Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 708735112.mp4

Downloads

Content

Another Creator Commentary to tie you over! A particularly well put together trial vid in my ever so humble opinion. Longer black screen update than usual - starts at 1:21:56. I give quick previews of: Laurie Shaver, Lindsay Clancy, West Memphis 3 Addendum and The Kerri Rawson Situation. Kerri thing I’m not sure will actually be a thing. Sort of floating a vague idea to see if it sounds appealing to many. 

Links:

Title 4 Flag Says You’re Shwag: https://www.scribd.com/doc/120005446/Title-4-Flag-Says-You-re-Schwag

State of Georgia Vs. Denver Fenton Allen (Ricky and Morty): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vN_PEmeKb0

The Early Premiere version if you want to see the ever so slightly different ending: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=InI0y3qnGfw

Files

Comments

libbydd

Just rewatched the original vid, this is a treat.

dathanlo

My personal favorite video of yours, been waiting for this commentary for some time

misused alien

I also cannot stand him, but I'll listen to your commentary!

Claire

Yay!!!! Happy to hear your voice again Matt. Ps I just showed my sister the overachieving Army captain the Hennis video. She liked it :)

Samuel Hayden

One of my favorite vids, looking forward to the commentary

Hunt Westbrook

Just finished rewatching the OG vid for a 3rd or 4th time so this is perfect timing. I think the fascination with Brooks is that he’s the worst combination of insane, delusional, and a full on loser.

Jessica

Lord I hate this man so much that watching your video on his trial is always a struggle. He's insufferable. I can 100% understand your point of view of "awful to make but great product." That being said I'm excited to listen to your commentary on the video.

Jim Pickens

Hi Matt, one of the new subs here! Skipped most of the video and started with the black screen part, and I want to say I'm very excited about your future plans. I think I'm actually equally anticipating Clancy and Memphis 3, no matter which one goes first.

Jim Pickens

Also with regards to M3 - as a normie-informed on the case, I was shocked by your comment. And then I researched into it more and... now I agree. (Am I that gullible or what lol?) Although there are parts that still give me pause. Can't wait for your take.

Jess of the Planet

Thanks!! Watching the Clancy trial—arguably the most important of the year here in the US. So far the strategies of each side are interesting to analyze. Look forward to hearing your thoughts!! *Addendum (lol)—at the end now listening to your update so just hearing your planning around schedule; just wanted to add my support to the pile, very reasonable plan, esp. given the circumstances around Clancy logistics. Had just stumbled across you on YT & was happy to join here after going through your library—I like to support creators over supporting the platform where I can!

Claire

@29.26 it's a sad fact of life that you can have carbs, or you can have booze, but you can't have both 🥲

Yonder

Heya Matt and new members, Ive been a member since 2021, and I can confidently say that the monthly membership is 100% worth. Even with delays in uploads, the creator commentaries, addendum, and Eastburn video make the $5 monthly a no-brainer for me.

Rikard Gustafsson

This is probably my favorite video yours, so I am happy you are finally doing the commentary on it.

AR

Watching this commentary has made me realize that I don't think I've actually ever watched the original video. I'n sure I've always passed it over, or never been in the right headspace before, and it's entirely because I always have the same reaction to Brooks as you do: just an utter inability to deal with his presentation and constant petulance and trial interruptions. And, too, there's the stress I feel every time, watching the judge constantly engaging in arguments with him instead of shutting him down and moving on (the way the prosecution finally does by stepping in re: his closing statement). It's just excruciating. But the good news for me is that means I get to watch a new-to-me Matt Orchard video. Yay! Re: Milwaukee, it's known for producing: 1) beer 2) Jeffrey Dahmer. Street scene? Not so much.

BCS Norway

Friday AND new upload from dear MO?! I didnt know christmas came so early this year <3

Erin

Hey Matt, one of the new subs here as well. Love your stuff! I would love if you could do any kind of content on the Peter Falconio case. I have posted comments before requesting it but I am early for once and you are more likely to see this. I think you would do a fantasic job covering it, whether you do it like a usual upload or more in the style of the Eastburn video, it will be a banger. It's just such a messy case and even though there has been a conviction it just doesn't seem like it is anywhere near being solved. Even just to know it's on your "list" would make me very happy. Either way, love your stuff and don't stop. Love from Australia.

Sherlock Holmes

Cat tax! Also, I've never heard of being from Milwaukee as a particularly significant thing to brag about, but every town, no matter how small, has people who make it part of their identity. Like around here there are relatively small high schools who are "rivals" to one another, and I could definitely see some kid from one or the other putting [smalltown]-PRIDE all over his little rap video.

AR

re: Kerri Rawson, keeping in mind that her family also were victims and must have experienced at the very least an untold amount of gaslighting from their father, it's really easy to see her having a difficult time processing reality to begin with. Based on what I've gathered from book reviews, she became a super-Christian after/while dealing with his arrest, and it's not hard to see her having been vulnerable back then to predatory cultic faith-based groups and/or social groups. I'm just saying none of that bodes well for her overall mental health. At least it doesn't seem like she has any violent tendencies herself.

Bec

It's not incongruous for him, as a self-proclaimed gangster, to "rep" his city. Places like Compton and Detroit get their reputation because all the criminals living there take pride in their crime stats moving up in the national ranks and work hard to make their city's name synonymous with "hard" life. It's why rappers and their fan bases constantly cite their area code to establish some sort of credibility of their bona fides of truly being "about that life". Popular rappers know and understand this, which is why you get 2Pacs ubiquitous California Love and others. They are connecting with their fan base, telling them, I see all my thugs out there doing a great job "keepin' it real" in the cities you're actively working to destroy! *Edit to add my personal, anecdotal evidence. I grew up outside of Detroit before it completely fell, when the big 3 were still the big 3. I lived in a privileged area, but as a teen of course ventured out to the dark lands my father warned me to never go to. I made friends with a guy who was desperate to be a gangster and frustrated that his parents moved to Detroit when his entire extended family was in Compton. He was constantly clipping newspaper articles about various crimes, shootings and apparent gangster activity that he would mail to his cousins in Compton, along with actual letters he wrote explaining to them that Detroit was just as tough as Compton.

