Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 734144518.mp4

Downloads

Content

Howdy All!

Just popping in quickly to let you know where things are at as we go into a new month. If you don't wanna listen to the longer audio update, Key takeaways are:- Next feature video on the Laurie Shaver case is coming along nicely and I'm projecting a release date of ABOUT September 10th for the Early Patreon Premiere. Possibly even a touch earlier, and worst case scenario I guess the 15th, but 10th feels about right. If you don't know much about that case I'd recommend going into my vid blind. - Lindsay Clancy will be next after that. I chat about it a bit in very vague terms, because I don't want to give away any of my current inclinations...though current inclinations are all I have anyway. There's not a lot to give away when I haven't reviewed the trial yet, because I can't really know what my opinions are until I do that part!

As most of you know, we're actually in "verdict watch" mode at the time of this update, wherein I mention I think a hung jury might be at 50% probability. If it goes that way, whereas I was thinking that might lead me to shelve it until it fully resolves, now I'm leaning more toward just do it anyway with a hung jury being the ending of my video on the case. Let me know if you think a more definitive outcome is worth waiting for, or if you agree with the way I'm currently looking at that situation. Have a great September, and I'll catch you again soon!

Files

Comments

Claire

Yaaaaaay! Hi Matt!

Holly Burton

Looking forward to both videos! I haven’t heard much about Laurie Schafer so looking forward into going in blind. I’ve tried to keep as blind about Lindsey Clancy but as you said it’s everywhere at the moment and as a feminist I’ve been getting a-lot of takes more generally about the mental load of motherhood. I know it’s a little insane as my very normal coworker is convinced the husband secretly did it (which I do think is inappropriate, also I think is maybe trying to find an obvious villain). I do think my current opinion is that she was unwell for a while and kept trying to get help and nothing was working and things kept piling and piling up until the psychosis took over. But I’m down to have my opinion changed! Looking forward to both videos!

Ben Harrington

Apologies if you addressed this somewhere else and I missed it - I saw something about Gerhardt Konig's verdict potentially being overturned due to a text message - do you have any thoughts on the verdict and the stuff that has happened post?

Mary Stribley

Re: What if hung jury? My vote is yes, still drop the video, and possibly create a Pt.2 for retrial! Really unique opportunity to observe the effects of a hung jury on such a high profile case. Love ya work Matt! 🫶

Declan44441

Is the Lindsay Clancy video going to be modified in the face of how much international attention it has gotten? Like from the TikTok true crime women who seem to have no care for what she did and are fully supporting her with no care for the children. How they then decided to character assassinate the husband with so many ridiculous statements and lies accusing him of really doing it. I would think it would be difficult to do a video without attracting attention from both them and the other side who has no interest in any nuance and just says she should be put in the electric chair and it turning into a circus in the comments

Solar

Please still drop the LC video if there is a hung jury. A hung jury is a legitimate and likely outcome in this case I think.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I think the case already has so much going on in it that there won't be time for a social commentary aspect. There's like a video's worth of material if you wanted to tackle only that aspect.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Maybe if they've got legit jury misconduct material (I doubt they do) they have some shot. The other stuff they cite in the motion is the sorts of comments that are clipped in my vid. They're super unlikely to get a retrial off of that for reasons l outline at the end of the vid. Juror comments almost never reverse trial outcomes. Here's my Twitter/DIscord update on that: Today's planned sentencing has been delayed as Konig is asking for a new trial - citing evidence the jury misunderstood their instructions based on post-trial statements covered in my video (as in, he's citing the statements, not my video's coverage lol) The reason this is *particularly* interesting is that it's quite an eyebrow raising gamble. GK wasn't actually acquitted of Attempted Murder 2, but rather convicted of it, and then downgraded to Attempted Manslaughter based on the jury's finding of Extreme Mental or Emotional Disturbance. That means IF he were granted a new trial, he would NOT be protected by double jeopardy. It would be a completely clean slate with the higher charge of AM2 back on the table. Personally, if I were in his situation, I would take the manslaughter as a win - and not a particularly minor one. Almost like yelling "hit me!" when you're sitting on 20 in a game of blackjack. I'd say the motion is very unlikely to succeed - as covered in the vid, trial outcomes are very seldom reversed based on subsequent statements from jury members. Though when they are, it can only happen in favor of the defendant, so there is *some* chance.

David Budelecean

Drop the video anyway and make a part two if retrial. We want to see the cold hard facts of the case, maybe your video might influence public opinion

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Yeah the Patrick Did It stuff is just unhinged! ...And I think the people who start making overtures to the sort more generic burdens of motherhood aren't doing their side many favors! LCs real defense is, and always will be *insanity* - nothing more, nothing less, nothing different. That she was for all intents and purposes, functionally not really her when she did what she did. To the extent anyone starts to sound like they're adding, "and to the the extent she really was her [some sort of excuse or ideological shit]" - that's not feminism, or nuance, it''s just demented.

Alan Holding

I'm so committed to the MOCAS coverage that I've been actively avoiding reading or watching anything about the Clancy trial. Roll on Laurie Scafer video, I'm going in blind! Thanks for the update

Xavier

Hi Matt, thanks for the update, eagerly looking forward to both videos! Regarding the hung jury possibility, I concur with others in releasing the video and following up with an addendum/part 2 if needed. Keep up the great work :)

Fletcher Henery

If the Lindsey Clancy case does end up on a hung jury, you could always do an addendum like the Nicolae Miu case. Can’t wait to see your newest video!

MandyxLola

I have no idea whats going on with either case (but ive seen Clancy being mentioned by name) I think you should do the video even if there's no final verdict, no real reason other than because im impatient and want to hear it from you before anywhere else lol

Adam M

For LC I'm all in on "make the video anyway" as a hung jury would only highlight how complex a case this is. But also, if you were to make a follow-up, would you want to wait for an outcome to the civil suits against the healthcare providers? I'm not sure how much those will sway public opinion on the case, but it could be an interesting angle nonetheless.

