voice message feels to me like the phenomenon you talked about in the Tim Hennis video: it's someone pretending to be Mr. Normal and forcing themselves to announce how Normal things are. But maybe that doesn't get at why the delivery reads as off. It's both slow and lilting, and it doesn't match any natural rhythm to the sentence. It reminds me of another True Crime case with a killer leaving a chilling voice message as part of an alibi: Jodi Arias does it, and it's extremely unconvincing. The prosecutor played it in court after going through how ghastly the crime scene was, and you can sense in the courtroom how ghoulish it is for this brutal murderer to be leaving this overly-feminine "hey everything is normal" message to cover her tracks.

Claire

The Cult of Matt oh god it's such a slippery slope 😂

William Sokol

The Adnan sayed case is one of those I don't even understand how anyone can fathom he's innocent. I don't know how anyone can fathom maybe he's guilty but not enough to convict. It's really on the oj level of no one else even comes close and you have a wide range of evidence from witness to forensic.

Erin Morrison

I always felt really bad for Amber Frey in all of this because that poor girl didn't have a clue how much of a scumbag she got involved with. All these people who had the nerve to compare Amber with that evil hosebeast Nicole that was with Chris Watts really pissed me off 🤬

Steve

Rewatching full video, I’m struck by his voicemail from mother in law. Not exactly sure how I’d response to hearing “it was an anchor and not your pregnant wife in bay”—but doubt it would be a whistle. That’s a hell of a response.

Matthew Thayer

While this case is not interesting to me, and I see no point in trying to litigate it further, I just can't leave well-enough alone, and the thought just sort of came to me that, technically, all the timeline establishes is that she wasn't home when he left. If a situation could be imagined where he was lying about that for a reason that is not his guilt in her murder, then the impossible timeline doesn't mean it was him(everything else still does, but not that). The best I could come up with was he tells her he's been having an affair with Amber and she freaks out, says he's never gonna see her or the baby again, and leaves on foot, thinking she shouldn't drive, and either takes the dog with her for some reason or is in such an overwhelmed state of mind that something like the gate-open theory happened. Scott never speaks up because he figures the story would make him look even worse(somehow). This absolutely did not happen, but I thought it was worth it to at least probe the question.

Gigi

Erin sounds like my kind of woman. Really looking forward to the Konig case video.

Char

I'm from South Holland in the Netherlands. Calling the in-laws mam or pap is pretty common here. Maybe not the norm, but certainly not strange in my experience. It certainly points to the relationship being good, which might be why Scott puts emphasis on it as in "see how close we are". I read the book you mentioned and wow... his cheating was quite understated in the media.

Staive Gaming

Exactly this, if enough people want to watch it they can, it's on the Patreon, which in comparison to others, is very affordable for the content it provides

Michaela Egge

I kind of doubt it was just about Connor. SIDS is common enough still, isn't it? Surely wouldn't it have been easier to smother the newborn one night? Maybe they had drinks the night before and Lacie was out cold. He wouldn't even have had to dispose of evidence or a body. Lacie would just wake up and find him and it'd be a terrible tragedy. It's way more plausible than you're wife just going missing. I really believe he must have wanted to get rid of Lacie primarily.

feedergoldfish

It made me laugh when you described him as "immensely hateable". Yes, he certainly is.

Samuel Hayden

I’m Canadian. It’s pretty common here to call your in-law mom or dad, but not universal

Queen of Hearts

Sir, for your consideration: Brian’s legos, the most bizarre True Crime story currently ongoing. Starts with a man trying to sell his dad’s old legos, then rapidly turns into a wild story of lies, theft, police corruption, and the fucking Mormon Church.

Evan

I cannot believe anyone could actually convince themselves of that story with the dog. Has the Scott Peterson Innocence people tried a theory based around a giant owl picking up Laci and dumping her in the bay?

Emily

That was brilliant! Cheers Matt!

Haili Devillier

there is a new documentary coming out with geragos about him on july 16 talking about “new evidence”, maybe you can do a small text post update/opinion when it drops?