PlugInKathi

I love rewatching the original video and then treating myself to the commentary 😅

BayouGirl!1976

Thank the sweet baby Jesus! I needed something excellent to listen to while I spend my last free Friday, before school starts back🥺😳🤪, painting with my watercolors. Thank you, Darlin’!

Joe Best-Rotheray

No Matt I won't be cancelling my subscription, in fact I shall be upgrading to a whopping $5 because how can I reasonably only pay $2 for all of this content? It would be criminal, and I don't wish to feature in a future video

Claire

Kerri Rawson captured my attention right from the start. She has always struck me as a deeply traumatised woman experiencing extreme guilt over continuing to love her father. Which she cannot seem to stop doing although it’s clear she’s tried in numerous ways over the years. In my view she’s been repeatedly taken advantage of by several media outlets and investigators over the years and could really have done with a lawyer and a publicist long ago, which she obviously could not afford. A really interesting comparison to make with Kerri is a woman named Sarah Turney, whose older sister Alissa was abused and eventually murdered by their father. Sarah has found a lot of strength in crusading against her father for her sister’s memory. I see a lot of parallels in how she and Kerri describe their confusion and grief about their fathers and the torment it causes them. Sarah has a critical difference though as the victim was her sister who she’s motivated to fight for beyond her love for her father; Kerri doesn’t have that bond with her father’s victims. Lastly: the craziness. In my opinion Kerri was very likely experiencing what lay folk call stress-induced psychosis and what the DSM calls Brief Psychotic Disorder. Someone can be diagnosed where there is sudden unexplained onset of psychotic features that last longer than a day but less than a month that is not better accounted for by other things like schizophrenia, drug abuse, a serious head injury or brain tumour etc. To me this is broadly supported by the New York Post’s reporting of Kerri calling her husband from wherever she was sectioned to, violating a domestic violence injunction from a judge, asking to understand what’s been happening in the last month. For the avoidance of doubt: I believe her family deserves to be protected from her actions. Being sectioned sounds appropriate at the time given the things she was saying and doing. She was objectively, medically, ‘crazy’. She was seriously unwell with classic symptoms of psychosis that she has never demonstrated previously (according to her family who seem completely flummoxed by all of this). Unless she was newly secretly abusing drugs or had a serious head trauma/brain tumour or undiagnosed schizophrenia that had not manifested until her late 40s, I feel quite confident in my hypothesis that her brain malfunctioned on her due to prolonged stress and the effects of her trauma history. She has a long period of recovery ahead of her even today many months later. If we consider the sustained stress and anguish that is required to induce psychosis in someone’s brain and make it last weeks like that, and when we consider the protocol of anti-psychotics that it takes to bring someone down from such an episode... it really doesn’t bear thinking about. The terror that I have watched people in psychosis experiencing in front of me in an otherwise completely physically safe environment is truly immense. I absolutely hate writing anything to you other than praise and adoration but personally I want to suggest waiting to speak about Kerri on youtube.com for a while, just my two cents xx

Alex

I’m from Wisconsin, and while I never lived close to Milwaukee or even really visited there, I can give you an idea of what other folks in Wisconsin say about the city. There’s not really any association with rap that I’m aware of, but it does have a reputation of being a “dangerous” or “bad” place compared to the rest of the state. However, most everywhere in Wisconsin is predominantly white, but Milwaukee has a large black population. So there’s a solid chance everything I heard growing up was just rural racism. Those same folks also talked about Chicago in the same way, and Chicago has been lovely every time I visited. That said, he could have been trying to play off that bad reputation whether it’s true or not.

Dan Stoval

I like how you are finding older work you've done to hold up when going back to it.

Purnam Jantrania

I like how much fun you seem to have doing this commentary! glad it can give you back some of the joy that was taken by making it. it really is a great video.

Karolina Salaei

Big fan here 😉. I love your content but I do have a one complaint : there is not enough of it! I need a lot more lol. PS. Omhg this is the most annoying guy ever! While watching Darrell Brooks vid, I had to pause so many times cos I was getting really worked up! Anyway, love your stuff Matt 👍

Bridj

Desperately awaiting your video on Clancy!

Bridj

And the Kerri thing sounds like it could have real legs. Hope that one comes down the pipe too

Rachel

Hi Matt! New patron here. With the discussion about future videos, I’m wondering if you’d be interested in making a video about when minors commit serious crimes and how society reacts. The James Bulger case comes to mind.

Matthew Thayer

Huh, I just thought, been a while since the last Patreon commentary, and went to check, lol.

Rosie Wu

Ahhh! Really looking forward to the Clancy video. But really, I’d watch anything made by you lmao

Matthew Thayer

For the Clancy update I cheer. For the WM3 update I weep, for the Shaver update, I have no strong opinions at this time.