Isabel Glasow

Please do some research on coercive control in the lead up to this. He was logged into her social media, and might have had a cloned phone - discontinued meds that were not in the house but in her system were kept in his car for weeks. Controlled substances are not routinely given to spouses to dispose of. Just think of the Gisèle Pelicot case, it's not unheard of. A nurse also would not look up the carotid artery and misspell it. The Google searches about were done by Patrick (using her Facebook account!) while she was at the doctors with the children. Most importantly, Baby Callan was able to be revived which means he can't have been harmed much earlier than 6.10pm - when Patrick was home and Lindsay had been seen lying on the ground at 5.50pm. Just take that fact alone, it's a physical impossibility. His timeline is wrong if he sent an email from his Surface Pro at 5.24pm. Since she was seen outside on the ground at 5.50pm, she would have had less than 25 mins, possibly less if the neighbour didn't see her immediately. It also means that Patrick lied, having 10mins before leaving - and quite a few minutes when he came back - that would have given him ample opportunity. To simply take his word for it is crazy, and this is why so many people talking about it. A man is far more likely to be believed than a woman, especially in that particular area of America. When police arrive at a crime scene with three dead children and a half dead woman, the husband should automatically the prime suspect for a reason. 95% of family annihilations are committed by men, that's simply a fact. You just cannot make the timeline fit. Also, why are there no traces of footsteps in the blood or water, when she was found on the ground soaking wet? You think that she used gloves or wiped her fingerprints of the knife after cutting herself? Why didn't he see the children through the window right by her when the emergency services did? There was no proper investigation either, other than a quick Google search of how long it would take him to get to the places he went to. He wouldn't be the first person to pop out to try and make himself an alibi for something that he could have done just before he went out or when he came back. The claim that he couldn't connect to emergency services because the phone supposedly toggled between data and the WiFi is nonsense. There is a lot of reasonable doubt. Patrick made a lot of contradictory statements and told some obvious lies. She can't have told him what he claimed she told him with a crushed thyroid, end of story. That is simply logical, and I haven't heard anything that would resolve these flaws in the prosecution's reasoning. They have even contradicted things that witnesses said as well as themselves. Dismissing everyone who has obvious questions as stupid feminists doesn't fix the problem with their arguments. I have seen more men than usual saying the same thing, even though it shouldn't matter. Just imagine for a moment that Patrick was responsible. He would have pulled off the perfect crime. She is held responsible, and permanently paralysed whilst he walks off with $ 1.7 Million from the GoFundMe, $700000 from the house, a potential malpractice suit, AND the life insurance of the children. Meanwhile he puts them altogether in a group grave in a memory wall, manages to get the death date for Baby Callan wrong and talks about how exhausting they were at the memorial. Says that he 'envies their misery' when he sees people with young children. Goes on holiday to Costa Rica three weeks later, leaving petty reviews about something costing $17.-, possibly a bit too much in his opinion. Why would someone earning $400 000 a year make her feel so terrible about not being well enough to go back to work, fire the nanny just after being told that she was suicidal, and tell his father 'No' when they offered to help with the children? Let her struggle with a baby, a stroller and two toddlers all by herself and just stand there, on his phone, completely disengaged? The first video I ever saw on this was a woman saying that he was a family annihilator who used his wife as a weapon. With everything that has been shown in the trial, in my opinion he hasn't been properly ruled out. Lindsay clearly has no clear memory of what has happened and been very vulnerable to suggestion. There have been a lot of conversations about coercive control, and the weaponisation of mental health issues by abusive men, as well as very poor mental health care for women especially after having children. A lot of these issues are exacerbated by abuse and domestic violence. It might be helpful to look up the case of Linsey and Patrick Barnet. Sometimes women are driven to suicide and sometimes those suicides are staged, especially when they are found by a partner who was the last person to see them and who has control of the crime scene. Please check out the podcast Crime Analyst for more information on this. There is a 10 point checklist for authorities to watch out for a coerced or staged suicide, and this situation covers 8 out of 10, even with the little information we have. I would rather that you take your time to do a ton of research on these matters as well as the flaws of the case as it was presented. Normally I love your videos and agree with your takes, but this one needs to be handled with special care and deeper understanding than most. It would be time well spent because understanding coercive control, domestic violence, perpetrator psychology and staged crime scenes would help you in countless cases going forward.

Mrs. Kip Dynamite

Publish the LC video regardless of outcome and put any updates in a vid or addendum after retrial that covers the (to me) nonsensical “PC did it” angle from the true crime watchers.

A sausage with just enough snap ... *snap* ... mmm

I'm surprised you're 50/50 on hung jury. Do you think the other option is NGRI or guilty? I think Defense offering and getting Manslaughter on the instructions pretty much reduced the possibility of a hung jury to being less likely than NGRI, which feels less likely as well. Edit: Unless you think they're hung on the exact charge? Edit to answer your question too 😅 : I think it'd be interesting to do two parts if it's hung since the CW will likely present two different strategies, same with defense. Probably don't need to delve as much into the facts of the case, but the differences and highlighting that would be interesting.

Carrie James

Chandler Halderson was definitely a favorite for me!

Declan44441

I presume it would be approached in a similar way to Karen Read then, where the discourse was discussed but not focussed on?

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I was saying I think the other 50% belongs to any outcome. NGRI becomes roughly equal to all shades of guilty after they haven't returned NGRI past 10 hours - that's my sort of punditry. I guess if they're not settled she was insane then without being able to read their minds I can't say what they're more likely to go for between Manslaughter and M1. Do they think she was seriously ill and wrong in the head at the time, but just not to the point of not being able to remove herself from the house or what have you? That would maybe be more in line with Manslaughter. But if they think she might be using psychosis as a cover...Well yeah, that'd be more M1!

A sausage with just enough snap ... *snap* ... mmm

Understood! I think it's worth noting that, though it is, arguably and reductively, about whether she was or wasn't in psychosis, she technically could have been in psychosis and still guilty of murder 2 or manslaughter. I think that's why it's so complex, as well. Whether the jury takes that instruction to the letter of the law or thinks about it more along the lines of "possibly psychosis = NGRI" and "most likely not psychosis = guilty", will likely impact how they reach a decision..

Alex

Hi Matt, I'm pretty new to the Patreon. Thanks for the update, looking forward to all the new stuff!

Fady Sedarous

16:40 absolutely not! Would love to see how you'd navigate a case where you'd put out a "part 1" with a "to be continued..." at the end of it and then putting together a sequel. It would be a MOCAS first, and it gets me excited thinking about how you'd pull that off!

grace

Appreciate the updates Matt! Looking forward to your thoughts on the LC case and trial.

Shakespearerabbit

Not to sound “unhinged” Matt but since you know how powerful confirmation bias can be once people have heard a story, especially one involving children being murdered. Do look into the original police investigation and watch the whole trial and all the expert testimony. This is the same county here in MA that prosecuted Karen Read. Husband ended up selling his house off market to the former DA for the same county that is prosecuting his ex wife. Her layer asked for a bifurcated trial twice but was denied both times. Also asked for mistrial due to lack of police investigation “Bowden defense” but was denied. As I actually watched the trial a lot of evidence presented ends up pointing away from Lindsay. But here in the US if you even express that opinion, the amount of vitriol you’ll get reaches the level of violence. Women across the country who have experienced manipulation and gaslighting relationships (not me) are sounding the alarm bell about Patrick, but the media and everyone who has heard this story is dug in, and there’s nothing you can show anyone that will change their mind. It’s becoming a real cultural phenomenon. I’ll probably delete this comment because here in the US if you even question the narrative you’ll be absolutely clobbered by comments. Not anything substantial, mind you, just things like “he was cleared you idiot” and “she confessed you stupid ****”. I’ve been told three times in the 24 hours (by men) that I shouldn’t be let anywhere near children. That I’m defending a child murderer. Of course that’s a logical fallacy. I just think the husband had motive (the Watts motive), the prosecution’s timeline doesn’t make sense, the alibi isn’t air tight by any means, and the police who originally found a woman half dead in the snow took her husbands word for what happened and he was let back into the house to untie the bands from his children’s throats John Ramsay style. Conspiracies do happen. And when they do women especially are… often not believed. I truly think that here in the US, all Chris Watts would have had to do was wait for Nico to be born, annihilate his whole family, then say his crazy wife killed everyone. Shit, he tried to say that after the fact, remember? If he had not been a complete idiot and had a plan and was in IT like PC, CW could be living with Nichol Kessinger with his new wife, new life, no alimony and no child support for 18 years. Just like Patrick Clancy. If I had taken a drink every time one of the expert witnesses during the trial said “Patrick told me” I’d be under the table. No expert witnesses should be basing their testimony and opinions on what the partner says about a woman they found half dead. Watching the trial I realized with horror the whole investigation was based on a story given by Patrick. The prosecution’s own expert witnesses (dr heilbrun) admitted on cross that Lindsay had no independent memory of killing her children when she woke up from her coma. She had to be told. She was heavily drugged, badly injured, and with no independent memory to contradict him, she believed Patrick. Just like everyone else, evidently. She is a nurse. She knows women do kill their children in post partum psychosis, and with no independent memory to contradict him, she accepted what her husband said as truth. It makes complete sense that she believed her husband. The question is, why the hell did everyone else? “She killed the fucking kids” were his words to police. Who refers to their dead children in that moment as “the fucking kids”… ? It’s not a smoking gun but it’s one of the very weird things that sticks out about him to me in particular. Who finds their wife bleeding out in the yard with a slit throat and crushed thyroid and asks her “did you plan this? Is that why you sent me out?” … This is someone immediately setting up a narrative and an alibi. It’s not normal. Neither is not being able to squeeze out a tear for his kids on the stand. Watch his testimony. Who refers to their dead children as “good people”? Watch the hyperventilating, and how he immediately recovers when he’s asked another question and has to think. Watch him speak at his children’s funeral. Lindsay’s phone searched “Can you treat a sociopath?” on Jan. 20, 2023.