Haili Devillier

also im reading the book you mentioned and it is my favorite format of a true crime book probably ever so big ups on that!

D

Matt, you’re the best! Thanks for this video and for all you do. We really appreciate it.

ashbin

Yeah, same. I've *heard* of it, but never seen it IRL here in the states. It sounds like a really weird thing to do!!

Queen of Hearts

At least the one on Netflix is really good and doesn’t even pretend to entertain Scott’s innocence.

gucciburrito

I’m a little late. But even when I do marry my girlfriend, I don’t know if I could see myself calling her parents by the names of mother and father. Or mum and dad. Although my mother herself does call my dad’s mom “Mom”.

Anastasia

I am from Ukraine, and I *think* calling in-laws mom and dad is a thing only in small rural areas, and it is slowly dying down. Nowadays, it only happens in families with exceptionally close and warm relationships. I personally wouldn't do it tho

AR

I've listened to this at least three times since you posted it in May. it's sooooo satisfying lol

Cristiana Macedo

Just listened to a kidnaping case on Criminal from Vallejo - Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn. I can see how you could make a good tale out of it. I don't think I saw it covered elsewhere.

BCS Norway

No pressure, but I’m still on the edge of my seat waiting for the next masterpiece :)

Janissa Rose

Super late but OMG what was the deal w the Gerhardt case?? It truly appears the jury got really confused about their job and applied no critical thought or questioning to what they heard...

Brandon Mathews

I am American I don’t call my wife’s mom “mom” I think it’s weird but I do know people that do that but I always thought it was weird

Matthew Thayer

I think you hit on a big part of it with the OJ comparison: once you believe the police are trying to frame someone, the evidence becomes a la carte(not saying the police are lying in this case, I'm saying that many or most innocence believers seem to think so).

Jenifer Joseph

Would be super interested to hear our thoughts on Ezra McChandless and Brandon Banfield cases

Katie Bradshaw

Yeah, I've always been a bit weirded out by calling the in-laws "Mom" and "Dad." I've always just used their names. If I ever have children, I might call them "Grama" and "Granpa," at least for the first few years so the names stick, but that's the furthest I'd ever go. I feel like the kind of people who have that kind of relationship with their in-laws either have a bad relationship with their own parents, or come from a really conservative background that teaches a wife becomes a part of her husband's family. Those are the only two instances I can think of that would be like that.

Tristan Mahr

Man, it’s nuts that Ben Affleck basically played/channeled an innocent version of Scott Peterson. Like, so many shots of Scott make me think of that movie.

Oyster Herman

I’ve lived in Canada, Australia and the USA. No one I have ever met anywhere says ‘mum and dad’ for the inlaws.

Luthen’s Reality

What a good boy, the poor dog was a crucial part of the case. It feels like he went to find someone and tell them something was wrong.

BayouGirl!1976

I’m American and my hubby calls my parents Mom and Dad. We have been married/together 26 yrs now.

Soffity

Exactly what I was thinking. Here he is off enjoying himself with his new boat and expects his pregnant wife who isn't well to go and get a basket. What? How darn selfish if nowt else.

Soffity

I just joined because Ive been wanting too for ages; for years. My darling dad died and left me some money. What better way to spend some of it. So I'm here and loving it. Thanks dad RIP. Matt is my favourite. I'm worried I'm addicted then I'm worried I'm not then I think I don't care, enjoy it. Janey Peterson is one dedicated SIL- I've always wondered what her husband thinks of her obsession with 'proving'Scott's innocence.

Soffity

Go Claire

Soffity

When I was a kid back in the 60-70's my parents and their peers called in laws mum and dad. However that went out and now most call them by their first name. I called my mother in law Mil but my father in law said if I called him FIL he would call me DIL so I called him father in law. They were in their 70's and this was the early 80's. They thought I wasn't good enough for their son. Turned out he wasn't good enough for me 😵‍💫 Even to this day I still call my friend's parents by their surnames unless they ask me to use their first name. I don't like being called by my surname. I think it's a thing that was and now isn't so much. Aussie here, so the States may well be different.

em

i'd never refer to my in-laws as mum or dad, and im a brit. So i think it must be some rare americanism, and a weird one at that.