SpergGurtDirt

As someone who has lived in Milwaukee, I will say that most of Milwaukee proper is "safe," in that I've never felt at risk of great bodily danger or anything like that when I'm in the city. There are two exceptions though: there are a lot of homeless people, even in the nicer areas and around the colleges. If you're not used to it, this can throw people off or give them "dangerous" vibes, which is understandable. The other exception is the north side - I work for a company where I have to go out to customer sites for work, and in the north side, the company advises that we never go alone - having been there a few times, I wouldn't recommend anyone go to the north side (it is very run down to put it lightly). One of my coworkers even had a car stolen from them during a meeting on the north side. (In fairness, I have also had a car stolen in South Milwaukee, an adjacent city that has its own problems) But I still broadly agree - people who think Milwaukee is some kind of super dangerous gangland probably haven't been there often. As to Matt's question about gangster rap scene in Milwaukee, I'm not too familiar with the rap scene in general, but I've never gotten the impression that there was a vibrant rap scene in Milwaukee like there was in places like LA or Atlanta.

Hamble

Thanks for all that you do Matt, I can’t wait for Laurie Shaver. I’d say you’re currently the best True Crime YouTube channel out there right now

Bianca Nascimento Lara Campos

I'm glad to know that the mayor video was fun to make bc is the most fun to watch till this day. This one is great also, but the Ford video is a gem!

Clare

Loved this commentary and keen for the next projects! Re: WM3, I'm very much looking forward to it but it will be a treat regardless of when it comes out. Happy to wait however long you need and will be thoroughly enjoying all other content in the meantime. You're a legend Matt :)

Samantha W

I appreciate your openness on the artistic license you took with some of the editing, it was so seamless I never would’ve noticed it otherwise. It brings some levity to such a frustrating case.

Clare

and I totally agree with you, the ending with the family member yelling at Brooks was exactly what was needed after having to watch everyone hold in their emotions to get through the trial

Grace Y

Wonderful commentary Matt! It feels like chatting with an old friend. I was wondering and maybe I missed this, are you planning on doing a West Memphis 3 addendum still? Edit: sorry I watched this on my lunch break at work so I wasn’t able to get to the very very end, my apologies 🩷

ReformedHoneyBadger

Regarding 1:04 the prosecution going through how extreme the attack was, I don't think the point is really to try and convince the jury. I'm sure everyone in that courtroom knows how the trial was going to end by then. I think the real reason to keep emphasizing the ruthless brutality of the attack is to rile up the jury and remind them that this case isn't just a clown show. Get them focused back on their fury at Brookes. I'm also sure it was some catharsis for the prosecution who finally get to unleash their total contempt for this worm of a person that they've had to bottle up throughout the proceedings. Must've been nice to finally say out loud what everyone is feeling.

PlugInKathi

New Patreon member here .. Just keep talking and take my money 🤑😅👍

MandyxLola

I was having a bad day(more like month tbh) then saw you posted and my day got brighter, thank you Matt 🫶🏽

Luke Monaghan

Really enjoyed this. One thing I've wanted to say for a while tho is I am getting fed up on the owl jokes on the main channel. I want to see comments discussing the actual ins and outs of the case but it's just owl jokes.

Jean Pierre Linares

The right tone for a Rawson video sounds tough to nail, but you've got that grasp on delivering seriousness with pockets of levity and absurdism already, so it's definitely worth considering

Declan44441

Ignoring any sort of practical considerations about the practice, I do truly think that Brooks is a prime example of someone who should be executed. We think in terms of how we would feel being stuck in a prison for life with the thoughts of what we had done but for someone like this who has no consideration, care or an inkling of remorse, the only punishment that would truly make him at least regret his actions would be capital punishment

JabboMC

I am legitimately, completely, totally baffled as to how someone can go through life as just such a massive ASSHOLE. Like, how is this conducive to human interaction whatsoever? How did such a gigantic prick even like, go to the grocery store man?

Matthew Thayer

Anyone have any guesses about what the 2 big things are?

Margaret Graham

34:10 The cut to Publix is a nice touch. 😄 Constant learner.

Mike

I really appreciated your reminder about the cancellation at the end of the video—that almost felt like the business-equivalent of mentioning jury nullification in your closing. Lol. I’m sure I’m not alone in saying that I’ll be sticking around though. I really enjoy the more casual, less narrator-ish videos, and they’re great for the work commute. It feels like I’m having a beer and talking crime with a friend! Also, I spent some time up in Wisconsin for college, and Milwaukee has some pretty rough parts from what I gathered. You’re right to assume that it doesn’t hold the same cultural footprint as a Detroit or Chicago, but it’s certainly the kind of place that could give you street cred from a rap perspective.

Queen of Hearts

Assuming this isn’t a joke, I would recommend you watch to the end of the full video rather than just the end of the commentary portion

Queen of Hearts

I would recommend against the Kerri Rawson thing. I get the schadenfreude that comes with learning that a public figure you never liked really is exactly what you thought they were (I never liked James Somerton and certainly felt vindicated at when he got exposed) but if she’s having legitimate medical problems I don’t think that making a video spreading the news of this to millions of people would really be a good idea. There’s often at least one crazy weird person who goes around leaving messages defending the criminal/most likely for multiple years in the comments on one of your videos, there’s Beth for the JonBenet video who is hardcore pro Ramseys and believes that some guy named Gary (I think) that boarded with the neighbors killed her, and Kitchen Sink on the Darlie video who claimed that you had been deepfaked/brainwashed/possessed (?) by Evil Brian into making an anti Darlie video, and No Spam who swears up and down that Laci Peterson did her whole entire walk in the outfit the witnesses described, changed clothes, came back out again, only to be abducted by a different group of criminals from the ones who did the robbery (though I think his fanfic had the two be related) and held captive alive for an extended time before being killed and dumped in the water. They’re frustrating and fascinating. Funnily enough, there isn’t one for the Todd Kendhammer one. There’s a few spattered Kendhammer defenders in the comments but none of them really committed to their arguments, just left a single comment or a small handful “I like him” or “the people who are emotionally invested in believing he’s innocent believe that he’s innocent, so he’s innocent” or I shit you not “Jerry Logging was angry on the stand, so he’s the real killer”. I haven’t found anyone for Sarah Boone either, and what little defenders there were for Papini didn’t really stick around. Tempted to go back through and look for any case weirdos for Brooks, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Black Israelite/New Black Panthers/Hoteps/Foundational Black Americans/Nation of Islam/other fringe weirdos were down there.