Emily McKenzie

Incredible summary. I went into the case expecting an argument between if she was mentally well enough to do this out of a desire to kill her children, or if she was suffering from psychosis. I was open to being persuaded either way because I knew nothing else about the case. But having watched the trial, I was surprised to find myself questioning if she even did it at all. And maybe she did, but even if she did, the evidence isn't there to let me confidently state she did it (psychosis or not) beyond a reasonable doubt. The investigation was botched and it's incredible that the police decided that Patrick's word was all they needed.

Sam Fury

I think if there were to be a retrial it would be perfect material for an addendum if not a full YouTube video. I think you're right that the odds of reaching a verdict drop if there's another trial, and you might end up waiting around forever to cover the case if you need a verdict.

AR

I think the bar for insanity in Massachusetts is lower than we're used to, though. Under MA law all the jury has to find is that she was "incapable of conforming her conduct to the law" and a finding of psychosis (or even a reasonable doubt of psychosis) would fall into that category.

Andy

Hiya, Matt. Thanks for the update. If you're skimming for views, please go ahead with the Clancy video! Selfish, compassionate and pragmatic reasons. I've deliberately avoided going too deep on the trial whilst it's happening because you said you were going to cover it. It sounds like you have similar knowledge of it to me at present. If you do it as planned, the details will still be fresh and I'd hate your headache trying to do it later or after what could be two trials. The option is always there to do another and both would be most welcome - and no doubt successful for you. I agree with your gut prediction. The jury will be as split as the public, so I can't see a guilty verdict for murder or manslaughter coming. In the event of a hung jury, I'm not convinced the Commonwealth will go again depending on the weight of the split. My gut is telling me fewer of the jury will be screaming for a murder/manslaughter conviction. TLDR - please press on. Love and stuff from Edinburgh

Alan Holding

Glad I'm not the only one to say it before hitting play (or am I?)

AR

For everyone suspicious of Patrick, it's worth going back and revisiting the reports of people who were in the courtroom and heard the 911 call. Patrick's agony on that recording was reportedly very authentic and overwhelming. In addition to the impossibility that Patrick could somehow make Lindsay call him back while he was at the CVS, there's all sorts of reasons to think that many things are true in this case: the cops took the scene at face value and took Patrick's word for many things, and also did a shoddy investigation. Patrick's memory was faulty and he had an unreliable and inconsistent narrative due to shock and trauma, *and* he was a bit checked out as a father in the lead-up to the event, *and* he is also a heartbroken grieving additional victim in this case. It's worth remembering that he's supported Lindsay throughout this and believes in her innocence. True, not all of the evidence in this case makes sense; that's typical for any case. And rarely are all parties in a case "perfect" victims. But that doesn't mean it's a rational approach to choose to ignore the plain logic that Patrick couldn't have done this because he couldn't have been in two places at once. Many people distort that fact because they want him to be the villain and want this case to have an entertaining twist. But that thinking winds up distorting reality itself, and it does nothing to restore justice to Cora, Dawson, and Callen.

AR

As for the jury makeup I am dead certain there's at least one person in there going NGRI NO MATTER WHAT because that person would be me. It's not even because I think she 100% is actually innocent. It's just that this case is an overwhelming sea of evidence indicating that she could have very probably slid into psychosis. In the middle of all that, I have a reasonable doubt that she might have done it intentionally. Absolutely none of it meets the bar for the moral certainty needed to convict.

Shakespearerabbit

This woman’s comment. Look how much thought she has put into this. How nicely it’s written. How well researched, and how kind. She’s simply asking people to look at another side. If this same comment became popular on Facebook, I'm telling you, she would already have 100 comments, half calling her crazy, the other half dismissing her as a “wine mom,” with the odd death threat thrown in. Someone told me yesterday that someone should call CPS and take my kids away from me. (I don’t have kids.) This is how dug in the U.S. is about this case. All it took for some guy I didn't know to say I should be put in a padded room was point out that undisturbed blood drops don’t appear underneath table legs unless the furniture was moved on top of them. The crime scene shows signs of having been staged. And for saying that, I was also told I’m not safe to be around children. Look at the exhibit of the nightstand shown in court. Undisturbed blood drops (not spatter; drops) do not appear under table legs. If people want to argue that point, their argument isn’t with me. It’s with gravity. The dismissal of women about this has been horrible. The “wine mom" thing is pure sexism. I'm not a wine mom... This woman sounds educated to me. I know I am. And I've seen some genuinely amazing analysis of this case from legit wine moms. These are the same kind of “wine moms” that solve cold cases. Like the Golden State Killer. Women everywhere, now that they've seen Patrick Clancy, are telling us something is not right.

ReformedHoneyBadger

You've got to release this Lindsay Clancey video soon. I'm dodging information on it left and right like Neo in the Matrix. I'm tired, boss.

Ben S

It's a beautiful day to hold Lindsay Clancy accountable for her actions 🌞

Harkness

I vote for just dropping Clancy when you've got it done. I think your 50% rating for a mistrial is pretty on the money, and the details of the case both for her and against her are more than likely not going to change significantly. So little reason to put it off. Also, frankly the internet is fickle, Clancy case is rocking the societal boat *right now*, you mention "what if they have 6 more months of this?" but remember we're on a 24 hr news cycle in a culture that goes from one outrage to another. Believe it or not, there's not a guarantee if you wait for a final verdict that it will even be the flavor of the month at that point in time.

mackie poo poo

Not poking fun at anyone in particular but I received an email alerting me to a new Matt Orchard update. Although I read that email to myself, in my head, the narration was in Matt’s voice. Now seeing how that WAS a males voice & I’d only heard it one time, I still obeyed & went onto Patreon. Should I be concerned?