Ioanna Batziou

This case and the convoluted stories they came up with always make me think of my good friend Occam and his razor

Grace Wagler

So which of your videos do you like best (at this point in time)?

Teal

Growing up as a kid I would call my absolute best friend in the world's parents Mom and Dad (like elementary school age). We were always confused for sisters anyways. (also I am American). I do think it is more common in America for people to do this with in-laws, but I also live in the bible belt. My current partner of 6 years (we are not officially married but basically common law at this point), I refer to his parents by their first names to their faces and when talking to him. However if I am the one writing the mother's/father's day cards and such that we both sign I will start them with Mom or Dad as they are still his parents.

Isaiah Hiles

I think the actual walking into store, getting product, going to counter with possible line, then actual swiping card can add some time. I think we are really working with 5-7 mins

Bug

i love your point about the flaws making them feel more real. as a non-stop chatterbox myself hearing those bits about laci genuinely floored me and filled me with even more rage

BigBirdTitty

I’m like 99.9% sure calling your in-laws mom and dad isn’t an American thing. I know multiple people from mainland China who do it, and then I know just casually that it’s very common in the Middle East and while I’m not sure how common it is in Africa as a whole but I know it’s not NOT a thing. Can I ask why you were so sure it’s an American thing? No hate or venom I just have never seen the custom as anything if not universal as a concept.

PityTheHateful

I'm sure the regular delivery / post workers, the gardeners and the pool guy think our dogs bark at them every time too. But they don't. It's maybe 80% to 90% of the time. I can't believe that any dog is always awake, always hears the post and always barks. It's more likely that you think the dog is out when you don't hear it because it's so regular.

And Harry

In my opinion, the indefinable oddity in Scott’s voicemail is because of the context. Let’s take a look at what he’s essentially saying: “Hey, my 8-month pregnant wife, because I fucked around fishing all day I won’t be able to do that thing you asked me to do, so now you have to do it yourself.” In a genuine situation like that you’d expect to hear some kind of conciliatory tone or any kind of recognition that you’ve fucked up. Something like, “Hey honey, sorry about this, but fishing took way longer than I thought it would so I’m not gonna make it to the farm. Can you pick it up?” Instead, of course, he puts on the lovey dovey act because his main concern is establishing his alibi. It’s not how that type of interaction would occur if it were genuine.

SynonymRoll

I feel like it depends on the how the pregnancy has gone. Some women have suuuperrrr easy pregnancies and others have very very difficult ones. If she were up to it, then she can. But I personally wouldn’t ASK a pregnant woman to mop.

PastelPixie

I, also, would love your take on the Hae Min Lee case. I think Sarah Koenig had an inappropriate relationship with Adnan and Rabia was full of it. He was a jealous teen that killed his girlfriend out of revenge. End of case.

PastelPixie

I am American and I find it weird. My mom is my mom. My in-laws are referred to by their names.

Grace

would you ever consider making a video about jens soring?

Tearyawna

Cheers Matt, this video is well done. The mini addendum plus the commentary added so much context and entertainment. Thank you for always providing such quality content. Also, do not worry about practicing brevity. We’re here for your robust explanations.

Susie P

Laughing at your comments on Rabia from the serial case. I don't want to say anything unkind so I will say this, she sure is a podcaster.

Katherine Villarreal

The mom/dad thing for me is because I am not super connected with my family. When my in laws make like more attempt to hangout with me it makes tha feel more acceptable? But it's not something that I just do out the gate, I often feel like parents always ask for it more than people just doing it. It's odd

Rosie Wu

As someone who is very chinese, calling your in-laws “mom” or “dad” is the most normal thing ever and a sign of respect. Like a sign that the parents have accepted the marriage… sort of. So I honestly never found that weird when I watched the og vid, even if its in a completely different language 🤣 It was the only thing that wasn’t weird abt this guy tbh