Queen of Hearts

Looking forward to the WM3 addendum as someone who doesn’t really believe that they did it. I feel like from your video I have a better understanding of the anti WM3 viewpoint beyond just “BURN THE WITCH”, but I still don’t really find Damian’s mental health records or Jessie’s confessions damning enough to even really go to trial, much less convict. I feel like compared to the multiple videos and eyewitnesses against Brooks, the impossible timeline for Scott, or the fiber on the knife for Darlie, the booze bottle just isn’t really enough. I have thought for about a year that the confessions not being forced could easily have been because of Jessie trying to make up a story to frame the other two so he could testify in court and get reduced time, but going about it in the dumbest manner possible given that he was a teenaged boy at the time, to the point that the only way his lawyer and the Blair Witch 2 guy (can’t remember the filmmaker’s name, just that he made Blair Witch 2) could explain it without admitting that he was trying to throw other innocent people under the bus to save his own skin is by making it out that he’s literally medically r*tarded

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah, like I say, it's sort of foreign to me how people could watch 1000x more of him than what's depicted in my edit as a leisure activity! I suppose it would be more tolerable with a chat box and/or streamer commentating - but still.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

All true!...And my take *is* a little bit toward the mean spirited side of things, but now that this has come up, I do feel like it validates certain instincts I had kept to myself - there's a *structural problem* going on there - something more fundamental than the (incredibly profound) trauma that would come from the revelations she was subjected to. That trauma would f just about everyone up in all sorts of ways...but I don't think it would ultimately put most of us in a place where we think we have psychic powers telling us our children are about to be murdered and calling in reports of mass shootings that aren't happening. I think that's very suggestive of something deeper and pre-existing. None of which is to say it's Kerri Rawson's *fault*, any more than anyone's mental illness is their fault. But it does mean she's an unreliable narrator, and in my estimation always has been.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Haha - yeah, I think that subtle gag is in a few vids now. Publix has become my sort of go to visual for "grocery store" - I know there's another use in Haggard/Edwards!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

The reason Ford was so much fun to make was there was an ongoing creative challenge in it - how do you spin ALL of his words and actions into a positive?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I dunno if it's really owl jokes all the way down in the comment section! Maybe just a few rising to the top. I hope people have enough taste to drop that gag when the Clancy case rolls around though.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeaaaah, we'll see - and you're right that it is one of those things where I feel like there's something to get across but I'm struggling to get a handle on exactly *what*...something like while Rawson was always deserving of our sympathy, it was always kind of evident that she never really had much to say, nor did we have anything to learn.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Probably applies to most mass murderers and stone cold blooded killers honestly. My opposition to the DP is more pragmatic than principled. I don't buy the notion society loses any of its collective moral righteousness from killing people like Brooks.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Thanks Mike! It's not like I want to talk myself out of money, I just to try to do everything I can to ensure no one ever feels ripped off or over promised by the paytch, which is "bad-business" aside form anything else!

Luke Monaghan

Usually it takes some time for relevant comments to filter through on a new post. Which sucks because I like reading what other conclusions people draw from the case

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I've never seen a single Boone defender in the comments either, though they are out there! One took the stand at sentencing...maybe that was the ONE she found on the internet idk loi. I get the Kendhammer defenders because I had the same instinct when I picked up the case - I thought it might wind up being a gray one...didn't pan out. So you're right, it's a matter of some people not being able to let go of the emotional pull of "awww, but what if he's telling the truth?" even when the facts of the case should tell them that's off the table. With Bryan and the Darlie video - I DID actually correspond with Bryan St John, who is sort of close to a from-day-one anti-Darlie forum poster, while I was writing that video. Same thing like I was talking about with Erin and the Scott Peterson case. It doesn't really matter if they're "biased" - if someone has been deeply entrenched in case discussion for decades, they're invaluable as a resource and beat google all to hell when you want to clarify finicky details (with references). Bryan REALLY gets in the mud with it though - exchanging barbs and insults with Darlie's family online and that sort of thing, which isn't really my style, but hey, it's a free country and all. And I like Bryan. Anyway, because of that...difference in style, I was erring toward not disclosing his involvement precisely because I didn't want to give people the wrong idea. And I would have been justified enough in doing so - Bryan had zero editorial control, just gave me a steer when I needed one. But ultimately I felt like it would be rude to ignore his help entirely so I thanked him in the description and pinned comment. ...Naturally, the Darlie Die Hards, including her sister Danielle (who I do have sympathy for), seized on that to say I had gotten Bryan to actually write the entire script! As if I would ever let anyone do that!!!...But oh well, they can have fun with that I guess.