Isabel Glasow

That single phone call proves nothing. We don't know where that phone was, who spoke nor what was said. As for the call, it seems a little odd to me that he stayed on the call after the emergency services arrived. It's not unthinkable that it might have been a performance. We don't know for a fact, nor do we know when exactly the murders happened. We do know that Lindsay was seen in the yard by a neighbour at 5.50pm, and that baby Callan was harmed no earlier than 6.10pm because they can't get a heartbeat back after more than 30mins. At that time Lindsay is lying paralysed outside for some time, and Patrick has just returned home and is moving around the house. The prosecution's timeline makes no sense, because she claimed that Lindsay did everything after that call. In 15mins? She couldn't lay out a timeline that is logical. Lastly, what do you make of him not being in court?

alyssa paull

I think you strike while the iron’s hot and do the coverage asap— hate to say it but the views this video’s going to generate are massive, and the faster you do it the better. Then, you can make a second video covering the retrial. I think the opportunity to comment on the practice of retrying a case in general (and especially this one) is meaty enough for its own video.

Shakespearerabbit

Not to start an argument, just going to state that plenty of people pop out on an errand to establish an alibi. Tim Hennis, for example. Tim’s timeline to get to the bank and back to base was far tighter than Patrick’s errands, especially since an ATM withdrawal time is so specific and a time of death is difficult to pin down to the minute. PC was seen 2 places he knew there would be a video camera (CVS being the most obvious). His own cameras at home, though, were not working, as he says his WiFi was out. He’s an IT professional. Please don’t suggest that people who think this case was rotten from the start don’t want justice for the children. That’s a straw man argument and I see it everywhere. Of course we want justice. But you can’t have justice without truth. I want to know if a tech bro Chris Watts is getting away with murder just because he was smarter than a notoriously sexist and dumb, not to mention corrupt, police department.

Jenifer Joseph

I just think if there was really enough evidence against Patrick her lawyer would have used that defense instead, that he did it. If she's found guilty she'll still experience hell forever.

Shakespearerabbit

Framing your wife with well documented PPD for a murder suicide really is the perfect crime. To be honest I have a hard time believing a man thought of it, but that’s just speculation. Remember it’s very likely Nichol Kessinger was the one who gave Watts the OxyContin he used to try to induce a miscarriage in Shanann. But the police stopped short of investigating her involvement. (Rachel Danis, Patrick’s new wife, is a fertility doctor.) Patrick said Lindsay crushed up pills and drank them but the glass of lemonade was never tested, and no residue from crushing pills was found. What, she cleaned up after drugging herself? I could go on and on. The whole thing is nonsense. His execution was in my mind very messy. Women stranglers are rare because it’s physically very difficult. And the amount of people who attempt more than one suicide method is miniscule, let alone drugging yourself, cutting your own wrists and throat with the scariest knife you can find, then throwing yourself out a window. But the police signed off on it all and charged LC within 24 hours while still in a coma… which tells you how thorough the initial investigation into Patrick was.

Shakespearerabbit

She is someone who in the eyes of the public has already confessed to child murder. Imagine if she (and her lawyers) turned around and said “actually my husband did it”. Nobody would believe her. Instead they are laying breadcrumbs in court, exactly like the Karen Read case. Trial strategy is complicated. Her lawyer explains a part of it. For the explanation about the bifurcation go to min 3. https://youtu.be/FmGg1HiDNLo?is=p87U7PhTlbxRj_5P

Stars and Sprinkles

The thing I keep going back to is Patrick claiming to have talked to Lindsay while she was outside with a crushed thyroid amongst other catastrophic injuries with an internal body temperature of about 80 degrees. This is absolute nonsense to me personally and really raises my suspicions. There is no evidence of her talking on the call and everyone else on scene testified that she was not able to talk. The timeline of when baby Callan was harmed to her injuring herself and having such a low body temperature is an absolute logistical nightmare that seems to have no good explanation. I think there is good reason to suspect Patrick but even if he didn't do it, I think he is still responsible for what happened to those children. He knowingly left Lindsay alone with them as she was struggling with horrible intrusive thoughts of harm. No matter what happens, there isn't going to be a satisfying ending in this case because at the end of the day, three children paid the ultimate price. It really highlights the burdens of a struggling postpartum mother and absent fatherhood. There are so many more unexplained details but this is what I personally keep circling back to.

Kaylee Cox

I would wildly prefer the release of a video even if the jury is hung. An update video could be made after a final verdict is rendered in the future if the content of the trial is substantially different enough from the first, like you said.

Isabel Glasow

I agree - especially a nurse! Lindsay Clancy does not fit the profile at all, but he does. There are only five reasons why a mother would do this. There was no child abuse or revenge plot, the children were very much wanted. Altruism is out due to the violent method and the fact that she was found somewhere else instead of with them. Psychosis would be the only possibility here, but the timeline and evidence simply don't line up or make sense. She had absolutely nothing to gain, no motive at all. This case is being discussed worldwide, in the UK, Ireland and Germany of all places. People cannot believe that this case was brought on such shoddy evidence, especially the vile way they did it. I hope that Matt looks up the 10 signs of a concealed femicide before doing his episode.

2bit

I totally agree about making the video regardless of a hung jury or not. I don’t think much would change in the courtroom for trial 2. It’s really just a matter of, who are the 12 people in that room? IMO

Queen of Hearts

Tim Hennis didn’t make the ATM run as an alibi, he did it to cover rent. Shannan’s family themselves have stated that they don’t want people speculating about Nicole K, and it’s pretty selfish to keep digging up the trauma of her family even after they said not to. There’s no evidence at all that Patrick’s new wife has anything to do with it, nor is there evidence that Patrick is involved. People are saying that Patrick conspiracy theorists don’t care about justice because it’s obviously true.

Queen of Hearts

Definitely team “do the video anyway”. So much bad information is spreading about this case from selfish and unscrupulous True Crime channels, we need channels like yours that actually give a fuck about facts rather than mental health misinformation or conspiracy theories

Isabel Glasow

People are asking questions about problems with the case, and not everyone who is doing that is suggesting that his new wife is involved nor supporting all of the more outlandish claims. I don't want to repeat everything I have said in another comment about how the timeline doesn't work and the evidence doesn't fit. Yes, everyone wants justice for the children, but I don't think that they have proven beyond a reasonable doubt that it was her and not him. Surely justice is making sure that you convict the right person? Staged suicides are a thing, increasingly so in recent years. There is a checklist to help authorities remain alert to the possibility of foul play. Check out this case of Linsey and Patrick Barnett. Countless cases are examples of someone establishing an alibi when in fact they did something just before or after, Atif Rafay and Sebastian Burns as a random example. The prosecution has been unable to lay out a motive, evidence and timeline in a way that makes logical sense. You haven't actually refuted the real points that were made, but just cherry picked something and distracted from the technical problems with the case.

Queen of Hearts

You do realize I wasn’t even talking to you, right? I was talking to Maria, hence the thing about Hennis. If you wanna throw hands I’m absolutely ready for it. Lindsey Barnett had very obvious signs of being beaten and Ted had wounds on his hands from her fighting back, no pop psych internet checklist needed. Burns and Rafay are still considered by many to have likely been false confessions. The prosecution has no duty to prove motive. Lindsay’s own testimony has been that she committed the killings. Not that Patrick told her that she did it, she herself has described waking up that morning and hearing voices in her head telling her to kill the children. Tell me what “real points” you made that supersede the word of the woman herself?

Lisa Adler-Golden

"Oh no, you might have to do a second video later!" cry your audience members who are paying you to make videos. "Not that!" My pet peeve of the Lindsay Clancy case is the inability of the media (and likely most of the people consuming the case) to recognize the false dichotomy being offered: people can be deep in the throes of psychosis and still be capable of premeditation.

Queen of Hearts

So your “real points” are: >The phone call could’ve been from anywhere That’s not how phones work. If he had the phone with him and was calling himself it would’ve pinged off the tower where he was. >He might’ve been lying. Do you have any proof he was lying? > Baby Callan couldn’t have been harmed early than 6:10 because they can’t get a heartbeat after 30 minutes Gonna need a fuckin citation on that because there are absolutely cases of people being brought back successfully after 46 minutes (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-40639385), hell the current record is over 8 hours (https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/71677-longest-time-survived-without-a-pulse). Neither of these cases are babies, because understandably we have very little data on how long a baby can survive without a heartbeat, but given the medical precedent and the fact that a baby’s life is at stake it makes perfect sense for EMTs to be working extra hard. Also given that Lindsay was outside by 5:50 and Patrick was at CVS by 5:32, if this is femicide then who the fuck threw her out the window? > She can’t do everything after the call Why the fuck not? > He isn’t in court He has a right to not want to look at autopsy photos of his children

Evelynn Rose

Would love a 2 parter on Lindsay in the case of hung jury. Frankly, I’ve been holding off on looking into it until you drop your video, and I don’t want to wait potentially years for it.

Isabel Glasow

Actually, I thought that you were talking to both of us. As CVS and ThreeV were local businesses, it would be the same cell tower, and I don't believe that they ever analysed Patrick's phone properly other than to confirm his location (which doesn't tell us what he did before he left, and when he arrived back). If they did, I'm sure that it would have been mentioned and explained in court and put a lot of minds to rest. There appears to be a second pink phone with no identification number. The apple watch wasn't even taken into evidence. The prosecution hasn't cleared this up in a way that people can clearly understand it. Getting the heartbeat back for a baby after a certain time is a very different challenge from a fully grown adult (no matter how hard they work at it) , and a lot of professionals with medical knowledge are talking about it who know more about it than we do. Patrick made a lot of contradictory statements, and by definition both cannot be true at the same time. Also, you don't know for a fact that he is telling the truth, how could you? If Lindsay was seen outside in the yard by 5.50pm, she could have been there longer, which would make the timeline even shorter. Patrick sent an email from his Surface Pro laptop at home at 5.24pm, that has been established - even though he said that he left by 5.15pm. Both of those things cannot be true at the same time and it was never fully cleared up and resolved at trial, like many other things. Most parents are in court for the entire trial regardless, especially since the autopsies were dealt with quite some time ago and he wasn't there at all last week. Getting aggressive doesn't make you more right or logical. As for the cases I have given as random examples, there are countless others. Lastly, the most predictive factor for femicide is not physical violence, it's coercive control - and there are some red flags here, which is why I wish that they had done a thorough investigation. What was supposedly said on this call has also changed and doesn't line up with evidence. The reason so many people are talking about it is because none of these points have been explained in a way that makes sense.

Queen of Hearts

> He was logged into her social media Citation needed > might’ve had a cloned phone He also might’ve had Bryon Noem’s inflatable breasts, until you can prove he had it you can’t make accusations off things that “might” exist > meds that were not in the house but in her system were kept in his car for weeks And the meds weren’t there in lethal amounts. Sounds more like the meds just hadn’t cleared her system. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/aug/05/lindsay-clancy-trial-toxicologist-testimony > a nurse would not look up the carotid artery and misspell it As the daughter of a nurse, this is fucking hilarious. Medical professionals are constantly looking up things, it’s part of the job to continue educating yourself since it’s impossible to remember everything. Hell, in isolation that search really isn’t that fuckin suspicious. Being a medical professional doesn’t make you immune to misspellings either, that’s just stupid. > The Google searches were done by Patrick (using her Facebook account!) 🤦🏾‍♀️ Read that again, slowly. He made searches on GOOGLE, using her FACEBOOK. Complete fuckin genius here I tell ya. https://support.google.com/mail/thread/158709929/can-i-use-facebook-to-sign-into-gmail?hl=en > Baby Callan was able to be revived There’s no hard limit on how long someone can be either a pulse and still be revived. > he sent an email from his Surface Pro at 5:24 Ever heard of distracted driving? > It also means Patrick lied Or he’s a human being with fallible memory > A man is far more likely to be believed than a woman We’re believing the woman, the woman said she killed her kids > You just cannot make the timeline fit You can’t, because you’re stupid, but other people can. > Why are there no traces of footsteps in the blood or water? Probably all the EMTs running in and out of the scene > You think she used gloves or wiped her fingers off the knife Didn’t you just say she was sopping wet? >Why didn’t he see the children Because his wife being on the ground with a hole in her neck was probably a big distraction > There was no proper investigation Okay detective random fucker, prove it > He wouldn’t be the first person to pop out to try and make an alibi He would be the first one to somehow magically brainwash the woman he himself tried to murder into never ever at any point to anyone saying that she didn’t do it > There’s a lot of reasonable doubt The actual defense has created reasonable doubt. The ramblings of bored white women on the internet haven’t. > She couldn’t have told him what he claimed she told him with a crushed thyroid You can in fact talk with a crushed thyroid in most cases. “The key to efficient care of such trauma is to have a high index of suspicion and comprehension of the mechanism of the injury. Hoarseness of voice is one of the most commonly encountered symptoms in blunt laryngeal injuries. Juutilainen et al. reported that hoarseness of voice was a presenting symptom in 28 of 33 cases of external laryngeal trauma he reviewed.” https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6298297/#ref3 > I haven’t heard anything that would resolve these flaws in the prosecution’s reasoning I haven’t seen any flaws at all > They contradicted things the witnesses said as well as themselves. Citation needed >Dismissing everyone who has obvious questions as stupid feminists I highly doubt the prosecutors, who are themselves women, are going around calling people stupid feminists. > he walks off with $1.7 million from GoFundMe No he doesn’t, the GoFundMe money is for her parents >he puts them together in a group grave Which really isn’t that uncommon > manages to get the death date for Baby Callan wrong People fuck up. Not proof of murder > talks about how exhausting they were All children are exhausting. Being tired doesn’t make him a fucking murderer > Says he ‘envies their misery’ And this proves what exactly? > Goes on holiday to Costa Rica Is this seriously the best you have? > Why would someone making (yadayadayada I ain’t typin this shit anymore) White male raised under patriarchy. Shitty husband? ✅. Shitty father? ✅ Murderer ❌ > Lindsay clearly has no memory Citation needed > There have been a lot of conversations about coercive control Has there been any evidence of coercive control in this case? > weaponization of mental health issues by abusive men Again, need evidence here > Linsey and Patrick Barnett You mean the case where there was blatantly obvious evidence of murder from the wounds on her body and the scratches on him from her defending herself? What, you gonna pull out Todd Kendhammer next? > Blah Blah checklist podcast car door hook hand Hey genius, if this was staged and he had absolute control of the scene then how the fuck did she get outside after he already left? How does he have not a single fucking scratch on him after killing 4 people? Did your podcast explain that?