Soffity

I enjoy your commentaries and congrats on the big increase in your patron numbers. I didn't see anyway of joining a $2 tier but was only too happy to give you $5.50 a month. You work hard on your videos and I'm always checking to see if the next one is out at about the 2 1/2 month mark. Would you be interested in doing an Aussie one such as Ivan Millat or Snowtown, Port Arthur, the Beaumont Kids? It's a pity we don't have cameras in court like they do in most American states, so perhaps lack of video footage may be one of the reasons you don't cover Aussie cases. However now you're doing the podcast type of presentation I'll leave my suggestions up. I know there are quite a few videos of interviews with Boris Millat and other family members but whether they are copy written I don't know. Your narration has improved so much as well, I remember suggesting years ago you speak more slowly when narrating snd the very next video you did. I'm sure I can't take any credit but it made a big difference. For some reason I thought you must have a background in law so it's interesting to hear a bit about your past experiences. Thanks

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

The good news is you can actually attain a perfectly decent physiche indulging in a bit off both. Abs seem basically unattainable though, I'm afraid :(

Claire

The even better news is that your abs are actually in fact already there, they're just hiding 😁

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah non-US cases are just tough because of that gap in resources, but like you say, with the emerging format maybe some day.

Erin

Thank you 🙂‍↕️

Soffity

Was his motive anger at his ex girlfriend? Yes he hit her but didn't kill her and then he goes and ploughs thru all those people just enjoying themselves. His car looked like it had been thru a war zone. He had attacked his ex before and not taken it out on anyone else so I wonder what made him snap that day. I bet the man who gave him the sandwich and helped him wished he hadn't when he found out what he had done. I realise the judge had to make sure there was nothing he could appeal against in the way the trial was run but she was very very patient and tolerant. I would have put him in the other room and muted him the minute he started to argue. The stenographer must have been pulling her/his hair out by the roots trying to sort out all the over-talking. I don't understand why he did it. He must have known he would get caught. So many witnesses, his car left at the scene CCTV footage, etc etc. Anyone got any ideas.

Soffity

Matt, you may not have six pack like Darrell but you have a much, much nicer heart, are far better looking, kinder, more intelligent and your videos are so much better than his. All the best to you from a fellow NSW fan. 🌈🦘

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah, no actual personal background in law, but both my parents were lawyers. My mum thinks it's funny that after years of trial and error I wound up really finding my place in a sort of hybrid area - creative work that's still steeped in the "family trade." I don't have any of those cases on my list - but with the new podcast like format there's definitely more room to look at Ausie and other non US cases in the future. Narration is a constant struggle, and, funnily enough, I think around the Brooks case is where I started finding my stride. When I look back at the Konig video in a few years though, I'll probably still feel it's not *quite* right. Always trying to make it sound a little more natural, which is easier said than done when you're recording a sentence or sentence fragment at a time!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

If I said the argument with his gf was his "motive" then that was clumsy phrasing. The video itself qualifies it - "his real motive...for lack of a better word" or something like that. The argument would be better described as the "catalyst" - the event that set things in motion. He got extremely angry, drove off in a huff wanting to get back home (or wherever), found the roads on his chosen route blocked on account of the parade...and smashed through the blockade and the parade goers because they were just all in his fing way and it really pissed him off. All available information points to that explanation. There's nothing to "get" or make sense of because it's utterly senseless.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I might do a child offender some time and I guess never say never, but I don't think I'll ever do Bulger. I honestly just personally find the crime too upsetting, which I know is saying something given what I've covered but there you go.

Matthew Thayer

So, I am 90% sure I know both of the things that he is going to talk about in the first part of the addendum, and I'm 99.99% sure I know at least one of them. The one that I'm 99.99% sure about is based on a comment from a reply to a DM I sent him that was about the case, which I won't reveal in case he would rather that remain undisclosed. The other one is just my guess, based on my extensive familiarity with the case, and the fact that it got the most time in the other-other-side chapter of his original video, which is the confessions, either just Jessie's confessions or those plus the stuff Damian said(Jason allegedly confessed in prison, but that testimony has since been recanted, and was never credible to begin with(Though maybe Mr. Orchard disagrees)). Speculating a lot, I think that he would argue that the things Jessie gets right are way too numerous and striking for a confession that he's just pulling out of his ass, and that the confession is not really consistent with simply going along with leading questions(and maybe bringing in things like Buddy Lucas or the step mom, idk). If he brings up what Damien said, the big thing is that he was interviewed a month before Jessie confessed and either guessed, heard, or knew specific details of how the boys were murdered the day after the bodies were found(allegedly(nothing in this case is straightforward)). So, that's half of my wild(but confident) guess on what he would say.

Declan44441

Same as me, I’ve never bought the argument that it is “state sanctioned murder” because then prison is just state sanctioned kidnapping. Also some say that life without parole is worse, but why then do the majority of US death row inmates accept their guilt but still appeal their sentence. It almost certainly is the case for most of these people, perhaps Brooks stands out just because through his antics it became clear quite how little he cared about those he hurt, whereas most you just see a lawyer doing their duty to the client

BrianC

As someone who watched the entire trial from start to finish, I think part of why I could stand the frustration, is as someone going through a rough time at college, it was a weird reassurance that no matter how badly I might fail, I would never sink even close to the level of shitbag Darrell Brooks was

Rachel

Totally understandable. Thanks for the response!

Queen of Hearts

I think there’s a certain hilarity to people who feel the need to constantly respond to every single comment response they get even on videos that are years old. You just have to wonder what’s going on in their lives. Plus the way Darlie supporters talk about Bryan like he’s Satan’s strongest warrior is hilarious.

A

Darrell Brooks should have been Derek Chauvin's bum ass lawyer EDIT: 43:30 Matt I think you can be Chauvin's bum ass lawyer

Kevin Amos

Love your content bro and everything in your plan sounds great, don’t overdo it.

Patrick Kelly

You can't pay for marketing like that though. Every crime video on YouTube is referencing macos, that's invaluable

Claire

I just have to jump on back here and tell everyone that when I hear someone say 'Milwaukee', I always also hear Alice Cooper discussing the alternate pronunciation for the city name from the Algonquin tribe. Party on. https://youtu.be/gyFCbkK1xV4?si=GoOlIFrRLiN_kCa1

Claire

Matt did a bit as Chauvin's lawyer in the commentary on that video!