Queen of Hearts

> As CVS and ThreeV were local businesses, it would be the same cell tower Cell towers cover only one to three miles. Unless they were right next to both locations it’d be a different tower > I don’t believe they ever analyzed Patrick’s phone So how can you claim that he was accessing all her accounts? You’re making a lot of claims about data you don’t even know exists > Getting the heartbeat back for a baby after a certain time is a very different challenge Prove it > a lot of professionals with medical knowledge are talking about it Who? Where? What are their qualifications? There are a lot of so called professionals saying vaccines cause autism too. The actual established facts say that people can be brought back after 30 minutes, and I, like a reasonable person, will trust the documented cases more than third hand accounts of supposed experts > Patrick made a lot of contradictory statements Prove it >you don’t know for a fact he is telling the truth And this means jack shit, because you can’t prove for a fact that he’s lying, and as an American he has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty. > which would make the timeline even shorter So what? >Patrick sent an email from his Surface Pro So supposedly police never checked his phone but did check his laptop for some fuckin reason? Also as discussed in the Karen Reed addendum, timestamps can fuck up > Most parents are in court for the entire trial And not being in court isn’t proof of guilt >Getting aggressive doesn’t make you more right I never said it did. Relying on actual facts is what makes me right >the cases I have given as random examples Are completely fuckin wrong and unrelated to the case > the most predictive factor of femicide is not physical violence, it’s coercive control. And you have no evidence of either coercive control or femicide

Queen of Hearts

As for Maria, complaining about people getting mad at you on the internet when three children are dead is a bad look. Lindsay Clancy stans are not the representatives of all women.

Queen of Hearts

Maria, you might wanna look at the Karen Reed addendum before you start running that playbook. Again, neither Lindsey nor Karen are the avatars of all women, and it’s kinda fuckin frustrating to have white women once again centered and put on a pedestal of doing no work where anyone standing against them is attacking all women. Highly doubt any of yall would have much to say if Lindsey had dark skin and nappy hair. There is no conspiracy. There wasn’t with Karen, and there isn’t with Lindsey. No, Lindsey wasn’t “heavily drugged”, that’s not what the toxicology says.

Isabel Glasow

Your arguments are getting nonsensical now - maybe you should prove what you are saying. 'So what' does not provide a timeline that takes into account all of the evidence, and Patrick made a lot of contradictory statements - maybe you should put some effort in, and research it for yourself. Good luck!

Queen of Hearts

So cited sources are “nonsensical”? What was it you said about cherrypicking? One sentence out of multiple lengthy responses. You have yet to prove that the prosecution’s timeline is wrong and still haven’t shown me anything contradictory.

Queen of Hearts

Genuinely, what evidence do you have beyond repeating the same bullshit ad nauseam? You got anything at all that explains how he 3 children and nearly killed an adult without getting a scratch on a speck of blood on him? How he accused a Google account using Facebook despite that being literally impossible? How he supposedly planted incriminating searches on her phone without her realizing it? How he managed to brainwash her into believing she did it while she was in the hospital surrounded by witnesses and medical devices with cameras on them?

Isabel Glasow

It's not my job to convince you - and one Google Search that appears to say what you want it to doesn't really resolve a complicated question. The burden of proof is on the prosecution and they have failed to explain and outline a timeline that makes sense and explains all of the evidence. You should do more research on this case, there are a lot of problems with it, but you are clearly determined not to see it, and quite uninformed on a several things. That's fine by me. I don't have all day, but clearly you do.

Queen of Hearts

More yapping, still no evidence. If you’re too scared to prove your point I’m not gonna chase down conspiracy theories when the actual facts say something different. What’s the complicated question I haven’t resolved? What hasn’t the prosecutor explained? What supposed fucking research is out there that magically proves this complete and utter psy-op true?

Stars and Sprinkles

I would really encourage you to take some deep breaths. I'm sure no one disagrees that there is a lot of misinformation but going by medical records and professionals alone, the timeline does indeed not make sense. This to me, would be enough to create reasonable doubt. Baby Callan was revived at 640, that we know. Lindsey had a reported internal body temperature of 82 degrees upon arrival at the hospital. While there isn't a hard limit of when someone can be revived, it is safe to assume that for someone Callan's age, it would not be long. From what I understand, it is incredibly rare for them to be revived after an hour, meaning that he most likely wasn't harmed before 540. From when Lindsey called Patrick back to when he finds her outside, there is a hard 30 minute time frame. If we assume that it is Lindsey, she must have harmed Callan right before that call or did immediately after. Then, there's 30 minutes to go from being able to speak in a way that Patrick suspected that nothing was wrong to being on the ground in the snow, soaking wet with life threatening hypothermia(even less time if Callan is harmed after the call). There is very little blood in the basement which leads us to believe that she was cut in their bedroom. She also must have stood around to create the round, pooling blood on the floor, creating even less time from after the call. Even if she had immediately exited the window right after ending the phone call, it is unlikely that her body temperature would reach that low in that short amount of time even with the five fractures to her spine, her head injury, slashed wrists and crushed thyroid. There is something off and I don't blame people for pointing out inconsistencies. Take for instance, the 5:24 email. Patrick stated he didn't remember whether it was sent from his phone or his laptop. That isn't creating reasonable doubt, that IS reasonable doubt. Reddington asked him if he knows from where he sent the email at that time. Wouldn't Patrick have remembered if he had been out of the house during that time and said a firm no? Why did he say he didn't know? It's easy to write off individual instances and I would agree with you that he is a shitty father, husband and person as far as I'm concerned. People do grieve differently but taking all his actions, accounts and demeanor as a WHOLE is very off putting.

Queen of Hearts

> I would encourage you to take some deep breaths And I would encourage you to not spread misinformation > going by the medical records and professionals alone Who? Where? When? >Lindsey had a reported internal body temperature of 82 degrees Which is what happens when you bleed > its safe to assume Assumptions make an assumption out of you and me > he most likely wasn’t harmed before 5:40 Citation >she must’ve harmed Callan right before that call or did immediately after I don’t see how that’s a problem with the timeline > I’m too fuckin tired to keep doing the line by line thing Like I don’t see how it taking 30 minutes for all that to happen is some impossible feat? Also how the fuck is an email sent from his phone reasonable doubt? His demeanor being off putting isn’t reason to accuse someone of fucking murder

Stars and Sprinkles

I am sure going line by line is quite exhausting, maybe you should take a break and go touch some grass? (If your descent into inflammatory language in other comments is anything to go by). I'm not sure what you mean by who what where why? It was clearly testified to in the trial footage and evidence logs. Bleeding does lower body temperature , that is correct, it's the TIME it took for her to descend that low that's the issue. I see you also have seemed to misunderstood my point about the email. Patrick should have said NO to sending the email from the surface pro because if he had sent it from that device, that would have put him in the house at the supposed time of the attack in the exact area of the attack. Instead he says he doesn't know. If he knew he wasn't in the house at the time of the attack, then it would stand to reason he sent it from his phone which should have been his answer. I'm also not using his demeanor to accuse him of murder but rather the evidence and actions IN ADDITION to his behavior is cause for concern and further investigation.