Soffity

Not being American I thought Publix was a restaurant also when Matt said Justin Ross Harris had been there for lunch. If he did kill poor little Cooper he certainly chose a very cruel way of doing it.

Soffity

Matt I've done some research on lie and lay and apparently lay means to put down or position for use and lie is to be lying down or reclining. 'I lie down for a nap after a Matt video." I lay my iPad next to my bed in case Matt uploaded." Mind you grammar and varied and interesting vocabulary seems to be a dying art.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

You might be thinking of the Chandler Halderson commentary. Chauvin actually had a good, union appointed lawyer - Eric Nelson. He did a very good job with a terrible set of facts.

Claire

Eeep, my MOCU (Matt Orchard Cinematic Universe) lore is fading! Time to study up 😏

A

MOCU or MOCU20

Ciara Dunne

Hi Matt, hope you're doing well. I'm excited to hear that you're doing a WM3 addendum; like you, i believe they are guilty, but I'm curious to hear your thoughts and what convinced you. Have you ever considered doing a Michael Peterson addendum or creator commentary? Alongside JonBenét it's the one true headscratcher in true crime for me, though (like you again) I do think Michael likely murdered Kathleen.

Liam Sullivan

The eastburn video plug was pure genius matt (as was the execution of the video itself)

Ciara Dunne

Hey Matt, hope you're doing well. I'm glad to hear that you're doing a WM3 addendum; like you, I believe they're guilty, but I'd like to know what convinced you given that their innocence is the default narrative of the case. Have you ever considered doing a Michael Peterson addendum or creator commentary? That case, alongside JonBènét, is perhaps the biggest headscratcher in true crime for me. Like you (again) I think Michael probably killed Kathleen, but I think your analysis might help me sort out my thoughts on the case.

moogiewoogieboogie

Wow, I can't believe Matt hates homeless people and think women are "crazy" smh my head 😔 Also Some Chick's real name is definitely Dehleighlugh or Shampayne or Trageideigh or some shit. Loved the commentary as usual (less so the actual listening to Brooks barf out bs again but hey ho) - looking forward to all the new projects coming up! Hype as heck

moogiewoogieboogie

Gotta read up on the daughter of BTK now haha. She seemed super iffy and weird when I saw her in a doc a while ago but I had no idea about all the things you referenced. Pretty wild situation all around

sammer

I do not think that you are some woke white hating leftist elder of Zion covering up shameless white genocide or whatever those people say. However, I think you really have erred on the attack being a hate crime for the following reasons: 1. Most people who commit hate crimes do not have great personal lives. Conversely, there's a lot of hateful people who are only held back by fear of death and complacency in an OK life. 2. I wouldn't need the south carolina church shooter's stupid web posts to call what he did a hate crime, even if his GF had just broken up with him. But they do contribute to that fact. 3. As you pointed out I believe, he committed his massacre at the whitest event imaginable, and on the heels of the Rittenhouse shooting. More interesting to me is what your biases seem to be (no offense). 1. Unlike most of what you cover, this is a spectacular terrorist attack. Even for another horrible crime, such as if he had raped and murdered a white woman on the street, I would not call that a hate crime necessarily despite his dumb posts. The message he made by his attack is so obvious even he didn't need to restate it. 2. Your video is also far better by focusing only on the trial, and treating it as a hate crime makes that far harder to do. There's certainly an audience for anti white hate crime videos but that's not really your thing 3. Nor should it be.

sammer

Also, I also don't see why Darrel Brooks is treated as unintelligent. There would have been no plea for him, it was a pretty genius maneuver to invite something that could be called judicial malpractice, as he had zero other options or chance for a plea, and he gets to antagonize victims. Saying he just wanted to kill white people doesn't really help that plan. Great video though and excited for WM3A!

Jeff

32:10 I saw that video. It is HILARIOUS. David Allen something v. Georgia

Aurora H.

The closest Milwaukee gets to hip hop is when rich evans ironically puts on a gold chain

ChemicalCocktail

Laurie Shaver, Lindsay Clancy, WM3 ADDENDUM?! Thank you for all that you do, Matt!

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Probably just agree to disagree for the most part, but just a couple things there: - With the Dylan Roof comparison, that's a great example of why it's NOT an arbitrary classification. I.e. It's not simply that he chose black targets and therefore society made an *assumption* it was WN terrorism. Roof had a manifesto and explicitly voiced his racial motivations - as virtually ALL ideology driven killers do. - I don't have the actual figures in front of me, or know if they're even available, but I suspect the whiteness of the crowd has been exaggerated. Majority white for sure, and all of the dead were white. But of the dozens injured there was more color in there, some non-white victims even took the stand. I've seen some suggest he CHOSE to just kill the white ones, but I doubt you could be that surgical with a car in a crowd - he appeared to swerve with no rhyme or reason. All of that aside though - there's no evidence he came to the area for any other reason than to see EP, or that he even knew a parade was happening, let alone what the racial demographics of the parade were. I can get how in the direct wake of things if you saw the crime, saw DB, learned of his past tweet, and then factored in the Rittenhouse acquittal had recently happened, you could form an initial theory that it may have been a BN terrorist attack, and I'm in no way allergic to the notion such a thing *could* happen. But after everything came out in the wash there was no good support for that, and I think people who hold onto the hypotheses on the basis of those pretty darn weak supporting facts and in the face of much stronger indicators that say otherwise do so because it fits in with their wordview. The same thing they (often correctly) accuse their adversaries of doing when interpreting current events.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