Isaac Malone

Oh boy, I can already tell a LC video is going to be very polarizing. It’s very much giving Karen Read vibes. Looking forward to your breakdown on it. And yes, I agree that you should go ahead and make your video despite a hung jury verdict.

Queen of Hearts

I live on a farm, I touch grass everyday. I’m asking who, what, where, and why so I know who specifically you’re referring to and what parts to cross reference. Where in the trial footage does it say that? What part of the log? What about the time is so perplexing? If there were actual evidence you wouldn’t need to be so evasive about it.

John Gainz

Matt, if the jury is hung in the Clancy case I would really appreciate if you waited until the retrial verdict, especially if you plan on just making one video and being done with the whole thing. I follow you because you have really insightful things to say about trials and whenever you’ve had a retrial in your videos you cover them quite well. I care about learning more, not seeing the video more quickly. Also if you’re ever starved for ideas you should cover the whole Afroman fiasco

K

Id watch you cover any case btw

K

And can't wait for your coverage on Lindsey clancey

Stars and Sprinkles

May touching grass bring you some much needed peace. Are you actually looking for genuine conversation or wanting to just be worked up? I'm always open to talking to others but you must also come prepared with solid rebuttals and not resorting to calling others stupid or demanding "citations". I'm curious as to why you think I need to specifically find the who what where because if you had watched the trial footage, you would know that the body temperature was testified about specifically by Kelly McDonough on her direct. I suspect you haven't actually researched much of anything in this case as these facts are easily found and readily available. Court TV on Youtube is free. It isn't misinformation. On his direct, Patrick testifies to Lindsay's phone calling him at 5:34. The 911 call is at 6:11 after Patrick was in the house for a couple minutes and found Lindsay outside. There is a lack of evidence of exactly how Lindsay harmed her child, bled all over the floor, became soaking wet with no visible water at the foot of the window (Have you looked at the crime scene photos? She is sopping wet and the blood in the bedroom has no evidence of being diluted or smeared with water), then lay outside long enough to melt the snow beneath her and have her core body temperature drop by 14 degrees while ALSO talking to Patrick and then becoming almost completely non responsive to all other EMTs on scene in that time. If you have an decent explanation of how she could do all that in that 30 minute window time frame as well as talk to Patrick while suffering from severe hypothermia, I will gladly hear you out. Keep in mind, when you're severely cold like that, you will lose your ability to think and talk coherently

Isabel Glasow

You are clearly not listening, uninformed, disrespectful and have far too much time on your hands. I don't have to prove anything to you, especially with that attitude. Figure it out for yourself.

Jess of the Planet

I’d definitely love an LC vid if we have a hung jury—it’s going to be such a drag & a long wait to get to verdict, & there I so much to cover. You could do one video focused on the event or evidence, & another on the trials, for example.

Jess of the Planet

Hit send by accident, sorry! I personally have a strong feeling about the “right” verdict, but am also curious to hear your views & discussion with others here because my hope/expectation is it will be much easier to have an intellectual discussion about the facts & their legal implications. Comments on every other platform just make me roll my eyes with how uninformed & un-constructive they are—poor rhetoric full of logical fallacies instead of thoughtful arguments based on again fact & actual law. So toss my hat in that pile, & I’m sure no matter what you decide will be great! Thanks!

Samantha W

Considering the jury said today they can’t reach a unanimous decision and the judge told them to keep trying, a mistrial is looking more and more likely. Jesus.

MissChanandlerBong

Do the Clancy video ASAP because I really need to hear a rational person's take that's not motivated by their stance on the men vs women culture war.

PastelPixie

Definitely drop the video! I don’t have a strong, factual background on this case because everyone has such a strong opinion. We need you!

Matthew Thayer

Seems I’ve already been outvoted, but I would prefer the case to be put in hold😅. But it’s for the selfish reason that I’m already sick of the case, and would selfishly rather you turned you talents towards something I’d be more interested in, lol. Don’t get me wrong, It was a very interesting case to me at first, and I followed it intently, until I realized that most of it is misdirectional: What the family members and doctors have to say, analysis of Lindsay’s parenting ir crying or whatever, quibbling about the suicide stuff, all of it is basically irrelevant. What actually matters are two things: What is Lindsay’s actual story of what happened, and how likely is her version of events compared to pretty much any other scenario that fits with the extensive records and physical evidence(because in pretty much all of those scenarios, she is guilty). Once I looked at it that way, it became clear to me that she was guilty BARD.

G◇nSqu¤chn

A Lindsey Clancy "final outcome" vid sounds like the most highly anticipated addendum I could think of! And I think the nuanced conclusion of a hung jury could make for an incredibly interesting first video! Hopefully you can parse where my vote lies

Michael

Hi Matt. Thanks for the great videos. I really enjoy your content. With all the discussion of the Clancy trial potentially being a hung jury, it seems relevant that I was a juror on a murder trial that ended in a hung jury 2 years ago. This case was very different. About as far removed from the Clancy case in terms of media attention as possible (haven't been able to find even a single article about it, so unfortunately would not make a very interesting video except to me). However, there seem like there might be some psychological similarities between the divides in the respective camps. Like the Clancy case there is not that much dispute over the main timeline. Everyone agreed in this case when where and how the victim was shot and that it was by one of 5 people (all identified) who drove by in a car and that all were guilty at least as accomplices. Then it was just whether the defendant was the one who actually pulled the trigger. The similarity to me is that there seemed to be a divide between people focused on moral guilt vs legal guilt (probably giving away my feelings, obviously not quite this simple). Anyway, although probably not the most interesting case in the world, it was still a very interesting experience for me and I think pretty enlightening about a lot of aspects of jury trials. I don't know if you'd be interested in hearing more. I'm pretty keen to think more about the experience so will probably be writing up something about it, but would also like to talk to you about it if you thought it was useful.

Go Pro

Regarding Clancy…Your audience is full of middle aged women. I hope you’re not a coward or people pleasing weathercock. She strangled three kids with stretchable exercise cord. Drugs don’t do that. We don’t blame ‘Thrive’ for Chris Watts. Praying you have a spine…

Bianca Nascimento Lara Campos

I agree with everyone that said that you should release LC video even with a hung jury. I didn't watch the trial. All that are organically coming to me is favorable to her... I'm thinking that the fact that she acquired a disability in the incident makes some people lean more towards the no punishment side... We will see!

Steve

Remarkable some jurors wore pink in court this week. I suspect they violated standard instruction to ignore coverage—which, I suspect, is common but not typically blatant. Just look at timing: jurors heard final closing on Friday, went home for weekend during media firestorm, and began deliberations on Monday. Too bad they didn’t start deliberating immediately or get sequestered.

Lisa Adler-Golden

I suppose I should rephrase that slightly: those are the two options I'm generally seeing in the media. The judge did offer another option, and occasionally I see a media piece talking about what psychosis is, but those two positions are the vast majority of what's being thrown around.

Rusty Shackleford

Maria, I just wanted to "clobber" you with the comment that you're not very bright.