When the table's clear, quite a while from now, I will do an addendum outlining what I've come out thinking on MP - incorporating Tiddy Smith's absolutely wild 4th option. I went into that thinking it might be a Darlie type video, but it really did wind up being a genuine head scratcher as you say. With WM3 - if I start explaining myself on that I'll just end up writing the damn addendum, so it's bad time management! What I will say about how I came to my position is it's one of the few instances where I can actually pinpoint a specific moment. It was the last thing I did before beginning to write the script. I had been totally lost in research for a month - as you know, the volume of information is quite overwhelming and can kind of spin you out. So I figured, "before you start plotting out how you're going to present this, you should get a handle on what YOU actually THINK - guilty/innocent/don't know" So I stopped reading this that and the other, sat at my desk, and just thought it through from square one focusing on what I made of the information we have rather than what anyone else might want to argue about it. Within a span of minutes, what I truly thought sort of washed over me, and ever since I've been of the opinion that it's not actually that complicated - the seeming complexity is just an illusion built over years of endless discussion. That's why I'm starting off with "the two big things" - I think if you're willing to really sit with what I see as some very fundamental things, the picture gets pretty clear.

austin cramer

Publix is pretty great. Their subs and fried chicken are amazing, and it’s the go-to for cakes and pies.

austin cramer

You have to appreciate how the courts respond when they are stretched to the absolute limits, how careful lawyers and judges must be when faced with utter disobedience, just smart enough to exploit the system through frustration. I found it a fascinating angle into a usually buttoned up process.

Magdalena Siepka

I’m a retired lawyer and often crime themed shows annoy me for their inaccuracy and downright stupidity but boy do I enjoy everything you put out. So much so you are the sole creator getting my $ support on Patreon. Episodes are even great for rewatching. About this particular episode - imagine those of us in the legal system (cops, lawyers, judges) who cannot get away and have to deal with these humans without losing our shit on the record/in court. Ultimate test of patience. Thanks for your work and creativity.

Jenifer Joseph

I think he definitely hated white people but I really think he didn't care who was in his way that day, regardless of color. Definitely made it easier I bet but this guy is deeply unhinged and I think just as willing to go after other black people if it suited him.

Jenifer Joseph

This video always fascinates me because of the juxtaposition between how stupid this particular person and the sheer evil and malice of his crimes. Fine line to not punch down at the victims, and you did a great job with that.

Emily Tupper

Loved this commentary and have been a patron for a while…the West Memphis 3 addendum is my most anticipated video yet besides the Darlie Routier one (my favorite video yet)

Ty P

There is an issue most people overlook. What does it mean if your father or another close family member did something horrible? People struggle to understand why families of perpetrators very often are unable to accept the guilt of that close family member. The issue is that it's not just about accepting that this person has done something evil, it is also about giving up significant parts of your memories. Every memory that includes that evil person is now tainted forever. I found out that my best friend was a pedophile and that really messed me up. I needed years before I could trust again. 20 years later and that entire terrible affair is still very uncomfortable to think about. Now imagine that happens with one of your parents. You childhood is essentially gone.

Kevin Amos

I think a video or commentary on Gisele Peilcot in your narrating would be great. Such an immensely horrible case that just happened. Horrible stuff

Dylan Pemberton

Wexler is such a fan of the exchange with the witness Nicholas Kirby that he had to come down and watch with us

pink pink

I love your faith in humanity, but I actually think a decent amount of people would give the child/family of a serial killer a hard time. I often see lots of sentiment of "you had to have known. You can't live with someone like that and not know something is wrong. You should have noticed and put a stop to it" (not that this makes her not crazy lol)

Virginia

Your point about the editing of the video making his bull crap tolerable is right on the money. I liked this video and got recommended unedited trial footage, so for a while I’d put it on in the background. Every time, ten minutes or less in, I’d get so tired of him I’d turn it off! Bless you for going through the whole thing, lol

Grace

are you keeping up with the lindsay clancy trial?

Bug

i lived on a homestead in the mountains of california for a couple weeks and some of the people who would move on and off the homestead to live and work were SovCitz and they’re def crazy and some of them actually schizophrenic but most of em are nice people! very fascinating folks!

Chad McRod

Not the GRRM diss 😭 if you make anything like the Eastburn video again I will buy the shit outta that. I’ve already watched it twice, it was so interesting

Sherlock Holmes

I am going to be so interested to watch your Clancy video. I've never watched a court case before, but I'm watching this one, and I am curious to see if I come to the same conclusions as you. By and large, I always feel like you get the right read on things (haha!), and I don't expect that to change, but to what extent is that due to your presentation? In this case, we will find out! Also, your forensic tech expert from the Read trial is on the stand today. Cool!

Jake Duncan

Hey Matt - love your work and rewatch your videos often to wind down. Your story telling and logic are second to none.I With that said, I have noticed we have a lot of the same conclusions, even when you cover cases I’m familiar with so without bias (JDI, Karen Read). The one where we differ is I heard in passing you think the WM3 are guilty, which I personally don’t, although I’m not ruling out propaganda for that belief and is likely a major contributing factor. I’d LOVE to hear your reasoning as to why you believe in their guilt, as like I said pretty much all your other videos I staunchly agree with your assessment and wonder if your takes would move the needle to me. I know how busy you are crafting these masterpieces, but if you ever decide on a side project I would be thrilled to see it. Either way, cheers and look forward to your future works!

MissChanandlerBong

As someone who suffered from postpartum psychosis and was very much a danger to their child, I largely avoid any Lindsay Clancy commentary unless I know the creator already. It's just too triggering otherwise, as it's a condition that is so misunderstood. I trust you will do a good, balanced job with this case, Matt!