Rusty Shackleford

I think everyone is saying this, but I would rather have a LC video presently covering the trial, verdict, and broader cultural moment going on. Then, in the event of a hung jury or mistrial, a second video covering that.

Jonathan Gill

I think it makes sense to make the video even with a hung jury, especially while it's still big in the public imagination. I've actually been avoiding news coverage of the case, if you can imagine that, to keep it spoiler free. Incidentally I'm one of the viewers that might rate the Chandler video as "mid", not because there's anything wrong with it: I really like it opening with the father's IT call and how it covers both sides' lawyers. It's just one of the rare cases I knew before watching the video, and because I think the prosecutor's opening statement was already about as perfect a telling of events as there can be.

Sam Thompson

If we get a hung jury outcome, I think that is a fitting end to an installment, and getting a part two when that happens would be cool. It’d be a really good chance to dive into a bit more of the “society” part, in my opinion.

Tamara Dawn Bruno

Yet another vote for an LC video even if the outcome is a hung jury. Especially given the public attention and narratives I expect there would be plenty to discuss in a follow-up, with differences in how the case is tried etc. (assuming a retrial). I also think we appreciate the sensitivity with which you approach difficult aspects of these cases, which provides a way to obtain the information while protecting our mental balance!

Soffity

As a long time fan and follower I can see why you're working on the Clancy case. However hasn't it been done to death? I reqlise you have already spend weeks on this and of course I'll watch it. You invariably come out with something I didn't know or hadn't seen before so of course I'll watch it. I'm supporting you on patreon for heavens sake so I'll watch anything you post. If I watch some of your videos yet again I'll be in hospital with crossed eyes and fitting from watch too much M.O. Fellow living in Australia to another, please do some Aussie cases or something like your wonderful cult video or the tale of two narcissists, one, they lie detector machine . Etc. Do something that hasn't already had hundreds doing it previously. Sorry if I sound harsh, I don't mean to. You're my absolute favourite. I just want to see a case that's hasn't been so covered they know what necklace she is wearing.

Drew Boatman

Given the hung jury outcome and the last-minute “jury foreman note” passing to the judge on whether one of the jurors was basically ignoring the definition of “reasonable doubt”, I would kindly request Matt make some kind of video to sort out these legal proceedings.😀

feedergoldfish

You called it. Hung jury. I'd appreciate a video on this messy case. Good luck! PS: I think you should go ahead and make the video and then follow up with a part 2 later.

Sam

Hello from mistrial land. What a shitshow. I'm very interested in hearing your take on all this in its current state, so I'd vote for a video on it as soon as you can and then a public addendum for the second mistri- uh, trial.

Zaynab Chamalian

I would like some more investigation into Patrick to be honest. I’m not convinced he’s guilty but I do think there were some strange goings on in his story and the initial investigation. I think as long as this fishiness isn’t addressed there will remain a large group of people who suspect him of involvement.

Soffity

I love your videos and have been following you for years. However I really like it when you do less "popular' cases that other channels haven't done to death. The pipe thru the windscreen for example. The tale of two narcissists is wonderful. Now I can afford to join your patron since my dad died and left me some money I hope to see some Aussie cases and more interviews. Go well Matt. 🦘🌈 northern rural NSW.

Learned Paw

No, don't wait. A second trial won't matter to, as you said, the fundamentals of the case.

AlwaysRock

Please drop it. I need the in depth explainer instead of hearing random talking points from either side.

Jessica Koch

Omg my friend also went on a long diatribe about how the husband did it and made her confess….i hadn’t paid attention to this case tbh then i was looking into it and was wondering where the heck this narrative came from…

scrubsplunking

Matt make the video so you get big payday. Everyone else is and you have by far the most professional and respectful true crime vids ever. And then make a sequel to get the opinion and development done and get paid again

Queen of Hearts

To Jessica, it’s coming from bots and people who profit off the culture wars

Queen of Hearts

Yeah as an American I would love to see him cover more non US cases in the future.

BlüddShövel

Never underestimate the stupidity of Americans

Bader

Can’t wait for the new video 😫

Anne Marie Coutts

I think the only video you should consider shelving is the Shaver case. Putting anything out, especially for a channel like your own with so many fans desperately seeking clarity on such a convoluted case where you are the waterfall in a desert, will be shockingly u desired by fans. Not by any fault of the Shaver content of course but by the pure necessity driven by the Clancy machine

Alan Holding

*looks at calendar and clock* Where's my lunch ? Your invite said the 10th and yet I am still hungry.

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

I put extra emphasis on ABOUT!!…it’ll be up within 24 hours or 48 max just gotta do about 2 mins more animating then go through it all again with polishing touches

James Jones

For real, love the transparency. The videos are always worth the wait

Crash

Yes, re: Lindsay Clancy. Eager to hear your presentation. With the caveat, that we now know a mistrial has been declared and there is likely to be a new trial, but even THAT is not guaranteed. Always appreciate your uploads and I dom't think it is too early to present on her case once you've researched the trial. I don't think much new info would come out in a new trial. The biggest difference we are likely to appreciate will be that the DA will have different prosecutors. The current team has received a great deal of criticism, importantly, from the jurors who have spoken out and how poorly they perceived the team.

Michelle Brochon

Susan Monica is one of my top 5 most rewatched mocas vids, it's wild to hear that she was "just" a placeholder!

Luke Monaghan

Honestly, I think having you cover both the hung jury trial and the potential future trial would be interesting. Wether you do that as a 2 part series or just as one video is up to you. As for the debate surrounding the case, it's so frustrating. I am not reading comments about the case anymore because it's so agrivating. I am looking forward to when the Internet moves on to the next culture splitting topic. But chances are people will make that another men v women debate...

Netrunner54

You were right on the money with the hung jury

Matt Orchard - Crime and Society

Someone else said that and I was going to say I don't really deserve the credit because I did hedge a lot. Listening back though, my descriptions of the dynamics in the jury room were prescient enough based on reporting so I will take half credit!

Lexi Palmer

hey just chiming in wicked late and adding a vote to doing a video asap on clancy. that was my take when you posted this and now that it’s a hung jury i can’t imagine waiting until the retrial to hear your thoughts. you once said somewhere, either in a comment or video i’m not sure, that you thought the West Memphis Three were guilty as hell (i’m likely paraphrasing) but any chance you’d consider making an addendum for that case?? i genuinely thought they were innocent after listening to your video multiple times. i would be so interested in your perspective. you rock. cheers!!

AlwaysRock

So… LC video coming out soon?

Freya

Matt would you consider covering the Dr. Tomasz Kosowski case? Big fan btw 😁

Ruth Randall

I'd be very surprised if they do a new trial, I think it will quietly go away. No way are they going to get 12 people to agree on this one. I would love to hear Matt's view on this, most are so in support of her...

Steve

Just watched Laurie Shaver video. I went in blind and found it interesting. It’s not exactly a Greek tragedy, but you’re right she could have made defense better by admitting things—frame as protecting daughter—but she just couldn’t. She projects terribly. And did body near fire pit remind anyone else of Pompeii? Seriously, imagine that daily sight in your backyard.

Logan

Go ahead and make it bro

Queen of Hearts

Especially now that they’ve doxxed and harassed number 12