Jonathan Gill

Not sure I agree that the closing argument solution is something the judge should have first proposed. It's more meaningful coming from the prosecution, because theirs is the side 'disadvantaged' (however minutely) by this allowance. I'm not sure the judge is the one who should be asking the prosecution to accept circumstances they would never accept for a real lawyer.

Jonathan Gill

The discussion at the end about the BTK killer's daughter (sounds like an interesting topic, by the way) had me think of another short style Patreon content. Nothing I'm deadset on, just an idea for a short video: You've mentioned several times how BTK and Bundy are pointed to as seemingly "normal guys" who actually did have a few disturbing signs in their personal lives. I thought a short video covering a few of those instances could be interesting. Not a deep dive, just a few talking points.

Jonathan Gill

The confessions and the whiskey bottle? Matt's alluded to the former as being credible in the main, so I think that might be one of them. The other thing is the complete lack of alibis, which shouldn't constitute strong proof, but in Damian's case it does seem almost suspicious how the alibis work for afternoon and night but not evening. (I have no idea about the case myself. I guess I'm a fence-sitter so I'll wait for what Matt has to say)

John M.

Re: the question posed in the commentary at 43:00. As an American, I don’t associate Milwaukee with that genre of music as opposed to, say, Los Angeles or New York. I’m sure most would agree. And if Brooks lived in either of those cities, then he probably would have featured it prominently in the music video. But I’m assuming they were just going for the gritty/big city vibes, and Milwaukee was the best they could do given where they were. Similarly, if he could’ve scrounged up more cash then he wouldn’t be flaunting a single, lonely $100 bill in the music video but, alas, he didn’t. Again, just my (*objection*) speculation. But maybe that’s not lawful law.

KT

Probably not going to see this, but I'd like to toss in my two cents anyway. Re: the Kerri Rawson thing. Putting aside her as an individual, there is a valid idea behind the whole "family members of murderers are attacked for being family members of serial killers." I'm not sure I would call it discrimination per se (like you said, people aren't really going like "your dad is a murderer so I will punish you too" (or, well, not consciously at least; we can't rule out subconscious bias)), but more people just interpreting every move in the worst faith imaginable, or not seeing them as human. Many family members of serial killers, not just children, do struggle with having to reconcile the person they love with the person who did horrible things. And that's not even mentioning the potential trauma bond that comes from living with an abuser. If the relative doesn't act how the public thinks they should--ie, they don't immediately cut off all ties with their serial killer relative and disavow them publicly and loudly; they even hint at having, at any point, a positive memory with them; god forbid they mention paying for a defense attorney or pointing out an actual judicial issue--they are harassed and attacked for "taking the side" of a serial killer. The public at large has no sympathy for the incredibly painful situation of loving someone who did something horrible. And that's not even mentioning the extra baggage that comes with having an abusive parent; most of the time, serial killers are not actually very nice to their families. Who would've thunk it. But that just adds on another layer of trauma bond that will make someone not act how people think they "should." Obligatory, of course that doesn't overshadow the victims' pain, but I'm saying the relatives are victimized as well. Also, given the rise of true crime, while people won't say "I bet you're a murderer because your dad was a murderer"... they will stalk the relatives of serial killers. Fans, documentary directors, Netflix producers; they all want the perspective of someone close to a killer. And sure, they're not saying "I bet you're a murderer because your father/cousin/sibling/child was a murderer"... but having hordes of people show up at your doorstep to ask you the same horrible questions about horrible topics--and remember, if you answer "wrong", your name will be splashed across the headlines. Jeffery Dahmer's father was stalked and harassed by "fans" of his son (and the Netflix series) until he died. I honestly don't think people would really report as much about Kerri Rawson being an insane person if she herself was not intertwined with the BTK killer. Not to say you can't make your video about Kerri Rawson. But rather, I do want to point out that, though she may not articulate it well, there is something there to the idea that family members of serial killers (or other high profile criminals) do face a lot of unique challenges and difficulties. And I think that could be an interesting topic to cover.

Mae

I looked into Rawson and while I get what you’re saying about her being “off,” I don’t think it’s because she’s crazy. It’s because she has to balance the loss of the man she loved and thought she knew against the horror that her father caused. Of course it’s hard for her to look directly at the things he did. And it was “her fault” that he got caught so I can only imagine the warring guilt of “I did this to my family,” no matter how illogical that thought is! It sounds like she had psychosis, be it limited or otherwise. From what I could find with an admittedly short records lookup (only Seminole County), she got a divorce in 2022 followed by an eviction and 4 lawsuits by creditors. There were no criminal court cases. It’s also worth noting that a permanent injunction isn’t as big a deal as it sounds, especially depending on whether she showed up and whether he had an attorney. She certainly wouldn’t have since only criminal trials grant access to a public defender. Not that he didn’t need one - her behavior absolutely was alarming - but the injunction itself isn’t nearly as remarkable as it sounds. Lastly, you are definitely giving people too much credit. There are MANY people who believe the children of serial killers should be on watch lists because of course they’ve inherited the “killer gene.” It’s not a particularly loud subsection, but it’s kind of natural. How many of us don’t think a little bit to ourselves that it makes sense that the kid of BTK is “crazy”? Woo that was a longer post than I meant to write. Great video! Looking forward to your Clancy coverage.

Bird

In most of Wisconsin, people sometimes use “Milwaukee” as shorthand for “place where Black people are” (which is kind of accurate when you look at demographics compared to most of the state). So of places in Wisconsin that could have a reputation as a place with a gangster rap scene, Milwaukee is basically the only option.

Bird

I just want to assure everyone that, despite the four Matt videos based here, Wisconsin is a very nice place to live!